News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dmix on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @07:13PM (#29719987)
I for one thank our piracy overlords who endlessly work to make every form of content (optionally) freely available in high quality.

I pay for plenty of subscription services that finally figured out how to make content as easy and accessible as piracy but there will forever exist legitimate gaps where “just pay for it” is simply insufficient (geo being #1, silly copyright owners #2, etc etc).

The other article mentions this dump is a result of a Discord dispute and we randos seem to be the winners. And who knows it might inspire others to get into the scene.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:25PM (#29721845)
Remember when the Covenant Kodi plugin was thriving and the media companies hadn't waged legal-nuclear war against that sort of thing yet? It finally felt like the future: I could watch anything, in any language it was available in, right now, in my chosen quality, with automatic subtitle downloads if you want that sort of thing.

I would pay good money for a service that could do that legitimately, but no, we can't have that.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by matheusmoreira on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:47AM (#29722562)
Copyright holders will never be able to compete with piracy. It's impossible. Imagine what it'd take for them to actually offer a service that can even begin to compare with what copyright infringement makes possible. They'd have to pool all their intellectual property into a single holding and offer access to all of it at once.

Piracy offers us all the works of humanity, everything ever created. These copyright holders can barely manage to display episodes in the correct order in their little streaming service user interfaces.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by eitland on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:22AM (#29723233)
> They'd have to pool all their intellectual property into a single holding and offer access to all of it at once.

Reading this triggered a (for me) very interesting observation - my feelings about video streaming services are not triggered by the price, but to the scamminess of it:

I've been paying for both Apple Music and Spotify for months - and I know it - and I don't care.

Contrary I did not sign up for HBO Max even at their low offer of around $5/month for life, and it annoys me that I have two video streaming sites already.

I think it is because both Spotify and Apple Music are OK: they contain almost everything I want from commercial music, while the video streaming sites feels like an elaborate scam: pay just as much as I pay for Spotify to an increasing number of services where none of them are good.

I want creators to get paid, but I don't want to support scams, so being somewhat principled I only watch whatever I have on DVD + what is available on the services I subscribe to (and I'm planning to get rid of one) and the few that I bought from Apple.

I can clearly see why people pirate though and if I worked in law enforcement I'd probably do my best to work with something important and useful, not to support large scale scams.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by madeofpalk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @09:19PM (#29732771)
What's this "scam" you keep mentioning?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:44PM (#29743021)
You pay for netflix yet you can't watch stuff you want. You search for a film and it shows up on the search autocomplete and yet it's not there. Why? Copyright bullshit nobody cares about.

Films that used to be in your list mysteriously disappear. You swear it was there but it's not. It's like netflix is gaslighting you. Sometimes you try to watch something only to be greeted by an ominous "last day to watch on netflix" notice. You thought you were paying for a subscription but it was really a long term rental that you have no idea when it expires. They simply take stuff away. Whenever something new shows up instead of being excited you now wonder how long it will take for them to take it away too. Cowboy Bebop? I wonder how long that's gonna last.

Whatever scraps and leftovers you do get is ruined by quality issues: extremely compressed encodes, shitty video player software, cropping, changes, sometimes they can't even get the episodes in the correct order which means I'd be watching it backwards. You now wonder if what you're watching on netflix is the best version. You now wonder if the netflix version is censored or altered in any way. I find myself searching for reddit discussions on a series to see if netflix screwed it up.

You entertain the notion of paying for other services as well but you discover their apps are even shittier and they still don't have what you want to watch. You remember facts such as amazon's non-existent customer service and the industry's tendency to profile you based on what you watch. You realize that paying money to these people is a lot like being in an abusive relationship.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by madeofpalk on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:25PM (#29743789)
"This shop doesn't sell everything I want" is hardly a scam.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by eitland on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:15AM (#29734779)
The scam is that it started out with Netflix being like Spotify, only even though I paid full price I couldn't see all content because I was in Norway.

Then more and more got pulled out and now if I want a full Spotify experience for video I need to subscribe to Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max, Warner, AppleTV and maybe a few more.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by freebuju on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:06AM (#29734725)
Not in OP's shoes but maybe they used to enjoy the convenience of being able to just watch Friends on Netflix. Or maybe they login to their Netflix on an "un-approved" device such as an Ubuntu PC and Netflix deems this bad so they get capped to 480p video streaming. Or just maybe, whatever price is deemed appropriate for a NF subscription is no match for the volumes of content available on the other side of the high seas for free.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by boudin on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:17AM (#29723497)
There is a way to make piracy obsolete which almost happened in France: the Licence Globale. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_globale (content in French).

The concept is to allow the exchange of copyrighted cultural goods and collect a fee at the ISP level to finance those back.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by sofixa on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:46AM (#29723678)
Thank you for this. What a world we could have had if this law had passed!
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by skyzyx on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:51AM (#29767017)
I co-founded a company in 2006 which intended to do something very similar to this. We ran out of money when the economy collapsed in 2008. I’m still passionate about the idea, but it’s high-risk for a private corporation in the US to pull off.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by lemoncookiechip on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:48AM (#29724325)
> Imagine what it'd take for them to actually offer a service that can even begin to compare with what copyright infringement makes possible

Netflix was kinda of that for a few years (2012-2015) before the rise of streaming services. Piracy was way down (P2P not indicative of the whole picture, but good enough), during that period. Then everyone decided to make their own platforms and started taking pieces of the pie from Netflix and here we are today, where you need at least 4-5 services to get access to half a dozen show you want to watch per year, as well as requiring a VPN service if you don't want to have less than 20% of the US library in a lot of countries.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by paganel on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:54AM (#29722854)
> in the correct order in their little streaming service user interfaces.

