It’s part of a broader change in the way the SEC approaches insider trading. Previously they took an “issuer based” approach where a big pop or loss in $ABC triggered a look at all the trades in the right direction prior to the announcement. Now they take a “trader based” approach where they look at person’s pattern of activity over time.
So if your spouse or sibling works in M&A and tips you off to potential deals so you can make (relatively) small investments on the inside information the scheme will be flagged and investigated much more quickly.
However, I'm not sure they do have that information. I would speculate that the number of people who make large option bets before earnings correctly on the same stock over multiple quarters should be zero and if it is very small, it is worth investigating. If they see that a subset of traders is 3 people with Korean names, that would immediately suggest that something is wrong...
But honestly, it’s much more likely that it was simply the timing of the trades and the earnings reports multiple times over a couple years raised some eyebrows.
And then it's a matter of connecting the dots - most often the dots between the "lucky" guy and someone within the company.
Done.
If you consistently make directionally-correct trades (no matter how big) on one particular symbol (or derivatives of it) within +/- n days of earnings, that probably raises your risk score. Probably even more if your trades are always the same day of week before earnings or same number of days before earnings.
I’d be surprised if the SEC wasn’t proactively monitoring this sort of thing on some level.
...which includes lying to you and telling you that the other parties have already confessed, and that you'll be the one holding the bag in jail if you don't confess as well.
A few hours of this, and unless you have the foresight and tenacity to demand a lawyer, most people break. Only one of them needed to break in this case.
It can actually be harder to make money off of insider information than it sounds. The market doesn't always react in the precise way you might expect. As a result, inside traders usually make large sums of money one of two ways:
1) With single, huge bets placed on huge news that shocks the stock price.
2) With many, medium bets placed around regular earnings reports.
In the first case: If someone never trades options and then suddenly places a single, large, highly-leveraged trade that happens to pay out handsomely, that's an easy red flag to spot.
In the second case: If someone is pattern trading in the right general direction around most earnings releases and they happen to work for the company (can be as simple as a public LinkedIn search) then it's obviously a red flag.
The encrypted messaging app is a red herring. The SEC isn't eavesdropping on their comms. They're getting one or more of the conspirators to flip on the others in exchange for reduced sentences. One of them gladly gave up the messages as part of a bargain.
That's possible but they also could have just seized one of their phones or whatever and recovered the chat history that way.
The SEC could put them in a perfect "prisoner's dilemma" game and we're only talking about regular people, not hardened operators with like, a suicide capsule in their molar.
It seems wrong that my personal info is being given out by my brokerage, in a way that lets them identify my personal trades.
insiders are required to report their trades (search for "sec Edgar").
it is hard to make money knowing that a trade has taken place.. you need to know BEFORE and this is clearly illegal with very serious penalties (martha stewart served jail time...).
you send your order to your broker/dealer, they send it to their OMS, which sends it to Citadel, who sends it to their internalisation engine..
All of these messages, including order Identifiers to create the linkages are sent to FINRA.
So your broker sends order "123ABC" to Citadel, FINRA gets this and can trace your order back up and down the "stack" however they want.
As an example, according to the NYSE FIX Spec, this is 54 (Side) = 8 (Cross).
This is how they are able to "internalise", by crossing retail flow vs their house account.
CATNMS https://www.catnmsplan.com/ helps with this.
Also, the trades were done prior to CAT. I suspect it’s from Blue Sheets.
If you combine crosses with OATS you can still get some of the data you are looking for, just not as cleanly as with CAT.
Broker/dealers send order data to the regulators daily.
It isnt 'wrong', you agreed to this when you opened your account,and the broker/dealers are REQUIRED to provide this as it is a "market rule".
EDIT : replace "trade" with "order"...
Unlikely.
More likely is that the brokerages and/or exchanges submit transactional order-book trade data to the SEC (i.e. anonymous numbers .... timestamps, quantity traded, direction).
If the SEC then spot something, its just a case of picking up the phone to the brokerage and asking to ID the client for the transaction at a given timestamp.
Most exchanges require the client details to be sent to them (encrypted) so the regulators can see who is behind the orders on a real-time basis.
