News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by tyingq on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:47PM (#27646721)
There's also a Microsoft provided tool: https://aka.ms/GetPCHealthCheckApp

And the text list of what's compatible:

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/windows-11-specifica...

The two that people are complaining about most are:

- Arbitrary requirement of 8th gen or better for Intel i3/5/7/9[1]. Which seems odd, given that some 2017 era Celerons are on the list.

- TPM 2.0 module

[1] Specific Intel CPUs: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/design/min...

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by tzs on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:59PM (#27647842)
According to Ars [1], it seems that every CPU that is on the supported processor list includes TPM. It's called iPPT on Intel and fTPM an AMD.

Most motherboards ship with it disabled in the BIOS so you have to find that setting (probably somewhere in the "advanced" settings) and change it.

They also warn that some OEM motherboards have it disabled in the BIOS but do not expose a setting to change it, so with those you might be out of luck if the OEM did not include hardware TPM.

[1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/heres-what-youll-nee...

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Krasnol on Sunday June 27, 2021 @05:47AM (#27650083)
I have it turned "on" to something which is called "Discrete TPM" on my AMD but it seems that it's not good enough according to the tool.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by AbacusAvenger on Sunday June 27, 2021 @06:48AM (#27650439)
"Discrete TPM" means you have a daughter board that you plug in to a physical TPM port on the motherboard (check your motherboard manual for where it is, and which kind is compatible). If that device is physically not actually there, then that BIOS option does nothing for you.

You should check and see if the "Firmware TPM"/"fTPM" option is available, because that one will work without the physical add-in card.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Krasnol on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:41PM (#27653510)
Ah got it.

Thank you. Yes indeed there is a Firmware option there.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by mattowen_uk on Sunday June 27, 2021 @03:24AM (#27649398)
> There's also a Microsoft provided tool: https://aka.ms/GetPCHealthCheckApp

Doesn't work on Domain joined machines. It tells me to contact my IT department (which is me!) and doesn't show anything else.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Sebb767 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:48PM (#27647458)
Could it possibly be that they want to compile with support for a specific instruction set extension or depend on spectre/meltdown fixes? Though Wikipedia [0] only lists CNVi [1] as new feature.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coffee_Lake#Features

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CNVi

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by nohr on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:23PM (#27646943)
I believe that app is currently checking the cpu against the list of compatability for OEMs which tends to be more strict though. So there's a chance an older cpu might work that the app says will not.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by morpheuskafka on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:31PM (#27647334)
My guess is that 8th gen was picked since that's when quad core became standard across the product line, but that leaves out the earlier HQ series (such as the i5-7300HQ on my ThinkPad T470p) that are quad core. And of course the Celerons aren't either, so it doesn't make any sense.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by pram on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:39PM (#27647053)
TPM excludes Boot Camp, so no Intel Macs. I guess with the EOL date being 2025 and the ARM migration it probably wont matter by then though!
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by tyingq on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:11PM (#27653269)
If you search around, there's a few implementations of a virtual TPM around. Vmware does it, Parallels also, and there are also some open source ones. I would guess someone might find a way to graft that into Boot Camp.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by williamstein on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:15PM (#27646889)
On my fairly new second gen Surface Go 2, GetPCHealthCheckApp says that my CPU isn't supported, despite it being an m3 that is explicitly on that list you linked to. The tool at github says everything is supported when I run it. I guess we'll just have to wait and see...
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Krasnol on Sunday June 27, 2021 @05:22AM (#27649982)
The Microsoft tool won't tell you why it doesn't work though. Says only: "While this PC doesn't meet the system requirements to run Windows 11, you'll keep getting Windows 10 updates".

The tool told me that it's indeed TPM. I didn't even know what it is and my PC is 2 months old ;)

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by qalmakka on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:23PM (#27646947)
If you can't boot Windows 11 without having secure boot turned on, I guess I'll have to skip this Windows version for the first time in decades. I've always been an early adopter for new Windows versions, but I really can't be bothered with signing my damn Linux kernels just to boot Windows every once in a while.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by blibble on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:34PM (#27647019)
all large distros are using shim which supports secure boot

you can also enroll your own key relatively easily using mokutil

if you're building your own kernels it's one command to sign them (sbsign)

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by ozfive on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:58PM (#27648457)
You could also just run Win 11 in a VM and emulate TPM in software. ;)
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by amluto on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:04PM (#27647561)
Citation needed.

