News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by peter422 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:18AM (#32847818)
I really wish all the anti-vaxxer types would just listen to TWiV.

The hosts and guests both openly and candidly talk about some of the disagreements they have with the prevailing public health guidelines while at the same time give so much detail and depth into virology and immunology so as to show how full of shit the big anti-vax misinformation peddlers are.

So many anti-vaxxers say you can't have any disagreements with the party line or you get cancelled and then these prominent experts at the top of their fields do it every week on TWiV and don't get cancelled (because they aren't full of shit).

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by stingraycharles on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:26AM (#32847881)
In my experience, it’s usually not about finding out the actual facts / truth for these groups of people, but rather based mostly on emotion. I have an extremely hard time believing that letting them listen to TWiV would have any meaningful impact.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by cat_plus_plus on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:40AM (#32847970)
Just curious - if you say so many other people are forming their opinion based on emotion rather than facts / truth and don't realize that - why do you think you are immune to the same phenomena? I don't mean it as an insult, I probably also have a few beliefs like that, with no way to realize which ones. Certainly feels good to believe I am protected from a deadly disease and feels bad to wonder about side effects. So why listen to any critique of COVID-19 vaccines after I already got my shots?
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by hamandcheese on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:28AM (#32848363)
Parent did not say they believe they are immune.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by OJFord on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:59AM (#32849499)
'these groups of people' does imply there are (other groups of) people immune to it, whichever group they believe themselves to be in.

(That's an everyday speech 'imply', not a mathematical 'imply'; where of course the existence of sets containing x says nothing about the existence of sets not containing x.)

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by blueblueue on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:11AM (#32849154)
But strongly implied it.
[dead]
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by space_fountain on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:40AM (#32848504)
Hey, that’s not how vaccines actually work. I think you’ve had fragments of the truth presented in a way to try to make you believe things that aren’t true. Vaccines aren’t a platform that can be triggered to do different things. It does use RNA which is cool because it allows for more rapid changes. The vaccine will mostly work with a wide variety of RNA payloads with the only difference being the exact antibodies it encourages. In a few decades that might mean we could start developing and deploying vaccines in weeks. But rna doesn’t last long. It’s pretty unstable so the only thing getting updated is your bodies natural immune response
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by elcritch on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:12AM (#32849160)
Technically uwagar is correct, if perhaps overestimating the capability of the "payload". The mRNA could in theory produce a wide array of proteins. Personally I'm excited by the potential for treatments for other conditions using mRNA tech, with research on autoimmune conditions already progressing. Also it's probably possible already to develop and deploy vaccines in weeks, though safety and efficacy tests trials still take months.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by nullish_signal on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:13AM (#32849166)
That's not how CLASSICAL vaccines work They changed the definition of "vaccine" to include the new mRNA technology
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by space_fountain on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:32PM (#32854511)
Hum, it pretty much is how classic attenuated vaccines worked, except here we are directly controlling the rna that gets stuck in your cells rather than trying to evolve the virus a bit and then stick it in you
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by VMG on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:47AM (#32849405)
anything that doesn't involve cows is not a classical vaccine
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by uwagar on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:05AM (#32849127)
u are just reinforcing my understanding. so payloads, triggering and 'specific' products are all real. surely 'bugs' in this sequence are inevitable too with maybe devastating consequences for which no one is liable. who is to say the boosters are not updates that sneak in backdoors with additional 'features'? + these vaccines are peddled by for profit companies that refuse to share IP and emergency approved by govt agencies that have these company officers on their boards.... sorry, i refuse this workflow that treats my body like a phone that needs constant 'security' updates.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by space_fountain on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:30PM (#32854464)
Did you get flu updates in the past? What about yearly physicals? Obviously I’m not going to convince you, but I would like to invite you to wonder what the difference is. RNA tech is potentially scary, but the idea that vaccines are secretly doing something else is a bit silly. For one thing the number of people who can “decompile” the vaccine is pretty large. I believe there have been some research papers on it even and beyond that biology is pretty limited. You’d need a lot more than is in the vaccine to do anything more than your run of the mill virus does to you dozens of times a year and honestly a lot less than some because it can’t modify your dna, it can’t save itself anywhere.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by kube-system on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:04AM (#32849546)
> companies that refuse to share IP

That only means they have an exclusive right to manufacture the vaccine. It doesn’t mean that the details are secret.

For example: https://github.com/NAalytics/Assemblies-of-putative-SARS-CoV...

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:47AM (#32849025)
In my experience, it’s usually not about finding out the actual facts / truth for these groups of people

actual facts

https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/covid-deaths-in-israel-h...

look at that chart and then recall the absolutely mad state so many people went into Summer 2021

"time to blame the 'unvaccinated'"

"time to inject them against their will"

"time to violate their basic human rights"

https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/i-know-what-you-did-last...

maybe, just maybe, the "unvaccinated" were able to see something you weren't and chose the better path

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by netsharc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:26AM (#32849266)
Ah, you link to (your) "actual facts": a few short sentences, and a demand based on one graph. Plus speculation (no details though) that the vaccine is interacting with Omicron. A title with a demand in all caps.

Yay for facts, and not emotions! For the obtuse: the last sentence was sarcastic.

Give me a long detailed scientific paper and then maybe it's worth considering.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:10AM (#32849591)
The “actual facts” are the numbers represented in the graph. (My bad, I thought that would be clear)

The shots were sold as “If you get this shot you won’t get the virus” but apparently people still are getting the virus. And not just getting the virus, but dying from it. And dying from it in greater numbers than before the shots! WTF is up with that?!

Clearly the shots don’t work as they were supposed to.

