News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by yootyootr on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:10AM (#34709074)
I'm not worried about total bank surveillance at all, actually. I'm extremely worried about:

* money that is programmed to be returned to the bank unless it is spent by X time

* money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services

* high barriers to entry for businesses who want to allow money to be spent with them

* unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government

* universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat

* money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by pjc50 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:03AM (#34709952)
> money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services

The US food stamp system does this.

> unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government

The US police seizure system does this; I submit that if this happens you have a serious rule-of-law problem and already, or are about to, have bigger problems.

> universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat

This implies nonconvertibility?

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by rkangel on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#34710539)
> The US police seizure system does this; I submit that if this happens you have a serious rule-of-law problem and already, or are about to, have bigger problems.

The US police seizure system already is a serious rule-of-law problem due to lack of accountability.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by blitzar on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:43AM (#34722099)
> The US police seizure system already is a serious rule-of-law problem due to lack of accountability.

The US police seizure system already is enshrined in the actual law. However, by the "rule-of-law" it is the law. The problem is that particular law, every single word of it.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:12AM (#34710119)
Nonconvertibility is a forseeable next step. I imagine first there would be a fee for converting to cash (eg. if you "withdraw" 100 digital pounds, you get 90 paper ones). Then the decreasing popularity of paper pounds would be used as a basis for eliminating them entirely: going forward, paper pounds could be deposited for digital, but not withdrawn.

Next, the bank starts applying negative interest rates when they need to "stimulate" asset prices and keep the stock market from crashing. No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year...

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by bsdz on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:29AM (#34710436)
> Next, the bank starts applying negative interest rates when they need to "stimulate" asset prices and keep the stock market from crashing. No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year...

Can't they do this already by increasing money supply or QE? Central bank's can already create inflation which isn't dissimilar to negative interest rates.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:06PM (#34711060)
QE is effectively an interest-rate cut but for long-term bonds rather than short term. It would typically be used in conjunction with control of the overnight rate, which still struggles with the zero-lower-bound unless the ability to hold cash is removed from the system.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mywittyname on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:56PM (#34711944)
> No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year...

Why would they do this? There's already a much more streamlined legal mechanism for this: taxes. Plus, this isn't some new feature. If the government orders you assets frozen/seized, then a bank is going to comply with the order.

> I imagine first there would be a fee for converting to cash (eg. if you "withdraw" 100 digital pounds, you get 90 paper ones).

Again, not new. This is basically an ATM fee. Paper money has costs associated with it, whether that cost is paid explicitly (through fees) or behind the scenes (collecting fees from purchases, selling information about you to third parties, or "borrowing" your deposits to collect interest on it) is pretty much irrelevant.

Nothing you're saying is a "new" feature of digital currency.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:07PM (#34712110)
Taxes are generally set in proportion to income, not savings. ATM fees are limited by competition to close to the bank's actual costs, rather than a deliberate policy to eliminate paper currency in circulation; if they charged upwards of 10% on withdrawals, people would very likely leave.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by kwere on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:22PM (#34712359)
wealth taxes exist
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:25PM (#34712401)
For example?

More importantly, this wouldn't be a tax on wealth, it would be a tax on savings, meaning it would disproportionately affect the less-wealthy and the less-credit-worthy, who tend to not own significant assets or have the borrowing power to buy them. In terms of the discrepancy with a wealth tax, imagine trying to save money to buy a house, except that the house price grows each year, due to negative interest rates, while your savings account shrinks by the same proportion. Perhaps it doesn't take much imagination, because it's similar to 2020's zero-interest-rate environment, but without the restraint of being bounded by zero.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ineptech on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:30PM (#34713540)
When people talk about central banks using negative interest rates to juice the economy, they mean the interest rate for borrowing, not for savings. They're related, but not tied to each other. The Fed lending money to my bank at a negative rate means my bank will be more likely to lend me money to open a business; it does not mean the bank would charge me interest on my savings (which would of course cause me to withdraw my money and close my account).

Are you imagining the government using digital currency to enact some kind of "shrinking money" policy that would have the effect of a negative savings rate? If so, why would they do that, and couldn't they do that regardless of whether the central bank lending rate is positive or negative?

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:50PM (#34713848)
> it does not mean the bank would charge me interest on my savings (which would of course cause me to withdraw my money and close my account).

