Presumably the Vauxhall mentioned would provide exactly the measured MPG when driven at the correct speed by any owner in the real world - hence the 'flat spot' noticed.
The defeat concept you're referring to (presumably VW's) was set to only function during a test, and not in the real world (AIUI).
Perhaps about 5% of regular vauxhall driving was in those flat spots...
Seems the same to me.
I don't really have a problem with my effective range being less do to my driving style as long as it's predictable (and it is).
It's one thing to have the engine+drivetrain efficiency peak at 70. But for total efficiency to be worse at 60, despite massively reduced wind resistance, is pretty suspicious.
But the most efficient way to drive a gas car is to speed up, then turn the engine off and coast down to a slower speed, then engine on for quickly moving up to a fast speed again.
Of course, the only way you'd want to drive like that is if you are alone in the desert and need to get to a gas station.
Over a 4.5 hour period if I can cruise at 75 mph, I will be 44.5 miles ahead of another car which departs at the same time, for the same destination, at 65 mph.