Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and...
by godelski on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:32PM
(#34712519)
> Every single bank you have an account with already has to keep track of know-your-customer information. It's not like the fact that there's a centralized digital currency will give the government more control over you than not.
This isn't quite true. Most concern is about how mundane transactions are tracked. Things like how your grandma giving you $5 could now be tracked. Obviously this won't be an issue if physical cash still exists, but it would if that was eliminated. The other aspect of a digital currency is that it allows for much finer detailed tracking. High precision. This is still useful in our ever increasingly surveilled world.
I don't know how the UK works, but in the US banks don't need to report when the inflow/outflow is <$10k. Meaning that for most people Venmo could choose not to report to the IRS for them (no idea if they do or not, but if they do, another business model could not) because their annual transactions don't exceed $10k. So even digitally, your small standard transactions aren't (necessarily) being tracked. This could even include things like tips for servers. Of course, the Fed has recently been pushing for this threshold to come down to $600[0] with an explanation that this targets the rich who have multiple bank accounts that are amassing millions of untaxed income.
I am actually for digital currencies, but I personally think we need to make them like digital cash. That is, they use ZKP transactions with minimal metadata to produce as anonymous transactions as possible. Surveillance capitalism and surveillance states have been a mistake. We had centuries of tracking commerce with physical cash and have learned a lot about how to catch fraud and theft. While anonymous payments can enable some more theft I don't personally believe that any government needs to specifically track what an individual person is spending their money on.As a data nerd, I'd be perfectly fine if we had some homomorphic encryption that allowed for some anonymized analysis on how aggregates of people are spending their money but I still don't think we should be tracking citizens.
This isn't quite true. Most concern is about how mundane transactions are tracked. Things like how your grandma giving you $5 could now be tracked. Obviously this won't be an issue if physical cash still exists, but it would if that was eliminated. The other aspect of a digital currency is that it allows for much finer detailed tracking. High precision. This is still useful in our ever increasingly surveilled world.
I don't know how the UK works, but in the US banks don't need to report when the inflow/outflow is <$10k. Meaning that for most people Venmo could choose not to report to the IRS for them (no idea if they do or not, but if they do, another business model could not) because their annual transactions don't exceed $10k. So even digitally, your small standard transactions aren't (necessarily) being tracked. This could even include things like tips for servers. Of course, the Fed has recently been pushing for this threshold to come down to $600[0] with an explanation that this targets the rich who have multiple bank accounts that are amassing millions of untaxed income.
I am actually for digital currencies, but I personally think we need to make them like digital cash. That is, they use ZKP transactions with minimal metadata to produce as anonymous transactions as possible. Surveillance capitalism and surveillance states have been a mistake. We had centuries of tracking commerce with physical cash and have learned a lot about how to catch fraud and theft. While anonymous payments can enable some more theft I don't personally believe that any government needs to specifically track what an individual person is spending their money on.As a data nerd, I'd be perfectly fine if we had some homomorphic encryption that allowed for some anonymized analysis on how aggregates of people are spending their money but I still don't think we should be tracking citizens.
[0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/irs-bank-account-update-change-...