So I’ve been on the verge of doing this for years so this was the final push and motivation.
Yesterday I sold my iPad and Apple Watch. They are being shipped today. I’m just waiting on refunds on my AppleCare for my MacBook and iPhone now and I will sell them.
Yesterday I had a Nokia 215 arrive as a replacement phone. Also a monster pile of PC bits arrived which have been assembled into a Ubuntu running desktop. I am spending today migrating my data over carefully. When the MacBook sells I will buy a Nikon DSLR.
At the end of this I lose perhaps 20% convenience for an immeasurable privacy gain, lose a big chunk of the distractions from my life and end up with some cash left over which I will use to go on holiday.
The only thing I will miss is Apple Music but it’ll give me a chance to curate my music collection without distraction again.
I'm not sure how is that better?
Wouldn't AOSP/Lineage with Signal installed be better?
you get privacy and freedom from the smartphone-service-based-everything-forever lifesytle, it's nice
I sold my DSLR a couple of years after getting my G9x Mark II. The DSLR was always gathering dust compared to the G9x which with a small belt case could easily be taken anywhere.
That said these cameras are definitely not as flexible as a full SLR nor will you get the same performance. Its a large sensor when compared to a camera or other point and shoots but its still nothing compared to APS-C.
At this point I'm going back to owning a seaparate dedicated music device that is totally divorced from the computer. There's just something intentional about walking over to a CD player or record player, picking out an album, and putting it on compared to mindlessly browing Spotify playlists.
If most of your music is on major labels, then bandcamp may not be great for you.
I love it. I think I have around 300 purchases. It’s also great for discovering music. Much better than spotify in that regard.
(I'm unaffiliated, just sharing)
I use a Yamaha receiver (R-N803) that has their MusicCast software on it. And I use these various inputs:
- CD
- Phono
- USB. A little teensy usb loaded with music I’ve collected for the last 25 years - however, I’ve cleaned it up so it’s not filled with random things that makes my wife go “what is all this stuff! I just want to see MY music!”
- I have a Navidrome server running on a pi, with a hardrive connected to it. It basically contains the USB + all the other random stuff. This is played via the bluetooth input and Play:Sub app on my phone.
- Likewise I play the bandcamp app via Bluetooth through the receiver, and spotify as well (I mostly use spotify for listening to the back catalogs of established artists).
- Net Radio. Access thousands of radio stations, worldwide, that stream their service. It’s pretty cool!
There’s more. But, point is the setup is cool and diverse and it’s pretty easy to use.
Pinephone is my hope, too, but do not expect anything stable soon. That will take some time, probably years. It does not happen on its own, though, they need support now to make it a real alternative and not just a tinker toy.
Pinephone: Cheap. The device isn't very powerful. With people coming from an Apple device, that's a problem.
Fairphone 3: Fair. The hardware isn't very powerful either, and the device is more expensive, but the product is better for the people who assembled it and the environment.
Librem 5: Open. Even more expensive than Fairphone, but the hardware features killswitches, and there's no binary blobs. Lacks the fair advantages Fairphone has.
Each of these can run a myriad of FOSS OSes from a deGoogled Android (ASOP-based fork) such as /e/ or Ubuntu or Debian/Arch/Ubuntu mobile versions or SFOS (Sailfish) community version (without Android emulation layer!), and each hardware and software has their pros/cons. I use a Fairphone 3 with stock firmware with a Pinephone as back-up phone (and have to use a Samsung flagship device for work). Previously I used a Fairphone 2 with LineageOS + microG (kind of like predecessor of /e/ before that took off).
PS: On the gaming side, I'm getting a Steam Deck. Its a bang for the buck compared to Aya Neo/Nintendo Switch/gaming smartphones). No, it isn't open hardware, but the device runs Linux and you get root on it, plus all the reviews (including Linus Tech Tips) are positive.
It is nice the the fairphone trys to be nice and fair, but I would rather have a focus of a actual open phone under my control and they do not deliver this (not to blame them, the issue is hard). Fixing the global exploitive economy is a different issue and trying to solve everything at once is not working usually.
"Librem 5"
How useful is a microphone killswitch, if there is no killswitch for the speakers, that can be used as a microphone, too? And it would be news to me, that it is now completely free of binary blobs and their claims always felt a little bit dishonest to me. I recently read a interview by the former CTO that confirms it
https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Zlatan-T...
