My general takeaway is to see the EPA range as a useful, albeit unrealistic, indicator. Essentially nobody gets the EPA range, either because they choose not to go the speed limit, they accelerate harder than the EPA test factored in, or the vehicles drain some juice while parked.
The data: For the hundreds of Nikola trips with an average speed of 60 mph, the actual MPGe was about 102. Once you get up to a 75 MPH average trip speed, the MPGe drops to 94. And by 80 MPH the MPGe drops to 77. (avg over all Tesla types)
As a bit of "anecdata", I've driven trips where I hit my range on the nose, just to show I could, but the driving is less fun and I was going slower than traffic. I don't drive that way anymore.
What's most striking to me as someone who has heard over and over again about how air resistance is a X^2 property, is the extent to which short (and presumably slow) trips punch above their weight in terms of range consumed per mile. From what I can tell, the actual cost here is the fixed cost of booting up some systems and electronics, and the variable costs of running them over fewer miles can make the MPGe drop. Starting and continuing to run the AC adds up!
edit: have had some people ask. The app can be found at https://download.nikolaapp.com
I can also post data / graphs or make a blog post about that if people have more requests. Let me know what you'd like to see!
That makes total sense. What I think most people don’t realize is that power is force times velocity and the force you need to apply to maintain a given velocity is equal to the friction plus the drag. Unfortunately, drag increases with the square of the velocity and so when you go faster you need way more power. This translates directly into increased battery drain for an EV.
The problem may be further exacerbated by the greatly increased mass of an electric vehicle and the potential for the batteries to overheat.
Wow never knew this is true, any sources where I can read more about this?
(ETA: The search term I was forgetting was "jaywalking", because AAA was instrumental in the creation of jaywalking as a crime, related to the goals of allowing faster car travel versus speed limits. https://www.salon.com/2015/08/20/the_secret_history_of_jaywa...)
Two factors.
First, if you go 10% faster, air resistance may be 21% higher, but you only take 10/11 for spending 10% more energy per mile. So higher speeds cost less than you'd naively think.
Second, at low speeds we start and stop a lot. Coming to a full stop requires actually putting physical brakes on and losing energy. The heavier your car, the more that this costs you. For slower traffic, if you look at distance traveled, number of full stops and energy, I bet that you can fit a linear model in 2 variables that fits the data better and gives you a sense of how much coming to a stop costs you.
Either way, its 21% increase in energy consumed per mile in this case.
wipes egg off of face
The nissan leaf has an energy usage display that breaks down energy into driving, climate and other systems.
http://www.nissanusa.com/vlp-assets/media/vehicles/2016/leaf...
When you apply a load to a cell, the voltage sags. Heavier load, bigger sag. When a battery is operated at low voltage, it loses efficiency - the total power available decreases significantly. If you ever buy batteries for, say, building your own EV, you’ll pay a lot of attention to the C values - C1 is the capacity of the cell if it is discharged in 1 hour, C100 is the capacity at 100 hours, etc. - and there is a big difference between these values - it’s non-linear, and while the difference between C100 and C10 might be a 30% loss of available power, between C1 and C10 you’re closer to 50% - a 65% loss overall between C100 and C1.
Obviously in an EV C2-C10 are probably your most relevant numbers - but the difference in available power is significant over that range, and if you’re driving harder, putting more load on the battery, your range will be lower.
Source: design engineer at EV company.
This is most often seen if you remotely turn on the climate control to warm the car up in the morning, when the car is still plugged in after overnight charging.
While I love sentry mode and think it's a great feature, it keeps the electronics awake. In some cases this can cause double digit per day mileage drain. Tesla has clearly been working on this though, as the numbers have improved.
Could this be due to the battery not being at the ideal temperature on short trips? I always noticed that the efficiency of my car is lower for the first 10 miles when commuting to and from work. Since it happens in both directions, it can't be due to terrain or road type so I was guessing battery temperature.
