News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:00AM (#34146366)
> So I pirate the movie (please don't arrest me, it's google's fault)

I really like the frank tone of the article and I wish people in general would just write unabashedly more often when it comes to stuff like this. Writers online love to dance around the idea of "pirating" their digital goods when communicating on the topic: "Ooh my 'friend' may or may not have downloaded 'xyz' movie from 'abc' website, but I don't advocate piracy".

I pirate my music. I pirate my movies. Who gives a fuck? I'm not selling it for money. I love having mp4 files, I love having mp3 files. I ESPECIALLY love pirating mp3 files ever since Spotify and the streaming/subscription model has taken over. spytify automatically records mp3 files with metadata tags while you personally listen to Spotify https://github.com/jwallet/spy-spotify

Adhering to file-based digital possessions has saved me countlessly over the years and it will continue to. I had my music uploaded to Google Play Music, and once that was shut down (the equivalent songs are not in the replacement), I swore off streamed music as a way to organize my personal library, forever.

The things I could be doing better in this regard is better file organization and encrypting everything to safeguard against when my cloud file-hosting services come for me based on some dystopian DRM file-content scanning scheme. I've not hit that extreme point yet, however, although I should get around to it sooner than later with rclone.

Re:I'm Done with Google by notpushkin on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:39AM (#34146678)
> Spytify records the same quality that Spotify outputs

But it's still doing bad transcoding. It's like taking a screenshot of a JPEG photo: if you save it, you end up with more artifacts.

I'd just use one of the numerous Deezer downloaders – they decrypt the actual audio stream, and the input quality is just as good.

Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:54AM (#34146796)
Yes that's a fair criticism. I still want to use Spotify for discovery, and I'm not an audiophile, so the quality ends up being sufficient for me.
Re:I'm Done with Google by notpushkin on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:09AM (#34146888)
Yeah of course, if it suits you then I'm happy for you! It's just that the author rants about other tools downloading music from YouTube (which is also fair criticism of course), and then goes on and does the thing that's just as bad (or so says the audiophile zealot inside me).

(FWIW, there were some tools that could rip out the exact Ogg stream as used by Spotify, but I don't think they're working now.)

Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:15AM (#34146937)
Yes to be honest though going to greater lengths to extract high quality audio reaches a personal point where I'd rather try searching for the artist on Bandcamp or SoundCloud to buy lossless/high-quality audio, although everyone has a different personal point and the avenues in which you can buy good audio from the artist may not always exist. My thought process goes as: "If I want good audio quality, that means I must think the artist is pretty good, ergo I should definitely try buying it in file format somehow".

Thanks for clarifying that point about spytify.

Re:I'm Done with Google by comprev on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:01AM (#34146838)
I have no issue in paying the premium Deezer subscription with access to FLAC (16/44) files to build up my DJ-friendly music archive. I never play out/stream/upload mixes so audio only leaves the house if I save a mix on my phone for a long bike ride or run. Many artists get a healthy chunk of my cash for physical media (vinyl) via Bandcamp too.
Re:I'm Done with Google by tzs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @11:22AM (#34150011)
If one has digital audio that comes from playing back something encoded with lossy codec X, it should be possible to re-encode that in X format with no loss and no increase in size (this is trivial to prove).

Does anyone make re-encoders that can actually do that?

Re:I'm Done with Google by yellow_lead on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:01AM (#34146377)
Even a hardcore pirate like me tried to do the right thing when it comes to music - I got Spotify. But when I moved to Taiwan, I tried to switch my payment location to get regional pricing and they refuse to accept my Taiwan debit card. Now I pirate music or use Vanced (YouTube).
Re:I'm Done with Google by philliphaydon on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:17AM (#34146505)
I live in Taiwan but my CC is from Singapore. I want to get HBO but I can't because I don't have a Taiwan CC. But I can sign up for HBO Singapore but I can't use it in Taiwan... Soooo I'm subjected to pirating HBO content. Sometimes I wonder if these companies actually want to make money because they make it so far for us to give them money.
Re:I'm Done with Google by RedShift1 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:52AM (#34149671)
I've never ever understood geoblocking. What kind of company says no to someone wanting to purchase their products? They are literally throwing away money.
Re:I'm Done with Google by prirun on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @11:56AM (#34150520)
Not defending it, but I think it's a thing because media companies want to price things according to what a country/region can afford. So if they price something cheaper for Thailand, they don't want it to work in the US. Same as drug companies.
Re:I'm Done with Google by OrangeMusic on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:51PM (#34152216)
This is just one example I know of, but in France they have laws regarding when movies are available to stream, in order to regulate competition with the movie theaters. This means that movies available in the US are often not (yet) available in France. I can imagine media companies having to deal with such rules for all countries being a nightmare to implement and then just open in the US.
Re:I'm Done with Google by dzhiurgis on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:04PM (#34152404)
Netflix has this nuanced aspect with languages. There's no way to filter films by:

* non english (but english subs)

* actual language you understand

Plus subs selection is pathetic - Apple TV shines here, but it's not perfect.

Re:I'm Done with Google by BbzzbB on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:36AM (#34146653)
Works both ways tho. I remade my Tinder account from the Vietnamese phone number I had, have used my Canadian credit card and changed my account's phone to my Canadian one (ported to VoIP) after 3-4 weeks, but I still get billed in động for their top subscription.

You could remake your Spotify account. Alternatively, make a family account and share it with 5 more members. Works out to just 3$/month (Canadian!) for us. Wonder what it would work out to from a cheaper geolocation.

