News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by cletus on Monday July 04, 2022 @03:30PM (#31980824)
People who've never spent significant time in the UK may not appreciate the significance that pbus have played in the UK culture and social structure. Pubs have for many eyars been a social nexus. You wouldn't even go to drink necessarily but just go by default because that's what everyone else was doing.

These are quite typically "locals" rather than going somewhere to go to a pub in particular.

So this is really a long term trend in the changing social structure of the UK. Pubs are becoming less important socially, probably conciding with the rise of Internet culture and online connectedness. But also real estate prices come into play. Pubs sit on some valuable land, particularly in London. Costs go up to the point where you might be paying 8 pounds for a pint. That gets really expensive.

I haven't seen anything close to this in the US. Take something like the bar in How I Met Your Mother. Obviously this is all fictional and these characters spen da lot of time there but it's still portrayed as extremely intentional, meaning plans are made to meet there. UK pub culture doesn't tend to be that intentional about meeting particular people but rather hanging out where others may or may not show up.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by xyzzy123 on Monday July 04, 2022 @05:02PM (#31981746)
IMHO an under-appreciated side effect of rising property values is the destruction of third places (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place), a role that pubs often filled in the UK. As land values rise the pressure to make a return on any given space goes up. Leads to fewer places to "hang out" without strong pressure to spend money.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by OscarCunningham on Monday July 04, 2022 @05:39PM (#31982029)
Damn. Working from home I don't even have a second place.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by cletus on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#31982715)
And with skyrocketing rents and house prices, hanging on that first place presents a challenge.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by astrange on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:47PM (#31982876)
Land value tax would solve this.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @06:08AM (#31986364)
Don’t know why you think giving the government even more money is gonna solve anything.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by astrange on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:41PM (#31992068)
Taxation doesn’t give the government money; the government is the source of money and can create more if it wants to. Taxation destroys money, which is good if you think there’s too much of it.

(Some exceptions to this model due to federalism, since state and local governments don’t get to create money except by issuing bonds and getting federal funds for unwise construction projects.)

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by maest on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @08:02AM (#31987161)
You're lazily strawmanning and failing to offer an alternative to a constructive suggestion.

This comment has negative value.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by seoaeu on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:44PM (#31983438)
Perhaps in the very long term. But drastically increasing taxes on property would certainly not improve things for home owners who'd still have to keep paying their mortgage as well. And even renters would likely find their landlord passing on much of the taxes...
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by astrange on Monday July 04, 2022 @10:22PM (#31983646)
The solution for low-income groups we want to protect (like retirees in their primary home) is generally to defer the tax until their home is sold. And ideally it would reduce their cost of living for other reasons, since land value near them would be deflated and properties would be improved so there's more workers in the area, there's less reliance on other regressive taxes like sales tax, etc.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by nivenkos on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:48AM (#31985517)
You don't want to protect groups like that, as it means that they tie up valuable properties in economic centres and workers can't afford to live there. The failures of rent control in Sweden for example, are a great example of this.

Tax wealth, not work. Income tax should be near zero (especially <$100k), and instead tax property with land value tax, property tax, inheritance tax, etc. so that people can work their way up.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by astrange on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @06:33AM (#31986514)
The main reason you want to do that is they're the average voter. Young people don't vote. They also might not have a community/family/friends anymore and might not be capable of relocating.

LVT is a better-designed alternative to property tax; taxing property (improvements to land) has the downside that you want people to improve their land, and taxing that would cause deadweight loss.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by Ericson2314 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:43AM (#31984744)
Homeownership cannot be saved. Do LVT and maybe bsil out people with underwater mortgages with a debt rightoff, but do not preserve SFH ownership.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by shakezula on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:10AM (#31988383)
This is my biggest complaint with the remote revolution right now. I don’t get out of my house anymore during the week and it makes me sort of stir crazy by the weekend.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by sp527 on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:06PM (#31983253)
Wouldn't it be more aptly described as a conflict between the relative rate of increase in (urban) property value vs wages ? Arguably entirely a function of monetary policy for the past decade plus.

[0] https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2021/05/how-uk-house-p...

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by s0rce on Monday July 04, 2022 @08:50PM (#31983161)
Going to church or other religious assembly seems like your only option, doesn't work for me though.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by DaiPlusPlus on Monday July 04, 2022 @10:09PM (#31983575)
Ever considered becoming a furry instead?
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by ehvatum on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:29AM (#31989368)
As a way to destroy property values, sure, all the time
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by adhesive_wombat on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:00PM (#31982580)
> You wouldn't even go to drink necessarily but just go by default because that's what everyone else was doing.

