Isn't the idea of building the "next big app" itself based on the same kind of get-rich-quick mindset those schemes are exploiting?
Only except for the "nomad lifestyle" or "selling courses", etc, it's supposed to happen by coding in a dingy apartment. But it's equally unlikely, and too starry-eyed, the tech nerd version of the kind of dream the stereotypical bus-arriving Midwestern teenagers had of "becoming famous in Los Angeles".
How about merely building a business? Think small indie developer or Basecamp at best, vs Facebook and Amazon.
I think I could have made roughly as good of a living being a plumber, an electrician, or a welder! A good electrician around here makes 150k a year. I think the best career advice I heard was pick something you can stand doing and work as hard as you can at it, try and be as good as you can, not measured against someone else but for your self. If you pick a career where expertise matters and it has demand and you work harder and smarter than other people you will do fine.
Different strokes, different folks.
These days, money isn't impressive. What you actually do in your life is. For some of it, some amount of money is important, and if you have plenty its easier to achieve. But that's about it. I live in place swarming with rich folks, both old rich and new rich, while being neither. Most of them live such boring lives it would be sad if I cared for them. Never once met one of them that I would want to swap my adventurous life with. Had to go through a bit of hardship to get where I am obviously but not that much.
What I want to say - striving to get rich from the start is a stupid strategy of a clueless person. Be good at something you do, and more importantly be good at living a great life, being a good kind person. Being rich becomes just a gimmick, whether it happens or not.
I was half-expecting the next sentence to be "Sign up for my webinar and I'll teach you how to make your life as fun as mine!"
Seriously though, what do you mean by "adventurous life"?
If the post you were replying to wasn’t composed while skydiving above shark-infested waters with a supermodel by their side, I’m going to be terribly disappointed.
It doesn't have to be that many (which is hard to manage with 100% employment), even 1 would suffice if done properly. I have a kid now, second possibly on the way, so even without covid some of this is/will be massively scaled down. But I still want to pick up new ones - right now its precision target shooting and archery.
Its more about mindset - if you feel you have a great life, money is just a tool to keep it. For that you don't need terribly much, heck some full time climbers live in camper vans for the whole time. On the other hand if you don't enjoy your life, money won't make it magically better, sometimes the opposite.
And no I don't sell some stupid coaching :) Those are just my own experiences
More people need to be told this.
The combination of work ethic, of risk tolerance, and of perseverance against ridiculous odds that is required to build a Tesla, or an Apple, or a Whatever, is extraordinarily rare
Agreed. For every tech millionaire there are a thousand guys who are just as smart and worked just as hard and it didn’t work out for whatever reason. Maybe their timing was off by a mere 6 months for example. There’s a lot of survivorship bias in what is in large part a lottery.
First job I had (1995) was "Classified Ads on the Internet" - back then it was expensive to host a website and hugely expensive to add CGI (I think Demon wanted maybe £300 a month for that?) and the money ran out after a year. If they'd been able to keep it funded for, say, another 2-3 years, until home internet was more accessible, I think they'd have been in a pretty good position to own UK classifieds on the web (at least for a while.)
I recently had a recruiter from color.com reach out to me...
If you aren’t well connected or hyper credentialed (or if you’re a minority founder), raising capital is very hard. It’s easier than it’s ever been, but it’s not « easy »
A lot of VC capital is democratized: an elected official appointed a pension fund manager who decided to allocate some funds to a particular VC firm.
It's a genuine question. Who's the poorest YC founder? Least family wealth, least angel/seed investment. Who genuinely managed to get YC funding without putting in any money of their own?
Generous subsidies for electrics in the US and other countries helped with that.
Like generous government money funnelled through NASA contracts helped Space X repeat what NASA did in the late 60s/early 70s, slightly improved, 40 years later...
And NASA hasn't used "5% GDP" for 40 years. It has been less than 1% since 1973. Actually scratch that, it has been less than 1% the federal budget, which is much much less than the GDP.
Of course all that 50-years of IP got handed to the "private visionaries" of SpaceX for free, or rather, along with money paid to them...