The MS link appears to say that you need UEFI that is Secure Boot capable. That includes most implementations.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Trung0246 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @06:17AM (#27650241)
Is enabling SecureBoot would wipe your C:\ drive? I'm too afraid that I'll have to reinstall and configure everything again.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by amluto on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:42PM (#27665899)
I know relatively little about Windows, but toggling Secure Boot by itself should have no such effect. Secure Boot is a firmware policy that affects what OSes are permitted to boot and a few other boot-time things. It has essentially no relation to your disk.

If you have Bitlocker enabled, all bets are off. Make sure you have a recovery key set up.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by xwolfi on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:56PM (#27648447)
Why wouldnt you want secure boot as well?

I signed linux and it's just fine, debian does it transparently now.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by qalmakka on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:12AM (#27659240)
Because it's a hassle, and I really don't care about that. Given that I'd have to go through the hassle of signing my own kernels just to get Windows to boot once a week, I really don't get why I should do that in the first place.

There's no way Windows _NEEDS_ to be signed to boot. Even macOS doesn't complain that much when booted without Secure Boot. Perhaps someone will find a way to cheat Windows about SecureBoot or TPM by using OpenCore, like the Hackintosh community has been doing for a long time.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Bancakes on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:30AM (#27648862)
Why would you want SB+TPM? It's called TPM 2 because only 2 pieces of software support it. Lol.

I already know where microsoft is going with this - Xbox-like DRM. In a few years they'll probably release pci-e based "security devices" with full DMA privileges, too.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Snetry on Sunday June 27, 2021 @05:08AM (#27649892)
Because doing kernel dev and constantly having to resign modules is more tedious than its worth
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by slipframe on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:41PM (#27646668)
I sure hope this isn't the start of the phone-ification of 'real computers', with the expectation that people buy new hardware every few years lest they get left out in the cold by software vendors.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by tyingq on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:51PM (#27646744)
Seems to be the case. There are laptops manufactured 2-3 years ago using 7th gen Intel, which isn't making the cut. Maybe MS will back off after all the corporate IT people start bitching about their laptops.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by xarope on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:20PM (#27647278)
Corporates are constrained by application dependencies (not OS), and will likely be the last to adopt Win11 (given how long it took to migrate off win7 to win10 the last round).
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by le-mark on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:39PM (#27647400)
I for one still have a win 7 desktop at a big dumb corp (f500). So yeah.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by macintux on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:01PM (#27647546)
At the Fortune 500 company where I contract, Big Sur is finally almost ready to be certified for use.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by d3nj4l on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:37PM (#27647744)
God, I wish they got around to that at my place. Having used it on a personal device, I love Big Sur much more than Catalina.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by sgt on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:12PM (#27646873)
Corporates usually replace hardware every 3-4 years don't they?

We do as well, but since we're using Macs they last so friggin long that some folks are still on 2016 MacBook Pro's. I badly want the new M1 ;)

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by tyingq on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:18PM (#27646910)
>Corporates usually replace hardware every 3-4 years don't they?

Yes and no. 3-4 years from when the person got it maybe, which is usually not the manufacture date. And, it's one of those budget items that tends to get pushed out when there's a financial crisis, like now for many Covid affected businesses. I work for a F500, and my laptop was made in 2018, and is a 6th gen Intel.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by slipframe on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:50PM (#27647115)
> Corporates usually replace hardware every 3-4 years don't they?

At the companies I've worked for the programmers generally get new hardware about as often ...but other workers not so much. They are more likely to get the hand-me-down hardware.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by xwolfi on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:59PM (#27648465)
Wow what a good corporation. We rolled windows 10 last month, hardware changes are very rare, maybe every 10 years. Usually done on a rolling when needed basis.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by bombcar on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:15PM (#27646893)
Laptops might be cycled that often but ah guarantee you many other machines are much MUCH older.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by jakebasile on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:51PM (#27647476)
The next version of iOS supports older hardware than the next version of Windows, from what I can tell.

My 3 year old top of the line gaming PC won't get Windows 11. It's annoying.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by fartcannon on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:55AM (#27648965)
Hey! Use Linux. Get off the stupid windows train.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Schnitz on Sunday June 27, 2021 @04:24AM (#27649674)
On a gaming PC?
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by armchairhacker on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:07PM (#27647202)
Is there an actual reason why windows 11 isn't supported on older hardware?

