Honest titles of search results:
* Five pages of flowery text and images before two lines of instruction on how to boil rice
* A bunch of tantalizing pictures of exactly what you're looking for but zero further information about it
* Product reviews machine-generated from public review sources with affiliate links. Top-rated product has the best affiliate revenue.
* You won't care about this solution to a problem you don't have.
etc...
[5 pages later]
1. Put rice and water in rice cooker
2. Press "start"
I find it annoying too, but it often feels like people ridicule the authors when they wouldn't get any traffic if it weren't for that approach. I don't think I've ever searched for a recipe and come across a barebones Gantt-chart-style engineer-thinking recipe plan.
They still deserve it, IMO. Willingly making a clown, a pawn of an ad-spamming corporation, out of oneself by doing one's darnedest to "win through" at some perverse game rigged by the aforementioned scourge of the Internet, is neither a natural human right nor a divine command. Not playing that game is still a valid move, and AFAICS the only honourable -- i.e. the only non-ridicule-worthy -- one.
I'd agree that misleading made-for-AdSense sites that purport to, but then don't, answer a question, farm out writing to $5/page content squads and intersperse stock photos - that's shoddy. But all the recipe sites I find in my searches and have to scroll down for the content, they always seem like genuine, personal efforts. If I'm getting the content for free, scrolling a little bit as a price isn't too laborious and a stretch to think of it as dishonourable work IMO.
IOW, you're trying to earn money. Sure, go ahead -- but then you get to pay the price. If the method you're trying to earn money by is going to involve playing along in the game of clickbait, then the price you get to pay is going to be, to be seen as a purveyor of clickbait. Which I, and I suspect quite a few others with me, see as distinctly less than honourable.
It's a free choice: Nobody is forcing anybody to "establish a career as a recipe creator or food photographer" on the ad-financed Internet. If they choose to play the clickbait clown/scum game, they're making themselves into -- so, in the end, are -- clickbait clown/scum. I sure didn't tell them to do that, so I'm perfectly free to see them as such for doing it.
They, OTOH, are perfectly free to try it some other way: publishing printed cookbooks in stead of Internet clickbait; or something adjacent, like run cooking classes, start a restaurant or catering business... Or to do something else altogether.
They could always go into the deeply honourable (/s) business of software engineering, which nowadays seems to consist to about 45% of running ad-spam networks, to about 45% of writing SEO crap to get your ads onto those networks, and about 10% other development... :-( What, me cynic? Bah, geroffmylawn!
I've been to cooking schools in multiple countries. All have gone into detail about the background of the chef and each recipe.
Same with restaurants. Many restaurants and certainly almost every fine-dining restaurant pushes the profile of the head chef.
More seriously: At least the classes and restaurants already push that stuff in their marketing, don't they? So I get all that already doing my comparison shopping, and therefore would probably actually (at least to some extent) resent the time wasted on repeating it. And the few cookboks I (or we, my wife and I) have are also of the matter-of-fact, recipes and nothing more, kind... I am probably just much less of a "foodie" than you. I think my preference pattern is the overwhelming majority.
Note that Clovegarden has "the history of nut x in remote tribal desert y, etc" too -- but on pages separate from the recipes. (As I recall Mr Grygus started the site in preparation for starting a business of selling foodie stuff online after winding up his computing and automation consultancy business -- but that still seems to linger on, and he is nearing [or, probably, well past?] normal retiring age, so I don't know if that new business will ever materialise. But as long as he is up to updating Clovegarden every now and then it remains my favourite site for food-related stuff.)
[Edit: Ttypo.]
How much water? Do you salt the water?
https://plainoldrecipe.com/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23648864 (Thank you HN :))
* e-bike with 10 miles of actual range even though they advertise 30 miles
* laptop with 2 hours of battery life at 100% CPU usage even though they advertise 10 hours
* median $450 flight even though they advertise it as $199
Is there any laptop on the market that lives up to this. Even top specced MBPs I've gotten from work fall down when you actually use the CPU with compilers and VMs.
Or a (min,max) based on idle and 100% CPU.
And advertising laptop battery life based on the CPU getting pegged to 100% gives meaningless information as its rare for people to actually have their device running at 100% load anyways.
Yeah but testing the e-bike on a track and telling the public it has 30 miles of range based on that is disingenuous.
Instead, go to a city with an average amount of hills, stop lights, and cold weather and give in a go, and tell that number to the public. If it beats that, in their actual city they'll only be pleasantly surprised. Right now you strand a shitton of people because they think they have 30 miles.
