News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by nine_k on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:39AM (#33800522)
Social media is a harassing tool, and can be a pretty blunt and heavy one (see "cancel culture").

In 1920, a newspaper publication or a public speech needed to be really outrageously beyond the frames of the Overton window to end up in mass protests, boycotts, etc. It took a serious effort to coordinate the outrage, so it only happened when people felt really deeply about it.

In 2020, with social media, the cost of spreading the outrage is nearly zero: a retweet or a repost, maybe with some a few words of an inflammatory comment added on the top. But with social graphs being what they are (highly connected via a number of popular "influencer" accounts), any bit of outrage has a good chance to spread quickly and widely.

The outrage can defend itself by directing the outrage at detractors and doubters, so attempts to actively stop it can make one a victim of it; the cost of spreading outrage, and the cost of ignoring outrage, is much lower that the cost of trying to calm it down, and / or to call to reason over emotions.

It does not help that any moderately public figure, especially a journalist, has to have social media presence, because it's such a powerful tool to spread their own publicity, influence, and agenda.

Freer information flows usually change societies. Invention of writing changed ancient societies profoundly. Invention of the printing press and movable type in Europe changed Europe drastically. The internet and social media are changing our societies seriously, as we speak. There's no way back to the pre-Internet state of society.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Robotbeat on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:47AM (#33800654)
This is a very astute observation. It’s also only really possible with centralized social media, not decentralized/federated.
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by buran77 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:54AM (#33801558)
Decentralization has some advantages but it also enforces bubbles further. My corner of social media will have no overlap whatsoever with your corner and they drift further and further apart.

The only real solution for this is education, teaching people to think, to listen, to evaluate the quality of their sources of information, to draw their own conclusions, and so on. It's not perfect but the alternatives are closer to simple AI trained on a very limited and one sided dataset.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by Robotbeat on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:46PM (#33812459)
One idea that has stuck with me: maybe polarization isn’t caused by bubbles but actually due to being exposed to the “other side”?
Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by tablespoon on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:54AM (#33802499)
>> In 2020, with social media, the cost of spreading the outrage is nearly zero: a retweet or a repost, maybe with some a few words of an inflammatory comment added on the top. But with social graphs being what they are (highly connected via a number of popular "influencer" accounts), any bit of outrage has a good chance to spread quickly and widely.

> This is a very astute observation. It’s also only really possible with centralized social media, not decentralized/federated.

I'm not so sure. Can you explain why you think that? The GP describe a social problem, while the difference between "centralized" and "federated" is a technical implementation difference. If you can "retweet" a post from a federated instance, then I don't see any barriers to this kind of emergent social behavior.

Federation is a solution to a set of very specific problems, it's not a panacea.

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by dls2016 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:31AM (#33803170)
> In 1920, a newspaper publication or a public speech needed to be really outrageously beyond the frames of the Overton window to end up in mass protests, boycotts, etc. It took a serious effort to coordinate the outrage, so it only happened when people felt really deeply about it.

Uhm, are you familiar with the material Henry Ford was publishing in 1920? Specifically to increase sales?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_International_Jew

Perhaps this wasn't "beyond the frames of the Overton window" at the time, I don't know. But cancel culture ain't all bad!

Re:Author warns about 'epidemic of self-censorship' by philippejara on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:46PM (#33804487)
Surely if that was being used to specifically increase sales an analogue of cancel culture wouldn't really do anything since the zeitgeist held that opinion somewhat, if it was enough to drive up sales for a company of ford's size.