And in the correct format [1]. Made me just want to pirate Seinfeld so that I could watch it under the proper conditions, but I'm too lazy for that as Netflix is just a few clicks away.

[1] https://twitter.com/Thatoneguy64/status/1443961536079450117?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:00AM (#29724407)
Every version of Mission Hill except the pirated one has the wrong goddamned music!
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:12PM (#29743252)
How embarrassing.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by thih9 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:06AM (#29722904)
> Copyright holders will never be able to compete with piracy. It's impossible.

Legal music streaming is good enough for me. Seems a much more convenient and less fragmented ecosystem; I wish movie streaming was like that.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bayindirh on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:02AM (#29723165)
The only problem is "license expire" between the labels and the streamers.

My absolute favorite song suffered from this. One morning I opened Spotify, and all the songs in that album was greyed out.

It returned a couple of months later, but it's an enough of a warning.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Sander_Marechal on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:12AM (#29723204)
I would love to see compulsory licensing schemes for audio and video streaming like they have for radio broadcasts. Maybe allow 1 or 2 years of exclusivity, but anything else is fair game to stream by anyone as long as they pay the license fee.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by sneak on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:49AM (#29723364)
We don't need compulsory licensing; we already have piracy. Everything is already available, forever, for free, without DRM.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by sdoering on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:22AM (#29724177)
Some people would love to compensate the original creator. And some people would be willing to pay to be able to easily consume content legally.

The problem is that the current state of affairs is fragmented and not set up in a way that ensures that I as a consumer can be sure that I can consume said content again tomorrow.

I pay for access but am not ensured that the content I like is going to be available.

That makes piracy an option for some.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bayindirh on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @07:33AM (#29724233)
The best thing is iTunes store IMHO.

I start to listen an album via Spotify. I buy it via iTunes if I continue to listen it. If I really like that album that much, I find a lossless copy.

If I can buy a lossless copy from the original artist, I go that route first. RadioHead's leading the pack on that. I have a 24bit wav album from them.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by mrja on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:17PM (#29729470)
this would be nice if artists which one can relate to had any correlation to how, and, more importantly when, society affords them their existence.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by luckylion on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:11AM (#29722924)
> Copyright holders will never be able to compete with piracy.

Music has proven that idea wrong. I'm part of a few private music trackers that came after oink and what.cd. They're much smaller today than they used to. Legal music streaming has made them all but obsolete for everyone but enthusiasts. They're maybe serving 200k people worldwide, if you include the language-specific ones from China, Korea etc.

Spotify alone has 172 million premium subscribers.

Movies are similar.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:29PM (#29743388)
Yeah, if you like popular music which is what the average person consumes. If I look up some less popular artist or even a soundtrack on spotify chances are it won't be there. About a year ago I tried it, found exactly one of the about 30 works I searched for. All the stuff that gets played on the radio is there, of course. It was an immensely disappointing experience. Why pay for this crap since I'll still have to resort to youtube or something to get what I want?

What I meant by competition is they won't be able to offer higher quality and availability. They will never achieve the ideal I proposed: everything humanity has ever created at the highest possible quality. They are of course masters at being just good enough for the average consumer. Honestly that bar is pretty low.

I will never forgive them for shutting what.cd down. I consider that a crime against humanity itself that vastly outweighs whatever little profits they thought they were losing.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by baybal2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:52AM (#29723708)
> Legal music streaming has made them all but obsolete for everyone but enthusiasts.

Sitting in a cafe Abu Dhabi now, a shop on the opposite side of the street has "$10 for 1000 MP3 Hitz"

I don't know who streams, when you can just download MP3s.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by vladvasiliu on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:30AM (#29724619)
I do (Spotify). It's much, much more convenient, and quality is good enough.

Of course, I'm a bit concerned with the tracks "unavailable in my region" or "no longer available at all", but convenience trumps it.

As others have said, when I really like an album or something, I'll usually buy it, ideally lossless download, but a CD will do in a pinch.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by luckylion on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:31AM (#29724625)
It's mostly three things according to my friends who use streaming services:

1) discovery: Spotify is great at giving you more of what you like, without you needing to manage your library

2) ease of access: No need to carry around a hard drive to have everything available

3) giant catalogue: to buy MP3s at that price and have a similar breadth and depth as Spotify (or rather: what you'd use of Spotify), you'd pay a lot more.

If you just want some tunes and are happy with what's very popular, you could also stream for free from Youtube.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by heavyset_go on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:02AM (#29723428)
> They'd have to pool all their intellectual property into a single holding and offer access to all of it at once.

They could federate and rely on open protocols, but that might be less profitable.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by madeofpalk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @09:17PM (#29732756)
Doesn't the success of Netflix, Spotify and the rest say otherwise?