I would go with the Pinephone. For now I have a stupid samsung phone with facebook app preinstalled and unremovable, but have not yet found the time to try lineage with it.
I know that physically / electronically, a speaker is a microphone, but is there any way for someone to actually record sound through the speakers on the librem? There is a lot more to a microphone than just the diaphragm...
https://www.hackread.com/hackers-steal-data-air-gapped-pcs-m...
Maybe not at all likely (in my case) but when we talk about real security and for some people this is indeed a question of live and death, then I don't want to promote half solutions.
edit: to clarify. , yes a microphone killswitch is probabyl useful in the way that it eliminates most common attack vectors to silently listening to people, but it is potential harmful if people would rely on it for 100% - but do get listened to and send to gulag because the local KGB did in fact took the effort to implement such spyware
A lot of people in our world simply cannot afford a Fairphone. I can, and I applaud the project, so I went for it. I also applaud the other projects, and remember that perfect is the enemy of good. That a Librem 5 isn't going to be perfect in terms of security, is OK. Its their first iteration (and they had various iterations of it, which lead to considerable delays).
There's also some keyboard smartphones such as Planet Cosmo Communicator and Planet Astro Slide. And some other ones as well such as F(x)tec (which is a good successor to Nokia N900). These are also niche, specific, with their hardware keyboard (which include custom layout such as Dvorak). But they can run alternative OSes, by default. I believe that, for me, this (hardware keyboard smartphone) is going to be the ultimate usability dream, if the keys are large enough. I previously owned a Nokia E71 and Nokia N900, before touch typing became the status quo.
> [...] I recently read a interview by the former CTO that confirms it [...]
I also backed Astro Slide (and own a Cosmo Communicator), and am disappointed with their hardware downgrade from Dimensity 1000 to 800. I hate it when promises are not kept. But it happens. As mentioned I owned a Nokia N900 previously, but I wasn't fond of the keyboard, so I hope Astro Slide's going to be better. And, given its like the Cosmo Communicator (which I am used to), I am confident it will be. The big disadvantage of Planet devices is their slow updates, and being reliant on Mediatek (MTK) which means EOL soon.
With regards to hardware keyboard I read Pinephone is planning such as well, which is great news because its otherwise such an affordable smartphone. Pine64 sells a lot of other cool FOSS stuff such as Pinecil and Pine Camera.
It's the only phone running FSF-endorsed OS without binary blobs, PureOS. It's recommended by the FSF [0]. More details here [1].
[0] https://www.fsf.org/givingguide/v11/
[1] https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
Speakers can be wired to do that, but this is not something you can change with software.
I've never used a phone like this, but are you also forced to provide FB credentials during initial setup? If not, then is the FB app just being installed a privacy threat if it is never used? Is it still accessing information on the phone without being tied directly to you?
I would be worried that even without logging into Facebook or giving it my credentials, my FB-ized phone would help FB's efforts in creating and maintaining shadow profiles. As far as I'm concerned, since the FB app is tied into the OS so tightly that it cannot be removed, it poisons the phone and makes it an adversarial surveillance device.
This type of poison, of course, is not limited to Facebook.
These preinstalled apps are still crap though, I'd rather have a smaller system partition and a bigger user data partition, should I own such a phone.
Good to know about deactivating apps on Android, though; thank you! I do not remember if I had that option.
I don't know. I do not have FB. But the fact, that I still have to have the app no matter what I want, illustrates my point, that I really do not own or controll this phone. But it works reliable, was affordable - AND I can remove the batterie.
And I do it regulary, because then I can be sure, it is really turned off.
Otherwise I kind of assume everything I do with it or around it, is potentially recorded.
So yes, I really, really want a phone that I can trust, even if it is turned on.
I do have Xperia X & Xperia 10 II and can confirm Android emulation layern works very well.
You can run Sailfish OS on many other devices thanks to community porting work, but without support for the Jolla provide Android emulation layer. The devices will still run all the many native Sailfish OS apps + ARM compiled flatpaks just fine & the is community work in getting Anbox to run to provide Android emulation on the community ports as well. :)
It's at the top of my if-I-ever-jump-ship-from-Apple list of phones.
