Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by ChuckMcM on Friday March 12, 2021 @08:23PM
(#26443039)
I'm wondering what process uses molten metal. Or if it was another process that ended up creating molten metal (like a battery fire of some sort).
Given the hydraulic fluid mention I was also speculating that a gigapress might be involved.
Like everyone commenting I am always amazed at exothermic events that can't be put out by water or CO2. The only one I've ever seen "in person" (other than the obligatory set some magnesium on fire in chemistry) was a halon dump on an IBM System 370 when the water coolant system burst a pipe and shorted the many bus bars. That one triggered a 15 second siren followed by a halon dump. I found it quite exciting, the plant manager, not so much.
> VAXen, my children, just don't belong some places.
The story involves a VAX 750, and an IBM 3090.
The passage that will get you to start shaking you head is:
> The fire alarm klaxon went off and the siren warning of imminent halon gas release was screaming. We started to panic but the data center manager shouted over the din, ``Don't worry, the halon system failed its acceptance test last week. It's disabled and nothing will happen.''
One of the largest pressing machines in the world. I think it currently presses 1/3 of the frame of a model y but they're hoping to press an entire model Y frame eventually.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:32PM
(#26448145)
Correct, this isn’t mere casting. It is die casting, with really good surface finish (which matters for strength) and good tolerances once you iteratively take warpage into account.
And a big reason they didn’t use this in the past is you’d get bubbles which reduce strength dramatically. But improvements in process tech and ability to use X-rays to do fast, non-destructive evaluation allows near-forged material properties. Better than castings of years past.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:34PM
(#26448159)
Not really any more. X-rays and other process improvements have allowed modern die casting to approach hot forged properties. You don’t get grain flow as good as cold forging, but it’s pretty dang good now.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by olivermarks on Friday March 12, 2021 @08:13PM
(#26442989)
Wondering why Tesla doesn't have fire suppression solutions in place ready for this type of danger. Surely major Class D fire suppression would be a prerequisite for this type of process?
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by xxpor on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:08PM
(#26448510)
Agreed. Class D extinguishers are expensive, but we're talking ~$500 instead of ~$50 for an ABC (obviously depends on size). Both costs are trivial for any manufacturing company, and frankly I'd be shocked if they both weren't required by code.
The only thing that I can think of is perhaps no one noticed until it was too late? And then the employees didn't want to touch it until the fire department showed up. If there was a hydraulic leak, they used the sand bags to stop the spread of the fluid, and then used foam to actually put out the fire? No clue.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by userbinator on Friday March 12, 2021 @11:23PM
(#26443943)
Incidentally, this is why a lot of planes use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skydrol instead of regular mineral-oil-based hydraulic fluid, despite the former being far more irritating for human handling.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by olivermarks on Friday March 12, 2021 @09:27PM
(#26443346)
You'd think fire regulations would need to be adhered to before production was allowed to start. Small businesses have endless compliance check ups for this type of thing and big fines if they don't have safety and fire suppression in order
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by londons_explore on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:48AM
(#26445102)
I suspect the machine itself was also under construction. Someone was probably doing tests on it when it caught fire due to some design issue (like the hydraulic hoses touching the pipes where the molten aluminium flows)
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by justapassenger on Friday March 12, 2021 @10:07PM
(#26443543)
That press in literally in a tent on a parking lot. There’s lots of things that are missing, from what would be considered normal operating conditions for equipment like that.
Silicon Valley spirit of move fast and break things is still strong with them.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by kiallmacinnes on Saturday March 13, 2021 @09:16AM
(#26446695)
Based on the photo above - it's a purpose built structure designed to house that exact machine. What makes you think it doesn't meet the machines operating requirements?
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by joering2 on Friday March 12, 2021 @05:42PM
(#26441859)
Props to Fire Dept. for having some decent response code enforcement - I mean you would never put off a molten metal; it would burn forever, and while you add water to it, it would only expand. AFAIK the only way to put it off is with sand.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by __turbobrew__ on Friday March 12, 2021 @07:39PM
(#26442743)
Class D fire extinguishers can be used to put out metal fires. They are expensive however and not all fire departments have access to them.