I've read the announcements, but from what I've seen Windows 11 is basically Windows 10 with new UI. And a few small details like widgets and "built-in" Microsoft Teams.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by easton on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:46PM (#27647783)
My ~~conspiracy theory~~ guess is that the Windows 10 minimum requirements were "If it ran Windows 7 you're good", which means that this upgrade saying "If it ran Windows 10 you're good" would entail supporting machines built in 2009 or earlier. Which is pretty old, so they decided to draw lines that would get rid of machines that old (for example, no more 32 bit). Then they kept going because someone said "legacy BIOS is dumb, UEFI is the choice of a new generation" and then another manager said "nobody uses disk encryption on home edition, let's mandate TPMs so they can do it easier", and sooner or later you have these probably higher than actual system requirements.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by judge2020 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:05PM (#27647868)
The engineering/testing cruft that goes along with testing super old hardware probably also hurts how quick they can iterate and how much they have to spend to validate changes on multiple hardware configurations.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by II2II on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:07AM (#27648501)
Possibly, but I was under the impression that the free upgrade to Windows 10 (and the inexpensive upgrade for Windows 8) was to entice people to move to the new operating system in order to reduce support costs. By making a hardware upgrade a prerequisite of an operating system upgrade for a larger number of people will just encourage people to stick to Windows 10. That's especially true for desktop computers, where a moderately old machine will outperform many modern laptops.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by rejectedandsad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:18PM (#27647933)
But...supporting that is literally the appeal of Windows?
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by cdash on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:59PM (#27648136)
Is it? I thought the appeal of Windows is supporting old software with new versions of Windows.

Getting new hardware is easy, getting new software isn't.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by rejectedandsad on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:59PM (#27654216)
That’s fair, but having long hardware support periods has been a consistent goal since at least XP, which supported machines with 64mb of RAM. Machines that could run vista well can still run W10 fine!
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by shadilay on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:55AM (#27652055)
I somewhat doubt that given that most of the work for specific hardware is done by the OEM.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Sebb767 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:43PM (#27647425)
I'm assuming they simply start with a very restrictive list, as it's easier to say "it's supported anyway" later than to explain to people that their PC is incompatible despite their tool having told them otherwise before. Other reason might be newer CPU instructions and that they can't guarantee a good experience on older hardware. This is just my speculation, though.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by void_mint on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:08PM (#27647213)
Money
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by gentleman11 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:34PM (#27647363)
Is there a way to avoid ever getting windows 11, or will it be a forced sneaky upgrade like last time?
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by jmkni on Sunday June 27, 2021 @01:55AM (#27648967)
Turn TPM off and you'll avoid any sneaky upgrades!
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by anothernewdude on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:52PM (#27647817)
How was the last one forced? My game machine is still on 7
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by xeromal on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:57AM (#27648727)
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by MrStonedOne on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:23AM (#27649105)
if you had recommended updates enabled it would give you a pop up to schedule a upgrade to windows 10 with a recommended date and time preselected, and if you hit X in the popup to dismiss it, it would just use that recommended date and time.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by mattowen_uk on Sunday June 27, 2021 @03:26AM (#27649406)
MS are currently saying that Windows 11 will be an optional upgrade until support on Windows 10 runs out.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by IshKebab on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:11AM (#27651299)
Which is October 2025 apparently. Hopefully they'll be forced to extend it like they did with older Windows.

I built my current PC in 2012 and it still works perfectly well - no slowdown at all thanks to SSDs and the end of Moore's law. I can't imagine I'll want to upgrade it within the next 4 years.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by MrStonedOne on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:24AM (#27649110)
use piracy tools to crack your windows 10.

worked on windows 7 to windows 10 for me.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by amanzi on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:37PM (#27648029)
My custom-built PC was flagged as not being compatible due to not having TPM 2.0 module. I have an Asus Prime B450M-A motherboard and a Ryzen 7 2700 processor and was surprised that it wasn't compatible.

But it turned out there was an easy fix. Recent AMD processors have a TPM module built into the processor, and it was just a case of heading into the BIOS and turning it on. Now the PC is compatible with Windows 11.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by LAC-Tech on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:03PM (#27646816)
I'm out of the loop here - I thought windows 10 would be the last version of windows released, and it would just have rolling updates for the foreseeable future?

What changed?

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by bombcar on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:14PM (#27646888)
Apple took MacOS to 11.

