News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by badpun on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:00AM (#33606507)
What's so bad about American dealerships? Here in Europe I've never heard anyone complain about them. They just provide a service - they have cars available to test drive and have a real person to talk to during the purchase. Sure, the owners make profit, but they DO provide value for the customer and they're at mercy of the car company, which means, in bad economic times, they can get squeezed pretty hard. How is it different in the US?
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by jakewins on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:08AM (#33606572)
I’ve bought vehicles at both US and EU dealerships; the EU sales process was; they showed me the vehicle I had seen on their website, we drove the car, then we haggled a bit and signed contracts. US sales process was much more akin to how I imagine time share sales scams work - when you think you’re done, the gauntlet of high pressure multiple-rooms-with-increasingly-“senior”-managers has just started.

It took nearly two hours of people telling me I was an idiot for not taking the extended leather steering wheel warranty etc before getting out of there.

Both of these experiences were at official Hyundai dealerships.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by badpun on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:30AM (#33606725)
Interesting. I've only bought car in EU (in Mitsubishi dealership in Poland) and it was BY FAR the best customer service I've received in my life. The salesman was thoughtful, listened to me carefully, knew the product well, didn't try to push anything on me. It was pure pleasure. I was kind of sad that one has to spend $15k in order to warrant a customer experience this good.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by CubicsRube on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:28AM (#33607883)
Hyundai dealership in Norway: Came to check the car in person and to ask couple of questions. Without any pressure dealer asked me if I wanted to take it for a ride. I agreed reluctantly, expecting that he will be joining. Nope, he just handed me the keys and asked to take a picture of my driving license. I loved the experience so much I ended up buying the car on the spot.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:48AM (#33608482)
> expecting that he will be joining. Nope, he just handed me the keys and asked to take a picture of my driving license

To be fair, this was my experience buying a Subaru in Wyoming. The paperwork was then signed, I pushed back on one or two fee line items, they were removed with apologies and I was offered a beer.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by bliteben on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:23AM (#33608818)
I bought a new subaru in wyoming with a personal check and my address registered to general delivery with a similar experience. I was so surprised they didn’t make me get a cashiers check or verify the check.

I did later get screwed by the dealership when I was tired of doing my own maintenance after having replaced the timing belt on my truck and let the wife take it in for service and they literally replaced every fluid in the vehicle including brake fluid on a 2 year old vehicle, a $900 service.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by n65463f23_4 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:15AM (#33611068)
in my experience almost all dealers take personal checks, they can get the car or money back from you pretty easily if there is a problem with the check
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by bliteben on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:32PM (#33613077)
little harder when I had no address, or employer they could look up
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mehrdada on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:50AM (#33607205)
I have only experienced the US version firsthand, but hearing from EU friends, it seems the EU prices are more-or-less set in stone and the haggling potential in the US can get you a better deal if you are savvy and patient (and then say no at every “value-add”).

Of course that comes at the cost of customer experience.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by oblio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:49AM (#33607645)
The rule of thumb is that you can get a lot of stuff cheaper in the US, if you know what you're doing.

In Europe discounts are much lower, and prices are a lot more set in stone.

However, the key caveat here is that most people don't know what they're doing.

So in the US 80% of the population is robbed so that the 20% can take advantage.

In Europe everyone gets a worse deal, but it's never going to be super bad.

Pick your poison :-)

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mysterydip on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:27AM (#33607880)
I was sitting at a table at a dealership in process of buying a car and overheard this at the table next to me:

"What's the best price you can give me?"

"Sir, we advertise our lowest prices up front so you don't have any pressure to haggle."

"You can do better than that price."

"... Let me see what I can do."

I believe he got a grand knocked off when it was all said and done.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wil421 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:22AM (#33608249)
There are 2 types of dealers in the US. Lowest price advertised volume dealers who will never give you the advertised prices because you’d have to be a Veteran/new College grad/AARP member and use their shitty financing just to qualify.