Re:I'm Done with Google by yellow_lead on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:40AM (#34146690)
I might try that but I have a lot of data already on my spotify account. The Spotify support tried to help me, escalated like four times, told me to talk to my bank (my card works on other sites and my bank said there should be no issues), etc. So I think it may not even work on a new account.
Re:I'm Done with Google by notpushkin on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:49AM (#34146757)
It would work. But it would still be piracy: their sublicense of content to you is likely conditional on you not doing any shenanigans to get another region's pricing.

So use it if you want to get recommendations, or don't want to bother managing your library, or want to give some pennies on a dollar to the actual artists. But remember, you're still a pirate. Be proud of it. Yarr!

IANAL

Re:I'm Done with Google by RockRobotRock on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:07AM (#34146424)
Between iTunes and Bandcamp, it's very easy to buy DRM free music (most of the time). In the streaming era, its basically impossible to buy TV shows and movies without DRM.
Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:27AM (#34146581)
SO EASY. Thank you. Daps up.
Re:I'm Done with Google by codethief on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:55AM (#34146801)
> Between iTunes and Bandcamp

…and, if I may add, shops like https://www.qobuz.com/us-en/shop , which fill the gap of providing HQ downloads of popular music that cannot be found on Bandcamp. I have to admit I haven't used them in years (ever since I got a Spotify account) but they used to be my go-to place for purchasing FLACs.

Re:I'm Done with Google by cassianoleal on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:58AM (#34147909)
Are all purchases on iTunes DRM free?
Re:I'm Done with Google by RockRobotRock on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:13PM (#34151682)
All music is.
Re:I'm Done with Google by JodieBenitez on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:32AM (#34146610)
> Even a hardcore pirate like me tried to do the right thing when it comes to music - I got Spotify.

This is not the right thing to do. Spotify is peanuts to artists. If you want to do the right thing, buy music at Bandcamp: you get files you can keep forever and artists get a fair share of your money.

Re:I'm Done with Google by yellow_lead on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:37AM (#34146661)
The artists I listen to don't all sell on bandcamp (most don't).
Re:I'm Done with Google by JodieBenitez on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:59AM (#34147568)
You're the lucky one, because there's a whole universe for you to discover ;-)
Re:I'm Done with Google by verisimi on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:53AM (#34146781)
Yes you're taking peanuts from the artists and sacks of peanuts from the music corporations, that provide.. er, promotion, a contract, and own the rights to the music the artist created.

Although it is true artists do get something, the lion's share goes to the music corporation.

Re:I'm Done with Google by piva00 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:22AM (#34147365)
That's the part about passion industries people don't understand: the distribution side doesn't have much power to structure the payment to artists, it's all in control of the publishers (labels/movie studios/game publishers) who control a large catalogue of works and have immense leverage to negotiate all this bullshit on geo-locked content, royalties' payments to the creators, etc.

Ranting about Spotify's, Apple Music's, Tidal's payments to the artists or region-locking IP is a smoke-and-mirrors move from major labels, they are the ones forcing these practices unto the distributors/streaming services.

Re:I'm Done with Google by comprev on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:04AM (#34146862)
Bandcampers forget the platform is for underground artists and those not tied by contract to the heavyweight labels.

You'll never see mainstream pop artists on there.

I love to promote Bandcamp where possible but have to remember what it can offer to "Average Joe"

Re:I'm Done with Google by JodieBenitez on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:58AM (#34147561)
True... but I would argue the average Joe was never inclined to "do the right thing" anyway, he would just do what's more convenient for him (back in the days it was listnening to the radio, these days it's spoteezer). That's what made me react in the first place... conflating a spoteezer subscription with "do the right thing" is just... bizarre to me. You can only do so when you ignore the truth of the revenue share behind these platforms
Re:I'm Done with Google by unity1001 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:12AM (#34146914)
> This is not the right thing to do. Spotify is peanuts to artists. If you want to do the right thing, buy music at Bandcamp

The right thing to do is to directly subscribe to their Patreon. It not only gets you access to exclusives, behind the scenes and even events, it also crowdfunds the future projects of the artist.

Re:I'm Done with Google by Closi on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:27AM (#34147020)
The right thing to do is to identify where the artist lives, then withdraw unmarked and untraceable cash which you post through their mailbox as a 'gift'. This means that you can guarantee all the money goes directly to the artist.
Re:I'm Done with Google by cassianoleal on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:57AM (#34147905)
If you mean that as opposed to part of it being converted to taxes, I'd argue that's not quite "the right thing". Or does the artist not benefit from public goods and services, like roads, public lighting, police, firefighting, etc etc etc?
Re:I'm Done with Google by zirgs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:53AM (#34149154)
It's the artist's responsibility to pay their own taxes. And yes - anonymous gifts like that are taxable income too.
Re:I'm Done with Google by prirun on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @12:02PM (#34150635)
I disagree. A gift is not taxable. If I send a check to you in the mail because I like your HN nickname, you don't pay taxes on that. You might need to pay taxes on a Patreon account if you have set it up for the purpose of supporting a business venture, but if you have set it up for donations to an ailing relative for example, IMO you do not owe taxes.

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

Take this with a grain of salt, I am not a tax attorney nor an accountant.

Re:I'm Done with Google by ptman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:41PM (#34153510)
Depends on where you are based. It may not be a gift if you receive something in return. And in Finland, where I live, gifts over a certain value are taxable income
Re:I'm Done with Google by Closi on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:10AM (#34183329)
Ha, I was joking - I was just playing the game of 'claim the original suggestion isn't what a true supporter would do, and heighten the previous suggestion' by suggesting a semi-illegal 'stalk and dump unmarked cash' technique.

i.e. If you were a true supporter, the right thing to do would be to form a legal trust and make the beneficiary of the trust the artist's children, and put your money into that, as this would help them legally avoid income taxes on the money you are giving them while using the money for their children's education.