I pirate significantly less content than before because its just easier to watch on Netflix or buy the season from iTunes or whatever.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by katbyte on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:33AM (#29723032)
Games and music seem to have managed to defeat piracy. And when it was just Netflix before the fragmentation and greed of the movie/tv content holders no one I knew downloaded.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by tpxl on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:35AM (#29723299)
They have, then came Epic Games store and we're back to exclusives.

If you want a really good example of where video games got it wrong in recent years: Metro Exodus was sold as a "pre-purchase" on Steam before it released for some time (at least a few months, could be a year). A few days before release it went exclusive on Epic Game store IIRC and you couldn't buy _or download_ it on steam anymore. After some well deserved outrage, people who pre-purchased on steam could play on steam, but you couldn't purchase it for about another year.

Metro: Exodus was the only title I pirated in the last 10 years because they took away the ability to purchase it (and I like the series and have the first two titles on steam, and I bought and read the books because of the first game).

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by gruturo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:49AM (#29723360)
> They have, then came Epic Games store and we're back to exclusives.

And that's why I'll never buy anything from them even if it's nice. I feel morally compelled to do my tiny part to let them (and every other steam competitor) go bust, to stave off exactly the fragmentation we see in the video streaming market.

Of course, there's always the possibility of Steam becoming evil and making all of us regret propping them up, but you know what? I'll have to live with it.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dartharva on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:13AM (#29723482)
> Games and music seem to have managed to defeat piracy.

> Games

Hmm.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dmix on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:07AM (#29722106)
I use Kodi on my android smart box with some 4K soc, almost daily. With some addons it’s like god tier piracy.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dghughes on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @07:41PM (#29720249)
Amazon and Apple lure you in but many shows it seems need to be rented or bought. How much disposable income do these companies think the average Joe has to spend? the answer seems to be $10 to $20 to rent or "buy" movies. Which you never own a physical copy of. They seem to be out of touch with reality.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Philip-J-Fry on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:14PM (#29720498)
People used to buy DVDs or blu-rays for $10-20. But of all the ones I have, there's probably only a handful that have been watched more than once.

That's what the renting system is built off. The fact that most people only watch a film once.

I couldn't care less about whether I own a copy of a movie. All I care is that I can watch it when I want to watch it. That's a different issue though, not one of disposable income, but of licensing and content availability.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bluedino on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:32PM (#29721510)
Christmas is a good example. A couple years ago I threw out all of my DVD's.

We watch the same ten or so movies every holiday season. Now we scramble to find them on streaming services and pay $3-5 each to watch.

At one point I had them all downloaded on a portable HD (along with others) but it failed, and why back up what you can just re-download?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Consultant32452 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:51PM (#29721633)
I don't understand why the major streaming services don't have the good Christmas movies. They all have these new "made for TV" quality awful movies they push really hard.

It's A Wonderful Life

A Christmas Carol

Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer (old animated version)

How the Grinch Stole Christmas (old animated version)

National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation

Home Alone

Miracle On 34th Street

Elf

White Christmas

There's tons of GREAT Christmas movies. On any given Christmas season Netflix might have 1-2 of the greats. Same for Amazon Prime.

I'm confused because it seems like an easy win for these streaming services. Is licensing them really so expensive?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by xwolfi on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:08PM (#29721747)
Imagine you re a tv station with a license. I think you re ready to MURDER to keep some of these exclusive, must be their last easy butter these days.

Last time I watched tv I did the whole vpn + american tv package thing and I just was appalled at the sheer amount of unwatchable content (ads)... I pity these things, how did it even work in the first place?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by lostlogin on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:57AM (#29722598)
Christmas without a Die Hard?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by stjohnswarts on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:05AM (#29722628)
Not a christmas I want any part of.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Trex_Egg on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:12AM (#29722398)
I agree with the points that you are making, which makes the high quality entertainment cheap or affordable at scale.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dmix on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:01PM (#29720396)
I stupidly “rented” a copy of Apollo 13 for $3.99 and being a long movie fell asleep halfway through. I came back to watch it a few days later and found the rental had “expired” in 2-3 days and was required to pay again to continue watching.

Sometimes I think these people live in an alternate universe. last time I did that.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by ramraj07 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:13PM (#29721370)
Pirate if you want (and can) but let’s not keep persisting the myth that these companies are being unreasonable. The average family paid 100 for cable and on top kept buying dvds for 10-20 a pop. These streamers are just trying to replicate that level of spending (and for the most part, failing).
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by kortilla on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:31PM (#29721888)
> The average family paid 100 for cable and on top kept buying dvds for 10-20 a pop.

Lol, no way in hell that was the average. That was the high end dream consumer that very few of the people I knew matched even back in cable’s heyday.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/680645/number-of-cable-s...

In my family we would rent lots of movies each week with an 2-3 times a week ritual trip to the video rental store to pick something out for $2 or so.

Movies we liked were bought when they went on sale at the cheap DVD trough at Walmart for $5.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:28AM (#29723006)
probably it was the average family but not the median family, which of course means that the high end dream consumer family was paying much more than that.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by VRay on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:25AM (#29723247)
Man, I grew up lower/lower-middle class, about 30-40% of the median family income, and we had the $80/month cable package plus went to Blockbuster for 5+ rentals per week

I don't think that was unusual, either.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by ralferoo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @06:08AM (#29723795)
If you're watching 5+ rental films per week, when do you have the time to watch anything on the cable package?

