News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by btilly on Monday June 15, 2020 @11:15PM (#23535617)
What's most striking to me as someone who has heard over and over again about how air resistance is a X^2 property, is the extent to which short (and presumably slow) trips punch above their weight in terms of range consumed per mile. From what I can tell, the actual cost here is the fixed cost of booting up some systems and electronics, and the variable costs of running them over fewer miles can make the MPGe drop. Starting and continuing to run the AC adds up!

Two factors.

First, if you go 10% faster, air resistance may be 21% higher, but you only take 10/11 for spending 10% more energy per mile. So higher speeds cost less than you'd naively think.

Second, at low speeds we start and stop a lot. Coming to a full stop requires actually putting physical brakes on and losing energy. The heavier your car, the more that this costs you. For slower traffic, if you look at distance traveled, number of full stops and energy, I bet that you can fit a linear model in 2 variables that fits the data better and gives you a sense of how much coming to a stop costs you.

Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by tlb on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:01AM (#23535838)
That's incorrect. Power consumption is proportional to drag * speed, and drag is speed^2, so power is speed^3, and energy per mile is speed^2.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by D_Alex on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:53AM (#23536039)
Or: Work = Force * Distance, so the energy spent per mile will be proportional to drag force, which is proportional to speed^2.

Either way, its 21% increase in energy consumed per mile in this case.

Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by btilly on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:16PM (#23541558)
Ah, shoot. You are right. Energy is force times distance, momentum is force times time. I was thinking about force times time.

wipes egg off of face

Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by carlob on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:04AM (#23536624)
True but we're interested in power consumption per distance traveled so it goes back to O(v^2).
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by sokoloff on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:56AM (#23537391)
That’s precisely what the last clause you’re responding to says. You’re agreeing but couching it as a “but”.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by modeless on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @05:49AM (#23537359)
Starting and stopping does cost energy, but regen is pretty efficient and the lesser wind resistance of slow speeds mostly makes up for it. No, davidwhodge is right, the problem with short trips has to do with the fixed costs of "warming up" the car. Just looking at the energy graph in the car while driving it's easy to see that it's much more efficient after the car has warmed up.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by kube-system on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @10:16AM (#23539381)
Yes, but electric motor regen usually does not work all the way down to zero mph. Usually it stops somewhere around 5-10mph, and the friction brakes take over. Slow rolling traffic that fluctuates between something like 10-30mph is very efficient, but stop and go traffic fluctuating between 0-20mph is pretty inefficient.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by ajuc on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:39AM (#23536240)
Additionally if you drive 10% faster you spend ~9% less time on the trip which means heating/AC is working 9% less.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by baddox on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:32AM (#23536775)
And there’s also some “inherent” value in spending less time traveling that is more difficult to quantify.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec... by londons_explore on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:50AM (#23536862)
To balance with the inherent disadvantages of more speeding tickets and a higher risk of a collision.