My guess is it's often cold enough for the battery to need to warm up to be efficient, but not cold enough to make it worth it to turn on the battery heater. (Your point still holds in that case)
A piece of data I happen to remember, far fewer than 10% of supercharges have the battery heater on for any period of time at all.
My (non-Tesla) EV only gives me trip watt-hour per mile (Wh/mi)
Using an mpge to Wh/mi converter [1], 102 mgpe = about 330 Wh/mi, 94 = 385 Wh/mi and 77 = 437 Wh/mi.
My car (Ford Focus EV) gives about 275 (conservative driving) to 350 Wh/mi. It usually gives me about 80 - 130 miles range, and the stated average is 110. I get the 80 during the colder months in a warmer clime. When I was commuting into the office (pre-COVID) I was usually doing about 70-80mph.
When we had a Tesla in the garage to install some aftermarket equipment on it, this parked power drain astonished me. Several miles PER DAY.
And we have the nerve to bother TV makers about a watt here and a watt there.
I’d love to see them!
the reason for the cutoff is that because it's pretty hard to have a trip with an AVERAGE speed above 80mpg. It's very rare in my large dataset.
Can I ask:
* Which car models are included?
* You write that your methodology for this chart looks at average speed for the whole trip; if this is true, would it be feasible to apply a different methodology and divide your data up into much smaller chunks (e.g. 30 seconds) and calculate the MPGe for each chunk?
* Is there any way I could calculate a similar graph for my own car? Can I get a graph like this from your app? (I'd personally be super-interested in both being able to access my own car's curve, and also explore a 'dashboard' of the whole dataset with filters by (e.g.) model, wheel size, etc.
(Since the data is smoothed, an outlier datapoint could influence speeds 2mph in each direction)
As a bit of anecdata here: Parking inside vs. outside seems to have a big affect. A slightly chilly garage vs. a cold soak outdoors understandably are quite different.
Over a 4.5 hour period if I can cruise at 75 mph, I will be 44.5 miles ahead of another car which departs at the same time, for the same destination, at 65 mph.
Presumably the Vauxhall mentioned would provide exactly the measured MPG when driven at the correct speed by any owner in the real world - hence the 'flat spot' noticed.
The defeat concept you're referring to (presumably VW's) was set to only function during a test, and not in the real world (AIUI).
Perhaps about 5% of regular vauxhall driving was in those flat spots...
Seems the same to me.
I don't really have a problem with my effective range being less do to my driving style as long as it's predictable (and it is).
It's one thing to have the engine+drivetrain efficiency peak at 70. But for total efficiency to be worse at 60, despite massively reduced wind resistance, is pretty suspicious.
But the most efficient way to drive a gas car is to speed up, then turn the engine off and coast down to a slower speed, then engine on for quickly moving up to a fast speed again.
Of course, the only way you'd want to drive like that is if you are alone in the desert and need to get to a gas station.
There's also self-discharge and other consumption when not driving, which may be an even worse problem for EV efficiency. I wonder what percentage of total EV electricity consumption is wasted while the car is off.
Car & Driver: https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a30874032/porsche-tayca...
There's a number of other tests that show that Tesla almost never lives up to its EPA range.
The leaf did lots better around town, but it was a relatively small and light car. The battery was charged significantly higher and drained significantly lower than tesla batteries. There was degradation. At highway speeds it was significantly less efficient and range anxiety became a real problem. On trips usable range was much less than the specs because: you couldn't drain it all the way because logistics was a real problem. You also couldn't charge it all the way because a "fast" charger would take as much time to charge to 80% as from 80%-100%. Range was an issue and being an engineer or mathematician helped. Around town 3.5-4.5 miles/kwh was common, on the freeway you would hit 2 at 70mph.