Indeed. The reason why this matters, and becomes possible, with a CBDC is that there is nowhere left to "withdraw" to. Private banks would not offer you any higher rates on savings than the CBDC does (why would they, when they can borrow at the interbank rate for less?). The fact that account holders would withdraw if rates on savings became negative is why central banks presently are unable to reduce the interest rate (significantly) below zero. With a CBDC, "withdrawing" simply means transferring from your private bank account to your CBDC account.

It would not be the government enacting this policy, but the central bank itself, as a necessary step to conducting monetary policy below the zero bound.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ineptech on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:26PM (#34714454)
> with a CBDC is that there is nowhere left to "withdraw" to

Why can't I use them to purchase dollars or yen? How did we get from the BofE issuing a currency that people can use to everyone being forced to use it? (Also, may I humbly suggest the wikipedia article on Gresham's Law, if you're not familiar with it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law)

I agree that bad things would happen if everyone was forced to use a currency they don't want to use, but that's kind of axiomatic.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by d110af5ccf on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:25PM (#34717171)
It's the obvious logical conclusion. Much of Europe is already actively trying to eliminate cash for quite a few years now. So the notion that a CBDC is acceptable specifically because cash will still exist, and that people won't be actively prevented from using cash in the future, is utterly absurd in light of the facts on the ground.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ineptech on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @07:21PM (#34717831)
I didn't mention cash at all, perhaps you meant to reply to a different comment?
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by IanCal on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:22PM (#34714389)
> Private banks would not offer you any higher rates on savings than the CBDC does (why would they, when they can borrow at the interbank rate for less?)

The interbank rate has to be lower than 7% I'm sure, but that's what I have in a savings account.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @10:36PM (#34719453)
Congratulations; you found a loss leader?
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by IanCal on Thursday February 09, 2023 @06:35AM (#34722462)
Yes, that's one of the many reasons why private banks would do it.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by d110af5ccf on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:18PM (#34717093)
> this isn't some new feature. If the government orders you assets frozen/seized, then a bank is going to comply with the order

You aren't seriously trying to imply that it would be feasible for a government to decide to seize 5% of everyone's bank accounts at present? Being able to do something in a targeted manner and being able to do that same thing to the entire population at once with ease are not at all the same.

This is actually where a lot of people's perceptions about government tyranny seem to break down somewhat inexplicably. Guns? The police can show up right now and outnumber you so it makes no difference if they're outlawed. Restrictions on movement? The government can already blockade roads if they want to so it makes no difference if checkpoints are allowed to be constructed. Mass surveillance? The government can already wiretap you without your knowledge so it doesn't matter if that process is allowed to be automated.

All of those positions are very obviously false and yet a significant portion of the population seems to struggle with the common underlying concept. Enabling a behavior en masse with little to no friction is not at all the same as something targeted that requires noticeable resource expenditure to carry it out in each individual instance.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by avn2109 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:10AM (#34710074)
> "* unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government"

This is A) a correct, valid worry and B) isomorphic to the "surveillance" thing, in the sense that the surveillance is just a means to an end. They mostly want the surveillance in order to demonetise the outgroup (however that outgroup is defined).

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by thedangler on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:10AM (#34710094)
And it probably wont be open to the public to see the ledgers.
[dead]
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by h0p3 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:30AM (#34761405)
I'd like to hear your thoughts on [[peruvian bull]].
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by euix on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:21AM (#34710296)
"* money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services"

This is basically a rationing system, like the olden days in China and the Soviet Union, where it wasn't enough to have money, you also needed a ration coupon to buy the good. Everything was rationed not just food, but bolts of clothes, consumer goods of any type, electronics (if you were fortunate enough to be able to afford it).

In this way the regime controlled scarcity and ensured loyalty and favoritism by awarding special rations and coupons for those who uphold the correct ideology and "meritorious labor". Each month your work unit issued a new ration book for the month that is based on your families' allotment of grains, cooking oil, clothing, soap, etc. If you are being a bad boy and you don't get your ration book for the month, you can't buy the goods in the state supply shop and have to go the black market.

Thus pure money wasn't good enough to live well or even to survive in those systems - one needed connections and access and the authorities can cancel your access at any time.

