News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by tryptophan on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:08AM (#26672023)
NYT calling for more regulation as usual.

Fools will always find ways to lose their money. The way the market is regulated now, it is hard for honest people to raise money on the markets (the original purpose of stock markets), but scammers are still there.

If stock markets weren't horribly over-regulated, would the VC industry even need to exist?

Why must every part of the world be regulated into safety for the common man? Stock markets were once powerful tool. With power comes the ability to help, but also hurt one's self greatly.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulgb on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:00PM (#26672586)
> NYT calling for more regulation as usual.

I couldn't find anything in the article that fits this claim. There are a couple lines that report on what regulators are already doing, but not calling for more.

> If stock markets weren't horribly over-regulated, would the VC industry even need to exist?

Emphatically, yes. The best startups in their early stages do not want thousands of mom&pop cheques and investors to manage, they want a small number of smart money, value-added investors. The need for public investors to have transparency into their investments is in conflict with an early stage startup's need to keep competitive information to themselves.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:27PM (#26672913)
I don't agree at all. The rise of ICOs and crowd funding provide a strong counterexample. Ideally the best startups would be funded by revenue and bank loans.

The idea of value-added investors is pretty silly IMO. On one side, you add value to your team not by investing but by hiring. On the other side, you never want to have to rely on investment and with interest rates as low as they are, loans would almost always be preferable over equity dilution.

Usually the most significant value an investor can add is by making a raise as fast and painless as possible so the founders can get back to building their business. "Smart money" and "value-added" seem like concepts invented by investors to get equity at a better price. Founders should desire to spend as little time possible networking with investors and the maximum time focused on building products, engaging with customers and networking within the industry.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:20PM (#26673537)
> I don't agree at all. The rise of ICOs and crowd funding provide a strong counterexample. Ideally the best startups would be funded by revenue and bank loans.

ICOs provided the single best example of why regulation is necessary in decades — a world of fly by night scammers doing whatever it takes to separate people from their money, and a few well inventions but utterly unsuccessful projects. Zero ICOs turned into real successful business. Zero. You can count them on no hands. In exchange for what must be hundreds of billions of dollars worth of investments from the common person. What an utter write off.

Thing is, if you can raise from value added investors with experience and connections, you do. If you can’t you go after people who don’t know better. This leads to massive adverse selection risk - present in JOBS act investing too fwiw.

There’s a long and storied tradition here.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by DennisP on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:59PM (#26673969)
A lot of ICOs aren't trying to turn into businesses, or at least not primarily. They're trying to make an open protocol with a valuable token. Successful examples so far include Filecoin, Ethereum, and several major Ethereum competitors. One built on top of Ethereum is Maker, the leading decentralized stablecoin. Another is Chainlink, which does oracles.

Two actual businesses I can name that started with ICOs and appear to be doing well are Funfair, which does legal regulated gambling over Ethereum state channels, and Monolith, which puts tokens on VISA cards for spending.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by billytetrud on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:30PM (#26674326)
ICOs are mostly scams. If the company's product isn't the coin, clear scam. If the product is the coin, is the coin unique in some way? If not, scam. Most ICOs fall into one of those categories. I'm sure there are a handful of counterexamples amongst the myriads of scams
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by twox2 on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:03PM (#26675360)
The following ICOs became successful projects:

Ethereum Tezos Monero ( I think ) BAT (Brave Browser's Token)

There are plenty of others, but these are the ones that came up off the top of my head.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by renewiltord on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:31PM (#26675096)
Brave Browser is doing all right AFAIK.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:02PM (#26675342)
You know what, I'll give you that.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulgb on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:06PM (#26673376)
> The rise of ICOs and crowd funding provide a strong counterexample.

The crowdfunding provisions of the JOBS act are nearly a decade old now, which is the horizon of a typical VC fund. Has there been a single company that has returned well to investors? (Honest question, I haven't looked -- but I've seen some pretty suspicious looking pitches enabled by the act)

> Ideally the best startups would be funded by revenue and bank loans.

This is basically what happened before venture capital. If it were a more efficient way of funding startups, VC would not have emerged as an industry.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:08PM (#26674828)
Certainly, absent the VC model (or some other wealthy investor model), it would be much harder to scale businesses that are capital-intensive and/or aren't profitable in the short-term. So presumably absent VCs, you'd have a lot fewer crappy tech startups but you might also not have the success stories--or at least it would have taken them a lot longer to get there.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:33PM (#26676218)
Oculus started on Kickstarter. I believe GlowForge is a unicorn and started on Pebble.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulgb on Friday April 02, 2021 @08:45PM (#26677435)
Although the naming is confusing, crowdfunding in the JOBS Act sense enables small-time investors to invest for equity. It’s different from crowdfunding in the traditional, product sense which is essentially just a preorder and was legal before the JOBS act.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by matkoniecz on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:12PM (#26674110)
> The rise of ICOs

The rise of this scam ecosystem is proof that regulation is useful. Maybe there are rare cases of ICOs that were not scams. And maybe some of few remaining and were not utter, complete and predictable failure.

But it was a good demonstration how gullible people are and how evil people will readily exploit it.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:28PM (#26676192)
> how gullible people are and how evil people will readily exploit it

This really shouldn't be a surprise to anyone at this point. At least this one didn't create a war or recession. ICOs are innovative the same way other crowd funding initiatives are. It's a way for poorly networked but high quality people to get funding. There will be less scams over time as the people get smarter. It's no different than when radiation was discovered in the early 20th century, irradiated products became all the fad (1). Innovation always brings this risk.

(1) https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/the-lethal-legacy-of-e...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by matkoniecz on Friday April 02, 2021 @06:23PM (#26676590)
ICOs seems to have vastly higher rate of fraud than say Kickstarter
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @06:47PM (#26676740)
Yes, but you don't get equity or securities equivalents from Kickstarter. Here's an article about how $115B was scammed from crowdfunding investors in China (1). The biggest individual scam was a simple $8B Ponzi scheme.

(1) https://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2020/08/165315-115-billion-...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nradov on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:46PM (#26673127)
Value-added investors effectively act as "free" management consultants, and also make introductions to potential customers and partners. Those services are valuable, at least to founders who lack experience and industry connections. Small investors can't provide those services.