The other dealers focus a little more on the experience and will haggle a bit with you. They usually don’t use high pressure tactics but won’t give you the lowest price.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by orangepurple on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:24AM (#33609484)
I called 15 dealerships asking about their best price out the door "RIGHT NOW" for specific VIN numbers they had on the lot and only had to yell at one salesperson. Once I got dollar figures, at each generation of the binary search I would call and ask if they could beat the lowest price of the prior generation. In the end I paid well under MSRP for that particular trim level and model.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by prisoner655321 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:45AM (#33609710)
I wish I had your patience, but I just don't. I find the entire process so insulting to my time and intelligence that I refuse to participate, especially after spending 6 hours -- 6! -- buying a specific EV in the Bay Area.

I also find the personalities of used car salesmen to be so grating that I'd rather do it all over email.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by orangepurple on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:40AM (#33611459)
I did everything over the phone and REFUSED to come in until we had a firm price negotiated
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wil421 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:46AM (#33621178)
Like the other poster said you can deal completely online/over the phone with the dealers internet sales team. I called around for my wife’s car but they would only come down $500 so we went with the original dealer to avoid wasting time.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by dangerface on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:18AM (#33607829)
> it seems the EU prices are more-or-less set in stone

Haggling is defiantly a thing in the UK you wouldn't buy a car for sticker price.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Moissanite on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:37AM (#33607951)
Prior to 2020 this was true; I think I got around 13% off my last new car. However since the pandemic shortages and with manufacturing delays, there is much less flexibility as the dealerships know the cars are going to sell either way. When I went to test drive a car recently I saw a couple getting a flat denial on any discount even after attempting to haggle.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by graderjs on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:20AM (#33608231)
Maybe they were actors employed by the store to discourage haggling among other customers by providing negative social proof
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by orangepurple on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:26AM (#33609502)
Those are next level psychological operations
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mehrdada on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:12PM (#33613552)
COVID era supply was impacted and demand was high. US car dealers routinely sold cars way above MSRP too.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by graderjs on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:19AM (#33608227)
Car in the UK reminded me of this:

https://m.lingscars.com/

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by RugnirViking on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:16AM (#33610132)
the mobile version isn't as good as the desktop one :)

https://www.lingscars.com/

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by graderjs on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @10:34AM (#33624767)
Totes agree, I thought it was worth a look too, tho
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wil421 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:16AM (#33608204)
I’ve bought 4 US cars (not by choice!) in the past 5 years and every single time it’s like your EU experience. 3 of the times I just shut the finance guy down immediately about the warranty crap. I already know the exact car plus options I want and how many other dealerships in the East Coast have them.

Ordering a BMW was an even more pleasant experience and haggling for 6% off was easier than when I did it with my Jeeps.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by gryfft on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:09AM (#33608697)
> I've bought four cars

> I just shut the finance guy down immediately

> Ordering a BMW

These facts paint a pretty obvious picture of why car buying is a much more pleasant experience for you than most: you have experience, you have options, you don't have a lot of patience, and you are willing to loudly signal those things "immediately," leaving no metaphorical door open for a metaphorical foot to slide into.

If someone else is reading this it's worth taking into account when you deal with a higher ticket item than you usually would: in those situations, being polite is a huge disadvantage and a good salesperson will take a mile for every micrometer you give them.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wil421 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:50AM (#33621204)
My wife got the BMW and I got 2 Jeep Grand Cherokees. I also helped buy a Toyota. I think the Jeep guy played more games but it was still less than 1 hour from test drive to price agreement.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by spywaregorilla on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:45AM (#33609054)
Ah but you're doing it backwards. Signal that you're a sucker for big insurance packages and they'll lower the price of the vehicle to ensure they get that juicy warranty deal from you. Only then do you change your mind and decide that you don't actually need it.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by xwdv on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:46AM (#33609718)
This doesn’t work because they just go back and change the price to the original higher MSRP.

What you have to do is agree to financing (with no prepayment penalties) in exchange for a discount, and then, before you get the first bill you pay the car off in full.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by rrauenza on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:19AM (#33610171)
Isn’t this also a win/win ? The dealer still gets their financing kickback?
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by xwdv on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:26AM (#33611241)
Nope if you do it too early they don’t qualify.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wil421 on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @05:51AM (#33621217)
No the loan has a set time you have to meet before the dealer can get their kickback. Usually 6 months.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by cm42 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:14AM (#33608740)
In my early 20's, I briefly considered getting a new car, or maybe leasing.