Standard Fed'Gov contract hustle -- provide a service for less than what they're currently playing and leach off that gob'mnt teat.
Can't turn around without bumping into an electric car / reusable rocket company these days.
>Yeah, just look at all the other profitable companies in the space which did it too!
Did those other companies in the space (of space) got NASA contracts and subsidies?
Butthurt emotions is not the same as lower quality of life (e.g. less access to food, entertainment, travel, housing, health, studies, taking care of kids/relatives, etc).
> In Ashlee Vance's biography of Elon Musk, it is claimed that the Musks' father, Errol Musk, provided them with US$28,000 during this time,[4]:Ch.4 but Elon Musk later denied this.[6] He later clarified that his dad provided around 10% of US$200,000 as part of a later funding round.[7]
I feel like someone who is able to get 90% of their funding round could either convince an existing investor in the round or convince someone else to join the round. This doesn't sound like money to "start Zip2" as you claim.
Also, note that Elon had to shower at a YMCA while starting up Zip2 (https://www.cnbc.com/2018/06/19/how-elon-musk-founded-zip2-w...). Does that really sound like a "trust fund baby" to you? I feel like a lot of the myths trying to tear down Elon Musk's successes are all sourced from Ashlee Vance's book, which in turn are based on, as I understand it, interviews of Errol Musk himself (the father).
Are there other people who could do it but were not in the right place in the right time or didn't have the right leverage (money, connections, etc.)? Lots. If you took away those parameters, if Elon was just an engineer working for Boeing with just enough money to go on vacation every year, then he probably wouldn't have founded Tesla. He'd be some middle manager somewhere like lots of other smart/capable people.
But that's the thing right? You aim to make the next big app, and fail into the comfortable existence of "merely" building a business, or aquihired. Certainly better than aiming for moviestar and ending up a waitress.
Perhaps, depending on the app, a ponzi scheme is based on wanting to get rich by taking advantage of people's gullibility and non-understanding of how ponzi schemes work.
I suppose some apps could have that kind of disregard for how users of the app are harmed, but I think in most cases people building apps also think they are helping their users in some way. Ponzi schemers know they're only helping themselves.
I think you're getting hung up on my qualifier of "big" -- really, I'd be very happy to make 250k yearly off of a project (a far cry from Basecamp's $25MM yearly revenue), but even ramen profitability is hard, let alone getting to quarter-of-a-million.
Or this talk from the Bandcamp guy about financial sustainability: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MaUkS-lr-ZM
WSB members have come to realize that so-called "financial professionals" by and large have no scrying crystal into the market. WSB got there because of the democratization of knowledge that the Internet has caused.
And before you cite some unicorn like Renaissance, that's generating 40% YOY for 20+ years, keep in mind that unicorns, while rare, do exist. Microsoft, Uber, Google, Apple, etc., so forth. How many "investment professionals" would have recommended you dump all your money into these companies when they were but fledging entities? Or even when they went through tough times?
No, I think WSB is doing a service to humanity. They're exposing the smoke and mirrors behind Wall Street.
Good on them.
The Hollywood-inspired folk concept of Wall Street is that they trade stocks. That’s what everybody in those big buildings in Manhattan does all day. They yell buy/sell orders into red phones and drink Scotch.
Except they don’t. Wall Street firms like Goldman Sachs make money by providing services such as mergers and acquisitions, IPOs, market making, etc. That is, they make money by selling shovels in a gold rush, not by speculating on where gold will be found. Other firms are in the business of buying and selling illiquid assets such as private companies and commercial real estate (with illiquid assets, there is far lower price efficiency, and thus it is possible to generate excess returns). Still others are in the business of managing people’s money for them—an industry which is mostly about managing volatility, not about generating excess returns (a pension fund usually cannot afford to have its portfolio go down by 50%, even if it’s temporary, so they’re not going to put it all in the S&P 500).
Proprietary trading (where firms use their own money to buy and sell public securities) has been in decline for decades at the big banks, precisely because they don’t have a scrying crystal, and they know it. Public stock trading on Wall Street is mostly the domain of companies in niches like high-frequency trading (such as Jane Street). HFT firms gain an edge through arbitraging different prices faster than anyone else (for example, sell Exxon in New York a few microseconds after oil futures drop in Chicago). In other words, the only people on Wall Street who do what Hollywood-Wall-Street does are the few who do have a scrying crystal.
