You're diminishing the amount of research and effort that is frequently required to realise an easily commoditized idea. This is why patents exist.
Original game ideas are the product of thousands of hours of experimentation and playtesting. All of that time, effort, and creativity produces a fun mechanic which can often be cloned with ease.
Would you be saying this if we were talking about a non-entertainment product?
What if we were discussing, hypothetically, a novel user interface for medical software which a startup produced after conducting thousands of interviews with doctors across the globe? And then a better funded competitor got their hands on a copy of the software and just replicated the screens in a few weeks?
Or an AI research startup that spent years working on an innovative new model, only for a customer to yoink all the parameters/weights/configuration/whatever and release a competing product backed by a large company?
Indeed, copyright and licensing are similar attempts to solve this problem. Indie devs tend to lack the resources to litigate with cloners, though.
> Original game ideas are the product of thousands of hours of experimentation and playtesting. All of that time, effort, and creativity produces a fun mechanic which can often be cloned with ease.
This is no different than any product, right? If your selling point is so easily copied (and not patentable), it’ll be hard to compete. You need something more than that. It might be good marketing, the right characters, good writing, or even just a good community.
I’m not trying to trivialize the effort devs put in. But unless we’re talking about patenting abstract things like game mechanics, you need something more than just good game mechanics to be commercially successful.
> wholesale theft of art assets
Curious what you think the difference is?
Music, sounds, and other art assets are trivially copied but you don't seem to be OK with that.
What's different to you about the specific combination of numbers that makes Mario's movement fun vs. the specific combination of 3 notes and rhythm that makes the bassline from Psycho Killer catchy?
The problem is that solo indie doesn't work well in any medium.
Everything worth doing benefits from having team members. I think novelists are the closest to still doing things solo, but they still have publishers, editors, beta readers, proofreaders, sensitivity readers, people who check their research if they care about historical accuracy, etc.
I think there was a slow-motion bubble from maybe the 1980s until the 2010s where solo indie game dev worked because:
- Video games were hard to make
- Computers were hard to use
- The tools sucked
- Almost nobody knew how to program
So if you were a smart person who could program half-decently, you had the makings of a game. Now the world is better, and the solo style is left behind.
I don't know much about music, but I speculate musicians would say the same. You might be able to play a bunch of instruments, do your own mixing, publish yourself on Bandcamp and whatever, but dollar for dollar most of the industry is singers who don't write their own songs, backup dancers with no names, and session musicians who are in the studio when the recording is done.
Calling it "clone culture" misses the point: Games are easy to make now. Indie dev is probably never going to be as hip as when Braid came out. And even Jon Blow didn't do it solo, he bought the music and I think contracted an artist for Braid. Specialization works, scale works.
Stardew Valley came entirely out of left field, ConcernedApe released a pixel graphics farming sim of all things, made $35 million dollars because he’d literally done it all himself, even the game engine, and the niche (farming games) he was competing with, including games like Harvest Moon which has teams of developers pumping out absolute crap compared to what he made. Then again he wasn’t necessarily doing it to make money in the first place, it uses “timeless” pixel art, and he spent 6 or so years making the game with no actual time limit to when he could release it (as he had a day job and wasn’t going to run out of money).
And the game just has a soul that makes it feel great to play and be in. I just got around to playing it this year and absolutely love it.
Barone eventually moved in with his girlfriend, Amber Hageman, who paid most of the bills. Barone stuck with his plan. He learned to put on a mask of confidence for friends and family. He knew that if he game wasn’t a success, he’d squander the trust and hope his loved ones placed in his dream."[1]
So he relied on first his parents, and then his girlfriend, to heavily subsidize him for 4 years. It ended up paying off in this instance, of course, but most people don't have this luxury.
And it doesn't always pay off, either. I've seen firsthand many a game that seemed like it would be a success fail once it hit the market.
[1]: https://www.knkx.org/other-news/2017-03-25/this-man-committe...
Anyway, most people have this mental model of the video game industry where there's a measurable, comprehensible number of games, but the actual volume of released games is insane.
Anecdotally, one of the most impressive devs I've ever talked with had a full time day job and did solo dev on mobile games on the side. He released 3-4 games within 2 years, 2016-2018 and they all earned around $200k+. But again, you never would have heard of any of these games, just like you don't hear about whatever current hypercasual game has 20 million players (unless you're an addict or monitor App Annie / Steamcharts / whatever else on a daily basis).
I think single-dev games start, similarly to startups, and gradually pick up small teams as they go. Minecraft fits that bill to a tee, I'm sure there are younger, more informed people here who could point to other examples.
The totality of direction that one solo person has over a project isn't actually all that important, in reality. Having one or two or three team members to rely on, delegate to, bounce ideas off, is way more effective towards getting things done, and especially on a schedule.
I personally prefer “band-sized” teams (mid single-digit) over solo, I find it a lot easier to stay motivated and easier to achieve high productivity due to more chances for specializations while still being small enough to maintain an “indie feel”.
