News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simias on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:37AM (#25289210)
I've never owned a Mac and don't intend to own one but I'm very happy with this M1 move, mainly for the reasons highlighted in the introduction to the article:

>M1 Macs embarrass all other PCs — all Intel-based Macs, including automobile-priced Mac Pros, and every single machine running Windows or Linux. Those machines are just standing around in their underwear now because the M1 stole all their pants.

I think it's a bit unfair to lump Linux in there since it's been running on ARM and other embedded, low-power devices basically forever, but it is true that few of us run our Linux desktop on an ARM board.

But I think the overarching point is true: now desktop and laptop makers can't just pretend that having a hot and/or slow, clunky, noisy x86-based architecture is just a fact of life. I hope and expect that it'll help create a new generation of ARM-based laptops and maybe even desktops that will run cool and smooth.

I want to believe.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:34PM (#25292626)
> I think it's a bit unfair to lump Linux in there since it's been running on ARM and other embedded, low-power devices basically forever, but it is true that few of us run our Linux desktop on an ARM board.

We aren't running ARM on our desktops because there aren't ARM desktops for us to use. The market jumps from low-end boards like the Pi and Pine's lineups - which are excellent for what they are, but suffer from poor performance and I/O - to the high end where ex. https://www.asacomputers.com/Cavium-ThunderX-ARM.html looks like a nice system but $2,820 is a bit of a barrier to entry.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:29PM (#25293421)
> We aren't running ARM on our desktops because there aren't ARM desktops for us to use.

Indeed, while ARM based Linux desktops hit the price and energy efficiency on the nose, they aren't going to wow anyone with performance.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:28PM (#25294308)
Exactly! I would love to switch my systems off of x86, but I can't buy anything performant for a price that I'm willing to spend on hardware. I might yet try a Pi 4 as a desktop with USB for disk, but that's hacky and still suffers from performance problems. Or, I could get something with good performance, either POWER or ARM, but then I'd have to pay through the nose for the privilege. Now, some of this is market size: I get my x86 boxes at a huge discount by buying used, and high-end ARM/POWER machines aren't popular enough to really show up on eBay (yet). But in practice, there's just no good options.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by koffiezet on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:41AM (#25302685)
The thing is not just "ARM", it's Apple's implementation. Their A* mobile cpu lineup destroys any competing mobile ARM CPU, and the M1 evolved from that. So just running ARM isn't going to save anyone.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by maximilianburke on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:45PM (#25294578)
The ThunderX is also, what, 4-5 years old now? There are no ThunderX3 desktops, are there?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by s3cur3 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:04AM (#25289475)
It's not just "ARM is fast," though—Apple's ARM chips in particular beat the pants off their ARM competitors. (See benchmarks of any iPhone compared to flagship Android devices.) I don't think you should expect similar levels of performance from a run-of-the-mill ARM chip on the desktop (though I'm happy to be shown benchmarks to the contrary).
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by colinmhayes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:36PM (#25292644)
Probably because there's basically no competition in the ARM space, especially in non-mobile. I'd like to see what amd and intel can do with ARM before saying apple will continue to be king.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mlyle on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:42PM (#25292732)
Qualcomm, Samsung, Cavium/Marvell, and nVidia don't count? Not to mention ARM's own cores...
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wmf on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:32PM (#25293459)
They don't count in the PC space. For desktop PCs there's just the Mac mini and various hacker boards. For laptops there's the new MacBooks and the mediocre Qualcomm 8cx/SQ2 and nothing else.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ghettoimp on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:59PM (#25293874)
For other ARM manufacturers, I wonder how much of this is a software problem.

I mean, what would the market be for a super-fast ARM laptop/desktop machine? It would run Windows RT, I guess?

How much better than Intel/AMD would the ARM machine need to be to justify buying it and running that? It seems like the M1's "magic" is not just the chip, but very much also the Rosetta thing.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nordsieck on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:12PM (#25297783)
> For other ARM manufacturers, I wonder how much of this is a software problem.

IMO, one of the key innovations Apple made in the M1 is a modification to the memory model so that it is much more efficient to translate x86 code into ARM code.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sgerenser on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:17PM (#25297394)
Windows RT doesn't exist anymore. Now its Windows ARM, which is basically 100% fully featured Windows with the exception that x86 apps have to be run in emulation and x86-64 apps don't run at all (yet).
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mlyle on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:56PM (#25294787)
No one said "in the PC space" here.

There's lots of credible ARM work in both the mobile and the server space. Generally, a lot of it would work OK in the PC space, but for the lack of software support. Apple has the ability to leapfrog that particular problem.

Still, Apple seems to have done pretty well compared to both the other mobile and server ARM vendors with their PC offering.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by r00fus on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:30PM (#25295320)
This whole article and thread are about the desktop (not server) space.

I do agree that Apple's push to ARM for laptops will have a dramatic impact on the server space in a year or two. Intel is in for a world of hurt unless they can pull a rabbit out of their hat.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:44PM (#25308517)
Dunno, seems more like now. Amazon has arm instances, there's a bunch of arm systems in the server space already and the world's fastest HPC cluster is already arm.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cestith on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:53PM (#25293777)
There's Exynos.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wmf on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:17PM (#25294145)
No, there aren't any PCs running Exynos.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cestith on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:38AM (#25302647)
That's true if you consider Chromebooks not to be PC-class machines.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by vetinari on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:56PM (#25293826)
Exynos is dead.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by vetinari on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:55PM (#25293818)
Samsung stopped Exynos development a year ago. Cavium is basically dead (yes, bought out by Marvell). Qualcomm is interested only in mobile SoCs at mobile SoCs volumes where they can also sell radios, and Nvidia was traditionally not capable of delivering anything at promised power consumption.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by x87678r on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:50PM (#25298363)
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by jcheng on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:05PM (#25293963)
Are you sure about Exynos? They announced the 1080 just a couple of weeks ago and the 2100 is expected next year.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by vetinari on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:13PM (#25294087)
This is from wikipedia (under "Exynos"), so apply the appropriate amount of salt:

On October 1, 2019, rumors emerged that Samsung had laid off their custom CPU teams at SARC.[21][22][23] On November 1, 2019, Samsung filed a WARN letter with the Texas Workforce Commission, notifying of upcoming layoffs of their SARC CPU team and termination of their custom CPU development.[24] SARC and ACL will still continue development of custom SoC, AI, and GPU.[25]

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wmf on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:29PM (#25294317)
You misunderstood what that means. Samsung is continuing to develop Exynos SoCs using stock Arm CPU cores and AMD GPU cores. This will require fewer people hence the layoff.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by vetinari on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:47PM (#25294617)
Exactly; they do not have their cores anymore, they are going to use ARM's Cortex. So their SoC will be always average at best, by definition. They won't be able to make anything exceptional.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by andor on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:35PM (#25295424)
HiSilicon's Kirin chips use Cortex microarchitecture and are very competitive. I didn't follow recent releases, but I remember that the Kirin 970 was way ahead of the Snapdragon and Exynos chips at the time, both in terms of performance and power efficiency.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by fomine3 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:02PM (#25298081)
Huawei often releases new Kirin SoC on October with Mate series meanwhile Qualcomm reseases flagship Snapdragon 8xx on December, so Kirin outperform latest Snapdragon that released on last year.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by GekkePrutser on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:21PM (#25294202)
Samsung stopped developing their custom cores. They will still continue making Exynos, but with reference design ARM cores.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by vetinari on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:48PM (#25294639)
Yes, and their SoCs will be as average as Cortex reference implementation can be. They won't be able to make M1-like SoC.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by erk__ on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:02PM (#25293916)
And Fujutsu as well, I think they are making the fastests chips at the moment, or at least the fastest systems with ARM.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simias on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:07AM (#25290260)
Apple's ARM SoCs are definitely ahead, but it's not like the competition is hugely far behind. Top of the line Android phones and tablets perform well enough for most desktop tasks IMO. It's mostly the software and I/O that makes them unusable as such.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by zepto on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:22AM (#25290464)
The numbers say otherwise.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ChrisLTD on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:17PM (#25292370)
The numbers show that the other chips are slower, but they don't show that they are "unusable".
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by unsigner on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:39PM (#25292698)
Put it this way: if the new Macs had the performance of the fastest Qualcomm ARM cores available today, we wouldn’t be having this conversation now.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wk_end on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:38PM (#25292673)
x86 chips aren’t “unusable” either, and if these other ARM chips wanted to compete in the desktop space they’d be just as - or more - “hot and/or slow, clunky, noisy”. ISA just doesn’t matter half as much as microarchitecture.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by egsmi on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:41PM (#25293618)
And those x86 are only still usable because M1 hasn’t been out long enough for the new software, that needs the speed to be “useable”, to be written.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mixmastamyk on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:07PM (#25297738)
5nm process would help a lot.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:30PM (#25293424)
When iPhone came out in 2007, Android was still an OS for BlackBerry like devices. It didn't take long for Android to discover touch screens once Apple made it clear that they were dramatically better. Similarly, it's not like other ARM chip manufacturers are going to have to go through all of the same R&D expense to figure out how to make chips that are comparably fast--they just need to copy what Apple did without infringing on any particular patents. Even if they did have to spend the same R&D expense to get there, Apple has already derisked it. So they have a small fraction of Apple's expense and none of the risk, so I would fully expect to see M1 competitive chips come out in a few years' time. This isn't to say that they'll catch up with Apple completely; only that they'll be able to recoup a significant amount of the gap in a relatively short period of time such that there will be a similar breakthrough in the PC market (this is effectively what TFA is predicting as well, if that lends me any credibility).
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by buran77 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:17PM (#25294151)
> it's not like other ARM chip manufacturers are going to have to go through all of the same R&D expense to figure out how to make chips that are comparably fast--they just need to copy what Apple did without infringing on any particular patents

Very handwaivy but the devil is in the details of that "all they have to do". Copying success is not that straight forward or else AMD would have had a response to Conroe in 2007, Intel for Zen in 2018, and Qualcomm for A-chips around 2014.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by snazz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:38PM (#25293548)
In my opinion, Apple "derisked" high-performance ARM chips with the A9-ish era five years ago. Other companies have had a long time to spend catching up to Apple mobile chips, and they haven't.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:48PM (#25294644)
That's a completely reasonable challenge, and I might be wrong. My very amateur speculation is that, in the mobile space, Apple got incrementally better over time. Rank-and-file Android users didn't really notice the performance gap and thus didn't demand faster chips. M1 changed expectations for the laptop market virtually overnight, and rank-and-file users will expect M1 performance, battery life, etc. I think this represents an enormous market opportunity for PC manufacturers and thus chip suppliers that didn't really exist circa A9.

My key assumption is that there's some pareto principle at play--80% of the M1's performance gains over the next best generic ARM chip are due to a handful of key innovations while the remaining 20% come from a long tail of incremental improvements. This would mean that generic manufacturers could copy those handful of key innovations (modulo IP rights, which might be another fatal flaw in my speculation) and recoup 80% of that performance gap in just a few years. If that assumption is bad and the performance is entirely an accumulation of lots of minor innovations over time, then I suspect it will take chip manufacturers quite a lot longer to catch up.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by spfzero on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:41PM (#25295513)
There's more to it than chip design though. There is the OS work to take advantage of the chip's new features. And designing new chip features to accommodate sw bottlenecks. Apple has very close collaboration between software and hardware engineering, while in the competitive space, those two things are not under the same roof. Makes it tougher.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:10PM (#25295886)
True, and I don’t expect generic manufacturers to completely close the gap between them and Apple, but I do expect there will be enough to copy that we’ll still see a step change in PC performance.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ndiddy on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:11PM (#25294052)
Qualcomm has been unable to compete with Apple's ARM phone processors for years. It's gotten to the point that the only processor that comes close to a new Apple SOC on benchmarks is Apple's previous SOC. Why do you expect the PC market will be different than the phone market?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by fomine3 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:05PM (#25298095)
Because now Qualcomm just use (or modifying a bit, like cache capacity) Cortex-A CPU core design. Both Intel and AMD designs own core.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hsitz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:16PM (#25295963)
> When iPhone came out in 2007, Android was still an OS for BlackBerry like devices.