Or a TRUE SUPPORTER wouldn't use band camp, instead they would evaluate the quality of roads and infrastructure around the artists house and pay for a series of contractors to improve the surrounding roads and areas, which will not only improve the artists quality of living but will also improve the value of their house. etc. etc.

In reality there is no 'right thing to do' - just choose whatever channel the artist has put up that supports them at the level that you want them to, and where you get value out.

Re:I'm Done with Google by unity1001 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @11:32AM (#34150142)
Patreon takes something like ~8%. Its chump change for the service given - they also handle sales tax, EUVAT and equivalents, chargebacks, fraud etc.
Re:I'm Done with Google by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @08:24AM (#34148366)
I think subscriptions are part of the problem. I personally compensate artists with a one time payment on Bandcamp, download permanent files to my NAS, and replicate them in devices I use for music.

I don’t want recurring payments.

Re:I'm Done with Google by zirgs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:51AM (#34149137)
Spotify is peanuts to artists, but without Spotify I would not even discover most of the artists that I listen to.
Re:I'm Done with Google by fsflover on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:21AM (#34159454)
You can benefit from Bandcamp in the same way.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:48AM (#34159625)
Is it agreeable that Bandcamp's discovery system is equally as good as Spotify's? I've never tried it.
Re:I'm Done with Google by fsflover on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @06:03AM (#34159741)
It's probably not as good, but works fine for me. Also, I heard they have a human-managed discovery instead of the automatic one. Podcasts with the overviews are also amazing.
Re:I'm Done with Google by satvikchoudhary on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:19AM (#34146518)
Is Vance still working?
Re:I'm Done with Google by recrof on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:34AM (#34146638)
look up ReVanced
Re:I'm Done with Google by charcircuit on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:31AM (#34146609)
Yes. I would recommend migrating to it's successor revanced though.
Re:I'm Done with Google by astkaasa on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:30AM (#34147045)
check revanced, it works just fine with specific version
Re:I'm Done with Google by PartiallyTyped on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:20AM (#34146525)
I tried doing the right thing via Spotify / Apple Music / Youtube Music. All of them have issues that piracy just doesn't.

Especially youtube music, sure i have access to otherwise "unpublished content" (looking at you Watsky refusing to put Wounded Healer on a streaming platform). But in a 3 hour flight I found myself iterating through all the songs I could download via the app.

For spotify, why do I have to go through all the hassle to explain to a person why tf I want my account closed? Why are you not giving me the tools to manage my library better? Why do I have to manually delete every single one song instead of group select or even purging everything?

I am not saying I am pirating, but I am not saying that it's a thing I will never do again.

The industry should get their shit together and build something that works for the customers (us), and smaller artists as well (cough spotify cough).

Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:25AM (#34146562)
How hard did you try, though? Can you not purchase physical mediums in Taiwan (or have them shipped there) and rip them lossless to your local disk? Or are you just a "hardcore pirate"?

As a full, self-assigned nerd with a family of artists, you're all drunk on tech salaries & anger about web frameworks or whatever the fuck is popping this week as you convince yourselves in comment threads that it's ok to Ayn Rand capitalism wrapped-out-but-disguised-in-left-leaning-ideals fuck other humans for the fuel that cranks through your headphones as you collect six figures with banger benefits.

But keep shrugging with your try hard posts and fuck those people because Spotify and labels and stuffs, right? Still gonna gobble it down while you shit on their dinner plate with a smile on your face, I'm sure.

Re:I'm Done with Google by dmantis on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:33AM (#34146631)
Not the guy you ask, but for me, I just want convenient digital thing on my laptop I actually own, not rent. I live in 2022 and don't want that physical crap.

I would have no problem to pay for DRM-free and location-independent stuff, but all this thing with "rights owners", "you can't hear that in this location", "you can't download it to listen offline and locally" is a total bullshit. I don't care what some lawman or government thinks. I also don't care about 5$ per month, that's nothing. But for my money, for any amount, I expect some respect and not this "money cow" attitude.

If artists want to get money from people like me, they probably should release their works under some more ethical distribution systems, which actually respect their customers wherever they live and whatever way to listen they prefer.

Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:05AM (#34146867)
> Not the guy you ask, but for me, I just want convenient digital thing on my laptop I actually own, not rent. I live in 2022 and don't want that physical crap.

Welp I got you bruh bruh...

> I would have no problem to pay for DRM-free and location-independent stuff, but all this thing with "rights owners", "you can't hear that in this location", "you can't download it to listen offline and locally" is a total bullshit.

Give me your two favorite artists and I'll send you their latest releases in lossless ripped form after I cop their physical records. You pay me the cost of the physical medium (which I'll immediately turn around and go donate to the public library for others to enjoy) and I'll fully eat S&H etc aka any dollar amount over the cost of said physical medium. That fits your description of 'no problem to pay', yeah?

> I don't care what some lawman or government thinks. I also don't care about 5$ per month, that's nothing. But for my money, for any amount, I expect some respect and not this "money cow" attitude.

Yes all the artists I know could definitely be placed in one of your three categories; lawmen, government entities, and/or money cows. That certainly doesn't drive home my point that you're all disconnected & wildly removed from reality.