That is what a CBDC has the potential to evolve to and what worries me - a digital ration book. If all a CBDC is is digital cash, then we already have that system (Visa, e-payments, etc) and things won't change much but if a CBDC is a programmable form of money that can be disabled, inflated at will, turned off, or only allowed to buy certain goods - then there is no limit to the amount of tyranny that will be on hand. In a free country common people will not and should not accept it.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by rkangel on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#34710530)
> If all a CBDC is is digital cash, then we already have that system (Visa, e-payments, etc)

It has taken me a while today to get my head round this, but no we don't have digital cash.

Visa, e-payments etc. are all claims on financial institutions (banks, payment providers etc.). Those banks then indirectly have a claim on the Central Bank currency for us.

The only thing that gives private individuals a direct claim on CB currency is cash, which is increasingly less a part of society. This is the Bank of England (potentially) empowering private individuals and making us less beholden to banks.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by neilwilson on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:57PM (#34711960)
There’s no difference in reality. If you have money in a U.K. building society or credit union they are two steps away from the Bank.

All deposit takers in the U.K. are agents of the Bank.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by omnicognate on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:11PM (#34711160)
The UK has had rationing before (in wartime, and for some time after) and didn't need a CBDC to implement it. It also already has the power to freeze assets, levy taxes, ban products, introduce license requirements, etc. Why do you think a CBDC makes the government more likely to use its powers in a manner similar to what China and the USSR were doing long before CBDCs were conceived of?
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by febeling on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:04PM (#34712077)
Because you can push a single button and a person is in the cold. There will be no disruption for anyone else, just your one neighbor with the dangerous views can't pay rent and buy food anymore. I can't think of anything more dystopian.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by lottin on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:30PM (#34712494)
Do you understand that by definition a government is able to exert violence against citizens? Surely you must find this more terrifying than the possibility that they might be able to stop someone from making payments.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:07PM (#34714133)
They have always been able to do things like this in a targeted way to particular people at some cost as well as some inconvenience to judges and police officers, but not efficiently, programmatically, instantaneously, at scale, and integrated with the rest of their surveillance infrastructure. This creates similar risks and incentives for politically targeted abuse and the advancement of totalitarian, technocratic forms of government masked by secrecy laws as those found in the FISA courts.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by febeling on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:23PM (#34715395)
That’s kind of distorted. Government has the monopoly on violence, true, but only to the extent as the law grants it. A prime focus of constitutional law is to set strict limits to and legal recourse against acts of government.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by notch898a on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:44PM (#34715714)
[redacted]
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by febeling on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:02PM (#34715996)
That sounds completely unacceptable. With CBDC we would be in an even worse situation, that's my point.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by lottin on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:51PM (#34715826)
Well, in that case, the same applies to CBDCs, but so far all criticisms of CBDCs assume that the government will use CBDCs as a means of oppression unrestrained by any laws.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by febeling on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @05:18PM (#34716275)
Are you saying that it's unlikely that the government might abuse it's power? Look at history.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by lottin on Thursday February 09, 2023 @12:24AM (#34720097)
I'm saying that, if we assume that the government will oppress people (that's the assumption that CBDC critics make), it's silly to assume that it WILL use CBDCs to oppress people, and at the same time assume it WON'T use violence to oppress people.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by euix on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:05PM (#34714098)
Do you want to make it even easier for the government to do that? Sure the government can come to our house tomorrow and seize from us under one charge or another - but there is a price to pay in terms of public opinion and the physicality and limitations of applying coercive force to you. But digital tools, if you made it easy and convenient enough, then it becomes another matter.

Justifying extensions of government power with "but they can already do that" is cowardice at best and disingenuous at worst.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by scotty79 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:53PM (#34717548)
Sometimes government needs to do that and when it does it's costly and the cost comes from our collective pocket. So making it easier just saves us money.

There's of course argument that if it's easier it will do it more often so it costs more. But that's something that will need to be controlled through political system.

Basically development of humanity is making forms of oppression increasingly more painless and predictable to both the oppressor and the oppressed. Predictability and painlessness is good for business so we thrive.