When iPhone came out in 2007, Android did not even exist. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Phrodo_00 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:51PM (#25297144)
How is that any true? From the article:

> An early prototype had a close resemblance to a BlackBerry phone, with no touchscreen and a physical QWERTY keyboard, but the arrival of 2007's Apple iPhone meant that Android "had to go back to the drawing board".

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:45PM (#25298007)
Your own source contradicts you.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hsitz on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:10AM (#25299208)
I'm not sure how. iPhone was available in June 2007. Android went into public beta in November 2007, and reached 1.0 and was first released in a commercial device in September 2008. [1]

I guess Android, or what morphed into Android, was probably being developed, in a pre-beta state, when iPhone was announced in January 2007. Okay. It sounded to me like someone was saying that Android was released on Blackberry-like phones at the time iPhone came out. That was only thing i was objecting to. Sorry, a small point I almost didn't even bother to make, and probably not helpful to anybody, anyway.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_version_history

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by scarface74 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:32PM (#25293454)
If it were so easy, why are all of the other ARM manufacturers years behind?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simias on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:01PM (#25292980)
To be clear I'm not talking benchmarks, I have no idea what the raw numbers are. I'm talking about my personal experience using ARM SoCs. Specifically I've worked with Tegra chip and they're powerhouses for instance, I could definitely see myself do my day-to-day development on such a chip.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by adkadskhj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:34PM (#25293470)
Do they? Because i have yet to see any numbers that aren't clearly the result of a massively streamlined SoC. Yes the ARM chip is great, but the RAM is blazing, tiny, and more close to the ARM chip than anything out there for x86, right?

I'll be interested to see if Apple can keep this up with 128GiB of RAM and a beefy GPU.

So far to me M1 is great, ARM is great, but comparing a tiny amount of RAM soldered onto the CPU compared to flexible and huge RAM potential devices seems dishonest. Unless Apple manages to squeeze 128GiB of RAM on their chip, at least.

I want to see what my Blender workstation looks like on Apple's Architecture. Where i purpose built a huge CPU, GPU, and RAM for Blender rendering and large scenes. I suspect Apple will start seeing huge falloffs in the SoC design under larger workloads.

Apple is dominant in making phones though. And this Laptop is designed like a Phone. So yea, it's amazing for that.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by spijdar on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:45PM (#25293659)
Architectural analysis of the chip [0] suggests it is a massive improvement as a general purpose CPU, not just because of Apple's vertical integration and streamlining.

The magnitude of extra ROB entries, having an 8x wide instruction decoder, that massive L1I cache, and such fat cores with lots of ALU and other op units while simultaneously keeping over a 3GHz clock is a phenomenal architectural improvement overall.

Apple may not need to add more RAM locally. Other silicon designers like IBM with POWER10 are moving to serial memory with massive "L4" caches, seen previously with their Centaur memory controllers. I can see Apple using OMI or a similar serial memory bus to add extra memory, using 16/32/etc GB of PoP RAM for caching reads and writes to slower off-chip memory. I expect Intel and AMD will eventually move to a similar memory model, at least in server grade hardware.

[0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-de...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by adkadskhj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:50PM (#25293729)
Yea and to be clear i'm not saying it's not awesome. I'm just saying that a lot of things - like real world benchmarks of programs/etc - massively benefit from the proximity and speed of the RAM. Proximity seems to be a very difficult beast to scale. Works great in small scale, horrible in large scale.

Sidenote, even if Apple rolled out 128GiB tomorrow i probably couldn't afford it. As the OP says:

> including automobile-priced Mac Pros

That's rough.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by spijdar on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:04PM (#25293934)
Hypothetically, with these new memory architectures, you could get the best of both worlds. Best case, you get a huge speed up if everything fits in the high-speed RAM, worst case, you fall back to the "old" RAM.

Side note, while Apple charges ridiculous prices for their upgrades, Mac Pros are actually some of the more ""reasonably priced"" computers comparatively. I've looked at HP and Lenovo's equiv. workstations, and you pretty much get screwed by everyone at that scale.

My desktop can take up to dual 128 GB sticks but one stick costs over $1,000, so I'm stuck with my 32 GB stick :(

... OTOH, it's pretty insane you can get 128GB of RAM for $1,000 nowadays. I remember when 8GB was a lot and cost several hundred. Time and miniaturization go on I guess...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by rootusrootus on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:51PM (#25293754)
> RAM soldered onto the CPU

It's just very close to the CPU, on the same package. It's not on the same die or anything. There are laptops that already have a shorter physical path to RAM than the M1 MacBooks, stacking the RAM right next to the CPU is common.

So it's just a matter of time before >16GB is available with an M1. These are just entry level machines in the first round.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by adkadskhj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:53PM (#25295687)
> It's just very close to the CPU, on the same package. It's not on the same die or anything.

Yea, i was just simplifying. Though in SoC i think that's a perfectly fine simplification lol.

> So it's just a matter of time before >16GB is available with an M1. These are just entry level machines in the first round.

Think there will be > 32GiB?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by saagarjha on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:16PM (#25297386)
Almost certainly, although maybe not immediately.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by rsfinn on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:35PM (#25298274)
I know I'm probably older than most people here, but the notion that 16 GiB is "a tiny amount of RAM" is tremendously amusing to someone who paid $740 in 1986 (with a developer's discount) for 2 "MB" of RAM (we didn't have MiB back then)...
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by redler on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:08AM (#25299527)
To be fair, we sort of still don't have MiB even now.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mixmastamyk on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:12PM (#25297785)
Let the Pro devices come out next year.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by HJain13 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:03AM (#25290198)
It depends on what you're comparing: A14 on phones have a Multi Core score which would be quite comparable to Snapdragon 888 (extrapolating a 20% boost over SD865) that was just announced all while A14 being clocked higher (3.0ghz 4 core vs 2.84 x 1, 3 x 2.4) comparing performance cores. Single thread OTOH Apple wins comfortably but I would suspect X1 to reduce the lead a bit. As for AI performance Apple claimed 11 TOPs, while Qualcomm claims 25 TOPs
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by jcheng on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:13PM (#25294073)
A14 has two performance cores.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:41PM (#25292717)
> But I think the overarching point is true: now desktop and laptop makers can't just pretend that having a hot and/or slow, clunky, noisy x86-based architecture is just a fact of life. I hope and expect that it'll help create a new generation of ARM-based laptops and maybe even desktops that will run cool and smooth.

Be careful what you wish for. X86 is the most open architecture right now. ARM, on the other hand, has locked bootloaders, messy device trees and so on. You can see that virtually every Linux distro running on an ARM SOC needs some specific tweaks.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:34PM (#25293472)
> X86 is the most open architecture right now.

x86 is not "Open" in any fashion. You can't license x86 even for a fee, let alone free.

While ARM isn't open either, it is by comparison far more available to license at reasonable cost.

> ARM, on the other hand, has locked bootloaders

It also has open/ unlocked boot loaders. One of the advantages of licensable technology like this is you can have a lot of different architectures with the same underlying core. With x86, you get whatever the Intel/ AMD duopoly decide to ship you.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by AsyncAwait on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:41PM (#25293602)
> x86 is not "Open" in any fashion. You can't license x86 even for a fee, let alone free.

OP is not talking about being able to manufacture x86 CPUs kind of open, that's useless for most folks.

They're talking about being able to install any OS, drivers being fairly universal, no device specific out of tree kernel patches for the vast majority of PCs, no device trees etc.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:47PM (#25293688)
It's a lousy use of the word "Open" in a discipline where Open has a fairly specific meaning.

I mentioned that as well though. Using your goofy definition of Open, x86 is no more "Open" than ARM. Pinebook and Raspberry Pi both use no bullshit ARM setups. With ARM, how accessible the architecture is is 100% dependent on the implementation which vary greatly by manufacturer.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by heavyset_go on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:46PM (#25295585)
> x86 is no more "Open" than ARM. Pinebook and Raspberry Pi both use no bullshit ARM setups.

They're ARM SoCs, meaning that you can't just download the Ubuntu ARM ISO[1] and run it on either device like you could with an x86 ISO and an x86 machine.

To run Ubuntu or any Linux distribution, you need to use images that were specially crafted for either SoC.

This is because ARM SoCs use custom bootloaders and don't have hardware on enumerable buses. Each SoC model is essentially a unique hardware configuration that needs an individual Linux port.

ARM servers are more similar to x86 machines in that they use UEFI and have enumerable buses.

As long as machines are shipped that use ARM SoCs, Linux support for all of them will be quite difficult to achieve[2] compared to x86 machines.

[1] https://ubuntu.com/download/server/arm

[2] https://elinux.org/images/a/ad/Arm-soc-checklist.pdf

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by chipotle_coyote on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:19PM (#25296019)
While Apple likely has no motivation currently to make a UEFI-based ARM computer, there's nothing that prevent anyone else from doing so. UEFI is not x86-specific.

(I also think it's a bit too early to say definitively that no ARM-based Apple computer will ever be able to boot into Linux. I don't think Apple has any motivation to make that easy, but that may not be the same as making it impossible.)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by SulfurHexaFluri on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:50PM (#25298025)
There is also nothing pushing OEMs to do this and in the decades we have had ARM SoCs we have not seen this happen.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by kuhsaft on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:36PM (#25298594)
Windows Mobile/phones actually had UEFI bootloaders with Windows Boot Manager [1]. For some Windows mobile devices, people have managed to unlock the bootloaders and load other EFI applications.

[1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/br...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by kuhsaft on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:42PM (#25298629)
UEFI can be just as closed as custom non-UEFI bootloaders. Windows Mobile devices were UEFI, but they had Secure Boot enabled making it almost impossible to boot non-OEM signed images. (Un)fortunately, their Golden Key was leaked allowing experimentation with some Windows Mobile devices [1].

[1] https://www.xda-developers.com/microsofts-debug-mode-flaw-an...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by heavyset_go on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:06PM (#25296648)
It's cheaper to just design a ARM SoC with a custom bootloader.

> I also think it's a bit too early to say definitively that no ARM-based Apple computer will ever be able to boot into Linux.

There's a big difference between a SoC running a Linux fork and actually running Linux distributions in the same sense that we can on x86 computers or ARM servers.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by AsyncAwait on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:23PM (#25294236)
> Using your goofy definition of Open

If I buy any x86 PC, chances are I can install mainline Linux on it. Picking up any particular recent ARM SoC and the chance of doing so is much, much less. The M1 included, after all.

> Pinebook and Raspberry Pi both use no bullshit ARM setups.

Both of these took considerably longer to get mainline support that your average x86 hardware needs.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:02PM (#25294870)
> Both of these took considerably longer to get mainline support that your average x86 hardware needs.