Re:I'm Done with Google by dmantis on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:10AM (#34146895)
No problem, Send me Eminem, last Cypress Hill album and bitcoin address to pay, I'll pay you in public, put tx hash here and the whole HN will be able to see that.

Please also send here the invoice photo with yourself and nickname on hn as proof, so it's not some torrent downloaded content already and you really supported artists.

Though I won't do that process on day-to-day basis for each track I listen, that's kinda inconvenient, you know.

Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:40AM (#34147100)
Just copped The Slim Shady LP for you. That one is a classic.

His later records are trash (ok he had one more decent showing on The Marshall Mathers) and Cypress Hill is laughable I won't do it. Holy fuck of course you picked those two artists lol.

For real though your shit is purchased straight up & on it's way and now that you've mentioned BTC I don't even want to be reimbursed I just want to send you the lossless rips when the physical lands – ETA 1/4/2023.

Send me something so I can give you these files, please. That Slim Shady LP is amazing and I want to come through on my offer.

> Though I won't do that process on day-to-day basis for each track I listen, that's kinda inconvenient, you know.

Right you'd have to go to the website where you buy things and do what I did. I can understand that that's a bummer for you. You know what else is a bummer? Two free album offer and you choose Eminem and Cypress Hill hahaha. God damn my HN music taste bingo board would have SMACKED.

Re:I'm Done with Google by dmantis on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:02AM (#34147235)
There is no proof that you bought it, you can save for yourself if you don't want "reimbursement". I know how to use torrents, you know. The point was to support artists, not to get anything.

If you change your mind and would like to get the payment, the offer conditions is still valid, I don't deny to pay.

Actually your attitude is more or less the same as in other current distribution platforms - they kinda might support artists, but don't respect the client. And that's the reason that they will continue to loose money.

So we have a nice cosplay of modern labels, really!

Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:32PM (#34155909)
Thanks for taking this train of thought through-and-through to its logical conclusion. leehuffman was being unreasonable bordering on absurdity, so I did not feel the need to engage with the posts, but you took it all the way to the end despite the rudeness and demonstrated how untenable/inconvenient the proposals were.
Re:I'm Done with Google by scrollaway on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:40AM (#34146688)
So you want people to have to purchase cd rom players and be limited to whatever can be physically shipped, or else they’re not allowed to enjoy music at all?

Those limitations were a hard cap years ago. Now they aren’t: if you put them on somebody, they are arbitrary.

And you’re going on a weird-ass rant about capitalism yet you’re not seeing that this is a classic capitalistic problem? You’re expecting people to go a route that is more difficult, more expensive, more time consuming and has less choice, because a fraction of a percent of their effort and money will then maybe go to the original producer of the music?

Let people pirate if it’s the easy route for them FFS. Blame the record labels and distributors, they’re the ones at fault here.

Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:16AM (#34146948)
> Let people pirate if it’s the easy route for them FFS. Blame the record labels and distributors, they’re the ones at fault here.

Except I'm not referring to anyone who hasn't retained their masters/credits outside of their first record 20+ years ago. The rest of their catalogs are producing checks, but they're fractions of cents per play because streaming music services that everyone here hates.

The flip side is not ganking their shit off the internet for free (they're available and doing numbers on public trackers FYI)... it's purchasing their shit... why is this so confusing and/or combative for y'all?

Re:I'm Done with Google by scrollaway on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:05AM (#34147263)
And why is it so confusing for you that if convenience and accessibility tend towards piracy, then piracy will be picked over an inconvenient and inaccessible way of trying to pay for something?

Where convenience and accessibility tend towards paying, that will be the preferred solution. Spotify, Steam and Netflix built billion dollar businesses on that assumption being correct, in three different areas where people pirate frequently.

None of these businesses thought their time was best spent sending letters to individuals who were pirating. Not legal letters, not random HN comments talking about capitalism. Instead, they offered a solution.

Re:I'm Done with Google by pwinnski on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:37AM (#34149017)
I know a number of "hardcore pirates" who pay for nearly every streaming service you can imagine, but never use the services. Instead they provide some sort of "moral cover" for their piracy. Whatever works for them, I guess.
Re:I'm Done with Google by dxuh on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:30AM (#34146599)
Music and movies are very, very different. While there is no site I know of that provides purchase of DRM free downloads of popular movies, there are many alternatives for music. I purchase most of the music I like from Bandcamp and I think even Amazon allows purchase of DRM free downloadable music. I feel ZERO regrets about pirating movies, because I am not given any option worth purchasing, but I would feel bad pirating music and I think you should probably too, if you could afford it.
Re:I'm Done with Google by plaguepilled on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:56AM (#34146806)
Not all music is available on Bandcamp or Amazon - the availability from what I have seen is quite poor. Its the same issue but the can has been kicked down the road for music a little.
Re:I'm Done with Google by dxuh on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:54AM (#34159307)
Of course if you searched and you could not find it, then I agree it's perfectly fine to pirate as well.
Re:I'm Done with Google by veltas on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:32AM (#34146620)
I ask for open mindedness that I bring religion here, I feel it necessary to discuss this question of ethics/morality: "Who gives a fuck?"

I quote Mark 12:15.

> But, knowing their hypocrisy, he said to them, “Why put me to the test? Bring me a denarius and let me look at it.” And they brought one. And he said to them, “Whose likeness and inscription is this?” They said to him, “Caesar’s.” Jesus said to them, “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” And they marveled at him.

This is pretty much the reason I don't pirate.