Most ICOs are simply scams and in no way comparable to legitimate investments.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:01PM (#26673308)
Wouldn't you prefer an advisor then? Same exact benefit but with better alignment. Usually advisors are actually currently in the industry and can give meaningful introductions outside their portfolio.

I also don't think it's fair to call all ICOs scams. It's certainly in its wild west phase but provides an alternative funding mechanism.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Animats on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:29PM (#26673640)
Name three ICO successes.

Let's look at topcoinlist.com. Not the current version, but the one of three years ago.[1] See how the top 5 from early 2018 came out.

- Tripbit - Down to near zero.[2]

- Developeo - No longer listed. "Website not active" as of 2020.[3]

- Proof of Toss - "Coin is inactive"[4]

- BitRewards - Still traded, sort of.[5] Issued at US$0.003, now at US$0.0002, with a daily trading volume of about US$1.

- CoolCousin - "Coin is inactive" [6]

FAIL.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20180403121628/https://topicolis...

[2] https://ih.advfn.com/crypto/TripBit-TBT

[3] https://icomarks.com/ico/developeo

[4] https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/proof-of-toss

[5] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitrewards/

[6] https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/cool-cousin

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by DennisP on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:15PM (#26674128)
I'll name nine: Ethereum, Cardano, Chainlink, Filecoin, Maker/DAI, Augur, the Brave browser, Funfair, and Monolith/Tokencard.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Animats on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:44PM (#26676312)
- Monolith/Tokencard: down 90% from peak.[1]

- Funfair: down about 95% from peak.[2]

- Brave basic attention token - actually went up.

- Augur - down about 70% from peak.

- Maker/DAI is a sort-of-stable coin. [4] DAI is supposed to be stable with respect to dollars, but is backed by Etherium and the right to dilute Maker coins. So Maker holders are subordinate creditors. Unclear how that will hold up in a downturn. Interesting, though.

- Filecoin has been going way up lately, with institutional backing. That's interesting and needs further attention. It's a scheme for trading disk storage capacity.

- Chainlink has gone way up. Although the system for actually storing files is only in beta, and hasn't been priced yet.

- Cardano - way up at the ICO, then way down for three years, now back up to slightly above the ICO peak. This is a proof of stake system.

- Etherium - big peak in 2017, crashed to about 15% of peak, now back up.

[1] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monolith/

[2] https://icomarks.com/ico/funfair

[3] https://www.coinbase.com/price/basic-attention-token

[4] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/augur/

[5] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/multi-collateral-dai/

[6] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/what-is-filecoin-a...

[7] https://www.coinbase.com/price/chainlink

[8] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/cardano/

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by DennisP on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:59PM (#26676409)
All true but what matters to ICO investors is their buying price. For Ethereum for example, the ICO price was between 30 cents and 60 cents, depending on when they bought. At the bottom of the post-2017 bear market it was $82, and at this moment it's $2098.

The only way Ethereum ICO investors could have lost money is if they bought over 43 cents, and sold when it dipped down to that point several months after launch.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:29PM (#26673632)
Advisors can certainly play that role, though they’re often low commitment roles with a small degree of aligned interests. Advisors are on their side and investors are on yours ideally.

Consider also that bank loans require that you make frequent structured payments with interest. That simply doesn’t apply to venture backed investments. Nobody ever got anywhere at a bank by taking risk. The role of the VCs is to provide the right level of risk tolerance on their capital.

> I also don't think it's fair to call all ICOs scams. It's certainly in its wild west phase but provides an alternative funding mechanism.

Usually switching out of the wild west phase is marked by regulation.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @06:04PM (#26676447)
VCs certainly have a role for high risk high reward investments. Equity is very expensive and if you can avoid giving it up, you should. Bank loans aren't an option for everyone but if both VCs and loans are on the table, you should pretty much always take the loan (unless it's personally collateralized).

I don't have any issue with the idea of VCs and generally I think they're better aligned than private equity. The big point is not to value smart vs dumb money. Just take the best deal and use the money you saved to hire someone. No amount of "smart" is worth even an extra 0.5% on the cap table. When comparing VCs, I'd like to safe vs dangerous instead. Does a VC have a reputation of creating problems for founders or giving them space even if things aren't going well? That's way more of a consideration than if a VC has better intros or a smarter team.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @08:16PM (#26677231)
> No amount of "smart" is worth even an extra 0.5% on the cap table.

I respectfully disagree. Your equity is worthless until it’s worth something. That 0.5% could be the difference between a unicorn and a bankruptcy. I would counter with: don’t over value your equity. Don’t make stupid decisions of course but don’t let 0.5% be the reason you fail.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by admax88q on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:08PM (#26674822)
Why would an advisor be better aligned than an investor?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:41PM (#26676284)
An investor has other constraints that prevent them from acting in the best interest of the company. Especially VCs have a timeline they need to hit for their fund so they'll push founders to make -EV decisions to speedup the timeframe. Investors also only care about the value of their portfolio, not the value of an individual company. Portfolio infighting, for example lawsuits, is highly discouraged even if it's for the benefit of one company. An advisor is usually an industry professional with fewer constraints and fewer possible sources of conflict.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by varsketiz on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:36PM (#26674398)
> The idea of value-added investors is pretty silly IMO.

The company I work at is VC funded. It would have folded if it was run by the original founders. At ~200m valuation it started stagnating. A member of the board that was on a VC seat found a consultant who came in as a strategy officer at first. He was able to turn the company around, made it possible for original founders to step away and became the new CEO in about 1 year. The company became a unicorn +-1.5 years ago.

After seeing this I prefer smart money very strongly.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:16PM (#26676081)
For every example of a VC saving a company (other than the actual investment), there are a dozen about a VC destroying one.

Let's also actually analyze the economics of this success case to show how it's still silly. Let's say the VC got a 15% discount for being smart(1). Let's say the VC owns 20% of the company. At a $200M valuation, the founders paid $6M to get smart investors as opposed to dumb money. For this $6M, they got an introduction at a pivotal point in the company. The salary of the COO of Yelp is $3.3M year (2) and most of that was stock compensation. For $6M, you could have your choice of COOs from top tech companies. IMO, that $6M could've been spent much more efficiently.

