He adapted to the situation by leaning on the expertise of the crew in a way that was very different than the normal command-and-control style of leadership. It sounds like what you describe in type 1.
If more leaders like this guy who wrote this book were sent to the top levels, it would be an improvement. Instead, you notice he's writing books for a living now.
Also most top tier MBA programs are an excuse to get wildly drunk basically daily and make a bunch of powerful friends, so it's very possible most people who go don't learn a damn thing.
Sorry to rag on MBAs.
This is a disease of all peacetime militaries. The Army suffers the same problem. They spend an entire career LARPing in camouflage, and think that somehow means they know anything at all about warfare or leadership.
As for why life sucks so much, leadership has let there be too much to do with too few people, and inflexible systems.
Because they were run by such a small crew, nobody wanted to command them because the number of people under your command mattered for rank advancement.
It's something I think about to this day. As we've made progress restoring and transforming our place, we're constantly informed by those observations — and it's really easy to see how many of the initial ideas would've been premature or lacking context.
The more modern type of reformer goes gaily up to [the fence] and says, "I don't see the use of this; let us clear it away." To which the more intelligent type of reformer will do well to answer: "If you don't see the use of it, I certainly won't let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Chesterton's_fencethis is the $44B problem to your CO analogy.
Skin in the game. The world runs far better on it.
I see you edited your comment from the original:
> this seems to be a significant problem to your CO analogy.
So let me ask you… how does a ship’s commanding officer not have more skin in the game? A rich person loses their second home or yacht when things go south… a person on a ship can hit the brig or lose their life.
They’ll stop being CO and will never be promoted, but will finish out their Navy career in a job where they can’t hurt anyone, and will have almost no impact once they retire and go into civilian life.
They’re not going to do time in the brig unless there’s willful misconduct.
I looked it up and found this at https://www.history.navy.mil/research/library/online-reading...:
> Commander A. L. Wilderman, CO of USS Plunger (SSN-595), lost overboard in a storm just off San Francisco. 2 December 1973.
Who is the last software CEO that died in the course of their duty specifically due to the nature of their work?
Lookup James Po Ho Cheung or Sid Agrawal if you want examples of CEOs straight up murdered for their roles.
Every human with a heart has some risk of heart attack. It’s silly to compare that risk to a soldier’s risk of death.
And any CEO that fires someone has a risk of being attacked by that disgruntled former employee.
This is exactly why I said
> software CEO that died in the course of their duty specifically due to the nature of their work
So that example fails the test.
The example of James Po Ho Cheung is more interesting. Now that I think about it, since software can operate in so many different domains, it’s valid that some of those can be dangerous, such as gambling in his case.
Absolutely not as the CO of a ship. You are orders of magnitude safer on one of those ships than working as a roofer or a farmer.
> don’t understand what you mean by “a CO doesn’t have to go overboard”, I provided an example of just that happening.
You provided an example of someone going overboard on a ship, but nothing a CO does makes them more susceptible to going over than any other person on the ship. Being a CO is not higher risk than taking a fucking Carnival cruise.
> Every human with a heart has some risk of heart attack. It’s silly to compare that risk to a soldier’s risk of death.
Given that “heart attack” is probably the most likely way a high level officer in the US military would die, I think not.
> Elon Musk has 0 risk of being swept into the sea from his desk.
Not quite. San Francisco has some pretty gnarly long tail risks from earthquakes. He’s also now in charge of one of the biggest propaganda tools in the history of humanity. The Saudi’s have wacked reporters for far less.
In fact a CO might be in better position in that regard. Soldiers don’t quit as fast as devs.
Bottomline, the last time tech truly saw a recession and slow-down was in 2001. So, the entire dev cohort has never seen economic conditions that they are about to face.
Even high performers at Meta, Coinbase, Netflix will have to navigate this.
There are two choices in front of them
a) work at Twitter and other startups which requires 60+ hours of work. High workload / High Reward
or
b) Join services firm like IBM, TCS and have work-life balance but do menial tasks with steady but medium pay.
Elon Musk will have no trouble hiring them.
Most devs are completely out of touch about the economic reality. Now they have to work hard like the rest of other industries.
Twitter is not a startup, and my understanding is startups are only "high reward" if your bet pays off (e.g. you got in early enough AND the startup was successful enough).
> Most devs are completely out of touch about the economic reality. Now they have to work hard like the rest of other industries.
Your a/b binary choice is out of touch in its own way.
Twitter is absolutely a startup. They are trying to a) find product market fit with a new vision b) Have negative cash-flow, so everyone has to workhard to reduce burn rate. c) Will have new fresh equity issued them with high upside rewards. d) Will have a liquidity event in a couple of years (IPO)
For all practical purpose, Twitter is a startup.
Musk will issue new equity
That sounds like a very idiosyncratic definition of a "startup" that would match all kinds of poorly performing companies no one would label a "startup." I think being new, small, and chasing orders-of-magnitude upside from that small start are pretty key to the conventional definition, neither of which apply to Twitter anymore.