I wasn't a Christian before. I first thought "if everyone else pays, why should I get it for free?". But eventually I came to question the concept of personal sharing of media being controlled by the state, and just gave in to 'piracy' (a silly name for the act). I suppose I also generally became jaded on social conscientiousness.

More recently I became a Christian and now I don't 'pirate' at all. It's because the above passage in my opinion can be applied to media (although it's not literally what was said, I think the rationale still works): most of the people who make such media don't approve of me 'pirating'. Therefore if I engage in it, which I actually have a choice about, rather than with the currency which frankly is mandatory for most people, then surely I owe them their price. And if I don't have a way to pay for it then I don't have any more right to it.

Respectfully, you act as if your hand is forced here, but you don't actually need to consume the media, you just want to.

Re:I'm Done with Google by nine_k on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:37AM (#34146662)
With all due respect, the OP has bought the movie legitimately. He has paid for it. It was legally his.

It was Google's technical ineptitude that did not allow him to use his legitimately bought movie, which had been readily available before.

So he obtained an illegally made copy of the movie which he had legally obtained before, which he had every right to keep in his possession, formally. I don't see anyone's interests being hurt by this, including financial interests, or any moral wrong done.

Re:I'm Done with Google by veltas on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:56AM (#34146807)
I was addressing the commenter who said they just pirate. I think the article is another matter.
Re:I'm Done with Google by swores on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:42AM (#34147479)
I can understand how Christianity-based morals might lead to thinking that digital piracy is immoral.

I can't understand how that particular bible verse could be a genuine influence on deciding whether or not illegally downloading copyrighted material is acceptable, at all. Can you explain what logic led from reading that text to deciding it meant you shouldn't pirate things?

And I'm also curious, if you hadn't read that verse would Jesus' other teachings, as told in the new testament, not have left you considering digital piracy to be immoral?

Re:I'm Done with Google by veltas on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:55AM (#34147894)
(To be clear: this is not a comment on Google's broken platform or the article, that's just awful. It's a response to the question "who gives a fuck?" regarding torrenting generally.)

> would Jesus' other teachings...not have left you considering digital piracy to be immoral?

Romans 13 calls Christians to be subject to authorities, that would be most Christians' given reason. It's one of my reasons, but it was not the reason that first convinced my heart.

> I can't understand how that particular bible verse could be a genuine influence on deciding whether or not illegally downloading copyrighted material is acceptable, at all. Can you explain what logic led from reading that text to deciding it meant you shouldn't pirate things?

Enemies of Jesus asked (paraphrasing) "Is it righteous to pay Caesar's tax, or not?". They were trying to trap him into saying something either illegal in the eyes of the Romans, or unrighteous in the eyes of the Jews. This is why Jesus says to bring him a coin, and asked "Who's head is on this coin?", and then says therefore "Give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and give to God the things that are God's". This is the answer to the question of what is right with conflicting authorities, because on reflection it is not controversial that God's ownership should take precedence, but that otherwise in Caesar's land and with Caesar's money you must play by Caesar's rules.

Furthermore, for a free man of those days, this principle would have been a precursor of the social contract: you partake in Caesar's money (or live in his land), then you pay Caesar's tax; the same way that you might argue that people who benefit from society owe a debt to society.

Thinking of it this way, now think about media that is 'owned'. It bears someone's mark. You watch completely freely, you are far more free and flexible to choose what media you consume than what economy you engage with. Nobody in the free world is oppressed into watching movies. I find it now actually principled to defend therefore that the 'owner' of some media (especially the creator) can expect payment in return for a copy of the media. We can certainly debate about reasonable scope of copyrights, but I think copyrights themselves are reasonable to an extent.

Re:I'm Done with Google by pc2g4d on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:57AM (#34147903)
I think the idea is that Jesus was saying secular authorities should be regarded as authorities in secular affairs, while religious authorities / God / the church should be regarded as authorities in religious affairs. At least that's one read of it. So the commenter defers to the illegality of piracy as determined by secular authorities, and doesn't pirate, as a way of respecting (his/her interpretation of) Jesus' (reported) teaching.

Which in my view is a fair approach to life, but hard for me to adopt personally.

Re:I'm Done with Google by linuxandrew on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:15AM (#34146483)
Exactly this. MSN Music screwed me over when they shut down and made the .m4p DRM music files unplayable. I redownloaded all of the music via BitTorrent and persisted to this day.
Re:I'm Done with Google by MikusR on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:30AM (#34146600)
That spy-spotify has some bs claims. Spotify uses ogg vorbis so if the output of the app is an mp3 there is a quality loss.
Re:I'm Done with Google by 22289d on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:13AM (#34146464)
I don't pirate for similar reasons. I just like the UX better. I like all these apps on my tv full of content. Until like 2015 pirating was the better UX so I did that. But now it's a pain in the ass relative to what streaming offers.

I always thought if they want me to pay, they gotta make it worth it. And they have. So they get my money.

Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:25AM (#34146560)
I agree with this approach and your approach does not have to conflict with what I described (and I'm not saying that you wrote this as a rebuttal, either).

What we come to is that for one person, dealing with the pains of content management and organization is not worth the cost, monetary or otherwise. For me, it is worth the cost, it's just not monetary.

Having said that, I too also use Netflix although that may change in the future. It helps with content discovery. Still, by no means is it my go-to method for content organization or full retrieval. I compared the colors side-by-side to Inception in Netflix compared to a downloaded version and for some reason it was way off to the point it hindered my enjoyment of the film. The massive blue tint was that noticeable.

Re:I'm Done with Google by tluyben2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:21AM (#34146539)
> And they have. So they get my money.