Class D fire extinguishers are used at air bases in my country to put out plane fires since our fighter jets are made out of a magnesium alloy which can burn.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by dmlittle on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:08PM
(#26442068)
I was curious as to the reason why water or CO2 can't be used to put off a metal fire. The TL;DR is that with a metal fire the high temperatures cause the H2O and CO2 molecules to be unstable enough that the metal can attract the oxygen molecules to fuel the ongoing fire rendering them useless as a fire suppressors. H2O is even worse as once the oxygen is split from the water molecule you are left with hydrogen which will combust and explosion might cause the molten fire to spread further. This doesn't happen with wood burning as the attraction to the oxygen molecules from the carbon being burnt is the same or stronger than the attraction from the CO2 or H2O molecules.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by DavidPeiffer on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:36PM
(#26442295)
Another big concern is the water turning to steam. It expands 1,000x. 2 cubic centimeters of water expanding to a 2 liter bottle worth of steam. My facility had its own quick response fire unit (production employees who went through fire and rescue training), and I believe the company helped fund a ladder truck for the town of ~600 people which is adjacent to a decent metropolitan area. Fast response is vital to minimize danger to people and damage to the facility.
Factories have been leveled by water hitting molten aluminum. The Hackaday link below does a great job summarizing the dangers.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by myself248 on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:43PM
(#26442359)
We did this in HS chem class, with a block of dry ice that we cut in half and hollowed out. Then we coiled up some magnesium ribbon so it would perch in the hole, lit it with a MAPP gas torch, and closed the block. The magnesium continued to burn long after any lingering air in the hollow could've been consumed. After a few minutes the magnesium was gone and we opened the block, and there was black carbon dust in the bottom of the hollow.
And that introduced the conversation about using the right extinguisher for the job!
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by jseutter on Friday March 12, 2021 @10:59PM
(#26443826)
Nitrogen wouldn't work in this situation. In fact nitrogen and aluminum will burn, forming AlN. Normally this doesn't happen because of Aluminum readily forms a "rust" layer in the presence of oxygen, and there isn't enough heat. Molten aluminum in a pure nitrogen environment wouldn't have that layer, and there likely would be enough heat.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by pmiller2 on Friday March 12, 2021 @10:30PM
(#26443652)
Probably not. Nitrogen is roughly the same density as air. It would just get dispersed into the atmosphere before it could do much, unless you had insane amounts of it.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by d110af5ccf on Friday March 12, 2021 @11:31PM
(#26443974)
> very large
It depends on how large, what temperature, and what type of metal. If there's enough latent heat in the quantity of metal to flash boil a significant fraction of the water, you're going to have a bad time. If you're literally dropping it in the ocean on the other hand, then you'll get a brief but impressive geyser and the fire will go out.
(Unless this is an alkali metal we're talking about. In that case you'll just get a "vigorous reaction" of a size proportional to the quantity of metal. Ex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cc6W6SptLvU)
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by sriram_sun on Friday March 12, 2021 @07:08PM
(#26442515)
> H2O is even worse as once the oxygen is split from the water molecule you are left with hydrogen which will combust and explosion might cause the molten fire to spread even farther
Yup, this is why you never douse an oil fire (say in the kitchen) with water. The fire will erupt! Seen it happen live. Fortunately the damage wasn't bad. One third-degree burn.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by sonofhans on Friday March 12, 2021 @07:17PM
(#26442582)
A kitchen oil fire is a different effect. They're not hot enough to disassociate water molecules. What happens typically is that the water floats the oil, and the fire, remaining on top of the oil, spreads more rapidly.
