News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by elric on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:48AM (#23092365)
Tangent: I wish the idiom of "placing" cookies would go away. Websites don't "place" cookies. Websites can include cookies in their HTTP responses. Your browser can include them in future requests. But it doesn't have to. There is nothing in the HTTP spec that says you have to accept cookies or include them in subsequent requests. There certainly isn't any reason to "place" them on your computer.

If more browsers were still User Agents in the literal sense, maybe we wouldn't have needed this legislation. Browsers could have informed people about what cookies were, and could have presented the user with the option to never accept tracking cookies from Big Advertising. Every browser has the option to reject third party cookies or to clear all cookies at the end of the browser session.

This mischaracterization of cookies has, ironically, made life a lot less pleasant for people who don't accept cookies. The "opt-out" is just another cookie. There's nothing special about them either, they can be used to track return visitors just as well as any other cookie. I'm sure they're not, because that would be against the spirit of the law ...

Not tracking people without consent is definitely a Good Thing, but it shouldn't require everyone and their grandmother to put annoying cookie banners on every website under the sun. And I think it wouldn't have, had people been better informed.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dcow on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:03PM (#23092593)
Cookie banners have taken the internet back 20 years. Now every website has a mandatory popup. And you can’t block these new breed because they're part of the site.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Reason077 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:13PM (#23096366)
> ”Cookie banners have taken the internet back 20 years.”

I agree. The EU cookie laws were well-meaning, but have had the unintended consequence of making the web more annoying, more difficult to use, and more fragmented.

The solution? Cookie consent should be a built-in feature of browsers and http, not something that is reimplemented in a slightly different way by every single website.

Your browser should pop up a standardised cookie consent request when you browse a new site, and enforce your selection as part of its security policy. If you choose to block all cookies (ie: private browsing mode) then the cookie consent request wouldn’t need to appear at all.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by apatters on Thursday May 07, 2020 @12:17AM (#23099675)
Yes, the browser is where cookie management should happen, we call the browser the user agent for many years, it is the piece of software which is meant to represent the user's best interests when surfing the web.

Unfortunately these days the browser would be better referred to as the advertiser's agent," or perhaps just Google's agent.* Owing to Google's control over both web standards and the advertising market, cookie management features have received little attention.

Google's monopoly power has prevented a competitive market of privacy-focused, user-first browsers from flourishing.

It's also probably unlawful, the irony is that not too many years ago we punished Microsoft for unlawfully leveraging its monopoly to control the browser, and when we stopped them we paved the way for Google to do the same thing!

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by toyg on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:58AM (#23101635)
> when we stopped [MS] we paved the way for Google to do the same thing!

Well, from a antitrust perspective, having TWO giants in the space is better than having only ONE giant.

Ideally we'd now apply to Google the same pressure and further split the field. Alas, politics are complicated.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jamaicahest on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:35PM (#23107224)
A duopoly is hardly better than a monopoly. In fact I argue it is worse, because it gives the illusion of choice, yet there is no real choice.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by totony on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:43AM (#23100357)
Lynx still asks for each cookie iirc
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by yosito on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:20AM (#23101170)
I love Lynx, but unfortunately most websites don't work in Lynx these days.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bonyt on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:50PM (#23096727)
Browsers used to have this, sort of: https://i.imgur.com/AAm3AJs.jpg
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by oceliker on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:19PM (#23097039)
Now I'm wondering why you were running this in 2019. I watch a lot of nostalgia game reviews on Youtube and get the serious urge to build a '90s era computer from time to time.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by joeraut on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:53PM (#23097374)
Same here. Running some ancient OS/software in a VM can be pretty satisfying though, especially since I don't have a whole lot of space for physical hardware.

Many games wouldn't work well in a VM, of course, there's no getting around that.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TedDoesntTalk on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:58PM (#23097973)
Browsers never displayed such a pop-up for cookies by default. You had to tweak settings, just as you do today (in today’s world it might require a browser extension, I don’t know).
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bonyt on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:38AM (#23102803)
I don’t think this is true. I recall this being taken on the default settings for that web browser. Web browsers like IE in that era showed scary pop-ups for all sorts of things - like there would be a pop-up for when you connected to a site over https!
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by HenryBemis on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:22AM (#23100584)
If this were Reddit, I would comment that: IE.. it only took it nearly two months to display that message /s :)
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:32AM (#23113591)
> I agree. The EU cookie laws were well-meaning, but have had the unintended consequence of making the web more annoying, more difficult to use, and more fragmented.

Only if you ignore the giant market of adtech tracking bullshit that that has been ruining the web since about 2000.

Every website that shows you a "cookie" banner (aka we-track-the-fuck-out-of-you banner), is part of this problem. The law is just bringing it to light. Don't be annoyed by the law, be annoyed by the websites, they are choosing to be annoying.

Look at those websites, they are the problem, not the law telling them they can't do it secretly behind your back any more.

The biggest problem was that this law didn't tell them to be fucking honest in the banners. "This website needs cookies to function" (when it's only about their mishandling of data to 3rd parties) is a straight up lie by omission. If they had to honestly tell in the banners what they were up to "we track your every breath on this site and then sell it to third parties, who sell it to other parties, and god knows what", people would be looking at these sites differently.

"We're forced by law to inform you that we crap on your privacy and are actively ruining the web by delivering the fundamental data that runs the adtech industry"

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by WhyNotHugo on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:32AM (#23114082)
Completely agree that prompting permission should be the norm. Sadly, if Firefox did this, people would just move off firefox, since "it's broken".

And obviously Chrome would never do this kind of thing, since it hurts Google.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by gpderetta on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:44AM (#23101571)
At the risk of being hyperbolic, isn't this a similar argument as saying that we shouldn't make burglary illegal and should instead build better doors?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by toyg on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:55AM (#23101617)
No, it's more about having standard laws about burglary in every town so you don't have to re-read them every time you get in the car.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by WhyNotHugo on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:33AM (#23114097)
> I agree. The EU cookie laws were well-meaning, but have had the unintended consequence of making the web more annoying, more difficult to use, and more fragmented.

TBH, I wouldn't blame GDPR for this. Here's a good analogy of what's tracking companies are doing:

    - Companies dump used batteries into the sea.  
    - Dumping batteries into the sea is banned.  
    - Companies start dumping batteries into lakes.
This basically shit on the law, and just though of another way to keep disrespecting consumer's privacy.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by rmc on Saturday May 09, 2020 @07:35AM (#23123854)
There already is a DNT (Do not track) HTTP Header, but advertisers ignore it.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by fomine3 on Friday May 08, 2020 @03:09AM (#23112174)
So we really missed P3P Policy implemented on IE7.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by akersten on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:47PM (#23096700)
If only the regulators had been happy with (or even aware of?) the existing capabilities of browsers to manage cookie consent, like "Block 3rd party cookies" and "block all cookies" that have been around since the late 90's, we wouldn't even have needed to add anything new to websites or browsers!
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by cnorthwood on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:29PM (#23097146)
The legislators haven't legislated for a particular mechanism, they've just said that any tracking has to be opt in, as opposed to opt out. Do Not Track was a technical solution for this, but when IE made do not track the default, and tracking something you had to opt in to, they panicked and stopped supporting the headers and instead preferring the cookie walls, rather than trusting the browser settings. If websites respected UA settings, and the UA implemented DNT in a way that's compatible with the law (so, DNT: 0 only when you opt in), then we wouldn't be here
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by akersten on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:45AM (#23104315)
Not sure what DNT has to do with it. Do Not Track was circa 2009, we were already "here" at that point. The cookie law was like 2002.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by kalleboo on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:07PM (#23099263)
EU legislators avoid legislating particular technical solutions, since those tend to not age well (see the uproar on HN when it was reported that the EU legislated to mandate USB-C, when they didn't actually do that, they just mandated that the industry agree on a standard)
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by zycon on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:12AM (#23100854)
Czech Republic (EU member) data protection regulator is aware and ruled that if user has cookies enabled in his browser, that's enough and user gave cookie consent. If user doesn't want to have cookies stored, he can block them in the browser.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Reason077 on Friday May 08, 2020 @11:45AM (#23116052)
A simple off/on switch does not provide a sufficient level of control over cookie policy. It's reasonable to want to allow first-party cookies on certain sites, especially where they're needed for site functionality. But block third-party tracking cookies, or even block all cookies on others.