Not sure what you are thinking here. It's taken 25 years so far and we still have tons of x86 hardware which isn't supported well in Linux. There is a reason Dell ships a specific laptop for developers with Linux pre-installed.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by AsyncAwait on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:12PM (#25295012)
> There is a reason Dell ships a specific laptop for developers with Linux pre-installed.

And yet, even Windows DELL laptops are more likely to run mainline Linux than any average ARM SoC, even including the ones targeted at developers.

I am no fan of x86, but trading what we have now for an M1 is a net loss in terms of our ability to install anything we want as users, no question.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:20PM (#25295149)
Consider for a moment how many independent developers rely on x86 based Linux systems versus ARM. x86 isn't open, Linux's support for it is a symptom of Intel's monopoly.

> And yet, even Windows DELL laptops are more likely to run mainline Linux than any average ARM SoC, even including the ones targeted at developers.

This is more about inertia and developer resources than openness. The more developers you have on ARM, the faster device and software support will come.

> I am no fan of x86, but trading what we have now for an M1 is a net loss in terms of our ability to install anything we want as users, no question.

You've changed the question here. We were speaking about ARM in general, not the M1.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:08PM (#25309551)
Well there's two issues there. One is if the bootloader is open, which it is.

The second is if there's linux port for that hardware, which it isn't. There's a project underway, seems likely that the CPU (which is still AARCH64) will work, and likely networking. However to make a usable desktop you'll need a GPU which is much harder.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:53PM (#25298038)
> Raspberry Pi both use no bullshit ARM setups.

Seriously? You need a blob from Broadcom to even boot the thing, and you call that a no bullshit ARM setup? I am astounded.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:46PM (#25298340)
Compared to the amount of bullshit we had to to deal with in the 90s and 00s getting Linux running on a laptop, it's a walk in the park. Often it was a choice between mediocre FLOSS drivers or binary blobs from 2-3 private parties... when things even had drivers at all. It's been a while, but how many laptops lack wifi support or require proprietary drivers to work now?

Are the FLOSS drivers for Nvidia's cards great now? How many years have people been hacking on that project to make them work as well as they do?

What people are describing as "Open" is actually an enormous amount of work on the part of developers and the grudging support of hardware vendors after decades of struggle.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:48AM (#25302772)
> It's been a while, but how many laptops lack wifi support or require proprietary drivers to work now?

Very few actually.

> Are the FLOSS drivers for Nvidia's cards great now?

Don't shift goalposts, we are talking about CPU support, not GPUs... GPU support on ARM is anyway not that great to begin with.

> What people are describing as "Open" is actually an enormous amount of work on the part of developers and the grudging support of hardware vendors after decades of struggle.

Intel has Linux dedicated teams at least, pushing FOSS code every single day. Most ARM licensees could not care one bit about FOSS.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:22PM (#25305045)
> Don't shift goalposts, we are talking about CPU support

Linux already supports ARM CPUs and has for some time. The challenge is drivers. Getting video/ wifi/ etc running is the part that makes devices actually useful. The Broadcom Blob the poster I replied to was referring to is not for supporting ARM. Very similar to the Nvidia blob many people install (often unknowingly) when they install Linux on a system with Nvidia.

> Intel has Linux dedicated teams at least, pushing FOSS code every single day. Most ARM licensees could not care one bit about FOSS.

Intel didn't give a shit about Linux for how many years? Companies don't care about FOSS until it has potential to affect their bottom line. It was only after Linux servers were running half the Internet, that Intel stepped up and started supporting Linux.

I'm guessing you missed the first couple decades of Linux adoption. Linux on ARM is just a fast motion repeat of the early days of Linux on x86.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by folmar on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:40PM (#25296295)
The is a free one: https://opencores.org/projects/zet86 (I don't know how complete/production grade is it).
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by erk__ on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#25293889)
I am pretty sure the most open at the moment are OpenPOWER and RISC-V, while there is is MIPS I am sure how open it is.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:55PM (#25298047)
Can you buy a desktop with those right now?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by josephcsible on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:49PM (#25299088)
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:49AM (#25302785)
> POWER

at prohibitive costs. So not really an option...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by josephcsible on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:53AM (#25302839)
They don't seem that expensive. They're high-end machines themselves, and their pricing seems on-par with high-end x86 workstations, like the Dell Precision series.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by daenney on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:25PM (#25293354)
> Be careful what you wish for. X86 is the most open architecture right now

You might want to take a look at PowerPC/OpenPOWER.

ARM not being very open is mostly because there's been limited development interest in it, aside from specialised devices, and those companies have no real need or interest to have open things. Doesn't mean ARM itself can't evolve past it.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Koshkin on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:11PM (#25294996)
> ARM not being very open is mostly because there's been limited development interest in it, aside from specialised devices

That's an extremely weird thing to say...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:25PM (#25293355)
I know very little about this space, but presumably that will change if/when a significant portion of the laptop space (and probably the server space as well) moves from x86 to ARM? It might be painful for early adopters for a few years, but I would expect this stuff to get ironed out in time, no?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by buran77 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:59PM (#25293879)
No, that ship has sailed. Anything new that comes now can be built according to the expectations smartphones have set over the past decade and a half. Closed systems that are treated like disposable items. Even PCs in their mobile incarnation are now far less open and flexible than they used to be.

The reason PCs are still open is historical, they started like this and people can't really see PCs any other way but they're a dying breed and whatever comes after is a different game with different rules. We'll have some niche manufacturer building something more open for the small segment of enthusiasts.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by egsmi on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:33PM (#25296959)
We've basically got one foot though that door already.

> We'll have some niche manufacturer building something more open for the small segment of enthusiasts.

I would argue that's exactly what Raspberry Pi and Arduino is.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by SulfurHexaFluri on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:52PM (#25298032)
The raspberry pi requires a very proprietary and custom boot process. Nothing can start until you first load the GPU driver blob on to the SoC.

This is why you need rpi specific distro builds.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by haberman on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:35PM (#25296222)
"Developer Mode" exists in many new devices, eg. Chromebooks, Oculus Quest, Android phones.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by buran77 on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:01PM (#25304731)
There's a difference between swapping or adding any of the many standardized components you want or installing pretty much any operating system you can think of on your PC, compared to enabling "developer mode" on an Oculus Quest.

The fact that so many people casually say how a platform is open or flexible because if you jump through enough hoops you get to make some minor modifications to your device, or applauding the openness of a system for allowing you to sideload standard apps is the reason manufacturers don't see a need to propagate the PC philosophy anymore. Too many users grew up with this new model so they don't see the loss.

None of the devices you mention are user serviceable in any way hardware-wise, the software is almost always locked onto the device and there's no easy, or even supported way of changing it. And if you do change it you just get a small variation of the same software. Your phone may get a slightly degooglified version of Android but it's unlikely you'll get it to run Ubuntu, Windows, or a FreeBSD without a massive investment in time and knowledge.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by haberman on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:29PM (#25310291)
My understanding is that developer mode on Android and Chromebook will unlock the bootloader. Software wise, that's about as user-hackable as you can get. It's true that the Oculus Quest is not as open.

I don't expect or even really want to swap hardware on these devices: if that was a priority for me I would get a PC, Arduino, Raspberry Pi, etc. I get the desire to tinker and customize, but from where I'm sitting I have plenty of opportunity to do that.

I also don't expect the device manufacturers to do the work to make Ubuntu or FreeBSD run. They didn't do that for PCs, the community did.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by throwaway894345 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:05PM (#25294908)
Sadly, I find this persuasive.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:05PM (#25309521)
The apple M1's don't have locked bootloaders, there's a warning in the firmware about enabling unsigned booting, but it's just warning. That's why there's an attempted linux port underway.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:21PM (#25294205)
> messy device trees

Can you please elaborate?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:00PM (#25298072)
> * the x86 world resolves around standards such as ACPI, BIOSes and general-purpose dynamic buses. > * ACPI normalises every single piece of hardware from the perspective of most low-level peripherals. > * the BIOS also helps in that normalisation. DOS INT33 is the classic one i remember. > * the general-purpose dynamic buses include: - USB and its speed variants (self-describing peripherals) - PCI and its derivatives (self-describing peripherals) - SATA and its speed variants (self-describing peripherals)

> exceptions to the above include i2c (unusual, and taken care of by i2c-sensors, which uses good heuristics to "probe" devices from userspace) and the ISA bus and its derivatives such as Compact Flash and IDE. even PCMCIA got sufficient advances to auto-identify devices from userspace at runtime.

> so as a general rule, supporting a new x86-based piece of hardware is a piece of piss. get datasheet or reverse-engineer, drop it in, it's got BIOS, ACPI, USB, PCIe, SATA, wow big deal, job done. also as a general rule, hardware that conforms to x86-motherboard-like layouts such as the various powerpc architectures are along the same lines.

> so here, device tree is a real easy thing to add, and to some extent a "nice-to-have". i.e. it's not really essential to have device tree on top of something where 99% of the peripherals can describe themselves dynamically over their bus architecture when they're plugged in!

> now let's look at the ARM world.

> * is there a BIOS? no. so all the boot-up procedures including ultra-low-level stuff like DDR3 RAM timings initialisation, which is normally the job of the BIOS - must be taken care of BY YOU (usually in u-boot) and it must be done SPECIFICALLY CUSTOMISED EACH AND EVERY SINGLE TIME FOR EVERY SINGLE SPECIFIC HARDWARE COMBINATION.

> * is there ACPI present? no. so anything related to power management, fans (if there are any), temperature detection (if there is any), all of that must be taken care of BY YOU.

> * what about the devices? here's where it becomes absolute hell on earth as far as attempting to "streamline" the linux kernel into a "one size fits all" monolithic package.

> the classic example i give here is the HTC Universal, which was a device that, after 3 years of dedicated reverse-engineering, finally had fully-working hardware with the exception of write to its on-board NAND. the reason for the complexity is in the hardware design, where not even 110 GPIO pins of the PXA270 were enough to cover all of the peripherals, so they had to use a custom ASIC with an additional 64 GPIO pins. it turned out that that wasn't enough either, so in desperation the designers used the 16 GPIO pins of the Ericsson 3G Radio ROM, in order to do basic things like switch on the camera flash LED.

> the point is: each device that's designed using an ARM processor is COMPLETELY AND UTTERLY DIFFERENT from any other device in the world.

https://lists.debian.org/debian-arm/2013/05/msg00009.html

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Aissen on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:08AM (#25301081)
ARM UEFI systems exist. There are now the norm on servers along with ACPI. Even some embedded devices use UEFI. There are other standards to address those various points.

This post is so outdated, that ARM servers' companies had the time to have everything, then still die (most of them). And then revive with the AWS Graviton2 and other Neoverse chips.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by heavyset_go on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:46PM (#25306067)
It's not outdated, it holds true for ARM SoCs. Consumer ARM devices are ARM SoCs, and not server hardware. It's cheaper and easier to design custom SoCs than it is to build consumer hardware that conforms to the standards that ARM servers do.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:53AM (#25289374)
> I want to believe.

If we can end up with superfast, supercool ARM-based Linux laptops, that'd be a huge deal :)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ficklepickle on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:19AM (#25290426)
This is it. I'm excited because Apple just showed what is possible. Other companies are going to have to try to match it.

I have wanted a powerful "enough" fanless laptop for many years. I got excited about 4 years ago with Intel's short-lived M line and I bought an Asus ux305. It served me well for front end web dev (had to use a cooler stand under sustained high load though). Great Linux support and battery life (after installing tlp). I remember feeling a bit of awe that it was reasonably snappy with no fan, but it was not quite there. I can only imagine the feeling is an order of magnitude greater with the M1.

