> Tenant screening companies compile information beyond what’s in renters’ credit reports, including criminal and eviction filings. They say this data helps give landlords a better idea of who will pay on time and who will be a good tenant. The firms typically assign applicants scores or provide landlords a yes-or-no recommendation.
> A ProPublica review found that such ratings have come to serve as shadow credit scores for renters. But compared to credit reporting, tenant screening is less regulated and offers fewer consumer protections — which can have dire consequences for applicants trying to secure housing.
These tenant protections come up because governments want their cake and eat it too. If you live in a functional housing market the need for tenant protections also decrease, because more people can afford to rent places!
But we could have it both ways pretty easily (if political will is there). Meaning, protect both parties from abusive people on the other side.
US is doing somethign similar to this, except its being done by companies rather than the government.
Brooklyn and Queens; formerly "affordable" places to live in New York, are now getting $4,000 (or more)/mo for 1-bedroom cribs. I've seen it with my own eyes, in Manhattan. Areas like Alphabet City, that used to be considered "dangerous," are now primo real estate, and well-dressed young couples walk their toy poodles around these neighborhoods.
It's only a matter of time, before NYC becomes an East Coast San Francisco. Manhattan is pretty much there.
I am not personally familiar with the way France is structured, but I have been told that the cities are where the wealthy live, and the suburbs are where the not-wealthy live.
From what I have seen, Seattle is becoming that way. I was pretty surprised, when I visited some friends, down in the suburbs south of Seattle, and saw that it was actually a rather scruffy area. I had gotten used to Bellevue and Redmond.
Unless there have been major changes in the last few years, many of those buildings will not, in fact, be filled with yuppies. They'll sit vacant, parking the money of the world's ultrarich in a low-tax investment.
If you don't build new housing, then the people who can afford it will just end up driving up the price of older homes. Alphabet City is expensive now because they didn't build enough apartments in the East Village to meet the demand from people who want to live in that area.
So long as the total number of units increases, it really doesn't matter how much they cost, so long as they get filled. Increased supply will bring down rents at the less expensive end of the market.
New rental-only builds were even going up in the area, not just condos. But they were more expensive to rent than the bloody condos, and about 3/4 the size.
How awful. The government should do something about this kind of degradation.
Supply is supply, and there's only so much real estate in NYC.
Buisness dump invested money into expensive building. If no one rents then it stays vacant. Why vacant, isnt the landlord going to lose money? well yes but if he rents a lower amount then his valuation goes down and he is suddenly upside down on his loan. So he is compelled to not rent versus renting it.
Add to this governments make more tax yearly if its valued hire and now there is no incentive to fix this.
More about the tax: https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/taxes/speculation-vacancy...
https://vancouversun.com/business/real-estate/three-years-in...
I hear Italy is the same way. Source: Gomorrah
London literally has tens of thousands of dwellings sitting empty. Many are investment properties and will be sold multiple times without ever being lived in.
It's easy to make money at the high end from rising property values without the hassle of dealing with tenants.
It's easy to make money at the low end by packing as many tenants as possible into small properties and spending as little as possible on maintenance. There's occasionally some legal hassle with evictions, but generally for landlords it's a seller's market, with minimal regulation and enforcement.
There is, indeed, tens of thousands of empty homes in London. In a city with millions of homes. Current statistics show a vacancy rate of 2.2% [1], which is an incredibly low rate, which implies a pathologically supply-constrained market. Additionally, there is no evidence to support that even a statistically relevant proportion of those empty homes are empty for investment purposes; vacancies can happen for a number of reasons, including being between tenants, non-primary homes, etc.
That said all rental projects that I know of in Maine and New Hampshire are all rented before they even finish construction.
EDIT: I'd also like to make a point about current regulation and zoning. It's not unusual for a developer to pay around $500,000 or more in state fees, environmental review, and layer time to get a new apartment complex approved. This requires insider connections and specialized knowledge of the municipality if you want it completed in a reasonable time frame. Partially this is because national building codes are more complicated then ever but more often building anything at all requires a zoning exception or amendment.
If you pull of the zoning maps for your town or city you'll likely find it riddled with parcels that have been cut out or otherwise exempted from the rest of the zone. This process can be expensive and take years to complete.
