Also, private stock valuation can't simply pay health insurance bills.
Then again, with many wage-earners already leaving the state, this may turn toxic.
"Doubling my taxes?!"
Oh... for a CA based single payer healthcare system that for the last 10-20 years people have continually asked for again and again? (Ok, maybe not just for CA, but... sometimes ya gotta start somewhere)
So now I'm back into the evaluation phase after headline whiplash. Will definitely consider the 'total compensation package'.
The headline is no accident, The Tax Foundation is a center-right, fiscally conservative organization, generally critical of tax increases.
In addition, your employer now has to pay more based on their gross receipts and if you make more than 150k a year you are paying even more.
I mean - plans my work offers (which aren’t even the best) are like $500/month out of pocket for the entire family - and that’s for really good coverage with no deductibles and low copays. The plans they offer aren’t even the best I’ve gotten…
We have good plans too but still have our deductibles which, if I remember right, are around $1,000.
Overall I think a single-payer system is for the best. Having healthcare tied to your job creates another anchor to keep people tied to large, stable companies instead of taking risks with startups or small businesses.
The main downside is that companies have started doing tiered healthcare costs based on things like smoking or health indicators. Having income tax based on your weight or smoking status is probably a non-starter, so it removes some of the incentives for people to make good choices (and reduce healthcare costs).
80% of people with Type II diabetes who are also overweight or obese would be asymptomatic if they lost weight. Why spend public money if there exists a free treatment? Save the public resources for right-weight type IIs and type Is.
Speaking as someone who has lost over a 170lbs…it ain’t eas. It is the hardest damn thing I have ever done and your body fights you every step of the way…forever. It never ends—for the rest of your life your body is constantly fighting you to get back up to the weight you were.
Also, your concept of preventing all other treatments until someone loses weight is absolutely barbaric.
You also need to consider that a sugar tax can hit lower income people a bit harder.
It cuts in many ways: save money and gain health by drinking water/tea/coffee instead of softdrinks. Use the money for healthier foods.
If you were obese and now are not, I applaud you. But I also know it wasn’t easy for you to make that change. I used the word “likely”, because it felt to me like you communicated in a dismissive and nonchalant manner, like someone who hasn’t gone through the difficulties necessary to do it.
Yes, you can.
And you get a vote on who is running it, too
Elections have consequences. Try un-electing your group plan provider.
Australia has very high taxes on cigarettes mainly because they want to keep their (universal) healthcare costs down. They could do the same thing to sugary snacks as well, even the conservatives would get onboard if it was to save money on healthcare expenditures.
I suspect a GRT is also a regressive form of taxation (just as sales taxes are, though many [most?] states exempt food and other staples from their sales taxes, to minimize the regressive nature of these).
I was shocked to learn how much my parent's insurance costs.
Even though ostensibly employed by a huge multi-national, my dad technically operates as his own S-corp so they have to buy on the market. That seems to be a trend in the gig economy which is worse for low 'wage' earners.
I also am on private market as I own my business. Mine is $500 a month at 32 and healthy. Theirs is 2k ish and increases significantly each year (65 and 62). That is really hard for almost all older Americans to afford. By the time they are 75 or even older the cost would be insane if this continues.
I agree that messaging is what's holding back reform. The messaging is so easy to short circuit. Just look at the headline of this post. No one wants their taxes to double.
That's more or less why Medicare exists.
But still a lot of out of pocket costs and premiums if you want drug coverage and more.
Correct me if I'm wrong but it doesn't really cover if you need long term care which is insanely expensive.
(I pay out of pocket via a side business, not from my current employer.)
In what sense? What do you like about KP: the doctors, nurses, etc.? The billing department? Single-payer would not take the staff away. It would get rid of large swathes of the billing department that are pure waste.
Not everyone has had your positive experience with KP. We switched away due to lack of availability of certain specialists.
All that money is overhead that can be removed from the costs if health care didn't have to funnel through a private company taking profits from it.
https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/hospitals/kaiser-permanente...
Certainly not the salaries to actual health professionals (doctors, nurses, techs, etc).
When you see a doctor for 10 minutes and get billed $400, the vast majority of that money goes all the layers who are extracting their slice of profit from it, only a small bit goes to the doctor.
The us has the most expensive drug approval process in the world making any drug that goes to market needing high prices to exist. Around 10% of NH spending here.SP does not fix this.
Hospitals receive large gov funding, regulatory protection that includes the inability to build or run new or for-profit hospitals, and with the constant moral hazard of running hospitals in the red and getting bailed out. Almost all hospitals are non-profit. About 40% of NH spending. SP makes this even worse by eliminating forever the risk of bankrupcy.
Maybe it would be a good idea to lean on the better insurance companies (are there more than kaiser?) to administer.