The tesla actually had freeway speeds. Where a leaf would have you in the right hand lane trying to go as slow as possible, the tesla would have you looking out for speed traps. The battery was huge. You could plan your trips with the help of the nav computer and your battery would generally stay in 20-80% range. On long trips it was better to stay 10-60% because the battery would charge faster before it started tapering off. By tapering off, I mean 2-3x the max the leaf would charge on a good day. I will say that tesla battery size makes it possible to care for the battery. It would be uncommon (and sort of bad maintenance) to charge to 90% let alone 100%. Same for below 20%. Telsa shuts off some automatic climate features below 20%
Oh, and tesla drivers are a diverse group. Just talking to them, some will average close to 200 wh/mi, while others will be above 400wh/mi. climate and foot weight make a difference. Besides behavior, there are also several tesla settings that will increase your range. Range mode, different driving settings [chill | standard | sport | ludicrous | ludicrous+ ] depending on the vehicle.
I can see it being worse than whatever people who are buying leafs are trading in but I can't see it being that bad overall.
I was commuting with a plug in hybrid and it was very similar. If traffic was bad, I could make it nearly home on nearly all electric, but if traffic was light, the battery would be drained even if it was running in normal hybrid mode. Not a problem for me, the gas engine works fine, but it would be an issue for a leaf.
It's a bit of a shame to see so many Tesla fans point to its supposed inefficiency based on the EPA range. It feels like the tables have turned 180 since the Top Gear scripted test days; it was shitty when Tesla was attacked with FUD back then and it's shitty when the Taycan is today.
But regardless of the reason, its EPA range proportional to WLTP and real world driving is very low compared to other EVs. It doesn't point to poor efficiency, just a corner case of EPA testing.
While extrapolated from 100 miles, this Car and Driver test [1] puts a 6% gap between the 2020 Model S and Taycan, compared to a 70% difference in EPA range. Extrapolation sucks as a method, but there's no way it would mask a true 70% range difference - the Porsche would be close to empty at the end of the test.
Considering the Tesla costs just over half as much, it's still a home run for Tesla. They're the ones to beat and by all accounts are likely to stay that way.
https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/comparison-test/a307994...
The point is Tesla has increased their range yet again. There is no disputing this fact. If people were buying Teslas before, they're getting even more value out of it now.
It seems most people here find this EPA discrepancy a great justification for criticising Tesla, but I highly doubt anyone owns a Tesla who is doing the criticising.
Most Tesla owners were happy to buy the Model S at 265 EPA range. Now its 400, almost 50% more. Who cares if that actually means 300 miles? That 300 miles is still awesome, and if its good enough to buy a Tesla, buy one. If not, don't.
Looking at the first article the lead commenter posted that compared "real-world" to EPA ranges, Tesla misses the EPA range by an average of 22%. Other vehicles that miss the EPA range average 4.5% off.
Of course the EPA range is as much an estimate as the testing is and conditions change between testing and real world scenarios, but what's so different with the Tesla vehicles during EPA testing compared to real-world testing to cause such a large drop-off compared to other vehicles.
We can rightly question the EPA testing methodology in the first place meaning, what are they running (or not running) that regular people would. For example, does EPA not run the A/C during the test? I'm not accusing the Tesla A/C from excessive battery draw, as it's just an example.
Yes, having a larger battery is welcome, so with an EPA range of 400 miles, then we can real-world expect 320 miles.
*Quick addendum: I'm not a big fan of these types of articles and can more then accept that the testing the article performed was "flawed" as well. But we do need better, consistent range tests.
Tesla should be criticized for every number they inflate. Every time they pull some marketing crap, they should be called out on it.
If it's such a benefit as you write, why do they feel the need inflate the numbers?
What happened to honesty among engineers? Understated performance, instead of throwing around huge numbers that are technically possible but are nothing short of misleading for the consumers? I suppose it clearly works for Tesla, but my support goes to the company who claims a conservative number that I'm actually likely to exceed in reality.
So how is Tesla at fault here, if their cars do well. Btw, you can get the EPA range if you drive around 55-60mph... So it is misleading?
The EPA test methodology is actually pretty sound. It includes things like multiple wide-open throttle accelerations to highways speeds. The problems appear to be lack of independent testing and the existence of loopholes mentioned above. Companies like Honda seem to always beat EPA #s and Ford always seems to fall very short of the numbers.