I don't own any Apple products, but I still hope that raising the bar will benefit me later on. I'll be pretty pumped when this level of hardware can run a mainline kernel.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Klonoar on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:42PM (#25292736)
>Other companies are going to have to try to match it.

This actually worries me.

Lately, anytime I look outside the Apple ecosystem, I wonder to myself what all these companies are doing... sure, I could see AMD closing the gap, but Apple's made additional choices for integration beyond what AMD would do alone.

I guess my summary would be: other companies trying to "match" Apple hasn't really gone well in the past decade, short of a few select standouts.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hsitz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:24PM (#25296084)
I've had same desire for a lightweight, fanless laptop for many years, also had (and still have and use) an Asus ux305, which I used for Linux development.

My main use machine now and for last couple years has been a Google Pixelbook. Lightweight (2.4 lbs) and fanless, solid 8+ hours on a charge, great for general use on chromeos, okay for Linux with built-in Crostini container.

I've had an iPad, but have never had any other Apple product. I've been pretty much anti-Apple since 1979, when as a 15-year-old I bought a Radio Shack TRS-80 over the much more expensive and glitzier Apple IIe.

I now have a Macbook Air M1 on order. We'll see how it goes. I'm sensitive to weight, prefer very light laptops. At 2.9 lbs it will be a noticeable step back from the ux305 (2.6 lbs) and Pixelbook (2.4 lbs). If I end up not bonding with the Macbook I plan to sell it; Apple's generally high resale value is a factor in giving the M1 a try.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by jack_pp on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:56AM (#25289395)
Let's not forget the super long battery.

While I dislike apple and have never owned any of their devices I can't help but feel thankful to them because now that we know this is possible soon others will re-create their success and we will hopefully have the same perks on a more open platform

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:39PM (#25293581)
Someone needs to spend the time/ money to design this M1 killer CPU. There is very little money in delivering powerful Linux laptops.

ARM based Linux server CPUs? Very likely. Low end/ Chromebook style laptop ARM CPUs, Already exist.

Performant ARM CPUs designed for laptops? I expect you just gotta hope Windows on ARM takes off or start porting Linux to M1 Macs.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cestith on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#25293886)
Work has already begun to port Linux to M1 Macs. Linux for ARM and Windows for ARM are already running as PoC on the M1 Macs with QEMU (running ARM-on-ARM).

https://www.techradar.com/news/you-can-now-run-linux-and-win...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:11PM (#25294045)
I suspect people interested in "superfast, supercool ARM-based Linux laptops" are looking more for running on bare metal, not in a VM.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wmf on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:31PM (#25294361)
Linux on M1 bare metal is also in the works.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cestith on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:36AM (#25302623)
Please read the first sentence again. Porting is underway. It's already running under ARM to ARM emulation, but porting is underway.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:39PM (#25298605)
If Linux can be made to run on M1 bare metal, I expect it will. And computing history shows us Linux can be made to run on anything ;)
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:47PM (#25299082)
I expect (very much hope) it will. I haven't contributed to the Linux on M1 fund yet, but I am seriously considering it, particularly if I get an M1 Mac. I likely wouldn't run Linux until after Apple retires MacOS for the M1, but want the option.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:57PM (#25298710)
> Performant ARM CPUs designed for laptops? I expect you just gotta hope Windows on ARM takes off or start porting Linux to M1 Macs.

What makes you think Windows won't take off on ARM?

In any case, if it can be done -- i.e. if there aren't locked down specs -- you can bet Linux will be ported to M1 Macs.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:35PM (#25299001)
> What makes you think Windows won't take off on ARM?

I have no idea if it will or not. Microsoft's current strategy on ARM seems pretty unlikely to succeed though.

> In any case, if it can be done -- i.e. if there aren't locked down specs -- you can bet Linux will be ported to M1 Macs.

I'm confident (and hopeful) we will see an M series Linux port. How good it will be without support from Apple is questionable. The current state of Linux on Mac doesn't exactly inspire hope.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:30AM (#25302542)
> Microsoft's current strategy on ARM seems pretty unlikely to succeed though

I'm not familiar with Microsoft's current ARM strategy, but they can always pivot of it turns out it's really the future. I must reluctantly admit Microsoft has been capable of some pretty surprising and welcome changes in its history.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:43PM (#25292747)
But that won't happen unless there's a Windows ARM build that does everything that Windows does in x86: the market for Linux-only laptops is pretty small.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by qppo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:52PM (#25292863)
> the market for Linux-only laptops is pretty small.

but growing more today than it was a few years ago because of the prevalence of Chromebooks in education. Many of which run ARM CPUs!

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ekianjo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:51PM (#25298030)
Most recent Chromebooks are intel-based these days.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:29PM (#25309711)
Indeed, at least they are running linux though.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:58PM (#25298721)
What makes you think, if ARM becomes the hot new target, that there won't be a Windows ARM laptop?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:11PM (#25294047)
Yeah, that would be really amazing. Is it even possible to install Linux on this new Mac though? Probably not. Will Apple offer these chips to other manufacturers? Would be cool if we could build small form factor PCs with these M1 chips!

I also wonder about the driver situation. Intel hardware has excellent support on Linux, everything works out of the box. Apple probably has zero interest in contributing drivers to the Linux kernel.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Siilwyn on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:00PM (#25297239)
Not at the moment but probably some time next year: https://www.patreon.com/marcan
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by doggydogs94 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:39PM (#25294468)
You are correct. The answer is no Linux on M1.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:24PM (#25309669)
Contribute to the Linux -> Apple M1 projects, I have.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by doggydogs94 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:38PM (#25294451)
Not going to happen anytime soon.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:00PM (#25298732)
It's ok, I'm in no hurry: my current Intel-based Linux laptop works great.

I can dream of an even better one, though!

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:13AM (#25289561)
If we can end up with superfast, supercool ARM-based Linux laptops, that'd be a huge deal :)

Apple showed Debian running in a VM on an M1 prototype Mac nearly 6 months ago.

I get that it won't be acceptable for some Linux diehards but the superfast, supercool ARM laptop running Linux will soon be an M1 MacBook Pro.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by matheusmoreira on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:18PM (#25294167)
Apple laptops have always been among the best in terms of quality. If you can run free software on it, even better.

Is it actually possible to replace macOS with Linux though?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:51PM (#25294691)
Apple hasn’t locked down the Apple Silicon Macs to prevent a non-Apple OS from being installed, so maybe?

The main issue is driver support, since graphics, networking, etc. is all Apple proprietary hardware.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:15AM (#25289579)
If I can get it to run Linux not on a VM, but natively and without coexisting with macOS at all, then it'll be good enough for me!...

...except I cannot afford a macbook. The one I'm using now was paid for by my employer.

More generally, I'd love to see fast ARM platforms not built by Apple.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Toutouxc on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:07PM (#25293057)
I don't think you really pay that much extra for an Apple machine, especially for the M1 ones. I'm afraid that when/if fast ARM alternatives arrive, they will probably cost 80-100 % of what the MacBooks cost. So basically, if you can't afford a MacBook today, you won't be able to afford a comparable high-end ARM offering from, say, Dell.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:53PM (#25298688)
I honestly don't know about the M1's, but I've never liked the price/specs ratio of Intel macbooks. While it's true their build is solid and they look good, they always seemed overpriced to me regarding specs.

And even the build quality... a friend who's an Apple fan used to tell me "they are better quality, they have less problems" yet his macbooks seem to break down at about the same rate as my Dell, HP or Lenovo laptops, so...

I've decided macbooks look good, have good quality screens and the best touchpads. I'm unwilling to pay a premium for that, and I don't even like OS X/macOS...

> I'm afraid that when/if fast ARM alternatives arrive, they will probably cost 80-100 % of what the MacBooks cost.

Possibly! I wouldn't buy them when they are the latest new thing, either.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by snazz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:41PM (#25293613)
One big difference is that MacBooks (and Apple products in general) retain their value far better than any other computer brand. If you're looking at the used market to save money, a Dell looks way cheaper because it's depreciated far more than the Apple machine.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:47PM (#25298654)
To be honest, I've never ever resold a laptop. Ever. I end up giving old laptops to friends or family who can't afford a new one. So resale price is a non-issue to me.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by samoa42 on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:17AM (#25301464)
resold once, neither the buyer nor me was happy with the deal. family and friends it is
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:24PM (#25297445)
...except I cannot afford a MacBook

You know, the M1 Mac mini is $699…

And since you can attach up to 6 displays to it (or the MacBook Pro), you'd never have to look at macOS if really didn't want to. ;-)

https://www.macrumors.com/2020/11/24/m1-macs-able-to-run-six...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:44PM (#25298641)
But the M1 Mac mini is not a laptop. And in any case, if those are US prices, count about 4x in my country.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mypalmike on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:24PM (#25294257)
Local compensation practices where you live must really suck if you can't afford a $1000 laptop. :(
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sound1 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:57PM (#25294799)
I feel this is not a very thoughtful comment. There can be many more reasons for not being able to afford a $1000 laptop other than local compensation right? Financial constraints like kids, mortgage, lack of spare cash for a new machine etc.?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by the_af on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:42PM (#25298627)
I don't live in the US and I must politely ask you to see how the rest of the world lives.

The macbook I was given costs, after customs, taxes and everything, $4000. Not $1000. Are there cheaper macbooks? Sure. Why would I want them, though?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mypalmike on Saturday December 05, 2020 @02:37AM (#25312645)
I'm sorry if my post seemed rude in any way.

First, this discussion is about the new MacBook Air that costs $1000 US which is why I mentioned that price point. I suppose tariffs and such would increase that substantially, so that's a fair point. My bad. That said, I believe there was discussion about the hypothetical situation where you did want a Mac.

More to the point, I checked your post history before I commented, and I gathered you are a developer, somewhere in South America (?). I suspect that the code I write is probably no better than the code you write. But your pay is presumably quite a bit less than mine. My point was that it's unfortunate that like work doesn't yield like rewards.

Now here I am going to make some assumptions... In all likelihood, people are amassing wealth off of your work in the same way they profit from mine. But due to local wage norms, they can pay you less and reap higher margins. They get to upgrade the yacht, but you might not even have enough free time time to use a boat even if you could afford one.

It's possible that I extrapolated too much and that your situation is nothing like what I have inferred. Sorry in advance if that is the case.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:53AM (#25289372)
>Those machines are just standing around in their underwear now because the M1 stole all their pants.

Not sure what shitty machine hes talking about, but my threadripper's are not impressed with some 4 core M1.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simonh on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:02AM (#25289448)
He's talking about the vast majority of PC chips sold today, who's power consumption / performance / thermal ratios just got marmalised.

You're quite right, your machine and in fact everyone else's are still just as good as they were a few weeks ago. I got an Intel 5K iMac in the summer and I'm still very happy with it. I need to be able to run windows and Linux in VMs so M1 isn't for me right now. It's no for you either.

Having said that, your manufacturer of your Threadripper is now on notice. Apple isn't done with the M1, more powerful desktop chips are on their way over the next few years and there's a very good chance they'll do exactly what they just did to Intel and AMDs mobile chipsets to the high end stuff. Apple are coming for them, and not being impressed now isn't going to serve them well down the line.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by greendave on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:40PM (#25293591)
Sure, and when they do, we can have that conversation.