Price, health aspects, time (when two people work full time, fitting in hours of drinking is harder) and possibly good availability of alternative neuro-affective substances aside, I think this is the actual "problem" pubs have now.

Not long ago, in living memory even of millennials, "going down the local" was literally your only option in a lot of rural and suburban places.

People just have things to do with friends these days that tickle the dopamine centres more than cheap beer, dirty toilets and sticky carpets. Phones, games, thousands of hours of TV and films, hacking on Linux kernel drivers over Discord, whatever. You don't even have to always physically meet up any more to hang out, and you certainly don't have to pay by the minute for telecoms any more. Once the network effect of "that's just where my mates are going to be" is gone, so are you.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by bencollier49 on Monday July 04, 2022 @03:58PM (#31981134)
Pubs were closing long before the internet appeared, albeit in smaller numbers.

The main driver, in my opinion, is specialisation. We've got a much more professional workforce these days, with more specialist skills, who for this reason often have to travel for some distance to get to their places of work. That means far less time to go to the pub. Combined with modern media, it's just easier to sit indoors. People have posted other points elsewhere on this thread - they're all contributing (plus drink driving laws and smoking bans).

I mean, a lot of people used to stop working at lunchtime and spend the afternoon in the pub.

Now, if home working holds up, and then inflation abates a bit, perhaps pubs might regain an advantage, but I fear we're now in a new "steady state", and it'd take more to change things back.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by calvinmorrison on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:02PM (#31983239)
25c beers, air conditioning and a color TV that always had the Phils on, yeah our local pub was always packed during the baseball season.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by jmharvey on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:00AM (#31984481)
Out of curiosity, when was that? The last time I was in a place with 25c beers, I was watching the 2001 Daytona 500.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by zimpenfish on Monday July 04, 2022 @03:33PM (#31980858)
> probably conciding with the rise of Internet culture and online connectedness

Possibly also related to the greater ease of accessing, e.g., sports on TV compared with 10-15 years ago - now you don't need a satellite dish etc., you can just stream Sky Sports over the internet which cuts out the need to find a pub showing whatever match you wanted (assuming you're not doing it as a social activity.)

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by acjohnson55 on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:26PM (#31982747)
When I studied abroad in Wales, it was literally the only thing to do in the evening. We had no TV. We didn't even have wifi at first (they added it a few weeks into the term). The student village wasn't a short walk from anything of interest. Everyone hung at the pub at the center of the student village.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by tomcam on Monday July 04, 2022 @10:10PM (#31983581)
I’m a nondrinker but that sounds great
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by WastingMyTime89 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:30PM (#32003313)
Lived something fairly similar in the UK a decade ago. It was great especially when you consider how pubs are organised. The place makes it very easy to come and go and as service is at the bar and you can order both food and alcohol you don’t really feel pressured into drinking. That’s the part of the UK culture I miss the most.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by OJFord on Monday July 04, 2022 @04:06PM (#31981219)
> UK pub culture doesn't tend to be that intentional about meeting particular people but rather hanging out where others may or may not show up.

Interesting, other than 'the locals' propping up the bar, that's not my experience at all.

I think going to each other's homes (on a smaller scale and in a less organised way than 'a party') is more common now. For whatever reason, I wouldn't like to say, could be fashion, could be the other side of 'the pub is too expensive', or something else.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by Atheros on Monday July 04, 2022 @04:51PM (#31981644)
I want to raise another contributor: volume. At most bars in large cities, if I'm in a group of six people, I can not hear someone talking who isn't sitting directly next to me.

The parent commenter said "Take something like the bar in [the television show] How I Met Your Mother. Obviously this is all fictional and these characters spend a lot of time there". The only reason they can meet there and hear each other is because the bar is silent and they're actually on a sound stage. Watch any show where any characters interact at a bar: they talk comfortably in a way that would not work in real life.

Bars and restaurants have simply gotten measurably louder to the point where people are choosing to meet at home instead. When English Pubs and U.S. speakeasies became popular, amplified music was not a thing. Even the name "speakeasy" comes from the fact that people could and did speak quietly in the bars!

> But consider a 1993 study of about a dozen dining establishments, which found that sound levels peaked at 68 decibels (a little louder than normal chitchat). Compare that with a much larger 2018 survey of New York City restaurants, in which one-quarter hit at least 81 decibels (more like a garbage disposal), the average level was 77, and just 10 percent were 70 decibels or below. The report deemed those “quiet.”

https://www.popsci.com/story/technology/restaurant-noise-lev...

