Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by chemmail on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:05AM
(#23536079)
Oh yeah, The leaf was scarey on the freeway. It would burn so much battery and was pretty loud. I try to keep it below 60MPH in which things get uncomfortable. In the city it was very compliant and very efficient. I could go through two weeks without charging my now half degraded battery.
In the Tesla it loves going to about 70mph. After that you start getting wind noise.
Two very different animals. But both great cars. Never going back to ICE.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @08:31AM
(#23538339)
I've never ridden in a Leaf or other compact electric but is it really worse than the 2002 Tauruses and 1999 Grand Caravans (or 2019 Mitsubishi Mirage for that matter) that people seem to have no problem keeping up with traffic in?
I can see it being worse than whatever people who are buying leafs are trading in but I can't see it being that bad overall.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by toast0 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:41AM
(#23540476)
The issue is not you can't keep up with traffic, it's if you do keep up with traffic, you use your stored energy very fast.
I was commuting with a plug in hybrid and it was very similar. If traffic was bad, I could make it nearly home on nearly all electric, but if traffic was light, the battery would be drained even if it was running in normal hybrid mode. Not a problem for me, the gas engine works fine, but it would be an issue for a leaf.
Re:Model S Long Range Plus: Building the First 400-Mile Elec...
by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @01:02PM
(#23541398)
So it's a range/performance issue, not an NVH issue, correct?
The leaf did lots better around town, but it was a relatively small and light car. The battery was charged significantly higher and drained significantly lower than tesla batteries. There was degradation. At highway speeds it was significantly less efficient and range anxiety became a real problem. On trips usable range was much less than the specs because: you couldn't drain it all the way because logistics was a real problem. You also couldn't charge it all the way because a "fast" charger would take as much time to charge to 80% as from 80%-100%. Range was an issue and being an engineer or mathematician helped. Around town 3.5-4.5 miles/kwh was common, on the freeway you would hit 2 at 70mph.
The tesla actually had freeway speeds. Where a leaf would have you in the right hand lane trying to go as slow as possible, the tesla would have you looking out for speed traps. The battery was huge. You could plan your trips with the help of the nav computer and your battery would generally stay in 20-80% range. On long trips it was better to stay 10-60% because the battery would charge faster before it started tapering off. By tapering off, I mean 2-3x the max the leaf would charge on a good day. I will say that tesla battery size makes it possible to care for the battery. It would be uncommon (and sort of bad maintenance) to charge to 90% let alone 100%. Same for below 20%. Telsa shuts off some automatic climate features below 20%
Oh, and tesla drivers are a diverse group. Just talking to them, some will average close to 200 wh/mi, while others will be above 400wh/mi. climate and foot weight make a difference. Besides behavior, there are also several tesla settings that will increase your range. Range mode, different driving settings [chill | standard | sport | ludicrous | ludicrous+ ] depending on the vehicle.