I believe supercell (hardly an indie) maintain game teams at around 8 during dev and increase up to 17 when live, which is also sorta similar to the size you see in indie teams(f2p/GaaS need a lot more manpower for liveops). They just have a lot of such teams.
Way to the Woods is another example, and the solo dev built it as a teenager! https://junkee.com/way-to-the-woods-e3/210743
Ghost Knight also looks promising (still in progress): https://store.steampowered.com/app/1374810/Ghost_Knight_A_Da...
For example: If I pay an artist to do most of the art for my game, did I still make it by myself? What if I pay for music? What about the engine?
Here's some highly successful games that one might argue were created by one person (to varying degrees):
- Minecraft
- Dwarf Fortress
- Kenshi
- Banished
On top of those there's probably an endless list of successful browser and flash games.
The fan culture around it is even bigger though.
Games are more like music than food IMO. It's trivial to copy a song once you hear it. That doesn't somehow mean it's not a worthy song.
Games are software, there's not really much equivalence here.
In lieu of software patents, software has no means of preventing clones outside of using high production value (expensive to develop) as a moat.
I don't think it's particularly great for indie creators, to implicitly tell them "make your games more expensive to clone (more expensive for you to develop) if you want to actually keep a roof over your head." A fun creative game worth playing isn't necessarily costly to develop, but this situation is strongly discouraging such games from being made.
But that's the world we live in now, games are basically yet another starving artist industry.
Back on the subject of hot foods, VICE just did a story on a NYC pizzeria clone serving a community increasingly composed of folks who once lived near the original pizzeria. It resulted in mob "meetings" and an unexplained murder of the original pizzeria's owner...
Maybe not, but the alternative is worse. I don't want federal judges declaring that Torchlight is illegal because it's too close to Diablo.
games are basically yet another starving artist industry
Yes, this is the market correctly telling potential game developers that there's an oversupply and they should consider doing something else.
It would be a jury and a judge who agrees that they are too similar. And why the fuck not? It's the same system that keeps me from debuting my new book and movie "SandHill" a sci-fi story about a bunch of sand worms and spice or my new hit song "Elder Rural Highway" under my country/rap name "Smaller Nos Y".
For some reason, writing, music, movies, TV and even boat designs are all granted copyrights. But we have yet to extend the same practice to game designs.
The argument to make for example distributing Harry Potter epubs to your million closest friends is that its vastly easier to transmit a few MB than it is to sit down and write the thing and fewer people might write if they had to compete with people spending 1/100th of a cent in electricity vs their months or years of work.
It's not remotely clear that the same argument holds for the game industry. We have an embarrassment of riches in terms of tools/distribution/games and its not clear that Torchlight for example is as good or better replacement for Diablo unless they just do it better.
The tools you suggest we create would overwhelmingly be used in favor of those who can afford all the lawyers not to protect indie developers and the entire world of art is so very very derivative that in 10 years no game would be created without the largess of a tiny number of owners whose undeserving great grandkids would inherit the rights to the entire industry or whatever is left of it after you assassinated it.
Shouldn't the abundance of clones naturally cease in an oversupply scenario, since they'd be unable to garner any returns? I'm no economist, but it doesn't seem to make business sense.
Perhaps what's really going on is the act of creating and shipping low-effort clones has become a game unto itself. That doesn't have to be profitable for the "creators"; they're being entertained and paying app store fees so Valve is still happy selling proverbial shovels.
Yes, lawn mowing services aren’t global over the internet. Not I think the same principle still applies: to have to offer more than just some value proposition that can be copied. The global nature of software just means anyone can compete from anywhere.
Coming up with an idea, then balancing a cool new 2D puzzle game might take months, or by a once-in-a-lifetime flash of brilliance. Cloning it will take a decent game dev team a month or two.
Imagine instead that you've spent two years in a kitchen, working nonstop on a completely new type of food. You've discovered how to make something unprecedented, but it took endless rounds of tweaking ingredients and taste-testing. You open a restaurant to sell your food, and it succeeds massively.
... unfortunately for you, the main ingredients are just flour, eggs, sugar and milk, and for whatever reason, it's pretty easy to reverse-engineer your recipe. Within half a year, a dozen copycat restaurants are all making the same thing, except maybe they sprinkle some powdered sugar or salsa on top.
Now, I don't know what you'd do in the restaurant industry to litigate against that. There's probably some viable path, though, because it's obvious that you created something entirely new, and it can't exist without a specific recipe and method.
In the video game industry, though, it's pretty difficult. Patents don't work very well. The legal system hasn't been kind to people trying to claim ownership of gameplay types, even if it's blatantly obvious that the described gameplay wouldn't exist without that person. Platforms also really don't give a shit (see the recent thread about Apple allowing through dozens of Wordle clones, but that's only the latest in a very long history of App Store clones).