WSB is not “exposing” anything except the fact that most people (understandably) have no idea what the financial industry does.
I am not super plugged into the financial industry so I can't say for certain, but I think while people may not understand the difference between traders shouting on phones, "wall street", and wealth management, people think about wealth management the most in the context of "wall street", because that's what they're personally most familiar with. They think that even though wealth management seems to me to be very decentralized and not really something physically centered around Wall St.
I think wallstreetbets is mostly a pretty unsophisticated subreddit (which somehow declined in quality even more as it grew) but I think the parent was valid in pointing out that they willingly eschew the old-school strategy of diversification + "value investing" done by a third party on your behalf and the new-school (boglehead) strategy of putting literally everything in the S&P 500 or a bond index with the allocation mix dependent on retirement date/age.
There has undoubtedly always been a group of people micromanaging their personal portfolios with less risk-averse strategies like this, and WSB mostly takes things way too far, but at least for me it exposed me to the idea that maybe I could personally do better picking stocks on my own than just blindly throwing everything into VOO (and for people not plugged into the online-personal-finance-geek community, it could be the first time they even realize they don't need to have a third party manage their investments for them).
If anyone wants to know that other reason, I used to be a mod there (low bar, but keep reading)
WSB existed in a void surrounded by personal finance forums full of the dumbest financially illiterate crowd being spoonfed Robert Kiyosaki and Suzi Orman all obviously sponsored by Vanguard. In fact, it still exists in that void. If you wanted to talk about trading volatility derivatives without being in some 1990s-layout investment banking forum, there was no place to go. WSB was the light, its forum rules specifically saying its the place where trading the VIX is normal.
That is its utility. A place for people with a risk tolerance slightly above an undocumented wage slave. Okay, that was hyperbole, I don't like personal finance forums and Wall Street Bets is the opposite of them. Not everyone is born sucking at basic money topics and not everyone is too risk averse to consider financial products outside of the mold. Actually, let's take it one step further, not everyone was raised around a stigma of money and maybe isn't completely ignorant as a product? Obviously that isn't the prevailing culture, and there aren't many communities that catered to it.
Anyway, outside of WSB the only other communities at the time were in trading guru chatrooms, the ones you subscribe to get into. Now everyone might be joking around but they are worshiping the guru. Its pathetic.
WSB was made for options traders to make jokes and wild trades that had a week to pay off. It then got co-opted by penny stock traders pretending like it was the new Yahoo finance board, and now it got co-opted again by the most denegerate options traders in history and it is marvelous! Its even better than what it originally was and the financial meme niche is new and hysterical.
Hopeless 20 year olds fueling the flame? Sure, that is pretty much what happened. I'm glad they made the venue, it is wildly popular now, and the options market is wildly liquid in ways I could have only dreamed of.
WSB has been duped.
While we're at it, quant firms occupy a family of trading strategies which are a superset of HFT; not all quants are market making, trading intraday or pursuing low latency strategies.
With all due respect, please stop perpetuating popular finance misconceptions of the Flash Boys variety. If this is something you'd like to learn more about, I suggest you read the following:
- https://blog.headlandstech.com/2017/08/03/quantitative-tradi...
- Flash Boys: Not So Fast
You can quibble with the academic arguments on whether or not this facilitates liquidity and price discovery (and therefore helps retail investors). Or you can just place a limit order and move on. Either way, nothing illegal or nefarious is happening. Just because they're purchasing order flow and executing your trade doesn't mean the national best bid and offer (NBBO) is being violated.
Just like if market makers say the only thing they do is flow, doesn’t really mean it’s the only thing they do.
I think the trick is to realize those glamorous selfies are mostly a mirage. If you were having the best day of your life on the beach, maybe, just maybe, you wouldn't be on your phone trying to get the perfect selfie.
Well said, but the optics are still there. The selfie is bound to get more hits on social media, more coverage, etc.
