News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:59PM (#30846147)
> The quickest way to get landlords to become less selective would be to let them toss freeloaders on their ass on day one of delinquency.

The quickest way to get landlords to become less selective is to say "any vacant apartment/home not occupied by at least one fulltime resident can be claimed by someone homeless as of [date]." You'd have landlords begging people to sign leases (and people would because then they would get a sure nice apartment as opposed to a lottery for one of the few ones left).

Now, that produces bad other results, but so does allowing people's homes to be ripped away from them at a moments notice.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @05:53PM (#30848867)
> quickest way to get landlords to become less selective is to say "any vacant apartment/home not occupied by at least one fulltime resident can be claimed by someone homeless as of [date]."

This is basically extreme squatter's rights. Places which have those produce some combination of people paying guards, those who can't afford guards taking matters into their own hands, people demolishing perfectly-good housing to avoid risking the land, et cetera.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:32PM (#30849202)
I actually meant via a lottery system, not armed competition. Paying the guards when the city says someone else gets the house is not a real thing. And demolishing housing could be fixed by going off zoning.
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:53PM (#30849360)
> via a lottery system, not armed competition

You’re proposing to reassign millions of dollars of property based on various levels of evidence for whether someone was physically present? That’s basically the 90s in Russia.

It’s certainly a neat fictional universe. I imagine everyone who can afford to would live in a hotel, leaving the scramble of defending your property to those who can’t. Also, fraud. Lots of fraud.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by notch656a on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:07PM (#30849477)
Simple, comrade. 15 years you work on potato farm and trade ration-booklet for wood and drywall. You pay for and possibly build with your own two hands nice home for hard working fellow comrade to live in, and you ask in return they pay you some amount to help you recoup your investment.

After a couple years, nice family leaves, so you spend long time to find another nice family to fit into the house you worked hard to provide. Instead Kommisar come along, give house to homeless in name of proletariat. Social welfare bureau hold lottery, and the neighborhood violent drunk under the bridge is ecstatic his number came up, as he was very sad he no longer has home to beat wife in. Much vodka is drunk while copper piping is gutted and appliances scrapped to dealers in nearby Ossetia.

Sit back and cry: I work on potato farm for 15 years to build nice second home to house hard working families! Instead government create lottery and hands to drunk who destroys house in only 15 days. Decide to stop trying. Start drinking everyday. Become a drunk yourself, enter the lottery, now you gut houses of others to survive. Process repeats -- now all units look like Grozny in the late 90s.

Mission accomplished.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:40PM (#30849757)
The point is that, if you want to incentivize landlords to rent out places, this does this. Other people hear your story and rent it out to a responsible person instead of waiting for a "nice family". Or they auction it off in the time they have and pocket the money.

Responsible people who don't rip up housing are sought after and pay a reasonable rental rate. People who buy and sit on property are taken out of the system. A new equilibrium is reached and most people take reasonable care of their rental properties they are given because they don't want to have to enter lotteries that will likely end them up in a slum. Homeless people end up in better than the street.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by djbebs on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @03:44AM (#30852425)
Landlord are already incentivised to do so, the reason they don't is because there are costs of doing it, which regulation magnifies
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by selimthegrim on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:41PM (#30849774)
I’m not sure that was legal in USSR (private renting out) until well into perestroika
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:47AM (#30856800)
The USSR thing wasn't part of the conversation, and just is some "all government regulation is communism".
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by selimthegrim on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:24PM (#30849628)
Plot twist - you call your Chechen friends from next raion over who take care of drunk guy and split the house with them.
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:17PM (#30849571)
Either I'm being far less clear than I think or you're being deliberately obtuse.

Everyone has a primary residence. I'm saying, if the only goal is to force landlords to rent out houses, simply have any residential property without at least one person identifying it as their primary residence given away by the state, ideally in a lottery. It would only change things for landlords. And I don't know what "fraud" would be engaged in. I suppose a couple could rent two apartments only needing one, but I don't see why a landlord would do that as opposed to renting to someone who presumably wants it and would pay money.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @08:19AM (#30854104)
> don't see why a landlord would do that as opposed to renting to someone who presumably wants it and would pay money

You’re not sure they will pay the money or not trash the place. Same reason landlords are hesitant about renting in the real world.

In any case, this would be defeated by enlisting family members as back-up primary residents. (As in the old world, when property rights were enforced at sword point, sucks to be someone without a dependable family.) Though, again, the wealthy would likely opt out of renting and favour not owning or just own a single massive house and opt out of renting.