Sounds like a ridiculous waste of money to me, but then I'm firmly at the other end of the spectrum. I finally cancelled my £30 a month TV package, I've not rented a film for over 10 years, and would buy blu-rays or DVDs only for things I thought I'd watch more than once, or where buying them was cheaper than renting (common in the case of box sets).

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:09AM (#29724471)
It's not particularly difficult to imagine a family situation where that would happen - although perhaps not nowadays when there is a much broader entertainment landscape:

1. traditional patriarchal setup, male parent works, mother at home, watches some cable during the day.

2. Kids come home from school / kindergarten at 4, watch some cable.

3. Eat dinner at 7, watch movie.

4. kids go to bed at 9, folks watch cable for couple hours.

5. Kids at age where they have their own tastes, 3 kids, buy 2 movies for adults 3 movies for kids or variations thereof.

I mean obviously the time to do this stuff is a waste of time, but often families waste the time because parents are burned out from various things and the easiest way to get through the time is to give everyone media to consume and forget about them.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by VRay on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @10:04PM (#29733063)
Yeah, it probably wasn't the most efficient use of my family's limited budget, but that's how it goes

Nowadays I'm a big /r/financialindependence guy, and I was shocked recently to find out that a lot of my lower-middle class friends and family are constantly ordering food with those ripoff delivery apps. It's completely insane IMO to pay $50 for cold, soggy food that should have cost 25, but I guess people do it. They buy new top-end smartphones every year or two, lease cars, and do all sorts of other ridiculous money-wasting stuff.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by kortilla on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:17PM (#29743740)
Of course you don’t think it was unusual, that was your upbringing. The stats I linked showed that cable’s peak was 40 million households.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by kortilla on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:19PM (#29743753)
No, it wasn’t the median either. That would be the high end of a cable subscriber setup in the 90s and 00s. About the only way to go above it is constant on demand rentals and PPV fights.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by na85 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:41PM (#29721930)
They are being unreasonable, though.

They had a moat that let them gouge consumers for years, but the moat dried up and now they're throwing a tantrum because they can't continue their outdated and overpriced business model.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by ddingus on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:55PM (#29722031)
TL;DR: They are being for the most part perfectly reasonable, and the rest of this comment suggests why that is.

Yes, and average cost and risk exposure that family sees is higher now, wages down or flat.

First order realization:

I've long maintained most families have a fixed entertainment budget. They have their monthly nut to crack, and entertainment falls into that somewhere, with a little flexibility here and there.

Say that's a few hundred dollars. Might be $200 or less, depending.

The various entertainment forms compete for those dollars, and sometimes compete to stretch the amount a little too. Something really special might displace some other spend, or warrant a draw from savings, use of credit, whatever.

This was my experience bringing up a family through the 90's and 00's. I had a few hundred bucks for entertainment, special spends, and that was basically it, unless there were very compelling reasons, say getting a new game console, or special event that warranted some other adjustment to allow for greater entertainment spending.

There is a near infinite demand for entertainment! Maybe not infinite, but it's a lot higher than the budgets would fund at the generally accepted market prices. This demand is both material, in that real, liquid dollars are there to satisfy the demand, as well as demand not backed by liquid dollars. (the latter being an opportunity to build relevance and sell through later, whether that is recognized as marketing efforts tend to be is another discussion)

Second order realizations:

The entertainment spend is made each month and every month overall, and that's true whether there is massive piracy, or not.

Additionally, content that is pirated hard also earns well. Content that is lightly pirated also tends to not do well.

Entertainment forms compete. Video game vs movie vs whatever. There is a little flexibility, but overall the dollars go where the value perception is highest. Basically max entertainment per dollar. How people see this is all over the map too.

Pricing up can be the right move, as can pricing down. Depends on value perception, relevance, and how that stacks up to the entertainment budgets out there and the different forms.

Third order:

Piracy =/= a loss.

Infringment is weird. It's not theft in that no one is denied property or rights. It's all about people doing or experiencing something they were not supposed to.

There is value created via infringement too. A lot of the sales opportunity boils down to personal relevance. When a content creator is irrelevant, they must somehow reach potential consumers, who then become opportunities for income.

Infringement builds relevance the same as licensed users do, and it all works the same, personal recommendations, sharing, all that stuff people do in order to trade on and participate in culture and relevance applies when people use the content whether it's infringing use or not.

All this suggests a strategy allowing infringement as investment in relevance which will deliver returns in the form of high value license rental or longer term media entitlement purchases later. Higher quality, greater availbility, as in "I'll buy this and share it with the others on my subscription.

Many people subscribe and share with parents, friends, family making good use of both the profile capability and device allowances. This is "infringement" in a similar sense to piracy, but different in that it's not a high priority for enforcement.

Finally, pricing / piracy / competition with other media forms tend to make pricing self-correct and settle in to maxima. There is a right price to capture more value with material demand backed by dollars. Too high, and other forms will garner more of the entertainment dollars, or other works in the same form may do that too. Too low, and value perception may be impacted as well as leaving money on the table.