Sure, as long as that holds. I like the music services as they have all the weird stuff I listen to. I like the book services as they have all the weird stuff I read. But movies/tvshows are a different ballgame; if i'm watching some series or saw some trailer and I want to see it but it doesn't appear in the netflix/hbo/disney/apple in my country, I am not going to wait or not watch it at all.

There are too often new shows that seem interesting (sure, they hardly ever actually are) but are anglo-saxon countries or US only.

Then, in the days of yore, Netflix used to have old movies/shows and people used to hate that. I did not, but they are mostly gone. Why would they not stock ancient content from the 40s-80s? Maybe they do in the US, but here it's almost completely gone.

Re:I'm Done with Google by cableshaft on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:27AM (#34147023)
It's almost completely gone in the US on Netflix also. I've had better luck watching older movies on Youtube 'Free with Ads' service, especially 80s and 90s movies, than I've had on Netflix. And there's no ads if you get Youtube's premium service (I currently don't, but don't mind the ads).

Currently on there is Wrongfully Accused (funny Leslie Nielsen movie), Glengarry Glen Ross, Robocop (1987), Ghost in the Shell, The Mask, License to Drive, The Neverending Story, Tombstone, Leon The Professonal, The Amityville Horror, Over the Top (some Stallone movie), Miracle on 34th Street, Con Air, Edward Scissorhands, Gone Fishin', Look Who's Talking, While You Were Sleeping, The Craft, Red Dawn, So I Married an Axe Murderer, Secret of Nimh, Killer Klowns from Outer Space, Revenge of the Pink Panther, Mad Max, Das Boot, Little Shop of Horrors, Hackers, Children of the Corn, Death on the Nile (1978 version, remade recently), Delirious, Rock-a-Doodle, The Big Boss (Bruce Lee, 1971), Babes in Toyland, Samson an Delilah (1950), The Grapes of Wrath (1940), The Seven Year Itch (Marilyn Monroe, 1955) .... okay, I'm just going to stop now, but t keeps going, I'm only a third of the way though the list.

Only downside is you never know how long they'll stay on there, it doesn't seem to be as long as other services, so you kind of need to watch the ones you want to see while they're on there and check the list often. I think I had a similar comment on here six months ago and the list I had then would have been completely different.

Re:I'm Done with Google by 22289d on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:03AM (#34147244)
If you haven't, you might checkout HBO Max. It's got a much better lineup of movies than Netflix imo, especially in that timeframe.
Re:I'm Done with Google by cableshaft on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:21AM (#34147360)
You're probably right about that, I have noticed a pretty good line up on there when we had it for Silicon Valley, Game of Thrones, and Barry.

But I'd expect that of HBO also. They were the original channel to go to if you wanted to see great movies when I was a kid.

Re:I'm Done with Google by TylerE on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:34PM (#34151961)
Also Ceiterion Channel. Tons of old (good) stuff, and lots of weird indie modern stuff.
Re:I'm Done with Google by TylerE on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:19AM (#34146515)
Ditto, although on a marginally earlier schedule.

Not having to worry about being a data hoarder, with all the sorting, renaming, categorization, archiving etc is incredibly liberating.

I think of all the time I spent on an ancient single core machine ripping CDs (or downloading for OG Napster on dialup), many of which I probably never even listened to, and just shake my head.

Re:I'm Done with Google by nextlevelwizard on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:14AM (#34146481)
Hope you are at least buying CDs otherwise you are just making excuses to take stuff for free
Re:I'm Done with Google by leehuffman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:34AM (#34146635)
My W I Z A R D ! ! ! ! LET 'EM KNOW!
Re:I'm Done with Google by encryptluks2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:33AM (#34146629)
It's full of inaccuracies and hyperbole. It isn't frank, it is exaggerated to illicit a response.

For example,

> So I go to google play store and go through the 50,000 security verifications.

And this comment:

> Google is contributing to the destruction of the concept of ownership, as are many services of the modern age.

Pretty much any service that uses DRM. There is a lot to be upset with Google about, but this is like someone ranting that they can't figure out how to use a Google device. If you don't like it then buy a portable blu-ray or DVD player, or convert the DVD and blu-ray yourself to a digital format without DRM.

Re:I'm Done with Google by ryantgtg on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:10AM (#34146893)
The article doesn’t express that Google is _solely_ responsible for the destruction of the concept of ownership. That statement isn’t inaccurate. It’s perfectly reasonable to be bothered by the fact that their setup worked fine for years and then stopped working for no good reason. It sounds like you’ve “heard it before” and don’t care to hear it again.

Remember that this is grandma’s setup. Sure, there are alternative paths for young bucks like us, but for others they simply want to “buy” something and then play it at will. This is a story about Google depriving a dying grandma of one of her last joys.

Re:I'm Done with Google by encryptluks2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:14AM (#34148800)
I am not under the impression that is what happened here. It sounds like a DRM sucks period rant that someone uses Google as a scapegoat and encourages like-minded Google haters to air their grievances about wanting to quit Google.

Like I said, there are a lot of reasons to dislike Google but this post sounds like a misguided complaint. The issue likely could have been solved and maybe entirely be attributed to user error, but it didn't matter.

Re:I'm Done with Google by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:40AM (#34149546)
you're free to interpret it that way, but that certainly wasn't my interpretation.

I wonder if it's a generational thing where those of us who are old enough to remember when streaming wasn't a thing don't find it acceptable because companies didn't used to be able to treat us this way. Once the physical media was in our hands it was ours and if it randomly stopped working it was generally duo to a physical problem we had a hand in.