Musk also fired Engineers who weren't productive in the past two months. Musk has enough software expertise to see through people who bullshit and people who know their shit.
That's why the best Car Designer, the best rocket engineer, the best AI expert were all working for Tesla/SpaceX.
Is Musk clueless about Social Media? absolutely.
Do you think he isn't spending every waking second to figure out the nuances and deliver something amazing in 2-3 years?
This is where HN/Reddit/Blind/Media are clueless about Musk. They look at current state of Musk and mock him (they mocked him for his rocket dream, his electric car dream, they mocked his tents)
True to form and cluelessness, they are currently mocking his lack of expertise in creator economy and other social aspects of social media.
Let's try 2 years from now. Musk is a fast learner and has always pivoted when data shows him where he is wrong.
He will make plenty of mistakes and clueless media will be there to highlight that because there is an audience of clueless people who are thirsty for Elon Musk thrashing articles to feel good about themselves.
At the end of the day, Twitter will be successful, Elon will be a Trillionaire (from all his ventures) and there will be salty HN/Redditers who will still be mocking him in 2030 because he probably would be doing some stupid thing in some new industry
He just held an all hands where he said he doesn't know how long a run rate Twitter has, Twitter may lose billions next year, and bankruptcy isn't out of the question, so it sounds like it's possible he may have trouble hiring anyone.
That's how he motivates people
Not everyone in this world is a coaster
From everyone I’m in contact with it’s a terrible time to be in sales, marketing, or hr, and the engineers are mostly bitching about no raises this year
It's not only about layoffs, but not enough absorbing capacity for freshly printed Tech graduates the universities are churning out at the rate expecting previous level of hiring.
Most HN guys demanding work-life balance have seen nothing yet.
This is a great time for Startups and Startup-like firms like Twitter to hire and require 60+ hours workload. There will be fresh graduates from Stanford, MIT, Berkeley who have no choice but to put pressure on existing coasters on various companies
That’s where all your startup analogies (which I find interesting!) break: Twitter is a “turn around” case. Musk had never to deal with such. He always build up companies from the ground. That’s very very different to acquiring a large company with an existing culture.
Now I’m not saying it cannot work. Maybe it does. But you can’t argue he’s done it before.
Most people in 2001 had to find work quickly to keep surviving. Mid-career high performers from Meta, Twitter, Netflix, etc have millions in savings and assets.
Those people could sit out a few years if they wanted, or even just retire early if they were happy with the $60-100k/year income from interest/capital gains at a consevative withdrawl rate.
Most of these people still choose to work today because they have well paying jobs which they enjoy. High performers gonna perform, etc. But, if the only option was toxic jobs combined with low pay many would simply opt-out.
Many in this dev cohort have been extremely lucky and have the privilege to take a stand. 2022 isn't really a great time to be an asshole captialist banking on qualified employees having no other options.
Fresh graduates and early career individuals are a possibility. But, you still need experienced devs to mentor them and maintain the large complex systems/infrastructure that fresh hires can't yet handle without more experience. Attracting and retaining this senior talent is the hard part.
Every industry works like this. It's only out-of-touch techies who enjoyed unprecedented rewards/hard-work ratio that need to adjust their lifestyle and expectations
Still a lot of skin.
To be fair, he actually does own the place.
I wish that we, as a culture, stopped harping over what Elon Musk might do to Twitter next.
It does not matter. This will take some time to play out. I hope Twitter employees land on their feet. That is pretty much the only thing that matters. I don't have a lot of reasons to think that they won't barring some exceptions.
The point was not employee happiness, but an attitude that completely ignores that the employees might know a thing or two about how to run the place. And plenty of employees are willing to put up with subpar pay and otherwise boring work if they feel valued for the stewardship and experience.
That sounds like a reasonable hypothesis. I don’t know if that is being (or was ever) tested at Twitter.
Of course he is.
Was it that before Musk actually decided to buy it? Because as far as I can tell, the ad dollars started dropping after his announcement.
When you transfer onto another ship, do you need a long onboarding as well, does each ship have its own culture? How do they coordinate?
There's some commonality, but it's like a fork of other ships. When a new ship is stood up and built, the pre-comissioning crew will write the SOPs for the new ship. Most of the time, you crib it from an old ship and make changes you think are useful, like a fork. There are some standards from up high, especially encryption stuff, but things can be run with some discretion.
Crypto was probably a bad example, since no decent Navy crypto tech would deviate from the proper procedures, even in the face of the CO asking for it. Kinda like how once the CO asked me to use more ordnance for training than I was alloted, and I said "no" and he said "yes" and I said "if you do this, I will put in writing that I told you not to and you did it anyways and I also won't operate the system to check out the ordnance, so we'll have an imbalance" and he said "ok".
> When you transfer onto another ship, do you need a long onboarding as well,
Not long, but a bit, yes. Much like starting a new job. For some jobs, you shadow the current position holder for a good while.