But claiming that what’s available today from Apple is of great interest to the high performance market is jumping the gun.

There’s also the fact that cost (including peripherals and support) and software availability, not performance and efficiency, are what guide most PC purchases. The M1’s advantages are far less pronounced in those areas.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Recurecur on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:02PM (#25304759)
> But claiming that what’s available today from Apple is of great interest to the high performance market is jumping the gun.

I think that misses the point that most users (and most software developers in particular) use laptops. The M1 SOC pretty well kills everything CPU-wise, and does graphics as well as a GT 1050 discrete GPU. It also throws in AI silicon and RAM, and runs all of it in a 20W (or so) power budget.

Single-thread performance is quite comparable to a Threadripper.

It'll be interesting to see how things look when M1 style silicon is introduced for the 16" Macbook Pro (guessing 8 performance cores, 32 GB RAM), and the Mac Pro (guessing up to 32 performance cores, and at least 64 GB RAM used as cache for a potentially much larger main memory).

> There’s also the fact that cost (including peripherals and support) and software availability, not performance and efficiency, are what guide most PC purchases. The M1’s advantages are far less pronounced in those areas.

Actually as to cost, it's highly competitive in the premium laptop segment (like Dell XPS for instance).

Software availability is good, since it'll run almost all Intel Mac software, all M1 Mac software (soon to be ~everything), and all ARM-compatible Linux software (ARM Linux runs in a VM).

The only thing missing is Windows, and that may well be temporary.

I'd say if you're doing web, Mac or Linux software development the Apple Silicon Macs are the wave of the future! :-)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by fomine3 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:30PM (#25298255)
I wonder does Apple really make real "Pro" line Apple Silicon for Mac Pro that competitive to 32-64 core Threadripper. Is it profitable?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simonh on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:43AM (#25299991)
Before the M1 I worried about that. Now I don’t. The M1 is the lowest performance, lowest end Mac chip Apple will ever make, and it’s already knocking on the door of premium Intel and AMD chips. Not the super-premium, highly multicore stuff like threadripper, buts it’s a lot closer than anyone expected in single core.

To me, this means that when Apple consciously goes after the high end desktop market, they are likely to overshoot in exactly the same way M1 overshot the mid range mobile space. That could put Apple’s high end iMac chips in Mac Pro territory anyway.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by free2OSS on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:52PM (#25293768)
I'm the other side. Vertical integration is a fast way to fall behind.

This move is very Nintendo-like. Gimmick then don't even attempt to compete with the big dogs.

The fanboys have their meat to chew on "it's not hot". And they will repeat it on command as Apple falls behind to a swath of competition. "It might be slow, but at least it doesn't warm my lap."

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hchz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:59PM (#25295768)
Nintendos profit forecast for FY2020 is 150% of Sony's gaming division.

Apple just dropped hardware which crushes every comparable competitor.

But to you, Nintendo is not competing by "making more money", and Apple is "falling behind" by ... jumping years ahead? This reads like personal axe-grinding that is detached from any objective link to the market.

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/28/sonys-second-quarter-profit-...

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/05/nintendo-raises-switch-forec...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simonh on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:13AM (#25301444)
The third most valuable company on the planet's long term business model has been a "fast way to fall behind", and is not "even attempting to compete with the big dogs"?

Well, they just pantsed Microsoft at their own ARM laptop game (#2 most valuable) and the #1 big dog is, er, Saudi Aramco.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by pathartl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:51AM (#25290035)
It's all going to come down to user experience and versatility. Apple is doing some crazy stuff with the M1, but I personally would chock (most of it) it up more to being clever than true innovation. I think only Intel needs to be concerned right now because they're being outpaced by both AMD and Apple. Additionally if the acquisition of Arm by Nvidia results in what people expect, Intel will basically be losing out in every market.

Going back to versatility, there's no way that AWS or Azure is going to move to Apple silicon for their infrastructure, so there's still a massive market for AMD or other Arm manufacturers to target. For the consumer side unless Apple releases a chip that results in them making a sub-$800 laptop, they're just simply not going to capture a large market. With the rise of devices like Chromebooks in education and home there's still something to be said for Apple devices just being too expensive.

In general, Apple devices also leave a LOT to be desired for any sort of large scale enterprise organization. Unless they go back to their 90's and early 00's mindset, I just can't see this changing.

It's certainly exciting to see the CPU market being upended by Apple and AMD, as well as the potential future for a large architecture shift, but I don't think there's any real threat to market shares as a whole.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by saagarjha on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:59PM (#25292950)
You don’t just go and make ever part of your chip architecture wider by being clever. Well, there was probably some cleverness involved, but it’s not like this has been a one-off trick.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by pathartl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:08PM (#25294006)
By clever I mostly mean, from what I've seen from reports, handling stuff like transition from x86 to arm by baking in instruction translation into the die. Their approach with some things is a bit different from what others are doing, but it's not like they wholly invented a new 2nm process that breaks what we thought the laws of physics were, they're using the same fab as everybody else. Thus their design at the moment is clever.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by saagarjha on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:35PM (#25294404)
There’s no hardware instruction translation.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ithkuil on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:26PM (#25297453)
there is little hardware assist though: TSO can be enabled and disabled and thus simplifying x86 instruction translation by implementing the x86 memory model in hardware and thus avoiding unnecessary memory barriers
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by free2OSS on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:53PM (#25293776)
This is Apple we are talking about. The last 20 years have been tricks.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:41PM (#25294500)
Hehe, i see what you did here ;)
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by MaxBarraclough on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:19PM (#25293265)
> there's no way that AWS or Azure is going to move to Apple silicon for their infrastructure

AWS already have a series of AArch64 instance-types which they will most likely continue to improve.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by pathartl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:05PM (#25293953)
I didn't say that they wouldn't go Arm, I said they wouldn't buy chips from Apple. Apple would never sell it like that.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by judge2020 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:20PM (#25298508)
Current Macs on AWS run via real Apple hardware, so I don't see how M1 will be different. https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/new-use-mac-instances-to-bu...
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by MaxBarraclough on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:14AM (#25300456)
Right, but they're going to remain a tiny niche. They're priced so highly that there's no risk of them cannibalizing Amazon's own AArch64 instance-types.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simonh on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:29PM (#25293420)
I don’t know about under $800, but I wouldn’t be at all surprised if Apple didn’t keep the current M1 Air on the lineup at a lower price when the Airs get their next revamp.

This is exactly what Apple did with the iPad, nowadays you can get a very decently specced 10.2” iPad with their 2018 CPU for $309. That’s astonishing, but it’s a great way for Apple to get extended value out of their silicon.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:06AM (#25289493)
but my threadripper's are not impressed with some 4 core M1

The M1 has 8 CPU cores, 8 GPU cores and 16 Neural Engine cores. It also runs at 10 watts and maxes out at 24 watts. A Threadripper starts at over 100 watts…

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by msla on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:50AM (#25290018)
So are we going to have "Core Wars" to replace the "MHz Wars" of previous decades?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by rsynnott on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:46AM (#25290882)
No, but we've had performance per watt wars for years now. It's why prior to Zen you only saw AMD chips on the cheapest of laptops, and also now why Intel is panicking.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by mox1 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:25AM (#25290515)
No probably not. More of a "Benchmark vs. Power Consumption" war I think.

Power users understand today that max MHZ doesn't even matter anymore, for various reasons.

I think power consumption (even in desktops, servers) will be a large factor / marketing number.

I think the big tech sites will continue to hammer home some type of "CPU work / watt" type metric, which is roughly like "time to complete some standardized workload vs. power used to do it"

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by arvinsim on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:51PM (#25298368)
Some people don't care about performance per watt and only care about absolute performance.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by bfgoodrich on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:26AM (#25289703)
To be fair, 4 of the cores on the M1 are efficiency cores and are very low performance (but sufficient performance, at incredible efficiency, for a lot of casual ongoing background things). An 8 performance core M1 would be a monster.

Not sure if it maxes out at 24 watts. Someone measured wall power of a Mac Mini hitting 21 watts at full load, but that's including power supply inefficiency, all of the supporting circuitry and IO, a fan, flash storage, etc.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by wtallis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:01PM (#25292976)
> 4 of the cores on the M1 are efficiency cores and are very low performance (but sufficient performance, at incredible efficiency, for a lot of casual ongoing background things).

I think you're underselling the small cores a bit. Their microarchitecture is roughly comparable to a Cortex-A75, which was the high-performance cores in Snapdragon 845 phones like the Samsung Galaxy S9. But Apple clocks them about 26% slower than the SD845 did, so maybe we should be comparing against Galaxy S8 instead: flagship Android performance from 3 years ago. That's capable of a lot more than just casual background processing. Samsung introduced their DeX docking station for smartphone-powered desktop usage back with the S8 generation, when their phones only had as much computational power as the Apple M1's smaller cores.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by bfgoodrich on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:47PM (#25293689)
Pulling other cores into this discussion does nothing but muddy the waters.

The Firestorm cores in the M1 are 4.5X faster at SPECfp than the Icestorm cores. The Firestorm cores in the M1 are 3.1X faster at SPECint than the Icestorm cores.

In my world, the 3.1 - 4.5X faster sibling makes them very low performance, relatively. In a fully working together scenario, the "8" core M1 is equal in performance to a conceptual 4.5 core Firestorm part (see the Geekbench scaling, for instance). This, again, has positively nothing to do with any other core or part.

Bizarre that anyone thinks this is somehow negative or dismissive of the M1. It is an extraordinary chip. But they intentionally, purposefully put 4 very low performance -- compared to Firestorm -- cores because it matches the computing model of users average workload.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by romanoderoma on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:25PM (#25293358)
But honestly, does it matter?

People buying a threadripper today don't care about it.

What matters to them it's the performance, my gf is a 3d artist, she doesn't care if some cpu consumes more or less power than another (when I say she doesn't care I mean she doesn't even know that CPU have very different power requirements), she needs the fastest gear she can buy on her budget.

Apple M1s are not it.

There are many other that do not care because the hardware stays at the office, where someone else pays the bills and they too don't care because the electricity bill is the last of their problems, fixing it buying more efficient computing devices would mean spending a lot of money in advance to replace at least half of the stock.

How many more months of electricity could that money pay?

A lot.

People buying Apple for its M1 low power consumption are a niche inside a niche.

So I think the reasoning stands: Apple M1s are not a real threat for its competitors because the market that really cares about its strengths is smaller than the one that doesn't and Apple will keep to largely miss the second one.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by matwood on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:43PM (#25293631)
Laptops have outsold desktops every year for the last decade+. The M1, being a mobile friendly chip, is addressing the larger market. People may not care about power usage from the wall, but they do care about battery life.

Also, the fact that the M1 is even being mentioned along with a desktop powerhouse like the threadripper says it all. The M1 is the lowest end mobile Apple Silicon. We know higher end mobile chips are coming along with desktop ones. The M1 has put all the chip manufacturers on notice, much the same the way the iPhone did (to the point RIM thought Apple was lying about the iPhone because they thought the device was impossible).

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by rgbrenner on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:21PM (#25294197)
It's only being mentioned alongside threadripper because the article went overboard and claimed the M1 "embarrass all other PCs — ... including ... every single machine running Windows or Linux"

This is a joke. The M1s performance is no where near the threadripper. Even on per-thread performance, new AMD cpus perform better than the M1... and they have many more cores. The M1 can only win these comparisons when we start adding all kinds of conditions, like power draw, heat, price point, etc. They need to add those conditions to redirect the conversation, because on raw performance threadripper destroys the M1.

