News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by iandanforth on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:05AM (#23246891)
Curious how many people share this opinion, but I think this is extremely good news. I would love to see birth rates drop below replenishment across the globe. We simply don't need billions of humans. We have done, and continue to do major damage to our environment and historically a tiny minority has benefited from the labor of the majority. The people who benefit most from an increasing population are those who exploit people to increase their quality of life in clean sanctuaries while distancing themselves from the effort and waste required to maintain those lifestyles.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:29AM (#23247214)
> We simply don't need billions of humans.

You make an excellent point, and I'll raise a counterargument. I would claim, simply, that human life is intrinsically a good thing. I believe that my life is worth living, that it is better that I'm alive than if I were dead. I'll presume that everyone who reads this believes the same about their own lives. In that case, the more people alive, the better -- (if all else is equal).

That said, the philosopher Derek Parfit anticipated this and raises a counterargument to my argument above, known as the "mere addition paradox". [1] Roughly speaking, it goes as follows.

1. Suppose you have a population of 1,000,000 people, living happy, healthy, productive lives. Let's stipulate that this is a good thing.

2. Now, suppose in addition to this, suppose you have a second population of 1,000,000 people, who lead difficult lives with a lot of hardship, but whose lives are (perhaps barely) worth living. Then, if human life is intrisically good, then it is good that these people also exist. (This is the "mere addition" part.)

3. Given these two populations, equality is a good thing: lower the standard of living of the first million people ever so slightly, and raise the standard of the second group to match the first. This, too, seems to be a good thing.

4. Repeat. Eventually you arrive at a huge population, living lives of misery and squalor which are just slightly better than nothing -- but which one has argued is a better scenario than your original million people. This is the "repugnant conclusion".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by scottLobster on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:43AM (#23247411)
If nothing else more humans increase our collective potential intelligence to solve problems.

It's my my main issue with the anti-natalist movement: If theoretically everyone who believed in climate change agreed that anti-natalism was the solution, by definition within a generation the largest voting block would be the children of climate deniers. Which would actually make climate change much worse.

We don't need fewer humans, we need smarter/better institutions and more efficient technology. Every life born is one more potential option for a breakthrough.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:14AM (#23247847)
> If theoretically everyone who believed in climate change agreed that anti-natalism was the solution, by definition within a generation the largest voting block would be the children of climate deniers. Which would actually make climate change much worse.

As an anti-natalist (more precise would be anatalist, I am not opposing that other people have kids, I just wish they chose not to), let me address that. The point is not everybody to not have kids, but just enough to stabilize or slightly decrease the population.

First, you're assuming that climate denial is genetic and not cultural. Which is a big assumption, and I am in general in favor of nurture argument. (As a side note, by waiting longer to have kids, humans might actually be selecting for kids that are learning more and longer, which favors nurture even more.)

However, even if I take that assumption. If I chose not to have kids, that very much means I do not care about biology and what my genetics want. I am making the decision as a person free of the evolutionary pressure (well, somewhat, because I still care about survival of human race). Therefore, I am not sure why I should be bothered by the evolutionary pressure on other individuals. The truth is, it is going to be their battle. I can only lend them a helping hand (and perhaps an example), and do (what I believe is) a morally correct thing. If they mess up and still act wrong, it's not my moral responsibility.

It is a similar question as to whether or not vote strategically. If everybody votes strategically, you can get a result that no one wants. Therefore, somebody has to sacrifice and decidedly vote not strategically.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by scottLobster on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:40AM (#23248181)
I'm not assuming climate denial is genetic at all, parents and cultures have a great deal of influence on their children's beliefs. If every Christian decided to not have kids tomorrow the world would be mostly Muslim and Hindu within a few decades. The few converts to Christianity would not replace the losses. Same with Climate Change. If the only culture that reproduces is climate deniers, the they will be the majority. In democracies majorities win.

I'm not saying you or anyone else should have kids out of some sense of duty. If you don't want kids, fine. People having kids they didn't want has led to a lot of messed up families. However I find the argument that it's because of climate change to be a post-hoc rationalization. It's like if during the black death people said they're not having kids because it's morally correct to not produce more plague carriers.

As for your voting analogy, under our current system (in the US) if everyone votes strategically some good might occur albeit in a somewhat corrupt, half-assed manner. If fewer people vote strategically then those who vote strategically win, however small a minority they might be. That's how we ended up with a two party system. Alliances willing to compromise parts of their values will defeat smaller but pure adversaries.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @12:12PM (#23248581)
> I'm not assuming climate denial is genetic at all, parents and cultures have a great deal of influence on their children's beliefs.

I think for my argument it doesn't matter whether the inheritance of the denialist position happens through biological or cultural means. Either way, what you're assuming is that by and large people cannot change their position (from the position of their parents) based on the situation they will find themselves in, that they cannot adapt culturally (i.e. they can only adapt via natural selection).

> However I find the argument that it's because of climate change to be a post-hoc rationalization.

Maybe it is. How can anyone know? I don't think it changes anything in the debate, if it's just a rationalization of something else. Maybe your belief that it is a post-hoc rationalization is a rationalization of something as well.