I'm not sure what you'd expect, given that every single defined test can be gamed. 'Real world' is different for everyone. And if you drive 80mph, every single car ever will underperform compared to the stated EPA range/mpg.
But, even at mild temperatures cruising at steady speed on mostly level terrain, I generally see 325 Wh/mi. If I cruise at 75, it's 350 Wh/mi. The rated range can only be achieved by hitting about 250 Wh/mi.
Here's a chart with speed/efficiency measurements for most Tesla model/wheel configurations:
In the winter I run snow tires, but then there's the low temperature and corresponding use of the climate control that destroys range. And in the summer I've got the performance wheels and tires installed. So I'll never see optimal range. But Tesla probably shouldn't be quoting 300+ miles of range for the Performance model, either.
Given the climate where I live is pretty mild, and snow is relatively rare and short-lived, I've given some consideration to ditching the performance tires and snow tires both and replacing with 19 inch Conti DWS to run year-round. If I got away with that on my Camaro, it would probably work on my AWD Tesla, LOL.
Yeah, I'd imagine running all seasons on 19s or 18s ought to be fine, especially with the killer traction control... This would be my plan in the event I were getting a P3D (trying to hold out for Cybertruck...)
P.s., the way you describe the summer tires ripping up the pavement gave me a chuckle - I'll have to remember that next time I'm talking to someone about the difference with the summer tires!
To add to this, it's especially difficult to exercise the restraint necessary to drive economically in a fun and/or comfortable car. Before I got a comfortable car I didn't understand why BMW/Mercedes/Audi drivers drive so fast. Now I do. It doesn't really feel like you're moving very fast in those cars.
Electric cars can regen brake and so recover some energy in stop/go traffic, but they're still more efficient at constant low speed than stop/go at low speed.
ICE vehicles only get better economy on the highway because they have no regen braking and their engines are more fuel efficient at highway speeds.
For this reason the target speed for efficiency had to be 56 mph. For that would be important for comparisons. Fleet buyers were important in those days so a 'rep-mobile' able to sip the fuel as it went about crossing the country at sensible A road and motorway speeds was what was wanted. If a manufacturer wanted to sell into this market then the 56 mpg figure had to be available.
I am not sure fuel efficiency was discussed in quite the same way in the U.S. market during these times and there weren't the same tax incentives to get companies buying 'rep-mobiles' so the auto-sector could be stimulated.
Europe wasn't the EU in those days with each major country having different tax regimes for cars.
So it's a bit more honest in that regard... Those days where I got to go 80mph the entire freeway segment and get home really quickly my mpge suffered a lot.
It depends also on how much you use the available acceleration features.
As you will know there is quite a range of acceleration available, from barely pushing the pedal and matching normal cars, to putting the pedal about 1/4 of the way down and smoking even most fast cars, to putting the pedal down more than halfway and having a beast in your hands.
I’m sure the EPA is pretty conservative and this is where the literal meaning of ymmv comes into play.
The Tesla Model S is one of the fastest-accelerating cars available at any price. If you drive it like a normal person and obey the speed limit (approximately), you will get close to the EPA rating depending on weather etc. If you actually use all the power it has (and you manage not to get pulled over), you will have lower range and you'll need to buy new tires every 6 months.
Therefore Tesla cannot "overestimate" EPA range.
If you think that EPA range is not accurate, then you can blame EPA.
And since you bring science, who are "they" and in what way their tests are more scientific that EPA's tests?
Actually in the recent Model S test prior to this one, Tesla discovered through examination of the data logs of the car that the EPA had carelessly left the key in the car all night while it was parked during testing that spanned multiple days, leading to an artificially low number as the car was unable to sleep at the level it normally should be able to when parked.
This whole episode happened because the EPA was doing the testing… I don't know where that leaves your anecdote. It's just false, I think. I love Wikipedia and even have a monthly donation to them, but your link is not reflecting what happened with Tesla here.