Personally I think there needs to be stronger regulation so that they can still make some profit (not obscene) for incentive to get more efficient, while regulating they can't take that profit at the expense of patients & access to care.
https://www.irs.gov/affordable-care-act/form-w-2-reporting-o...
Grandfathered plans are an absolutely screaming deal. You can do an HSA plan with a $2000 deductible and low OOP max, fully fund the HSA ($7,200) and come out way ahead at modest cost. This let's you do things like vision / dental / chiro / accu / whatever day to day stuff on the HSA, then keep costs controlled (after 2K) for a major issue. If you don't end up using the HSA you can basically use it in retirement.
The obamacare bronze HSA plans (which actually cost a bit more) have a $4,800 ind deductible and something like a $13K (!!) out of pocket max and something like a $9K+ family deductible limit. And they cost more. This is totally unworkable absent the subsidies.
I like obamacare, but something happened as part of obamacare that has CLEARLY driven up costs. Is it the lack of limits (ie, $10M in coverage during last weeks of life?) Is it some sort of other mandate?
One area where govt care is better priced is for the elderly. The grandfathered / free market type plans get expensive at 60 years +. The obamacare plans are more of deal here (relatively). At the 20 year old range obamacare is horrible for the coverage if you actually have to pay for them.
That's an easy one, Obamacare mandated that insurance companies couldn't charge more than X times as much for their most expensive plans vs. their cheapest plans, The people pushing it were either tremendously ignorant or outright lying and claimed that this would make plans cheaper, while critics rightly predicted that instead of making the most expensive plans cheaper they would make their cheapest plans more expensive.
[1] https://www.cms.gov/CCIIO/Programs-and-Initiatives/Health-In...
It would be kind of similar to forcing auto insurance carriers to afford coverage to cars they didn’t previously insure after they had already been in an accident.
And the requirement that 80% of premiums paid had to go to paying for care was supposed to prevent insurance companies from jacking up prices to increase profits.
Neither actually made an attempt at fixing the underlying problem of health care being expensive.
Since the insurance companies now have to cover pre-existing conditions, and don't want to do that, they came up with another plan: don't answer the phones except during open enrollment. I tried calling several insurance companies (major carriers) just to get quotes for health insurance, and none returned my call. Some had phone trees that went in a circle so you could not get to a person. I did get one broker to talk to me, and he said pre-existing conditions weren't covered for 24 months. First, that's a lie, and 2nd, it's illegal (ACA outlawed this practice).
By only accepting applications during open enrollment, the insurance companies have effectively done an end-run around the law against pre-existing conditions.
Note: this is for an individual to get insurance. I'm sure companies can get insurance for their employees any time they want it.
Follow-up: it turns out that if I did have PPO insurance and was covered at Mayo, then with the same bill from Mayo it would have cost me $8000 more with coverage than it did without insurance, paying cash. That's truly f'd up!
Bigger than denial was recission, where if you ended up with an expensive to cover condition, your insurer would fine-tooth-comb your history for evidence that you had a preexisting condition that has not been revealed, cancel your coverage, and leave you uninsured and uninsurable; recission for reasons other than proven intentional fraud was prohibited by the ACA, which is a pretty big deal.
The distinction is subtle, but in my mind having it structured as an individual paid income tax would yield better results for edge cases and not incentivize bad corporate behavior like running 1099 contractors instead of FTEs.
Well, if they didn't, you could just change jobs. The old benefit of working for an employer that paid all of your premium would be gone, so that wouldn't be a reason to stick with them.
I'm pretty sure I do know the answer to that question...
How is the high speed train project coming along?
The net effect is predictable - Canada consistently ranks very poorly in international health system comparisons. We have far fewer ICU beds, doctors, imaging machines, etc. per capita than peer nations, and the entire country is in varying degrees of harsh lockdown because our hospitals were already overwhelmed during a normal flu season.
What states should do is encourage more competition as a way to lower healthcare costs. Y'all actually have one of the best systems in the world, it's just way too expensive.
Funny that despite this 'extreme example', Canadians have almost 3 years longer life expectancy than us in the US, are healthier throughout their lives, and have comparable or better outcomes with treatments. Where the US has better outcomes (e.g. - some forms of cancer, some organ transplants), it's only very marginally better (like 1% higher chance of surviving 5 years after colon cancer diagnosis when compared to Canada). And for that 1%, you're spending MUCH more money on your treatment.
Basically nearly every measured outcome is better in Canada rather than the US, despite US paying twice as much on healthcare costs per capita when compared to Canada.
> We have far fewer ICU beds, doctors, imaging machines, etc. per capita than peer nations, and the entire country is in varying degrees of harsh lockdown because our hospitals were already overwhelmed during a normal flu season.