You can't get rid of oppression. Humans will always divide into the ones that hoard power and those who don't with former living off the latter. Best we can do and the best we've actually done is to make this process as painless and as predictable as possible. Currently we are at the stage of territorially divided monopolies on violence. We learned in world wars that "territorially divided" is a very important part.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by euix on Thursday February 09, 2023 @10:00AM (#34724927)
Starting to go off topic but, there is no such thing as painless oppression or making it "less painful". You can view the matter in abstract from a distance like this, but if it ever falls on you or your family then it becomes a different matter. We can all view the matter impersonally and without passion, the philosophizing stops the moment it lands on our own heads - and I don't believe one can go through life without ever being on the wrong end of that.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by scotty79 on Thursday February 09, 2023 @10:14AM (#34725180)
> there is no such thing as painless oppression or making it "less painful"

What kind of opression do you prefer? Filling a tax form every year and paying what you calculated under the threat of arrest (while telling yourself you are voluntarily contributing to society and less fortunate) or being raided by a warband with guns on random intervals taking whatever they please and leaving you only what they at the time believe will let you bounce back so they can raid you again sometime in the future?

Either you are one who enacts or profits from violence or you are affected and robbed by violence. It's a constant setup since the beginning of the human race (or even before that). The only change that evolution of civilization delivers is making the violence predictable and gradual, thus less painfull, thus allowing for more efficient economic activity. If you make oppressors work harder for their cut they'll just take more from you once they do take it.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by int_19h on Friday February 10, 2023 @04:01AM (#34737295)
Winning elections is a lot of work to get to the point where one can collect their cut. Should we get rid of that obstacle and return to hereditary nobility in the interest of making violence less painful?
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by scotty79 on Friday February 10, 2023 @05:47AM (#34738029)
Hereditary nobility doesn't result in less painful violence. It results in way more painful violence less often in the form of revolutions either successful or supressed.

The main value of democracy is making the oppressed docile and easily subjugated.

And yes, winning election in US is way too costly. Budgets for campaigning should be capped. Other countries manage to sustain democracies with far less. Ultimately it doesn't matter who wins as long as it's not the same faction all the time. In that case unrest wouldn't be suppressed and violence would necessarily get more painful.

Democracy didn't win because it's moral or just. It won because it's most efficient system of maintaining oppression in post industrial technological landscape. You can look at how fragile single party system of China is, or Soviet Union was in comparison to even just rudimentary two party system like in US.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by nivenkos on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:36PM (#34711593)
All of Europe had severe rationing during and post-WW2.

Gringos don't know how good they've had it.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by pmalynin on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:51PM (#34711841)
It wasn’t to the same extent I’m sure but the USA did have rationing during WW2 with ration books and all. It was organized through the Office of Price Administration.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by bobthepanda on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:11PM (#34715237)
Also, this kind of restricted spending is already a function of US EBT (food stamps for the poor), no digital currency needed.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by notahacker on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:01PM (#34712026)
The accounts are already electronic and can be frozen at the government's will, and the government can already set new spending rules which apply to all bank accounts whenever it wants. Commercial banks have the same purely theoretical capabilities to issue electronic accounts with time limits or spending restrictions on the money as the central bank, but the central bank has a lot less incentive to do so
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by einherjae on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:42PM (#34712683)
Or, simply a gift card.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by bobthepanda on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:12PM (#34715245)
Not even, US EBT is already this.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by com2kid on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @02:46PM (#34713785)
> That is what a CBDC has the potential to evolve to and what worries me - a digital ration book. If all a CBDC is is digital cash, then we already have that system (Visa, e-payments, etc)

Famously, credit cards prevented microtransactions from ever being a thing, and may have very well lead to the ad dystopia we now live in. Insisting on taking a % cut of every transaction, and not allowing small transactions to occur, has dramatically limited business models across a multitude of industries.

Imagine going back to 1999, before clickbait journalism, when newspapers were incredibly well staffed with fact checkers and when long form journalists could easily spend months upon months on a single article.

Now instead of forcing a race to the bottom of ads and needing to get as many eyeballs as possible, imagine if it was even possible to experiment with a 5 cent per article view microtransaction.

Reddit and Twitch have both shown that users are very willing to invest in microtransaction ecosystems for large enough content platforms.

Saying Visa is the same thing as digital cash is rather inaccurate!