(1) This is a big assumption and you can play around with the numbers but if "smart" money doesn't get a better valuation than dumb money, there's no value to being a smart investor and the extra effort wouldn't make it worth it. 15% is also pretty conservative as you can feel free to look at the difference in VC valued companies vs how Sovereign Wealth Funds valued them.

(2) https://www1.salary.com/Jed-Nachman-Salary-Bonus-Stock-Optio...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by varsketiz on Friday April 02, 2021 @08:38PM (#26677380)
Well, you made a lot of assumptions here. For example that a COO from a good tech company in the US would come to a small EU country to save a failing startup. Also, we needed some pretty specific knowledge to succeed and we did not even know we were missing it.

Our company checks with people working in the org to see if we want to take money from particular investors. We have rejected investors in the past because the values of the investors were different from ours. We take money from investors that we can align on the mission. I mean, there are so many more criteria than money - values, mission, control of the company (are we free to run the company as we like?), preference treatment (how much preference you give VC's on their stock? How much are you willing to reduce the risk of the investor by taking their terms?). We used to value such things and we continue to do so. I'm happy we paid a premium and would do so again.

I look at it the other way round - if you compromise on values / mission / control / other things that are important to you and people in the organisation - you can get more money.

I mean, but how did we get into a hole if we took all this smart VC money? We followed some of their advice (as well as our own misguided ideas). If we failed back then, we would have been just another company "destroyed by smart VC's".

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dumbfoundded on Saturday April 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#26682833)
I think I'm much more cynical about investors than you. Employees are very different from investors. Employees dedicate most of their waking hours to make your company better while using that money to provide for their families. Investors spend maybe a couple hours every quarter making sure their investment is successful. The vast majority of investors do not depend on a single bet or really care that much if a single bet loses. As a founder, how you treat investors and employees should be very different. For me in particular, I see investors as a necessary evil. I see employees contentment and fulfillment as a chief responsibility.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by aussiegreenie on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:46PM (#26676322)
I have client who has developed industry-changing medical technology but they do not want to sell any equity.

We are looking at a bank loan to fund the factory and growth. They sell products that cost $5 per metre and sells at $500 per metre.

Bank loans are under used in startups but every company is different.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nmfisher on Saturday April 03, 2021 @02:35AM (#26678817)
There’s also a lot of debt finance available outside the Western world of finance if you know where to look (and how to negotiate with...interesting types).
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ejanus on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:20PM (#26674199)
I was expecting to see Brave browser in your list.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by xur17 on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:40PM (#26674469)
> Emphatically, yes. The best startups in their early stages do not want thousands of mom&pop cheques and investors to manage, they want a small number of smart money, value-added investors. The need for public investors to have transparency into their investments is in conflict with an early stage startup's need to keep competitive information to themselves.

That is probably true, but that's also the only option startups have during their early stages, so there's nothing to compare it to.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:11PM (#26674858)
Not all startups are VC-funded. (Of course, if your definition of startup is the sort of hypergrowth that requires VC funding, then we have a tautology.)
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by anotherman554 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:31AM (#26672241)
NYT says Penny stocks are filled with fraud.

This is a factual claim, but your response is not to say that the NYT has the facts wrong, but instead to imply they shouldn't report on facts and imply they have a secret agenda for doing so.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by rcoveson on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:44AM (#26672398)
That's not a factual claim, it's a subjective statement. "Some penny stock transactions are fraudulent" is a factual claim, though not a very interesting one. "The SEC estimates that X% of penny stock transactions are fraudulent" is a stronger factual claim.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Apocryphon on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:56AM (#26672546)
What's actually factual is the NYT says

> But last month, there were 1.9 trillion transactions on O.T.C. markets, an increase of more than 2,000 percent from a year earlier, according to data from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, a self-regulatory group that oversees brokerage firms.

And

> A 2017 paper from Thomas Renault, a finance professor at the University Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, analyzed millions of Twitter messages about low-priced stocks. A surge in tweets about a small stock led to big price increases followed by sudden collapses, he found, saying the pattern was consistent with pump-and-dump schemes.

Granted, the rest of the article is mostly quotes from ex-SEC regulators, investors, economists, Jordan Belfort; anecdotes about a few OTC stock scams; and an explanation of what pump and dump schemes are.

But this whole discussion is oversimplifying the article, assigning motives where there doesn't seem to be one.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:53AM (#26672510)
The growing frequency and magnitude of fraud in the penny stock market is absolutely a factual claim. It would be better if the article made it explicitly. But it's implicitly there, albeit only anecdotally substantiated.

The SEC is chronically underfunded. A compelling anecdote in the press isn't an uncommon way for an investigation to start. In that light, this article is an expression of a hypothesis.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by rcoveson on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:59AM (#26672580)
> The frequency and magnitude of fraud in the penny stock market is absolutely a factual claim.

Yes, that's exactly what I said. However, the article doesn't make any such claim.

Or maybe I missed it, because it was "implicit". What frequency or magnitude of fraud was claimed by the article? "A lot" doesn't cut it. That can mean anything to anyone.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:45AM (#26672405)
> Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers

The editorializing agenda is right there in the title. This isn't news it's propaganda and as usual the NYT lies through omission. Please name one reason the state lotto is ok but investing in penny stocks is not. You don't see any NYT articles about that though.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by llacb47 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:52AM (#26672496)
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by raunak on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:28PM (#26674292)
That was a great article - to anyone seeing this comment, I’d recommend reading through it
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:56AM (#26672547)
Notice the difference between the two articles?

OP: Penny stocks are rife with fraud and reward swindlers

Your article: This one instance of state lotto had fraud. No comment on the lotto in general.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by em-bee on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:51AM (#26672485)
(sarcasm) the government profits from state lotto, it doesn't profit from stock swindlers.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Ensorceled on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:49AM (#26672462)
Ummm, actually you do. Editorials and Op Eds as well.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulryanrogers on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:20AM (#26672131)
Financial regulation has many goals. At least two of them are protecting the naive from thinly veiled fraud and mitigating tax evasion. Even if governments had no other objectives I imagine those are enough to produce a lot of regulation.