Insurance would have been more than the monthly car payment, and when I expressed that $400/mo wasn't awful, but $1,000/mo for a car was a non-starter, the guy was seriously like "Well, do you want to eat food, or have a car (with lighted cup holders) to get to work?" and "If you can't afford rent, you can sleep in the car!"

That's still one of the dumbest conversations I've ever had.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by thehappypm on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:16AM (#33609404)
Not to shill, but this is why I buy at Carmax. Prices are as listed, that’s the end of it.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by tablespoon on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:43AM (#33610548)
> US sales process was; they showed me the vehicle I had seen on their website, we drove the car, then we haggled a bit and signed contracts. US sales process was much more akin to how I imagine time share sales scams work - when you think you’re done, the gauntlet of high pressure multiple-rooms-with-increasingly-“senior”-managers has just started.

So basically: it's a culture thing. High pressure tactics are entrenched on the sales culture side, and the customer culture has gotten used to tolerating them.

As an aside, IIRC, someone once told me that Japanese makeup is superior to and cheaper than Western makeup, because Japanese customers are picky and won't put up with less.

The concept of dealerships makes some sense to me: an individual retail customer has zero leverage with a mass market manufacturer, but they'll have more leverage with a smaller dealer, and the dealer will have more leverage with the manufacturer because they're buying far more than a single person. Though the actual implementation leaves a lot to be desired.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mym1990 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:14AM (#33606617)
American dealerships(only ones I’ve dealt with) make a lot of their money on the auxiliary purchases, so they keep you in rooms, passing you around managers to try to get you to buy these things(extended warranties, extra options, tire changes, yadda yadda). They are also pretty difficult to negotiate with.

The service they offer is convenience and possibly peace of mind(over an owner sale), but they sure do take an arm and a leg for it.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by propogandist on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:46AM (#33608460)
For those in the US considering purchasing the manufacturer warranty coverage (“bumper to bumper”), you can often purchase the same coverage from a different dealer from the one selling the car (whoever offers the best price).

Just call a dealers finance department and find out if they sell standalone warranty and get a quote (you may need to provide a sample VIN). Make sure they are quoting the official manufacturer warranty coverage (new car) vs some BS third party warranty.

If you do this in advance you can fight off the finance guy easily and (more often) get them to price match to keep your business. This method has saved me thousands.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mym1990 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:54PM (#33616966)
Yes, having competitive alternatives in hand is a great bargaining chip, and always giving yourself the option to just get up and walk away. Problem is people get to the dealership and fall in love with the car and all sense goes out the metaphorical window.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by propogandist on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:10PM (#33617110)
true, they will definitely try FOMO tricks to get the sale instantly, and the above assumes there is research prior to going in and a desire to save $.

knowing that warranty can be purchased separately for brand itself is a great way to beat up the finance guy, as that may be where they expect to make the bulk of their profit (although nowadays it may be “market adjustment” and other BS fees)

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by elromulous on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:14AM (#33606619)
Whether they provide value is kind of irrelevant, because one (at least in the US) _has_ to go through them. Is their markup equal to the value they provide? We'll never know, because we can't choose to not go through them.

If I want to place an order for a vehicle (not buy one off their lot), the dealer does nothing but still makes a cut.

Not to mention, the majority of folks selling cars (even new cars) are some of the slimiest you'll meet. They are masters of manipulation.

This short NPR piece provides more information: https://www.npr.org/2022/11/09/1135633742/economists-hate-ca...

P.s. example of manipulation: some years back I bought a used Honda Civic. The 4th person I got passed to made sure to tell me "the civic is the most stolen car in the US", while trying to sell me on some aftermarket alarm system. I of course knew this was an intentionally misleading statistic, but I'm sure many folks could fall for it.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by vladvasiliu on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:28AM (#33606709)
> Whether they provide value is kind of irrelevant, because one (at least in the US) _has_ to go through them. Is their markup equal to the value they provide? We'll never know, because we can't choose to not go through them.