> under our current system (in the US) if everyone votes strategically some good might occur albeit in a somewhat corrupt, half-assed manner

Saying "some good might occur" is equivalent of "some bad might occur", which was my point. Your (not mine) U.S. voting system is horrible, you should push for changing it into something more sane. But regardless, I think what I wrote is true for most voting systems.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by justwalt on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:36AM (#23248140)
I highly doubt he thinks climate denial is a genetic presupposition.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @12:21PM (#23248697)
Well, I didn't want to say that out loud, but the argument is a soft version of "stupid people will win" argument, which I disagree with (and I find it repulsively elitist). That's where the genetics comes in; I should have written biology instead of genetics, though.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by boardwaalk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @07:45PM (#23253357)
We (humans) are so mind-blowingly disorganized at solving problems that you likely could have much more of an impact focusing on solving that organization problem (even just a small part of it) than spending resources raising kids. And that is ignoring the environmental impact.

IOW, if your goal is to better humanity, having a kid is a really, really blunt instrument versus using more of your brain capacity x time on that goal.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by nitwit005 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @09:19PM (#23253933)
Pick silly axioms, get silly conclusions.

If it were genuinely the case that human life should be maximized, we should lower everyone's standard of living as much as possible (it consumes resources), and then force everyone to have as many children as possible.

Of course, that would also maximize human suffering, but apparently human life is intrinsically good regardless of suffering, so not a problem.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by saiya-jin on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:45AM (#23247444)
This is perspective from purely human view, ignoring just about everything else that makes reality, which is way more complex.

People don't live in vacuum, we destroy our environment on maybe even exponential scale as our numbers grow. Extermination of vast amounts of species and whole ecosystems might mean nothing to you, but sure as hell is something I value very highly.

I am not an extremist, I don't claim that earth and universe would be just fine without humans, we can be a worthy addition even if only for selfish purposes. But as usually some middle path is probably the best, especially in long term view, which is very hard to model for human mind.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#23247768)
> This is perspective from purely human view, ignoring just about everything else that makes reality, which is way more complex.

I agree. (And, in particular, I agree that ecological diversity is very important.) I consider it to be something of a foundational model -- kind of like how in introductory physics you assume that things like air resistance don't exist.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jonwalch on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:40AM (#23247365)
"I'll presume that everyone who reads this believes the same about their own lives."

That's an enormous assumption, in my opinion.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by volkk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#23247753)
you've lost me at

> Given these two populations, equality is a good thing: lower the standard of living of the first million people ever so slightly, and raise the standard of the second group to match the first.

I'm trying to understand why you would repeat this step if you've lowered the standard of the first million ever so slightly but have already matched the miserable million to be that of the happy million?

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:12AM (#23247816)
Repeat steps 2 and 3: in addition to the now combined group of two million people, assume that you have an additional group of two million people living difficult lives. Now repeat step 3, and so on, until you've doubled the population many times.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by volkk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:25AM (#23247987)
Why cant you add a million happy people instead? or both? I understand this is a philosophical thought experiment, but of course if you keep diluting substance X with more and more of substance Y, you'll eventually get mostly substance Y...right? Is it impossible for a society to add 1 happy person for every unhappy person?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:31AM (#23248080)
> if you keep diluting substance X with more and more of substance Y, you'll eventually get mostly substance Y.

Exactly, that's the paradox. Parfit's argument stipulates a series of steps each of which seems to make the world better, but where the end result seems to be worse than what you started with.

Hopefully, we can avoid the paradox, and instead grow in such a way that everyone thrives and we mitigate the negative effects on the environment.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by WhompingWindows on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:13AM (#23246975)
In this case, it's a good thing, because the birthrates declined most for women 24 and younger. Creating another person is one of the most carbon-intensive actions anyone can do, you're literally spawning a lifetime of energy use. Best to do that when you're SURE they will have all the resources they need to be a productive and helpful member of society...not when you're 16 and can't care for them properly.

I do think there is value to having a balanced aged pyramid, however. We don't want a China or Japan situation, where there are far too many old people, which would crush the younger members of society under the burden of caring. The one way to counteract that would be immigration, which has been a hot-button issue and is not a given or perfect remedy for population pyramids.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:17AM (#23247029)
how can a human being be simplifed down to a "lifetime of energy use" and a very carbon-intensive action? I know this language has normalized and that we use it with "good" intentions, but sometimes we sound much more soulless and anti-human than even the language of soviet ideology
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:18AM (#23247054)
Easily. As a human, based on your country [1], you will emit a certain amount of fossil CO2 over your lifetime. You will have an impact on natural resources. This math is no different than estimating your dollar value for something like a payout in the event you are accidentally killed.

[1] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.PC?view=map

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by mc32 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:24AM (#23247123)
Alternatively are you saying that people moving to less carbon intensive economies would also be a “good thing”. Get as many people from the developed world to move to places where they’d have less environmental impact? Though I’m sure there would be massive resistance from the affected people as well as from the destinations as they would upset the order on those places.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:27AM (#23247170)
The two most crucial focuses would be to decarbonize carbon intensive economies, and throwing massive amounts of money at education and healthcare for women in developing countries.

