In some ways this was the extra profits banks made off illegal activities but that was largely held within the bank, not available to normies.
Few outside people get rich off the mafia.
Bitcoin is in contrast a pure fiat currency with very weak backing. Nobody has a need for it which can’t be satisfied at least as well by alternatives and it requires a very expensive always-on network to perform transactions. The floor is zero and liquidity is a very real concern.
Have you ever tried to send more than $5k, $10k or $20k before? You basically can't with your bank without having to go through a bunch of hurdles or time delays. I can easily do that with bitcoin.
Legit, real need for it that can't be satisfied with alternatives.
In addition the bank is often closed on weekends, and doesn't service you into the night. My bank site "shuts down" at night. Sorry, but my ability to use my money isn't limiting by your waking hours.
That is, of course, the flip side of that convenience: if you ever make a mistake with your Bitcoin wallet, it's gone with no recourse. Good luck!
I also dont know what bank you have but I can operate it any day through my app.
And your ability to use your "money" is still limited to having access to some wallet application, internet connection, your keys and chain fees.
Yup, I pay 0 to wire money, but I have fees for blockchains.
After that it was a matter of uploading the form and getting confirmation in a couple days, which I'm gladly willing to accept for peace of mind when it comes to large transfers.
> In addition the bank is often closed on weekends, and doesn't service you into the night. My bank site "shuts down" at night. Sorry, but my ability to use my money isn't limiting by your waking hours.
Odd, banking apps are open 24/7 here and if it's an in-bank transfer it's instantaneous.
Pay a third party like Venmo, Square, etc a fee, or use my banks (also horribly designed and bad UX system) to send the money slower than watching paint dry. I'd rather pay the Bitcoin Miners that fee than a third party or even by bank.
Don't forget giving them cash or a check, or a credit card, as billions of people do every day. Fees are a fair point but that's purely a cost and timeliness question: Bitcoin historically has been slower and more expensive but it certainly could be useful as a competitor to horrible companies like Paypal if it can keep the costs down and transaction times low, not to mention scaling the system by 7+ orders of magnitude.
The catch, of course, is that this is not the path to world domination which features prominently in the sales pitch. That caps the maximum value at the percentage Visa, Paypal, etc. charge and if Bitcoin ever matured into serious competition, the credit card companies have plenty of margin to cut.
All of us who've been around enough know what FUD campaigns look like on well-managed Internet forums. I am middle-aged and find this worthy of countering as it appears obsessive. Younger technologists are constantly having their efforts defamed needlessly on this leading technology forum with nothing being added to the conversation.
Speaking of nothing being added to the conversation, it’s somewhat conspicuous that you are attacking the source rather than engaging with the argument. His criticisms are valid and shared by many technologists of all ages and skill levels, surely you can explain why they’re mistaken — for example, you could point to extensive use of Bitcoin in a legitimate non-speculative economy. You’ve been promoting it for many years, surely you must have examples?
Tracking the making of negative generalized statements using FUD techniques is something I have been involved in algorithmically tracking professionally and am countering not in the pursuit of karma or sycophantic agreement but simple public commons maintenance. (The data was often used to identify FUD campaigns of short sellers in finance forums and resulting sentiment analysis feeds are available via subscription through financial data providers.) These comments never mention the continual reigning supremacy of the US dollar for crime, ever, and never provide any evidence that bitcoin has a higher crime usage ratio than the dollar with less prosecutability. This is because law enforcement generally haven't advanced that position while enforcing and in earlier posts I've explained my extensive experience in detail as to how and why they haven't. There has been no direct engagement with this factual information.
In my view some on this forum are intent on spreading classical FUD on the subject and countering FUD is an occupation for some. After a decade of particularly questionable behavior coming from the technology sector involving unfathomable amounts of US dollars, we run the risk of portraying an image of incumbent ideological corruption instead of supporting meaningful technological discussion. This slide has been happening for years IMO and it saddens me. Younger technologists have considerably less opportunity than we did, not more, and the frontier is much smaller. Ruthless negativism doesn't serve them.