Another effect is when the fire (and typically, the cooking vessel) are hot enough to vaporize the water. This rapid vaporization spreads oil droplets rapidly, allowing much more of the oil to burn at once. It can appear explosive, even though it's just rapidly-expanding steam spreading fine oil droplets.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday March 12, 2021 @08:10PM
(#26442969)
I'd agree that it's explosive. I suspect they were trying to make a distinction between a detonation and a deflagration. A detonation is an explosion with a supersonic shock wave. A deflagration is an explosion without such a shock wave. An oil fire getting water dumped on it is a deflagration, but almost certainly not a detonation. A metal fire getting water dumped on it can result in a detonation. Detonations are vastly more destructive in general than deflagrations.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by quickthrowman on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:08PM
(#26442063)
> I mean you would never put off a molten metal; it would burn forever
I doubt that, if it burned forever you could use it to heat water and spin a turbine and produce free power. If you meant “forever” as “a long time”, then sure :P
It would eventually cool down after removing the source of heat keeping the metal molten, which are electric resistive heating elements (assuming it works like an aluminum smelter).
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by dmlittle on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:10PM
(#26442079)
It would burn until all the metal has reacted. I think the point is that due to its chemical properties what you're using to try to "extinguish" the fire is actually fueling the reaction so not forever but you're certainly not helping.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by shagie on Friday March 12, 2021 @09:14PM
(#26443290)
> Be warned: the "Things I Won't Work With" category is entertaining and can easily take up an evening of your time.
Don't forget the "Things I’m Glad I Don’t Do" category with such gems as "There’s Toxicity, And There’s Toxicity." Not as many posts as "Things I Won't Work With", but enough amusement for few good reads.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by mindcrime on Friday March 12, 2021 @08:23PM
(#26443036)
Handling flammable metals fires by burying the fire load in sand is not uncommon. As other people have mentioned, there are special extinguishing agents out there that handle flammable metals (Class D) fires, but they're expensive, and not all fire departments have them. And many departments that don't specialize in industrial response may have a Class D extinguisher or two, but nowhere near enough extinguishing agent to handle a large fire.
OTOH, large industrial plants often have their on on-site fire brigades that have specialized equipment and training specifically around the unique hazards found at their facilities. Not sure what the situation was here at the Tesla plant. But I can say that if my old volunteer department in a mostly rural part of NC had ever encountered a large flammable metals fire (the most likely scenario would probably have involved something in transport, and a motor vehicle collision), we would almost certainly have started requesting dump truck loads of sand, and a front-end loader.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by jdavis703 on Friday March 12, 2021 @06:55PM
(#26442432)
My understanding from talking with firefighters is large industrial plants, major apartment complexes etc give the local fire department tours and discuss special circumstances of their building.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by convolvatron on Friday March 12, 2021 @07:10PM
(#26442535)
even tiny little light industrial shops have an ongoing conversation and yearly inspection with the fire department about doors, locks, stairs, extinguishers, chemicals, flammables, aisles, accessibility, sprinkler coverage, signage, bottled gas storage, electrical, etc. etc.
as a solo operator its a huge pita. I do appreciate that these people are putting their lives at risk, so I suck it up (don't have much of a choice actually)
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by monksy on Saturday March 13, 2021 @09:36PM
(#26452284)
Politically Texas attempts to avoid regulating industries. I don't believe that it is unreasonable to consider if the area in which the factory is being built may not have the strongest requirements and preparations by the local emergency services.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by mindcrime on Friday March 12, 2021 @08:19PM
(#26443012)
Are you saying ICE cars aren't at risk of incidental fire from other [burning] cars, what with their 10+ gallon gasoline tanks?
They definitely are (source: former firefighter here), but a deck full of Teslas's is more of a problem for the FD in some regards, than a corresponding deck full of ICE cars. The reason being, Teslas are known to be hard to extinguish when they burn, and are apparently prone to rekindles. I don't remember the exact number, but I seem to recall hearing that Tesla recommend flowing water on a burning Tesla for somewhere around 10 hours in order to cool it sufficiently to avoid a rekindle.