Developed countries already have total fertility rates at or below replacement rate; it's all population momentum now, so you want to reduce the impact of everyone living a first world life for the remainder of their life span. Less combustion vehicles, less unnecessary air travel, fossil generation plants, meat heavy diets, etc. We're already headed in this direction, we just need to invest more heavily (Green New Deal, ESG funds, etc).

Regarding education and healthcare in developing countries, educated, empowered women with access to robust healthcare have fewer children [1] [2], and this data holds true across the entire world, even in countries that attempt to use generous subsidies to encourage higher fertility rates.

Moving folks from the developing world to the developed world, or vice versa, wouldn't have a meaningful impact IMHO.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#empowerment-of-wom...

[2] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/womens-educational-attain...

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by danans on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:48AM (#23248288)
True, but also we need to also do a rethink of how the savings from decarbonization are socialized on the form of higher quality of life available at a lower cost to more people.

If most of the savings of decarbonization go to capital, we will end up just bringing our current issues with growing wealth inequality into the decarbonized economy.

Developed economies should lead the way on this by demonstrating how a high quality of life can be preserved with decarbonization at population scale.

That means not just for the wealthy to build net zero eco-mansions and drive Teslas, but for most regular people's energy bills (for both home and transportation) to drop to near amortized capital investment cost of renewables plus the marginal cost of producing renewable energy, which should be far lower than fossil fuels.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:03AM (#23247700)
i understand it on theory, my problem is that this language assumes human life is somehow "measurable" and comparable to a random number and that regulations/change of society should follow: this sounds to me like the same way of thinking that eventually did let eugenics become big(later nazism) and later all kinds of communist social experiments to happen (and also sadly leading to many capitalist abuses of society): once our life is mostly a variable in a big calculation, in which stuff like iq/carbon print/social production is more important, you have problems
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:04AM (#23247712)
You can quantify human life while still having respect for it.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:06AM (#23247732)
but if this changes the way whole societies live, is this really respect anymore? (X respects his life, but is afraid of even having children because Y)
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:07AM (#23247741)
Finite systems don't care about the human condition. Does gravity care about your opinion as you race towards the ground? No, it just is. Such is the consumption of resources in a finite system.

It sounds like you mean for respect to be an acceptance of entitlement. Again, I'm unsure how to reconcile that when resources are finite.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:12AM (#23247820)
ah, i see what you mean now: anyway, most resources aren't really finite, as many of them are renewable, especially when you have the need and ability of more people
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:14AM (#23247850)
Yes, exactly. It's about bending the population curve down to meet up with the technology advancement curve.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:10AM (#23247792)
societies after all are groups of people and sadly people can be easily manipulated : no need to go into "finite systems", please
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by whateveracct on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:18AM (#23247049)
ecofascism
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by orwin on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:55AM (#23247565)
As long as he does not force you to go along their life choices without a democratic decision, this is not fascism.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by whateveracct on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @03:55PM (#23251033)
That's true. I'm not saying it's institutional.

But we have fascist political forces in America despite the democracy. Same thing. It's a political thing not a structural thing.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alehander42 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:59AM (#23247616)
once a political view is widely accepted, it starts getting really easy to force it on people
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by blueblisters on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:26AM (#23247164)
> Creating another person is one of the most carbon-intensive actions anyone can do, you're literally spawning a lifetime of energy use.

Cutting back on energy use is the most regressive way of solving climate change. We will almost certainly use more energy in the future, regardless of the population.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by ZitchDog on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:18AM (#23247044)
You could also be spawning the person who solves the problem of climate change.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:32AM (#23247259)
I heard this argument many times. Has anyone ever actually done that? IMHO it's just a generational procrastination.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by nl on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:46AM (#23247451)
Well consider Jean-Joseph Pasteur and Jeanne-Etiennette Roqui for example.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:56AM (#23247589)
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by nl on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:03AM (#23247682)
Sure, but all those simultaneous discoverers have parents too.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:56AM (#23247581)
I don't understand what argument are you trying to make.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by derwiki on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:21AM (#23247093)
.. or the one who ruins the climate forever? Not sure this how you should be thinking of spawning :D
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by ben_w on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:25AM (#23247146)
We have solutions to that. The biggest remaining problem right now is a few vested interests who don’t like the solutions we have because their wealth is tied to lots of people burning lots of stuff.

There are other reasons not to follow this path, but that isn’t one of them.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jjoonathan on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:23AM (#23247115)
Right, and that's why the otherwise learned people who have been predicting, incorrectly, for thousands of years, that the earth was at/past carrying capacity have been wrong: more people means more human capacity, and that has outweighed having more mouths to feed.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by kpmah on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:38AM (#23247333)
Except now we have a scientific consensus that the Earth's carrying capacity will decrease. I don't think that's been true before.

Expecting technological advancement to bail us out every time is wishful thinking.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by nl on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:49AM (#23247489)
That's not true.

There is no scientific consensus on the impact of climate change on total food production (there is a significant school of thought that it will increase due to increased production in Canada and Russia), and there's no consensus at all on what the carrying capacity of earth is.