In a better world, algorithms would be perfect and there would be a lot of healthy competition in search engines and google would be incentivized to provide users with the best possible results. In our current world Google's algorithm can't identify obvious spam well enough to keep it out of their results and there are no major search engines that haven't been lifting results from Google directly or indirectly and repackaging them as their own, so google has no pressure to do anything but promote whatever is in their own best interests or keep their results accurate and free of spam.
Forcing folks to trudge through inaccurate titles – or hoping people know the tells of a "spammy site" title – does not seem a better alternative.
It's quite the opposite, "Search Engine Optimization" is the fancy euphemism for gaming the algorithm.
That causes me to lose faith in google not a better experience.
Because I want the title to be concise, but still help people explicitly understand what my writing is about? Because I've already spent a lot of time on the content, to then just slap 'Lou's Wednesday Website Update' as a title? Because, historically, a title is an introduction to my writing?
Any of those.
How to Fix a Broken iPhone Screen [Tested by Experts] - Phone Fixer
-> How to Fix a Broken iPhone Screen - Phone Fixer
Tested by Experts is obviously clickbait; nobody's going to say [Tested by novices].Same for things like [Updated 2022] - there are tons of websites that superimpose [updated <currentyear>] even if the article content wasn't updated.
And yet, I don’t see how Google can automate checking this. It’s possible to add a couple of sentences about how you’ve not seen anything to change your mind about last year’s recommendations. That may well be true. Or false. How can Google know? It just sees content that has changed. So it has been updated in 2022.
The bigger issue is brand trust (as a reviewer brand). The NYT bought Wirecutter, I think, because it had established itself as a trustworthy brand. That’s in direct line with the reputation the NYT wants to have as a whole.
That seems fundamentally impossible without defining trusted sources. But then that means that you're trusting that Google's trusted sources are good. And if you do think they're good, then why not just check those sources directly?
The only answer I have is to find your own sources that you trust and go to them first.
Then the content would not need to be spam, to be high ranking.
Not if google just cared about content quality.
So in this scenario, where only quality counts for rankings, all a spammy title shows, is the desire to bypass legitimate rankings.
Thus, it should be downranked.
Again, this was if Google legitimately wanted to rank good content high.
What about the opposite, the title being great but the contents not really? Shall Google serve its own "improved"/"summarized"/whatever version?
Meh... - this reminds me of the snippets of text extracted by some websites that are sometimes shown directly in Google's results, which in my case were sometimes wrong because they didn't take into account the context of what was written in the original contents.
If we're going to start filtering all "obvious clickbait" then the search results are going to change fairly dramatically...
Isn’t this the intended effect?
I hate clickbait as much as the next user, but using that technique to get users to click appears to have even become part of the core business model of previously prestigious outlets.
Picking on the WaPo for no real reason:
How the Washington Post pulled off the hardest trick in journalism https://www.cjr.org/public_editor/washington-post-fluff-news...
An Open Letter to the Washington Post: Please Stop Doing Clickbait https://thedailybanter.com/2016/05/letter-to-the-washington-...
The dead tree headlines are almost always very factual and to the point. I don't think I've ever seen anything close to something like "Here's four awesome tricks to get China to admit to the Tiananmen Square massacre" as a headline in actual print.
Clickbait pisses me off when it's used to waste my time, but a good search engine wouldn't give me results that waste my time.
In other words, it could give me a relevant result with a clickbait title.. I guess that'd be a little annoying but I don't know if I would want Google to be the judge on what's clickbait or not, and even then I don't feel like it's their place to override titles. I wouldn't want useful pages be downranked just for having a poor title.
I do agree it’s not really Google’s place to be rewriting titles, though. That feels very suspect.
Is there an objective way to assess quality?
A click-bait title on a page full of ads and text that keep the visitor's attention but don't deliver on the title... ?
Then having held the visitor on your site for a minute or two, but managing to leave them unsatisfied, how about ending the page with a big fat block of even more visual click-bait content at the bottom (Taboola, I'm looking at you).
Don't advertisers and publishers love this stuff? Great metrics.
"Phone Fixer" sounds more scammy to me, lol
Nobody would write [Tested by novices] into their headline, but leaving out the part in the brackets would leave it open if it was tested by experts or novices. So in this case the removed bit does provide some information.