Tax evasion alone looks like a continuous game of cat and mouse. Where governments are always playing catch up as less ethical legislators slip more loopholes and pork into incomprehensively large budget proposals.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cwhiz on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:50AM (#26672468)
The tax problem is actually relatively simple to solve. Tax at the point of consumption. Unfortunately, people would rather have an ineffective game of cat and mouse where they FEEL like it's progressive, even though the rich still aren't paying.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cmonagle on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:07PM (#26672677)
Classic consumption taxes (sales taxes and VAT) tend to be quite regressive.

I haven't read the whole report, but this was studied in 2005[1] and they had to add a "Family Credit" (basically a UBI) of 500-1000$ per month to balance it out, and recovered approximately 65% of individual and corporate income taxes.

1. https://govinfo.library.unt.edu/taxreformpanel/final-report/...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nullserver on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:59PM (#26673271)
Sounds like the fair tax by Neil Bortz.

High sales tax on all “new” products. None on used. A check to everyone each month so that poor don’t suffer from it.

Basically eliminates the IRS, and much of the Tax compliance / avoidance industry. Stops a lot of the tax nonsense that corporations and congress loves.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by csunbird on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:12PM (#26674105)
The problem with that is, people (usually rich people) will stop buying expensive stuff in the country, and they start buying them from another country that does not have any sales tax. Rich people avoid taxes and poor people are now stuck with the VAT on their daily needs.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by mcguire on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:01PM (#26674747)
Or, as a government professor I once had said, "You can only eat so much filet mignon a day."
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:16PM (#26674914)
Variants of that are even older. Here's one variant of a quote often attributed to Adolphus Busch: “You can only drink 30 or 40 glasses of beer a day, no matter how rich you are.”
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nullserver on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:33PM (#26674378)
Tax purchases made overseas.

Tariffs are already used a lot.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nemo44x on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:31PM (#26672954)
Yeah more or less credit it back as a function of income by way of monthly payouts. At a certain income the credits begin getting phased out slowly. You can also tax different things at different rates. For instance, vegetables sound be taxed differently than yachts. It also lets externalities be taxed the entire lifecycle of the good or service.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by jerry1979 on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:10PM (#26674088)
I imagine that I would have a hard time listing out all the points of consumption. For example, I would include "filing to make a corporation" on the list. However, when the police come to protect my business from burglars, do I add that to the list? Or would a "daily protection" make more sense? Higher up the ladder, when our intelligence agencies trade favors in exchange for weapons contracts, should lockheed pay for that? Or should the workers at the bomb factory? Or the municipality in which the factory exits?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by throwaway2048 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:58AM (#26672568)
consumption based taxes are an even larger boon to the rich since they consume so much less of their income.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cwhiz on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:10PM (#26672717)
This is predicated on the idea that the rich will pay their taxes if we just close all the loopholes.

If you polled the top brackets I think you'll find that they are more than happy to continue with our current tax system.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:31PM (#26672964)
Are you suggesting that the rich would break the law and engage in tax evasion (not legal loopholes)?

A great portion of my taxes goes to military and police. Wouldn’t they just collect the money push come to shove? They certainly have the capability, but possibly not the will.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by g00gler on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:06PM (#26673378)
It’s relatively easy to pay less taxes than your true compensation once you get past the rank-and-file level of employment.

As income taxes rise there’s a clear pattern of altered compensation like stock grants, expense accounts, etc.

For example, a company can lease an apartment for you to live in. That expense is a write off and isn’t subject to FICA taxes.

Instead of giving you $40,000 in cash which would cost 30% in FICA between you and the company plus personal income tax to you, you can live in a nice $3500/mo apartment you would otherwise be paying for in after tax dollars.

Instead of you paying $800/month+ for a Tesla model X lease with your after tax dollars the company can pay for it, write it off, and again they’re saving 15% on taxes and you’re saving > 40% on that $10,000 and pocketing more of your after tax income.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by gruez on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:57PM (#26673936)
>For example, a company can lease an apartment for you to live in. That expense is a write off and isn’t subject to FICA taxes.

I'm not an accountant or a tax lawyer, but it doesn't look like that's the case according to the IRS's website. Housing is only exempt if it's "Lodging on your business premises"[1]. A tesla would also likely not be exempt for a typical office worker[2]

[1] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p15b#en_US_2021_publink1000...

[2] https://www.irs.gov/publications/p15b#en_US_2021_publink1000...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by sneeze-slayer on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:24PM (#26673577)
Other countries solve this by taxing it as a "benefit in kind". It is compensation, and should be included in how one is taxed.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by filoleg on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:06PM (#26674037)
It is a thing in the US too. For example, I have to pay income tax on the annual "fitness reimbursement allowance" the company provides for us.

Very simplified version: we can spend up to $1k/yr on fitness related expenses and get them reimbursement. We submit a reimbursement request, and if it gets approved, I get the money back in my account. The HR page explicitly warns that any reimbursement received will count towards your income tax.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:39PM (#26673724)
I don't think you can tax the rich with income tax, for the reason you state. I think you need a wealth tax.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nickpp on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:46PM (#26673133)
At which point the regulatory burden imposed with the righteous purpose of catching those damn nimble "tax evaders" actually causes more tax loss by affecting and discouraging initiative, entrepreneurship and business agility?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulryanrogers on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:08PM (#26674816)
If the wide view of the landscape in the US (little) and EU (much) is any indicator I imagine the point at which there is too much regulation is closer to or beyond the EU levels. In the US the never ending stream of new MLM, ICO/DeFi, and otherwise repackaged 'investment' scams is a constant reminder that it's very much a wild west.

Average people in the US need to know an obscene amount just to walk the minefield, while inflation erodes what little earnings they have.

Of course the richest investors can pump money into new ventures started in the lowest regulated markets to realize the highest gains with whatever hoop-jumping to get profits laundered through lowest taxed markets.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by pc86 on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:27PM (#26675054)
You seem to view legislators as mustache-twirling villains while regulators are valiantly trying to save the little guy. They're often the exact same people.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulryanrogers on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:56PM (#26675896)
Naturally there are good and bad among both roles, accountability and transparency is sorely needed everywhere.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:39AM (#26672340)
It's funny how only when it comes to investments does the government care to "protect" people from their own free will. I present a sample list of fraudulent activities either not discouraged by the government or actively promoted:

* State lotto

* Psychic hotlines

* Supplements/vitamins of dubious value

* Regular stocks with wildly ridiculous P/E ratios

* Various forms of "insurance"

Which is to say, it's never been about protecting people from fraud and it's always been about limiting who's allowed to participate in the capital class activities.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by gizmo686 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:50AM (#26672471)
Just because there are some things the government does not protect people against, does not mean that investments are the only thing the government protects people against.