I saw you make that claim but that's too vague to evaluate whereas what Nagle described has been well covered for many years and even the Bitcoin salespeople rarely argue that it's commonplace. Even with the extra two paragraphs you added later there's no way to know what this meant, what fraction of the total Bitcoin usage it accounted for, etc.
> These comments never mention the continual reigning supremacy of the US dollar for crime, ever, and never provide any evidence that bitcoin has a higher crime usage ratio than the dollar with less prosecutability.
This is incorrect, and the need for the counterfactual narrative is telling: this comes up frequently and it's usually mentioned in the context of the larger economy. Nobody says that the U.S. dollar isn't used by criminals but it's trivially easy to show enormous amounts of real, non-criminal economic activity — nobody thinks, say, drug cartels are tiny but there's no serious argument that they're anywhere near a majority of the legal economy. If you want to address this claim, try highlighting examples of real economic activity using Bitcoin — real businesses which are not selling Bitcoin. If USD (or just Visa/Mastercard, Paypal, etc.) activity suddenly halted, a ton of people would be unable to engage in their daily business — can you provide any examples of similar Bitcoin dependencies?
> Younger technologists have considerably less opportunity than we did, not more, and the frontier is much smaller. Ruthless negativism doesn't serve them.
I agree that the landscape isn't as good as it used to be but I don't think it's helpful to steer people into false hopes, either. Bitcoin has an inherent conflict of interest built-in since all of the people who've poured money into it for the last decade will have to write that off if they can't find buyers. That lack of utility is the real problem and calling it FUD won't solve it.
As you may imagine, it's impossible for me to provide the 1,000 page+ documentation trail of an in-progress federal investigation here in order to refute a comment. I understand that my sincerity may be questioned and there's nothing I can do about that.
In fact, the sheer number of predatory scams being performed using crypto would surely outweigh the alleged single incident in which Bitcoin had a positive influence?
Your inability to meet any other requests for evidence (businesses that legitimately use and depend on btc) is downright damning.
I hold btc, but every booster simply fails to demonstrate any actual utility for Bitcoin beyond being a speculative vehicle.
I'm specifically refusing the demand that it's my responsibility to provide evidence of commercial btc usage in order to highlight FUD tactics. The alleged story I mention is likely to receive media exposure in Q3 2022, and it's largely but not completely up to the target.
In your opinion the anecdotal story of aiding in the stopping of a predatory crime is not compelling and does not demonstrate meaningful utility. If you think every human agrees with you that is not compelling, I believe that is an extraordinary statement on your part.
The common hostile attitude here on the subject is what's being captured and addressed, and my response to it is what I'm specifically capturing in my comment history for posterity. It has utility.
Do you see the irony here?
I can tell you that I helped stop a predatory crime that was being committed using US dollars this year, partially by using digital assets defensively. Defamatory general statements about the target and digital assets had been made in the past in this case, and it backfired on the perpetrators- horribly, in the federal jurisdiction.
Could you take a moment to consider why unqualified generalizations like yours could concern some? In the past, the perpetrators had attempted to capitalize on the perception you are asserting as reality. The possibility of resultant ankle bracelets or worse for them is high, due generally to record keeping and time stamps.
The reality of this technology is that it solved the technical problems associated with Internet native asset classes. The rest is editorializing.
Perhaps... or maybe the reputation for crime that some people are intent on projecting onto bitcoin is not particularly accurate to the realities of currencies used most frequently in the commission of criminal activity.
The gold supply is inflating at about the same rate as bitcoin right now, but has enough incoming cash flows to keep the priced propped up enough to maintain a $10 trillion market cap. Obviously some of that incoming cash flow is for actually generative industrial use cases, but it's a minority, https://www.statista.com/statistics/299609/gold-demand-by-in.... The lion's share of incoming money flow is for jewelry, long term savings/investment, and central bank holdings, and you could argue that most of the jewelry use case only exists because it's a good store of value, since we can easily make jewelry that looks as pretty for much cheaper than the real thing.