> If I want to place an order for a vehicle (not buy one off their lot), the dealer does nothing but still makes a cut.

I'm pretty sure this is the same in Europe, or at least in France. Even if I wanted to buy a local make, say a Renault, I don't know how I'd go about getting in touch with the manufacturer directly instead of going through a dealership.

Now I've never actually bought a new car, only motorcycles. And even though it's the same process (I don't think I can order a Honda nor a BMW "direct"), the dealerships didn't try to make me buy useless options.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ilyt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:56AM (#33606870)
>I'm pretty sure this is the same in Europe, or at least in France. Even if I wanted to buy a local make, say a Renault, I don't know how I'd go about getting in touch with the manufacturer directly instead of going through a dealership.

The difference is that manufacturer-owner dealership is basically not an option in US.

My local Toyota dealership is owned by Toyota. Some other ones are just "licensed" to be their official dealerships, so not owned by Toyota.

In US the "licensed" one can decide "well, the car is rare" (and in pandemic that was every car), here is extra 10-20% dealer markup just because we can. In EU, customer would just go to official Toyota one that doesn't do shit like that

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wongarsu on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:15AM (#33609385)
I'm pretty sure you can buy both Volkswagen and BMW direct if you go through their website. Honda meanwhile seems to refer you to a dealership.

Volkswagen even offers you the option to fetch your vehicle from their factory in Wolfsburg (tour included, drinks cost extra) instead of having it delivered.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by natch on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:22AM (#33607019)
> _has_ to go through them

Strong wording for something that is not true. You can bypass them by getting a Tesla.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by darkwater on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:23AM (#33607027)
> Whether they provide value is kind of irrelevant, because one (at least in the US) _has_ to go through them. Is their markup equal to the value they provide? We'll never know, because we can't choose to not go through them.

To me this is a bogus argument because with Tesla you don't have the other option. Well, you kind have it but Tesla showrooms/service centers are usually a shitty experience in terms of "a salesman caring for you". Anyway, I'm from Europe and I guess that the car dealership experience is pretty different (I know the US ones just by movies and Monkey Island)

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by elromulous on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:29AM (#33611288)
Sure, you don't have any other option, but it's their product anyway. You're already saying you want something from them.

Also, my experience at Tesla dealerships has been the best of any dealership (and keep in mind I'm not a musk apologist (quite the opposite), nor own or plan to own a Tesla). They literally give you the keys and let you drive around by yourself, no questions asked. The experience is lower stress than buying a pair of shoes.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by msravi on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:37AM (#33606761)
Maybe. But why are there laws that prohibit companies from selling directly to customers?
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by rgmerk on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:14AM (#33606976)
I haven’t found a good, well-referenced article on this topic, but the short version seems to be lobbying of state governments by car dealers back in the 1930s, and continued lobbying since.

Incumbent car manufacturers had no particular incentive to upset the applecart, but Tesla had the opportunity to see how insane it was.

Interestingly, BYD has chosen a direct to consumer model here in Australia (if you haven’t heard of them, you soon will). Mercedes has now switched to an agency pricing model where the dealers sell on commission and don’t own the cars, so Mercedes can legally control the retail price.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:53AM (#33608535)
> why are there laws that prohibit companies from selling directly to customers?

Dealerships were in state while manufacturers concentrated in Michigan. And states didn’t want to let manufacturers sell a car and then stop offering servicing in state.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by pjc50 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:57AM (#33608583)
Used car dealers are an important part of the political donor base.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by klabb3 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:09PM (#33612782)
The first time I realized I have to pay sales tax if I sell a used car in the US, big wtf moment. Dealerships don't. I think. A sane tax framework avoids re-taxing products on the second hand market.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:13AM (#33606607)
They are middlemen adding very limited value. It's not nothing; but maybe also not the thousands of dollars of a cut that they take. The fact that they need protectionist measures like state legislation to prevent competition that simply cuts out the middle man, kind of proves that. It's more of a tax than a value add.

Tesla organizes test drives too. And you can bring your Tesla in for maintenance (well not in these states obviously). So, it's not like you don't get any service.

It's the protectionism that is bad. Without it, more manufacturers would cut out the middle man and sell directly. Because why give that big of a cut to a middle man you don't need?

