It comes up whenever I make a point similar to yours above, and I haven’t had a good answer for it
Of course speculation muddies the waters, but you can see how important annual accounts etc are - to ensure the business really has the value it is being ascribed.
Unfortunately the other side has a good response to this - if the dollar value of buybacks+dividends exceeds the dollar value of IPO's, then you end up with the same problem that Bitcoin is in, where it's a net loss system. That seems to be the case[0]. This is not a well known fact.
Ultimately this comes down to the fact that we don't have a stable velocity of dollars, and an unstable velocity that results in more dollars chasing less more goods produces speculative bubbles that must eventually crash and create recessions.
All investments, including all currency, whether it be stocks or gold or bitcoin or dollars, is inherently valueless. The only time you can calculate the value is when you actually are extracting utility. You can then work back from that to determine who produced that value.
[0, Figure 5/Figure 8]: https://www.yardeni.com/pub/buybackdiv.pdf
And do be so quick, there's always another issue to simplify! Can we get base 12? Can we get a carbon tax? A land value tax? Voting reform? I can go on all day here...
Also, lots of people take loans to buy BTC. This is called "leverage".
Since BTC is intrinsically worthless, any 'price' that might be ascribed to it is meaningless (aside from the profit/loss action described above).
Even the supposed utility of BTC - as a money transfer mechanism - does not require the price to be anything other that not zero.
By the way his argument is that any absolute value ascribed to a currency is arbitrary or rather that there is no correct number.
To be exact in this scenario, the 'price' of BTC will still be the price of the last trade in cryto exchanges. The trading volume however, will be 0, and there will no demand on the bid/ask. Hence you're stuck with BTC you can't offload.
The BTC system does not create money - you can follow the creation of a coin system to its eventual destruction and discover that exactly the same amount of fiat went into it as came out (less mining). In fact, at any moment in time, the same also holds! If you buy $100 of BTC, somebody somewhere has just sold $100 BTC. No money is ever created or destroyed. Of course (if you were a lunatic), you could get a loan to buy BTC, and so money would be created, but by the banking system, not BTC, and it would go straight to whoever you bought BTC from.
As soon as people decide they don't want to put money in, then no money can come out. You will know this because the 'price' of BTC will be zero.