It's not their house. It certainly is their home. I would prefer those be the same person as often as possible to align incentives.
> they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it
Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.
It's not uncommon for landlords to be the first party to breach the contract either intentionally (e.g. losing checks to move a tenant at below market rates out), neglectfully (e.g. ignoring upkeep or repairs) or unintentionally (e.g. entering at will).
Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.
> The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.
Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.
If you take something you're obliged to pay for without paying for it, it isn't "yours."
>Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.
Minimum wage is another thing that crushes the poor, as do eviction protections. Both serve to make jobs/housing (respectively) more difficult for the poor to acquire via regulatory barriers.
>Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.
Conversely, withholding housing from a breaching tenant is appropriate.
>Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.
In the US, "Home" can simply mean a house [1]. My apologies if you're using a different dialect of English and I misunderstood; I was using home as it's used in one common interpretation of the word in English in my country.
[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/home : refer to 1b
What an entitled viewpoint. It's not their home; an entirely different person owns it and they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it. The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.