Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Google rewrites many page titles. Parent comment
Then the content would not need to be spam, to be high ranking.
Not if google just cared about content quality.
So in this scenario, where only quality counts for rankings, all a spammy title shows, is the desire to bypass legitimate rankings.
Thus, it should be downranked.
Again, this was if Google legitimately wanted to rank good content high.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
Then the content would not need to be spam, to be high ranking.
Not if google just cared about content quality.
So in this scenario, where only quality counts for rankings, all a spammy title shows, is the desire to bypass legitimate rankings.
Thus, it should be downranked.
Again, this was if Google legitimately wanted to rank good content high.