Scientific papers abound

https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=...

> There are increasing numbers of reports from patrons complaining about the difficulty in conversing with fellow diners due to loud venues. In Zagat’s 2016 Annual Survey, when surveyors were asked what irritated them the most about dining out, noise was the second highest complaint (25%) behind poor service (28%). But in major urban cities of San Francisco, Boston, Portland and New York City, noise was the number one complaint [34]

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by dpeck on Monday July 04, 2022 @05:03PM (#31981755)
This is a huge thing to me and many others who I’ve spoken with. My spouse seems to be able to handle it just fine, but to me it’s just a wall of sound all around me and it has led to frustration that they cannot hear me and I cannot hear them.

It’s become true at even many very “nice” restaurants as the open kitchen, open spaces, and hard surfaces everywhere aesthetic has taken over nearly everything.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by maerek on Monday July 04, 2022 @05:57PM (#31982163)
Strong seconding here. I have a low voice that doesn’t travel well in noisy environments. It’s pretty tiring having to shout an entire night out just to converse across the table.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by Atheros on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:01AM (#31984845)
I've found that people cannot think deeply about much of anything when it's loud. They can answer simple fact-based questions about themselves and not much else. Useless.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by ascorbic on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:53AM (#31984800)
That's not something I'd say applies in the UK. Save for large city-centre pubs on Friday night, most are relatively quiet. If it's too loud to have a conversation then someobody is guaranteed to ask them to turn it down. Having a conversation is one of the main reasons to go to the pub. It's pretty much the only place in the UK where it's normal to strike up conversation with a stranger.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by viraptor on Monday July 04, 2022 @06:01PM (#31982186)
> Even the name "speakeasy" comes from the fact that people could and did speak quietly in the bars!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speakeasy

The more common explanation is that it's a place where you have to speak easy to not attract attention.

It makes sense too, since without amplified music being popular why would the speakeasy be specifically quiet rather than just "like everywhere else".

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by DoughnutHole on Monday July 04, 2022 @09:00PM (#31983231)
Eh, here in Ireland nearly anywhere I'd describe as a "pub" is still relatively quiet unless it's a busy night with live music. Most pubs don't have particularly loud piped music, or they have none at all.

Now there are a host of modern "bars" with extended drink and cocktail menus and cacophonous piped music, especially in city centres. But in most traditional pubs the ambient noise comes almost entirely from the patrons.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by OJFord on Monday July 04, 2022 @04:59PM (#31981701)
Very good point.

It's worse than not fixing it, the trend is to make it worse, by removing soft furnishings etc.

Saw an article recently on loud restaurants (the loudest in the world are in London, followed by SF iirc) - the top few in London were measured as so loud that per the law (I assume it's not known/adhered to) they have to provide staff with hearing protection from the injurious volume!

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by laurencerowe on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:13PM (#31982662)
I’ve read that bars getting louder was in part deliberate since people drink more quickly when they have a hard time having a conversation.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by SoftTalker on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:29PM (#31982761)
Yeah. In restaurants it's also to increase table turnover.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by ascagnel_ on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:04AM (#31984509)
> The parent commenter said "Take something like the bar in [the television show] How I Met Your Mother. Obviously this is all fictional and these characters spend a lot of time there". The only reason they can meet there and hear each other is because the bar is silent and they're actually on a sound stage. Watch any show where any characters interact at a bar: they talk comfortably in a way that would not work in real life.

The bar in the show is (very) loosely based on a real-world location: McGee's Pub in midtown Manhattan. While I haven't visited in quite a few years, when I did visit, the pub was typically quiet enough to have a conversation at your table without raising your voice.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by cletus on Monday July 04, 2022 @08:44PM (#31983134)
I'm with you on group size and volume. I'll add another: a lot of bars tend to be annoyingly dark. Volume could either be music or TV. Sports bars are big in the US.

When faced with unkowns, I'll tend to gravitate to hotel bars for this reason. Not too busy, not too loud, not too dark, as a general rule.

It's also why i tend to prefer going out to eat at off-peak times.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by LegitShady on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:20PM (#31982710)
>Bars and restaurants have simply gotten measurably louder to the point where people are choosing to meet at home instead. When English Pubs and U.S. speakeasies became popular, amplified music was not a thing. Even the name "speakeasy" comes from the fact that people could and did speak quietly in the bars!