And they are killing people. Excess deaths are way up in mRNA injected countries.

And they are preventing people from being born. Birth rates are way down in mRNA injected countries.

Not good.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by netsharc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:29AM (#32850158)
Sorry, that is poor application of the scientific method. The blogger - and you - have made hypotheses, and conclude (the page:) "How can anyone view this chart as evidence of anything except - at best - complete vaccine failure?" and (you:) "Clearly the shots don’t work as they were supposed to.". You've concluded these things because emotionally that's what you want to happen, because (I'll assume) you're afraid[1] of the vaccine.

From 1 screenshot graph! Is that all the data you need to draw your conclusions? Is the graph even real, or is a graph from a random blog good enough because it supports your viewpoint? (Let's be honest, "both sides" have this deficiency; "This PNG supports my viewpoint, I'm right!"). Let's see the vax rates (to me the page is trying to trick people by presenting "Over 95% are vaccinated" but that's for people over the age 50. Let's see the rate of "returning to normal" and partying and mingling by people who think since they were vaxxed 6 months ago they were safe.

> And they are preventing people from being born. Birth rates are way down in mRNA injected countries.

Oooh... it must be the vaccine! How about the fact that there's been economic instability since the pandemic? Nah: mRNA introduced, birth rates down, must be mRNA!

Look, birth rates have been down since 2007, oh, must be Bill Gates' time machine: https://www.aei.org/economics/the-reasons-for-americas-birth...

Sorry if you're insulted, but geez, either this comment slaps some sense into you (here I am fighting against a windmill) that you're an idjit who needs to be more scientific about his way of thinking, or you're just going to reaffirm your beliefs, because it's more comforting to think that you have a clue and everyone else are the idjits[2]. A toast to that!

[1] Yeah TBH it's a foreign substance, I don't know what liquid they injected into me, at the end of the day I had my faith in the scientists making and checking the vaccine, just like we all put faith that the burger we're eating have been checked properly - by whoever is in charge for checking those things - for mad cow and other diseases.

[2] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/02/27/why-facts-dont... - Yes, arguably your "facts" won't change the minds of "I have faith in the vax" people either...

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by thunky on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:43PM (#32890232)
> Is the graph even real, or is a graph from a random blog good enough because it supports your viewpoint?

It's Google's chart. Search for "covid", then select Israel from the country drop down.

The poster you replied to is asserting that this chart should look much better by now, given the promises made when the vaccine when it was introduced. I don't see why you need "a long detailed scientific paper" to agree or disagree with this.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by LadyCailin on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:21AM (#32849231)
Public health rights and not clogging up hospitals with easily preventable diseases readily outweigh your individual right to not get vaccinated, in general. Had the discussions around the specific Covid vaccines been argued with this in mind, a more productive conversation could be had, but instead it jumps immediately to a conversation about “muh rights” which is wholeheartedly disingenuous and/or selfish.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by brigandish on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:55AM (#32849471)
To protect or support one individual's rights is to protect or support everyone's individual rights. That is why, for example, prominent free speech activists will support the right of people they vehemently disagree with to voice their opinions, as it protects one's own right to voice opinions.

How is that selfish?

> If you would like to be selfish, you should do it in a very intelligent way. The stupid way to be selfish is … seeking happiness for ourselves alone. … the intelligent way to be selfish is to work for the welfare of others.” - Dalai Lama

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by LadyCailin on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:06AM (#32851299)
Individual rights do not trump collective rights in all cases. If I have the right to shoot a gun, that does not mean I have the right to shoot a gun while people are down range. This lack of nuance in your argument is absurd. The selfish part is suggesting that your individual rights trump everyone else’s rights.

Specific individual rights can and do trump collective rights, but this is a conversation we have to have as a society. For instance, if I am down range, my individual right trumps everyone’s right to fire a gun down that range. It’s the flip side of the same coin. Positive freedoms are zero sum with negative freedoms. Realizing that is step one to having a productive conversation about these things.

Once we get past that fact, by realizing that it is zero sum, and your individual right takes away some collective right (and vice versa) we can look at specific instances and debate those. But when the conversation begins with “you’re taking away my rights”, the rest of the conversation is guaranteed to be unproductive, because, depending on your perspective, both outcomes take away someone’s rights.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by brigandish on Friday September 16, 2022 @06:14AM (#32864269)
> Individual rights do not trump collective rights in all cases.

I agree, though:

a) I didn't make that claim

b) You may as well just say "one right does not always trump another", which is just as true and more insightful

Which makes this part:

> This lack of nuance in your argument is absurd.

actually absurd. And this part:

> The selfish part is suggesting that your individual rights trump everyone else’s rights.

as I've already pointed out, is not something I claimed. This was my claim:

“To protect or support one individual's rights is to protect or support everyone's individual rights."

Perhaps you'd like to try again, and this time actually address me with some respect, not least by actually replying to what was written and not what is most convenient to you in the fantasy argument you've spilled out from your head.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:37AM (#32849335)
The shots don’t work. Even if they did, people’s choice over what is injected into their bodies comes first.

Even if they did work, the profile of who was at risk was clear, it wasn’t healthy young people. So why was it pushed on healthy young people?

From the outset the risk reward ratio was not clear for those without high comorbidites, the minute the myocarditis signal showed up it should have been pulled for most people.

Bearing in mind we now know myocarditis is just one of a multitude of negative side effects.