Check the IPCC report:

For the major crops (wheat, rice, and maize) in tropical and temperate regions, climate change without adaptation will negatively impact production for local temperature increases of 2°C or more above late-20th-century levels, although individual locations may benefit (medium confidence). {7.4, Figure 7-4} Projected impacts vary across crops and regions and adaptation scenarios, with about 10% of projections for the period 2030–2049 showing yield gains of more than 10% and about 10% of projections showing yield losses of more than 25%, compared to the late 20th century.

https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/wg2/food-security-and-food-pr...

Note how the projections are mixed between decreased and increased production?

Don't claim consensus when it's not there.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by folkhack on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:21AM (#23247094)
And you could also be spawning a genocidal maniac.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by SkyBelow on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:37AM (#23247323)
>Creating another person is one of the most carbon-intensive actions anyone can do, you're literally spawning a lifetime of energy use.

This feels like a very odd view because the reverse is near profane thought.

>Best to do that when you're SURE they will have all the resources they need to be a productive and helpful member of society...not when you're 16 and can't care for them properly.

If it is okay to accept this logic based on age, what about other factors? For example, income level?

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by actuator on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:38AM (#23247332)
Japan gets talked about a lot but Taiwan and SK are doing worse if you see TFR. TFR of SK was below 1 in 2018, replacement level being 2.1. It would be interesting to see how this plays out in the next two decades over there considering the high life expectancy.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by manquer on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @07:24PM (#23253211)
Interestingly both have major geopolitical disputes which are a critical part of their national discourse in addition to being highly developed economies and associated drop in TFR .
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by iandanforth on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @06:10PM (#23252568)
The phrase "population pyramid scheme" comes to mind.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by ausbah on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:06AM (#23247731)
if your birthrates and deathrates at roughly equal, I don't think this conclusion holds up
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by dudul on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:18AM (#23247045)
> Creating another person is one of the most carbon-intensive actions anyone can do

This is a bold blanket statement that I can't agree with. It all depends on how this new person will live their life. I would argue that creating 10 new persons in a third world country doesn't hurt the environment as much as 1 single person in the US or in Europe.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:42AM (#23247390)
> Creating another person is one of the most carbon-intensive actions anyone can do [...] Best to do that when you're SURE they will have all the resources they need to be a productive and helpful member of society...

I totally get the sentiment, but history stubbornly is full of people born into abject poverty who somehow rise to the occasion. Take a look on Wikipedia at inventor profiles. Our best, life changing inventions came from people who were born into less-than-ideal situations. In many ways the impact people have on the world is a dice roll and not a matter of proper financial preparation.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by chillwaves on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:07AM (#23247744)
Have you ever heard the saying "exception that proves the rule"?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by keiferski on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:22AM (#23247109)
The cause of this is an overemphasis on consumption, not an increase in the number of human beings alive.

Ironically this consumption-based mentality is also one cause of the declining birth rates in developed countries. On a material level, potential middle-class parents are vastly better off today than the parents of ~100 years ago. As a percentage of income, food is cheaper, entertainment and education are essentially free (thanks to the Internet), clothing doesn't need to be hand-made, etc. And yet many people don't have kids because they "can't afford it" which basically translates to "can't afford to maintain society's baseline consumption levels." I'm not blaming them, either - this is something that society pushes constantly. Going against that tide is extremely difficult.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by bagacrap on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:29AM (#23247208)
Every problem with modern society becomes worse with more humans. We could cut per capita consumption in half and every additional human would still accelerate climate change.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by keiferski on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:31AM (#23247241)
I'm talking about cultural trends and consumerism.

> Every problem with modern society becomes worse with more humans.

No, not necessarily if enough people adopted a minimalist/low carbon emission lifestyle. More people would lead to it becoming a bigger social movement, thus making it more acceptable for 'regular' people to join.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by chillwaves on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#23247770)
The cost of rent has increased as a percentage of income.

People aren't choosing to not have kids just so they can eat avocado toast.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by keiferski on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:15AM (#23247858)
The cost of renting what? It used to be considered normal for multiple people to share a room and for children to live with their parents (and grandparents) all under one roof until they got married.

Don’t get me wrong - I prefer living alone to having roommates, and certainly prefer having my own private room to sharing it with multiple other people. But this is a very modern expectation. If it were normal for 3-4 people to share a room (as was common in the past), I imagine rent prices would actually be lower today than historically.

In any case, rent is really only overinflated in coastal megacities. And rent wasn’t really my main target: there are a whole lot of modern consumption activities considered ‘essential’ which really aren’t in any sense, but have simply become social expectations.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rubber_duck on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:17AM (#23247030)
In theory this will suck for you because the entire society is structured so that younger people support the old and reducing the number of people who have to support you is a terrible thing, especially if we continue to rise life expectancy (although suicide/accidents/drugs are doing a fine job at countering this in aggregate).

But there is no telling how things will pan out with economy in the future, to what extent will automation increase productivity, etc. Also if the anti-aging research comes through the productive age of individuals could be extended along with longer lifespan.