Oh wow, that's a very interesting option - I like the way that hinge works, but I fear that a mechanical part that complex in a smartphone is likely to become worn out quickly (source: I had both a Moto RAZR and a T-Mobile Sidekick back in the day and both would barely stay closed by the time I upgraded).
> the Pro 1 X is just a rebrand
This is very interesting to me, would you mind filling me in on what it's a rebrand of?
(1) To Pinephone designers: I would absolutely love a 2cm thick Pinephone if that allowed some more speed and serious battery life. I'm serious about that; my current phone is a Nokia 8110 4G (the new "banana") which is 1.5 cm thick, and although the OS is a joke and I use it only for calls and as 4G access point for my laptop, wrt usability it's the best thing I've bought in years.
This is exactly what the keyboard mod is for. The keyboard has 6000 mHa battery (although it does not make Pinephone run faster).
Are you switching from a laptop to a desktop machine? Do you have no use for the portability anymore?
I have a desktop (not laptop) for my own stuff and a laptop for company stuff and a dock and KVM setup for it.
I am not using the company laptop for personal stuff.
Can Apple force people to install this even on devices they already sold?
https://daringfireball.net/2021/08/apple_child_safety_initia...
Not true. They will be scanning your messages also for inappropriate content - https://www.apple.com/child-safety/
If you're talking to adults, or children whose parents don't want to use the service, you're not getting your photos scanned.
Has Apple thought this through?
Without iMessage/Facetime, a large part of the peer pressure teens get for having an iPhone is gone. Now they might start asking for a Galaxy or something like that.
My sense is Apple is trying to keep CASM off their servers. Scanning phones before it gets there was their solution to what I assume is a government demand/ultimatum. “Do this or we repatriate your foreign entity taxes” or some other shit.
I too feel that Apple just caved and eroded trust that took decades to build up. The only way this gets sorted is the “screeching minority” continues to screech and brings other in. Notify state attorneys general, FTC, etc. will that do anything? Who know? My bet is that it’s the DOJ behind all of this.
Hopefully the plaintiff bar which are already preparing class action lawsuits will find a way to get documents in discovery that allude to government coercion. But then again I’m sure there would be a clever way those are not produced under some “national security” bullbaiting reason.
All we can do is try, and keep the pressure on.
It could (maybe) also be a prelude to enabling E2E encryption for everything in iCloud.
Firstly - CASM scanning is done via fingerprinting - the image is fingerprinted on device and when uploaded to iCloud that fingerprint is compared with the "dodgy images" fingerprints and an alert raised if a threshold of matches is reached (what's the threshold and with whom?)
Secondly - there is on-device AI image recognition - when you send an image to someone else (via iMessage or the share sheet) it is checked for nudity and if the iCloud account in question is registered to a 13-year old or younger, their parents are alerted.
In both cases the fingerprinting/scanning is on-device and is triggered by the images leaving the device.
Nope. The comparison is done on the device and the threshold is set there as well.
I am not sure how alarmed I am yet at this whole affair but I do know that maybe 50% of posts I read about this have glaringly incorrect information which definitely dampers my alarmism.
As I understand it the fingerprinting and comparison is done on device, but it only happens as part of the upload-to-iCloud process. So the grandparent's phrasing isn't unreasonable.
This is obviously not effective given that you can get around it that easily if you want to. Coincidentally though, it will be totally effective at surveilling the 99.999% that are normal users and won’t go out of their way to disable iCloud. The whole CP thing is such an obvious farce.
But what happens the second they get an order from $GOVERNMENT that tells them to use the spyware to also look at other documents on the device?
I think it's pretty obvious what Apple will say. They'll say "OK." They have no plausible deniability to tell $GOVERNMENT to go pound sand - they have demonstrated the capability already! Telling the spyware to scan different files is a trivial change from a technical perspective.
That doesn't make sense. The issue is that Apple is very publicly signaling they are changing their approach to privacy now. Companies change approaches to any number of things all the time, they're not static entities. As such you have to evaluate their nature as a consumer on an ongoing basis, not one time forever. It's true of food, it's true of consumer electronics, it's true of general product or service quality, it's true of privacy issues or censorship, and so on. Apple even knew the consequences ahead of time - per the insider notes - and don't care, they charged ahead regardless.
It would be much harder for them to pull of if the system was open with user actually in control.
