News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:29AM (#23247214)
> We simply don't need billions of humans.

You make an excellent point, and I'll raise a counterargument. I would claim, simply, that human life is intrinsically a good thing. I believe that my life is worth living, that it is better that I'm alive than if I were dead. I'll presume that everyone who reads this believes the same about their own lives. In that case, the more people alive, the better -- (if all else is equal).

That said, the philosopher Derek Parfit anticipated this and raises a counterargument to my argument above, known as the "mere addition paradox". [1] Roughly speaking, it goes as follows.

1. Suppose you have a population of 1,000,000 people, living happy, healthy, productive lives. Let's stipulate that this is a good thing.

2. Now, suppose in addition to this, suppose you have a second population of 1,000,000 people, who lead difficult lives with a lot of hardship, but whose lives are (perhaps barely) worth living. Then, if human life is intrisically good, then it is good that these people also exist. (This is the "mere addition" part.)

3. Given these two populations, equality is a good thing: lower the standard of living of the first million people ever so slightly, and raise the standard of the second group to match the first. This, too, seems to be a good thing.

4. Repeat. Eventually you arrive at a huge population, living lives of misery and squalor which are just slightly better than nothing -- but which one has argued is a better scenario than your original million people. This is the "repugnant conclusion".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by scottLobster on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:43AM (#23247411)
If nothing else more humans increase our collective potential intelligence to solve problems.

It's my my main issue with the anti-natalist movement: If theoretically everyone who believed in climate change agreed that anti-natalism was the solution, by definition within a generation the largest voting block would be the children of climate deniers. Which would actually make climate change much worse.

We don't need fewer humans, we need smarter/better institutions and more efficient technology. Every life born is one more potential option for a breakthrough.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:14AM (#23247847)
> If theoretically everyone who believed in climate change agreed that anti-natalism was the solution, by definition within a generation the largest voting block would be the children of climate deniers. Which would actually make climate change much worse.

As an anti-natalist (more precise would be anatalist, I am not opposing that other people have kids, I just wish they chose not to), let me address that. The point is not everybody to not have kids, but just enough to stabilize or slightly decrease the population.

First, you're assuming that climate denial is genetic and not cultural. Which is a big assumption, and I am in general in favor of nurture argument. (As a side note, by waiting longer to have kids, humans might actually be selecting for kids that are learning more and longer, which favors nurture even more.)

However, even if I take that assumption. If I chose not to have kids, that very much means I do not care about biology and what my genetics want. I am making the decision as a person free of the evolutionary pressure (well, somewhat, because I still care about survival of human race). Therefore, I am not sure why I should be bothered by the evolutionary pressure on other individuals. The truth is, it is going to be their battle. I can only lend them a helping hand (and perhaps an example), and do (what I believe is) a morally correct thing. If they mess up and still act wrong, it's not my moral responsibility.

It is a similar question as to whether or not vote strategically. If everybody votes strategically, you can get a result that no one wants. Therefore, somebody has to sacrifice and decidedly vote not strategically.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by scottLobster on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:40AM (#23248181)
I'm not assuming climate denial is genetic at all, parents and cultures have a great deal of influence on their children's beliefs. If every Christian decided to not have kids tomorrow the world would be mostly Muslim and Hindu within a few decades. The few converts to Christianity would not replace the losses. Same with Climate Change. If the only culture that reproduces is climate deniers, the they will be the majority. In democracies majorities win.

I'm not saying you or anyone else should have kids out of some sense of duty. If you don't want kids, fine. People having kids they didn't want has led to a lot of messed up families. However I find the argument that it's because of climate change to be a post-hoc rationalization. It's like if during the black death people said they're not having kids because it's morally correct to not produce more plague carriers.

As for your voting analogy, under our current system (in the US) if everyone votes strategically some good might occur albeit in a somewhat corrupt, half-assed manner. If fewer people vote strategically then those who vote strategically win, however small a minority they might be. That's how we ended up with a two party system. Alliances willing to compromise parts of their values will defeat smaller but pure adversaries.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @12:12PM (#23248581)
> I'm not assuming climate denial is genetic at all, parents and cultures have a great deal of influence on their children's beliefs.