Whatever happens the environment argument is ridiculous, environment has always been unstable, life on earth has been hit by major cataclysmic events throughout the history - the only difference is that historically we couldn't do anything about it - which is changing significantly with technological development. If we don't start decoupling our survival odds from the environmental factors we are going to suffer as a society irregardless of what we do to environment.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by neutronicus on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:26AM (#23247161)
Figuring out how to structure society in a way that doesn't require the young to outnumber the old is a band-aid the species will have to rip off eventually.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by throwaway5752 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:29AM (#23247213)
"environment argument is ridiculous"

It isn't. The environment isn't unstable right now, it has relatively stable rate of change, and it's predictable. It's just getting worse for our survival as a population. We are using carbon based energy sources too quickly for the environment to follow the natural cycle to sequester it, and as a result we won't be able to feed the existing number of humans.

We cannot decouple survival odds from environmental factors. You show a lack of understanding of how food is made to think that is possible at current populations.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rubber_duck on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:54AM (#23247555)
>You show a lack of understanding of how food is made to think that is possible at current populations.

On the timescale of declining birth rates affecting this - this is probably the simplest problem to solve - we have multiple ways reduce environmental impacts on food production with different levels of innovation/change required - from engineering resilient crops and using the same approach as we do now, over vertical farming in controlled environments (still producing the same food but with low surface requirement and isolation from environmental effects), all the way to producing essential nutrients from simple organisms large scale (eg. algae) (here we need to figure out a lot more about nutrition to provide reasonable healthy substitutes over complex food) - this is a matter of economics, scaling, research - not trivial but clearly possible.

Building cities able to withstand large scale environmental disasters like hurricanes and tsunamis, temperature control, isolation from air pollutants (eg. radioactive waste in the air), imposing strict bounds on entering/leaving to prevent viruses/bacteria from spreading (through humans and animals) - these are the kinds of things we will need to be able to do in the future - otherwise the next COVID, avian flue, Fukushima or global warming is going to leave us in a shit situation without any way of responding - we will be left in the same shit situation we are now - forced to hide and hope it goes away.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by lotsofpulp on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @01:49PM (#23249713)
The single biggest problem is consumption of resources that are altering the parameters of nature such that they will be less hospitable to human life. At its base, almost all consumption requires fossil fuel due to its unbeatable properties of energy density, storage, versatility, ease of use, and cheap cost.

I don’t see how any idea which increases consumption (such as building cities and farms and whatever can help mitigate the more immediate problem of carbon emissions and other fossil fuel related pollution. Only solution I can see is reduction in consumption per capita (mainly in developed countries), and accompanying that is reduction of ”capita”s Aka reduction in population .

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rubber_duck on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @04:12PM (#23251206)
That argument is assuming nature is hospitable to human life by default and if we stop doing what we're doing everything will be fine...

Droughts can still cause famine and starvation in many parts of the world. Floods, hurricanes, earthquakes, vulcano eruptions, forest fires, localised disease (like lime disease) etc. all part of the natural disasters happening without human intervention. These are the small scale common occurrences that we still really don't have good ways of dealing with.

A lot of these are exacerbated by climate change - which is already in motion and there is very little proof that we can predict what will happen accurately, so even if we cut green house gas emissions to 0 - and that's not a realistic scenario - we're still going to have to deal with the consequences.

Then there are global outlier events that can be extinction level - meteor impact, deadly virus strains crossing from animals to humans and spread by animals (eg. bird flu - we're covering from COVID with IFR of sub 1% which is largely targeting old people past average age of death - bird flue IFR was close to 50% and spread by birds which aren't so easy to contain - imagine if the transmission was easier). Again 0 human intervention required, have historical precedent, just not frequent enough to worry about when you have more pressing issues.

In any realistic scenario we will be living in a world were local actions can have global impact - nuclear disaster can spread radiation between continents, virus originating in one place can spread globally and we have no containment units, climate change is going to make the weather more volatile and many natural disasters are going to become more frequent and it can destroy currently hospitable areas, etc.

Nature is not great by default, and we're already on a path that will make it less hospitable - the only realistic long term solution I see is learning to live in that environment.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by iandanforth on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @06:12PM (#23252579)
To your first point. I think contraction economics (the study of economics under declining populations) would be a great area to enter right about now.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by mrfusion on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:19AM (#23247072)
Every human born is a super computer with AGI that can be purposed towards improving our situation and solving the mysteries of the universe.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by alex_anglin on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:33AM (#23247265)
If by AGI, you're referring to 'Artificial General Intelligence,' I'm curious to know what you think the Artificial part is.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by ketanmaheshwari on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:13AM (#23246976)
I think it is good if the decline happens at a steady rate rather than a sudden drop which will create an imbalance between the number of elderly folks who need support and a younger generation who could provide that support.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by vincentlee on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:30AM (#23247224)
or covid19 could naturally fix the glitch
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jes5199 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:39AM (#23247340)
this is happening! Check out “Empty Planet: the Shock of Global Population Decline”. They predict a peak in _global_ population around 2050. The same cultural change is happening world-wide: people are having fewer children, and they’re having them later.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by dudul on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:15AM (#23247002)
Except that it will probably barely move the needle. The US's contribution to world population growth is negligible compared to Africa's or parts of Asia.

That being said, this focus on "population" always sounds a little wrong to me. It's not about how many people are alive, it's about the consumption of resources per person. And by this metric, yes, the US is probably the worst offender. But here is the thing, will childless household/individuals consume less than families?

