News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by bitwize on Saturday February 19, 2022 @12:33PM (#30398782)
> Barring actual fraud and wholesale theft of art assets, if your idea is copied so easily and consumers apparently can’t team the difference between your game and a clone, do you really have a viable product or were you just the first person to think of an easily commoditized idea?

Under U.S. copyright law, game clones infringe copyright. See Atari v. Philips: Philips developed a game, K.C. Munchkin! for the Magnavox Odyssey2, that looked and played like Pac-Man (which Atari had exclusive home console rights to). The sprites were completely different, the maze layout was different, and there were a few different mechanics. Nevertheless the judge determined that K.C. Munchkin! was similar enough to Pac-Man as to be infringing.

Another example: Tetris, one of the most heavily defended game IPs of all time. The Tetris Company claims copyright on the concept of a falling-tetromino game with the characreristics of Tetris, and has won court cases (e.g. Tetris Holdings v. Xio) defending that copyright. Writing a Tetris clone is asking for contact from TTC's lawyers.

> The example at the beginning of the article looks like it’s different art in the same style. But if it’s a game and not an actual scam, so what?

It's "substantially similar" under U.S. copyright law, which may make it infringing.

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by the_af on Saturday February 19, 2022 @12:53PM (#30398975)
> Another example: Tetris, one of the most heavily defended game IPs of all time. The Tetris Company claims copyright on the concept of a falling-tetromino game with the characreristics of Tetris, and has won court cases (e.g. Tetris Holdings v. Xio) defending that copyright.

IANAL and really confused about this, but... how can you claim copyright over a "concept"? That sounds more like a patent to me. You can trademark names, e.g. tetris, and patent a mechanism for falling pieces, but how can you "copyright" a game concept? In my mind, copyright refers to actually copying large portions of the "content", which in tetris case would be... the assets? Are you sure the lawsuit wasn't about patents?

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by Nevermark on Saturday February 19, 2022 @03:20PM (#30400155)
A patent protects a means of doing something. It doesn't protect the final form.

In this case "concept" has a specific meaning. Not just an "idea", which obviously is not copyrightable. But the general structure of a creative work from the consumers experience.

For instance, rewriting a novel with new names, new locations, swapping out details not necessary for the plot with equivalent supporting details, etc.

IANAL, so I have no idea what the legalities of copyrighting a "concept" are. But that is what is meant by the concept of a creative work. It is the core of the creative work, and creative works are what copyright was intended to protect/incentivize.

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by the_af on Saturday February 19, 2022 @04:11PM (#30400560)
From what I can understand of Wikipedia's summary of the Tetris Holdings vs Xio case, the copyright was about "look and feel". The judge reiterated that gameplay cannot be copyrighted, which was also my understanding, but content (art, style, etc) can. There was also something called "trade dress" which seems to relate to the confusion in customer's minds about which game is which.

(English is my second language and legalese is my I-dont-understand-it-at-all language, so things like "trade dress" sound meaningless to me. But it's definitely not copyright of gameplay elements!)

> For instance, rewriting a novel with new names, new locations, swapping out details not necessary for the plot with equivalent supporting details, etc.

If you copy and distribute a novel/script, or parts of it, then surely that is copyright infringement. But if you "steal" the idea and change enough details that it's not the same thing anymore (i.e. you cannot point at chunks of the clone and claim "this is lifted almost verbatim from the original"), my bet is that it's either entirely legal (nothing you can do about it) or a form of fraud unrelated to copyright. Isn't copyright about copying/distributing the original work, or parts of it? If you make a clone that is similar but different, then surely that's not copyright infringement?

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by Nevermark on Sunday February 20, 2022 @03:30AM (#30404198)
I agree that swapping out enough details will eventually avoid copyright infringement, but its possible to swap out low-level specifics and still be so obviously a structural and topical "copy" that someone can get into trouble.

For instance, movies that were too similar to predecessors have been found to be infringing.

Example: Universal/Jaws vs. Great White.

https://screenrant.com/jaws-movie-universal-canceled-italian...

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by jrochkind1 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:46PM (#30401677)
Don't worry, "trade dress" is pretty meaningless to the casual native English speaker too, it is a technical legal term that doesn't really mean anything more in day to day English to anyone else than it does to you. (My guess is it may have meant more to an English speaker in the 18th century or something!)

and thanks for the very good explanation.

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by int_19h on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:12PM (#30403148)
The story with Tetris largely revolves around the trademark on the name itself, and various associated visual designs. You can still make a Tetris clone, though.
Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by bitwize on Sunday February 20, 2022 @04:46AM (#30404517)
No, this is explicitly incorrect. If you try to write a clone of Tetris and word gets around to Pajitnov and Henk, you'll be sued. Copyrights and trademarks protect all aspects of Tetris's design, including the dimensions of the playboard, the tetromino shapes, the next piece indicator, the fall rate and animations, and the overall look and feel of the game. (See Tetris Holdings v. Xio, YES THIS IS COPYRIGHTABLE.) The Tetris Company applied for, and vigorously defends, ALL of these copyrights and trademarks.

If you are not a licensee of Tetris Holdings, DO NOT, EVER, develop a Tetris clone. You face legal liability if you do.

Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers by bluedino on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:55PM (#30402128)
2048 needed better lawyers