News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by poszlem on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:34AM (#33799801)
I am both happy to hear BBC talking about this, and also can't help but feel like they (alongside with the rest of MSM) are the main source of that problem (even bigger than social media, as they shape what social media landscape looks like).

We just went through the most censorious (and self-censorship inducing) few years in my living memory (I am almost 40), where people who we "asking questions" were called all kind of names by all kind of news outlets.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by djaychela on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:43AM (#33799892)
I'd disagree that the BBC is more responsible for a backlash than social media is. I'd suggest that it's social media that shapes the wider media landscape (particularly in recent years twitter), not the other way round.

There's also a huge difference between "just asking questions" and "just asking questions" - and there are a huge number of people who are doing so in a bad-faith manner.

All IMO, of course.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by mantas on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:46AM (#33799906)
A good chunk of social media is mainstream media, discussions around mainstream articles or driven by people working in mainstream media.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by 543g43g43 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:46PM (#33806520)
I'd rather live in a world where raising certain questions is seen as "bad faith", than a world where the experts have decided that certain topics are "too important" to be discussed.

Also - if your point of view is threatened by people just asking questions, then you really should think some more.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by kryogen1c on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @06:08PM (#33809329)
> There's also a huge difference between "just asking questions" and "just asking questions"

What is that?

Let's pretend I'm a card carrying jackboot wearing nazi. What question could I just ask, in bad faith? How come black people commit more crime? How come more black people are in prison?

Those are actually fantastic questions that, seriously considered, could lead to some significant societal change.

I can't think of an instance where the good/bad faith of the asker has any bearing on the question.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:52PM (#33810670)
> I can't think of an instance where the good/bad faith of the asker has any bearing on the question.

It often shows up more clearly in the follow-up questions. "But doesn't that mean that..."

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by jakopo87 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @10:29AM (#33817521)
From the Rational Wiki[0]:

"Just asking questions (also known as JAQing off) is a way of attempting to make wild accusations acceptable (and hopefully not legally actionable) by framing them as questions rather than statements. It shifts the burden of proof to one's opponent; rather than laboriously having to prove that all politicians are reptoid scum, one can pull out one single odd piece of evidence and force the opponent to explain why the evidence is wrong."

I think it's about this.

[0] https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Just_asking_questions

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by phpisthebest on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:44AM (#33799899)
Social Media is the root cause, the problem is Social media became the "Source of news" for most "journalists" who lazily just regurgitate the same info, using the same "sources" of twitter, facebook, etc.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by thefounder on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:15AM (#33800214)
I highly doubt that. How did social media increase self censorship in the media?
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by nine_k on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:39AM (#33800522)
Social media is a harassing tool, and can be a pretty blunt and heavy one (see "cancel culture").

In 1920, a newspaper publication or a public speech needed to be really outrageously beyond the frames of the Overton window to end up in mass protests, boycotts, etc. It took a serious effort to coordinate the outrage, so it only happened when people felt really deeply about it.

In 2020, with social media, the cost of spreading the outrage is nearly zero: a retweet or a repost, maybe with some a few words of an inflammatory comment added on the top. But with social graphs being what they are (highly connected via a number of popular "influencer" accounts), any bit of outrage has a good chance to spread quickly and widely.

The outrage can defend itself by directing the outrage at detractors and doubters, so attempts to actively stop it can make one a victim of it; the cost of spreading outrage, and the cost of ignoring outrage, is much lower that the cost of trying to calm it down, and / or to call to reason over emotions.

It does not help that any moderately public figure, especially a journalist, has to have social media presence, because it's such a powerful tool to spread their own publicity, influence, and agenda.

Freer information flows usually change societies. Invention of writing changed ancient societies profoundly. Invention of the printing press and movable type in Europe changed Europe drastically. The internet and social media are changing our societies seriously, as we speak. There's no way back to the pre-Internet state of society.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Robotbeat on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:47AM (#33800654)
This is a very astute observation. It’s also only really possible with centralized social media, not decentralized/federated.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by buran77 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:54AM (#33801558)
Decentralization has some advantages but it also enforces bubbles further. My corner of social media will have no overlap whatsoever with your corner and they drift further and further apart.