That may all be true, yet it's still better care than what the average US citizen gets, despite paying twice as much per capita.
> What states should do is encourage more competition as a way to lower healthcare costs.
They've been trying to 'encourage more competition' for decades now with healthcare costs only continuing to climb while affordable access falls (ignoring the gains that came and went with ACA). "Competition" doesn't exist in industries that are nearly impossible to enter due to regulatory capture and the insane entrenchment of giant healthcare organizations. The few that succeed in making any progress at all get rapidly acquired.
Reality is that no-system is perfect, there will be complaints and tradeoffs. But the US system is broken for a huge proportion of residents, and it's not going to change without drastic measures. I'm all for torching the whole thing and trying single payer. There may be complains about single payer systems across the world, but according to most of the publications I've seen (probably all, but my memory is imperfect), the vast majority of those subject to it would never trade it for what the US has.
Basic healthcare access in 'the richest country in the world' should be a fundamental right, not a for-profit industry.
As for "fundamental right", this is not really how rights work and it's dangerous to define them that way. You have the right to bodily autonomy, freedom of speech, etc., but you don't have the right to someone else's labour. Rights are generally protection against interference from others, not an obligation to receive something.
Broad access to healthcare across socioeconomic status is a worthy policy goal, but saying it's a "fundamental right" begs the question: how much healthcare are you entitled to, exactly?
Which is more likely caused by different lifestyle choices (e.g. 27% vs 42% obesity rate). Also if you take out all the southern states the gap get quite a bit smaller (e.g. 82.4 in Ontario vs 81.7 in California and 81.4 in New York).
There's no free market for health insurance for the people who need care. Insurers don't want those people as customers, not from any state. They're money losers.
What pressure is there to lower costs? Why would they charge less?
Germany has more ICU beds than the US.
That would be shocking if true, which it does not appear to be.
Germany has around 32K ICU beds. US has around 96K ICU beds.
Germany has slightly more per-capita than the US. (387 vs 294 per million inhabitants)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_hospital_...
Not sure what the original poster is talking about, but America's healthcare system is fucked. And it's not just fucked because it's expensive.
I would love to see an international ranking that places Canada's system below that US that isn’t just coming out of some right wing think tank.
You can't, because the health insurance is provided by your employes so you get whatever they give you.
My health insurance (blue shield) is absolutely terrible (right now I need some medicine they refuse to let me have because it cuts into their profit margins) but there's nothing I can do about it.
And that's after paying $2500/month for the privilege.
Basically, get in contact with them, try and get an override, or get them to explain why you are not covered. If it isn't in the formulary your employer opted into, you're hosed; but there is usually one way or another to get them to give in, they will just make you go through maximum hoops.
Ask for their clinical people if you can't get any traction. They will likely be the ones with hand on the knob for whether a drug is "worthy of coverage" or not.
Magic words: Override,coverage decision appeal, utilization management/formulary question.
They will tell you to check a website. Look up your thing in their formulary, if not there, abort. If in there, but high-tier, prepare for the prior-auth gauntlet.
I gave up on BCBS and have resigned to paying out of pocket, but you might get luckier than me. They will generally fight tooth and nail to be difficult, but just keep a cool head and keep escalating. It's been a while since my last butting of heads but I'm gearing up for round 2.
Also remember: You can pay out of pocket, but you'll be at the whims of that pharmacy. They'll generally help you work through coupons.
> Also remember: You can pay out of pocket, but you'll be at the whims of that pharmacy. They'll generally help you work through coupons.
I did ask, but it was nearly $1K/week so can't afford that.
You have now reached beyond my "letters/phone calls to Congress" threshold. Generally doesn't get an instant response, a d may take months, but surprisingly does occasionally get some traction. More out of spite than anything else. However, there is increasing regulatory attention being directed at the space, and even some states have insurance regulators you might be able to hit up.
It's unfortunate, but there are some drugs that insurers are simply not willing to be on the hook for, and if you're the unlucky person suffering from a rare, expensive to treat condition; the only way around it is to make a lot of noise and waves, and be open to trying alternative regimens.
No one should have to go through that though. Good luck.
That's not true, is it? You could decline coverage and then go purchase a policy of your own elsewhere. Yes, that might be expensive but the original claim was "Y'all actually have one of the best systems in the world, it's just way too expensive." and that still tracks.
Even better, you could purchase a policy through the Obamacare exchanges.
If the government offers you bad medical care, you turn to the black market or you fly to the US to get the procedure done because the government has banned alternative care. This is a very normal Conservative talking point and the inherent competition in US healthcare is arguably the biggest benefit of its current system.
What other choices exist, there's only a few giant insurers anyway.