That's a bad example. By many measures retail investors have outperformed institutional investors since March. The simple reason is that options have a built in exit strategy, the thing that's missing when most people lose in scams - including Ponzi schemes!
On the flip side, why then do they outperform? High risk, high reward. Opportunities where you lose your entire principle, like out of the money options, turned out to be wildly underpriced, simply because institutions never buy them.
Anyway, I get it, those people are stupid. But they made money.
I don't think it's a bad example, because if you spend some time on that subreddit, you'll quickly realize people are literally gambling with their life savings. In no small part due to disillusionment and cynicism with the current economic realities -- we can no longer work at a stable company, marry a pretty wife, have a couple of kids, retire 40 years later, and live off of a plump 401k.
This is what nearly everyone in tech who isn't spending their free time shitposting about their side projects and the nuances of programming languages is doing. Sure you can't work your whole career at one company anymore but that's just a reflection of macroeconomic conditions, the stability is still there for the people who's skills are in demand. Pretty much no competent programmer, or electrician for that matter, is unwillingly unemployed for long enough to matter.
Saying this after 2008 is just empirically false. You do realize that people lost their entire 401(k)s, right? My dad worked at IBM for over a decade and was laid off. More recently, my buddy (late 20s) was laid off by IBM after working there for the past 7 years; I know people in their 40s and 50s (at big companies and startups alike) that were laid off at the drop of a hat once the pandemic hit.
I live in West LA and make a "comfortable" engineer's salary. Guess what, I'll never be able to afford a house here (unless one of my startups takes off or some other equally-unlikely miracle happens). I don't care if you blame this on "macroeconomic conditions," it just happens to be the reality of my generation. To touch on the loneliness/isolation angle, while doing the whole startup thing, particularly in my 20s, I was putting off dating; although I've recently said screw it: even if I die poor†, I'd rather be with someone.
I'm very much a libertarian "pull-yourself-up-by-the-bootstraps" entrepreneur's entrepreneur but let's be real: it's not surprising there's so much cynicism.
† Relatively, of course. I grew up in post-Communist Eastern Europe in actual poverty, so my life is much better than it used to be.
I find it hard to imagine someone making an engineer’s salary can not afford a house, even in LA.
The solution here is to move to Austin (which a ton of people have been doing recently) or just travel the world because, thankfully, I can do my job remotely (but many people cannot). This was actually my plan, but the pandemic kind of killed that -- maybe next year.
Professional, educated, well-off young people can't afford to buy houses in California (I've had this conversation with dozens of friends). Market forces or not, even as a part-time libertarian, it's clear to me that this isn't tenable and people are frustrated.
Not sure if your "should" is in the sense that logically it doesn't make sense to be, or that morally or ethically it had no right to be. For the first meaning, neighborhoods rise and fall in popularity based on trends, often driven by the tastes of young people, and is a natural cycle just like clothing fashion. Thus logically it should not be surprising that certain locations rise in housing costs as it increases in popularity. If you intend the second meaning, I'd be interested in your reasons.
> Your argument also doesn't work because most LA tech jobs are in Santa Monica.
I'd be interested in seeing the numbers, but there are a large amount of tech jobs in the South Bay area as well, along the 405 going south around Gardena and such.
> The idea that it should be status quo to commute to your job because you can't afford to live around where you work is nonsensical.
The problem is that traffic around Santa Monica is horrendous, making the housing more expensive. My previous commute from Torrance to Culver City was 40 min in the morning and 20 at night, but going from Culver City to Santa Monica was an extra half an hour. If you pick some of the worst traffic areas in LA, I don't think you should be surprised or incensed that people will pay to cut that traffic time down. It's an infrastructure problem, really.
> Professional, educated, well-off young people can't afford to buy houses in California
There are still lots of cities with affordable house prices, unless they insist on competing to live in the worst traffic areas of California.
Gambling, yes. But the stock market is not a ponzi scheme.
That depends on who you ask. https://www.hughescapital.com/the-stock-market-is-a-ponzi-sc...