Canada for example is behind the times here, but has a program to address this : https://www.iiroc.ca/members/client-identifiers
If you are a corporation, you are required to provide your "Legal Entity Identifier (LEI)"
If you are a retail client, your account number is sent.
It’s just a matter of finding suspicious trades to start an investigation.
That said, the SEC does have access to the full dataset including the person/entity making the trades.
This is why their data analytical skills are so impressive.
Obviously working for the company in question makes it different, but this doesn't seem crazy or unusual.
I've worked placed where it was very easy to predict the stock movements ahead of earnings call since the company's success/failure is in public eye a lot (same true for netflix?).
The top 5 companies in terms of market cap get lots of attention and analysis. I bet most people could review that data before the earnings call and guess the movement of the stock enough to make money.
Again, i would never touch my companies stock on the market but it doesn't seem like you need insider knowledge at a lot of big companies.
Well, as you said, not everything is a win, and sometimes you lose. Some people don't have the money to deal with options and handle a loss.
But who said i wasn't a millionaire ;)
There are entire firms trying to squeak pennies per share out of the market. To think that some backlog of data that most people could plainly interpret would lead to a pop after earnings is very difficult to believe.
People with insider trading knowledge don't seem able to accurately predict the exact price, but they know if its good/bad/great news and how wall street reacts to that .
I'd like to see what someone ends up with investing a more meager amount, like 1k. That's likely what a lot of young adults have in savings they could potentially invest.
If "most people" could do this, "most people" would.
I think the issue is not that most people can't "guess" the outcome, its that they can't afford (in the short term) the money to invest. Many people take years into their career before they can significantly invest and save money. Especially true for people who can afford the risk of options trading, which is more risky than "buy and hold" investing.
The article in question mentions netflix engineers who make large 6 figure salaries. They could probably afford to make well educated bets on many other stocks and profit handsomely after several years.
> Birinyi Associates studied Apple’s post-earnings stock behavior since 2009. It found Apple stock has gapped up, or shot higher 65 percent of the time in after-hours trading, right after its earnings report, with an average pop of 4.7 percent. On the next day, whether it gapped up or down, it has traded lower 65 percent of the time for a 0.92 percent decline.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/01/heres-how-apples-stock-usual...
Practically speaking, this isn't that easy. Most people don't have hundreds lying around to invest, especially not in risky trades.
Also, options (what is being discussed) are often a lot more than $100 - Eg. Opening Robinhood rn shows me AAPL options around 150 whhile GOOGL options are 2k+ while AMZN is 3k+. Even if someone is very confident in a stock movement (and realistically, its obviously not guaranteed), thats a lot of money for the average person, especially when they could lose it. You have to be somewhhat well-off to stomach multi-thousand dollar losses - especially at the start.
(also earnings are 1 per quarter)
The only fine I see listed is for about $72k. I can't tell if the scheme was profitable or not because that was just one person. I assume the others are going to trial, so we won't know for a while.
It is often the manner in which this money is made. Very concentrated bets, like buying far out-of-the-money options, that let you get enormous leverage - buy the option for pennies, exercise for $50. Combined with the absence of activity on other stocks, lack of other regular trading etc.
If you just had a "hunch", bought some shares of Netflix, maybe some other techy stocks for camouflage, and made your "measly" 10% return a few times, you'd probably never be caught. But that's not life-changing of course. To make the $3m over, say, 4 trades, you'd need to have $7.5m to play with, which is quite a lot.
Almost every case of insider trading is because of this pattern.
It makes sense. You have information that you think gives you an edge. Trading "linear" stocks is boring. You need something that will give you an asymmetric payoff to compensate you for the asymmetric info you just stole.
If I were a part of SEC, unless there is some regulatory hurdle, I'd use some other information (e.g., some gov documents? linkedin?), and use that to construct a giant watch list for insider trading even before trades are made.
I'm curious which messaging app they used. I also wonder if someone tipped off the SEC or they just uncovered this in their own analysis work - it doesn't seem like making $3m off Netflix stock trades over a couple of years is particularly alarming on the surface, but idk I'm not an expert... maybe the timing of the buy orders and also looking into what other trades they were making (if any) was easy to spot.