Cookie control/policy in browsers needs to become more sophisticated than what we have today.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by notechback on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:09PM (#23092661)
They are not mandatory, it's a choice by the site owner to include them. They are only mandatory if you include tracking features that track users across the web (= ads and Google analytics).
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mfontani on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:13PM (#23092702)
One can include ads and analytics without consent being granted - they're "just" restricted to a method of delivering ads and performing analytics which don't track the user.

IANAL, mind you - but that's how we implemented it - you're opting-in to the ads that target you and analytics which track you, or you get the non-tracking/non-targeting ads and analytics.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by skrtskrt on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:16PM (#23092752)
What are some good non-tracking & non-intrusive ad providers? I've wondered about one day being able to put a few "ethical" ads on a blog site.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bartread on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:27PM (#23093802)
You don't need to look far. You can simply tell Adsense[1] to serve up non-personalised ads:

    (adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle || []).requestNonPersonalizedAds = true;
If you do this you don't even need to check for consent since you're not tracking the user or storing any PII. In my case this is what I call if the user doesn't accept advertising cookies, but there's no reason you can't disable them completely on your site if that's what you'd like.

You also have pretty tight control over the categories of ad that Adsense can display, and you can even go as far as to review individual adverts. I've booted a couple of ads that I found to be unethical/distasteful from my site using the review feature in Adsense.

The only issue with Adsense is that there are a gazillion ads it might show on your site, so I'd recommend filtering out any categories you don't much like first, and then reviewing ads sorted by popularity/impressions in descending order, otherwise you'll quickly go mad.

[1] Obviously not an option if you absolutely don't want to do business with Google.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by luckylion on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:47PM (#23096108)
> If you do this you don't even need to check for consent since you're not tracking the user or storing any PII.

Google seems to disagree [1]: Non-personalized ads are targeted using contextual information rather than the past behavior of a user. Although these ads don’t use cookies for ads personalization, they do use cookies to allow for frequency capping, aggregated ad reporting, and to combat fraud and abuse. Consent is therefore required to use cookies for those purposes from users in countries to which the EU ePrivacy Directive’s cookie provisions apply.

What's not clear from Google's documentation, but what I assume, is that they also do not use the info about the context & visitor to serve them personalized ads on other websites.

[1] https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/7670013

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bartread on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:00PM (#23097432)
Hmm, that's interesting because that would suggest that if somebody declines advertising cookies then you can't serve them ads via Adsense at all... which would be an odd decision by Google.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by AstralStorm on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:43PM (#23099118)
That's not the issue. The issue is that if the user has and sends Google cookies AdSense will use them. (And many people have third party cookies on, and AdSense might be using some tricky bypass there too.) Getting sneaky about tracking is their business model. And then cookie law is in full force.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bartread on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:09AM (#23101134)
Sure but it sounds like the only way to guarantee those cookies aren't sent by Adsense is simply not to use it in the event that consent is declined. Or am I missing something?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by luckylion on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:48AM (#23101283)
That's my understanding. You can't use most Google services without prior consent. Adsense, Youtube (even youtube-nocookie, which just uses localstorage for tracking), maps etc. Google is not in the business of not tracking users.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by bartread on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:44AM (#23102297)
But this is what I find strange. It seems unlikely that Google would simply opt out of serving people who refuse to accept advertising or tracking cookies.

Granted, from measurements on my own site that's only 1 - 1.5% of people, but Google's ad revenue for 2019 was $134.81 billion, meaning that they'd potentially be leaving $1.3 - $2 billion on the table by not serving ads to these people. Maybe it would be half that or less because the ads aren't personalised, so they're a bit more hit and miss and therefore probably wouldn't attract the same level of bids from advertisers.

But still, they'd be leaving a lot more money on the table than it would cost to fix the problem (an order of magnitude? two orders of magnitude?). Whilst they might choose to leave it due to opportunity cost, it doesn't seem that likely to me. Here's an example: I once worked at a company whose revenue sat in the £250-300 million range, and they absolutely considered it worth supporting 1% of their userbase for the extra £2 - 3 million it brought in (this is back in the day when IE7 and 8 were still a thing), because it probably only cost them high 5 to low-ish 6 figures per year in PITA workarounds to do that[1].

So, as I say, it seems odd to me that Google don't have a solution for serving cookie-free ads that require no consent.

Going back to skrtskrt's original question, "What are some good non-tracking & non-intrusive ad providers?"

[1] Obviously all us devs hated this, but it was tough to argue against from a rational standpoint.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by luckylion on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:56AM (#23103703)
I don't know whether they really could. It's not just an issue of matching ads, it's also an issue of having relevant ads.

I use adblock by default, so I have no ad-profile at Adsense that they'd use to show me "relevant ads". When I occasionally have to debug some issue with ads somewhere, I'm essentially getting the context-sensitive, not-personalized ads, and they're terrible. At least to me they look as if they were using very simple keyword-matches with little regard to context and primary language. It may be that they don't care to invest more, but it may also be that they don't have enough ad buyers that care for unpersonalized ads so they simply don't have a large pool they can choose from.

I'm also not sure that "cookie-free" would be enough, really. If you're loading ads directly from Google, the user makes the request and can therefore be tracked by Google. Even with Google Analytics and anonymizeIp, at least in the medical sector in Germany, GA is considered opt-in only. In that sense, I'm not sure a central service that delivers ads for you can work without requiring consent.

What very much should work would be a server-side system that's sale/lead-based, where the service would crawl your site, manage your affiliate programs and create ads for you that you'd then insert into your site. That way, no third party learns anything about the individual user and you don't require consent.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mfontani on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:24PM (#23096486)
Well, sure - you can still send some signals to see ads that are relevant to the _content_ as opposed to the _viewer_.

Example: you're seeing an article about devops and you get an ad about AWS instead of an ad that has followed you around from another website you visited previously.

The cookie used for frequency capping is considered to be a "technical cookie" and has no bearing on privacy, best I can tell.

The other types of cookies can be pretty much disabled at the point of calling the google tag, or enabled (along with more tracking/targeting ads) if the user consented to that.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by the_gipsy on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:09AM (#23100193)
> The cookie used for frequency capping is considered to be a "technical cookie" and has no bearing on privacy, best I can tell.

But the comment you're responding to says it right there: Even google is telling you it requires consent. It's a cookie, so it requires consent, period. Don't fool yourself.

Could google serve ads without cookies, and do fraud detection by other means? Yes, perhaps lowering payout due to increased risk. But it much better to pretend that a cookie-banner is needed, so that you might as well enable ad-tracking cookies.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by luckylion on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:30AM (#23100628)
Since it's a technical cookie that's required for ads/marketing, it very much falls under marketing, I believe. Imho "technical cookies" are e.g. Cloudflare's __cfduid or your framework setting a session cookie because it wants to be stateful.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:23AM (#23113983)
> > What are some good non-tracking & non-intrusive ad providers?

> You don't need to look far. You can simply tell Adsense[1] to serve up non-personalised ads

This discussion describes exactly the problem. How long has this tracking consent law been there now??

And it's just an option in Adsense?!!!

So whenever I see a cookie banner, you can assume they are simply too greedy to flip the switch.

Clearly the adtech and adtech-supporting industry hasn't even slightly bothered to look for alternatives, instead opting to annoy the public with banners. It's pure propaganda in the hope that the annoyance will turn into defeat, and somehow they manage to turn people's disgust towards the EU law instead of them, simply continuing to do their useless crap business and pretending the EU got their hands tied ... when there's a literal boolean switch to tell their shit to behave.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by nicbou on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:26PM (#23092914)
Affiliate marketing is the best way to go. You have full control on how you advertise products.

