What I meant by competition is they won't be able to offer higher quality and availability. They will never achieve the ideal I proposed: everything humanity has ever created at the highest possible quality. They are of course masters at being just good enough for the average consumer. Honestly that bar is pretty low.
I will never forgive them for shutting what.cd down. I consider that a crime against humanity itself that vastly outweighs whatever little profits they thought they were losing.
Sitting in a cafe Abu Dhabi now, a shop on the opposite side of the street has "$10 for 1000 MP3 Hitz"
I don't know who streams, when you can just download MP3s.
Of course, I'm a bit concerned with the tracks "unavailable in my region" or "no longer available at all", but convenience trumps it.
As others have said, when I really like an album or something, I'll usually buy it, ideally lossless download, but a CD will do in a pinch.
1) discovery: Spotify is great at giving you more of what you like, without you needing to manage your library
2) ease of access: No need to carry around a hard drive to have everything available
3) giant catalogue: to buy MP3s at that price and have a similar breadth and depth as Spotify (or rather: what you'd use of Spotify), you'd pay a lot more.
If you just want some tunes and are happy with what's very popular, you could also stream for free from Youtube.
Music has proven that idea wrong. I'm part of a few private music trackers that came after oink and what.cd. They're much smaller today than they used to. Legal music streaming has made them all but obsolete for everyone but enthusiasts. They're maybe serving 200k people worldwide, if you include the language-specific ones from China, Korea etc.
Spotify alone has 172 million premium subscribers.
Movies are similar.