Re:I'm Done with Google by encryptluks2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:50AM (#34149655)
I remember that and still advocate for it. I'm just surprised that the issue was directed at Google and not DRM in general.
Re:I'm Done with Google by Hamuko on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:25AM (#34146559)
>spytify automatically records mp3 files with metadata tags while you personally use Spotify

I prefer pirating my music off YouTube.

  yt-dlp -f bestaudio https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=XXX
This nets you a bunch of *.webm files with Opus data inside them. YouTube's bestaudio is usually about 130 kbs Opus, which should be close to transparent. You can then use mkvextract to turn them into more usable *.opus files.

  mkvextract input.webm tracks 0:output.opus
The downside is that you need to tag your downloads manually after that. It's less of a problem for me since I use beets for my music library, but can be a pain if you don't have an automatic way of doing it.
Re:I'm Done with Google by MikusR on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:38AM (#34146672)
add -x to yt-dlp to directly remux to .opus and --add-metadata to write tags.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:48AM (#34146742)
Isn't the second extraction unnecessary? I just tried this command and it worked, with metadata

yt-dlp --output "%(upload_date)s ---- %(artist)s --- %(title)s.%(ext)s" --add-metadata --embed-thumbnail --audio-format opus --format bestaudio --remux-video opus "https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=0oAAlssVwEw"

Re:I'm Done with Google by Hamuko on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:02AM (#34146847)
Huh, didn't even notice that yt-dlp can do it automatically. Thanks.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:08AM (#34146886)
Happy New Year!
Re:I'm Done with Google by userbinator on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:43AM (#34146704)
I really like the frank tone of the article and I wish people in general would just write unabashedly more often when it comes to stuff like this.

I still remember when not pirating would get you strange reactions, and it was considered polite to share (on a USB drive or similar) the media you had recently consumed; some PMPs even had a USB host mode, which let users exchange files with others easily, and P2P was also far more popular. Here's some dated-but-related references from that era:

https://xkcd.com/488/

https://i.imgur.com/9l9nc.png

Re:I'm Done with Google by ce4 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:46AM (#34146729)
Re:I'm Done with Google by teddyh on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:16AM (#34147668)
Re:I'm Done with Google by gorgoiler on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:46AM (#34146735)
If you pirate something for which you’ve already bought a license, is it even pirating? If the license is for a particular set of bits then unless you are pirating those exact bits I guess so. You licensed Lemonade.drm.mp4 so downloading Lemonade.mp3 is pirating.

But then again it’s not pirating to re encode your audio files once you’ve downloaded them. So I feel more confident in saying it’s not the bits that are licensed, it’s the work itself. The act of downloading it from piratewarez.example.com feels fishy, but if you download it from musicbackups.example.com — a hypothetical site that says you should not download copies of files unless you have bought a license for them in the past — then it starts to feel like a more interesting gray area. You’ve licensed a digital copy of the work, so why is it wrong to get a copy of it from some place else? The person distributing the work is probably in hot water, but you shouldn’t be, as long as you have the receipt for the original purchase and/or a copy of the license.

For me, the big one here is ebooks. If I buy a physical copy of a book then as far as I’m concerned I’ve bought the license to the work as well as that particular piece of physical media. I don’t lose sleep about pirating the ebook version as well.

Re:I'm Done with Google by djhworld on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:19AM (#34146969)
IANAL but I think the license you buy from google play or apple or whatever is not a license for the content, it's a license to access the content from the provider through a specific player/app. So getting content from musicbackups dot com or whatever would not be a transferable right or gray area.

People will do it anyway though

Re:I'm Done with Google by danbulant on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:00AM (#34147574)
Not sure about US, but for example in Czechia, you can download any content legally - as long as you don't share it, it's fine. Torrents do share it though, so that is a gray area.

You also have a right to make a personal backup/copy of the content, again, as long as you don't share that copy (projecting for multiple people is also sharing in this context).

Re:I'm Done with Google by cassianoleal on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:00AM (#34147922)
> Torrents do share it though

Torrents don't share it. You do if your torrent client is configured to do so.

BitTorrent is a protocol. You use it how you use it. If you only want to use it to download stuff, you can.

Re:I'm Done with Google by Jorengarenar on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:07AM (#34148751)
>in Czechia, you can download any content legally - as long as you don't share it, it's fine.

Very similar law in Poland: you can legally pirate music, books, comics, movies, images for yours own (including your family and closest friends) use.

What's interesting, there is an exception for software and video games - those are always illegal.

Re:I'm Done with Google by notpushkin on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:22AM (#34146990)
“Emulators community” have a partucularly peculiar take on that by the way.

Current gen emulator developers usually say you should rip your own ROMs from the physical media instead of just downloading them from torrents (even if you have the disc/cartridge on hand). I don't think anybody's actually doing that, but discussing downloads is banned on official channels.

Re:I'm Done with Google by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#34149490)
It's the law in the US.

You can RIP copyrighted content of physical media you own for backup purposes, but you cannot share it.

This is why ripping a music CD you own is perfectly legal, but if you upload it that is not legal, nor is downloading it from someone elses upload.

Some people in the emulation community do actually adhere to this, but the vast majority do not, as you noted.

Re:I'm Done with Google by hansvm on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:29AM (#34159518)
Not sure about other content, but for games (and other programs) in particular this isn't quite true in the US (Copyright Act -- Section 117). You're explicitly able to authorize another individual to do the ripping on your behalf, and they can transfer to you the result. Websites offering those for download are problematic because they usually don't verify ownership or take any steps to ensure copies are destroyed or transferred when the underlying media is transferred.