For my website [1], I have build close relationships with local experts. They provide services my readers need, and I know they can be trusted. I get a commission from resulting sales. I like that model because advertisers have zero access to or control over the readers' data. Unfortunately, it's simply not applicable to all websites.

- [1] https://allaboutberlin.com/

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mfontani on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:23PM (#23092846)
I wouldn't say "ethical", but even Google's pubads can do non-tracking.

For pubads, look into "setCookieOptions(1)" and "setRequestNonPersonalizedAds(1)" for a good start on the matter.

It _can_ be done.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by nicbou on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:21PM (#23092822)
> across the web

That part is not necessary. They are mandatory if you collect any form of personal data without legitimate interest.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by cwbrandsma on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:36PM (#23093071)
Which means any website that does anything useful. That doesn't mean ads, but Google Analytics (or another comparable service) is just about everywhere these days.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:57PM (#23094909)
The only reason you need consent is when you're tracking people or storing data that isn't required for the functionality of the site.

Shopping carts, subscription services etc. will still work, you don't need to consent to that, as long as you're not tracking people or handling their data unecessarily.

When you see one of those cookie popups it is a sign that the website is trying to get more information out of you than they need.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by rcxdude on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:20PM (#23095158)
> When you see one of those cookie popups it is a sign that the website is trying to get more information out of you than they need.

Or the owner of the website has failed to understand the nature of the law. Given the amount of confusion in this comment section this also seems likely.

The ones which deliberately make the flow for closing the popup and accessing the site without 'consenting' are the ones I think are actually acting malicously.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:50AM (#23114248)
As with most law, you're not excused from following it if you fail to understand it.

If the admin of a site thinks they need a cookie banner when they don't, it's really because they haven't really bothered to give much thought to reducing the amount of data collection they do on their users.

But I bet it's not really that common, website admins who think they need a cookie banner when they really do not. What is WAY more common: the website admins that do need a cookie banner, but ONLY because they use Google Analytics, and don't realise this is a choice they get to make.

Or people (right here in this thread) saying "I can't make a useful website otherwise" -- it's not that the law is hard to understand, it's not. It's that they refuse to give the problem any thought. The ones "failing to understand the nature of the law", actually just don't give a crap. It's like a butcher complaining "Why do I have to label my meat with 'made from tortured animals', I have to kill them right? I can't possibly produce any meat without using this rusty spoon that I've used for decades".

> The ones which deliberately make the flow for closing the popup and accessing the site without 'consenting' are the ones I think are actually acting malicously.

You can easily not act maliciously, and still be a crucial part of the problem. That's also what laws are for, even if you cross them non-maliciously, you get punished. That's because people "not understanding the nature of the law", when it directly applies to their business, is undesirable, and really a responsibility they should carry.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:24PM (#23095195)
> Or the owner of the website has failed to understand the nature of the law.

Oh, sure, but if they don't understand it then they probably shouldn't be gathering people's data either.

GDPR is pretty complex, but website operators have proved for years and years that they can't be trusted to do the right thing themselves, so here we are.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dantheman on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:52PM (#23095534)
I'm still waiting to see the harm this tracking is causing that is requiring the GDPR and it's giant cost to society.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:16PM (#23095763)
Giant cost to society?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by leppr on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:14PM (#23096377)
An exageration, but in aggregate, the time wasted on this by users having to close yet another pop-up (and being more reluctant to browse new websites), and providers implementing the functionality on their websites is not negligible.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:38PM (#23096622)
I hate the consent popups, but to me they signal something different to me than I think perhaps they do you or the parent commenter.

Bear in mind:

- Extra data collection or processing must be opt in.

- Not opting in must be as easy as opting in.

- The content must be available if the user chooses not to opt in.

Then:

For instance, you go to a site, tumblr.com for example. Why is not important. You get a consent popup. Opting in to extra data collection is easy but you don't want to. Navigating this consent popup is almost impossible. within a few clicks you are lost, you find a list of several hundred "partners" tumblr wants to share your data with. All are checked and need to be individually unchecked. You still can't work out how to opt out.

To me it's like someone's trying to scam you out of your data. They are so desperate to get your information that they are jumping through all sorts of hoops to try to trick you into giving it.

Do I really want to give my data so an entity that is acting so creepily? Nope. I close the window.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:54AM (#23114281)
"Providers" that have previously wasted time on making sure all the data collection, tracking and adtech on their site worked perfectly.

That time "wasted" now, is time spent to fix their mistake.

The mistake of thinking they could collect data on me and sell it to third parties in perpetuity.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:43AM (#23102290)
Both these time wasters are on website providers. If they stuck to collecting only what they need to provide the service, they wouldn't need to ask for consent. Alas, they're greedy, but then they don't get to complain.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dantheman on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:27PM (#23097121)
How much time and effort have gone into compliance, it's insane. That's measurable. The real cost is the delay to new projects, uncertainty, increased costs - its what we wont have...
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:43PM (#23097848)
But the flip side is we get back control of our data. Having to treat users data and privacy with respect seems like a completely reasonable thing to ask, and it takes you longer to create something because you're now having to do that then that's good right?

It being inconvenient to you to treat people's data and privacy with respect seems like something it's hard to feel sorry for.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dantheman on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @08:55PM (#23098411)
It's not about treating it correctly, it's about worrying about vageries in the law and complying with them.

Of course information should be protected, but there are all sorts of compliance procedures and processes that significantly increase complexity and cost.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:45AM (#23102310)
Asking for consent doesn't significantly increase complexity and cost. The required level of audits to support a world without asking for consent - now that would increase complexity and cost.

And no, not asking for consent and collecting data without supervision is not an option, neither legally nor ethically.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dantheman on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:11AM (#23103875)
There is a lot more to GDPR than the consent popup.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:36AM (#23113265)
GDPR isn't about the popup, but is about consent, and having to get it to be allowed to process personal data.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jdietrich on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @09:30PM (#23098651)
The cost of compliance is directly proportional to the amount of personal data you're processing.

GDPR compliance is usually expensive because people ignore Art. 5.1.(c):

Personal data shall be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which they are processed (‘data minimisation’)

If you choose to collect personal data, you're responsible for handling it with due care. If you don't want that responsibility, don't collect the data. If your business model is predicated on doing shady things with personal data, find a different business model.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @09:00AM (#23114345)
I know some people in adtech, and the time they spend on "compliance" isn't really a very big chunk of the total time spent on why they need compliance in the first place.

But I'm eagerly awaiting your measurements ...

Truly. Even if it shows the really big numbers you seem to imply. Because that shows something about their choice. How much trouble they're willing to go through to track you regardless.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by flukus on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @08:02PM (#23098002)
Tracking has a giant cost to society, the sole reason it exists is so we can be manipulated by advertisers into spending more than we otherwise would have.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:27PM (#23096511)
GDPR isn't very hard to understand, it's just that website owners want to have their cake and eat it too. Looking around for loopholes to do analytics that aren't actually what the user came to the site for is fundamentally the thing that the legislation is targeting, and all this handwringing about cookie popups and consent and anonymized data is "complicated" simply because it is not in the nature of the law. You do that, you need permission, period, and you need to be OK with people saying "no, I'd really rather you not do that".
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mcqueenjordan on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:14PM (#23097558)
> GDPR isn't very hard to understand

It may not be terribly difficult to understand, but it is indeed very complex to enact at scale, especially with large systems that were designed under different constraints.

> Looking around for loopholes to do analytics that aren't actually what the user came to the site for is fundamentally the thing that the legislation is targeting...

Totally agree, and this shouldn't be done.

> ...this handwringing about cookie popups and consent and anonymized data is "complicated" simply because it is not in the nature of the law. You do that, you need permission, period, and you need to be OK with people saying "no, I'd really rather you not do that".