Seriously that’s probably more than half the reason.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by morpheuskafka on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:33PM (#27647352)
But macOS 12 will release just before Windows 11 does (shortly after fall iPhone announcement vs. holiday season), since Apple has abandoned the use of yearly point releases for good. So that wouldn't work out very well for MS.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Sebb767 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:40PM (#27647411)
But why would Microsoft care about that? Having the bigger OS number is really unimportant, else ChromeOS would dominate at version 90. Also, if that was really the case, they should've made the jump earlier and/or directly go to 12.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by byecomputer on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:11AM (#27648515)
Marketing. People got downright hyphy about Big Sur and the M1 chip, and Microsoft, by comparison, has had virtually zero excitement points in the past decade. Having a new product renews interest in the brand. I haven't run Windows in years, but you bet your ass that when I saw 'Windows 11' I was like, whoa, what's this all about? Turns out it's a pretty tame, incremental update with a major version number slapped on, but I still clicked to find out what was up. That's worth something.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by pansa2 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:35PM (#27648343)
> Having the bigger OS number is really unimportant

I can tell that you don’t work in marketing.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by bombcar on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:14AM (#27649053)
90 is super far out - obviously out of scope. But when numbers are close they get compared.

(I personally think we may see MacOS numbers start to move about as fast as iPhone numbers)

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by jlokier on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:40PM (#27648044)
Firefox is at about version 90 too.

Perhaps Windows and MacOS track version numbers the same way as Firefox and Chrome.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by zamalek on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:24PM (#27646954)
That's absolutely my suspicion, too. Just look at all this hype. The smaller part of the reason is breaking compatibility with some hardware.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by Frenchgeek on Sunday June 27, 2021 @03:59AM (#27649542)
They wanted to look like a dynamic and innovative company so they released a new theme and gave it a brand new version number? That or windows 10 still leave too much control of the machine to the user in their eyes... I think I'll watch that particular disaster from a safe distance.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by IshKebab on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:13AM (#27651316)
Must be partly due to the drastically changed minimum requirements. Would have been awkward to say Window 10.8364837 and earlier need this, but Windows 10.837492 and later need this. Support for Windows 10.8364837 will end in 2025.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by anothernewdude on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:54PM (#27647824)
They learnt how bad rolling updates are.

I used to use Arch until a libpng upgrade broke everything.

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by ninepoints on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:13PM (#27646878)
Their minds :)
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by ShaneMcGowan on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:47PM (#27647788)
They simply didn't forsee this far into the future
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by blendergeek on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:05PM (#27647870)
Does the UEFI/Secure Boot/TPM requirement mean that I won't be able to boot Windows 11 in a VM?
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:17PM (#27647924)
VMs can certainly do UEFI, and I believe TPM emulations exist, so probably doable.
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by jasonjayr on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:30PM (#27648318)
IIRC Hyper-V has an additional mode that chains with the real hardware TPM (if I'm understanding the feature correctly), which would allow attestation through the vm to the physical hardware root of trust to work as well. (Please, if this is wrong, please gently correct me ...)
Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by DiabloD3 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @02:26AM (#27649121)
This is called VBS.

It requires: virtualization instructions enabled and working, legacy bios disabled (not merely just booted with UEFI; workstations that are qualified for this operation usually have the option entirely removed, but simply turning legacy boot off entirely is enough), UEFI on, trusted boot on with Microsoft's keys enrolled, TPM 2.0 on and functioning and the OEM has to physically qualify that no external DMA interfaces can be hacked (ex: my 1660 Super claims it has a USB-C port (due to type-C DP support), the card physically only has DP and HDMI, no type-C, so I have to set a registry key saying "this PCI-E device has been qualified to not be an external concern") (another ex: even with USB3 etc host chips that are qualified (ie, the IOMMU properly sandboxes them), VBS sets the option that disables connecting a USB etc device awhile device is locked; you can only plug in a device while unlocked and have it actually connect).

VBS is for truly secure workstations, the kind that really truly try to defend themselves against all sorts of security issues, including physically there (in concert with Intel vPro deployed correctly for VBS, and AMD's equivalent that I'm blanking on the name for).

Re:Detection Script to help identify why your PC isn't Windo... by est on Saturday June 26, 2021 @08:44PM (#27647434)
Oh, from the title I thought it was written in Javascript, with some crazy WASM or WebGL hack to check your hardware models.