I also don't think it's fair to call all ICOs scams. It's certainly in its wild west phase but provides an alternative funding mechanism.
Let's look at topcoinlist.com. Not the current version, but the one of three years ago.[1] See how the top 5 from early 2018 came out.
- Tripbit - Down to near zero.[2]
- Developeo - No longer listed. "Website not active" as of 2020.[3]
- Proof of Toss - "Coin is inactive"[4]
- BitRewards - Still traded, sort of.[5] Issued at US$0.003, now at US$0.0002, with a daily trading volume of about US$1.
- CoolCousin - "Coin is inactive" [6]
FAIL.
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20180403121628/https://topicolis...
[2] https://ih.advfn.com/crypto/TripBit-TBT
[3] https://icomarks.com/ico/developeo
[4] https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/proof-of-toss
- Funfair: down about 95% from peak.[2]
- Brave basic attention token - actually went up.
- Augur - down about 70% from peak.
- Maker/DAI is a sort-of-stable coin. [4] DAI is supposed to be stable with respect to dollars, but is backed by Etherium and the right to dilute Maker coins. So Maker holders are subordinate creditors. Unclear how that will hold up in a downturn. Interesting, though.
- Filecoin has been going way up lately, with institutional backing. That's interesting and needs further attention. It's a scheme for trading disk storage capacity.
- Chainlink has gone way up. Although the system for actually storing files is only in beta, and hasn't been priced yet.
- Cardano - way up at the ICO, then way down for three years, now back up to slightly above the ICO peak. This is a proof of stake system.
- Etherium - big peak in 2017, crashed to about 15% of peak, now back up.
[1] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monolith/
[2] https://icomarks.com/ico/funfair
[3] https://www.coinbase.com/price/basic-attention-token
[4] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/augur/
[5] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/multi-collateral-dai/
[6] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/what-is-filecoin-a...
The only way Ethereum ICO investors could have lost money is if they bought over 43 cents, and sold when it dipped down to that point several months after launch.
Consider also that bank loans require that you make frequent structured payments with interest. That simply doesn’t apply to venture backed investments. Nobody ever got anywhere at a bank by taking risk. The role of the VCs is to provide the right level of risk tolerance on their capital.
> I also don't think it's fair to call all ICOs scams. It's certainly in its wild west phase but provides an alternative funding mechanism.
Usually switching out of the wild west phase is marked by regulation.
I don't have any issue with the idea of VCs and generally I think they're better aligned than private equity. The big point is not to value smart vs dumb money. Just take the best deal and use the money you saved to hire someone. No amount of "smart" is worth even an extra 0.5% on the cap table. When comparing VCs, I'd like to safe vs dangerous instead. Does a VC have a reputation of creating problems for founders or giving them space even if things aren't going well? That's way more of a consideration than if a VC has better intros or a smarter team.
I respectfully disagree. Your equity is worthless until it’s worth something. That 0.5% could be the difference between a unicorn and a bankruptcy. I would counter with: don’t over value your equity. Don’t make stupid decisions of course but don’t let 0.5% be the reason you fail.
Most ICOs are simply scams and in no way comparable to legitimate investments.