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jtbayly on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:29AM (#23247204)
Nope. As outlined in another comment, it will be travel and consumption for the sake of the individual, with no thought for what happens to society in 5 decades. Supposedly everything will be fine, since they didn’t “spawn” a “carbon consumer,” and the only problem we face is carbon. It is selfish.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by underbluewaters on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:04AM (#23247706)
It's almost as if humans consume as many resources as their circumstances allow... We are at global carrying capacity, it just isn't some optimal theoretical limit but one defined by political, historical, and ecological factors.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by chillwaves on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:11AM (#23247806)
It's really the height of hubris to lecture strangers on whether or not they should make the very personal and life long commitment to having children.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:17AM (#23247031)
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by pkaye on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @05:12PM (#23251859)
Most western countries are below population replacement fertility rate of 2.1. This also include China at 1.7 and India almost there at 2.2. The countries in Africa are still up there though but they will go down also.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by api on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:14AM (#23247001)
I think there are pros and cons. You mention some of the pros. Right now I think the ideal population growth would be slightly below replacement level for a while, and then replacement level once we hit a population that seems to "work."

You can't ignore the social problems created by shrinking populations though. A major one is monopolization of high positions in business and politics by an increasingly elderly class that is stuck in an obsolete way of thinking. In America this has given birth to the quip "ok, boomer."

I don't like sounding age-ist, but it does seem as if most people stop updating their understanding of the world at some point in their 40s. I don't think it's that older people can't learn. My grandfather taught himself computer programming, called BBSes (at 300 baud!), learned digital/TTL electronics, and learned all kinds of other new stuff in his 60s. It's just that most people don't do this. I think it might be an ego thing. People decide they know it all at some point and stop learning or changing their opinions.

It could also have less to do with age than with age plus status. High status people rarely seem to make drastic revisions to their world view because their brain stem is telling them everything they're doing is working. (At least this is the mechanism I suspect exists. It would have survival value to some extent.) So you get entrenched older managerial and political classes that double, triple, and quadruple down on failing policies because the failure has not affected them yet.

A second problem is that virtually every society on Earth today uses growth to paper over a range of systemic failings. Instead of dealing with inequality, we use growth. Instead of getting rid of moribund industries we use growth to make new ones while keeping the old stuff around. Growth really does avoid the need to confront a lot of very messy problems. Recent political history has not inspired confidence in me that we can confront these problems any more rationally than people in the past.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by iandanforth on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @06:27PM (#23252719)
I agree, some further thoughts.

The tipping point I'm looking at is when kindred.ai, covariant.ai, google, or similar player nails manipulation. Give me a set of hands that can reliably perform a task in a semi-structured environment 24/7 at 65% the speed of a human and 1B people will be out of work in a decade.

This will further increase the wealth of a few and raise the standards of living for many which will increase their rates of consumption. I'd like to see the population decline to balance this expected increase in consumption.

As for the gerontocracy problem, the easier it is for me to earn enough live the less I have to worry about who is in charge.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by snarf21 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @04:24PM (#23251338)
I agree with you. I don't think the planet can sustain more than about 4B people. As the third world countries get better health care and have better infant mortality, their rates will continue to drop. Additionally, robotics are going to continue to reduce our need for people to do stuff for other people.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rtkwe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:23AM (#23247113)
A big problem with that is long lifetimes and nice non-poverty level retirements basically require that there be more young people to support the older population in retirement because most people do not make enough to pay for their own retirement through savings.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by gizmo686 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:00AM (#23247637)
Retirement savings is irrelevant. No one saves for retirement by stockpiling cans of food. They save for retirement by stockpiling financial assets that can be exchanged for food when they are retired. They need just as much of a workforce to produce this food if they pay for it through savings as they would if it was provided through a socialist government program.

If everyone who retired has "adequate" savings, but their is not a large enough workforce to support them, you will see their buying power fall. Also possible is their buying power would remain, and the buying power of the young workforce would fall as a greater share of goods produced go to retired folks who hoarded financial capital when it was cheaper to do so.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rtkwe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:36AM (#23248143)
You're just talking about food, if we were willing to just let the elderly fall to poverty level subsistence it's much easier but that's poverty level which is not what I want in my old age or for anyone in their old age. We grew beyond that as a society for the most part lets not go back to it. There's medical bills, housing (for those who don't own their homes, which will be an increasing percentage as housing prices climb and people keep renting longer), and recreation.

> If everyone who retired has "adequate" savings, but their is not a large enough workforce to support them, you will see their buying power fall. Also possible is their buying power would remain, and the buying power of the young workforce would fall as a greater share of goods produced go to retired folks who hoarded financial capital when it was cheaper to do so.

That's another reason where you need either a larger working population or a vast excess that gets redistributed to support retirees.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by gizmo686 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:44AM (#23248239)
I was using food as an example because you could, in principle, stockpile cans of it.