> In 2010, its stock price was $20 and by 2017 had risen to $380 a share, yet Tesla reported a loss of $4.3 billion. How is this possible? The only way to explain this bizarre scenario is to recognize that the market is not efficient
I will pass on buying/reading that book based on this excerpt alone.
I am far away from a tesla fan (I actively encourage my friends/family to not buy teslas, or invest in tesla, etc), but saying "the only way to explain this" is pretty unbelievable.
I don't believe Tesla would be valued so highly or fluctuate so violently if the market was actually efficient.
Just to put some simple numbers on things, a commonly held expectation is that Tesla will grow revenue at ~50% a year until 2030 while maintaining high margins. At that point Tesla's revenue would be approximately 1T with perhaps 100B in net income. A fair valuation would then be around 3T, assuming there is still some future growth left.
This largely explains today's 500B valuation - if there is a 30% chance of this scenario playing out (and Tesla goes bankrupt in the other 70%) then this is a reasonable bet compared to buying other stocks.
As for the volatility, imagine if the average market participant changes their mind and believes that Tesla is only likely to achieve a 40% growth rate over the next decade. This would drop 2030 revenue and profits by more than 40% compared to the previous scenario, and today's stock price would fall significantly as well.
I am not expert enough to know, but just off hand declaring that something is "the only way" with literally no justification or reasoning puts a really bad taste in my mouhth
Been wondering lately, why is a position in a stable company also generally considered stable?
I mean, it’s a scalable system designed to survive, running on cash flow. Say load reduces, or flow reduces, wouldn’t it be only sane to immediately cut down on worker nodes? Why keep, except as strategic reserves?
I suppose because strategic planning up top used to be harder in the past so reserves tended to be large?
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/18/young-trader-dies-by-suicide...
Just sensible market behavior.
Most Americans have been so fully shut out of capital that they're practically begging for asset values to get rocked. They'll encourage it, even. (What do you think this lockdown backlash is, unconsciously?)
All of Disney's revenue streams shut down for 3 months and its stock went up. The market needs to be reflective of conditions and not simply the desperation to never see a bubble corrected, or people are going to start calling the bluff.
People don't understand how money comes from value created, in the long run. People think they can game the system. Everyone feels they are not a part of the average.
Not true, companies can create value, that value is reflected in the stock price. The economy is not zero sum. Did all the people that got rich off of apple, google, microsoft, nvidia, etc get rich because someone else lost money?
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/12/difference-inves...
Not that there is anything wrong with that. Just pointing out how I think your logic is flawed.
Many of the calls that have hit recently only capped out people’s gains - so yes there was an opportunity cost to that lost, but people didn’t literally lose invested capital. Not as much money as you think has gone into the red this year - even on the way down.
OR
The point of liquidity is to get people doing things, but the status quo today seems more like giant firms trading above our heads to manage the risk of rent-seeking on an increasingly precariously-positioned consumer class.)
Neither of his points seem based on Economic dogma shoved down your throat during undergrad.
was flagged, as it was neither inflammatory nor uncouth, but I agree with it. You seem to have an entirely elementary conception of the market and an inability to understand the ways those assumptions have fallen apart in the face of market and regulatory conditions.
People with invested capital aren't "hoarding" it. It actively invested.
No, the point of liquidity is to encourage an active market, which is exactly what it's doing. Not sure what "trading over our heads" even means.
They are absolutely not stupid. Everything they're doing is entirely rational. It doesn't seem that way, because clearly you're not in the same circumstances as they are. Neither am I.
However, I completely understand it. If you're 22-25, not married, and have far more liabilities than asset, you have no reason not to trade on high margin with an options play and try to turn $50,000 into $2 million or more.
If you lose the $50,000, you can recover. If you end up horribly in debt, you file for bankruptcy and move on.
Given the current state of affairs, its completely understandable.
The average retail investor might have outperformed institutional investors, but it's a leap to suggest that wsb outperformed institutional investors. Foe one, the average retail investor isn't buying otm options like wsb users are.
> The simple reason is that options have a built in exit strategy, the thing that's missing when most people lose in scams - including Ponzi schemes!
Not really? Options can have their value go to zero if they remain unexercised, just like if a ponzi scheme goes bust.
true. but as a person who plays with options, I should point out that when you buy an option contract, you don't want it to expire worthless.