This is where we disagree a little. Calling it handwringing is hand-wavey and dismissive -- this stuff isn't easy to get right, and it's arguably a large cost for the wrong solution. Cookies come in HTTP response headers. Don't want the cookie to do anything? Don't read it! Tell your browser to ignore it. Don't like the JS that's being run? Disable JS.

Waging a war against cookies is just a cop-out for fighting the actual problem. What's next? Opt-in banners for JS in webpages? For using HTTP? TCP?

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @09:09AM (#23114424)
> it is indeed very complex to enact at scale, especially with large systems that were designed under different constraints

The only different "constraints" relevant here would be "we get to play fast and loose with the data we collect or allow to be collected about users, without repercussions".

If that wasn't the "constraints" they were operating under, they have no problem now either.

> Calling it handwringing is hand-wavey and dismissive -- this stuff isn't easy to get right, and it's arguably a large cost for the wrong solution. Cookies come in HTTP response headers. Don't want the cookie to do anything? Don't read it! Tell your browser to ignore it. Don't like the JS that's being run? Disable JS.

> Waging a war against cookies is just a cop-out for fighting the actual problem. What's next? Opt-in banners for JS in webpages? For using HTTP? TCP?

This is indeed where we disagree, except the law also disagrees with you:

It's. Not. About. Cookies.

It's simply about collecting and storing more data on your users than you strictly need to run your business.

There's really nothing technological about it, if you did it with pen and paper, you'd be subject to the same GDPR. Talking about HTTP response headers or "waging a war against cookies" is just misleading.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:31PM (#23097728)
> It may not be terribly difficult to understand, but it is indeed very complex to enact at scale, especially with large systems that were designed under different constraints.

As a developer, I agree. As an end user, I am OK with this.

If organisations have to think hard about what data they collect, because it means they have to think hard about how to safely store and destroy it, then that's a good thing.

It has been easy to collect, store and disseminate user data without thought for a long time, and website operators have proved they can't (in general) act responsibly.

> This is where we disagree a little. Calling it handwringing is hand-wavey and dismissive

My honest opinion about most of the consent popups I see is that they are at best trying to weasel out of having to comply with the regulations, or at worst applying dark patterns to trick the user into "consenting".

I am sure there are some honest people with consent popups out there, but I'm not generally generous enough to attribute anything other than malice or incompetence.

> this stuff isn't easy to get right, and it's arguably a large cost for the wrong solution.

For sure, but it works both ways. There is a (potential) financial penalty for not taking care of user data, but at the same time, there's a pretty large cost to a user if their data is spaffed all over databases on the Internet when they didn't want that.

Also, I'm pretty sure if you are actually trying to be GDPR compliant then your first interaction with the information commissioners office will be them trying to help you comply, and you do always have the option of just deleting the data if you can't treat it safely.

> Cookies come in HTTP response headers. Don't want the cookie to do anything? Don't read it! Tell your browser to ignore it. Don't like the JS that's being run? Disable JS.

I feel like I read somewhere that telling the user to adjust their cookie settings in the browser was speficically discussed, and not allowed, but I could be wrong.

> Waging a war against cookies is just a cop-out for fighting the actual problem. What's next? Opt-in banners for JS in webpages? For using HTTP? TCP?

It would be a mistake to think that Cookies are the focus of the GDPR. See https://gdpr.eu/cookies/:

"However, throughout its’ 88 pages, it only mentions cookies directly once, in Recital 30."

The GDPR is about user privacy, cookies are one of the primary tools for violating it, and the most prominent artefact seen on the web, so it's the focus of a lot of discussion, but the main thrust of the regulations aren't around cookies themselves.

It is significantly unlikely that there will be opt in banners for JS, HTTP, TCP, phone calls, cameras at the beach, or just looking at people with your eyes any time soon.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by latk on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:21AM (#23101440)
> I feel like I read somewhere that telling the user to adjust their cookie settings in the browser was speficically discussed, and not allowed, but I could be wrong.

Consent must be informed and specific, so simply asking users to set their browser to accept or reject all cookies (regardless of purpose) is not compliant.

On the other hand, if browsers get their act together and standardize a consent API with the necessary features, then browser-based consent management would surely be compliant. GDPR and ePrivacy don't address this explicitly, though GDPR Recital 32 considers consent by “choosing technical settings for information society services”.

Centralising consent in browsers is a key consideration in the proposal for an updated ePrivacy Regulation, but the EU is not going to mandate specific technologies. Everyone is well aware of the mess that is the Do-Not-Track header.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mcqueenjordan on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:42PM (#23097839)
These are good points. It definitely cuts both ways.

I'm not against GDPR, and I'm glad these issues are getting attention. I just want to make sure we recognize there is a lot of nuance here, and there are real costs and second- and third-order consequences to consider.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by markdown on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:48PM (#23096117)
> The only reason you need consent is when you're tracking people or storing data that isn't required for the functionality of the site.

You forgot one more... you're a citizen of an EU member state. I live in a sovereign nation and EU law doesn't apply to me.

It's been quite funny seeing Americans fall over themselves to comply with GDPR requirements. It won't be funny when they also fall in line behind Chinese law.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by catalogia on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:07PM (#23096308)
> Which means any website that does anything useful.

That's a ridiculous over-generalization. My bank's website doesn't have ads on it; is that not useful? Wikipedia doesn't either, can you earnestly say you've never found wikipedia useful?

There is much more to the web than shitty ad-riddled websites.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by yoz-y on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:59PM (#23093435)
It doesn't have to be a modal popup either. If your default is truly "off" then you could have a banner on top or bottom or somewhere saying something like "please help us make the site better..." or whatever.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ferzul on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:18PM (#23094471)
but that isn't intrinsic to useful services. it is possible to run a profitable bookstore or organise an event without tracking individual users.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:30AM (#23114061)
Google Analytics doesn't do anything useful for the visitor of the website, only for the lazy administrator of the site. But the latter isn't the one giving up consent, are they?

Also it's kind of sad if you believe you can't make a useful website without having to hand over private user tracking data to Google. In fact you are using a website just like that, right now.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by kohtatsu on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#23093918)
Google Analytics being everywhere is a at least an order of magnitude worse than the embedded like button spying.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TomMarius on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:20AM (#23100253)
I disagree. Facebook has much more power over advertising to their users (by personalizing the wall).
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:50AM (#23102358)
Facebook personalizes the Facebook wall. Google personalizes almost every other page you visit and mobile applications/games you use. Not sure how Facebook is more dangerous here.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TomMarius on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:32AM (#23103376)
No, it doesn't. I use adblock, as does a lot of other users. The FB wall is organized to my liking without any direct ads needed.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by adrr on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:40PM (#23093142)
Or if you do Ab testing, or any e-commerce feature like a shopping cart. Internet is more than ad supported sites.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Jare on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:38PM (#23093950)
You don't have to assume your user wants to be A/B tracked, or wants to purchase anything. You can allow the user to enable them nicely and non-intrusively without a popup. You can ask the user intrusively when they actually initiate a purchasing action.

Most sites choose do popup instead because (they think) it is more effective. So be it, but don't say it's "mandatory" or that "they are forced to".

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by noisem4ker on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:43PM (#23094762)
Both false.

A/B testing is allowed and doesn't need opt-in if the A-or-B preference is only recorded in aggregate form and not tied to the user.

Same for the purchasing scenario. In this case, you would be explicitly collecting personal data to fulfill the order.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @09:20AM (#23114536)
Crazy how people whose job it is to build this crap, don't even know what the actual rules are.

It's almost as if they just want to collect all the data on all the users forever without any oversight, by continuously rehashing bad and misunderstood versions of the GDPR and pretending it's hard and complex and vague.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by goto11 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:32PM (#23094634)
You don't have to warn the users for using a cookie for a shopping cart. That is considered basic functionality.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by nsxwolf on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:47PM (#23094078)
It's a choice so many site owners have made that the web is effectively ruined.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by markdown on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:45PM (#23096088)
I refuse to include them. I am not a citizen of an EU country and I don't give a rats arse what the EU thinks of my website. They aren't the boss of me.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tjoff on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:50PM (#23094118)
No. In the pursuit of pure greed incompetent designers have taken the internet back 20 years.