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ralph84 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:10AM (#33606590)
In general dealers are relentless in maximizing their profit on each deal and turn the negotiation into an all-day grind of dealing with overpriced unnecessary add-ons and inflated financing rates. Dealer employees are not employed by the OEM so they don’t care how much damage they do to the OEM’s brand with their tactics.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by lupire on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:19PM (#33618020)
If you don't have a firm offer via email before you walk in, you are doing it wrong.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by roenxi on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:48AM (#33606818)
Is the idea of making a car then selling it directly to someone who wants it so strange?

There is some serious pretzel-thinking going on here somewhere in the halls of power (pretzled, one assumes, by careful application of money). The idea that there needs to be a middle-man is weird. The people who want one less layer of abstraction don't need to justify themselves, the dealers have to be doing a lot more than being not-so-bad to justify a mandatory role in the process.

> "The big achievement, instead, was making direct-to-consumer car sales possible."

This isn't the biggest problem America faces, but the idea of a business needing to "innovate" to sell its product to consumers has to be the most unAmerican sentences I've read in an article. It is hard to get a more petty strike in against capitalism.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ilyt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:57AM (#33606876)
> It is hard to get a more petty strike in against capitalism.

What capitalism ? The dealer problem is precisely because in the past dealerships negotiated for a laws that stops free market from happening

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Blahah on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:27AM (#33607474)
because resource inequality, unchecked, creates corruption
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by notpushkin on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:26AM (#33608862)
That's not true. Corrupt government creates corruption.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by mftrhu on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:43PM (#33613197)
So, corruption creates corruption?
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ilyt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:52AM (#33606832)
> What's so bad about American dealerships?

Here (in EU) we have anything from manufacturer-led dealership to entirely independent one.

But there laws that make it basically forbidden for manufacturers to sell directly and have a lot of protection for dealerships business. Hence no competition. That was made into slapping extra price over MSRP on rarer cars there. That practice started spanning pretty much all cars during pandemic.

Here is one example

https://www.carscoops.com/2022/11/honda-dealerships-payment-...

> They just provide a service - they have cars available to test drive

... sometimes

> and have a real person to talk to during the purchase

That is almost always clueless about nitty gritty, and just wants to sell you the one they earn most money on.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by cuteboy19 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:09AM (#33606946)
They only exist because it's illegal to do business directly with the consumer. Had they been needed by the customer, they wouldn't fight tooth and nail to keep those laws
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by pvaldes on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:41AM (#33607971)
Is a both ways road.

Many brands learned, the hard way, that clients watch on internet but don't buy a new car by internet. Is a too expensive investment. Most people refuse to talk with a robocall and want a local dealership where they can return if they have troubles.

Brands are always trying to reduce the number of official dealerships, to discover later that their business has run dry, and are about to be eaten by a bigger brand. Is happening all the time.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by int_19h on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @09:29PM (#33634168)
And again, if it was all down to either consumer or manufacturer preference, they wouldn't so heavily lobby for laws that require all transactions to go through the dealerships.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by kylehotchkiss on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:20AM (#33607006)
I bought a car last year during the covid induced car shortages. The first visit to the dealer, I said what I wanted, he went to the back and got a piece of paper with a price and a VIN number, the price matched what the Toyota website said, and I agreed to put down a deposit. The next visit 3 weeks later, I saw the car I was promised, the dealer told me the price which matched the sheet. He gave me the keys for a totally private test drive (he didn’t even come along) and I proceeded to hand over the check and was sent on my way as soon as the DMV paperwork was fulfilled. It was a Toyota dealership in California. They’re not all rotten. I’d happy buy another car from the same salesperson if I was in the market. If I had to guess, dealerships that do fleet sales have less pressure and can treat normal consumers with proper respect.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by propogandist on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:17AM (#33608754)
Virtually every dealer, for the Japanese brands I am considering, is 2 to 10K+ over MSRP (“market adjustment and dealer adds”) in a 300 mile radius (multiple big metros). These markups are for vehicles they won’t have in stock for months also.