If a complex had 500 units, thats a negligible cost
[1] https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-research/plans-reports/docs/pa...
A house is made up of individual pieces of wood, drywall, bricks that are "under 10% of the cost" individually by the single piece but when stacked up they absolutely help explain the (much greater) cost of the house. It's going to be difficult to point to a single smoking gun; with housing it's death by a thousand cuts (in California development fees are one of the bigger ones).
See, e.g., https://www.accessmagazine.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/20...
Doesn't seem to have done much to keep housing prices under control, and houses still sell so fast that you blink and a new listing will be gone. We can't possibly be a major location for internal migration—not like cities in California or Texas or anything of that sort—so IDK what's up with that. My 20ish year old McMansion has increased in value about 30% over the last two years, and was already way up from just a few years earlier. WTF.
I think of the ugliness of the facades as a bonus that would drive wealthier people to other buildings once options open up a bit.
See e.g. Portland, Oregon's façade articulation guidelines: https://www.portland.gov/sites/default/files/2020/lu_buildin...
Fed/State government can issues credits/tax relief for "investors" who build MDUs but somehow starter homes are off the table?
It's not all doom and gloom, Habitat For Humanity appears to be the only outfit that's building affordable houses/starter homes, helps when you get a nice influx of money going into that program (thanks MacKenzie Scott).
No, it isn't. Back in the early 1970s, the US was averaging about 2.4 million housing units started per year [0]. And at the time US population was only about 210 million, compared to 330 million today...
Want to talk about trickle down effects!
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/07/09/before-covi...
160,000 / 5 years / 12 months = 2,666 per month = negligible compared to US population growth of ~0.6% (167,500).
It's almost as if there's another thing to blame beside Mexican Boogeymen...
That isn't exactly true!
Chapter 7 bankruptcy remains on your report for up to 10 years, and Chapter 13 stays there for up to seven years. [1]
Chapter 7, which is known as liquidation bankruptcy, involves selling some or all of your property to pay off your debts. This is often the choice if you don't own a home and have a limited income.
Chapter 13, also known as a reorganization bankruptcy, gives you the chance to keep your property (including secured assets like your home and car) if you successfully complete a court-mandated repayment plan that lasts between three and five years.
[1] https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/bankruptcy-chapt...
Because you lack empathy and perspective? People can be forced into bankruptcy for all sorts of reasons that are largely beyond their control (such as the example you are implicitly referring to in the article). Doesn't mean they should be homeless (or limited to the most marginal of housing conditions) for the rest of their life. Especially if they have nursed their score back to a reasonable state of health.
A tenant can easily pay rent two or three times, and then stretch out the eviction proceedings for 6 to 18 months depending on the state.
This seems overdrawn (i.e. out of synch with reality). In the one state for which I am intimately familiar with these proceedings (and another certain very large blue state that I did a fair amount of research on at one point), a properly executed eviction proceeding should take no more than 120 days or so, even assuming delays in the court calendar (except in weird outlier cases like the city can't determine the zoning or protection status of the property, etc).
I can imagine there a few states with as grossly dysfunctional (general case) eviction proceeding standards like you describe, but not ... all that many states.
If you have a bankruptcy on your credit report, no landlord in their right mind is going to want to rent to you.
It's very easy to stretch out an eviction for a very long time, it's not fun, but it's doable.
Here's the rub, a mom and pop landlord can't have half their tenants not pay rent for 6 months, but Greystone can. And big corporate landlords are more likely to be strict when it comes to renters.
In other words, that "6 to 18 months" number was just basically made up.
What's their to debate, COVID had 2 year long eviction moratoriums in some parts
No - per the example in the article, you are proven to have the misfortune of living in a country with a corrupt and dysfunctional healthcare system.
No -- you do not have "no" say. But but the law says there are limits in the criteria you can use to reject candidates.
Of which you (as a landlord) are presumably already perfectly aware. As you are of the fact that minute you move out (and establish another legal residence) -- it's no longer your "home".
It's my property.
Sorry, but this isn't an Ayn Rand novel. In real life, property ownership does not give you 100 percent freedom to do what ever you want with your property. It is a social contract, with obligations and limits.