The article made the mistake of leaving out those conditions to make it seem even more impressive than it is... but hyperbole and fantasy will always sound better than reality. Reality requires those conditions. That doesn't detract from the m1's impressiveness.. but it's foolish to forget that and go off and start making ridiculous claims like the article has done.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by soylentcola on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:14PM (#25296741)
That was sort of my takeaway as well. I use desktop computers for most of my more demanding work. Laptops are great and (like smartphones, tablets, etc) any improvement in their capabilities is to be welcomed--but there's a difference between a headline that reads "New laptop is the fastest computer ever!" and one that reads "New laptop faster than all previous laptops!"

I don't do the most intensive tasks on thin, battery-powered computers for a reason. I try to do those on the box that's always plugged into mains power with heatsinks and fans as needed, plenty of ports to plug things in, and a big monitor. A more performant portable computer is awesome, but until I can spend a similar amount to make my workstation smaller without losing capability, I'll likely keep using it for heavy lifting alongside a cheaper, less powerful laptop or tablet for lighter work or remoting in.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by romanoderoma on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:56PM (#25293829)
Android has oversold Apple 3 to 1

Now if we look at what people are buying and ask ourselves 'are these the people who care about TDP?' the answer is simply 'no'

The majority of laptops sold are sub 700, as the previous post said, low budget, low power and in education, markets that Apple has never even considered (except education, but it's mainly college students in USA)

Not saying M1 aren't good, but that they won't shake the market as NVidia buying ARM could

P.s. M1 is a Zen 3 competitor, threadripper has been mentioned for the exact opposite reason: because that's the state of the art for people looking at performances in personal computing (while in HPC ARM is prominent)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cellar_door on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:55PM (#25293814)
> People buying Apple for its M1 low power consumption are a niche inside a niche.

Got it, watching Netflix in Chrome without the laptop getting hot is "a niche inside a niche" while GPU intensive 3d graphics workflows are mainstream.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by p1necone on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:59PM (#25297215)
This is doable on practically anything. Talking about being powerful with low heat/power consumption implies heavier workloads than Netflix because otherwise the "powerful" part is irrelevant.

Of course I'm sure you can find laptops with terrible cooling design that would get uncomfortably hot watching Netflix, but there's plenty of thin and light laptops available for < $1000 that would do just fine too.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by macNchz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:33PM (#25297511)
Even my 5 year old passive-cooling Core m3 12" Macbook streams Netflix for hours on battery without getting hot.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:49PM (#25294664)
>watching Netflix in Chrome without the laptop getting hot is "a niche inside a niche" while GPU intensive 3d graphics workflows are mainstream.

Well then i have to say Apple achieved what my 7 year old nexus 5 already could...bravo.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by romanoderoma on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:02PM (#25293918)
If not getting hot while watching Netflix is the benchmark, I can show you a 400 euros laptop that can do 9 hours of Netflix on battery (or 7 hours of 1080p 60fps streaming)

Don't need no M1

AMD and Nvidia have sold more GPUs than Apple laptops by a large margin

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by snazz on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:46PM (#25293685)
People using powerful laptops care about battery life, though. For someone moving from a "workstation"-class laptop, the M1's value is significant.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Friday December 04, 2020 @05:37AM (#25300927)
>For someone moving from a "workstation"-class laptop, the M1's value is significant.

Em NO, the M1's are not comparable with a workstation class laptops (not cpu wise nor ram...and especially not GPU wise)

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by criddell on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:44PM (#25293643)
> she needs the fastest gear she can buy on her budget.

> Apple M1s are not it.

If a person had a $1000 budget, they could by an M1 equipped laptop from Apple. Is there something significantly faster at that price?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by romanoderoma on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:04PM (#25293942)
Or a desktop with 64 GB of RAM and two previous generation GPUs
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by criddell on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:11PM (#25294055)
64 GB? From where?

I just looked at Dell and an XPS desktop with 16 GB of RAM starts at $650. You aren't going to be able to add two GPUs and a monitor for $350.

At HP you can get to 32 GB for $650 but again you still need to buy GPUs and a monitor.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by romanoderoma on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:34PM (#25294401)
64GB of ram cost < 300 euros

A lot of studios sell their old GPU (as in a generation ago) for cheap

If you stay out of vertical integrated supply chains you can buy the best your budget allows

If you are saying that you cannot assemble a laptop of the same quality of an Apple one, I agree

If you are saying that Apple laptops are what people want because they consume 20 watt full load, I disagree

The market of the good enough products is always gonna be larger than 'the best money can buy'

Apple will never make 'good enough products' hence they are not competing with the bulk of what is being sold right now

It could change in the future, but not in the immediate future IMO

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by criddell on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:16PM (#25295084)
I'm not saying any of those things. I'm saying a $1000 laptop from Apple is a pretty good value for a lot of people and I'm not sure you can do a lot better at that price point. When you include things like having an Apple store across town where you can go when things break, it pulls even further ahead.

The best that money can buy changes when you put the actual budget. Today, Apple may be the best that $1000 can buy.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by egsmi on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:57PM (#25294793)
> 64GB of ram cost < 300 euros

Not all RAM is equivalent. If one wants 64GB of the kind of RAM M1 uses, which is very high performance, it will cost more than 300 euros.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ianhowson on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:33PM (#25295385)
M1 is using standard LPDDRx. It's not "very high performance". It uses a different interconnect -- that's it.

I guarantee that 64GB does not cost anything near EUR300.

You might be thinking of HBM[2] which has a wider I/O path and costs more.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:53PM (#25296471)
>M1 is using standard LPDDRx. >It's not "very high performance".

AnandTech disagrees with you: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...

Besides the additional cores on the part of the CPUs and GPU, one main performance factor of the M1 that differs from the A14 is the fact that’s it’s running on a 128-bit memory bus rather than the mobile 64-bit bus. Across 8x 16-bit memory channels and at LPDDR4X-4266-class memory, this means the M1 hits a peak of 68.25GB/s memory bandwidth.

Later in the article:

Most importantly, memory copies land in at 60 to 62GB/s depending if you’re using scalar or vector instructions. The fact that a single Firestorm core can almost saturate the memory controllers is astounding and something we’ve never seen in a design before.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ianhowson on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:38PM (#25296996)
Anandtech is comparing M1 vs A14. It's high performance for a cellphone part.

Dual channel DDR3L or DDR4L also has a 128 bit bus. 4200MHz DDR4 is clocked on the high side for most laptops, sure, but it's hardly unusual.

Run the numbers and you get the exact same throughput figure as for M1, which isn't surprising, because we're just taking width * rate = throughput.

So I'll repeat my assertion, downvotes be damned: the memory on the M1 is not special. The packaging and interconnect is interesting. It might reduce latency a little; it probably reduces power consumption a lot. But there's nothing special about it. The computer you're on right now probably has the same memory subsystem with different packaging.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:45PM (#25299069)
Anandtech is comparing M1 vs A14. It's high performance for a cellphone part.

That’s where they started, but their conclusion was beyond that.

Did you miss the part where they said the fact that a single Firestorm core can almost saturate the memory controllers is astounding and something we’ve never seen in a design before?

This isn’t only about A14 vs M1.

It’s not that LPDDR4X-4266-class memory is special; it’s been around for a while. What is special is that the RAM is part of SoC and due to the unified memory model, the CPU, GPU, Neural Engine and the other units have very fast access to the memory.

This is common for tablets and smartphones; it’s not common for general purpose laptops and desktops. And while Intel and AMD have added more functionality to their processors, they don’t have everything that’s part of the M1 system on a chip:

* Image Processing Unit (ISP) * Digital Signal Processor (DSP) * 16 core Neural Processing Unit (NPU) * Video encoder/decoder * Secure Enclave

There’s no other desktop such as the M1 Mac mini that combines all of these features with this level of performance at the price point of $699.

That is special.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ianhowson on Friday December 04, 2020 @10:37AM (#25303417)
> Did you miss the part where they

I don't think that's notable, sorry. I would expect that of any modern CPU.

> it’s not common for general purpose laptops and desktops

Well, yeah, because "memory on package" has major disadvantages. You (laptop/desktop manufacturer) are making minor gains in performance and power and need to buy a CPU which doesn't exist. Apple can do it, but they were already doing it for iPhone, and they must do it for iPhone to meet space constraints.

I think unified memory is the right way to go, long term, and that's a meaningful improvement. But as you point out, there is plenty of prior work there.

> they don’t have everything that’s part of the M1 system on a chip

They actually do! The 'CPU' part of an Intel CPU is vanishingly small these days. Most area is taken up with cache, GPU and hardware accelerators, such as... hardware video encode and decode, image processing, security and NN acceleration.

Most high-end Android cellphone SoCs have the same blocks. NVIDIA's SoCs have been shipping the same hardware blocks, with the same unified memory architecture, for at least four years. They all boot Ubuntu and give a desktop-like experience on a modern ARM ISA.

> There’s no other desktop ... at the price point of $699

Literally every modern Intel desktop does this.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:37PM (#25309788)
I've seen latencies when pointer chasing (in a relatively TLB friendly pattern) of 30-34ns. Have you seen similar elsewhere?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by egsmi on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:41PM (#25295511)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25050625

showed https://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/cpu-apple_m1-1804

which determined the M1's memory is LPDDR4X-4266 or LPDDR5-5500. If those memories are not high performance, what is?

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by notreallytrue on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#25296391)
You can't do what you do on a desktop on a laptop, not even a good one

Who cares if an M1 consumes less energy than a candle if I can buy 64GB of DDR4 3600 for 250 bucks and render the VFX for a 2 hours movie in 4k?

Another 300 bucks buy me a second GPU

When I deliver the job I put aside another 300 bucks and buy a third GPU

Or a better CPU

vertical products are an absolute waste of money when you chase the last bit of performance to save time (for you and your clients) and don't have the budget of Elon Musk

The M1 changes nothing in that space

Which is also a very lucrative space where every hour saved is an hour billed doing a new job instead of waiting to finish the last one to get paid

You can't mount your old gear on a rack and use it as a rendering node, plus you're paying for things you don't need: design, thermal constraints, a very expensive panel (a very good one, but still attached to the laptop body, and small)

So no, M1 is not comparable to a Threadripper, it's not even close, even if it consumes a lot more energy

When I'll see the same performances and freedom to upgrade in 20W chips, I will be the first one to buy them!

https://www.newegg.com/corsair-64gb-288-pin-ddr4-sdram/p/N82...

Then there's the 92% (actually 92.4%) of the remaining market that is not using an Apple computer that will keep buying non Apple hardware

Even if Apple doubled their market share, it would still be 15% Vs 85%

How is it possible that on HN people don't realise that 90 is much bigger than 10 and it's not a new laptop that will overturn the situation in a month is beyond me

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by egsmi on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:00PM (#25296548)
> You can't do what you do on a desktop on a laptop, not even a good one

Ummm... ok. But my comment was not all RAM is equivalent.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by notreallytrue on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:59AM (#25300082)
Not all cars are equivalent

I guess you don't drive a Ferrari or a Murciélago

And does it really matter to have a faster car if you can't use it to go camping with your family because space is limited?

That's what an Apple gives you, but it's not even a Ferrari, it's more like an Alfa Duetto

It's not expensive if you compare it to similar offers in the same category with the same constraints (which are artificially imposed on Macs like there's no other way to use a computer...)