> State lotto

Most gambling is either highly regulated or outright banned. Also, gambling is a financial product, which arguably falls under the category of "investment".

> Supplements/vitamins of dubious value

Because these products are very carefully designed and marketed to avoid the heavy regulation that is applied to medical products

> Regular stocks with wildly ridiculous P/E ratios

These are investments, so this example doesn't really fit into your thesis that the government only regulates investments.

> Various forms of "insurance"

Insurance is a financial product that could also be viewed as an "investment". Further, many types of insurance are highly regulated.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:00PM (#26672596)
My point is the government isn't "protecting" anyone with these regulations. They will happily watch you spend your life savings buying lotto tickets (not an investment) but if you actually want to put that money into a company, you're going to be scrutinized.

An even better example are the accredited investor laws, which also claim to "protect" people but in reality cut off all but the wealthy from the true upside to investing.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Aunche on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:36PM (#26673008)
The difference is that a state lottery is completely transparent about their payouts. Companies will often lie about their expected payouts, hence the scrutiny.

> but in reality cut off all but the wealthy from the true upside to investing

I don't understand the logic here. There isn't a global conspiracy among rich people to stopping others from making money. It doesn't make any difference to Jeff Bezos on whether $1 million gets made by Peter Thiel or a regular person. In fact, Bezos would probably prefer the latter since they're more likely to spend their money on Amazon purchases.

The reason for accredited investor status is because losing money hurts more than winning money benefits unless if you have a lot of money to begin with. One regular person making $1 million doesn't make up for 10 regular people losing $50,000, even though that would be wildly EV positive.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:33PM (#26672979)
I'm very skeptical that there are all these highly lucrative investments that small retail investors are missing out on once you adjust for risk. Many VCs don't actually have particularly great returns overall, for example. The idea that there's some magic money machine out there that only the private club has access to doesn't have a lot of evidence supporting it.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by HarryHirsch on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:48AM (#26672443)
It gets really problematic when the money market doesn't allocate capital to productive investments. That's its ostensible and actually the only socially acceptable purpose.

We see people investing in dodgy companies, look at Theranos, not because the business idea is sound, but because the investors have powerful backers and can extract outsize return from inferior product.

And then there's bitcoin, which is not a medium of exchange, not a store of value, not a unit of account, but a pure object of speculation and now even Goldman Sachs advise to put the money there. The real world is not improved by clear-eyed people allocating funds to a Ponzi scheme.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:51AM (#26672486)
I'm not seeing the problem. What you're saying is that you want to dictate how people spend their money. Why is buying penny stocks a concern to you but spending that same amount of money on travel, cars, beanie babies... is not?

People should be able to spend their money as they please. Again, this is a red herring because their is upside to be had in plenty of these investments. Contrary to the article penny stocks are nowhere near 100% fraudulent.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:43AM (#26672379)
> State lotto

Heavily regulated.

> Psychic hotlines

Have large numbers of people historically lost fortunes to these?

> Supplements/vitamins of dubious value

Fair.

> Regular stocks with wildly ridiculous P/E ratios

Literally the thing you're criticizing.

> Various forms of "insurance"

Heavily regulated.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:46AM (#26672412)
Stocks are heavily regulated as well. Regulation and fraud are orthogonal to each other.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:47PM (#26673806)
It’s so weird that when what could be dumped into a river got regulated, the river stopped catching fire. Is that orthogonal too? Maybe a coincidence?

[1] https://clevelandhistorical.org/items/show/63

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by mateo411 on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:18PM (#26674935)
The Cuyahoga River catching fire was motivation for creating the EPA.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:50AM (#26672477)
> Regulation and fraud are orthogonal to each other

This is a heady statement. It goes against all the research I've seen about international markets, though I'm open to changing my view.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:54AM (#26672514)
Regulation leads to regulatory capture which leads to power and information imbalances that are great substrate for fraud. The stock market (not just penny stocks) is highly regulated but I think we could all agree there's fraud happening.

Happy to read any links you have that has evidence contrary to that though.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulryanrogers on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:15PM (#26674905)
Deregulation leads to collusion and centralization which are great for gouging.

Regulatory capture is corruption. In every scenario we need transparency and enforcement of agreed upon rules to maintain a balanced playing field.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:41PM (#26673757)
Basically everything on your list is highly highly regulated except for vitamins which should be. They really should be. When you buy vitamins you have no idea if they work or do anything, it’s a giant waste of money. I’ve read some studies on the bioavailability of magnesium supplements and they range from 20 to 90% depending on the brand. FDA regulated Tylenol doesn’t range from 20 to 90% affective depending on whether I get the brand-name or generic. This is yet another argument in support of regulation. [1]

As for the reason these financial products are regulated, they lead in part to the great depression. State has an interest in it because it is in the states interest to maintain a functioning economy.

There are compelling arguments against regulations, particularly in industries that have no business being regulated like aestheticians. Or barbers. There is genuinely no good reason for that. But the suggested vitamins and drugs shouldn’t be regulated, but financial product should be regulated? I’m having a hard time with this one.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6683096/#!po=0....

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by paulryanrogers on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:59PM (#26674718)
Article is about stocks, so the fact that governments aren't consistent in protections compared to other areas seems a bit off topic.

That said, whenever the failure to protect carries a very high cost one would hope those things would get weighted more heavily when protections are considered. Supplements in particular are interesting in that they appear increasingly _designed_ to skirt existing regulations. And as more and more are found doing significant harm the governments of various states have starting paying more attention.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by kiba on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:58AM (#26672577)
Politicians chase/follow outrage. There's not enough outrage about psychic hotlines and supplements of dubious value.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by solosoyokaze on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:01PM (#26672600)
Is there any outrage about penny stocks? I only see that from establishment media and financial outlets, not citizens.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nullserver on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:05PM (#26673360)
Vitamins and supplements are part of what happens when doctors don’t listen.