But it's less well-known that Chapter 13 bankruptcies stay on your credit report for 7 years, which had already passed. Chapter 13 represents about one-third of all bankruptcies.
Chapter 13 is less common, because it's more difficult to go through, and takes longer, but it has substantial benefits.
The article doesn't say what chapter she filed under, but it's easily plausible that it was Chapter 13, and the bankruptcy had already fallen off her credit report.
the US is doing a much shadowier version of china's social credit system. At least with china, its up front and in your face, with this it is much more background and insidious.
Around here (Maryland), landlords are required to offer leases up to 2 years (this might be a county law), although I suspect 12 month leases are still common.
At the end of a lease, MD law requires the lease to default into a month-to-month lease. To kick a tenent out without cause, a landlord need only provide 30 days notice.
However, if the tenent refuses to vacate, the landlord still needs to go through the eviction process.
I've wondered about taking a different approach: The landlord is free to evict on the day of delinquency, but must move the possessions to a storage facility (paying a month's rent at that time) and they must post a substantial bond. If the tenant shows the eviction was improper they get the bond + costs. (And I would apply the same thing to foreclosures.)
Instead of a long process of showing that they are acting properly they are putting up a substantial financial promise that they are acting properly. Make improper actions a costly mistake and there will be few of them.
The quickest way to get landlords to become less selective is to say "any vacant apartment/home not occupied by at least one fulltime resident can be claimed by someone homeless as of [date]." You'd have landlords begging people to sign leases (and people would because then they would get a sure nice apartment as opposed to a lottery for one of the few ones left).
Now, that produces bad other results, but so does allowing people's homes to be ripped away from them at a moments notice.
This is basically extreme squatter's rights. Places which have those produce some combination of people paying guards, those who can't afford guards taking matters into their own hands, people demolishing perfectly-good housing to avoid risking the land, et cetera.
You’re proposing to reassign millions of dollars of property based on various levels of evidence for whether someone was physically present? That’s basically the 90s in Russia.
It’s certainly a neat fictional universe. I imagine everyone who can afford to would live in a hotel, leaving the scramble of defending your property to those who can’t. Also, fraud. Lots of fraud.
After a couple years, nice family leaves, so you spend long time to find another nice family to fit into the house you worked hard to provide. Instead Kommisar come along, give house to homeless in name of proletariat. Social welfare bureau hold lottery, and the neighborhood violent drunk under the bridge is ecstatic his number came up, as he was very sad he no longer has home to beat wife in. Much vodka is drunk while copper piping is gutted and appliances scrapped to dealers in nearby Ossetia.
Sit back and cry: I work on potato farm for 15 years to build nice second home to house hard working families! Instead government create lottery and hands to drunk who destroys house in only 15 days. Decide to stop trying. Start drinking everyday. Become a drunk yourself, enter the lottery, now you gut houses of others to survive. Process repeats -- now all units look like Grozny in the late 90s.
Mission accomplished.
Responsible people who don't rip up housing are sought after and pay a reasonable rental rate. People who buy and sit on property are taken out of the system. A new equilibrium is reached and most people take reasonable care of their rental properties they are given because they don't want to have to enter lotteries that will likely end them up in a slum. Homeless people end up in better than the street.
Everyone has a primary residence. I'm saying, if the only goal is to force landlords to rent out houses, simply have any residential property without at least one person identifying it as their primary residence given away by the state, ideally in a lottery. It would only change things for landlords. And I don't know what "fraud" would be engaged in. I suppose a couple could rent two apartments only needing one, but I don't see why a landlord would do that as opposed to renting to someone who presumably wants it and would pay money.
You’re not sure they will pay the money or not trash the place. Same reason landlords are hesitant about renting in the real world.
In any case, this would be defeated by enlisting family members as back-up primary residents. (As in the old world, when property rights were enforced at sword point, sucks to be someone without a dependable family.) Though, again, the wealthy would likely opt out of renting and favour not owning or just own a single massive house and opt out of renting.
The fraud would be in people lying about their primary residences. Also, people lying about others’ lack of primary residence to appropriate their homes for their cronies. The injured family would be homeless while fighting for their property back, which somewhat compromises their ability to engage.