So why did it go on being pushed and coerced to healthy people, actively harming them?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by cm2187 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:56AM (#32848650)
Depends what you mean by anti-vaxer. It goes from crazy conspiracy theorist to people who don't see the point of vaccinating healthy children. I don't think I am an anti-vaxer, I got two shots despite having had covid. I totally see the benefits for the population at risk. But for a mild virus like omicron, for a population that wasn't even at risk of the original strain, I just don't see the point of mandating vaccines. It is certainly doing nothing meaningful to transmissions (if it did it would be another matter), and it does have side effects (I spent a full day in bed with fever after the second shot, and this is quite common), and what happened to "my body my choice"?

So not being in the population at risk I have no intention to take a booster. Am I an anti-vaxer? I certainly disagree with public health policy in most countries.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:21AM (#32848845)
There are many strange effects of covid still being understood, like blood clots:

  https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2022/04/covid-patients-may-be-higher-risk-blood-clots-6-months#:~:text=Ho%20and%20Pell%20said%20that%20while%20many%20Omicron,of%20infections%20%2894.5%25%20in%20this%20study%29%2C%22%20they%20wrote.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by octopoc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:02AM (#32848702)
According to Merriam-Webster you are an anti-vaxxer if you oppose the use of some or all vaccines, or if you oppose vaccine mandates, or usually both[1]. So if you oppose vaccinating healthy children then yeah, you are likely an anti-vaxxer. If you also oppose any vaccine mandates then you are definitely an anti-vaxxer.

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by jhugo on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:06AM (#32848732)
By that definition, "anti-vaxxer" is so broad as to be meaningless. Certainly useful as a way for people not caught up in its expansive definition to feel superior, I guess.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by blub on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:29AM (#32848905)
From your link: “ As a result of the global COVID-19 pandemic, the use of the term anti-vaxxer has both increased and broadened.”

It used to refer to parents which completely refused to vaccinate their children. It has transformed into a weapon, like racist, fascist, etc and is used to silence and manipulate discourse.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by Traubenfuchs on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:37AM (#32849333)
Depending on the country, people lost their jobs, weren't allowed to travel and were locked inside for not getting the vaccine(s), Austria even went as far as to introduce a law mandating everyone to get those vaccines (which they never executed and then promptly overturned).

Now whole governments are admitting that people under 50 don't really need those vaccines after all. We now have studies claiming that serious vaccination side effects are more likely than serious covid sickness in young men.

The anti vaxxers were proven RIGHT by this in many of their claims. How should they EVER trust governments again? How should they ever leave their anti-vax echochambers again? It was shown time and time again that governments and their high profile rockstar twitter "experts" get the facts right as many times as a broken clock the time, sometimes even spreading deliberate misinformation/lies ("Faucis noble lies") and absolutely can not be trusted.

My government as well scammed me into getting a second vaccine, after the retracted their claim that the single shot J&J vaccination would suffice.

I am not even an anti vaxxer -I am happy my parents are vaccinated. They always were at an at-risk age, but I am not and I am not interested in getting another covid vaccine. I remain terrified at the prospect of a reinstatement of the green pass system.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by scoofy on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:25AM (#32849700)
> Now whole governments are admitting that people under 50 don't really need those vaccines after all. We now have studies claiming that serious vaccination side effects are more likely than serious covid sickness in young men.

Wtf are you talking about. TWiV absolutely thinks everyone needs two cycles of vaccination period… and it’s likely beneficial to get three.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by OrvalWintermute on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:29AM (#32847902)
> I really wish all the anti-vaxxer types would just listen to TWiV.

We call it science the process/method, rather than science the religion.

> The hosts and guests both openly and candidly talk about some of the disagreements they have with the prevailing public health guidelines while at the same time give so much detail and depth into virology and immunology so as to show how full of shit the big anti-vax misinformation peddlers are.

I'll keep that in mind next time I am censored.

> So many anti-vaxxers say you can't have any disagreements with the party line or you get cancelled and then these prominent experts at the top of their fields do it every week on TWiV and don't get cancelled (because they aren't full of shit).

Profanity aside, it sounds like you are touting controlled opposition, or, Establishment figures critiquing establishment positions.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by simonh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:37AM (#32847952)
> I'll keep that in mind next time I am censored.

When were you censored? I mean actually censored.

Bearing in mind that being ignored, or the owners of publishing systems choosing not to cooperate with you in propagating your opinions on platforms they own or operate, is editorialising and not censorship.

[dead]
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by simonh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:29AM (#32848381)
There’s plenty of evidence for a strong correlation between some opinions and mortality rates. There are probably in the region of 135,000 or more dead Americans who would probably be alive today if they’d not been persuaded to hold a particular opinion.

https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.02.10.22270823v...

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by concordDance on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:48AM (#32848577)
Censoring anyone saying ageing is natural or not a disease or arguing against funding an anti-aging project would probably have an even bigger impact, but still seems like a bad idea.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by simonh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:16AM (#32850062)
It’s possible to imagine all sorts of problems we don’t actually have.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by fzeroracer on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:32AM (#32847922)
How do we know you're not 'controlled opposition'? If you want to make the argument that the people in question are establishment figures, then doesn't the same argument fly for you as well? How do we know you're not some agent of some other establishment pushing their own agenda other than 'trust me I'm a real person'?

This line of debate leads nowhere other than a dead end where each side is convinced that the other is a spy. And considering your post history, I don't know if there's a reason to lend you much credence at all.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by OrvalWintermute on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:47AM (#32848570)
The proper medical response, and ethical one, is pretty simple.

To any medical intevention there is risk. A chance of adverse events. A chance it won't work. Side effects. Your physician should make you aware of these potential issues, making you aware of them, before treating you. We call it informed consent.