The only real solution for this is education, teaching people to think, to listen, to evaluate the quality of their sources of information, to draw their own conclusions, and so on. It's not perfect but the alternatives are closer to simple AI trained on a very limited and one sided dataset.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Robotbeat on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:46PM (#33812459)
One idea that has stuck with me: maybe polarization isn’t caused by bubbles but actually due to being exposed to the “other side”?
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by tablespoon on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:54AM (#33802499)
>> In 2020, with social media, the cost of spreading the outrage is nearly zero: a retweet or a repost, maybe with some a few words of an inflammatory comment added on the top. But with social graphs being what they are (highly connected via a number of popular "influencer" accounts), any bit of outrage has a good chance to spread quickly and widely.

> This is a very astute observation. It’s also only really possible with centralized social media, not decentralized/federated.

I'm not so sure. Can you explain why you think that? The GP describe a social problem, while the difference between "centralized" and "federated" is a technical implementation difference. If you can "retweet" a post from a federated instance, then I don't see any barriers to this kind of emergent social behavior.

Federation is a solution to a set of very specific problems, it's not a panacea.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by dls2016 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:31AM (#33803170)
> In 1920, a newspaper publication or a public speech needed to be really outrageously beyond the frames of the Overton window to end up in mass protests, boycotts, etc. It took a serious effort to coordinate the outrage, so it only happened when people felt really deeply about it.

Uhm, are you familiar with the material Henry Ford was publishing in 1920? Specifically to increase sales?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_International_Jew

Perhaps this wasn't "beyond the frames of the Overton window" at the time, I don't know. But cancel culture ain't all bad!

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by philippejara on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:46PM (#33804487)
Surely if that was being used to specifically increase sales an analogue of cancel culture wouldn't really do anything since the zeitgeist held that opinion somewhat, if it was enough to drive up sales for a company of ford's size.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by phpisthebest on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:19AM (#33800254)
I think you misunderstood the comment, the self censorship is in the wider public not the media, the media via social media is the cause of the censorship

The chilling effect is that the "traditional" media see something on social media, say a "racist" post (something they deem to be racist anyway) of some normal person, then amplifies triggering wide scale harassment, and "canceling" of the person.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by thefounder on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:23AM (#33800302)
The real issue is not having laws to prevent firing someone for writing political incorrect stuff on social media not that mainstream media amplifies whatever someone posts on social media.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by nine_k on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:46AM (#33800641)
Such laws, if existed, would be of limited help. Would you enjoy to continue working when your boss badly wants to fire you, and your colleagues badly want to have you fired, but they can't by the law? How soon would you leave by yourself? Being fired usually at least involves some severance pay.

These laws could help though if it's just your boss who wants to fire you, but most of your colleagues would like to support you, even if silently.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by trention on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:52AM (#33800724)
>Would you enjoy to continue working when your boss badly wants to fire you, and your colleagues badly want to have you fired, but they can't by the law? How soon would you leave by yourself? Being fired usually at least involves some severance pay.

Most (all?) of continental Europe actually has such laws, which is why you don't hear about american style firings here. So, your logic has been tested in practice and found out to be wrong.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by 6510 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:34AM (#33801255)
If you cant have something you don't have to want it either. It's irrational and a waste of time to want to see someone fired or to want to fire someone if it's not going to happen.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by nine_k on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:18AM (#33801883)
There are always ways to make someone's employment feel miserable while staying on completely legal ground. If a boss wants someone fired but can't fire, the boss (and worse yet, coworkers) can "help" the person make the right decision and start looking for a new opportunity.

This can give the victim some valuable paid time though.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by thefounder on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:40PM (#33804366)
>> Would you enjoy to continue working when your boss badly wants to fire you

Chances are the boss is just doing what's political correct too due the pressure put by various groups not what he/she badly wants.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by xbar on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:20AM (#33800268)
"Media" is largely Twitter-driven due to journalism funding collapse. And media lives in fear that Twitter will take a dim view of some story.