So, since most of the cashflows into gold are just people holding long term with the expectation that there will still be people wanting to buy it for investment purposes in the future, and this scheme has worked incredibly well for 5000 years, why couldn't the same be true of bitcoin?
Bitcoin won't necessarily have the same problem, because it's an information protocol. Protocols can be updated and improved. Even if the main chain ossifies and can't be improved, bitcoin tokens are already being moved to alternative blockchains (sidechains) via 2 way pegs.
However, is there any reason the network couldn't decide to, say, subdivide Satoshis even further to allow the remaining supply to become more tradeable? If the changes are slow enough over time it doesn't seem like there's a limit to how far that could go.
So, my question is, is fiat currency cashflow positive? How?
The problem with Bitcoin is that if it goes up in value the additional time spent mining is ultimately a waste of time.
Bitcoin has intrinsic value outside of the fiat system. It can be used entirely independent of fiat. Whether that will become common is another matter, but the value of Bitcoin does not have to depend solely on it's value relative to USD.
The beauty of the design lies in the balance of the incentives -- if electricity is too expensive, then sure miners will drop out, which lowers the hashrate and thus the security of the ecosystem, but remember that if electricity is expensive for honest miners than it will also be expensive for attackers. And if somehow there is an asymmetry where attackers have access to cheaper electricity than other honest miners, well it's likely in their economic interest to simply become miners themselves rather than attackers...
Bitcoin can easily exist at a minimal survival level that is effectively outside the fiat system for all practical intents and purposes, by leeching off free or near-zero cost electricity (I mean, nobody cares about the electricity bill for "folding@home"). In that kind of mode, it may not have industrial scale and you might not want to transact trillions of fiat-dollars worth of value through it, but it can easily exist.
There are however miners using nearly free sources of electricity such as flared gas wells, solar, etc... If Tesla accepts Bitcoin/Doge for solar panels then you may have a system independent of fiat.
I'm just saying it's possible, not that I think it will necessarily happen. Like I mentioned I think BTC's value relative to USD will increase over time due to fiat's inflationary nature (Fed is targeting 2-3% inflation).
This is true, but then you have a bunch of costly mining ASICs sitting idle. The bitcoin network does not pay miners out of the goodness of its heart but because it needs a very high hash rate to defend against double spend attacks. Guess what those unused ASICs might be very effective at? A prolonged fall in mining power caused by a falling BTC price is a death sentence for bitcoin as it would lead to massive attacks by opportunists renting hashing power to double spend their coins. You can already see this in many smaller coins.
> nearly free sources of electricity such as flared gas wells, solar, etc
Those may be cheaper than regular power, but they are not free. Taking solar as an example, you need to invest capital to buy the solar panels and they have a finite lifespan. Cost divided by lifespan gives you the running cost in $/year. Similar things are true for flared gas wells; you still need to capture the energy somehow and generators are not free.
> If Tesla accepts Bitcoin/Doge for solar panels then you may have a system independent of fiat.
This just moves the problem by one degree of separation. Unless Tesla can buy solar panels for bitcoin, they will need to sell crypto for fiat to buy their inputs. This goes all the way down the supply chain down to the real-world miners who dig up the ores for the solar panels and even they will need to pay their taxes, which you cannot do in bitcoin.
> I think BTC's value relative to USD will increase over time due to fiat's inflationary nature (Fed is targeting 2-3% inflation).
Perhaps. I suppose that this will depend on how much the maintenance costs in electricity and miner ASIC replacement costs as a percentage of total bitcoin market cap per year. If these costs are higher than 2-3% per year, bitcoin will see a net outflow of fiat as running costs and can only rise in price if new users continuously flow in (and of course, only ~7 billion potential users exist).