And after the case to stop them refusing security updates for those without it installed+enabled, there will need to be another one to force them to allow it to be disabled, then a few circuits around the court of public tattle to make it really disable and not magically re-enable itself at random intervals.
https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-15-preview/features/ (under settings)
heres my photo gallery all shot with the z5
Not having to edit the pictures is a huge plus, and JPG files in Nikon, even with dynamic range on, are pretty mediocre compared to Pixel phone.
It takes longer but the end result looks MUCH better than anything your phone can produce. That said, sometimes I just want to take a selfie and not fiddle too much. Thats when I use my google pixel.
Yes, backdooring E2E encryption in general is a bad idea. However, consider two things:
* iCloud Photos was never E2E encrypted in the first place. They already can scan your photos all they want server-side, and they have been scanning for CSAM since 2019, while Google has been scanning for it since 2009. Yes, if iCloud Photos were to become E2E encrypted leaving in a backdoor like this could be bad, but it's still the lesser of two evils. Would you rather they keep photos non-E2E forever and have even more unfettered access to them than a "backdoor" allows? It does NOT scan photos that are not uploaded to the cloud, despite being on-device. And it's important to note the threshold and manual human review system put in place before the authorities receive any notification at all.
* For iMessage, all this entails is warning children under 18 about explicit content, and optionally notifying parents if the child is under 13 and the parent opted in. (I don't think it even sends the photo itself to the parents, but that's not explicitly clarified anywhere.) At no point do Apple or the authorities learn the contents of E2E encrypted iMessages. (Also worth noting: if you use iCloud Backup, your messages are no longer E2E encrypted in the backup, as Apple holds the keys to that. This was true even before the new system was introduced.)
Yet. Once it's on the device, it's a MUCH smaller step to use it in other ways. It's certainly easier fro governments to argue that they should be able to force it to be used arbitrarily... you know, for the children/terrorists/etc.
> And it's important to note the threshold and manual human review system put in place before the authorities receive any notification at all.
Until it's not. Once again, once it's in place, it's a lot easier for malevolent actors (governments) to force it to be used other ways.
This a back door. Plain and simple. The fact that it's not _currently_ going to be used for evil (depending on your definition of evil) does not mean it won't be in the near future. Back doors are bad. How many times does this need to be said?
We crossed this bridge a long time ago. Apple already has on device Neural Nets processing everyone one of your on device photos. That’s what powers spotlight search and “photo memories”.
Simple fact of the matter is that this isn’t the top of some slippery slope, it’s half way down one. A slope we started down when we figured out how to put powerful Neural Nets on mobile devices in people’s pockets.
> Until it's not. Once again, once it's in place, it's a lot easier for malevolent actors (governments) to force it to be used other ways.
Which is why Apples current solution makes it cryptography impossible to decrypt photos until a large enough number of suspect photos have been uploaded.
Yes, you might laugh and say that won't happen, but on-device scanning is the first step.
In less trustworthy countries it's not that farfetched to imagine what this can be used for.
So Apple must back down now or face the consequences in the form of loss of reputation and eventually loss of sales.
I keep seeing this jump. There's no evidence this will happen. Apple can already technically do anything they want to compromise the security of your device in the next software update, so could Google or Samsung or any other company. But when in Apple's history have they done this? There is zero reason to believe this is the next step other than speculation and fear mongering.
But they're making it easier for governments to come along and force them to do more. Or even for themselves, but I tend to think they're less of an issue.
I know "it's a slippery slope" gets overused... but if you keep taking baby slips down that slope, it only gets slipperier. You should avoid taking as many of those steps as possible.
Because that actually happened, and in a democratic country even.
So it's not hard to imagine what less democratic countries could demand of Apple.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-29/queensland-coronaviru...
It is as easy as always been. Only problem is that this might give them new ideas. As the most of the politics are probably non-tech people, they don’t know what is possible.
For tech person, functionality like this (on-device scanning and flagging) is super trivial to add. Antivirus engines have existed decades.
Yes I'd rather they do this. The fact that they're implementing on device checks doesn't suggest to me that they will be deploying E2E encryption. It suggests to me that they will be expanding on device scanning to all content in the future.
If they were going to make iCloud E2E encrypted, it would be a clear win to announce this at the same time as deploying on device scanning.
Because they’d also need to be announcing that you can no longer reset your iCloud password and recover to a new device. And I’ve not seen anything that suggests this.
