Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers
by Nevermark on Sunday February 20, 2022 @03:30AM
(#30404198)
I agree that swapping out enough details will eventually avoid copyright infringement, but its possible to swap out low-level specifics and still be so obviously a structural and topical "copy" that someone can get into trouble.
For instance, movies that were too similar to predecessors have been found to be infringing.
Example: Universal/Jaws vs. Great White.
https://screenrant.com/jaws-movie-universal-canceled-italian...
Re:Clone culture and its continuous impact on indie developers
by jrochkind1 on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:46PM
(#30401677)
Don't worry, "trade dress" is pretty meaningless to the casual native English speaker too, it is a technical legal term that doesn't really mean anything more in day to day English to anyone else than it does to you. (My guess is it may have meant more to an English speaker in the 18th century or something!)
and thanks for the very good explanation.
(English is my second language and legalese is my I-dont-understand-it-at-all language, so things like "trade dress" sound meaningless to me. But it's definitely not copyright of gameplay elements!)
> For instance, rewriting a novel with new names, new locations, swapping out details not necessary for the plot with equivalent supporting details, etc.
If you copy and distribute a novel/script, or parts of it, then surely that is copyright infringement. But if you "steal" the idea and change enough details that it's not the same thing anymore (i.e. you cannot point at chunks of the clone and claim "this is lifted almost verbatim from the original"), my bet is that it's either entirely legal (nothing you can do about it) or a form of fraud unrelated to copyright. Isn't copyright about copying/distributing the original work, or parts of it? If you make a clone that is similar but different, then surely that's not copyright infringement?