The ethical angle is a little more complex. Considering above, but also, knowing the statistics around fatality rates of various conditions, and the adverse events that go along with the interventions. Some cases it means they should, or shouldn't be treated. Also, you have to consider a patient's personal beliefs, religion, etc. Running roughshod over patient beliefs is considered unethical.

Each person should make their own decisions based on knowing their health, and consulting with a competent medical professional that understands all of above. There are simple calculators that exist for fatality rates around covid depending on age, weight, mordibities, etc. Thank JHU.

Which I do, thanks mostly to my wife that is a dual board certified surgeon.

> This line of debate leads nowhere other than a dead end where each side is convinced that the other is a spy. And considering your post history, I don't know if there's a reason to lend you much credence at all

Either I am a liar, well-informed, or quite crazy. Take your pick. I'd just like to think that I married well

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by elcritch on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:35AM (#32849326)
Not to mention trying to "force" the issue often isn't effective. There was a study on HN a while back showing higher rates of vaccination of newborns when the expectant mothers were given information on vaccines and their effectiveness months before and asked to consider them.

It's almost like most people can be reasonable if given the opportunity and proper information. People are also surprisingly good at picking up on BS, even if they then misattribute the source or reasoning.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by logicchains on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:16AM (#32848241)
>So many anti-vaxxers say you can't have any disagreements with the party line or you get cancelled and then these prominent experts at the top of their fields do it every week on TWiV and don't get cancelled (because they aren't full of shit).

On the one hand you say anti-vaxers are not cancelled but on the other hand you refer to them as full of shit. In spite of so many of their claims about the vaccine having been proven correct: it doesn't prevent transmission, it doesn't prevent severe covid or death, and for some age groups the risks outweigh the benefits: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4206070.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by archagon on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:38AM (#32849337)
> it doesn't prevent severe covid or death

Yes, it does…?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by lovich on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:21AM (#32848299)
He didn’t say they weren’t cancelled, he said that their claim that you can’t have any disagreements with the party line or you get cancelled.

Anti vaxxers tend to not discuss nuanced details and instead come out with unsubstantiated claims like “vaccines cause autism” which is going to get most people to stop listening to them

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by switch007 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:46AM (#32848559)
There’s plenty of nuance you just want don’t want to see it because anyone not 110% in favour = bad :)
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by lovich on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:48AM (#32849032)
Please illuminate us then. Dang doesn’t ban people for anti vaxx claims on this board so you should have nothing to fear
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by logicchains on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:31AM (#32848401)
>Anti vaxxers tend to not discuss nuanced details and instead come out with unsubstantiated claims like “vaccines cause autism” which is going to get most people to stop listening to them

Have you actually read any of the publications by prominent anti-vax scientists? For instance, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/359989585_Innate_im... is hardly lacking in nuanced details or full of unsubstantiated claims, nor is https://www.voiceforscienceandsolidarity.org/scientific-blog... .

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by lovich on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:51AM (#32849046)
I’m finding it difficult to summon the energy to read through these fully when the abstract of the first link has a political dog whistle[1] in the abstract before it gets to any actual hypothesis or claims. Finishing the abstract I see they end it with this sentence[2], implying this isn’t even original research? Is this actual research or a statistical analysis of the VAERS database?

This second link is even worse, it’s a blogpost with a a short paper riddled with citations linking to other blogposts from the same site making wild claims about how the vaccine actually makes things worse. I started on section 1 after his synopsis and he just points to a diagram included in his paper and then trots out the debunked anti vaxxer claim of

> vaccinees are now increasingly becoming asymptomatic shedders of SC-2.

There is no data or citation supporting that beyond his diagram. He just makes a claim and then starts making logical leaps off that claim.

This is the kind of “evidence” that makes everyone groan and roll their eyes when people claim that the anti vaxxers actually have proof and no one’s paying attention to them because it’s a conspiracy or doesn’t toe the party line. I am legitimately upset that I gave you the benefit of the doubt and wasted my time reading through these just to find out that your claims are as weakly supported as I had assumed.

[1]the sentence below, anti vaxxers commonly bring up lack of precedent as a reason the vaccines can’t possibly work

> The utilization of mRNA vaccines in the context of infectious disease has no precedent.

[2] > We show evidence from the VAERS database supporting our hypothesis.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by theiz on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:44AM (#32848539)
I really wish there was a normal conversation on this topic. If you would state that it might be better to offer vaccinations to the 50+ a few months back, you were an anti-vaxxer. That wording alone is also just to ridicule everyone that is somewhat critical on the Covid vaccination rules. There has been hardly any science in the regulations and mandates, just as there has been little science in the conspiracy people. And that is where we are now: A soccer match with hooligans shouting non-sense. So I agree with people that have to listen to specialists. At the same time your statement (2nd part) tells me that you are not open to listening, or having a conversation with anyone saying anything outside the allowed communication path.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by m000 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:28AM (#32849283)
> If you would state that it might be better to offer vaccinations to the 50+ a few months back, you were an anti-vaxxer.

And rightfully so. Policies adapt to the currently prevailing COVID variant. A change of policy today is not a vindication for statements made months ago under different circumstances.

Also, if the one making the statement is not an expert themselves, they're typically cherry-picking statements of real experts to match their preoccupations, while the topic is in fact still under debate and the verdict can swing either way.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by samuel on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:54AM (#32848064)
There are several kinds of anti-vaxxers. It's easy to focus on the tinfoil hat kind but there are others that just kept an skeptic outlook and were equally by the ridiculized by media, when not directly accussed of being accomplices of homicide (I'm talking about Spain here, may be in other countries the situation was different).

True experts' doubts just reinforce their positions instead of weakening them, IMO.