Also, it might be interesting to read up on why central banks universally target a low but nonzero inflation. There is a ton of established theory about why this is desirable and none of it is based on "let's screw taxpayers". Throwing that away will basically guarantee that crypto will never be very useful to pay your bills with.
In the 2018 bear market, BTC lost 82% of its market value peak-to-trough. Double spend attacks by dark ASICs didn't become a factor then. So most likely you'd have to see BTC fall by 95% or more before this became a threat.
Unless more countries follow El Salvador's example, and accept cryptocurrencies as legal tender. If El Salvador hadn't banned metals mining in 2017, you could the guys digging up ores with BTC today.
The same holds for, say, transactions in US dollars. Here, you also pay your bank or your credit card company.
I'm not saying this is a bad thing by any means, in some ways it is a good thing. Just stating that it exists.
Not really, because even though the number of Bitcoins is limited, the number of cryptocurrencies is not. In any application that uses Bitcoin, you can substitute Litecoin, Dogecoin, or most other altcoins/shitcoins in existence, and there would be zero difference.
In fact, Bitcoin's only advantage over those coins is extrinsic--it has more longevity, better brand recognition, and a lot of large players interested in making it seem (relatively) legitimate.
Contrast this to when people talk about gold having an intrinsic value, as you can't just replace gold with silver or copper when e.g. manufacturing electronics.
There will only ever be a single dominant SHA-2 PoW cryptocurrency, because mining power can be expended on only a single chain. Doesn’t matter how many new genesis blocks are minted, this is a natural monopoly and Bitcoin clearly is the monopolist.
So for all intents and purposes, Bitcoin is an unstable investment product.
Ultimately you are depending on another human who is actually doing work. This is why the credit theory of money is so appealing.
Money has value indirectly because someone obligated himself to give you value equal to the money created. When you add up debts and credits then you end up with nothing because money is just an agreement and not a commodity.
But more to the point, when I said "intrinsic value" I meant value relative to goods/services. Where as when I used "extrinsic value" I meant relative to other "money" such as fiat. Maybe it was a poor choice of words.
Pretty sure a sizable portion of Bitcoin holders understand and know that. They don't hold Bitcoin as a form of bespoke investment to be exchanged for money at some point in the future. They hold it because they believe it is sound and incorruptible money.
And as long as they (not any additional people!) continue to believe that, it will hold value.
It is to be seen if they are right or wrong, but they know how cash flow works.
A cryptocurrency without users putting in "new" money will slowly bleed out through electricity costs. This will become even more "fun" in the future as all coins will eventually be mined and the ginormous electricity bill will need to be paid through transaction fees alone. This is one of the main reasons Proof-of-Stake is getting so much research btw, since it should use way less electricity.
(The above is true for most currencies btw, even dollars and euros bleed out money because they have to pay mints and central bankers. The difference with those is that there will always be demand for (say) dollars because US citizens MUST pay their taxes in dollars. If they don't, a number of measures up to and including prison can be taken against them. Bitcoin has no such backstop since nobody ever NEEDS a bitcoin to pay off someone. Ransomware is a rare exception)
Countries are very protective of their cash flows.
The price of gold or land or BTC can go UP or Down, but that depends on market demand of that asset. The nice thing about owning the farm is that even if the value of land goes down you can still sell your vegetables or eat them to stay alive.
Why imagine? Both of these things can be purchased in the real world. And yet we see that some people purchase farmland, and others purchase bars of gold. Why is that?
Turns out, people called economists have been pondering such questions for hundreds of years and have developed quite sophisticated and nuanced theories about how humans create, assign, and transact value.
Anyways, thanks for the lesson on “cashflow” but you might want to pick up an economics textbook, you might learn something.
https://www.economist.com/economic-and-financial-indicators/...
Crypto technologies are interesting to me because of their great potential for good (defi) and bad (dystopian black mirror gold farms, dyson sphere fueling crpto mine, etc).