> Even better, you could purchase a policy through the Obamacare exchanges.
I have no direct experience, would love to be wrong, but what I've heard is that even the top-tier plans are extremely limited in what they cover and where they are accepted so it's even worse than company-provided plans.
I guess I should be thankful my insurance is ~$1000/mo, and hasn't left me with the horror stories some seem to experience.
So your comment only covers less than 10.5% of people at the moment... a little more than the number of people who have no health coverage (a good portion not out of real choice).
And that does not even cover how horribly this sort of market functions: you never know how good or bad your coverage actually is until you go to use it for a particular problem, and then you don't really know that until it is over and you are maybe bankrupt. Health insurance is the worst place to try and use market forces to regulate it... well maybe after military, fire, and police...
No thanks. We're moving. More real estate and jobs for the rest of you true believers. Enjoy the weather. I will miss it.
Really? From what I can find on the internet, CA state income taxes are usually in the 10% range for most folks. Are you really paying 10% of your income for health insurance? I'm paying about 2.5% right now.
The 9.3% marginal bracket stretches from 61k-313k. (260k is the 95%ile for CA tax returns, so minor-increase brackets above this one don't matter all that much) 10.3% is 313k-375k. 11.3% is 375k-625k. (99%ile is 680k)
At 61k, at the end of the 8% bracket, the real tax rate is still just 4.40%. At 100k, 6.30% actual. At 150k, 7.30% actual. At 313k, 8.32% actual. At 375k, 8.67% actual. At 625k, still only 9.72% actual tax rate. We finally cross 10% actual at about $702k AGI.
It's really, really important to keep in mind how much marginal rates mess with calculations, particularly when estimating.
Also, Californians are statistically much poorer than people often expect, especially around here.
[1]: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/california-state-ta... [2]: https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-adjusted-gross-...
I highly doubt that number is only 2.5%.
The COBRA monthly pricetag is $2093.
While employed (at this Fortune 300 company's San Jose, CA office), I was paying $425 per month out of pocket for the same set of plans.
[1] https://www.bls.gov/ncs/ebs/factsheet/medical-care-premiums-...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/why-v...
>As with any attempt to dismantle one American health-care system and replace it with another, Green Mountain Care was always going to be a long game. For starters, it would not be until 2017 that any state could get federal permission to change the way it used insurance subsidies created under the ACA.
Did they repeal the tax increase?
This is from an advocacy organization that is more or less anti-tax. There are probably much more balanced takes on this proposal from other sources.
It's a little trickier to account for when the employer is 'self-insured' for healthcare. They'll use an insurance company to administer benefits (and pay for that), but they'll pay the costs for treatment rather than paying into an insurance pool and having the pool pay the costs.
As a libertarian, false dichotomies between de jure and de facto government are really bothersome. There are certainly arguments to be debated about single payer. There are certainly arguments to be debated about this particular attempt at "single payer". There are certainly arguments to be debated about who may be shouldering more or less of the costs with this plan. None of them are discussed here.
California has benefited from the Federal spending bonanza and also has famously high tax rates, treats capital gains as ordinary income, and has a lot of rich people. The FTB seems to have screwed up the links[1] and I can't find later data for a complete fiscal year, but check out "Ordinary Dividends" and "Capital Gain" in exhibit A9 for FY2019[2] to get a sense of how important that is to the state budget.
[1]: https://data.ftb.ca.gov/stories/s/Other-Tax-Data/sgxz-494k#d... [2]: https://data.ftb.ca.gov/download/d6s8-gyup/application%2Fpdf
I love this state’s geography and food scene, but the various governments here (local, county, state) aren’t exactly the pinnacle of smart governance.
Have you done this analysis? Most employers cover a portion of your employer sponsored health insurance. Are you expecting that your employer will just add this amount back to your salary?
At no point in my career, going back to fast food in college, have I ever spent 5-10% of my income on insurance. I would have to include the employer portion to even get close to that.
It's designed to be a progressive system, unlike current health insurance, so almost nobody's change will be net zero, even assuming the cost of providing the service is the same (which, who knows). Low-income earners can probably expect to pay considerably less, and high-income earners can expect to pay considerably more; only people right at the crossover point would expect no change.
When you are the single payer for the entire state, yes, I think the doctors in the state will take it.
I have a lot of complaints about my government (like most people), but the idea of universal healthcare isn’t one.
*edit: spelling
This is key here. So instead of paying this out to a private insurance company I pay it in taxes, there by my actual change is net zero, in most cases. I have a feeling most reactions might be headline driven here.
I think it’s worth doing the math on how much it costs you in healthcare coverage before really judging a book by its cover here. If my compound deductions are the same who cares if it’s just taxes?