I suppose you could argue that some people do stockpile housing for retirement. However, other than that, all they are doing is stockpiling a claim on future productivity. As a matter of policy, we could give every old person such a claim regardless of their savings.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rtkwe on Thursday May 21, 2020 @09:45AM (#23258254)
We could and unless something drastically changes in the way the economy is structured that's going to come in the form of giving them money (or goods bought with money) from taxes paid by the working population... As the ratio increases that requires more support from each working person.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by mrfusion on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:20AM (#23247081)
On the other hand, what’s the purpose of a universe without humans?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rtkwe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:25AM (#23247151)
It's unlikely humans are the only life in the universe and beyond that why does it have to have a purpose.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by 0xffff2 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @04:47PM (#23251595)
What's the purpose of a universe with humans?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by stuntkite on Thursday May 21, 2020 @07:51PM (#23267051)
I don't think it's been proven that human or even earth life is the most effective method the universe has come up with to look at itself. Humans appear to be good at recording the universe's happenings but I haven't seen solid evidence that the record is important on a galactic time scale.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by cudima on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:25AM (#23247152)
what's the purpose of a universe without elephants?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by Analemma_ on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:16AM (#23247028)
It could be a good thing if we didn't have an economy-- in particular, retirement and health care schemes-- that essentially requires a pyramidal population distribution, and collapses if it goes inverted. We should be working to fix that, but if the inversion happens before the change does, we could be in real trouble.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by josephorjoe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:21AM (#23247095)
America already has an easy, useful, and generally positive solution to a decline in birthrates: immigration.

We'll just need to move beyond the current xenophobia and remember what we use to know.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by Analemma_ on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:37AM (#23247325)
I mean, I agree, but "just" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. I've had to accept that there's a finite amount of immigration that societies will take before you get a nativist backlash, and that amount appears to be much lower than the amount you need to sustain a healthy demographic pyramid. All the Vox articles in the world about how immigration is a net economic positive don't seem to have made a difference. I don't like it, but you have to work with the political situation you have, not the one you wish you had.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by cmxch on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:54AM (#23247548)
Then fix the issue of what to do with the displaced (in a way that doesn't presume fault with said displaced persons).

Writing people off as this or that is not the answer.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jimbob45 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:56AM (#23247584)
Why would the immigrants have any allegiance to the US? If you try to force more immigrants in than can be properly vetted for assimilation, then you're going to get Sharia Law slums and the Irish/Russian/Italian mafia all over again.

Should we incentivize our own population to breed or ship in foreigners wholesale? Seems like self-subversion to opt for the latter.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by josephorjoe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:07AM (#23247748)
You may not know this, but the native american population in the US is <2% of the total population. If you are part of that <2%, I understand your bitterness.

The other 98% of americans are immigrants or the children/grandchildren/great grandchildren/etc. of immigrants.

Some of my ancestors immigrated from Ireland and Italy to the US, but despite that, I've decided to work in software engineering instead of the mafia.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jimbob45 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:20AM (#23247934)
You're wrong. The US isn't an ethnostate. It's a group of individuals who believe in a core set of values and ideals. Letting too many in risks letting in those who have no affinity to the US Constitution. It has nothing to do with genetic heritage.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by josephorjoe on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:32AM (#23248091)
Empirically, I'm not wrong.

98% of the population are immigrants or the descendents of immigrants.

The people who wrote the US Constitution were immigrants or the descendents of immigrants.

All the presidents, including the current one, have been the descendents of immigrants.

The US Constitution has survived this reality for 200+ years.

I realize some people, like my aunt (whose grandfather was an italian immigrant), want to pretend there is a difference between immigrants coming to america today and those who came 50, 100, 200, 300 years ago. But the difference is primarily in her mind, and now she treats new immigrants the way her grandfather was treated by people who decided italians should not be welcome in america.

It seems to be a constant tension here that I don't expect to every really go away.

I'm sure in countries without immigration people find other things to use to classify each other into groups that are convenient to dislike and scapegoat.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rootusrootus on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:19AM (#23247074)
Have you looked at the population distribution? To make the 60+ brackets go inverted would require a remarkable improvement in life-extending medical technology. It narrows pretty fast at retirement age.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by xoxoy on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:16AM (#23247025)
US birth rates not global
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:14AM (#23247854)
Global birth rates are racing toward < 2. Almost every nation. We'll get there in a decade or two.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by mrfusion on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:21AM (#23247088)
A lot of environmentalists think humans are a plague on this planet.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by tengbretson on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:52PM (#23254384)
Well forgive me then if I totally disregard the policy prescriptions of people who hate my species.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by ecoled_ame on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:56AM (#23254920)
Amen
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by gtfoutttt on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:20AM (#23247080)
Amen
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:06AM (#23246907)
It's tremendous news. The carrying capacity of the Earth is closed to 1 billion people (we're at ~7 billion, and on track to hit ~10 billion by the end of the century due to population momentum). Target total fertility rate should be as close to 1 as possible.

This is a subject near and dear to my heart as a systems observation wonk, and have done a tremendous amount of research on the subject.