Also, IANAL, but I suspect the order of events might get somebody into hot water. Although the effect on the creator would be the same, I'm not sure it's legal to (1) make a backup, (2) be authorized to make a backup by a media owner, and (3) transfer it -- as opposed to (2,1,3). I.e., hosting the content perpetually might be illegal regardless of your access controls. That isn't a problem with upload/download/sharing per se, but it does potentially make doing so more complicated.

Re:I'm Done with Google by deelly on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:52AM (#34146773)
> for which you’ve already bought a license...

Bought a temporary license to use/read/watch. Its not like you bought a digital file. Nope.

Re:I'm Done with Google by bardan on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:52AM (#34146772)
Unless you are buying physical media, tbe only way you can actually own something today is to pirate it.
Re:I'm Done with Google by zirgs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:01AM (#34149230)
Sites like GOG provide you with DRM free installers of all their games - you can backup those wherever you want.
Re:I'm Done with Google by amelius on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:20AM (#34146976)
Spotify is still great for discovering music, though.
Re:I'm Done with Google by fsflover on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:31AM (#34159534)
Bandcamp does it for me, too.
Re:I'm Done with Google by thiht on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:17AM (#34148009)
I subscribe to 4 different platforms (Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+ and Crunchyroll) and every fucking time I want to watch a specific movie it’s not on any of these. Last week I wanted to watch Harry Potter which I know was on Netflix and/or Prime Video at some point, now it’s not available anywhere. So I went back to piracy. 2023 will be the year of Plex+NAS for me because I can’t justify paying for so many subscriptions if there’s not even the things I want to watch when I want it. I’ll just keep Crunchyroll as it’s giving me the best value so far.
Re:I'm Done with Google by tzs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @12:12PM (#34150801)
> Last week I wanted to watch Harry Potter which I know was on Netflix and/or Prime Video at some point, now it’s not available anywhere.

It's on Peacock Premium and HBO Max.

Re:I'm Done with Google by thiht on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:05PM (#34151571)
Not available in Europe. Also there’s no way I’m paying for 1 more service. Even if I subscribed to all of them, it passed the point where it’s annoying to check one by one where I can find what I want to watch. It’s time for a meta service in front of all the others, but there’s no way this is coming in the 5 years. At some point, Netflix was simpler than piracy. Now piracy is simple again.
Re:I'm Done with Google by spopejoy on Thursday December 29, 2022 @11:59PM (#34181973)
Not a plug, but roku's search makes finding a stream incredibly easy. More than once I've signed up for a sub on the spot because it had what I was looking for.

Not a plug because there are many things to dislike about roku, above all the ads on the homescreen. But that search ... there's nothing else like it.

Re:I'm Done with Google by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @10:24AM (#34149420)
I don't buy games from online unless there's no other alternative and I don't care. Usually it's some small, silly game I'm playing with my gf. But for everything _I_ want, it's physical medium, only. If sony or nintendo ever release a console that has no ability to use physical media, I will not purchase it. I say this because I believe nintendo has a version of the switch that has no ability to play physical media. I'm ok with different versions like that, I'm not ok with not being able to purchase a version that uses physical media.

Same with music, I have a huge music collection. A lot of them are pirated, many of them are FLAC rips from physical discs.

The _ONE_ exception I have to this is movies on Amazon. I'm not a huge movie/television guy but I _DO_ consume most of that type of media via Amazon Prime and Netflix. If something goes away I generally don't care, and if I _DO_ care I either already have physical copies or I know I can purchase them. So I will sometimes purchase this type of media on Amazon because I find the convenience acceptable considering the risk. Sometimes I'll repurchase on Amazon for things I physically own just for the convenience of it.

---

But yeah, pirating is going to become rampant again due to the behavior of these companies. I certainly have no qualms about doing it.

Generally speaking, if I want to watch a show and it's been pulled off of netflix or prime for some other service (HBO, CBS, etc) I just pirate it and move on.

I haven't watched past the last season of Survivor that's available on Amazon because I don't care enough to pirate it, but when I do decide I want to watch through the rest of it, that's how I'll consume it.

And fuck'em. You can't even _BUY_ the latest seasons on Amazon (my gf was purchasing them as she watched through them until they stopped offering it at all).

You don't want my money, then you don't want my money.

Re:I'm Done with Google by SergeAx on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:06PM (#34155099)
I do not keep files on my devices, unless they are in the queue for viewing/reading/listening. I know that any time I need anything - it is couple of clicks away on some torrent site. I will need to setup a torrent proxy some day if I decide to move to jurisdiction where ISPs are actively spying on their customers on using torrents (I heard a thing or two about Germany, for example). I am okay with that, as I am okay now with having couple of personal VPN exit nodes in countries where services want you to have a local IP address. Internet fragmentation is a fact, but not a very bothersome yet.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:22PM (#34155835)
Which country/ISP are you? The surveillance problem with ISPs became bad enough that I tunnel every single packet from every home device through a VPS using WireGuard now, and that solved it. None of the home devices need to know anything about WireGuard, just the router.
Re:I'm Done with Google by SergeAx on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:26PM (#34155871)
I was in Russia and Turkey, now in Serbia.
Re:I'm Done with Google by fsflover on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:30AM (#34159526)
Sounds overly complicated. I prefer torrenting on I2P instead: https://geti2p.net.
Re:I'm Done with Google by usui on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:32AM (#34159539)
I don't feel comfortable participating with this particular p2p network. I'd rather be my own custodian.