The value provided by a database such as BTC is that it provides a record of 'who owns what at what point of time in history'. I can argue separately about why the 'immutability' of this database itself is a value created by Bitcoin, for which holders can be willing to pay premium for.
Miners earn profit if Operating Costs > $ value of (Transaction Fees + BTC mined). Over a long enough timeline, Fees + BTC mined will ~~ operating costs of the rig. If not, more miners will continue to see economic opportunity, and keep joining the miner pool till that equation is balanced.
The other source of BTC value going up need not be more demand for it, let's say over next 12 months. The ~6% inflation could show up there too.
What am I missing?
We can estimate 300k transactions per day, which implies about $150 revenue per transaction. Miner revenue is your cost: it is what they extract from the Bitcoin system.
One Bitcoin transaction costs on the order of $150. It's really expensive.
Citation needed.
(I don’t see why this should be true at all. If anything I’d intuitively think the opposite: If gold were $1MM/oz I don’t think people would be using it to buy groceries… Unless you’re directly talking about hyperinflation where $1MM isn’t worth a loaf of bread any more.)
This is incoherent. It's hard to refute this because it's not even on the right page.
Demand for Bitcoin comes from demand for money (to transact, to store wealth, etc.).
It sounds like you're trying to model it using some idea of how equity pricing works - is that accurate?
It doesn't matter if the fed prints money or not BTC needs a constant infusion of new investment to keep the price up. Unlike a company with positive cash flow who could buyback shares and never get any new investors and still keep the price up.
Indeed. What may be missing from your model is that demand for BTC comes not just from people buying it, but from people holding it.
> BTC needs a constant infusion of new investment to keep the price up.
No it doesn't. Why do you say this? Where the market clears has essentially nothing to do with "new investment".
How do you think BTC miners pay for the graphics cards and electricity? NVIDIA doesn't take BTC as a form of payment. So money is constantly leaving the BTC network to pay for electricity and graphics cards. The only way that happens is if money is also coming into the BTC network
Miners need to sell BTC to cover their operating costs, so there's constant sell pressure. To maintain the same price, you need equivalent buy pressure. Hence the need for "a constant infusion of new investment".
Because it turns out every crypto market is a negative-sum game. If you invest, you are guaranteed to lose on average. If you do happen to win, your gains are coming out of the pocket of someone else who lost even more.
The price of the token in question doesn't enter into this at all. It can rise, fall, anything. It is still a negative-sum game, but some people have not yet realised that they lost.
And some people have not lost at all. As a lifelong poker player, the calculus is very much the same. A poker game where rake is taken out is a negative-sum game. But that doesn't mean that every player loses, even if they play forever. There will be more net losses than net wins, but these are not evenly distributed.
There's a reason we regulate or ban that.
In reality, you're going to lose money.
[Citation needed]
You can't just hand wave and assume this to be true. If the world's major investors decide that crypto represents a store of value, then that's a positive-sum game for crypto. If stablecoins transacted on smart contract chains generate demand for Ethereum to pay for the network transaction fees, then that's a positive-sum game for crypto. If new enterprises start raising capital through DeFi and DAOs instead of traditional capital markets, that's a positive-sum game.
It is a negative-sum game, no matter how hard you wished it were not.
The news business was destroyed in the process, just as the retail and once the establishment lost its ground the money began poring in. From 90's up to late 2000's the internet was amazing as everything was paid by people who were about to reap their investment back a decade later.
My point is, following the money is tricky. Maybe we are at the verge of another change where the costs are payed by crypto bros who will be splitting countries and starting wars once they are done growing the landscape.
I don’t think this is very mysterious. It’s coming from investors who are spending money in the expectation of future profits as the business scales and reaches greater efficiencies and increases monetization.
In the case of this cryptocurrency there’s no obvious point where these tokens suddenly become useful. People only buy them because somebody else will be willing to buy them later (which, of course, relies on ever-increasing amounts of money entering the system). With a stock you are at least theoretically anchored to real world value, since you can buy out a company with stocks and then liquidate the company’s assets.