Car dealers have discovered they can make huge profits by exploiting the inventory shortage. They’ve also kept some of the most arrogant sales staff (“closers”) who are guaranteed big pay days for every sale.

While this isn’t always the case, the days of paying below MSRP appears to be a thing of the past

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by Bluecobra on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:07AM (#33609309)
Had a similar experience a few weeks ago, for example a $25,000 Hyundai Elantra was marked up $8,000 over MSRP. All the Hyundai dealers near me are all pulling the same games and don’t post the actual price on their website so you have to waste time traveling there. Luckily for me I had the option to buy out my lease and won’t ever do business with any of these dealers again.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by propogandist on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:53PM (#33616962)
I came across https://markups.org, in my research, which crowdsources info on dealer markups. It will give you a ballpark if a dealer should be avoided outright.

Calling the sales department and asking for market adjustment and dealer adds info for make/model is also recommended. Most sales people, although not all, will disclose rough numbers.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by bluedino on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:13AM (#33609352)
This summer we looked at a Toyota. They were 8 months out on deliveries but if we bought $1500 worth of dealer prep/warranty we could reserve our car.

We went to Honda instead, and paid MSRP. They were only 3 months out, but nobody above us in line wanted the color of the next one that came in so we got it in a month.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by TulliusCicero on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:27AM (#33607068)
Dealerships in the US make a lot of money by convincing people to take bad deals. They're known for being sleezy and exploitative by default, as the model encourages that.

A lot of people want to be able to buy a car the way they buy almost any other consumer product: easily, for a set price they can research ahead of time. Dealerships stand in the way of that.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by e-clinton on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:33AM (#33607113)
I think that’s limited to lower end brands and the “sells any brand” dealership. My experience with luxury dealership has been nothing but positive. Yes, you still have to negotiate, but they won’t spring shady deals from random banks or tack on unnecessary “dealer fees”. Even when buying used cars, I go to name brand dealerships for a more predictable experience.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by thorncorona on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:36AM (#33607131)
The number of people who will buy at a luxury dealership are vastly smaller than those who will go to low end dealerships.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by arvindamirtaa on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:46AM (#33607179)
Like Teslas?
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by oblio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:51AM (#33607658)
Yeah, but then we run into another problem.

If Tesla truly wants to remain a luxury brand forever, its market cap should reflect that.

It shouldn't be the market cap of the next Toyota (car maker) and Panasonic (battery maker) combined and multiplied by 10.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by KptMarchewa on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:25AM (#33607866)
AFAIK, they eventually want to provide "Model 2" for about 60-70% of Model 3 price. They need to scale up their whole operations to be able to profit off of that.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by oblio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:29AM (#33608891)
Yes, they probably want that. And they also want pie in the sky.

The Model 3 was launched in July 2017, about 5.5 years ago. Unveiling in April 2016, more than 6.5 years ago. During the unveiling, if I'm not wrong, they announced the $35k Model 3. In 2019 they actually released the $35k Model 3, as more of a publicity stunt, since they pulled it after only 2 months.

Back then €1 was about $1.2, so that price would have been about €24k.

Instead, in the real world of today, where €1 is less than $1, the cheapest Model 3 you can buy in Europe is about €54k.

So at the new exchange rate, it's more than twice as expensive, and even with the old exchange rate, it would have still been $45k (about 30% more expensive).

So the "Model 2" will actually be around the price that was promised for Model 3.

More than that, Tesla is notoriously unreliable regarding forecasts. At this point I don't think the Model 3 will ever be back to $35k/€35k.

I don't know about you, but I don't make my plans around stuff that takes 15 years to be ready (5.5 years until now + the likely 10 more years it takes them to launch it).

And this new "Model 2" will probably be launched 10 years from now and it will cost what the Model 3 was supposed to cost, back in 2017.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by KptMarchewa on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:49AM (#33610654)
>Yes, they probably want that. And they also want pie in the sky.

That was being said about literally every Musk venture, either failed or successful.

>The Model 3 was launched in July 2017, about 5.5 years ago. Unveiling in April 2016, more than 6.5 years ago. During the unveiling, if I'm not wrong, they announced the $35k Model 3. In 2019 they actually released the $35k Model 3, as more of a publicity stunt, since they pulled it after only 2 months.