However if you are an options seller, that is the best possible outcome.
Source please?
Together these can become oppression or existential life difficulty.
Do you realize that up until about 2 generations ago that nobody had fulfilling work? That work was just labour? 3 Generations ago you worked on the farm, or in the factory, or keeping the shop for meagre wages. In 1960 only about 8% went to university. In 1900 it was probably only 1%.
Literally we live in a world where people can be or do anything they want. This is the first time in history this was even thinkable.
'Having no prospects for retirement' ?? Retirement is a modern concept. 1.5 Generations ago you worked, retired and very quickly died! You lived a few years maybe and that was that. And there wasn't much in the way of support, expectations, or even things to do. Government workers expected 'full comp' in retirement because they only lived a few years. The notion has changed dramatically and it's why our finances are so out of order. You do realize that 'social security' is a very modern concept, right?
People are living literally '3rd lives' now, decades into retirement, and generally much more fulfilling.
'Healthcare'? We are only 2 generations into socialized medicine! Again, the fact most Westerners have access to great healthcare, most of their lives, means they are living at vastly higher standards of living than in any era.
My grandparents were born on farms, with no plumbing or running water, and not electricity. Taxes were extremely low, and most people didn't go to high school (my grandmother did). There was no social security/insurance/retirement. There was no socialized medicine whatsoever. We were barely into having antibiotics. People worked hard and died at 65 from the large variety of ailments which we can now treat, push off, work around etc..
And finally - home ownership - again - a very new concept, only a couple of generations in. 'Retail Banking' is a very modern convention to the point wherein 'owning your own home' is really a '1st generation' concept even in parts of the Latin world. 'Home ownership' was largely driven by 'new world' ideals (US/Canada) where the land was not spoken for - which was a major political idea.
'Social Isolation'? Try living on a farm, where there are almost no cars, and it takes 1/2 day by train to get to the nearest 10 000 person population centre. We are materially less isolated than ever before.
I don't doubt the notion of feeling isolated, but it's almost as though we need to chose our words better, because whatever we mean when we say 'isolation' it's literally not that, but I agree it's a growing problem. I suggest it's a growing problem of people not participating in their own cultures.
Unconditionally, life is materially better. Whether life is better overall, that's a hard thing to say, but we are undeniably 'rich' as a class of people (anyone reading this). We have the gift of massive surplus and bounty, it's now a matter of being able to socially make do with that.
I live in San Diego, and I've talked to hundreds of homeless people while doing volunteer work and photography. You would not believe how many people, though they may be mentally ill, are smart, honest, good people, who just got fucked by the system. They're out here scrounging for food and getting Hepatitis A and dying in the canyons and not getting any medical or dental care, and their lives are incredibly hopeless.
To take the Steven Pinker-ish approach, and talk about about how great everything is, comes off as ignorant/dismissive of these real problems. I'm not saying what you're saying isn't true, but the average person is (relatively) not better off than 50 years ago. See https://wtfhappenedin1971.com.
Do you see gangs of homeless children wandering your neighbourhood? Because that's 'what it used to be like'.
I am not denying that real problems exist.
I am not denying that individuals face real, life pain, of the timeless kind.
I'm saying that materially, on the whole, everything is better. Way better.
In the Victorian era there would be homeless children wandering the streets.
50 years ago there were still orphanages.
We really don't have that anymore: nearly all babies/very young children are adopted.
'Homelessness' is not a lack of wealth or resources - it's a) a social disorder and b) civic dysfunction.
FYI I live across the street from a Women's shelter and there are homeless in my neighbourhood. It's complicated.
'Everything is Better'. For the first time in history we can really say that we have excess material surplus of every kind.
But for those barely clinging on to society, and those who haven't had the chance to accumulate real wealth, life is still pretty hard. Or, at least, a millennial may find life seems hard in comparison with the Baby Boomer generation. Many Baby Boomers lived stable, tracked lives in the postwar economy, and have now accumulated vast generational wealth.