For the record, I have got 3 shots (2 Pfizer + 1 Moderna), and I don't regret it. But I respect people who chose differently because the unknowns about the vaccines.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by michaelmrose on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:15AM (#32848222)
There actually really isn't any difference between the two groups. They differ only in how they articulate the same bad logic.

Vaccines became broadly available in relatively wealthy countries in 2021 wherein the only reasonable position would have been that vaccination of all groups would decrease net mortality even among those unlikely to die and reduce damage to people's bodies that we were already seeing even with mild infections of otherwise healthy people.

A reasonable analysis of a complex topic with an unknown number of unknown factors is ultimately going to have at least some support among smart people for niche positions.

Going with what your emotions proves you are intellectually incapable.

Picking out one smart person with an articulate position that matches your emotional position proves you are an intellectually incapable person who thinks they are smart.

Picking out a niche position and searching for a handful of smart people who support it because it makes you feel smart to be a contrarian makes you intellectually incapable AND smug.

I respect people with the aptitude and the niche knowledge to break new intellectual ground even if they turned out to be wrong. I do not respect the 1000 idiots following that one fellow into the brush who ignored all the other smart people going the other way and neither should you.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by samuel on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:37AM (#32848461)
I'm playing the devil's advocate and I'm not very comfortable with it, but I think it' valuable to the discussion to do so.

You are oversimplying and again conflating both groups. You assume people made their mind first and then looked for experts' to support which it's not fair to a lot of them.

Let's focus on an specific case. A healthy 25 years old male living in on of those countries. If he's an skeptic and decides to make a data oriented decision, the truth is that his chance of dying or getting a severe infection was really slim and probably comparable to the odds of getting a myocarditis because of it.

Yet the media and the government, at least in my country, did not make any difference between his case and a 60 years old with hypertension. Everyone had to take their shot or be denied his right to go to a pub or restaurant.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by michaelmrose on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:37AM (#32849784)
One gets myocarditus from covid and even mild cases in healthy young people commonly show damage from covid which isn't true of vaccination. Furthermore its reasonable to suppose that decreasing chance of infection decreases chance of spread which effects your 60 year old with hypertension which probably exists in most exists in most people's peer,friend, or family group and would really rather not die.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by samuel on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:36AM (#32850220)
Fair enough, but you are comparing a sure event (if you decide to get the vaccine) and a contingent one (getting covid). It's impossible to declare any of both as a clear winner. Furthermore the risk difference is negligible when compared to daily activities (like driving or making the dinner).

One of the problems here, and the source of a lot of trouble it's that sending nuanced messages it's very hard and goverments feared that being cautious could affect negatively to vaccination rates. So they took the simplistic path of presenting the vaccines as a silver bullet for everyone (and they were but in a very varying degree).

I can understand that decision but at the same time, it has thrown a lot of fair "skeptics" under the bus.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by michaelmrose on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:39PM (#32855658)
There is no reason to believe you can skip the vaccine and the virus indefinitely. Indeed you may encounter it nonetheless.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by blub on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:49AM (#32849038)
Your comment is a good summary of the kind of arrogance anyone pointing out problems with the vaccines was facing. When the AZ brain blood clots were discovered, when the Biontech and Moderna heart issues were discovered, etc.

IMO, your attitude is even more harmful than the typical vaccine conspiracy theories, because those are typically easily disproved!

But disguising a dogmatic attitude in the language of science is poisonous for discourse and misuses science itself.

Looking at the benefits and drawbacks of a new vaccine is the most normal thing in the world. And thanks to those that didn’t allow themselves to be bullied by misguided do-gooders is why we have a better understanding of the vaccines and doctors can explain to patients if the vaccine makes sense to them.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by yawboakye on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:35AM (#32848438)
This reads as something written at the height of anger and frustration. Unless you’re a vaccine scientist/researcher, and unless you worked on/studied COVID vaccines, you’re parroting the position of experts: both on vaccines and on skepticism of vaccine effectiveness.

Usually, in matters with very personal consequences, I don’t submit anyone’s position to the rigor of, say, a mathematical proof—irrationality is allowed. Most people refusing the vaccine have either died or survived multiple infections. I believe the individual has unquestionable sovereignty over such matter of life and death. Likewise the vaccinated dead, either from COVID infection or vaccine complication.

Overall, it’s really quite simple to understand that different people view this life thing differently and make trade-offs accordingly. It may not favor you, but calling the other sides names or applying a pretend touchstone of intellectualism is the height of intellectual laziness. Given that your position is also the position of the majority, I wonder at all if “intellectually incapable” should be used here. The majority is provably the intellectually incapable.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by michaelmrose on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:18AM (#32850073)
Re: parroting the positions of experts. How is that distinguishable from taking expert advice precisely. When I have a plumbing problem I take the expert advice of a plumber or a guide written by same unless I have good reason to doubt. Likewise with electricians, doctors and so forth. Given finite time and resources and not being able to bake a pie from scratch by inventing the universe I lean on the reasonable strategy of analyzing and synthesizing what experts have to say on a topic in order to decide on a course of action.

> Most people refusing the vaccine have either died or survived multiple infections.

Most people refusing to wear bulletproof vests into war zones have died or survived being shot at. This says nothing for the strategy whatsoever.

> I believe the individual has unquestionable sovereignty over such matter of life and death.

We were discussing whether there were reasonable antivaxxers who had arrived at their position through commendable means as opposed to ignorant folks who got their medical advice from facebook. People's right to refuse to participate in vaccination is an entirely different question.

> Likewise the vaccinated dead, either from COVID infection or vaccine complication.