An average car fire (depending on certain details) can be taken care of in somewhere around an hour, from start to finish. So a bunch of Teslas on fire would require more resources committed for more time, which would possibly impinge on the ability of the FD to handle other calls.
Edit: here's the Tesla Emergency Response Guide[1].
According to the "Firefighting" section:
Battery fires can take up to 24 hours to extinguish. Consider allowing the battery to burn while protecting exposures.
Re:CA crews handle tricky fire at Tesla factory
by userbinator on Friday March 12, 2021 @09:37PM
(#26443390)
Gasoline and diesel (which is harder to ignite) need a source of ignition to start burning, whereas a lithium ion battery can supply its own. The latter being a solid also means heat can build up deep inside a damaged battery pack enough to cause reignition.
Given the hydraulic fluid mention I was also speculating that a gigapress might be involved.
Like everyone commenting I am always amazed at exothermic events that can't be put out by water or CO2. The only one I've ever seen "in person" (other than the obligatory set some magnesium on fire in chemistry) was a halon dump on an IBM System 370 when the water coolant system burst a pipe and shorted the many bus bars. That one triggered a 15 second siren followed by a halon dump. I found it quite exciting, the plant manager, not so much.
I am reminded of The Vax War - https://www.hactrn.net/sra/vaxen.html
Some may recall its opening (and closing) line:
> VAXen, my children, just don't belong some places.
The story involves a VAX 750, and an IBM 3090.
The passage that will get you to start shaking you head is:
> The fire alarm klaxon went off and the siren warning of imminent halon gas release was screaming. We started to panic but the data center manager shouted over the din, ``Don't worry, the halon system failed its acceptance test last week. It's disabled and nothing will happen.''
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giga_Press
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giga_Press
One of the largest pressing machines in the world. I think it currently presses 1/3 of the frame of a model y but they're hoping to press an entire model Y frame eventually.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoa_50,000_ton_forging_pre...
What is special about the GigaPress die casting?
You don't get that high tolerances with casting the bigger you go. Thermal warpage needs correction, and there is only so much you can correct.
But the machine in question is used for a process much closer to injection molding than casting.
MIM is somewhat better with warpage
And a big reason they didn’t use this in the past is you’d get bubbles which reduce strength dramatically. But improvements in process tech and ability to use X-rays to do fast, non-destructive evaluation allows near-forged material properties. Better than castings of years past.
The industry after all spent a century working with it.
Aluminium alloys bring along own problems, but otherwise unbeatable on weight even if very weight inefficient methods are used, like casting.
It's a very complicated compromise even if economics is not involved.
Possibly the most extreme being chlorine triflouride, so reactive it's a better oxidiser than oxygen, as a result it can burn sand:
https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2008/02/26/sa...
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0173/8204/7844/articles/1_...
Casting
https://www.elitefire.co.uk/help-advice/detect-and-extinguis...
Everyone down thread is commenting like the aluminum caught fire. That's not what the article says:
"A piece of machinery containing molten metal caught fire"
It's really hard to get aluminum hot enough to combust if it's in a big blob. Powder on the other hand...
https://youtu.be/aj8-JlRqoWc
If you have molten metals class D powder suppression is needed. I'm amazed the old NUMI plant doesn't have both ready for action.
The only thing that I can think of is perhaps no one noticed until it was too late? And then the employees didn't want to touch it until the fire department showed up. If there was a hydraulic leak, they used the sand bags to stop the spread of the fluid, and then used foam to actually put out the fire? No clue.
Silicon Valley spirit of move fast and break things is still strong with them.
See: https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0173/8204/7844/articles/3_...
Class D fire extinguishers are used at air bases in my country to put out plane fires since our fighter jets are made out of a magnesium alloy which can burn.
Factories have been leveled by water hitting molten aluminum. The Hackaday link below does a great job summarizing the dangers.
https://hackaday.com/2020/12/30/water-and-molten-aluminium-i...