The stocks are more opaque in that regard, they are required to publish some declaration and financial disclosure but explaining why you need to invest in that company stock often comes down to CEO's appearing in the press. Countless internet ventures died in the process.
The thing I like about Dogecoin is that it's at least honest: it's not selling itself as anything more than a token with a price that will go up if more people buy it.
But they were visibly creating value. Seeing what my friends are up to and organising parties together is pleasant. Being able to find what you want on the internet in 1 second rather than 30 minutes is an obvious improvement to your life. So even if they weren't profitable in the short term, you could see that there was legitimate money to be made.
This single fact destroys most arguments about almost anything, but especially in economics
In the case of BTC, it's pretty clear that a huge portion of the market cap didn't come from anywhere. It's new capital. That doesn't mean it can't go to 0 and vanish overnight. But it does mean that play to earn games don't always need money coming in to pay out.
The BTC system does not create money - you can follow the creation of a coin system to its eventual destruction and discover that exactly the same amount of fiat went into it as came out (less mining). In fact, at any moment in time, the same also holds! If you buy $100 of BTC, somebody somewhere has just sold $100 BTC. No money is ever created or destroyed. Of course (if you were a lunatic), you could get a loan to buy BTC, and so money would be created, but by the banking system, not BTC, and it would go straight to whoever you bought BTC from.
As soon as people decide they don't want to put money in, then no money can come out. You will know this because the 'price' of BTC will be zero.
It comes up whenever I make a point similar to yours above, and I haven’t had a good answer for it
Of course speculation muddies the waters, but you can see how important annual accounts etc are - to ensure the business really has the value it is being ascribed.
Unfortunately the other side has a good response to this - if the dollar value of buybacks+dividends exceeds the dollar value of IPO's, then you end up with the same problem that Bitcoin is in, where it's a net loss system. That seems to be the case[0]. This is not a well known fact.
Ultimately this comes down to the fact that we don't have a stable velocity of dollars, and an unstable velocity that results in more dollars chasing less more goods produces speculative bubbles that must eventually crash and create recessions.
All investments, including all currency, whether it be stocks or gold or bitcoin or dollars, is inherently valueless. The only time you can calculate the value is when you actually are extracting utility. You can then work back from that to determine who produced that value.
[0, Figure 5/Figure 8]: https://www.yardeni.com/pub/buybackdiv.pdf
And do be so quick, there's always another issue to simplify! Can we get base 12? Can we get a carbon tax? A land value tax? Voting reform? I can go on all day here...
Also, lots of people take loans to buy BTC. This is called "leverage".
Since BTC is intrinsically worthless, any 'price' that might be ascribed to it is meaningless (aside from the profit/loss action described above).
Even the supposed utility of BTC - as a money transfer mechanism - does not require the price to be anything other that not zero.
By the way his argument is that any absolute value ascribed to a currency is arbitrary or rather that there is no correct number.
To be exact in this scenario, the 'price' of BTC will still be the price of the last trade in cryto exchanges. The trading volume however, will be 0, and there will no demand on the bid/ask. Hence you're stuck with BTC you can't offload.
Some of the anti-bitcoin crowd tried to make the term "Nakomoto Scheme" a thing, and clearly failed. The basic idea is that things like Axie Infinity have some of the aspects of a ponzi scheme, without the central organization and coordination that makes an actual ponzi scheme illegal. While there isn't a central operator paying out old investors with new investors money, anyone currently invested can only cash out if new people join. This begins to look a bit like a decentralized ponzi, with everyone currently invested in it motivated to evangelize it and convert new people in order to ensure the fresh supply of new buyers to keep the price up and/or let them cash out.
Alternatively, even simpler: where is the money coming from? A bunch of people playing a game are a closed system, and no value is created by playing the game. If the only reason why players are earning money from this game is because more people are continually buying into the game and entering that system, that sounds more like a pyramid scheme than anything.