That people absolutely ruin the user experience of their site deliberately is an active decision they make themselves.

Make an effort not to visit those sites. You will be surprised to know that people that make such bad decisions for their site seldom have any valuable content anyway.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by tripzilch on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:14AM (#23113901)
> Now every website has a mandatory popup.

Stop spreading this disinformation. It's just the filthy websites that track your every move on the site and then give it to third parties.

Would you rather they do that by default, extracting your data before you even notice, without even being able to distinguish the bad actor from the good actor?

The problem is that people think it's the cookie banner that's annoying, when it's in fact the very website that has been secretly abusing your privacy, except now they tell you.

The people think that agreeing to the tracking banner is a fair transaction because the adtech banner is being disingenuous. It's as if the entrance to a museum requires you to dump one empty battery in the ocean. It's a bit of a hassle but it doesn't cost you anything, and you get to see the museum which is what you want.

Except in 90% of the cases the museum is clickbait trash.

I mean I agree. No website should use cookie banners. None of them. Increasing fines all around for those adtech fuckheads.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by HenryBemis on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:07PM (#23096912)
> And you can’t block these

I beg to differ. I use AdBlockPlus (ABP) and I can block 99% of these banners, and proceed immediately to the website. One can also use NoScript to block some websites that are full of crap/trackers (like techcrunch).

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by cookiengineer on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:27AM (#23112626)
AdBlock Plus is owned by eyeo GmbH which actively forces media and news agencies to pay fees to allow advertising in their "acceptable ads" program. You can look that up on northdata.

I would heavily recommend to switch to uBlock Origin (and maybe uMatrix) instead.

Disclosure: worked for eyeo in the past, and quit.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by GvS on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:20PM (#23092812)
You can easily block them with uBlock.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dcow on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:45PM (#23093233)
How can I do this?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by noisem4ker on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:51PM (#23094844)
There are blocklists dedicated to cookie request elements. You can install one of those in your uBlock Origin and the banners will disappear.

I use and appreciate this one: https://www.i-dont-care-about-cookies.eu/

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by DangitBobby on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:00PM (#23094250)
Pretty sure GP is talking about the HTML elemenent blocker feature, which is not really a solution since you'd still have to use manually on each new site you visit.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by olalonde on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:08AM (#23101688)
What if browsers had an optional "consent to any cookie" setting that sent a `X-Cookie-Consent: Accept` header on every request? This header could be used by websites to decide whether to display the cookie consent popup. Would that be acceptable to EU regulators?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:54AM (#23102399)
X-Cookie-Consent: Accept would be explicitly illegal; consent must be specific. However, I believe X-Cookie-Consent: Deny would be sufficient grounds to not bother with showing cookie popups and assuming the user does not consent. But you don't need that anyway; lack of consent is the default state.

I propose a better alternative: just stop doing things requiring consent (which are, by definition, unnecessary, and almost always support an unethical business model), and then you won't have to annoy users with consent popups anymore.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by olalonde on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:59PM (#23110259)
I'd say a better alternative would be to allow people who don't care about cookie tracking to opt out entirely from the consent popups. It wouldn't change anything for you but it would be a big improvement for people like me who don't mind tracking and are just annoyed by the popups. Too bad that it's now illegal...
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:33AM (#23113248)
It can't be, because we both know how would it end. If you allowed people to auto opt-in, then malicious actors on the web, which currently show you consent popups, would instead use dark patterns to get people who don't want to be tracked to permanently opt-in anyway.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by zelphirkalt on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @08:22AM (#23153142)
I usually use uBlock Origin's element blocking to remove such popups, even if only for one time, or I use inspector to remove elements. If afterwards nothing is visible of the content, I leave. Seems like someone forgot to put the content on the page. shrugs
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jimmaswell on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:27PM (#23092924)
And all for what, some feel-good legislation that accomplishes nothing but making the web less profitable and entrenching big companies that can afford the wasted resources of their legal team navigating it. Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

It reminds me a bit of legislation in other areas that aims to make something so inconvenient people give up on it, like the death by a thousand cuts to American gun owners with state laws making magazine limits smaller and smaller over time, banning this and that cosmetic feature that has no bearing on anyone's safety, etc. What is Europe's vested interest in doing this to the internet though, information control (regulate a few conglomerates instead of having to deal with a bunch of little sites, by stamping out the little sites) and spite towards America's much more prosperous tech sector?

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:49PM (#23093279)
> making the web less profitable

This could actually be a good thing. These days advertisers act as censors: all it takes is a bunch of complaints and a website's revenue stream gets pulled. The webmasters react by deleting the controversial content and avoiding the subject in the future. If this is what a profitable internet looks like it should probably die.

> Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

How do you know?

> stamping out the little sites

Social media is responsible for this. Few people buy domains these days, it's much easier to register a name on some existing site. Most traffic originates from social media these days.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vkou on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:08PM (#23099271)
> This could actually be a good thing. These days advertisers act as censors: all it takes is a bunch of complaints and a website's revenue stream gets pulled. The webmasters react by deleting the controversial content and avoiding the subject in the future. If this is what a profitable internet looks like it should probably die.

This is how newspapers have operated for nearly a century, and how television operated for over 60 years.

What do you expect will replace it? A reversion to the patronage system? I don't think Bloomberg or Murdoch paying for content to be made in the way they want it is going to be an improvement.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by matheusmoreira on Thursday May 07, 2020 @11:29AM (#23104127)
> This is how newspapers have operated for nearly a century, and how television operated for over 60 years.

Yes. They depend on advertising revenue and are worse off for it.

Journalists have a duty to report facts accurately but they must also keep the advertisers happy. Due to this conflict of interest, newspapers lose trust and are perceived as having little integrity. Gotta wonder if the article is presenting a truth or some version of it that happens to be aligned with the interests of the people with the money.

TV shows are sanitized for maximum advertiser appeal. Even when they push boundaries, it's carefully controlled by the networks. There are numerous and well-documented cases where they actively influenced the creative process. Gotta wonder what shows would be like if creators had true free expression.

> What do you expect will replace it?

I don't know. Hopefully something better.

> A reversion to the patronage system?

Perhaps. Would be great if we had some kind of crowdfunding or patronage system that lets people directly fund the creators they like. Art should work like an investment: large numbers of people invest in the studios they like and the work starts once enough capital has been raised. Since the money is guaranteed, creators get more freedom to do what they want. Since they'd be compensated before the work starts, copyright becomes irrelevant.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vkou on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:05PM (#23105327)
The reality is that vested interests (Billionaires and nation states and political parties) will have an easier time in buying more favourable journalism under a patronage system, than crowd-funders will.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by 0-O-0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @08:55AM (#23102406)
I would love a return to patronage system, since now we have means to make it accessible and distributed.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vkou on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:03PM (#23105299)
Patrons whose interests are diametrically opposed to yours will outbid you. Patrons of billionaires will produce coverage favourable to them, and will have far broader reach than the guy begging for Patereon subs, likes, tweets, follows.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Supermancho on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:40PM (#23099465)
>> Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

> How do you know?

Same way I know that that defining the ASCII code for T as 084 has never hurt anyone. It's an interpretation of information, independent of the human condition. Change my mind.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by matheusmoreira on Thursday May 07, 2020 @10:58AM (#23103726)
Cookies are used to track users. Tracking users generates a huge amount of personal information. This data is stored in databases which run on computers. The security of servers can be compromised, leading to database leaks and the publication of people's information.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Supermancho on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:51PM (#23105885)
The setting of the cookie (the HTTP protocol) is not responsible for hurting anyone. People are, through negligence.

I would have accepted a case wherein a user in the arctic, with limited bandwidth, was hurt due to the cookie data interfering with the communication. Hand waving about a series of human failings being connected to a technology is not compelling.