Explosion links:
https://youtu.be/sIJmwF1Qs7M
https://youtu.be/jvddrln900Q (last ~20 seconds)
Source: Used to work at a very large aluminum facility.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonium_perchlorate_composi...
And that introduced the conversation about using the right extinguisher for the job!
It depends on how large, what temperature, and what type of metal. If there's enough latent heat in the quantity of metal to flash boil a significant fraction of the water, you're going to have a bad time. If you're literally dropping it in the ocean on the other hand, then you'll get a brief but impressive geyser and the fire will go out.
(Unless this is an alkali metal we're talking about. In that case you'll just get a "vigorous reaction" of a size proportional to the quantity of metal. Ex: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cc6W6SptLvU)
Also alkali metals is fun
https://youtu.be/I8tOtZKpi04
Yup, this is why you never douse an oil fire (say in the kitchen) with water. The fire will erupt! Seen it happen live. Fortunately the damage wasn't bad. One third-degree burn.
Another effect is when the fire (and typically, the cooking vessel) are hot enough to vaporize the water. This rapid vaporization spreads oil droplets rapidly, allowing much more of the oil to burn at once. It can appear explosive, even though it's just rapidly-expanding steam spreading fine oil droplets.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i20zvZ-3MMw
Note the initial dispersion of some atomized material followed by a triggered explosion some time later.
I doubt that, if it burned forever you could use it to heat water and spin a turbine and produce free power. If you meant “forever” as “a long time”, then sure :P
It would eventually cool down after removing the source of heat keeping the metal molten, which are electric resistive heating elements (assuming it works like an aluminum smelter).
https://www.livescience.com/65515-chernobyl-in-modern-times-...
Be warned: the "Things I Won't Work With" category is entertaining and can easily take up an evening of your time.
Don't forget the "Things I’m Glad I Don’t Do" category with such gems as "There’s Toxicity, And There’s Toxicity." Not as many posts as "Things I Won't Work With", but enough amusement for few good reads.
https://archive.org/details/ignition_201612/mode/2up
OTOH, large industrial plants often have their on on-site fire brigades that have specialized equipment and training specifically around the unique hazards found at their facilities. Not sure what the situation was here at the Tesla plant. But I can say that if my old volunteer department in a mostly rural part of NC had ever encountered a large flammable metals fire (the most likely scenario would probably have involved something in transport, and a motor vehicle collision), we would almost certainly have started requesting dump truck loads of sand, and a front-end loader.
as a solo operator its a huge pita. I do appreciate that these people are putting their lives at risk, so I suck it up (don't have much of a choice actually)
Departments will develop “pre-plans” for any large buildings, industrial buildings, etc.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explos...
https://electrek.co/2020/09/09/tesla-deploying-second-giga-p...
I don't think the die-casting machine is "under construction". It seems like they intend to leave it out there.
I remember seeing some news when it was operational a few weeks ago.
Feb 8: https://youtu.be/hF_oRMIY9tk?t=363
Battery fires are notoriously difficult to extinguish.
They definitely are (source: former firefighter here), but a deck full of Teslas's is more of a problem for the FD in some regards, than a corresponding deck full of ICE cars. The reason being, Teslas are known to be hard to extinguish when they burn, and are apparently prone to rekindles. I don't remember the exact number, but I seem to recall hearing that Tesla recommend flowing water on a burning Tesla for somewhere around 10 hours in order to cool it sufficiently to avoid a rekindle.
An average car fire (depending on certain details) can be taken care of in somewhere around an hour, from start to finish. So a bunch of Teslas on fire would require more resources committed for more time, which would possibly impinge on the ability of the FD to handle other calls.
Edit: here's the Tesla Emergency Response Guide[1].
According to the "Firefighting" section:
Battery fires can take up to 24 hours to extinguish. Consider allowing the battery to burn while protecting exposures.
[1]: https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/downloads/2016_Mod...