I think it's just a narrow and pretty uncharitable view of game dev that would lead to the thought that it's like opening a restaurant, much less one making some food type that has existed for a century. Creating a new gameplay mechanic is not at all like tossing a new type of pickle on a sandwich.
DOOM clones was a thing of past. There were many of them. Then Diablo clones - Sacred was one of them I liked. Torchlight or Path of Exile should not exist by the logic of article and OP.
If a clone is better and is outperforming original, then clone makers are doing right thing. In the big view on future, patents or any other restrictions on knowledge are only limiting overall progress.
Very few of them were any good, though. Does anyone remember any of them other than Dark Forces, Marathon, and Duke 3D?
A baker created a new type of croissant and it exploded in popularity - overnight success.
It wasn’t long before Dunkin Donuts was selling their own cronuts (they had to use a different name for them though, the baker had trademarked the original name).
Tiramisu is an awesome cake from a small mom+pop cafe in Italy, California rolls for sushi, etc...
Under U.S. copyright law, game clones infringe copyright. See Atari v. Philips: Philips developed a game, K.C. Munchkin! for the Magnavox Odyssey2, that looked and played like Pac-Man (which Atari had exclusive home console rights to). The sprites were completely different, the maze layout was different, and there were a few different mechanics. Nevertheless the judge determined that K.C. Munchkin! was similar enough to Pac-Man as to be infringing.
Another example: Tetris, one of the most heavily defended game IPs of all time. The Tetris Company claims copyright on the concept of a falling-tetromino game with the characreristics of Tetris, and has won court cases (e.g. Tetris Holdings v. Xio) defending that copyright. Writing a Tetris clone is asking for contact from TTC's lawyers.
> The example at the beginning of the article looks like it’s different art in the same style. But if it’s a game and not an actual scam, so what?
It's "substantially similar" under U.S. copyright law, which may make it infringing.
IANAL and really confused about this, but... how can you claim copyright over a "concept"? That sounds more like a patent to me. You can trademark names, e.g. tetris, and patent a mechanism for falling pieces, but how can you "copyright" a game concept? In my mind, copyright refers to actually copying large portions of the "content", which in tetris case would be... the assets? Are you sure the lawsuit wasn't about patents?
In this case "concept" has a specific meaning. Not just an "idea", which obviously is not copyrightable. But the general structure of a creative work from the consumers experience.
For instance, rewriting a novel with new names, new locations, swapping out details not necessary for the plot with equivalent supporting details, etc.
IANAL, so I have no idea what the legalities of copyrighting a "concept" are. But that is what is meant by the concept of a creative work. It is the core of the creative work, and creative works are what copyright was intended to protect/incentivize.
(English is my second language and legalese is my I-dont-understand-it-at-all language, so things like "trade dress" sound meaningless to me. But it's definitely not copyright of gameplay elements!)
> For instance, rewriting a novel with new names, new locations, swapping out details not necessary for the plot with equivalent supporting details, etc.
If you copy and distribute a novel/script, or parts of it, then surely that is copyright infringement. But if you "steal" the idea and change enough details that it's not the same thing anymore (i.e. you cannot point at chunks of the clone and claim "this is lifted almost verbatim from the original"), my bet is that it's either entirely legal (nothing you can do about it) or a form of fraud unrelated to copyright. Isn't copyright about copying/distributing the original work, or parts of it? If you make a clone that is similar but different, then surely that's not copyright infringement?
For instance, movies that were too similar to predecessors have been found to be infringing.
Example: Universal/Jaws vs. Great White.
https://screenrant.com/jaws-movie-universal-canceled-italian...
and thanks for the very good explanation.
If you are not a licensee of Tetris Holdings, DO NOT, EVER, develop a Tetris clone. You face legal liability if you do.
But clones have that exact same unique feature, that's why it's called a clone.
If you played/hear the original, you'll recognize the clone right away. But if you find the clone first, you'll think that's the one with that unique feature. Maybe later you discover the original, but the damage is already done.
Games that endure usually have something unique about then that resonates with consumers, despite the existence of clones. That might be the characters, the story, that intangible touch of the original artist some game clone sweatshop can’t replicate.
You can get a burger anywhere, but I bet every city has at least one burger place that just makes it better, the atmosphere is better, the beer menu better, and there’s always a line out the door.
Are games really any different?
The example at the beginning of the article looks like it’s different art in the same style. But if it’s a game and not an actual scam, so what?
This part confused me though:
Clones impact small developers in more than one way, but the most direct consequence for Witch Beam was a rise in confused players which in turn can grow into bad PR for the studio and its staff being overwhelmed by demands.
"People were going to our website and being confused, thinking that this is part of the sign-up process to play the game through this app that they got, and signing up to our mailing list thinking that they're signing up to play the game," Brier explains. "We were just flooded with mailing list sign-ups, which then brought us up a tier on Mailchimp, for these low-quality subscribers. And they're low quality because they don't want to be subscribers, and they might even mark us as spam if they get our emails.
Where were these confused players coming from? Sounds like the site was designed poorly from a UX perspective.