> does each ship have its own culture?
Yes, undoubtedly.
> How do they coordinate?
Generally via SIPRchat, radio, flag signals, etc.
But seriously, we have some standards for operations that make the different ships able to inter-operate easily. You also have groups of ships under commanders who do a bit more to coalesce those ships into a unit.
Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter is 2)
Twitter is in a shit load of trouble and unlike Meta & Snap which are crashing like a shitcoin.. Elon bought Twitter at 2x-3x what its actually worth.
Unlike the past decade, where these companies had easy access to funny money during a tech bull market.. now we are entering a uuge recession.. Twitter (or any company for that matter) which doesn't go into wartime mode is gonna get rekt
Also, in wartime, it's actually even more important that a new CO didn't upset the delicate balance or change procedures, because you need to rely on your skills and drills during wartime even more! Changing things just makes it harder to do your job and during wartime that would be deadly.
Also, you don't know where or when I served, so don't make assumptions.
I'm mainly talking about the difference in strategy/posture during wartime vs peacetime.. Just look at whats happening in Ukraine rn, Russia changing commanders to go full scorched earth.
To save a company like Twitter, this is exactly the kind of thing u need to do. Private equity does this all the time.
Military metaphors are common in business for a reason. Modern business management inherited a lot of the military after WW2. To this day, you'll see people with Special Ops history consulting businesses (Echelon Front)
Whatever state Twitter was in before Musk entered with a white knight syndrome, it was in a better state than it is now.
> Elon bought Twitter at 2x-3x what its actually worth.
Well, that was his first mistake at Twitter before he even "owned" it.
still tho, that 2x-3x multiple is a huuge gap to close and the company is still far from getting out its troubles. Troubles which btw existed wayyy before Elon or the recessions.
You google Twitter financials and metrics over the past years, its been grossly mismanaged..
My point was that the organization/ship is more than it's current head, it's a massive organism and if you make systemic changes that affect a sick or even healthy organism massively you tend to just destroy/kill it rather than improve it. The best way to fix/improve something so large and supposedly unhealthy as Twitter is by small or medium steps that are well-thought-out, over time.
Elon's got activist employees who're trying to bring him down personally and entire useless product divisions so the best thing to do is cut out the expensive rot - nothing ruins morale like having hostile and counterproductive teammates dragging you down.
The part of the company takes takes tweets, stores tweets, and displays tweets seems to be working fairly well. The rest is on the rocks or was headed for them full steam.
No, they'd try and figure out the motivation of the malignerer, or lack thereof, first. We had one guy who was a great tech, but then for a few months he showed up drunk to watch and was lazy. Found out his wife left him with the kids, to another state. The officer's mess arranged with some of the enlisted senior crew to invite the guy to family events every week, dinner and stuff, and helped him get back that family feeling with the ship, so he had something to work for.
> or enemy sympathizers.
I doubt anyone in the Navy I met was a spy for an enemy. I also doubt someone at Twitter is rooting for TikTok and working against Twitter in that direction.
Not trying to be confrontational, but whenever I see comments like this, I think that people really need to read up on narcissistic personality disorder. The "I'm being personally attacked" tactic is glaringly apparent. It's super common in cults too when the cult leader starts losing control of things (since they commonly have narcissism as well). People with NPD are completely incapable of comprehending that they may actually be at fault in any way and absolutely have to interpret failure as being due to conspiracies against them
That’s not a difference at all, as it would be exactly what (2) were thinking of their new commands as well.
I mean, if you ask any commanders in group 2, they're going to all say that.
Give Musk a chance… guy knows how to build and grow companies
Not sure, is there a government bailout or subsidy for tech companies as he got with Tesla?
https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hy-musk-subsidies-201...
I mean, the massive increase in cost is a result of Musk's debt purchasing Twitter.
If I'm being very generous, I'd give Twitter 6 more months.
1) The kind who investigated the goings-on in the ship, interviewed the officers and chiefs, and learned how the ship was being run, then made small changes over time to optimize the operations based on what they learned. Sometimes big changes in one specific area, if it was required (like fixing the ship's crypto key material protocols, if they are super fucked up).
2) The kind who came in and ran roughshod over the whole ship, made a bunch of big changes and policy decisions, and generally acted like they owned the place in order to fulfill a pre-concieved vision they had of how things should be.
With 1, we were happy because there are always improvements to an org, but the best people to know those improvements are those who know the org. These commanders always resulted in a better command overall by the end of their tenure, bar none.
With 2, we were sad, because suddenly mistakes were being made everywhere in order to try and fit into the "vision", and thus reduced morale due to the massive changes and the constant failures. I saw 2 of these and both failed miserably and brought the command down lower than it should/could have been. One of those was on a great ship that performed so flawlessly that we were always sent on the most important assignments, and after I left I learned the ship fell into disrepair and could no longer even get underway, due to mismanagement. That guy came in and basically made me decide to get an early re-assignment and 3 of my friends on that ship left the Navy completely because of him.