If there's a generation that grew up in a bubble, it's the Baby Boomers, and you'll see this typified by the "in my day, I worked my way through college and bought a house while working my job at the coffee shop" sentiment. Millennial and younger generations just don't have this chance at stability and building wealth at a young age.
Also, drug addiction, lack of any care for mental illness (even sanatoriums), and homelessness of the kind we see now are unique problems that started around the same time as the "war on drugs."
While some specific cities may have their heads up their butts with regard to public policy resulting in more visible homeless the living conditions of the "almost homeless" and working poor have very much improved since the early 1970s (as far back as my knowledge goes).
You can say what you want about the blue collar middle class (off-shoring and student debt have hit them hard over the past decades) but things have very much been improving up for the poor as a whole even though some poor people are unlucky enough to live in backwards places where things have gotten worse locally.
The downfall of the middle class is the downfall of everyone except the super-rich. Some kind of Portugal drug model / New Deal-type infrastructure plan would be necessary to fix this problem, which is present all across the US. Why do you think Donald Trump got elected? It wasn't bigots in the Midwest — it was impoverishment.
See:
— https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/14/us/homeless-busing-seattl...
— https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2017/dec/...
— https://www.mintpressnews.com/500-homeless-mental-patients-w...
a) There was no 'downfall' of the middle class and
b) Everyone with a job got materially richer, just not in assets like the 'super rich'.
We used to have smaller working + bigger middle + smaller upper, but now it's levelled out but a lot of middle class people have moved up.
Material surpluses for anyone with a job have gone up dramatically. Walmart has increased the material standard of living of working people hugely.
For those 'without jobs' - it's been hard.
And those with assets - it's been disproportionately good.
But the material surpluses in the form of better products and lower real prices to the masses means higher standard of living.
The number skills that are useful today are also less than they used to be. The need for actually skilled manual labor has been outsourced to China, Taiwan, and increasingly India.
And don't forget the swindle of universities — 18 year olds signing themselves away to lifelong debt to party, drink, and learn at an institution that couldn't care less about their future prospects. People who leave college with degrees in anything but highly desirable fields are learning they've been lied to about the importance of a degree.
It seems that they got fucked by mental illness, not by "a system". Not being helped is not the same as "getting fucked".
Once again proving my point: flippant assertions that 'the world is hard' when actual data suggests just the opposite.
Taking your example, suicide, we're very materially, measurably, scientifically, much better off.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_in_the_United_States#:....
[2] https://www.newscientist.com/article/2207007-us-suicide-rate...
More importantly, my claim was the change in suicide "among people coming of age." Suicide of minors has never been higher, ever.
[0]: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/296539307_Suicide_r...
The longer-term picture is that the millennials (born 1980 or later) will be the first generation in a very long time to have a lower standard of living than their parents did.
These are the kinds of problems civil unrest is made of.
Go and ask people who grew up then. It wasn't that great.
You're literally extending the plight of someone 'graduating in 2008' to 'Jews dying in the holocaust' as though they are on some similar scale which I think helps prove my point.
The economy is fucked. Its working because its artificially propped up by the Fed and the European Central Bank, to a lesser degree. People know this because the stock market continues to perform well, but individuals are mostly static. Social mobility in the United States is at all-time low and this is well-reported.
Student loan debt has ballooned 2000% over the past 50 years.
Housing prices, be it to buy or rent, have ballooned by 200% in the past 50 years.
Climate change is a serious concern, and absolutely no one can say with any degree of scientific certainty what the long-term (100-300 year range) effects will be.
Now I told you all that... to tell you this.
They're being robbed of hope. People can endure through hardships unimaginable... as long as they have hope. When you take away someone's hope, you take away their life.
You say 2008 wasn't bad because being lynched for being having to drink from the colored fountain is worse. So I tell you that's not so bad because the holocaust was even worse. And maybe the holocaust wasn't even such a big deal because <insert some other tragedy>. See where that leads us?
It also makes things harder for those of us that don't want to run Ponzi schemes: How does one break out when everyone's taking glamorous selfies in Thailand but I'm working in a dingy apartment trying to build the next big app?
It's a tough situation on all sides with no obvious solutions.