I thought this was a foregone conclusion.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by naasking on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:18AM (#33800246)
Social media virality started creating juicy headlines in mainstream media.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by 543g43g43 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:46PM (#33806530)
It's so true. The only people sad about Twitter's current state, are the journalists who (I assume) felt powerful and knowledgable thanks to constant scrolling.
[dead]
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by dang on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:46PM (#33819722)
Can you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamewar comments? You've been doing it repeatedly, unfortunately.

It also looks like you've been using HN primarily for ideological battle, and that's a line at which we ban accounts, so please stop doing that.

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by eulgro on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:35AM (#33800469)
I use uBlacklist to highlight results for good websites like reddit, stackoverflow, or official documentation. It also blocks hundreds of SEO websites and low quality stuff (quora, geeksforgeeks, clones of stackoverflow). You can even block stuff by title, like "\d+ (best|essential|...).*". Sometimes a get 2 results per page as a result of this.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by ambicapter on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:35AM (#33800470)
Probably because "asking questions" or "just asking questions" is a known bad-faith tactic https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=JAQing%20off
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by tiahura on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:38AM (#33800507)
Socrates deserved to die.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by scandox on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:52AM (#33800733)
Well as Ngozi Adichie says we must reestablish good faith as the default position. If we jettison good faith and always assume bad faith then indeed asking questions becomes impossible. But I'm sure that's not what people want.

She does seem to acknowledge that social media is not the best place for.good faith debate.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by trention on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:54AM (#33800755)
It's bad faith when applied to a scientifically established, factual claims. Not when applied to the quasi-religious civil morality of the modern left.

"I'm just asking questions about why the Earth is round" is bad-faith.

"Im just asking questions about why we shouldn't implement Operation Wetback 2023 and forcefully deport all illegals, even if that costs a trillion dollars and involves tremendous amounts of violence" is not.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Kye on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:59AM (#33800830)
>> "Not when applied to the quasi-religious civil morality of the modern left."

You could put this sentence in a museum. A real cultural artifact. It's nonsense, but very much worth preserving as a reflection of the rhetoric of our times.

edit: They can file it in the gallery of things people once considered true.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by trention on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:01AM (#33800860)
The truth always seems like nonsense to those that hate it and/or stand to lose by it breaking free.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by dbfx on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:33AM (#33803202)
Urban dictionary is hardly a good enough source to do the heavy lifting you're trying to use it for.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by 543g43g43 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:47PM (#33806536)
I'd rather live in a world where raising certain questions is seen as "bad faith", than a world where the experts have decided that certain topics are "too important" to be discussed.

Also - if your point of view is threatened by people just asking questions, then you really should think some more.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by curtisblaine on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @04:57PM (#33808407)
It's a bit too easy to avoid all questions on the grounds that some people might be asking them in bad faith, though.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by lapcat on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:36AM (#33800481)
The article talks about Salman Rushdie. The MSM didn't put a fatwa on Rushdie, and then stab him nearly to death. That was ultra-religious conservatives. Ultra-religious conservatives are also responsible for much of the censorship in the United States, especially in schools, refusing to allow kids to read certain books or be taught certain subjects.

Getting "called all kind of names" is not censorship, it's just criticism. That's actually an exercise of free speech by the name callers, don't you think?

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by HPsquared on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:48AM (#33800686)
It was indeed mainstream in Iran though. I mean, the fatwa was issued by the Supreme Leader - can hardly get more mainstream than that.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Jarmsy on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:39PM (#33804345)
I'm guessing Rushdie is the only specific case referred to in the article because they can assume that the vast majority of their audience will consider what happened to him abhorrent.

However, they then slip into much more general terms, as though by induction any writers facing any kind of social consequences for expressing their bigoted views is the same as the fatwa.

That they neglect entirely to make any mention of Adichie's own case seems disingenuous.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by robomartin on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:33AM (#33812740)
> ultra-religious conservatives

As an atheist I have to object to this comment.

There's a vast difference between what you call "ultra-religious" across cultures and religions. For example, I have Born Again Christian friends who never miss an opportunity to try to bring me out of the dark side. I also have "ultra religious" Jewish friends. In both cases some of the nicest people you will ever meet.