Subscriptions / content distribution agreements are a way to leverage many works and secure a more consistent share of the entertainment spends without as much risk and costs associated with going solo against high value, easy access, players.

See HBO MAX and how it's basically owning the new release. Used to be going to a theatre or buying a first release media copy was the way to go on a new movie. HBO MAX subscribers get it on release day, and it's great, easy, you name it. Tons of revenue locked in, forecastable, and so on.

The more of this we see that adds value, the less piracy will matter because that will be satisfying demand not backed by liquid dollars, but will still contribute to relevancy and can be considered an investment in the future as those people may change socioeconomic status and be able to meet demand with real dollars in the future.

Where it does not add value, say exclusives to drive new subscriptions, like we see with Paramount+ carving out a new service for "Star Trek" essentially, piracy may well be a response as will other higher value subscriptions and purchases win out over the arguably crappy deal required to see what is compelling, but not worth the hassle production. Basically, the program was used to add value to the basic subscription tier, then elevated to a new / higher service level without adding very much other value.

As examples:

Our family loves HBO MAX for the no bull shit, flat fee get new movies deal. We watched the new Matrix movie on release day, as we have others, and gladly buy this service.

We hate the CBS games being played. Do not gladly buy. Would consider just waiting and pirating the Star Trek, because it's a PITA now, or too expensive / time consuming to sign up, watch, then cancel because there isn't anything else, blah, blah...

Prior to these common sense streaming services, our family would pirate quite a bit, while buying quite a bit with the problem being unable to buy in ways, and on time, to make sense. It was often unavailable, or painful, or way over the top expensive...

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by azinman2 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:29PM (#29720638)
And what happened in the VHS days?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by archsurface on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:36PM (#29720690)
You connected the player to another player and copied it.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by throwawayboise on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @08:51PM (#29720795)
That typically didn't work very well, as there was crude anti-copying tech in most VHS consumer machines.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by archsurface on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:17PM (#29721401)
I never encountered that. Country related? I wasn't in the US. Year related - from the get go, or later on?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by naikrovek on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:00PM (#29720855)
macro block, a.k.a. MacroVision.

as a child I knew a guy that knew how to make the recording VCR record those properly, though I don't know how it was done.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bb88 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:52PM (#29721221)
It had to do with screwing around with the vertical blanking interval. TV's had no issue with it, but VCR's would fail.

Cable TV "scrambling" was similar back in the day as well. It wasn't so much that the signal was "encrypted" as it was "modified" in such a way it wouldn't play on a normal tv anymore. Over time they could modify the scrambling technique so that any box you did buy to descramble a signal would be worthless in a few months when they changed the method.

The only way to really descramble Pay TV was to be an electronics guy who could reconstruct the video signal. Usually you needed the minimum of an oscilloscope to analyze the timing signals, and then the ability to create a circuit to fix it -- it wasn't exactly easy.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:09AM (#29722913)
In the early 80s where I lived, there was some kind of filler that, once removed, allowed you to watch HBO. It was housed in a green box exterior to each house, where the cable left the street and entered your house.

I don’t know if it was a filter really. It was just an electronic component of some kind that screwed on/off.

When you ordered HBO, someone visited your property to remove this thing.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bb88 on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:35AM (#29734877)
Back when TV stations were broadcast on frequencies, it would be as simple as a notch filter to block out that particular frequency that HBO/Skinemax was on.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by rOOb85 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:41AM (#29722264)
My dad had a black box that worked awesome. It had a little dial in the back that you could twist to dial in a channel to be super clear.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by hunter2_ on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:50PM (#29721206)
I'm guessing it was something like a jumper over an AGC (auto gain control) circuit VCRs use to avoid saturating the tape, since the MacroVision mechanism was basically to intermittently blast out-of-frame lines with too-intense brightness, which has no effect on a typical TV, but does make the AGC clamp down so the whole frame is intermittently too dark.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by idworks1 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:09PM (#29720910)
Ah yes, crude indeed. We used to cut a small piece of payer, around an inch. Then fold it into a little square and place it inside that little empty square space on the front of the cassette tape. That's all it took to subvert it.

By the way this worked just as well for audio cassettes tape.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by YPPH on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:30PM (#29721045)
As sidpatil says, that's a write-protect tab. If you bought blank VHS tapes and recorded something you could rip the tab off to stop you or someone else accidentally overwriting, say, your wedding video. Of course, all retail tapes were tab free.

And you could simply use masking tape to bypass it, because it was only designed to stop unintentional overwriting, not intentional overwriting.

I'm pretty sure as a kid I wrote over a few (bad) retail VHS movies this way, tapes that served more value as blanks.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by nebula8804 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:16AM (#29722953)
>I'm pretty sure as a kid I wrote over a few (bad) retail VHS movies this way, tapes that served more value as blanks.

Now that I think about it, I've never gotten a Blockbuster/Hollywood Video rental that was damaged in this manner. This method of property destruction never even crossed my mind. It seems so obvious given how easy it is to disable write protection. Was I just lucky or were people more considerate back then?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by YPPH on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:04AM (#29724433)
Just to clarify, I meant retail tapes I (read: my parents) owned. I never overwrote rented tapes.