Was getting up 10 times a night. Life was a living hell. Doctors were useless.

So I tried a recommended one. (Aloe Vera pills)

I sleep through the night now.

Now I also have had bad experiences. Elderberry was not fun.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by arcticbull on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:48PM (#26673819)
Without getting into the specifics of weather particular substances have any meaningful effect vs placebo, part of the issue was that there’s no guarantee that there is even the thing on the label inside the pills or that their formulated in a way that actually makes them available to the body. For instance this study in magnesium supplementation shows a 20-90% absorption based on brand.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6683096/#!po=0....

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nullserver on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:30PM (#26674317)
Yea, lots of different kinds of magnesium and brands are very annoying.

Stuff is amazing dramatically reduced headaches and muscle aches. Magnesium citrate.

I generally stick to the most expensive ones.

Other variations have not helped, I felt weird on them.

Problem is the same (though to a much lessor degree) for prescriptions.

Plaqunial name brand is drastically more impactful then it’s genetics. So much so, that I have to cut dosage 1/2 to 1/4.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by css on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:10AM (#26672041)
> If stock markets weren't horribly over-regulated, would the VC industry even need to exist?

It's not just the stock market, its almost everything about corporate finance. The straitjacket bank regulators have placed around the ability of banks to go outside of the government defined process of evaluating credit-worthiness is a big factor. These rules (mainly FDIC insurance requirements) make it near-impossible for many companies to get loans. This problem incentivizes companies to play financial games (e.g., Adjusted EBITDA) to get around the crazy restrictions.

This is why there is an emerging trend of non-traditional lenders (e.g. some VCs and PE firms). I’m sure the government will find a way to regulate them eventually.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by api on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:24AM (#26672172)
This isn't wrong, but there is a counterargument: bad chases out good.

If you let scams run rampant, eventually the whole ecosystem becomes associated with scams and the good money and good players just leave.

This is the #1 risk to the largely unregulated cryptocurrency ecosystem. Many people already associate anything cryptocurrency with scams, or even equate the two. Legitimate value creating industries and legitimate players tend to avoid the whole space. Many people refuse to even look at cryptocurrency and block chain oriented technology for fear that being linked with the term will make them look "scammy."

A major objective of all this regulation is to retain US dominance in global finance by protecting US markets' reputation as (relatively speaking) solid and safe.

A good analogy is a "bad neighborhood." It takes only a small percentage of residents in a neighborhood committing street crime (far less than 1%) coupled with police neglect to label a neighborhood "high crime" and "bad," a label that will stick for decades and depress the whole area. Once a neighborhood carries such a label it often takes heavy handed police action or a complete tear-down / rebuild of the area to shake it.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by newsclues on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:40AM (#26672351)
The illegal drug market is a great example of bad chases out good.

Organized criminals who are willing to be violent displace outlaw entrepreneurs who are peaceful.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by api on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:48AM (#26672444)
Sure, and this is a major factor behind the number of deaths among drug users too. Bad product such as opiates cut with fentanyl or "bath tub crank" methamphetamine with nasty contaminants chases out purer (and thus lower margin because it's harder to make) product.

(I'm not advocating use of these drugs, just pointing out that less harm would be done if they were pure instead of nasty street jank.)

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ceilingcorner on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:21AM (#26672139)
Once I realized that The NY Times represents the establishment class, their writings suddenly made sense to me. Heck, they own a skyscraper in one of the most expensive cities in the world. How could they not be the establishment?

Established entities always prefer regulations, as it makes it harder for new competitors to join the market.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by totalZero on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:28AM (#26672216)
> Established entities always prefer regulations, as it makes it harder for new competitors to join the market.

Depends on the regulations.

Comcast opposed Net Neutrality, for example. Goldman Sachs didn't like the Volcker Rule. Devon Energy pushed for weaker regulations on methane venting and flaring.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nostrademons on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:27PM (#26672910)
Note that the first two are regulations designed to encourage competition and enforce a clear separation between industries. The last one is the rectification of an externality.

Perhaps this suggests a useful principal for government regulation: regulations that promote competition and divestiture, or that force companies to bear the true costs of their actions, are good. Regulations meant to mandate a specific way of doing things are bad, and should instead be structured so that they incentivize entrepreneurs to find the best way of doing things and allow them to bring it to market.

Regulate market structure, not markets.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:25AM (#26672176)
Yearly revenue is under $2bn though.

I'd like to see more print media do well- the NYT still needs competition. Everyone cries about ads and tracking. Put your money where your mouth is and buy print from a source that you enjoy.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by psychiatrist24 on Saturday April 03, 2021 @03:46AM (#26679068)
Any suggestions?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:31PM (#26731643)
I enjoy NYT and New Yorker.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by olivermarks on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:50AM (#26672472)
The NYT has been governed by the Sulzberger family since 1896, more recently via a dual-class share structure after its shares became publicly traded in 1969. A. G. Sulzberger and his father, Arthur Ochs Sulzberger Jr are the current leaders of the Sulzberger-Ochs dynasty. The NYT is as establishment as it gets, despite the endless posturing of 'investigative reporting', a fig leaf for quiet reinforcement of the status quo. Its equivalent in the UK is arguably the Financial Times, who are in comparison very straight forward supporters of globalization, WEF 'great reset' etc along with the Rothchild/Agneli magazine the Economist.

There used to be a common descriptor of the Soviet era Pravda that you had to read between the lines to get near the truth. I broadly feel the same way about all of the above media companies.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by olivermarks on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:03PM (#26672621)
Adding the UK Guardian to the above, who are in a whole class of their own as sheperds for the oligarchs wishes
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:41AM (#26672368)
> they own a skyscraper in one of the most expensive cities in the world. How could they not be the establishment?

I agree that the Times represents the institutional / political elites views surprisingly accurately. (Most societies don't have such a public lens into their elites' preferences.)