I guess it's the same argument as the "gun" isn't responsible for gun violence, excepting cookies aren't even designed to reveal information. Guns are definitely designed (in part) be used against people.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by matheusmoreira on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:14PM (#23109485)
> The setting of the cookie (the HTTP protocol) is not responsible for hurting anyone. People are, through negligence.

It's not just any cookie though. You specifically mentioned tracking cookies.

> Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

These cookies exist for no purpose other than information collection. They aren't even required for the website to function.

This isn't negligence, it's imprudence: being reckless with people's personal information, amassing large amounts of it in the name of profit without stopping to think about the consequences.

This isn't unique to cookies either. It applies to every browser fingerprinting method.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:30PM (#23096548)
> And all for what, some feel-good legislation that accomplishes nothing but making the web less profitable and entrenching big companies that can afford the wasted resources of their legal team navigating it.

Ideally, big companies would be subject to the law just the same. However, small companies can get a head start by just not doing what they know they are not supposed to.

> Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

It doesn't have to hurt me. I just don't like it and I don't want it, and that is a good enough reason for me to not give up my privacy.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mark_l_watson on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:23PM (#23096481)
There is a very good book that I am reading that might change your mind: The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power by Shoshana Zuboff. Another book I really recommend is Jenny Odell’s How to Do Nothing - Resisting the Attention Economy.

You make good points and I am not arguing with you, but I found theses two books really convinced me that some balance is required, and worthwhile.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dahart on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:49PM (#23097344)
This comment seems a little misinformed. I don’t like the banners either, but you could study a little about the GDPR and what’s been happening.

> some feel-good legislation that accomplishes nothing

It hasn’t been all 100% positive, and doesn’t apply to everyone, but GDPR has definitely had an overall positive impact on digital privacy practices globally. I say this as founder of a for-profit US web company affected by the legislation.

> Nobody has ever been hurt by a tracking cookie in the history of the internet.

This is really demonstrably false. Tracking cookies, tracking pixels, and other tracking technologies, have been and are still being used to de-anonymize people and cross-correlate browsing behavior of people visiting sites other than the one they’re on. The concern is over privacy, and tracking cookies are a real threat to privacy, hence the legislation.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by WhyNotHugo on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:30AM (#23114057)
Hint: You can use ublock origin. Go to its settings page, and check the "annoyances" lists. This hides all this BS.

(I do entirely agree with you, the default internet is pretty much like you said, sadly)

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Causality1 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @09:01PM (#23098454)
Indeed. It doesn't make much difference to me if the pop-up I'm clicking out of is talking about cookies or offering me hot redheads in my area.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by d4rti on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:49PM (#23096718)
I should be able to set a browser preference that I only ever want functional first party cookies, unless I whitelist the site.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by fhrow4484 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:27PM (#23092920)
> The "opt-out" is just another cookie. There's nothing special about them either, they can be used to track return visitors just as well as any other cookie. I'm sure they're not, because that would be against the spirit of the law ..

How is a opt out cookie the same as tracking cookie?

Isn't there a clear difference for a cookie:

    is_opt_out: true
Compared to a cookie:

    tracking_id: 374739585483292
Sure the first one can tell server "this is a user that had visited the page in the past". But this is nothing compared to the second one which tells server "this is this specific user"
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by est31 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:36PM (#23093077)
You might think it's just one bit of fingerprinting information, but if 99 of 100 users click "accept" and one user clicks "decline", it's suddenly become 6.6 bits. Now combine that with other fingerprinting data and you have uniquely identified the user.

It's the same problem with pages where most users are logged in: the few who aren't are suddenly such a small group that they become identifiable through other means.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jcheng on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:26PM (#23096505)
Can you explain how you got 6.6 bits?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by user2342234 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:11PM (#23096956)
From Shannon's formula for information content[1]. The Idea is that the less likely an event is the more information it imparts.

  I = -log2(p)
In this case they used p = 1/100

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_content

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by aDfbrtVt on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:57PM (#23096815)
Because it uniquely describes a user within a group of 100 other people. 2^(-6.6) ~ 1/100
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by marksomnian on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:16PM (#23097005)
log2(1/100)
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Guest0918231 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:07PM (#23093522)
I think the following should happen...

1. Do a study and check how many people want to be tracked. Don't trust the data from websites because everyone is currently being tricked into accepting. Go out on the street, talk to someone for 5 minutes about how tracking works, how it can lead to more relevant advertising and a potential increase in revenues for the service they're using, but in return their browsing history, purchases, and communication will be tracked and associated with them. How many want to be tracked?

2. If 80%+ of people do not want to be tracked, then just create a law saying it's not allowed. That's it, we're done.

3. If less than 80% of people don't want to be tracked, then force browsers to prompt users on install to ask if they want to accept tracking. Websites, analytics, advertisers, etc, then need to respect that setting or risk being fined. No need for every website in the world to invent their own cookie/tracking pop-up system, and no need for people to adjust their settings on a per-site basis.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by stared on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:09PM (#23094356)
> 1. Do a study and check how many people want to be tracked.

Ask the same people if they wanted websites to stay free.

I bet 80%+ would want to eat a cookie, a have it too. (No anti-pun intended!)

(Side note: the proposition of banning things if 80% don't want to use them is dangerous. No wanting something personally is not the same as banning it for everyone.)

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by whakim on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:51PM (#23094845)
I'm willing to bet that a lot of HN users block third-party trackers, but the average user has no idea how to do that. Why are we allowed the choice between (as you put it) "websites stay[ing] free" and privacy, and yet the average joe isn't? (To be clear, I don't even believe that's the choice we're facing.)
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by scotty79 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:00PM (#23105260)
I don't block any tracking because I want the web to know me and serve me with the stuff I might want or need.

Logging out of youtube feels like falling kneedeep into the gutter. What I personally want is more and smarter tracking, not less.

When I'm at random site I rather see ads for electronics kits I considered purchasing recently, not liposuction or some other gross random things I would never want or need or even like to be aware of.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by lrem on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:09AM (#23100517)
Because there isn't enough of "us" to topple the web economy. Once a critical mass is reached, we'll see a (slow) mass extinction in the open web as we know it. Then a bunch of new business models will fill the niche.

Disclosure: I'm a Googler. Not sure how that affects my fatalism here.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by esarbe on Thursday May 07, 2020 @04:50AM (#23101037)
Not sure what you would describe as "the open web", but from my perspective, the "open web" died with the hypercommercialisation of the web. Nowadays everywhere you look there are walled gardens, if they aren't walled gardens they are honey traps to lure you to divulge private data.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:01AM (#23102455)
I think Google is working off and promoting a peculiar definition of "open web", which is an ecosystem of a) commercial actors, and b) resources (individuals) to be exploited by said commercial actors. The "openness" of that web is focused mostly of making it easier for the commercial actors to make money off exploiting resources. Efficient and unencumbered exchange of information or culture doesn't even enter the picture.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by lrem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @05:05PM (#23128312)
That's not the impression I got. Note that Google does not need the hypercommercialization to earn money. The moment you allowed your site to be indexed, Google earned its cut.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by whakim on Thursday May 07, 2020 @02:33PM (#23106444)
I'm not sure that really answers the question, though. My point was that only those with enough technical know-how get to choose to remain private; shouldn't everyone be able to choose as to whether they believe free stuff is a good trade for their privacy?

Also, why do we assume that the choice is between the status quo and the total collapse of the internet ecosystem? That there's no way for digital advertising to generate a profit without gobbling up ever greater amounts of our personal data?

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by SquishyPanda23 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:34PM (#23095314)
The websites aren't free, you pay by letting others track you.

This seems like it's a silly nitpicking point, but in this context that's the whole point of the discussion: whether your users understand and consent to paying that cost.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by nofunsir on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @08:57PM (#23098426)
The onus is on the "website" to find an ethical business model, not the people who have been (rightly) trained that the web is free.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by moron4hire on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:03PM (#23096870)
People say this (ads keep the Web free) but it's not true. What keeps the Web free is the altruism of the vast majority of people who pay for their server costs out of pocket. The long tail of sites won't reach the threshold necessary to receive a payout from their ad provider. So tracking makes Google money at the expense of users and most websites.