I recall rental shops would have rewind machines, but I don't remember them ever checking the content of the tape.

Maybe people were just considerate. Maybe the threat of having a whopping fine when the the next unhappy renter returned and complained about the tape, causing the shop to check the rental history, dissuaded such behaviour.

Or, maybe people respected the institution. I used to really like video stores as they offered affordable access to entertainment and were just nice places to visit.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by sidpatil on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:19PM (#29720982)
I thought that was a write-protect tab. That shouldn't have affected the ability to read from the tape, but only the ability to record to it.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dwild on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:18PM (#29721802)
You can still do the same. HDCP has been broken for a long time now...
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Vrondi on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:51PM (#29722006)
He would have recorded it with a VCR during a promotional free weekend on HBO or similar, then watched it whenever desired.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by nebula8804 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:18AM (#29722965)
Yes this used to be a fun hobby. All my favorite films were TV runs and i'd have to time the stop button so I minimized any commercials ending up on the recording. Same goes for recording audio on the Radio onto tapes. It was a simpler time back then.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dwild on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:21PM (#29721818)
He would have made a similar comment but instead would complains of late fees.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by azinman2 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:13AM (#29723209)
You’re the only one who seems to have gotten that :)
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by jzb on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:48PM (#29721188)
If they’re out of touch with reality, there will be a price adjustment or they’ll fail. Something tells me they’ve done the research to determine what the average person will pay.

Looking at some newer films rentals are $4-$6 and “buying” $8-$15. Probably more for really new releases.

$4 for a rental isn’t bad compared to renting a VHS or DVD at Blockbuster a few years ago.

Compared to taking a few adults and kids to a movie theater, it’s a steal.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dmix on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:53PM (#29721232)
But why is rebutting a few days and not at least a week. Never made sense.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Skunkleton on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:10PM (#29721358)
s/rebutting/renting?

Its a few days because you can rent digitally just before you buy it. Back in the Hollywood Video days, you also had to make a special trip to the video store. Often this was done days in advance.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by tptacek on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:36PM (#29721108)
There has never been a better time to be a consumer of home media than today. I wouldn't trade the (legal) access I have to essentially any film or TV show I can imagine wanting to watch for any conceivable bookshelf full of DVDs. The Blockbuster Video and Comcast Premium Channel Package era was no more cost effective, and things just get worse as you go further back in time.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by chx on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:15PM (#29721386)
> the (legal) access I have to essentially any film or TV show I can imagine

My imagination runs amok..

There is a Disney+ but https://disney.fandom.com/wiki/Little_Dog_Lost is not on it. Nor is any other Walt Disney's Wonderful World of Color or whatever name the anthology ran on television since 1954 but to me this is the only one that matters, what can I do, I love corgis :)

The Mists Of Avalon mini series from 2001 is nowhere to be found.

Many, many movies have been made out of the novel The Count of Monte Cristo but what many consider the closest to the book, Robert Vernay's version from 1954 with no less than Jean Marais in the lead is impossible to find these days. This was Vernay's second Cristo movie, the vision he always wanted to make but couldn't in 1943 when he made the first. But no one knows of it because streaming, DVD, whatever you want just doesn't exist. Rare Films And More sourced a high quality 16mm print (it's in German) and digitized it and wrote English subtitles for it -- but it's a pirated copy, I don't think it entered the public domain yet.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dave5104 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:33PM (#29721521)
About your Disney+ example, I do wonder why it seems that a lot of content like that isn't available on the platform.

Are there streaming rights issues? Are they holding back content to drip feed content drops for as long as they can? Did they determine that some content isn't worth digging up the tapes and preparing for streaming?

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by danaris on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @10:09AM (#29725430)
Disney has always made a big deal out of the "Disney Vault"—back in the VHS days, they tried to replicate the scarcity of waiting until a movie was showing in a local theater by arbitrarily refusing to sell copies of some of their movies for years at a time. I believe they continued this practice with DVDs and Blu-Rays, though not nearly as widely.

This seems likely to be part of the same philosophy.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by foobarian on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:54PM (#29722026)
I wonder also how much of the older content is self-censored for e.g. political correctness reasons.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Lio on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:17AM (#29723504)
That’s certainly seems to be true for Kundun (1997).

The Chinese Communist Party wasn’t happy the film was made in the first place and would probably ban Disney from their market if it was available for streaming in the USA.

It’s quiet, limited sale on DVD is still tolerated.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kundun

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @03:20AM (#29722974)
This is indeed true of movies such as Disney’s Song of the the South. You won’t find that anywhere;; even eBay prevents sale of the DVD.

Cartoons have also been censored:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censored_Eleven

https://deadline.com/2021/03/pepe-le-pew-space-jam-2-new-yor...

Many cartoon shorts from the 30s and 40s with blackface and other offensive material has been edited. I can’t find references right now, but have noticed this personally.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by Thorrez on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:04PM (#29721712)
Yeah, it's sad some stuff isn't available. I think it was worse in the past though.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by stkdump on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:48PM (#29721192)
I used to live next to a DVD rental place that was 1€ per day. Often I would return the movie the same night. I used to watch 1-2 movies per month. Nowadays I have Netflix for what, 12€ a month? I still watch maybe one movie a month. So I guess I pay ~10x for not having to step outside?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by egypturnash on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:53PM (#29721643)
I sure did watch a lot more stuff when I lived a block away from Scarecrow Video, one of the last great video rental stores. With shelves full of stuff that had been curated, with staff notes here and there calling out the occasional film.