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by yurishimo on Thursday February 09, 2023 @08:35AM (#34723647)
> Reddit and Twitch

Are those examples we want to emulate in broader society though? At various points in my life, I have used both of those services extensively. I have never spent money on Reddit, despite being a registered user for 12+ years. I lurked for a year or two at least before creating an account.

On Twitch, I did have a free Prime sub that I would use, but I never spent any more on the service. I'm admittedly behind on the meta now, but is it even possible to give a streamer 1 "bit"? Or is there a minimum requirement of 10 or 50 bits? When I watch streams, I see some people donate with bits, but it seems like a way to save the user from making multiple purchases in a row, rather than a new paradigm of wealth transfer. "Hey, I'm gonna buy 500 bits now and donate 50 per stream" as opposed to needing to pull out the credit card on streamlabs or paypal 5 times a week.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by dboreham on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#34710761)
> money that is programmed to be returned to the bank unless it is spent by X time

Quick note that regular money works like this, although you might not realize this if you grew up in the USA since afaik it has never happened here. Governments re-issue all the money quite often. UK did it in 1971. India did it in 2016. It happened when the Euro was launched.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by roywiggins on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:17PM (#34711270)
Nigeria is just this week trying to do the same. I don't think it's going very well though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-64566992

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by febeling on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:30PM (#34712495)
All money (except for coins) is created in loans, which have a maturity date, at which "money is programmed to return to the bank", else you're forfeited. The monetary aggregate is ever-rotating, else all stops. It used to be 90 days, not sure now.

At least that was the state of affairs until 2008. Since then the system is more or less in decay, at least by standards which where held before.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by Our_Benefactors on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:51PM (#34712832)
These have always come with the option to exchange old notes for new.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ihatepython on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:24PM (#34715407)
At which point they ask you where you got the money in the first place, prove where you got it from, and then make you pay taxes on that money.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by yurishimo on Thursday February 09, 2023 @08:37AM (#34723663)
Is there a threshold to get these kinds of questions? I've never had to explain where I got a ratty old $20 bill from. I'm also not trying to replace $4,000 in old bills either.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by int_19h on Friday February 10, 2023 @04:05AM (#34737316)
The simplest way to exchange old notes for new is to use them to pay for things while they remain legal tender, which also neatly avoids such questions.

Now, if your government is of the kind that can realistically announce over the weekend that cash is going to be worthless by Monday unless exchanged, then yeah. Then again, if you live in a place like that, you probably already know to keep your money in foreign currency and use the black market exchanges as needed.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ihatepython on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:27PM (#34715450)
> Quick note that regular money works like this, although you might not realize this if you grew up in the USA since afaik it has never happened here.

This is one of the main reasons why the US dollar has been the de facto reserve currency.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by abigail95 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:51AM (#34710812)
All of that makes the money have lower value, and is similar to how central banks manage money supply by making it easier and harder to get.

The rest of it already exists for normal money. Tyrannical control over finance isn't a property of a digital currency, it's a property of the government. Your causality is backwards. A bad government will do that whether they have a digital currency or not, and a digital currency has no moral properties as it's just a tool.

Whether a digital currency makes it easier at the margin to oppress people, I don't think it does. You can imagine how many headaches an imperfect implementation could cause.

If the digital currency is so restricted that people would rather use cash, it will death spiral to zero as merchants who accept it can't trade it for full value to others. The only way around that would be for the govt to backstop it and trade 1:1 with cash, which would defeat the purpose of the restrictions.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by momirlan on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:19PM (#34711320)
according to this logic, total video surveillance is ok too, because it's just a tool. the government scanning all your private conversations is ok too, as long as the government is good.

but all these could be used by a government to influence the voter behaviour such that they stay in power forever, China style.

you are ready for communism.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by omnicognate on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:57PM (#34711964)
It doesn't make those things OK because the argument against those things isn't that they enable the government to act in an authoritarian manner but that they are violations of individuals' right to privacy. Total surveillance is a bad thing in its own right. A CBDC is, as far as I've seen so far, not. And the argument that it should be seen as bad because it could be used for bad things by a bad government doesn't hold water, because preventing a CBDC wouldn't materially restrict the powers the government could wield if it were to become authoritarian.