I agree 100% there are even some 'trendy' stores I've visited where the volume of the music was so loud I just left and have never gone back. There are some 'clubs' that are just immediate hearing loss damage, and everyone who goes there will pay for it later in life. Just a massive wall of sound that is waaaay outside safe hearing for any length of time - noisier than any construction zone.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by Atheros on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @01:58AM (#31984826)
People aren't meant to talk on a dance floor and wearing earplugs is common.

Bars and the quieter zones of clubs are different though: we're meant to socialize. People are opting out of the whole thing and I think it's because of the volume. Go to any bar during the summer that has music inside and a quiet outside and watch where most people go.

I strongly think that the patrons themselves don't actually recognize why they even like outside so much better.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by mecha_ghidorah on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:10PM (#32009209)
Wait. If people are wearing ear plugs why not just have the music at a volume where it doesn't literally damage and hurt people instead? I am so confused
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by Handytinge on Friday July 15, 2022 @07:49PM (#32113966)
Well then the people with the earplugs in couldn't hear, could they?
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by robonerd on Monday July 04, 2022 @10:36PM (#31983732)
Even without music or a TV playing, many bars can be deafening simply due to the way the room is designed and decorated. There is a lot that can be done to address this, like sound baffles on the ceiling, but most bars either don't care or prefer to keep the room loud.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by stevekemp on Monday July 04, 2022 @11:12PM (#31983912)
Yeah in the UK I could go to a pub by myself and find people to chat with and hang out with.

In Finland? People don't get social like that. People in bars will stare at their tables and drink for an hour or five, then leave - but not speak to others.

(OK sometimes it happens, especially later at night, but the idea of going to a bar here for company is very alien.)

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by cercatrova on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:36PM (#31982806)
I've heard this is because homes in the UK are comparatively smaller than in the US, so UKers go to pubs and other Third Places while Americans meet at their houses.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by nicoburns on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:43PM (#31982850)
That and pubs and 3rd spaces are closer. I have a pub 30 second walk from my house. Probably 10 within a 20 minute radius (walking).
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by cercatrova on Monday July 04, 2022 @07:47PM (#31982878)
Indeed. In the US, unless you live in a city or a suburb with shopping complexes within walking distance, you have to drive to a pub.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by vinay427 on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @02:50AM (#31985153)
I’m sure it’s one factor but probably not a defining characteristic. There are several countries with more similar home sizes to the UK in continental Europe that at least anecdotally seem to prefer meeting in homes, sometimes even more than in the US.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by dan-robertson on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:39AM (#31985446)
Regarding the land prices argument, I think there are a reasonable number of buildings which must be run as pubs and may not be e.g. converted to more lucrative uses. Though the local economy does influence the prices that must be paid for labour and the prices customers will be willing to pay. I expect you’re more likely to do well as a pub by having e.g. a wide rotating selection of beers rather than trying to compete with spoons on price.

A separate issue may be rent. The pub in my parents’ village was owned and successfully run by some locals for a while until they wanted to retire and sold it to a large company. That company would then lease the pub to people who would either fail to do well (and cause the village to get fed up with the pub) or do well only to have the owning company turn around and try to increase rents (and offer those people no reasonable path by which they might come to own the pub themselves), driving them away by making the business unsustainable.

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by sirodoht on Monday July 04, 2022 @08:09PM (#31982986)
Interesting to note the etymology, as well. Pub comes from "public house"; a house for the public.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by secretsatan on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @03:29AM (#31985386)
It's not just that pubs have to pay more for real estate, so do all their customers, and house prices have long outpaced wages in the UK. This will affect the younger generations more, but I always see it framed as "Young people just don't go out like they used to", rather than, "Young people have less disposable income and can't afford to go out like they used to"
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by codeulike on Monday July 04, 2022 @05:05PM (#31981769)
... pbus ... eyars ...

- typed while in the pbu, clearly

Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by wyclif on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @10:32AM (#31988629)
The article doesn't mention it, but another consideration regarding change in the UK is demographics. In areas of London where there has been an influx of Muslim immigrants, the local pubs tend to close down due to lack of demand.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by umanwizard on Saturday July 09, 2022 @04:34PM (#32039044)
Muslims are less than 5% of the UK population, so Islam can at most account for only a small part of the decline.
Re:Number of pubs in England and Wales falls to record low by selimthegrim on Monday July 04, 2022 @03:41PM (#31980955)
You should try visiting New Orleans.