The fraud would be in people lying about their primary residences. Also, people lying about others’ lack of primary residence to appropriate their homes for their cronies. The injured family would be homeless while fighting for their property back, which somewhat compromises their ability to engage.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @11:46AM (#30856792)
> this would be defeated by enlisting family members as back-up primary residents

I don't see how. The family members still have to live somewhere. Oh no, the person rents to their kid as opposed to a stranger! It still means that wherever that kid was going to live otherwise isn't rented out to them and is on the market.

> fraud would be in people lying about their primary residences.

Yeah, I don't see how. Everyone gets one. So, if you don't need a home and are responsible maybe you get hired to rent out an empty place? It doesn't scale.

> people lying about others’ lack of primary residence to appropriate their homes for their cronies.

That's stupid. It seems just as possible as people lying to get your bank account. There are all kinds of ways that people have to let the government know where their primary residence is.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @02:29PM (#30858976)
> wherever that kid was going to live otherwise isn't rented out to them and is on the market

The kid could have been living at home. One spouse in one house, one spouse in the other. Et cetera.

> just as possible as people lying to get your bank account

You're proposing an ad hoc centralized mechanism for expropriating and re-assigning a multi-trillion dollar asset class. This has clear and one-way precedence in history.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Thursday March 31, 2022 @12:36AM (#30863861)
> he kid could have been living at home. One spouse in one house, one spouse in the other.

Yes. If the "super-fraud" is that 18 year olds move out to unclaimed apartments or that couples can have a vacation house, I am remarkably okay with that.

> You're proposing an ad hoc centralized mechanism for expropriating and re-assigning a multi-trillion dollar asset class. This has clear and one-way precedence in history.

Except for the ad-hoc nature, the fact that property records and ownership (as well as lists of people's primary residences) are already centralized, that centralization and decentralization of real estate have precedence within the same society at different times, I totally agree. So I guess that's "multi-trillion dollar asset class" I agree with.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by notch656a on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @03:08PM (#30846987)
>Now, that produces bad other results, but so does allowing people's homes to be ripped away from them at a moments notice.

What an entitled viewpoint. It's not their home; an entirely different person owns it and they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it. The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:34PM (#30849715)
> It's not their home; an entirely different person owns it

It's not their house. It certainly is their home. I would prefer those be the same person as often as possible to align incentives.

> they failed to hold up to their end of the contract for the terms under which the owner agreed to let them occupy it

Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.

It's not uncommon for landlords to be the first party to breach the contract either intentionally (e.g. losing checks to move a tenant at below market rates out), neglectfully (e.g. ignoring upkeep or repairs) or unintentionally (e.g. entering at will).

Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.

> The person having their home ripped away at a moment's notice is the landlord.

Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by notch656a on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:41PM (#30849777)
>It's not their house. It certainly is their home. I would prefer those be the same person as often as possible to align incentives.

If you take something you're obliged to pay for without paying for it, it isn't "yours."

>Tenants, like many contract participants, have legal rights that cannot be waived (see also minimum wage.) They also have contractual rights due to the contract.

Minimum wage is another thing that crushes the poor, as do eviction protections. Both serve to make jobs/housing (respectively) more difficult for the poor to acquire via regulatory barriers.

>Certainly, withholding rent from a breaching landlord is appropriate while the breach is resolved.

Conversely, withholding housing from a breaching tenant is appropriate.

>Unless the landlord lives there, the landlord's home is unrelated to the property.

In the US, "Home" can simply mean a house [1]. My apologies if you're using a different dialect of English and I misunderstood; I was using home as it's used in one common interpretation of the word in English in my country.

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/home : refer to 1b

Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by tom_ on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @07:53PM (#30849870)
'Home' and 'house' are perhaps synonymous when preceded by the indefinite article. In the abstract, a house and a home can be considered the same thing. A house is, at least in principle, a home for somebody. But you can't call a rental property the landlord's home, since the key characteristic of somebody's home is that it's the place they live.
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by notch656a on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @08:01PM (#30849923)
Nearly every landlord I have interacted with when renting single family housing has referred to the house he is renting as a 'home' even when no one was living in it. I understand local dialects may be differ.
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by rdtwo on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @04:09PM (#30847724)
This would just cause rental terms to require tenants to find a replacement before moving out
Re:Shadow credit score could decide whether you get an apart... by HWR_14 on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @06:33PM (#30849214)
That would probably be one of the terms. Which meets the stated goal of ensuring the housing is being used.

Although I don't see how that clause would be enforceable. A tenant almost certainly doesn't have enough assets to go after to make up for a building. Otherwise they could have bought the home for their own use.