So I suspect it is encrypted at rest, with a key known to Apple as before as well as this CSAM approach.
Citing final phrase on the paper to TLDR their system:
> Apple is able to learn the relevant image information only once the account has more than a threshold number of CSAM matches, and even then, only for the matching images.
This applies only for images, so you can still reset your password. Technically, there are two layers of encryption on images. Regular server-side encryption and this "E2EE like" encryption, which allows access for CSAM matches in specific threshold.
[1]: https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...
> As part of setup, the device generates an encryption key for the user account, unknown to Apple.
The question is, how is this generated. Can it be re-derived from information Apple has? If not, how will Apple handle cases where the user loses or breaks their device?
Is it derived from the iCloud password? Currently Apple can reset your iCloud password and restore access to your images. Will Apple no longer be able to do this in the future?
It’s really unclear to me, and I’d want explicit answers to these questions personally.
[1]: https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/Apple_PSI_System_Secu...
But it’s still not clear how that key is derived. It’s not clear, as implemented that Apple do not hold a master key to decrypt all data (as they do currently).
In fact, if the key is randomly generated, if you have one device (as many users do) and you lose that device. Do you lose all your data? Even if you have your iCloud password?
It doesn’t make sense. It would be a massive change to how iCloud currently operates and is used. And I find this extremely unlikely.
Right now, you can browse your photos online. That functionality is going away?
There are seemingly many open questions. But given that there’s no clear statement from Apple, I’m inclined to believe that they retain the ability to decrypt all data.
I don’t think Apple are stupid, it would have been a clear PR win if they said “we’re adding E2EE”.
Given no explicit statement, and how drastically it changes the nature of their service, I don’t think your speculation is justified.
* SafetyNet doesn't work, as expected, which means no Google Pay. Nothing else I use has been impeded, though. * Chromecasting doesn't seem to be implemented in MicroG, so no casting content
Other than that, it's been solid.
but you are forewarned - you can blew through way more then a weekend de-oppressing you digital life.
It turns out that compromises have to be made. And it's also a moving target.
Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Twitter, etc. have all been scanning content for those same child porn images for darn near a decade now.
>The system that scans cloud drives for illegal images was created by Microsoft and Dartmouth College and donated to NCMEC. The organization creates signatures of the worst known images of child pornography, approximately 16,000 files at present. These file signatures are given to service providers who then try to match them to user files in order to prevent further distribution of the images themselves, a Microsoft spokesperson told NBC News. (Microsoft implemented image-matching technology in its own services, such as Bing and SkyDrive.)
"There are two opportunities to look at content," when it's going into a cloud-storage account and when it's leaving, she said. "There is technology to do this," Grant added, pointing out that file signatures — unique hashes or fingerprints — could be used to confirm the nature of the files.
https://www.nbcnews.com/technolog/your-cloud-drive-really-pr...
If it hasn't been a problem that Google has been scanning your cloud data for the last decade, it didn't suddenly become a problem now.
The feature what everyone is afraid of (scan all in my device), is super trivial to add generally. Company like Apple can push it to public in less like week regardless if this Child Safety came first.
This new feature is actually really hard to develop, because they try to create E2EE system with backdoor. And they want to lock themselves out of this backdoor to prevent misuse.
There is no difference.
If this is the case, then It is coming to every device (not just apple) or E2E will be made illegal(or a backdoor).
End-to-end encryption is intended to prevent data being read or secretly modified, other than by the true sender and recipient(s). The messages are encrypted by the sender but the third party does not have a means to decrypt them, and stores them encrypted. The recipients retrieve the encrypted data and decrypt it themselves.
Because no third parties can decipher the data being communicated or stored, for example, companies that provide end-to-end encryption are unable to hand over texts of their customers' messages to the authorities.
Would it even be considered end 2 end encryption based on this Wikipedia definition? I don’t think it meets the definition if apple can determine certain files exist in a conversation.
> It's definitely the last straw for me in terms of apple products.
Uhh and where else will you go where the grass is so much rosier privacy-wise?
It's absolutely ridiculous what apple has become. The exact opposite of what they used to represent, when I loved them. God rest Steve Jobs soul, his 1984 ad is exactly what apple is now. Screwed devs on app store, strongarmed into compliance, cooperation with china, worse and worse UX on phones, and now this...
Really disappointing.