How to Fix a Broken iPhone Screen [Tested by Experts] - Phone Fixer
-> How to Fix a Broken iPhone Screen - Phone Fixer
Tested by Experts is obviously clickbait; nobody's going to say [Tested by novices].Same for things like [Updated 2022] - there are tons of websites that superimpose [updated <currentyear>] even if the article content wasn't updated.
And yet, I don’t see how Google can automate checking this. It’s possible to add a couple of sentences about how you’ve not seen anything to change your mind about last year’s recommendations. That may well be true. Or false. How can Google know? It just sees content that has changed. So it has been updated in 2022.
The bigger issue is brand trust (as a reviewer brand). The NYT bought Wirecutter, I think, because it had established itself as a trustworthy brand. That’s in direct line with the reputation the NYT wants to have as a whole.
That seems fundamentally impossible without defining trusted sources. But then that means that you're trusting that Google's trusted sources are good. And if you do think they're good, then why not just check those sources directly?
The only answer I have is to find your own sources that you trust and go to them first.
Then the content would not need to be spam, to be high ranking.
Not if google just cared about content quality.
So in this scenario, where only quality counts for rankings, all a spammy title shows, is the desire to bypass legitimate rankings.
Thus, it should be downranked.
Again, this was if Google legitimately wanted to rank good content high.
What about the opposite, the title being great but the contents not really? Shall Google serve its own "improved"/"summarized"/whatever version?
Meh... - this reminds me of the snippets of text extracted by some websites that are sometimes shown directly in Google's results, which in my case were sometimes wrong because they didn't take into account the context of what was written in the original contents.
If we're going to start filtering all "obvious clickbait" then the search results are going to change fairly dramatically...
Isn’t this the intended effect?
I hate clickbait as much as the next user, but using that technique to get users to click appears to have even become part of the core business model of previously prestigious outlets.
Picking on the WaPo for no real reason:
How the Washington Post pulled off the hardest trick in journalism https://www.cjr.org/public_editor/washington-post-fluff-news...
An Open Letter to the Washington Post: Please Stop Doing Clickbait https://thedailybanter.com/2016/05/letter-to-the-washington-...
The dead tree headlines are almost always very factual and to the point. I don't think I've ever seen anything close to something like "Here's four awesome tricks to get China to admit to the Tiananmen Square massacre" as a headline in actual print.
Clickbait pisses me off when it's used to waste my time, but a good search engine wouldn't give me results that waste my time.
In other words, it could give me a relevant result with a clickbait title.. I guess that'd be a little annoying but I don't know if I would want Google to be the judge on what's clickbait or not, and even then I don't feel like it's their place to override titles. I wouldn't want useful pages be downranked just for having a poor title.
I do agree it’s not really Google’s place to be rewriting titles, though. That feels very suspect.
Is there an objective way to assess quality?
A click-bait title on a page full of ads and text that keep the visitor's attention but don't deliver on the title... ?
Then having held the visitor on your site for a minute or two, but managing to leave them unsatisfied, how about ending the page with a big fat block of even more visual click-bait content at the bottom (Taboola, I'm looking at you).
Don't advertisers and publishers love this stuff? Great metrics.
"Phone Fixer" sounds more scammy to me, lol
Nobody would write [Tested by novices] into their headline, but leaving out the part in the brackets would leave it open if it was tested by experts or novices. So in this case the removed bit does provide some information.
And yet from TFA:
>> In fact, we found that matching your H1 to your title dropped typically dropped the degree of rewriting across the board, often dramatically.
Users don't look much at titles - they end up in the browser tab or somewhere like that. If a title doesn't match the H1 heading it's often to get more stuff in for SEO. OTOH short titles might be useful when they show up in a tab where there is limited space. Maybe they shouldn't lengthen them for that reason.
Because I want the title to be concise, but still help people explicitly understand what my writing is about? Because I've already spent a lot of time on the content, to then just slap 'Lou's Wednesday Website Update' as a title? Because, historically, a title is an introduction to my writing?
Any of those.