However, I'm not sure they do have that information. I would speculate that the number of people who make large option bets before earnings correctly on the same stock over multiple quarters should be zero and if it is very small, it is worth investigating. If they see that a subset of traders is 3 people with Korean names, that would immediately suggest that something is wrong...
But honestly, it’s much more likely that it was simply the timing of the trades and the earnings reports multiple times over a couple years raised some eyebrows.
And then it's a matter of connecting the dots - most often the dots between the "lucky" guy and someone within the company.
Done.
If you consistently make directionally-correct trades (no matter how big) on one particular symbol (or derivatives of it) within +/- n days of earnings, that probably raises your risk score. Probably even more if your trades are always the same day of week before earnings or same number of days before earnings.
I’d be surprised if the SEC wasn’t proactively monitoring this sort of thing on some level.
...which includes lying to you and telling you that the other parties have already confessed, and that you'll be the one holding the bag in jail if you don't confess as well.
A few hours of this, and unless you have the foresight and tenacity to demand a lawyer, most people break. Only one of them needed to break in this case.
It’s part of a broader change in the way the SEC approaches insider trading. Previously they took an “issuer based” approach where a big pop or loss in $ABC triggered a look at all the trades in the right direction prior to the announcement. Now they take a “trader based” approach where they look at person’s pattern of activity over time.
So if your spouse or sibling works in M&A and tips you off to potential deals so you can make (relatively) small investments on the inside information the scheme will be flagged and investigated much more quickly.