Example: my personal website costs me about $35/mo to run. If I put ads on it, Google would tell me I made about $5/mo, and then take that $5 for themselves because they have decided they don't need to pay out small amounts. So I basically get to pay to host ads for Google.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by somebodythere on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:52PM (#23097355)
The vast majority of web usage these days happens on YouTube, Instagram, etc. Ads certainly keep those parts of the web free.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by hk__2 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:15AM (#23101154)
> The vast majority of web usage these days happens on YouTube, Instagram, etc. Ads certainly keep those parts of the web free.

Counterpoint: Wikipedia.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by stared on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:43PM (#23095423)
...or grab it for free (which you are obliged to provide) while you cover the cost. It doesn't sound like a fair deal to me.

If you were able to say "tracking or subscribe" it would made much more sense.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Guest0918231 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:48PM (#23094817)
Not quite the same, because right now tracking is suppose to be opt-in. Free cookies are not.

A fair comparison would be a law saying people need to opt-in for paying for a cookie. You can't charge the customer or hide the information, they need to agree to pay for the cookies, and they need an equally clear option to not pay for them.

However, stores bend the rules. They have someone stand at the entrance saying, "Thanks for coming to our store, we have cookies for sale at $0.99. Would you like to come in?" If you say yes, then you're charged for cookies you buy. To get the cookies for free, you need to realize you can say "No" to entering the store, and then through a complex 5 minutes conversation, you can get the person to let you into the store for the free cookies every person is allowed to have according to the law.

Most people don't know about the free cookies. Others can't figure out the correct questions to ask to get permission to enter the store for the free cookies. Some people want the free cookies but they don't have 5 minutes to waste talking to the person, so they just decide to pay.

At the end of the day though, of course everyone wants the free cookies. I want them. You want them. The law says the store is required to give free cookies. Why introduce all the complex interactions and rules that businesses will not follow, and customers will find annoying? Just give everyone the cookies and be done with it.

If you don't want a blanket statement allowing free cookies everywhere, what's the ideal process? 97% of people want free cookies all the time. 2% of people want free cookies "sometimes". 1% of people never want free cookies. Asking people at each store for their preference (similar to a website cookies pop-up) is only beneficial to the 2% "sometimes" crowd. For the other 98%, they're just being annoyed and repetitively giving the same answer to every store. Require the banks to allow a setting on credit cards to toggle free cookies on or off, and have stores respect that setting without needing to ask.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Jare on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:33PM (#23093879)
> force browsers to prompt users

Given how many people think the EU did a bad job defining cookies, tracking, tracking methods and etc, it would be fun to see what they would think about he definition of a "browser" as something that can be forced to implement a certain feature.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by takeda on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:39PM (#23097807)
> 1. Do a study and check how many people want to be tracked. Don't trust the data from websites because everyone is currently being tricked into accepting. Go out on the street, talk to someone for 5 minutes about how tracking works, how it can lead to more relevant advertising and a potential increase in revenues for the service they're using, but in return their browsing history, purchases, and communication will be tracked and associated with them. How many want to be tracked?

There's a very popular (it's a bit weird that number of reviews is so drastically different between Chrome and Firefox) extension called Honey. Apparently bunch of people install it because it provides free coupons. I don't believe people that use it know that ultimately they are the product.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:20PM (#23098984)
I wonder if we need instead of a "big fat cookie jar" browsers should support authentication natively (i.e. they are aware that this is authentication, not that just there is some cookie called "session") and then we depreciate cookies entirely.

Now that the auth headers are known about, they can be treated as such and expired based on user preferences, but by default after 24h. There can be an alert "google.com has logged you in and now knows who you are until you log out".

Auth headers are then only sent for a single origin, so no scripts to track you around the web anyway.

The cookie workaround for those that need to genuinely use them are 1. session feature mentioned above - tie to that on the server side and 2. stick something in the URL and then keep tracking that via links, like most SPAs do anyway.

Want to do analytics? Anonymous-ish pixel or server logs.

Local storage is another issue, that should be permission based. (+ any other dodgy web apis).

Someone might say, what about a site you don't log into but needs to remember your prefence? A. Easy local storage, and it will ask for permissions AWS style e.g. "enter the name of the site to agree ____"

Maybe get rid of UA string?

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by m12k on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:36PM (#23093926)
I wish browsers worked in a way where placing a cookie on my computer came with a permission dialog like sending notifications, or using my location, microphone or camera does. I guess the browser could have some logic around detecting login screens, so it can tell that I just entered a username and password, so the session cookie from that site gets a pass (I think automatic popup blocking works in a similar way). Or move it up a notch, so it blanket blocks cookies anything that doesn't look like a login and shows a permission prompt only for the first time I do a login for a new site (which then gets whitelisted).
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by zozbot234 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:45PM (#23094051)
That's the way things used to work, but these popup dialogs became an annoyance as sites started using 3rd-party cookies pervasively, and the simpler "always accept"/"always deny" model took hold. Perhaps with 3rd-party cookies being increasingly limited by default browser configurations, we'll ultimately turn back to that model.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ferzul on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:29PM (#23094604)
really? when? i don't remember.

and to this day, cookies in firefox are managed in a hidden box with a giant list of all the sites you've ever accepted. they don't want you to manage these permissions.

but for permissions they intent for you to manage, you click the security icon and you can revoke what you don't want. if the only permission you granted is the right to store cookies, it says you haven't granted any permissions, although this is a lie.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by smichel17 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:02PM (#23096254)
I remember at one point -- not sure exactly what year, I'd guess around 2010-2012 -- Firefox had a cookie option "ask me every time". It popped up a dialog each time a site wanted to set a cookie, with options to accept, decline, and whitelist/blacklist the site that was asking.

I used it for a week or two, maybe. I stopped because it made the web unbrowseable. If you think one banner per site is bad, imagine at least 5 consecutive popups to start, plus the possibility of more when you took any persistent action our the site loaded a new 3rd party resource. And if you don't choose the whitelist/blacklist option right away, it's the same thing the next time you visit.

I stuck with it until it became clear that I was not going to run out of domains to whitelist -- ie, this was a never-ending workload -- and switched to accepting only first-party cookies. I don't think there was an option to decline 3rd party and ask for 1st party; I probably would have used it.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jefftk on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:43PM (#23096064)
Here are examples from IE3 and Netscape 3: https://twitter.com/uygarr/status/1003784413644316672
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by goto11 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:24PM (#23094549)
The problem is cookies are fine and necessary for legitimate functionality, e.g. if you want a persistent shopping basket. But a user or user agent have no way of knowing what a given cookie is used for. Therefore the legislation requires to warn if cookies are used for non-functional purposes like tracking.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by elric on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:29PM (#23095257)
You don't need cookies for a persistent shopping basket. If I want a persistent shopping basket, give me the option to create an account and store my shopping basket for later use. Otherwise, just nuke my shopping basket when my session cookie expires. This is a non-issue.

Of course it's not visitors who want persistent shopping baskets. It's sellers. And I don't really care about what they want. On ~100% of the websites I visit, I'm the visitor, not the seller. And given that webshops were a thing before persistent shopping baskets were a thing, I'll wager they can do without.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by goto11 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:52PM (#23095531)
Logging into an account requires some kind of persistent identifier. And it is not just for shopping carts - you also have a login and cookie here on Hacker News.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by takeda on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:47PM (#23097890)
Cookies were introduced as a hack to allow sessions. When HTTP/2 was being proposed phk raised this issue and asked why they didn't use this as an opportunity to make real fixes to http warts like this and eliminate cookies[1]. But given that it was pushed by Google, which didn't mind them, this of course was ignored.

