Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by kemiller on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:25AM
(#23535938)
That’s really weird. Is it normal to blend in sport modes? Do you have a link to more info?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by reitzensteinm on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @12:57AM
(#23536051)
Unfortunately I'm struggling to find a source, so take it with a grain of salt. My memory is that the highway speed test for one of the modes had it running in first gear (of two).
But regardless of the reason, its EPA range proportional to WLTP and real world driving is very low compared to other EVs. It doesn't point to poor efficiency, just a corner case of EPA testing.
While extrapolated from 100 miles, this Car and Driver test [1] puts a 6% gap between the 2020 Model S and Taycan, compared to a 70% difference in EPA range. Extrapolation sucks as a method, but there's no way it would mask a true 70% range difference - the Porsche would be close to empty at the end of the test.
Considering the Tesla costs just over half as much, it's still a home run for Tesla. They're the ones to beat and by all accounts are likely to stay that way.
https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/comparison-test/a307994...
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by michaelt on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @03:27AM
(#23536748)
It makes sense to me, as otherwise a manufacturer could supply the car with a 50mph speed limiter (which users would instantly disable) to boost their EPA-measured range.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by secabeen on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:06AM
(#23536088)
My memory (and I don't have a citation for this) is that if the manufacturer gives you multiple range modes (like Eco and Sport) EPA tests in both, then averages them together somehow.