But if you compare it to the vast amount of better configurations that the same money can buy, it is not

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by alwillis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:09PM (#25297307)
>You can't do what you do on a desktop on a laptop, not even a good one

Yeah… no, those days are over. The reviews clearly show the M1 Macs, including the MacBook Pro outperform most "desktops" at graphics-intensive tasks.

>So no, M1 is not comparable to a Threadripper, it's not even close, even if it consumes a lot more energy

Um… nobody is comparing an M1 Mac to a processor that often costs more than either the M1 Mac mini or MacBook Pro. However, the general consensus is the M1 outperforms PCs with mid to high-end GPUs and CPUs from Intel and AMD. Threadripper is a high-end, purpose build chip that can cost more than complete systems from most other companies, including Apple. However, it's at a cost of power consumption, special cooling in some cases, etc.

>Who cares if an M1 consumes less energy than a candle if I can buy 64GB of DDR4 3600 for 250 bucks and render the VFX for a 2 hours movie in 4k. Another 300 bucks buy me a second GPU

The MacBook Pro has faster LPDDR4X-4266 RAM on a 128-bit wide memory bus. The memory bandwidth maxes out at over 60 GB/s. And because the RAM, CPU and GPU (and all of the other units in the SoC) are all in the same die, memory is extremely fast.

From AnandTech; emphasis mine [1]: "A single Firestorm achieves memory reads up to around 58GB/s, with memory writes coming in at 33-36GB/s. Most importantly, memory copies land in at 60 to 62GB/s depending if you’re using scalar or vector instructions. The fact that a single Firestorm core can almost saturate the memory controllers is astounding and something we’ve never seen in a design before."

It can easily render a 2-hour 4k video unplugged in the background while you're doing other stuff. And when you're done, you’ll still have enough battery to last you until the next day if necessary. According to the AnandTech review [1], it blows away all other integrated GPUs and is even faster than several dedicated GPUs. That's not nothing; and these machines do it for less money.

>vertical products are an absolute waste of money when you chase the last bit of performance to save time (for you and your clients) and don't have the budget of Elon Musk

>The M1 changes nothing in that space

This is not correct… seeing should be believing.

Here's a video of 4k, 6k and 8k RED RAW files being rendered on an M1 Mac with 8 Gb of RAM, using DaVinci Resolve 17 [2]. Spoiler: while the 8k RAW file stuttered a little, once the preview resolution was reduced to only 4k, the playback was smooooth.

[1]: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16252/mac-mini-apple-m1-teste...

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxH3RabNWfE

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by p1necone on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:06PM (#25297737)
The M1 beats low end desktop GPUs from a couple of generations ago (~25% faster than the 1050ti and RX560 according to this benchmark [0]). Current high end GPUs are much faster than that (e.g the 3080 is ~5 times as powerful as a 1050ti).

Don't get me wrong - this is still very impressive with a ~20w combined! power draw under full load, but it definitely doesn't beat mid - high desktop GPUs.

(This is largely irrelevant for video encoding/decoding though as you can see - as that's mostly done either on the CPU or dedicated silicon living in either the CPU or the GPU that's separate from the main graphics processing cores.)

[0] https://www.macrumors.com/2020/11/16/m1-beats-geforce-gtx-10...

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by criddell on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:01PM (#25298077)
How much does a 3080 cost? Could you build a complete computer around one for $1000?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by p1necone on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:06PM (#25298102)
You're missing the point. I'm not trying to argue about which system is better, I'm just saying that the comment I'm replying to is saying incorrect things about GPU performance. I'll answer your question anyway though:

You could build a complete desktop system including a GPU that's more powerful than the one in the M1 for ~$1000, but certainly not a 3080. They're very expensive, and nobody has any in stock anyway.

An RX 580 or 1660 would probably be the right GPU with that budget. (Although you could go with something more powerful and skimp out on CPU and ram if you only cared about gaming performance).

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by notreallytrue on Friday December 04, 2020 @03:14AM (#25300182)
- a 3080 costs > $750 . Good luck buying one, I would if it wasn't out of stock. On the other hand the gtx 1050 mobile that is on the M1 can be easily found on eBay for < $50

- yes, you totally can. The best thing is that with a 1k.entry level you can start working on real-life projects that have deadlines and start earning money that will let you upgrade your gear to the level you actually need, without having to buy an entire new machine. The old components can serve as spare parts or to build a second node. You don't waste a single penny on things you don't need.

Even though, it's true, you can't brag with friends that it absorbs only 20 watts full load and the heat of the aluminium body is actually pleasant

It's a big sacrifice, I understand it.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by notreallytrue on Friday December 04, 2020 @03:01AM (#25300097)
> The reviews clearly show the M1 Macs, including the MacBook Pro outperform most "desktops" at graphics-intensive tasks.

They don't!

Cut the BS

> Here's a video of 4k, 6k and 8k RED RAW files being rendered on an M1 Mac

Blablablabla

That's not rendering

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sib on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:46PM (#25292798)
Well, if you're not going to consider about power consumption, Fugaku (and its 28MW consumption) would like a word with you.

https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/311995-japans-new-arm-ba...

I think his point about moving the bounds of the power (and heat) / performance tradeoff is valid.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by trinix912 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:57AM (#25289405)
This is not a completely fair comparison, your threadrippers surely use more energy and produce more heat than the M1 chip.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by reallydontask on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:00AM (#25289431)
Sometimes it matters other times not. If you want absolute performance then it doesn't matter, if you want efficiency then it does.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hajile on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:55AM (#25290086)
Add 50 more PCIe lanes, double the bus width, 270mb of cache, 60 cores and a communication protocol then get back to me.

Anandtech ran the numbers a couple years ago and an EPYC processor spent around 60% of its budget on Infinity Fabric (up to 90% of used power with only a couple cores being used).

An M2 based chip might get more done, but it won't use much less power. In truth, I'd guess there's a good chance it bottlenecks on the IO and performance doesn't increase as expected (without widening IO further with all the extra power costs).

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by viktorcode on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:39PM (#25295483)
The fact that you have to compare a high-end CPU against the base level M1 to show it isn't the fastest underlines Gruber's point pretty well.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:33PM (#25294382)
> Not sure what shitty machine hes talking about, but my threadripper's are not impressed with some 4 core M1.

Gruber greatly exaggerates here. Particularly mentioning the Mac Pro in the same paragraph.

Apple's M1 isn't competing with higher end Intel/ AMD desktop class CPUs with external GPUs. The M1 is a laptop CPU, designed for good performance with good thermals and excellent battery life. It will be interesting to see what they come up with over the next couple years to replace the CPU in the iMac and Mac Pro. But that is next year.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by zionic on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:00AM (#25289428)
Wait for an 8-core (or the rumored 12 core) variants. Those will embarrass your threadripper.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by soneil on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:35AM (#25289813)
I really can't wait to see what they'll do in the desktop space. For all the gushing reviews the M1 is receiving, it's worth remembering this is their entry-level machines.

As it stands right now, I have an 18 month old 27" iMac with 64GB ram and an AMD gpu - and an 8GB M1. And I'm preferring the M1 for almost any task that doesn't demand the real estate.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by formerly_proven on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:41PM (#25292721)
The M1 core is roughly on par with the Zen 3 core, so how exactly would an 8 core part manage to embarrass a 64 core Zen 2 part?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by sliken on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:46PM (#25309859)
Depending on the benchmark the M1 wins at per core vs the Zen3. The threadripper is substantially behind at per core performance with the Zen2.

The apple also has twice as many memory channels (8 vs 4) and runs the memory significantly faster (4266 vs 3200).

The m1 also has about half the latency to main memory.

So for highly random workloads that aren't cache friendly I'd expect the M1 to win.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ianhowson on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:49PM (#25293715)
They might embarrass today's Threadripper. They don't exist yet, at least not outside an Apple lab. AMD's not sitting on their hands, either.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by walshemj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:25PM (#25296103)
Then there will be 64/128 5990x parts out
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:42AM (#25289904)
>Wait for an 8-core (or the rumored 12 core) variants. Those will embarrass your threadripper.

It will not, my TR has 64 cores 128 Thread and you know whats the best thing? 128GB Ram...and imagine that..they aren't even soldered...and i even can exchange my GPU..or slap in 2 others.

And if apple ever brings out a M1 Workstation, i can probably buy 3 other Server/Workstations with that money.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by valuearb on Thursday December 03, 2020 @12:04PM (#25291183)
Your TR is what, 280 watts TDP? nearly 20 times more than a M1. And is 30% slower in single core.

Firestorm Cores use less than 4 watts each. A 16 firestorm core Mx will produce roughly the same multicore performance as your TR, with a less than 70 watt TDP.

And a $65 M1 dusts a 4800h that costs over 4x as much and using 1/3 the power. Top end ThreadRippers cost $2,000 to $3,000 each. You can bet an Apple Mx ThreadRipper killer isn’t going to cost more than $500 given it only needs 4x the cores of the $65 M1.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hajile on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:39PM (#25292683)
At scale, cores are only a small part of the equation.

https://images.anandtech.com/doci/13124/IF%20Power%20EPYC.pn...

Given that scaling, you're looking at 140w between 64 cores which is right at 2w per core. The all-core turbo for TR is 3GHz. If we assume linear scaling on M1 cores, if you dropped them in to replace the x86 cores and the had to reduce from 3.2GHz at 4w down to 2w per core, the all-core turbo would be a mere 1.6GHz AND about a third less cache per core.

TSMC claims 30% less power going from 7nm to 5nm. That means those x86 cores power usage drops from 2w to 1.4w. With the same linear scaling and 4w at 3.2GHz, the M1 design is now operating at 1.1GHz competing with a part that is still 3GHz and the M1 still has only 3mb of cache per core instead of 4.5mb.

Now, I'm betting that actual power usage is 3w which bumps frequency up to 1.5GHz. Still half the frequency, but possibly close enough in performance to Zen 3 at that frequency.

EDIT: It's apparently 3.45w during cinebench according to these benchmarks.

https://twitter.com/panzer/status/1328715510100344833

I'm betting that if they didn't bottleneck on the IO that the M1 would perhaps be faster, but at that scale, interconnects are a much, much larger issue than the cores themselves.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by hajile on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:55PM (#25293805)
Adding on to that

Zen 3 chiplet is 4.15B transistors. The consumer IO die is 2.09B transistors. The Threadripper IO dies is 8.34B transistors. M1 is 16B transistors. A14 is 11.6B transistors. That difference is mostly 2 firestorm cores/cache, 4 GPU cores, another DDR4 controller, and some Thunderbolt/PCIe.

Taking a ruler to a die shot and multiplying that area by transistor density (16B/119mm^2) gives us somewhere around 500M transistors per core plus 3mb of cache. Adjusting out to 4.5MB per core to match Zen 3 adds another 75-100M transistors.

Zen 3 gives 518M transistors per core, but that includes interconnects. Taking a ruler to the core reveals about 14% of the die is interconnect, SMU, and wafer tests (about 580M transistors). Subtracting that from 4.15B and dividing into even core/cache gives 446M transistors per core.

We'll assume an identical IO cost of 8.5B transistors and 150M transistors of interconnect per core. (64 * (600 + 150)) + 8500 is 56.5B transistors and 420mm^2 total area. A zen 3 chip with similar densities would be 310mm^2.

No matter how you slice and dice that, Apple's chip is going to be significantly more expensive than AMD's chip. Thinking anything different is a pipe dream.

