Isn’t this the intended effect?
I hate clickbait as much as the next user, but using that technique to get users to click appears to have even become part of the core business model of previously prestigious outlets.
Picking on the WaPo for no real reason:
How the Washington Post pulled off the hardest trick in journalism https://www.cjr.org/public_editor/washington-post-fluff-news...
An Open Letter to the Washington Post: Please Stop Doing Clickbait https://thedailybanter.com/2016/05/letter-to-the-washington-...
The dead tree headlines are almost always very factual and to the point. I don't think I've ever seen anything close to something like "Here's four awesome tricks to get China to admit to the Tiananmen Square massacre" as a headline in actual print.
Clickbait pisses me off when it's used to waste my time, but a good search engine wouldn't give me results that waste my time.
In other words, it could give me a relevant result with a clickbait title.. I guess that'd be a little annoying but I don't know if I would want Google to be the judge on what's clickbait or not, and even then I don't feel like it's their place to override titles. I wouldn't want useful pages be downranked just for having a poor title.
I do agree it’s not really Google’s place to be rewriting titles, though. That feels very suspect.
Is there an objective way to assess quality?
A click-bait title on a page full of ads and text that keep the visitor's attention but don't deliver on the title... ?
Then having held the visitor on your site for a minute or two, but managing to leave them unsatisfied, how about ending the page with a big fat block of even more visual click-bait content at the bottom (Taboola, I'm looking at you).
Don't advertisers and publishers love this stuff? Great metrics.
If we're going to start filtering all "obvious clickbait" then the search results are going to change fairly dramatically...