I don't see how. The family members still have to live somewhere. Oh no, the person rents to their kid as opposed to a stranger! It still means that wherever that kid was going to live otherwise isn't rented out to them and is on the market.
> fraud would be in people lying about their primary residences.
Yeah, I don't see how. Everyone gets one. So, if you don't need a home and are responsible maybe you get hired to rent out an empty place? It doesn't scale.
> people lying about others’ lack of primary residence to appropriate their homes for their cronies.
That's stupid. It seems just as possible as people lying to get your bank account. There are all kinds of ways that people have to let the government know where their primary residence is.
The kid could have been living at home. One spouse in one house, one spouse in the other. Et cetera.
> just as possible as people lying to get your bank account
You're proposing an ad hoc centralized mechanism for expropriating and re-assigning a multi-trillion dollar asset class. This has clear and one-way precedence in history.
Yes. If the "super-fraud" is that 18 year olds move out to unclaimed apartments or that couples can have a vacation house, I am remarkably okay with that.
> You're proposing an ad hoc centralized mechanism for expropriating and re-assigning a multi-trillion dollar asset class. This has clear and one-way precedence in history.
Except for the ad-hoc nature, the fact that property records and ownership (as well as lists of people's primary residences) are already centralized, that centralization and decentralization of real estate have precedence within the same society at different times, I totally agree. So I guess that's "multi-trillion dollar asset class" I agree with.
What an entitled viewpoint. It's not their home; an entirely different person owns it and they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it. The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.
It's not their house. It certainly is their home. I would prefer those be the same person as often as possible to align incentives.
> they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it
Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.
It's not uncommon for landlords to be the first party to breach the contract either intentionally (e.g. losing checks to move a tenant at below market rates out), neglectfully (e.g. ignoring upkeep or repairs) or unintentionally (e.g. entering at will).
Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.
> The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.
Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.
If you take something you're obliged to pay for without paying for it, it isn't "yours."
>Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.
Minimum wage is another thing that crushes the poor, as do eviction protections. Both serve to make jobs/housing (respectively) more difficult for the poor to acquire via regulatory barriers.
>Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.
Conversely, withholding housing from a breaching tenant is appropriate.
>Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.
In the US, "Home" can simply mean a house [1]. My apologies if you're using a different dialect of English and I misunderstood; I was using home as it's used in one common interpretation of the word in English in my country.
[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/home : refer to 1b
Although I don't see how that clause would be enforceable. A tenant almost certainly doesn't have enough assets to go after to make up for a building. Otherwise they could have bought the home for their own use.
Unfortunately, temporarily homeless people have a habit of turning into chronic homeless people. And living in a city that's full of chronic homeless people, I don't think we need more.
Your comfort and convenience as a landlord does not rank higher than my desire to not step over human shit on my way to work.
Your comfort and convenience to have the option not to pay a landlord does not rank higher than the desire of homeless to have better access to housing. Places with homeless problems badly need to remove these protections from renters.
Eviction protections are incredibly helpful at preventing people on the margin from ending up homeless, by increasing the friction of evictions for landlords. This is absolutely necessary, because the cost to the tenant of getting kicked out of where they live is enormous - doubly and triply so if you are the kind of marginal person that gets kicked out of their home. It is incredibly disruptive to their life - much moreso than for someone in a stable situation not being able to find a different place to live.
Remove friction from evictions, and everyone on the margins is constantly at risk of losing their home - and once you do so, your ability to stay afloat becomes incredibly precarious.
If, on one extreme, tenancies were for life, and you had no way to kick someone out of a unit, you'd have an 'unfair' but stable distribution of housing. There would be very few life disruptions to people's lives, at the cost of housing being stuck in a local optimum.
If, on the other extreme, tenancies were day to day, and you constantly had to outbid other contenders for your apartment, you'd have a 'fair' but incredibly unstable distribution of housing. Between the incredibly high pain of moving/looking for a new place to live, anyone on the margins would suffer incredibly from this.
Economists rage against a stable but 'suboptimal' distribution of goods. But people whose lives constantly get upended from the instabilities of an 'optimal' distribution of goods are the ones who will suffer.
Harm minimization is exactly why there is more friction to throwing someone out of their house than 'the landlord feels like it'.