Your signaling mechanism, however, is poor. Lots of organizations own landmark properties in New York City. Most of them are property management companies. (Brookfield, I believe, owns about 40% of the New York Times building.) New York property types are...let's just say they've cultivated a reputation for eccentricity. Far from establishment, albeit powerful in their own right.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ceilingcorner on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:44AM (#26672394)
Yes I guess my point is just that Democracy Now or a similar org doesn’t own a skyscraper.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by mixedbit on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:29AM (#26672218)
ICOs were much less regulated, but I don't think this significantly helped honest people to raise money. Scam to honest company ratio was simply to high in such an environment.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by makomk on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:43AM (#26672380)
ICOs were regulated - they were covered by the same regulations that applied to stock sales. The only real way to avoid the consequences of that was for US Government not to be able to track down the people involved in creating and promoting them. Naturally, this didn't encourage the creation of honest and non-scammy ICOs.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:44AM (#26672388)
> ICOs were regulated - they were covered by the same regulations that applied to stock sales

Theoretically, yes. But enforcement was practically nonexistent.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by icedchai on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:24AM (#26672167)
It would be like 1999 again, where a junk company goes public and raises $20+ million, the collapses in 2 to 3 years.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by beambot on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:04PM (#26672640)
Substitute "SPAC" for "junk company" and you basically described the current situation.

There are some that are legit, but many of them are "greater fool" scenarios -- and that ratio is getting worse as acquisition targets dry up. No one wants to give their SPAC money back, less the music stops...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by MattGaiser on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:30AM (#26672224)
> Why must every part of the world be regulated into safety for the common man?

The common man will end up demanding something more extreme when they lose.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JKCalhoun on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:51AM (#26672492)
Yep. Better to regulate now than have to bail out with taxpayer dollars later.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:38PM (#26673039)
I'm willing to bet that there are a lot of people here who simultaneously believe two things:

- People should be able to put their money into anything they want

- There should be strong safety nets to protect people who have lost their money/income

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Karunamon on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:45PM (#26673780)
Those stances are not mutually incompatible. The safety net is there because it leads to worse outcomes for everyone to not have it, not as a statement on what people should and shouldn't be spending their money on.

Putting your entire net worth (to the point where you're out of room and board) into any investment instrument is unwise. I'd even support regulations at that point, i.e. you may not directly invest more than X% of your income

...but this applies to penny stocks and cryptocurrencies just as much as it applies to an S&P index fund or treasury bonds.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by uniqueid on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:29AM (#26672220)

  NYT calling for more regulation as usual.
Deregulation sounds inspiring in theory https://youtu.be/qXBswFfh6AY but, in practice: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/08/07/opinion/leonh...
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by shawnz on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:46AM (#26672420)
What does the latter link have to do with deregulation?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by uniqueid on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:06PM (#26672667)
If the question is 'what does two terms of Reagan have to do with deregulation?': https://daily.jstor.org/why-reagan-became-the-great-deregula...

If the question is a challenge for me to provide an unassailable proof that deregulation hurt most Americans: it's economics so I can't provide one.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by shawnz on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:14PM (#26672763)
It's not just comparing pre-Reagan to post-Reagan though, but also the 25 years following that. If you look at the animation, the biggest changes happen after 2000.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by adventured on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:16PM (#26672780)
> Why must every part of the world be regulated into safety for the common man?

That's not really their concern, they're pathological hypocrites in reality. They're very happy to keep state sanctioned lotteries plentiful and legal, so the common person can blow their financial brains out handing their hard-earned cash to the government in a scheme that specifically benefits the government (they get you on the tickets, then they get you on a massive tax hit on the win). Unregulated penny stocks are not worse for the common person than government controlled lotteries that vaporize so much money for average people; arguable lotteries are far worse, your odds of winning might as well be zero.

They absolutely do not care about the so called common man, not in the least. They care about control, power; they care about who has it, who has access to it, and who gets to sell it to the highest bidder.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by sethhochberg on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:42PM (#26673088)
This framing makes the whole thing sound like a nefarious plot, but I suspect the reality is more simple: you can't pump-and-dump a lottery, the draw is tightly controlled.

The parts of the penny stock / meme stock world that are drawing lots of negative attention right now are the online communities where anonymous people are giving plenty of "not financial advice" and disclaiming it away with a statement like "do your own DD" (due diligence). Obviously, yes, you should do your own due diligence when acting on a stock tip from a stranger. But even that assumes that the stranger's tip was made in good faith, and wasn't just designed to help them unload something they bought and want to get rid of profitably by hyping a market to unsavvy buyers.

With a lotto, you can see the projected winnings, know the draw date, and usually even know how many other people are buying tickets. With penny stocks from reddit, there's a decent chance the guy offering the tip about which stock to buy plans to exit long before his target price, because he strung together a plausible hype pitch to trick you into getting stuck holding the bag.

The state is usually prevented from lying about possible winnings to sell more lotto tickets.

I'm not sure whether more regulation for retail investors is a good thing or not. But I do think it isn't a very genuine comparison to say that regulating financial markets is a farce because lotteries exist, there is much more information asymmetry in retail stock trades.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Apocryphon on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:07PM (#26673390)
The government is also not a monolithic entity, the officials trying to regulate OTC stocks are not the ones running lotteries, and they're not even at the same level of government! What do the money-raising schemes of states have anything to do with federal regulators?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by dalbasal on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:57AM (#26672553)
ehh...

More/less regulated is a silly paradigm to think through... especially for long regulated industries. There is no more or less. Regulation are not quantitative, usually. It's about what the regulations are, and what enforcement looks like.

Even the term "regulator" doesn't mean quite what it sounds like. It doesn't just mean "rules governments make." Those are laws. To the extent this article is calling for anything, it's calling for policing... which is also something a regulator does.

> "it is hard for honest people to raise money on the markets (the original purpose of stock markets), but scammers are still there. If stock markets weren't horribly over-regulated, would the VC industry even need to exist?"

Maybe not on some a chalkboard model of the world. In the actual financial world, "penny stock" markets exist for lower cap companies. They are less regulated, for exactly the reason you are alluding to. From the article itself:

"Traded on the lightly regulated over-the-counter, or O.T.C., markets, penny stocks face fewer rules about publishing information on financial results or independent board members. Wall Street analysts don’t usually follow them. Major investors don’t buy them."