EDIT: also note that formal verification adds a lot to chip pricing.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by kllrnohj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:48PM (#25292817)
> Firestorm Cores use less than 4 watts each.

This is just not true. A mini going from idle to a full single-core load is a power increase of 6W. A heavy multicore load hits over 25W.

> A 16 firestorm core Mx will produce roughly the same multicore performance as your TR

With what fantasy math? 30% faster single core performance would be 16 * 1.3 = ~21 equivalent TR cores. It'd be less than half the performance of a 64 core ThreadRipper.

> And a $65 M1 dusts a 4800h that costs over 4x as much and using 1/3 the power

https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph16252/119365.png

M1's single-core performance is very strong. But not enough to overcome a ~2x or greater core deficit, either, not at all.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by foobarian on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:10PM (#25293116)
On-die memory is pretty much their one ace in the hole that nobody else will have the guts to match. Intel can't because their fabs are behind, and AMD probably doesn't have the resources to fork their architectures and/or piss off the server integrators.

I can't live without 64GB in my desktop and would love to have more, so the new Macs are not for me.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by kllrnohj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:32PM (#25293447)
M1 isn't using on-die memory[1]. It's on-package, and likely little more than just off-the-shelf Micron or Samsung dram modules that are just soldered instead of socketed.

1: https://d3nevzfk7ii3be.cloudfront.net/igi/ZRQGFteQwoIVFbNn (from https://www.ifixit.com/News/46884/m1-macbook-teardowns-somet... )

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by foobarian on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#25293882)
Thanks for the correction, that's a big difference. Still a severe limit but seems more hopeful for larger options in the future.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by p1necone on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:59PM (#25293868)
"$65 m1" where are you getting this number from? You can't buy an m1 CPU from a store and slap it in a system, you have to buy it in a $1000 laptop.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by valuearb on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:40PM (#25296284)
It's a pretty accurate cost estimate from those tracking Ax series costs. A chip AMD sells for $300 doesn't cost AMD $300 to make, but being a public company their gross margins tell us it costs roughly $150.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by p1necone on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#25296402)
But you were comparing this theoretical production cost to the retail cost of other chips, that doesn't make sense.

Hardware companies don't charge cost + some reasonable markup, they charge whatever the market is willing to pay for it. I highly doubt Apple would release some hypothetical "threadripper killer" at a price any lower than they needed to to compete.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by valuearb on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:16PM (#25311024)
My point is that someone building a Threadripper PC has to pay $2,000 to $3,000 just for the CPU.

Lets assume that all the other parts, high speed RAM, SSD, power supplies, cooling, motherboard, etc cost another $500, and that operations, assembly, marketing etc average 20% and the manufacturer aims for a 5% margin. So they sell their low end Threadripper PC for $3300, and their high end Threadripper for $4,700.

Then Apple comes along and makes it's own high core count versions of the M1 (lets call them the M16 and M24) for $1,000 and $1,500 with similar performance to the Threadrippers. When Apple builds high end Mac Pros out of the, they also spend $500 for other parts, giving total parts cost of $1,500 and $2,000, it marks them up 50% for their typical margins, and sell them for $3,000 and $4,000 and have the same performance as the ThreadRippers from the lowest margin manufacturers at for 10-15% less.

And on top of that, the M16 and M24 use less power and generate quite a bit less heat than the Threadrippers. They don't need any fancy cooling systems. That can lead to smaller packaging and even more cost savings.

Obviously when Apples 16 and 24 Firestorm core Mx chips come out newer Threadrippers will have evolved to smaller process as well, and that will help increase their performance, while reducing cost and heat. But there is little doubt that Apple's Mac Pros will be much more competitive price and performance-wise at that time, and if they keep leveraging TSMC first there is a significant risk that they actually take some of their laptop cost/performance advantage up to Threadripper levels.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by thu2111 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @12:32PM (#25291652)
How does that matter though? His machine isn't sitting on his lap or running on a battery. Electricity isn't that expensive.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by valuearb on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:42PM (#25296315)
It matters because its not just adding electricity, its adding heat. Pretty clearly Apple can add a whole bunch of Firestorm cores to future M1 derivatives and still fit in smaller power/heat budgets that current generation Ryzen and Threadrippers operate in.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by thu2111 on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:25AM (#25300521)
Maybe. I don't know enough about CPU design to argue with that. There are others elsewhere in this thread saying that a lot of the energy and heat goes on the communications systems and other resources you need more of when you ramp up the core count.

I suspect we'll never know. Apple have shown little interest in anything other than prosumer workloads for a long time. I doubt they'll be making an M1 server platform anytime soon.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by valuearb on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:19PM (#25311036)
I have to somewhat concede your last point. What percentage of AMD sales are Threadrippers in any year?

It's possible Apple just doesn't think the investment in a 30 core CPU is worthwhile and stops around 16 cores, which would still be higher than any i7 or any i9 ever made.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by ogre_codes on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:39PM (#25295486)
> And if apple ever brings out a M1 Workstation, i can probably buy 3 other Server/Workstations with that money.

Based on the MacBook Air/ Mac mini/ MacBook Pro pricing, I don't think this is the case.

Apple has delivered a significantly faster MacBook Air for the same price as the previous generation. Not only did they increase the CPU speed, they essentially doubled the performance of their the SSD while maintaining their base price.

Apple dropped the price of the base mini by $100 while delivering a significantly faster Mac mini.

I suspect whatever Apple delivers for their top end machines will be equal or lower price to their current Intel machines.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by free2OSS on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:49PM (#25293719)
I'm completely with you.

The hardest programs to run will not benefit here.

I don't need chrome to open up 0.1s faster.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:36PM (#25294426)
Well it's really good for a laptop, but praising it as the fastest and best cpu is just rubbish.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by Skunkleton on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:54PM (#25297172)
It is fair to lump Linux in there. Linux is supported on pretty much every largish Arm system other than Apples, at least if you include Android Linux. No other Arm system comes close to matching the M1 in terms of performance.

I don't think that is an indictment of Linux. It is likely if the specs for the M1 were released, Linux could wring more performance out of the M1 than MacOS. At least in some workloads.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by cbhl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:07AM (#25289510)
I think in the last year or so we hit an inflection point for ARM performance that makes it acceptable.

The Raspberry Pi 4 / Raspberry Pi 400 are halfway decent to use. The Lenovo Chromebook Duet is probably the first ARM-based Chromebook where I haven't felt constrained to keeping only three tabs open (and although it still struggles with some of the largest spreadsheets and dashboards at work, it is a delightful second-screen device).

But I think the M1 still has an edge because of the vertical integration between software and hardware -- if you previously wrote an app against Core Video or Metal, it should get hardware acceleration once you recompile it for the M1. Whereas if similar accelerators were exposed in Linux or Windows you'd probably have to write against a new custom API/library (such as nvenc).

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by refulgentis on Thursday December 03, 2020 @08:50PM (#25298027)
I don't understand this _extremely_ common viewpoint: Intel has been putting out awesome fanless chips for Windows and ChromeOS for a couple years now, and Tiger Lake scores ~1400 single threaded/3700 multithread on 4 cores in GeekBench. M1 is __awesome__ but it's exactly what you'd expect from a Tiger Lake die shrink, which is coincidentally, the same die M1 is on.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by piokoch on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:32AM (#25289777)
I am not sure if the derogatory tone is fair. This is just example how progress works. Not that long time ago Apple had to be saved by some pennies thrown by Microsoft. Not that long time ago Apple was moving from Motorola processors to Intel ones.

There is nothing bad that someone stayed behind. Someone has to stay behind if we want progress. No reason to insult predecessors.

Planc and Dirac weren't making fun of Newton. Minitel was used in France as some simple version of Internet years before Internet was created. Was Minitel bad? Should we make fun of it?

Was Minitel standing in its underwear in front of Internet? Has Dirac stolen Newton pants?

Intel made a lot of great stuff. Now Apple is making great stuff (or, to be precise, TSMC does). Next year someone else is going to make great stuff. Maybe Apple maybe not.

Intel and AMD chips are not that far behind, depending on what benchmark is used, even though they use older 14/10 or 7nm technology.

I also really hate the concept of not being able to upgrade RAM - If I use Mac and I need more RAM I need to throw away my old Apple laptop and buy a new one. So I have to spend way more money, not to mention impact on environment.

So, today, I am still choosing Intel/AMD computer, I can install whatever operating system I wish and upgrade my system to whatever configuration I dream about and I can afford now or in future.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by zepto on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:22AM (#25290459)
The point about being able to upgrade ram or upgrade to whatever you want doesn’t make sense.

A ram upgrade will never compensate for a less efficient memory architecture.

There is no CPU architecture other than Apple’s that will make your laptop faster because AMD and Intel are thermally limited, so there is nothing to upgrade to.

The only situation in which you are right, is if you are talking about a high end desktop tower.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:59PM (#25292947)
>The point about being able to upgrade ram or upgrade to whatever you want doesn’t make sense.

If my program needs 64GB of ram, your 8GB highly efficient "memory architecture" can do nothing about it...you have to know that even my gpu has 16GB alone. But i have to say that 8GB are probably enough for your Chrome Browser.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by zepto on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:50PM (#25293735)
Are you using a desktop tower?
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nix23 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:33PM (#25294387)
Yes tower form-factor.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by microtherion on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:54PM (#25293794)
> Not that long time ago Apple had to be saved by some pennies thrown by Microsoft.

Agree largely with the rest of your comment, but this particular event was more than 23 years ago. I'm sure a good number of readers of this thread is younger than that!

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by formerly_proven on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:29PM (#25292550)
It's actually really impressive how well Intel desktop CPUs still do considering they're still made on a (continuously improved) five year old process.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by simias on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:01AM (#25290167)
I agree with you but I basically filtered that as "typical Mac fanboy noise" and try to search for insightful content which I think this piece has, in spite of its "I have a shrine dedicated to Steve Jobs in my living room" tone.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by free2OSS on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:43PM (#25293635)
The whole narrative has changed over the last few weeks too.

"Fastest chip" uhh well no..

"Fast for this one thing", yeah it's 0.1s faster opening that program no one ever said was slow.

"It has good battery life"

So this is the new narrative? Are nerds constantly fighting back against Apple marketing and they are adapting?

Usually their marketing team just insists over and over. Maybe because this is actually measurable (unlike privacy and security) their legal team is holding the marketing team back.

Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nvarsj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:22PM (#25296067)
Such a silly argument. An M1 Mac embarrasses no one but prior Macbooks, as it only runs OS X. There is no useful comparison to Windows or Linux. It's as asinine as comparing a mobile phone performance to a desktop PC.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by buzzerbetrayed on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:29PM (#25296898)
How are 2 laptops running different operating systems not comparable? The similarities of a Windows laptop and a Macbook far outweigh the differences.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nvarsj on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:34AM (#25302053)
Because the software I use that works on Linux or Windows doesn't exist or cannot be run on OS X. CUDA doesn't even support OS X anymore. If I can't run my OS/software of choice, it doesn't matter how great M1 is.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by buzzerbetrayed on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:04AM (#25303829)
Oh so because this laptop doesn't work for YOU, anyone who compares it to Windows or Linux is making a "silly argument". Gotcha.
Re:M1 Macs: Truth and Truthiness by nvarsj on Friday December 11, 2020 @06:40AM (#25384628)
I think my original response was a bit overly dramatic. But my point still remains. I don't think you can compare an OS X based laptop to anything else. The software available is far too different, and OS X is much more locked down (and getting even more locked down).