These protections determine that quality of tenant preferred is higher, thus vulnerably are forced away during a shortage. For those who are accepted, risks mean increased housing costs and thus lower access to the poor.
>Eviction protections are incredibly helpful at preventing people on the margin from ending up homeless, by increasing the friction of evictions for landlords. This is absolutely necessary, because the cost to the tenant of getting kicked out of where they live is enormous. It is incredibly disruptive to their life - much moreso than not being able to find a different place to live.
Eviction protections are incredibly _harmful_ at allowing those on the margin to avoid homelessness, by increasing the friction of becoming a tenant. This is absolutely unnecessary, because the cost of a tenant refusing to leave after non-payment can be _enormous_. It is incredibly disruptive to the housing market -- much more so than not being able to find a different tenant to rent to.
>Remove friction from evictions, and everyone on the margins is constantly at risk of losing their home - and once you do so, your ability to stay afloat becomes incredibly precarious.
I'd argue the opposite, those at the margins who are able to meet their commitment but otherwise look bad at paper are at incredibly higher likelihood to gain a home -- and once you gain a home, your ability to stay afloat becomes much less precarious.
>If, on one extreme, tenancies were for life, and you had no way to kick someone out of a unit, you'd have an 'unfair' but stable distribution of housing. There would be very few life disruptions to people's lives, at the cost of housing being stuck in a local optimum.
This is achievable via something close to the 99-year leases available in many nations, where you prepay the lease up-front. You can negotiate for one of these if you can find a voluntary counterparty.
>If, on the other extreme, tenancies were day to day, and you constantly had to outbid other contenders for your apartment, you'd have a 'fair' but incredibly unstable distribution of housing. Between the incredibly high pain of moving/looking for a new place to live, anyone on the margins would suffer incredibly from this.
That's basically what a hotel is, which those on the margins often end up in due to renter protections that introduce risk for landlords to take in those on the margins.
>Economists rage against a stable but 'suboptimal' distribution of goods. But people whose lives constantly get upended from the instabilities of an 'optimal' distribution of goods are the ones who will suffer.
Renter protections make it look more 'optimal' to rent to the rich and stable. We're actually in a suboptimal state that disfavors the homeless, and allowing a freer market would give better opportunities to the homeless.
>Harm minimization is exactly why there is more friction to throwing someone out of their house than 'the landlord feels like it'.
Increasing regulatory barriers to homeless gaining housing is harm maximization, and should be eliminated. These renter protections maximize harm.
I am sirry but this sounds like youve never seen the bottomn of the housing market and what actually goes on there, and basically live in cloud coocooland.
I know a landlord who should be in jail for abusing student tenants, commiting fraud on deposits, renting out houses with mold, rats and leaking riofs, without working heating. Safety railing on stairs sre attached with hot glue. After years of criminality she got a RangeRover and a small fine.
>I am sirry but this sounds like youve never seen the bottomn of the housing market and what actually goes on there, and basically live in cloud coocooland.
Well at one point (and not so long ago) I lived in a closet in a basement for ~$100 a month in a relatively nice part of Oregon, and frankly I was damn happy someone was willing to look beyond the "formal" means available. Had only the "legitimate" means been available to me, I definitely would have been homeless. Renter protections would have eliminated the only housing available to me. I'm definitely no stranger to "substandard" housing.
>I know a landlord who should be in jail for abusing student tenants, commiting fraud on deposits, renting out houses with mold, rats and leaking riofs, without working heating.
Agree that elimination of renter protections should go hand in hand with elimination of landlord protections: that is, if someone moves out because the landlord hasn't held up to his end of the contract (provide habitable housing), then there should be no protection for that landlord in the courts to force the tenant to continue paying.
Wow that's insane. If I was renting out a property I owned I'd expect to be able to throw someone out within a day after an active refusal to pay rent.
With the recent rent moratoriums, I expect landlords to get even harsher. A tenant can easily pay rent two or three times, and then stretch out the eviction proceedings for 6 to 18 months depending on the state .
If this person went and filed for a second bankruptcy, they could then delay the eviction by years.
The bigger issue of course is we haven't built up enough new housing over the last 40 years, you want there to be so much available housing landlords can't be selective. They have to take the risk of losing a bit of money, because they're going to lose an absolute ton if they let their units remain vacant.