It's easy to find millions of people killed by covid. Where can I find the number of people killed by the covid vaccine?

> Overall, it’s really quite simple to understand that different people view this life thing differently and make trade-offs accordingly.

Surely many things are very complicated with no clear answer. This doesn't appear to be one of them. Given the cardiovascular and lung damage apparent in even the majority of mild infections and the potentially progressive nature of repeated infection starting out vaccine naive seems to be a bad strategy for any age and one that could only have been arrived at by failing to attend to reality.

Its not intellectual laziness to attend to the body of work done by experts. It is what one does in fields in which one is not a subject matter expert. One acquires as much information as is available much of it surface level understanding and reads a variety of sources and what other sources say about those sources until you develop enough of an understanding do operate in the relevant space to the degree required to make decisions.

In this way one learns enough about automotive tech to select a good car, to drive it, and to keep it running between visits to the shop.It is entirely normal to do this without learning enough to rebuild the engine much less build or design one from scratch.

If one discovers someone else is commuting in an eastern European sedan of antique vintage which lacks seatbelts or airbags I will happily conclude without being an engineer that they are essentially "bad at picking cars" even if it comes to pass that they have what they believe is a very sophisticated understanding of engineering and can put their death trap together blindfolded.

It turns out that one doesn't need to be an engineer to read analysis that says that these two safety features are highly desirable and that they by choosing dangerous cars have chosen a notably bad strategy for not ending up a meat crayon.

> Given that your position is also the position of the majority, I wonder at all if “intellectually incapable” should be used here. The majority is provably the intellectually incapable.

Ya people are stupid but it doesn't follow that what the majority does is necessarily stupid because the majority does it ergo being a contrarian doesn't perforce make you clever either. Claims should be evaluated on their own merit.

The claim that vaccines are more dangerous than covid seems not only unfounded but unworthy.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by OrvalWintermute on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:35AM (#32848433)
> There actually really isn't any difference between the two groups. They differ only in how they articulate the same bad logic.

I think the high number of adverse events, and the weirdness around allergies, and my wife's colleague that was receiving a huge amount of pressure to get a 2nd shot, despite having a severe adverse event, has ruined it for me personally.

> Going with what your emotions proves you are intellectually incapable.

No emotions. The adverse events in any number of journals, and the VAERS reporting data, as passive surveillance which underreports signficantly, convinced me there were issues.

> I respect people with the aptitude and the niche knowledge to break new intellectual ground even if they turned out to be wrong. I do not respect the 1000 idiots following that one fellow into the brush who ignored all the other smart people going the other way and neither should you.

Please don't call anyone idiots here on HN. We read the articles, and the medical journals, and the pros and cons and came to an informed opinion, not including all the noise that was public pressure.

Having had covid, I can definitely say I am happy I did not get vaccinated. If you have a bunch of comorbidities or are old, or you want it just cause, go get it. But don't force those of us that are healthy, with no comorbidities that already did the social distancing to get some therapeutic with a shady safety record and likely negative efficacy. I don't believe we needed to rush these vaccines, or therapeutics, or whatever ineffective thing they are, out the door.

What is really tragic is when I hear about the infants with severe adverse events to these vaccines..........

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by logicchains on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:23AM (#32848314)
>Vaccines became broadly available in relatively wealthy countries in 2021 wherein the only reasonable position would have been that vaccination of all groups would decrease net mortality even among those unlikely to die and reduce damage to people's bodies that we were already seeing even with mild infections of otherwise healthy people.

It's not necessarily a reasonable position when the clinical trials themselves showed an unusually large rate of adverse events in vacinees vs the placebos: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264410X2.... The bad logic is the logic that it's okay to assess the efficiency of a novel therapeutic by the protection it provides against infection rather than by it's overall effect on excess mortality, as such an approach is going to miss any safety signals.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by alvah on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:12AM (#32849157)
"Vaccines became broadly available in relatively wealthy countries in 2021 wherein the only reasonable position would have been that vaccination of all groups would decrease net mortality even among those unlikely to die and reduce damage to people's bodies that we were already seeing even with mild infections of otherwise healthy people."

That's about the worst case of projection I've seen on HN. Just because that's your position is very far from it being the only reasonable position. There were plenty of sensible people calling for vaccination of the over 50s and other vulnerable classes at the time.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by kaptainscarlet on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:53AM (#32848617)
The risk with trusting the people with "niche knowledge" is that they are susceptible to corruption. Now, given the choice between a corrupt capitalist expert and a doubtful idiot, I'd choose the latter.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by michaelmrose on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:34PM (#32855568)
The decision all over the world wasn't bought it was cleanly made all over the world. Doubt isn't a super power and an idiot remains an idiot by definition incapable of parsing a complex choice.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by mrtksn on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:45AM (#32849387)
Many anti-vaxxer are politically motivated, in a venn diagram you can find them in the same region with the anti-globalist, national socialists, radical leftist, libertarians, anti-americans, science-sceptics etc.

The overlap is not exact, that's why I say use a venn diagram but essentially anything anti-establishment has a anti-vaxxer component since vaccinse are considered establishments' game.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by Test0129 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:47AM (#32848569)
I got my original two vaccines. I refused pfizer and moderna on principle. I refuse to get any boosters. The signal to noise ratio is basically 0 at this point and I am having a hard time "trusting the science".