I think for my argument it doesn't matter whether the inheritance of the denialist position happens through biological or cultural means. Either way, what you're assuming is that by and large people cannot change their position (from the position of their parents) based on the situation they will find themselves in, that they cannot adapt culturally (i.e. they can only adapt via natural selection).

> However I find the argument that it's because of climate change to be a post-hoc rationalization.

Maybe it is. How can anyone know? I don't think it changes anything in the debate, if it's just a rationalization of something else. Maybe your belief that it is a post-hoc rationalization is a rationalization of something as well.

> under our current system (in the US) if everyone votes strategically some good might occur albeit in a somewhat corrupt, half-assed manner

Saying "some good might occur" is equivalent of "some bad might occur", which was my point. Your (not mine) U.S. voting system is horrible, you should push for changing it into something more sane. But regardless, I think what I wrote is true for most voting systems.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by justwalt on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:36AM (#23248140)
I highly doubt he thinks climate denial is a genetic presupposition.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by js8 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @12:21PM (#23248697)
Well, I didn't want to say that out loud, but the argument is a soft version of "stupid people will win" argument, which I disagree with (and I find it repulsively elitist). That's where the genetics comes in; I should have written biology instead of genetics, though.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by boardwaalk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @07:45PM (#23253357)
We (humans) are so mind-blowingly disorganized at solving problems that you likely could have much more of an impact focusing on solving that organization problem (even just a small part of it) than spending resources raising kids. And that is ignoring the environmental impact.

IOW, if your goal is to better humanity, having a kid is a really, really blunt instrument versus using more of your brain capacity x time on that goal.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by nitwit005 on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @09:19PM (#23253933)
Pick silly axioms, get silly conclusions.

If it were genuinely the case that human life should be maximized, we should lower everyone's standard of living as much as possible (it consumes resources), and then force everyone to have as many children as possible.

Of course, that would also maximize human suffering, but apparently human life is intrinsically good regardless of suffering, so not a problem.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by saiya-jin on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:45AM (#23247444)
This is perspective from purely human view, ignoring just about everything else that makes reality, which is way more complex.

People don't live in vacuum, we destroy our environment on maybe even exponential scale as our numbers grow. Extermination of vast amounts of species and whole ecosystems might mean nothing to you, but sure as hell is something I value very highly.

I am not an extremist, I don't claim that earth and universe would be just fine without humans, we can be a worthy addition even if only for selfish purposes. But as usually some middle path is probably the best, especially in long term view, which is very hard to model for human mind.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#23247768)
> This is perspective from purely human view, ignoring just about everything else that makes reality, which is way more complex.

I agree. (And, in particular, I agree that ecological diversity is very important.) I consider it to be something of a foundational model -- kind of like how in introductory physics you assume that things like air resistance don't exist.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by jonwalch on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @10:40AM (#23247365)
"I'll presume that everyone who reads this believes the same about their own lives."

That's an enormous assumption, in my opinion.

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by volkk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#23247753)
you've lost me at

> Given these two populations, equality is a good thing: lower the standard of living of the first million people ever so slightly, and raise the standard of the second group to match the first.

I'm trying to understand why you would repeat this step if you've lowered the standard of the first million ever so slightly but have already matched the miserable million to be that of the happy million?

Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:12AM (#23247816)
Repeat steps 2 and 3: in addition to the now combined group of two million people, assume that you have an additional group of two million people living difficult lives. Now repeat step 3, and so on, until you've doubled the population many times.
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by volkk on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:25AM (#23247987)
Why cant you add a million happy people instead? or both? I understand this is a philosophical thought experiment, but of course if you keep diluting substance X with more and more of substance Y, you'll eventually get mostly substance Y...right? Is it impossible for a society to add 1 happy person for every unhappy person?
Re:U.S. Birthrates Fall to Record Low by impendia on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @11:31AM (#23248080)
> if you keep diluting substance X with more and more of substance Y, you'll eventually get mostly substance Y.

Exactly, that's the paradox. Parfit's argument stipulates a series of steps each of which seems to make the world better, but where the end result seems to be worse than what you started with.

Hopefully, we can avoid the paradox, and instead grow in such a way that everyone thrives and we mitigate the negative effects on the environment.