Theoretically the streaming services are more convenient, they're all lurking right there on my PS4, but... I never really touch the things.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by ramraj07 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:14PM (#29721384)
So I suppose we should all move within walking distance to a rental place (that too a cheap one at that). Even back then it’s a pipe dream.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by lotsofpulp on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:57PM (#29721268)
You pay 10x for access to Netflix’s content.

The fact that you only want to watch 1 movie out of their catalog is irrelevant. I do not find their content worth it, so I do not pay Netflix.

I find it better to just rent a movie from an online provider if/when I want to watch one, since I rarely watch. If I want to watch it over and over, I buy it (kids’ movies).

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by stkdump on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:03PM (#29721319)
So I pay for what I don't need to get the little that do I need. What you call irrelevant I call the core of their business model.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by lotsofpulp on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:06PM (#29721342)
My point was that it is not productive to compare a la carte business models to all you can eat business models.

If you want to compare DVD rental to renting a movie on Apple/Google Play/Amazon, that would make more sense.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dmix on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:56PM (#29721262)
Bit of a niche anecdote.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by tomc1985 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:56PM (#29721653)
Sure, but how many streaming packages do you need to pay for (every month!) to be able to say you have that?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by duxup on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:57PM (#29721659)
I find I have access to a ton of content for the cost of a couple cds and dvds.

I like it.

Content is mostly ephemeral for me. I don't want to manage a ton of files or physical media.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by HWR_14 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:33PM (#29721511)
I assume that's mostly indicative of the rights they were able to grab, vs. seeking profit.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by stjohnswarts on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @02:03AM (#29722625)
they count on you to price it against going to the movies and a lot of people (particularly families) choose to stay home and spend 1/5 to 1/10 what they would have spend going to the theater
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by vimy on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:02PM (#29720870)
It’s bad UI design that mixes up two different services.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by labster on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:46PM (#29721171)
Amazon should offer an NFT of a physical copy for each streamed movie you buy. Then they could also sell that physical copy to another consumer. It’s a win-win!
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by harles on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @09:56PM (#29721260)
How does decentralization help with a centralized service?
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bitexploder on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:28PM (#29721480)
Magical acronyms and thinking.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by paulcole on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:27PM (#29721472)
I’ll admit I don’t understand how people can ethically pirate content. I dislike a lot of business models but I just don’t feel right calling them “silly” and looking for ways to take things I know I don’t have the right to take.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by benrbray on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:41PM (#29721931)
As an example, I recently wanted to watch The West Wing. I pay for Netflix and Hulu already, but the show is only on HBO Max. OK, fine, I guess I'll pay for a month of HBO like I've done before to watch Game of Thrones.

Ok, uh, what's it called now? HBO Go? HBO Now? Oh, HBO Max, ok. I live in Japan now, so I'm region-blocked, great. Time to open the VPN. HBO already seems to know that server #1243 is a VPN, but server #849 works OK for now.

Ok, time to create an account. "Account with that email already exists"? Ok, so let's log in using my old HBO Go credentials. Looks like there's some kind of account migration problem and the account is stuck in the "account verification" phase but I can't get it to send me a new verification email. There's a little pop-up chat window for the support team, let's try it. Three separate support agents and thirty minutes later, I have a working verification email. But my payment information is out of date. OK, let's update it. HTTP 505 error. Wonderful.

Ok, that's enough: Type "West Wing season 1 episode 1" into Google. Thirty seconds later I'm watching in full HD and there's popcorn in the microwave.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by nix23 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:25AM (#29723547)
Yep, same old story. If pirating has the better deployment, then pirating is the better service.

People have no problem to pay, but driving into the city to buy a cd then convert it so you can listen to it on your ipod......or eMule?

I love it that they are resistant to learn anything from the past.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by hellotomyrars on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:46PM (#29721605)
This is admittedly a small percentage corner case but there are people who are legitimately unable to access the content even if they want to and are willing/prepared to pay depending on their geographic location.

I pay for Prime and Netflix but I still often torrent shows from those services because of the stupid widevine drm level restrictions on quality/resolution. I guess you could say that’s not piracy then but I’m sure I’ve got things downloaded that are no longer on their catalogues so it’s hard to know.

When Netflix had 70% of the media content you’d want I was very happy to be a paying customer but now I’m mostly a begrudgingly paying customer as the cost goes up the the library shrinks. Everyone wants their piece of the pie right now and I don’t doubt they’re going to consolidate to some extent after the winners and losers are decided but it sucks ass that the ecosystem has become so fragmented.

Also having the raw files makes it easier for me to sync up watching with my fiancé who is currently abroad. She pays for Netflix in the UK but even when both libraries have the same content the UK version often has different intro credits which makes syncing difficult.