And yet from TFA:
>> In fact, we found that matching your H1 to your title dropped typically dropped the degree of rewriting across the board, often dramatically.
Users don't look much at titles - they end up in the browser tab or somewhere like that. If a title doesn't match the H1 heading it's often to get more stuff in for SEO. OTOH short titles might be useful when they show up in a tab where there is limited space. Maybe they shouldn't lengthen them for that reason.
Google should be a neutral middle man providing the results as they are found. If they feel the title is not of their version of quality they should rank it lower.
I'd prefer the version of title of several hundred million individuals rather than Google's aggregated version.
They used to 'borrow' DMOZ titles before DMOZ became defunct. At least in that case it's another point of view on top of their own (and the site author)
https://pressthink.org/2010/11/the-view-from-nowhere-questio...
Concrete personal example:
- Title shown by Google: "Policymaking Beyond Corporate CEOs and Partisan Pressure"
- Original title: "Towards Platform Democracy: Policymaking Beyond Corporate CEOs and Partisan Pressure"
Rather large difference!
More details in another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30087485 , but search term is just "platform democracy" (2nd result)
If you are, rightly, disappointed about low quality results in SERPs, then why not direct your frustration at Google's search algorithm? But ultimately once the algorithm has decided what to return, I don't want any of it to be tampered with. Maybe there's an argument that once you're using a black box, it might as well be the best black box it can be, but I don't agree.
I wonder whether there is a case for legal action here. Google would not have wasted time developing this rewrite engine unless it had an effect on clicks. Whether that is positive or negative, only they truly know. What if it was found that it was, or wasn't, being applied consistently to the results of their competitors, but not their own sites, for example?
100% of the above the fold content is now ads on many search terms, Google is doing everything they can to squeeze more ad clicks, not provide the best information to their users
Omelas, bye-bye (The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas)
Things are looking up (Great Expectations)
A crying cop (Flow, my tears, the policeman said)
The one that got away (The Old Man and The Sea)
on edit: I expect someone will point out those are the names of works of literary fiction not webpages, but obviously if we assume that webpages do not deserve the kind of respect we would give a creative work in book form and not change the title because it suits our needs, then we should not spend all our time complaining that the content of the web is just lousy stuff that nobody would care if you changed with an algorithm.
The problem there is that "optimizing for clickbaitness" means "making the titles as appealing to click on as possible when they're displayed in search pages". Google deliberately making them less appealing to click on means Google are reducing the effectiveness of organic search results, and that favors adverts instead.
In other words, what you are saying is that you believe it's valid for Google to rewrite website content to make search page adverts more appealing than the actual search results.
That is very hard to justify. If Google wanted to 'punish' sites for being too clickbaity then they should drop that site's position in the search rankings. Ranking it highly but rewriting the title to be something worse (or 'less clickbaity') is a massive abuse of their search market position to favor their ad business.
> Want to optimize your titles for increased traffic?
> We built a title optimizer to take advantage of the outsized role titles play in SEO. Free to try.
Definitely SEO gaming.
But it's not. It's being done by an algorithm which was carefully crafted to improve someone's chance for getting a promotion. It won't be maintained long term, yet it will continue to punish articles based on wholly arbitrary, biased, and opaque logic.
I made a little change there. Algorithms don't just magically appear like leprechauns and unicorns.
Why stop at the titles?
I have an idea, let's have bots rewrite the content in a compact tl;dr format and have it be directly displayed on Google SERP, as user, the less actions I take the better right? You don't even need to leave the SERP.
Why can't I just choose what title I want in my blog to be indexed, and if Google wants to penalize it, so be it?
Fuck yeah! I’d pay monthly for a search engine that does this consistently. Google already does this for the articles that are easy to parse, but I’d love to see what newer methods based on language models can do.
Btw this article is talking about the <title> tag which is mostly used for SEO since users don’t see it on the page. I don’t think search engines have ever cared about it all that much.
How many times do we bicker about titles that make no sense / are deceptive on HN...
The whole situation is a mess.
The ministry of truth. Google shall own all truth.
Would you be fine with Google changing the work of all authors? Maybe "The Brothers Karamazov" doesn't get enough clicks and Google decides it needs a better title. Or "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man" doesn't quite convey what Google thinks it should...
How is that different?
Yeah, I'm with Google on this one. I don't see many reasons why a site owner would spend extraordinary amounts of time to "carefully craft" page titles other than SEO and optimizing for clickbaitness. As a user, I'm fine with Google counteracting this.