"Manufacturers test their own vehicles—usually pre-production prototypes—and report the results to EPA. EPA reviews the results and confirms about 15%–20% of them through their own tests at the National Vehicles and Fuel Emissions Laboratory."
Wait a minute...
Which by the way would have totally sufficed to invalidate the original argument; the ranges are largely self reported, but they do get checked. The process ensures that the ratings broadly reflect EPA's testing methodology, otherwise you'd see the cars that do get tested having abnormally low range at best, and fines and other action taken by the agency at worst.
A Wikipedia link might be a crappy form of "proof", but as near as I can tell the parent post just made up how he or she thought the process worked. If someone says Caesar lived in the 9th century, a link to the relevant page actually is a valid response. If that person comes back with some source material that says otherwise, then you'll need to try harder.
I've made a spreadsheet to compare the energy usage of my 2019 3 SR+ to my old 2014 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16JLSzoWA0154ZUU3ahJ_...
But EPA rating is a mix, not a freeway rating. Though fueleconomy.gov has specific numbers for freeway speeds as well.
My venerable 2017 S90D is listed with 294 miles range, that's 473 Km, or 19.8 KWh/100Km. My last trips to Italy used pretty much exactly 20KWh/100Km (2500-3000 Km each time, more than 90% highway at 120-150Km/h [sorry Italy]). In the city I'm usually below that on average.
Tesla Model 3 Performance vs RWD consumption - Real Driving Data from 233 Cars
https://forum.abetterrouteplanner.com/blogs/entry/22-tesla-m...
Model 3 Consumption and Charging
https://forum.abetterrouteplanner.com/blogs/entry/13-model-3...
Tesla Model S Consumption vs Speed
https://forum.abetterrouteplanner.com/blogs/entry/9-tesla-mo...
Faster Tesla Supercharging - How does it actually perform?
https://forum.abetterrouteplanner.com/blogs/entry/29-faster-...
Of course, low temperatures and rain will also tank range.
Could customers demand their own data from Tesla? Europeans, under the GDPR, for example? If enough people did, and released it, that ought to be accurate.
It totally depends on the vehicle. I maintain a fleet of ~10 vehicles and keep records of fuel economy (because it tells me when calipers stick before the drivers do). The vehicles get ridden decently hard and pretty much all the highway miles are in the left lane at whatever speed that may be. A 2/3 majority pretty much always exceed their EPA rating by 2-4mpg. The rest are right on the rating. None of them spend much time in the gridlock that tends to characterize upscale inner suburbs during daylight hours nor do they cruise empty rural highways.
But yes, powertrain loses exacerbate the power consumption.
Also: friction of tyres don't make you consume energy, it's what makes the car move actually (with no tire friction you won't move at all).
The friction that makes you consume energy is within the wheels, gears, etc that are supposed to slide, also the deformation of tires makes you consume energy (which is why consumption is higher with under-inflated tires).
Since we're already in pedantic land, tires aren't spinning in a vacuum, there's friction between the spinning tires and the air around them.
Presumably there's also a subjective element, like if the driver tends to tailgate and brake late, which isn't exactly uncommon. You're not recovering any energy put into heating the brake rotors.
There are also plenty of locales where you're repeatedly braking heavily for hairpin turns like winding roads on the side of a mountain. Teslas aren't exactly light vehicles...
Here are a couple of the articles that got some discussion in that sub:
https://insideevs.com/news/407807/eletric-car-real-world-ran...
https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a30874032/porsche-tayca...
As someone who has owned both a Tesla Model X and one of the other EVs on the list from the first article, I can also provide my own anecdata that at freeway speeds Tesla routinely underperforms their EPA range rating, and by quite a large margin. Meanwhile at freeway speeds my non-Tesla EV routinely exceeds its EPA rating.
That's not to say that Tesla hasn't done an amazing job at maximizing efficiency in their cars. They have. Just maybe not to the degree that the EPA test would suggest.