VCs exist. OTC markets exist, they just aren't a popular place for startups to raise or for institutions to invest. VCs are. Reality is not a naive theory, so it's hard to say exactly why. We can think theories about why this is. To find out if they're true, we need to find evidence in the world. It's fine to propose that just not rational to conclude that honest people can't raise money because OTC regulators are too busibodied. It's irrational to conclude that without some corresponding facts from the world corroborating it. I'm not talking about absolute proofs... just something.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by snidane on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:43PM (#26673097)
Good point about VC industry. Would there even be a distinction among various types of funds if not for regulation?

Ie. pool money and invest? No matter if it is VC fund, hedge fund, pension fund, mutual fund, they all just pool money and invest in something. Which used to be called.. just a 'bank' before all those regulations.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by tim333 on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:12PM (#26672727)
I don't see them as calling for more regulation:

>But current and former regulators say penny stock fraud will remain as long as penny stocks are traded.

It's more fraud's going to happen. The "reminiscent of the 1920s, when amateurs flooded into the stock market before the 1929 crash" is a little ominous.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Shivetya on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:30PM (#26674324)
What I read was, Social media bad. A part of the long running crusade of the NYT and other media that is finding itself displaced by Social media, whether existing sites or new upstarts.

The simple point is, NYT and other legacy media companies resent that they don't control the news and how it is portrayed, delivered, and worse for them fact checked. They really loathe being called out repeatedly by "upstarts" who aren't real "journalist".

There have been many editors, writers, and more, taken down in recent years that used to operate with impunity within the legacy media. No one would question them or the paper they wrote for. Now they can get caught when they cross the line or worse outright fabricate stories.

So the legacy media simply writes stories that portray social media as bad and in need of regulation, in other words, silencing.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by nkozyra on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:30AM (#26672236)
Wouldn't that preclude investment until a company went public?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by currymj on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:00PM (#26672590)
what kinds of deregulation would you hope to see? make it easier for small companies to do public offerings?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cblconfederate on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:30AM (#26672235)
And who will pick the winners?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Craighead on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:15AM (#26672089)
Yes yes the boring and repeated argument of "why improve anything when things will fail on their own"

Please try something new, I'm so curious as to why this logical fallacy gets repeated ad nauseam

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by fractionalhare on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:24AM (#26672170)
I don't agree with the parent comment either. But if you're going to critique it, you might as well levy a substantive criticism rather than a driveby dismissal calling it a "logical fallacy"...
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by mancerayder on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:15AM (#26672087)
It's the now-routine elitism of the center-left liberal elites. I know it comes off as left regulatory demands, but it's a sort of call for the Clever to protect the Little People from themselves.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by sosuke on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:23AM (#26672165)
I'm not actually thinking anything about your comment or the parent comment. But I wanted to share that the characterization of the "elitism of center-left liberal elites" makes my gut reaction to dismiss your comment. The same thing happens with I see something like "right extremist Q" or whatever the vernacular is.

Is there a better, perhaps more clinical, way to more narrowly describe these kinds of groups? Or is that the right way to say it and my own bias is being applied?

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by JKCalhoun on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:54AM (#26672528)
Well, he/she did use the word elite twice in the same sentence....
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ceilingcorner on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:26AM (#26672191)
I think it’s mostly accurate, but you’d probably want to add a few more adjectives like East Coast, Ivy League, pro-Establishment (as in, not “punk”), neoliberal, etc.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cma on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:21AM (#26672138)
Isn't that what unchecked capital accumulation is too, where trickle down is supposed to protect the little people who would mess things up if they had more decision power (represented by capital)?
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by undefined1 on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:26AM (#26672186)
it's more the ruling class, that includes both left and right.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by runarberg on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:34AM (#26672282)
Interesting take. Can you point me to a time in recent history when good, honest, hard working people (i.e. common folks) were the once making money out of the stock market?

As a worker, my experience has always been the opposite. That is rich folks using the stock market to get some unearned money out of my work.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by Ensorceled on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:52AM (#26672505)
For the most part, the only time "good, honest, hard working people" make money on the stock market is via their pensions.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by havelhovel on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:10PM (#26672709)
Just look at AAPL or, heck, even SPY returns over the last decade. These opportunities were equally available to rich and poor alike, and they certainly didn't require a team of analysts working around the clock to uncover.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by ghaff on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:30PM (#26675090)
Yeah. The last 10 years have arguably been something of an outlier but there is no shortage of companies in which a 2010 investment wouldn't have you looking at a nice pile of money in 2020. Returns in fact that a lot of people peddling "accredited investor" type products would probably kill for. And, as you say, a really boring index fund wouldn't have done half-badly either.

I just want to know where these special opportunities are hiding. I do have an investment that pays me an annuity from an endowment that includes some less standard investments. But, while they get good returns, they're nothing truly out of the ordinary.

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by missedthecue on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:25PM (#26675030)
There are almost $30 trillion growing in retirement funds.

https://www.napa-net.org/news-info/daily-news/retirement-ass...

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by loceng on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:14AM (#26672069)
I mean, this is the only reason Bitcoin has made it mainstream, no? The hype has onboarded tens of millions of layperson speculators who are now financially invested in the MLM-Ponzi scheme - and they're all hoping, the army of HODLers, to get the rest of society to adopt - so it's the latest adopters left holding the bag - meanwhile then in the structure, the agreement that wealth is unnecessarily, unreasonably, transferred to the earlier adopters (via the "current price" being higher than their buy price).
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by seibelj on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:16AM (#26672097)
For a relatively quick read with an alternative perspective, check out The Bitcoin Standard https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Standard-Decentralized-Altern...

There is a logical explanation as to why bitcoin could be very valuable in our current world. It is because it cannot be inflated beyond the 21 million cap. If you have an open mind, give it a read!

Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by loceng on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:56AM (#26672551)
Thanks for sharing. There are other viable better options that simply don't get exposure, or thought by pro-Bitcoiners, as they aren't financially aligned with their investment - though better because they would use blockchain but would be leveraging real life trust networks like of those of governments of democratically elected governments agreeing to use a specific system with other democratic nations.
Re:Penny Stocks Are Booming, Which Is Good News for Swindlers by cmoscoso on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:56PM (#26673231)
blockchain tech is definitely the future. /s