You're clearly convinced that governments slide inevitably towards authoritarianism and can only be prevented from doing so by practically restricting their powers, but it's a rather backwards way of thinking about things. An authoritarian government takes whatever powers it wants and wipes its arse with any rules that have been written to supposedly prevent it. If an authoritarian government thinks a CBDC will be useful it can just make one. Not that it would have to, because the government's existing powers are already sufficient to implement all the nefarious schemes people are worrying about in this thread.

The way to avoid the threat of an authoritarian government is to have a fair and well run electoral system, a healthy national political dialogue and a well educated population (not that these things are easy), not to assume the government is inevitably going to go bad and block it from implementing useful policies in a futile attempt to curtail the powers of the dictatorship you've convinced yourself it will one day become.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by ahoya on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:12PM (#34712183)
In the US it is commonly held belief that the government powers must be restricted because all governments slide into corruption more quickly without.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by omnicognate on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @01:25PM (#34712402)
Yes, it's in the cultural DNA of the USA in a way it isn't in the UK, so it's a viewpoint you see a lot on hn. But this is a UK proposal.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by fortzi on Friday February 10, 2023 @02:31AM (#34736774)
It sounds like you imagine a totalitarian regime’s rise as a one hit move, with it rising to power and immediately abolishing laws, etc. in reality, it’s usually a slow crawl with another kind of freedom being taken away every time. With any such increment towards totalitarianism, folks like you will stress how this particular small step isn’t the one thing that enables totalitarianism. Totalitarian rulers like Orban and Erdogan owe everything to people like you.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by blitzar on Thursday February 09, 2023 @05:39AM (#34722071)
It is counter to the logic that, because cameras exist that they enable surviellance or because private conversations exist that enables the capture of those private conversations or ultimately because voters exist that enables someone to influence the voter.

The solution to that logic is to abolish everything.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by octacat on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:53PM (#34711880)
Basically every bad thing we've seen and tried with gacha games economics.
Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by neilwilson on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:55PM (#34711923)
CBDC is fiat currency.

Everything else you state can already be done with the existing banking system.

How do you think fraud stops work?

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by e63f67dd-065b on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:48PM (#34714865)
> money that is programmed to be returned to the bank unless it is spent by X time

We already have this: if you don't use your budget by xyz date, you lose it

> money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services

Food stamps can only be spent on food, you must meet specific criteria for tax credits, etc.

> high barriers to entry for businesses who want to allow money to be spent with them

Some businesses will absolutely not take your money without extensive KYC already

> unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government

Banks already arbitrarily shut down bank accounts with no recourse.

> universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat

The whole point of money is that it's the common means of exchange, it's not very useful as money if only some people use it.

> money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day

That's already the case today.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by d110af5ccf on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @06:36PM (#34717341)
> if you don't use your budget by xyz date, you lose it

It doesn't apply to cash or my bank account. I do not want that to change. I will not support a tool that would enable this.

> Food stamps can only be spent on food

Those are not cash. Those are effectively gift cards for use at a grocery store.

> you must meet specific criteria for tax credits, etc.

Yet the tax credit is paid in cash. You can do with it as you will once you receive it. I will not support a tool that would change that.

> Some businesses will absolutely not take your money without extensive KYC already

The fact that a problem already exists is not an argument in support of making it worse.

> Banks already arbitrarily shut down bank accounts with no recourse.

Once again that doesn't justify actively making things worse.

> The whole point of money is that it's the common means of exchange, it's not very useful as money if only some people use it.

Many countries apply controls when converting to or from foreign currency. China in particular is known for this. Does that mean that their currency isn't useful to the people who live there? If the poor aren't permitted access to traditional cash they would have no choice but to use the CBDC whether they wanted to or not. At least aside from outright bartering, which is even less flexible.

> > money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day

> That's already the case today.

No, from the perspective of the individual it absolutely is not. If I have US cash or even a balance in a bank account in the US the government cannot "quickly and easily" modify the rules by which I can spend it. Particularly for paper cash their only options seem to be either to outlaw a particular sort of transaction and hope the police can enforce that (doesn't work, see drugs) or reissue the currency to force me to exchange it for something that they have more control over such as a CBDC.

Re:The digital pound: A new form of money for households and... by Ekaros on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @04:05PM (#34715148)
* unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government

I at least believe that governments have higher barrier than private entities that have already provably done this.