We have to be careful not to classify-and-vilify. Every single one of us could easily fit into a classification worth of some level of vilification. That only serves to create further division and friction and does not make for a better society.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by lapcat on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:03AM (#33813980)
Notice that I said "ultra-religious conservatives" and not "ultra-religious people". It's both a religious term and a political term. It describes people who bring their religion in an overt way into a certain brand of politics.

There are a lot of religious people who mainly keep religion and politics separate. And there are a lot of religious people — especially outside the United States — whose religion inspires them into more left-wing politics.

In any case, I said nothing about "nice people" and "non-nice people". But that's always a spectrum anyway. People are complex. They can be super nice to some groups of people and super mean to other groups of people.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by robomartin on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:48PM (#33820719)
> ultra-religious conservatives

I noted that. Same objection. Conservatives are not evil. Democrats are not evil. The ideological extremes in these schools of thought are represented by a very small minority, just like the ideological extremes in any religion.

We need to get away from hating people by attaching labels to them. The vast majority of Trump and Biden voters are the same people, with the same problems in life and the same dreams and hopes. The only people who work hard to divide us are the politicians. They need you to hate the other side and vote for them. They need division, not unity. By characterizing people with labels such as "ultra religions conservatives" (and equivalent labels on the other side) and then applying blanket negative qualities to entire groups labeled this way all we do is provide fuel for politicians to divide us further.

This, in my opinion, is one of the most egregious negative results of social media. It has provided political masterminds with the tools necessary to divide the population with amazing granularity and drive votes based on the hundreds, if not thousands, of categories they are able to provide.

While all of this happens we lose sight of what really matters. Politicians have been talking about fixing healthcare, education, jobs, etc. for a century, and here we are. If they actually were in the business of getting things done (rather than gathering votes) none of these issues would exist today. That's the great lie. That's what people need to wake-up to. We divide. They win. They do none of the things we all care about and need them to actually get done.

Do not label, subgroup and vilify people. This is unfair and inaccurate. It is no different from applying the average to an entire population, which sounds great and yet it is one of the worst mistakes (or lies) anyone could make in statistics.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by lapcat on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:10PM (#33821099)
I find it very ironic that in a discussion about self-censorship — remember, that was the original topic? — you want me to censor my usage of any labels to describe people.

So, what are we supposed to say? There's a problem, involving some people, and... [censored] that's all I can say.

[Edit:] LOL I just read one of your other comments in this thread:

> And, yes, I am sorry to say, the blood is entirely, 100% on the hands of the ideological left.

Wow, hypocrisy much? Incredible. What happened to "We need to get away from hating people by attaching labels to them", "The only people who work hard to divide us are the politicians", and "Do not label, subgroup and vilify people"? SMH.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by robomartin on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:35PM (#33821491)
> you want me to censor my usage of any labels to describe people

You misunderstand. I am saying that applying labels to groups AND THEN using those labels to broad-brush is wrong.

Are all ultra-religious Muslims terrorists? No! Of course not! Yet, in some circles that very association was created. Can a Muslim be deeply religious and not be labeled a terrorist? Well, in my world, yes, absolutely. And I am an atheist. I don't agree with any religion at all. However, I am not going to take that to the deep dark level of labeling people and then characterize the entire group in various negative ways.

I am not asking you to self-censor. You can say whatever you want. More importantly, you need to understand that the reason people self-sensor is because of the very real threat of violence, professional and financial ruin that has been created over the last decade or so. That is not a all what is happening here. You can say whatever you want. I don't care and I will not hurt your in any way for it. Unlike others on HN, I never downvote someone with whom I have a disagreement. I am, however, pointing out that applying these labels in such ways is not fair or even accurate, just like applying the average to the entire population often leads to seriously flawed conclusions.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by RickJWagner on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:59PM (#33810727)
Yes, exactly.

Especially in some work settings, where 'approved' thought is rewarded and 'discouraged' thought is punished.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, you can find it in places like Reddit. Post something nice about a politician from one side of the political aisle. Then post something nice about a politician from the other side. You'll see pretty quickly what it's about.