I recommend these two books to those interested:

Shrinking-population Economics: Lessons From Japan by Akihiko Matsutani

Countdown: Our Last, Best Hope for a Future on Earth? by Alan Weisman

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by Mirioron on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:15AM (#23247007)
What does "carrying capacity" in this case mean? I've seen various numbers quoted on this and they all seem somewhat suspect to me. Humans improve the world for ourselves through work. As time progresses we get better at it and solve various problems. It's not like us consuming resources actually makes the resources disappear from Earth. They're still there, but they simply need more work to be done to be made useful. We extract new resources because it's cheaper, but at some point that'll change. Hopefully that's so far in the future that it's a challenge that's easily met.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by underbluewaters on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:10AM (#23247781)
Some resources are by definition are not sustainable. Fossil fuels are the best example, since they represent compressed biomass that takes millions of years to produce. The most worrying resource that isn't usually thought of are ecosystem services. The ocean produces an abundance of wild caught food, but also various cycles provide oxygen, consume co2, and coral reefs buffer shorelines against erosion. We degrade those systems with abandon, but they represent trillions in services that likely can't just be replaced with technology.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by Mirioron on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @12:39PM (#23248931)
>but they represent trillions in services that likely can't just be replaced with technology.

Why not? We probably have a lot of time before they become seriously unavailable. The Earth is huge. Imagine if all oxygen production on Earth stopped tomorrow. We would still have enough oxygen in the atmosphere that would last 1000 years at current consumption (obviously you couldn't live for a 1000 years though). Humanity has progressed immensely in the last 200 years. I can't imagine where we will be in 500.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by rubidium on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:13AM (#23246977)
"the carrying capacity of the Earth is closed to 1 billion people" This is FUD. The carrying capacity of earth is determined by the ingenuity of humanity. It can go poorly for the environment or not, but considering it purely a function of the number of people is Malthusian hogwash.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:15AM (#23247004)
Sure, and if you're skilled, you can disarm a bomb before it explodes. You're ingenious as a species, but you're still dead. The data does not show that on our current trajectory, we are going to disarm the bomb. Even with COVID-19, we're unable to reduce CO2 emissions to levels needed to avert climate change, without going on ad nauseam about natural resource exhaustion (fish stocks continue to be depleted [1], rapidly exhausting phosphorus reserves for fertilizer [2] and fossil aquifers for agriculture [3], etc).

800 million people out of 7.6 billion are chronically undernourished [4] and your argument is we can still support more people? At what point do people get real that we are burning the gas faster than we can fill the gas tank of the ecosystem engine? Hope is not a strategy, and we are not so ingenuous if we already have so many people struggling to survive. Less people over time (total fertility rate stepdown), less demand on world resources, less suffering. It's that simple.

[1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/07/fish-stocks-are-used-...

[2] https://web.mit.edu/12.000/www/m2016/finalwebsite/solutions/...

[3] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/5/100505-fossil...

[4] https://www.worldhunger.org/world-hunger-and-poverty-facts-a...

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by orwin on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:09AM (#23247776)
Mmm, the phosphorus reserves are doing better than a lot of other ressources. Its trues that _US_ reserves have peaked and will be exhausted soon, but currently China and Australia (from memory) are exporting currently half the world consumption and still have not peaked, while the place with the most reserves should be Morocco [0].

Anyway e is growing and will always be (unless our universe is not isolated) and we will all die even if we manage to: save our planet/move out of our planet/move out of our solar system/move out of our galaxy.

I realise that i argued against your point even though i'm quite agreeing with it. Oh well, precision do not hurt anyone.

[0]https://www.statista.com/statistics/681747/phosphate-rock-re...

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:11AM (#23247804)
To want to kick e down the road seems to be in line with my species' desire to keep kicking the can :) Appreciate the link regardless.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by vincentlee on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:16AM (#23247019)
agree. source: Rational Optimist How prosperity evolves by author Matt Ridley
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by throwaway55554 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:12AM (#23246972)
> The carrying capacity of the Earth is closed to 1 billion people...

Where does this come? Is it referenced in the books you mention? I just have never heard this before.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by zhdc1 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:17AM (#23247036)
The median study (according to a UNEP report I found after a quick Google search) puts global carrying capacity between 8 and 16 billion.

Source: https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/geas_jun_12_carrying_c...

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by WhompingWindows on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:15AM (#23247005)
Nor have I, it sounds fairly arbitrary to me. I don't think a global society that's structured the proper way need have a maximum population limit. If energy becomes cheaper and cheaper, like with breakthroughs in solar, wind, nuclear, storage, fusion, then it seems to me we could easily support 10 billion people's food and resource needs, given a circular economy which is highly efficient. There's also asteroid mining, carbon capture, vertical farming, high density living like in Asia...there are a lot of efficiencies to be gained in how our population lives.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by throwaway55554 on Thursday May 21, 2020 @08:34AM (#23257630)
It's interesting to think about. For instance, how much space do we need per capita? If we were to pack everyone together giving each a 2ft by 2ft space, the current population would take up the space of a large county or two. That's rather fascinating to think about because it isn't a large amount of space. Obviously it isn't sustainable, but our physical size is small. But then you start factoring in food, shelter, water, mental well-being, etc... It would just be interesting to find out how much space we really need per capita thinking along those lines.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by toomuchtodo on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:16AM (#23247015)
It's referenced in the Countdown book I mention, which includes citations. The author excludes the book from the Internet Archive OpenLibrary, so I can't directly cite the page. I'll have to reply back later when I can grab the book and find the page and citation it refers back to.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by prmph on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:10AM (#23246948)
> The carrying capacity of the Earth is closed (sic) to 1 billion

I assume you have a reference for this? How do you know the carrying capacity of the earth is close to 1 billion?