>Back then €1 was about $1.2, so that price would have been about €24k.

>Instead, in the real world of today, where €1 is less than $1, the cheapest Model 3 you can buy in Europe is about €54k.

>So at the new exchange rate, it's more than twice as expensive, and even with the old exchange rate, it would have still been $45k (about 30% more expensive).

Blame ECB (for currency value drop) and supply and demand. Turns out enough people want to buy 35k€ vehicle for 54k€.

>And this new "Model 2" will probably be launched 10 years from now and it will cost what the Model 3 was supposed to cost, back in 2017.

Yeah, but who cares? The purchasing power of that will be equal to what it would have cost based on original estimates.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by oblio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:10AM (#33610977)
Did you miss the "10 years from now" part? :-)

We call that "vaporware", not worth discussing.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by KptMarchewa on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:21AM (#33611145)
Yes, but this is only your projection, not a fact. Purely based on last 2 years of pandemic and extreme supply disruption, combined with wars and other geopolitics dangers.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by spywaregorilla on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:52AM (#33609143)
I'm don't get why people care about market cap, but for what it's worth, tesla sits at about 2-3x those two companies combined. And panasonic is "just" a 20 billion dollar market cap company.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by oblio on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:54AM (#33609160)
> tesla sits at about 2-3x those two companies combined

Now, when it fell about 50%. I was just behind the news.

At a certain point this graph was true: https://wolfstreet.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/US-Tesla-m...

Which was just insane.

Why do people care about market cap? Because it shows mindshare. It shows what people care about and where investments should go, preorders, a lot of that stuff.

Plus market cap can be converted into money (not 1:1, but still).

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by KptMarchewa on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:09AM (#33607777)
Luxury options are by design "worse deal" - the margins on core product are way higher, so they don't have to push the bad deals on you that much. You've chosen it by going there in a first place.

Now, that does not mean that you can't get higher, valuable utility from luxury vehicle.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by subpixel on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:14AM (#33607804)
My dealership tried to sell me tires at $300/each. At a tire shop I got comparable tires for about 60% of that.

Dealerships make a lot of money via convenience (you’re already here for your 30k service) and just plain ignorance (most people have no idea what makes their car work or what repair cost is fair).

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by bluedino on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:14AM (#33609377)
That's weird. Dealers are known for marking up parts and service, but around here they are aggressively price matching the local tire stores
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by AdrianB1 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:57AM (#33608074)
Dealership in Europe is not so good either. Real example: I bought a motorcycle from one of the 2 dealers in the country. I had to do the first oil change at the dealership in order not to lose the warranty (in my country, in US you can change the oil at home). They charged 100 EUR for an oil change, including 1h hour of workmanship, when it took less than 15 minutes from parking in front of the dealership to leaving the building with the work done and paperwork complete.

For a car, the oil change was 300 EUR at the dealership, same problem with losing the warranty. In that case it took one hour - no idea why because it takes just 10 minutes of actual work and there was no wait time to cool the engine and oil, they were almost cold.

Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by wongarsu on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:58AM (#33609211)
One thing that keeps European dealerships a pleasurable experience is that they have to compete with direct sales. I can just go on Volkswagen's website, configure the car I want and have it delivered. That means dealerships have to provide value to stay in business. In the US you don't have direct sales (except for Tesla), so even if dealerships provide negative value they still stay in business, as long as all of them provide about the same amount of (negative) value.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by notyourwork on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:48AM (#33609738)
Bought two cars, brand new. Never again. Dealers are abusive, scammy and inconsiderate. It’s such an arduous process that I dread the next car purchase coming up for my wife in next two years.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by ajvs on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:59AM (#33609887)
There was an Adam Ruins Everything episode about car dealerships in the US, from what I remember US lawmakers have made it so it's not a free market compared to the EU. I think it's similar to how US ISPs maintain monopolies in certain areas.
Re:Tesla finds a loophole in states where dealerships are fo... by newsclues on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:50AM (#33610672)
They don't have to compete against the factory to make sales, so they just have to compete with other middlemen selling the same commodity, which is a great situation for an anti-consumer cartel to form.