You know the only people more full of shit than the anti-vaxxers? The "trust the science" shills. The anti-vaxxers may have the wrong idea but from 2020 to...well about the last few months we saw that anyone who even remotely questioned the efficacy of vaccines was "anti-science" and a "science denier". Major platforms spent millions (billions?) to kill as much of this as they could despite the fact the "fact checkers" had no idea either. Fact checkers by-and-large are editorial writers on a power trip. I don't think anyone whose been awake at the wheel for the last 4 years is surprised at this. But they gained an entirely new level of unjustified power in 2020.

A few years later all of the sudden some of the "conspiracies" were at least shown to have some veracity: the vaccines aren't nearly as effective as advertised, the studies were rushed/manipulated, boosters are not effective, the lab leak hypothesis, etc.

Now, a real "science believer" would simply change their view at this point to match the reality of the situation. We spent two years pretending we have a full view of exactly what COVID is, what caused it, where it started, etc. The truth is we have no idea. The best scientists so far can't even agree on if a booster works or not (and by works I mean is effective along a wide population of varying demographics). People are seemingly religious bound to the "wear your mask, trust the science" non-sense. If anything, these people are just as bad as the people saying the vaccine is carrying nano-robots.

If you recall, in 2020 especially, the idea that the virus originated in the BSL lab in Wuhan was put into several papers. None of which can be found anymore (at least I cannot find them). These scientists were "canceled" immediately.

There's a lot of nonsense coming out of both sides. But to pretend it's simply "those pesky anti-vaxxers" as if none of them can rub a collective two brain cells together is frankly funny. I have a feeling the Pfizer documents once fully released and analyzed will be a treasure trove of hindenberg level disasters once the religious party-line fervor comes to an end.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by mjevans on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:38AM (#32849343)
It's an evolutionary arms race. We still have the staggering spread of the virus in the wild, let alone a well controlled one like might be had with more ideal circumstances. (Circumstances of reasonable precautions, regular testing, and thoughtful actions that benefit the greater good.)

The 'bivalent' boosters, as far as I understand (non-expert), combine a widely proven safe (likely billions of individuals who've had the treatment at this point) technology and version of the vaccine, which might no longer match the dominant wild strain of the virus, with a derivative of that same vaccine tuned to that current dominant strain of the virus.

In order to be most effective that updated booster should be used while the variation it was designed to protect against is still in the wild.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by comex on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:09AM (#32848755)
Citation for boosters not working?
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:24AM (#32848861)
Citation for boosters not working?

more people have died since the shots, than before, come on bro! It's staring you in the face

https://alexberenson.substack.com/p/all-you-need-to-know-abo...

What would you consider a worthy citation source, the same people who have lied or been wrong about everything to date?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:57AM (#32849083)
Wow, that's a pretty weird misinterpretation of the data. My understanding is that almost 30% of the Israeli population refused to get vaccinated for religious reasons, which (even if you could make robust inferences from a chart like that) would throw the whole theory into doubt.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:55AM (#32849472)
There is nothing to interpret. Very simply - more people have died since the shots than before.

No need for goofy phd words like “robust inferences”

Much more than 70% of the at risk population were injected, they are the ones that are dying. That shots were sold as stopping the virus entirely, “If you get this shot you won’t get the virus” let alone die from it!

So why have there been more deaths since the shots than before?!

The shots don’t work. Not only do they not work, they are killing people. In mRNA injected countries, excess deaths are running well above historical norms.

Not only are they killing people, they are preventing people from being born. In mRNA injected countries birth rates are way down.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by VMG on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:19AM (#32850625)
Currently Russia and Iran are leading the excess death charts, neither of which use mRNA vaccines.

Birth rate trends in Israel, German and Russia are the same as in prior years

https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/DEU/germany/birth-rate

https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/ISR/israel/birth-rate

https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/RUS/russia/birth-rate

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:52PM (#32855858)
https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/dramatic-decrease-in-birth...

https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/new-data-from-germany-birt...

The effect we are talking about is something that necessarily only shows up within the past year, 9 months after young people started getting the shots.

A line chart going back 70 years is not useful here.

If you look at the data, linked above, where it is possible to see the effect I’m referring to, it is not something to blithely dismiss with a chart where it isn’t even possible for the effect to be visible.

Birth rates may be down over the long term, but year to year they are fairly stable, we are seeing moves to the downside hugely outside the range of normal year to year variability. And we are seeing it in a wide range of different populations with the commonality that we are seeing this hugely statistically significant effect occur in all these various populations like clockwork nine months after the young people in those populations started getting the shots.

>This is a continuation of my post from yesterday about a massive 13% decline in births in Germany. Such a decline is a nine-sigma event, meaning that it is so unlikely to occur by chance, that it would naturally happen as rarely as an asteroid striking the Earth

…

When expressed in “sigmas”, units of standard deviation, the 23.24% drop in the birth rate in Taiwan is a 26-sigma event!

This is can be described as “unimaginable” in terms of the likelihood of happening due to random chance

https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/depopulation-of-taiwan

https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/taiwan-birth-rate-cratered...

https://igorchudov.substack.com/?sort=search&search=Taiwan

Regarding “excess deaths,” I maybe should’ve mentioned I was referring to what has come to be called “non-COVID excess deaths.” The excess deaths are found in statistics of “all cause mortality.”

Is data for non-COVID excess deaths available for Russia and Iran?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by VMG on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:15PM (#32857134)
The "sigma event" math is very dubious

In Germany birth rates are way up for April and May

I'm sure Igor will find something else to get upset about, as hysterics typically do

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:04AM (#32850469)
I look forward to hearing your Nobel prize for Medicine speech in a number of years so.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by canoebuilder on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:03PM (#32856016)
Big, is bigger than small.

The number of people who have died from the virus after shots were introduced, that were supposed to stop people from contracting the virus, let alone dying from it, is bigger than the smaller number of people who died from the virus before the shots were introduced.