I guess the overall crux of my issue with the business model is that I can pay $15 a month to access X service and get hundreds/thousands of movies and shows or Something like $20 a season for a show which could end up being hundreds of dollars for just one show. The economics really just break down for me since they price owning a digital copy against physical. Ironically physical copies will end up getting discounted at retail because things have to move but the digital copies won’t. Also in many cases even owning a copy digitally doesn’t give you the ability to dictate where you use it/give you a raw file.

I just want things to work the way I need them to, however that manifests and the only way to do that is with the video files themselves and any barrier or artifice between them is a problem.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by jancsika on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:38AM (#29722247)
> I dislike a lot of business models but I just don’t feel right calling them “silly” and looking for ways to take things I know I don’t have the right to take.

How do you know if you have a right to take them?

If it's according to the law, then your ethical stance changes with the wind. E.g., you would believe you have a right to derive new music by taking a chord progression from your favorite song, but not by taking the melody. Worse, the rich history in the U.S. of building new songs out of old chord progressions was preferred to taking melodies chiefly because it was illegal to take copyrighted melodies and put new chord changes to them. So your ethical stance would change depending on whether you happen to be reading the notes that are stacked vertically on the page (i.e., a chord), or horizontally across it (a melody). That's ethically incoherent.

If it's according to your own ethical stance, you have to explain what that stance is. E.g., are you ethically opposed to circumventing a company's API to download content in a way they didn't intend? Are you opposed to someone accepting a flash drive from a friend that has their friend's favorite music on it? Someone pasting their big fat head on indy content and reposting as a "reaction video" to steal views? I happen to think these aren't all covered by the same ethical rule, but maybe they are.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by paulcole on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @08:03AM (#29724425)
> How do you know if you have a right to take them?

If someone says “This is $5.” And if I don’t pay them $5, then I feel like I don’t have a right to it. If it takes paragraphs of text to explain why despite not paying them $5 I have a right to take it, then I feel like I don’t have a right to take it.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by dartharva on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @05:19AM (#29723513)
Not just "silly", many are genuinely user-hostile. I have legitimate copies of games that I'd rather not touch as against pirated copies of the same games (mostly from Rockstar and Ubisoft) that provide an objectively superior, garbage-free experience.

Same goes with Movies and shows. I have Netflix and PrimeVideo subscriptions but the overall quality they provide is trash as against 4K ripped HEVC releases with 10bit audio and better subtitles which you can watch in whatever player you want.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by nitrogen on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:58PM (#29722053)
I subscribe to some streaming services and that's all I use, but consider this: copyright grants ownership over a fraction of your mind without your consent. Once you've seen a show or heard a song, whether you chose to or not, those neurons are permanently allocated to that show or song. How is that ethical?

Moreover, the current state of copyright gives a few large corporations enormous power to shape our culture. The stories of our time should belong to us well before we're dead, but copyright lasts well past one human lifetime.

And as others have mentioned, sometimes there is no price you can pay to legally watch something, for reasons that are truly "silly" to anyone who isn't profiting from the international balkanization of distributors. Like the Great British Baking Show on Netflix: it's actually Great British Bake Off, and you can't watch the original in the US. Good luck finding anywhere to watch Grand Designs (from any locale) in the US without ads, no matter how much you'd be willing to pay. There are many examples of shows from UK, Australia, and New Zealand that aren't available in the US at all, and probably vice versa, let alone the rest of the world.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by brazed_blotch on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:53PM (#29721644)
Why do you have to justify it? You might pirate content simply because you can.

If you don't want someone to copy your data without charge then find a better business model.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by glanzwulf on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:53AM (#29723387)
For me its quite simple. Just the other day I really wanted to watch Anthony Bourdains No Reservations. Where I am right now I can't do:

1. Stream 2. Purchase 3. Rent 4. Catch on tv 5. Subscribe to an american streaming service using a vpn (requires an american credit card, and while there are services that allow to get a pseudo prepaid card the costs of it all are huge)

I can however pirate it.

Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by bo1024 on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:51PM (#29722005)
Your use of the word "take" is probably related to the disconnect. In copyright violations, the crime is copying. Usually "taking" has a different connotation than copying. (I'd be mad if you took my bike, but if you copied it then I'd just be happy for you.)
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by paulcole on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:05AM (#29722099)
If I’m describing an action I took as a “crime” I’m not going to feel good about it no matter how finely I choose to split the hairs.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by lazyasciiart on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @04:11AM (#29723197)
Some people have a looser coupling between legality and morality than others, often because they disapprove of some laws (like the crime of sleeping under a bridge, or repairing your own tractor…)
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:42PM (#29721938)
try it. use their best practices and be amazed how much mental energy it saves.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by paulcole on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @11:46PM (#29721969)
I don’t find it takes much mental energy to pay for what I want to watch or just watch something else if I can’t pay for what I want to watch.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @11:20AM (#29726217)
You are absolutely right it's the least draining part of the streaming experience. First you have to look if it's on a streaming service or where you can buy it in the quality you look for, is it like many sport events even available in my country, does the device or browser use the right drm or do I just get the 720p version, is it just the dub and not OV. Why are there no forced subtitles? What my Mac and Windows PCs can't play Blurays? What no Dolby passthrough? Your comment is just ignorant to the problem itself.
Re:Tools to Download Netflix / Disney / Apple TV Content by throwaway984393 on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @01:08AM (#29722379)
Maybe they're Utilitarianists.