Do you find this an important data point? Do you think it is enough to win the prize? Do you want to co-author with me? Where should we publish?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by disgruntledphd2 on Friday September 16, 2022 @07:47AM (#32864830)
Honestly I probably can't tell you my actual feelings without violating the rules here.

Suffice it to say that I don't think that chart means what you think it means.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by blub on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:40AM (#32848979)
Back when Germany was considering making vaccination mandatory it was already clear that they only protect against infection for a brief time and that they’re not that effective against Omicron in the first place.

I don’t have any citations on hand, but should be easy enough to search for, especially now.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by alvah on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:06AM (#32849132)
Is your casual "anti-vaxxers" slur aimed at the pre-2020 definition of anti-vaxxer, or the more recent iteration?
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by sharken on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:16AM (#32849184)
If you're talking about multiple iterations of the term "anti-vaxxers", then I'd argue that the term itself is no longer useful.

Nowadays it is used to create an us or them division. Which in turn removes any nuances.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by jhugo on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:09AM (#32848752)
If normal public health messaging was as forthright as TWiV then misinformation might already be less of a problem.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by raspberry1337 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:12AM (#32848199)
>So many anti-vaxxers say you can't have any disagreements with the party line

What about the people who were silenced about their negative vaccine reactions...[1]

orjournalists like Alex Berenson that were banned from twitter from talking about the data? The first journalist to win against twitter in court and get unbanned, ever [2]

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/covid-vaccine-side...

[2] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2022/08/alex-...

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by trention on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:37AM (#32851737)
Calling alex berenson a journalist is a travesty. The fact that he is a crank is obvious from all his writing about marijuana that precedes the pandemic.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by raspberry1337 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:31AM (#32852636)
You are saying that someone cannot write about marijuana without being a crank? Not a very convincing point

He is the first journalist to take twitter to court and get unbanned, so he is in fact already a historical journalist, wether you agree with him or not.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by trention on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:56AM (#32852959)
I'm saying his writings about marijuana are cranckish, as can be confirmed by anyone with any expertise in the field.

>He is the first journalist to take twitter to court and get unbanned

The fact that he was a "journalist" had nothing to do either with the reason for banning him or why he was restored (he was restored solely because a twitter employee behaved like a moron).

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by maxehmookau on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:59AM (#32849501)
I wish they'd listen to anybody with any actual knowledge rather than doing "research" on Google.
[dead]
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by trention on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:35AM (#32851706)
Have you considered that a lot of people in the medical field have always been latent antivaxxers and that was just the moment to out themselves? Spoiler alert, antivaxxers are always wrong.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by dekhn on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:06AM (#32852215)
How utterly dogmatic and closed-minded.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by mcv on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:56AM (#32848653)
A problem is also that both anti-vaxxers and climate change deniers have a tendency to interpret any nuanced discussion as proof that the expert don't know either and therefore it's all a lie. It's an incredibly destructive attitude to any honest discourse.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by cm2187 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:06AM (#32848735)
But you can't negate the fact that we have also been told a lot of bullshit. I remember the same speech in Jan 2022 where the health minister of France explained that covid was dangerous for children and therefore they will mandate vaccinating children, immediately followed by the minister of education explaining that covid isn't dangerous for children, that the number of children hospitalised for covid is less than for rare diseases, and therefore they will keep schools open during the covid wave.

Should I stop believe my lying eyes?

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by mcv on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:51AM (#32849049)
That's exactly my point: if you demand that people only speak absolute truths and take any disagreement as a sign that people are intentionally lying, then you're killing any honest constructive discussion.

Clearly there was a disagreement about the danger it posed to children, and perhaps more importantly: the danger that infected children would pose for the adults around them. Because that's another frequently ignored issue: vaccination is not just about protecting the individual, but about protecting the community.

But that disagreement doesn't mean that someone is lying, and it certainly doesn't mean that everything is bullshit. It means that people disagree. And with a very new disease, that shouldn't really be a surprise to anyone. Now there was clearly also a lot of misinformation from various sources, including sometimes governments, but the only way to deal with that and figure out what's what is honest, open discussion by people who know what they're talking about.

Stop demanding absolutely truths about things we cannot yet know, and instead try to think constructively about what would be the best thing to do considering the lack of information we have to deal with.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by cm2187 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @05:19AM (#32849213)
I don’t assume nefarious intentions, I assume stupidity and incompetence.
Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by jonathanstrange on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:35AM (#32848945)
And what's bullshit about that? Did you expect French politicians to be all-knowing robots who can never be wrong?

This sounds like a run-of-the-mill political debate that hopefully in the end was decided on the basis of an expert panel. (And no, of course, medical experts are also not infallible. I don't think we have investigated a disease and responded to it as fast as to this one ever before in the history of mankind, so there were bound to be made some wrong or misleading hypotheses.)

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by 988747 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:01AM (#32849518)
>> Did you expect French politicians to be all-knowing robots who can never be wrong?

I would expect government members making decisions to consult expert virologists/epidemiologists first. The fact that they can make two contradictory statements means that either they did not consult any experts, or they consulted different experts, which means there is no consensus among experts on the topic.

Re:Denmark not offering second Covid booster shot to healthy... by jonathanstrange on Friday September 16, 2022 @05:03AM (#32863844)
Incorrect logic. One of the French politicians could have consulted experts and the other one might not, for instance. That's not uncommon. In other countries that happened all the time, think about Donald Trump musing about injecting bleach to kill the virus. Personally, I'd vote for the politicians who follow expert advise in such matters.