[1] https://varnish-cache.org/docs/trunk/phk/http20.html

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:33PM (#23096567)
And such a cookie one that is necessary for the site to function, and as such not covered by cookie laws.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Kiro on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:24PM (#23097092)
Yes, but elric is arguing that even those kind of cookies are unnecessary. Meaning I would have to log in every time I visited Hacker News.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:28PM (#23097139)
I think they said it was unnecessary until you logged in, which was the thing that the Hacker News cookies were being used for?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by goto11 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:38AM (#23101861)
Yeah agreed. I was just replying to elric who argued we shouldn't need cookies at all.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by hk__2 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:20AM (#23101171)
> Of course it's not visitors who want persistent shopping baskets. It's sellers.

That’s not so simple. Persistent shopping baskets create problems for sellers e.g. stock changes; price changes; products may become obsolete. Some of them let the cart expire at some point, even down to a couple hours for some (ASOS). As a visitor I do want a persistent cart accross sessions because I may need some time to make (nor not) my purchase. And no, I won’t give you my email just for that.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Kiro on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:23PM (#23097084)
I run a game where you can play without creating an account, and going back to the game later will take you back to your previous state. How would I manage this without cookies? A lot of people don't want to create an account.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:29PM (#23097149)
Can you ask them if they'd like to save their progress?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:36PM (#23099084)
Save it where? What if there's no budget for server infrastructre? Say... a hobby project.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by kd5bjo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:26AM (#23099995)
A query argument inside a URL that they can bookmark is one option.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:07PM (#23105354)
Local storage?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by recursive on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:12PM (#23105417)
I assume that whatever fate befalls cookies will happen to localStorage as well. But maybe not. localStorage is kind of better for this purpose in any case.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by 0-O-0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:02AM (#23102463)
Shouldn't you be using localStorage for that?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Kiro on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:52AM (#23111794)
The state is saved on a server. I only need an identifier to retrieve the state but sure, I could use localStorage instead for saving the identifier. What's the difference though?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by 0-O-0 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:57AM (#23114313)
For some reason I assumed that you've saved game state in cookies.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by contravariant on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:43PM (#23097841)
Ideally browsers would ask permission for cookies that lasted longer than the current session (where a session lasts until the tab closes). And ideally most webpages wouldn't just keep nagging until people clicked 'always allow'.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by lidHanteyk on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:12PM (#23092696)
I still liked PHK's suggestion for removing cookies entirely from HTTP/2 [0]. I seem to remember that they advocated for instead having the user agent send a profile ID which is only meaningful to the user agent. That would allow the server to know which requests belong to which profiled user, but allow the user full control over which profile is presented.

[0] https://varnish-cache.org/docs/trunk/phk/http20.html#beating...

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by throwaway3neu94 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:37PM (#23093089)
Everyone would've emulated cookies using HTML local storage, because it would be a pretty quick fix (just wrap all cookie API's). So you'd gain nothing except push people from a standard to an ad hoc solution.

Switching to server side storage would've been a too costly architectural change. What if the server side was stateless before?

And even if, web applications would still have needed to support the old model for interop reasons. It's not feasible for everyone to maintain code for both approaches when they are so different.

It'd also break many use cases, such as using a (signed) cookie as cache for some really frequently used data. Or more importantly authentication, where an auth service returns a token (in some cases a token that can be checked by a different service without contacting the auth service again).

So yeah, that was a non starter.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Erlich_Bachman on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:24PM (#23093763)
> What if the server side was stateless before?

Then that's a pretty bad design choice to begin with? If some state is required for operation, but the website keeps it only on client? Not least of all reasons, for security?

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by toast0 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:35PM (#23093910)
You can make such state cookies tamperproof with server side signing. Depending on the state in question, leaving it with the client, instead of in server storage, makes for good lifetime management. Of course, if you want the state to be synced between different clients (for a logged in user or something), you'll need to do something else.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by throwaway3neu94 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:44PM (#23094031)
Statelessness is often a good thing in designs in many ways, performance, reliability, maintainability, operating cost etc.

As a concrete example for a common use case, websites show your user or first name in the top right corner. It's common to put this in a cookie set on login/logout. This avoids querying the user directory service (from the frontend or a different backend service) on every pageload. Security wise it doesn't matter if the user tampers with it, it's a display only thing. (More often than not it's signed anyway, and the cookie contains other things as well.)

Cookies meant to be presented back to a server can be signed and (optionally) encrypted. This is also a very widely used pattern ("cookie secret" is a good search term for concrete implementations in frameworks).

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by lidHanteyk on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:33PM (#23095944)
You can't have your cookie and eat it, too; the browser has to store profile information or cookie information either way, so this was never about statelessness. This is about the expectation that user agents will not just consent to server tracking, but carry around papers which will identify themselves to each server so that they can be better tracked.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by throwaway3neu94 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @09:46PM (#23098755)
I'm sorry if I didn't explain what I meant well enough.

I was talking about statelessness on the server side. If you remove cookies from HTTP, you now need a database on the server side.

You also get extra communication (between the client/DB, or the web service/DB), whereas previously the data would've already been available in both (the client has the jar, and the web service gets it in each the request). Turning a local memory read into a network request can be a difficult architectural change.

Also, DynamoDB reads are priced per unit ;-)

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dtech on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:14PM (#23095754)
That would mandate server-side storage for sessions and any kind of persistence though. It feels like that's throwing away the baby with the badwater.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vbezhenar on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:22PM (#23095170)
Soon all cookies will be treated with SameSite=Lax policy, unless website specifies otherwise. That means that by default it won't be possible to track users on other websites. It's still possible to track users with cookies using SameSite=None, but it's expected that most cookies should not use this setting, so browsers theoretically could use an approach similar to allowing notifications or location services: ask user for permission before accepting that cookie.

So if that UI will be deployed, may be those popups won't make sense anymore.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:52PM (#23096755)
> If more browsers were still User Agents in the literal sense, maybe we wouldn't have needed this legislation. Browsers could have informed people about what cookies were, and could have presented the user with the option to never accept tracking cookies from Big Advertising.

Unfortunately, cookies are not conveniently labeled as "advertising" or "federated login".

That said, yes, it'd be nice if the legislation in question had mandated proper labeling of cookies, and then let the user's browser handle rejecting them.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by takeda on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:09PM (#23096928)
That sounds good, but an infrastructure needs to be developed first, particularly a way to label which cookie is which and then have a law to enforce it.

Ultimately though by default I use extension to destroy cookies as soon as I leave the page, I can place an exclusion for sites that I frequent but when I do that I just allow all cookies. My reasoning is that if I have credentials they can track me using these anyway.

Anyway the whole thing is moot though, since advertisers are beyond cookies and use many other ways to track users. Now seems what their primary goal is, is to be able to tie multiple devices of the same user together.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by diafygi on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:06PM (#23092623)
Is there a setting in Firefox that allows you to whitelist specific cookies and ignore all others?

That combined with Firefox Containers would make for a very powerful combination since you could have different containers that would be your logged-in interface to a specific site, without then having to allow other sites be able to set cookies.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by abdullahkhalids on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:14PM (#23092719)
I have the

> Delete cookies and site data when Firefox is closed

setting checked in preferences. There is a Manage Permissions button next to it that allows some more per-website control.

Websites can place however many cookies they want. It won't help them track me past a day.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by monadic2 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:35PM (#23095320)
Firefox also has a "always use private browsing" option that I've been using for about ~6 months with great success—with a password manager the only annoying thing to do is get through sms "2fa" gated auth—mostly banks, health insurance, etc.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by mark_l_watson on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:32PM (#23096560)
Always private browsing as a default is a very good idea. I set Safari for auto-privacy. The overhead of manually opening a non-private browser when that is what I want is really a very small hassle.

Setting up Safari this way and using FireFox only with containers for each major web platform works really well for me and I have been able to talk non tech friends into trying it.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by arminiusreturns on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:10PM (#23093579)
It's been a while since I went the whitelist approach on cookies, but I think you can do this in the "manage permissions" section of the cookie area in settings.

Whitelist a site and set default behavior to block will still allow that whitelisted site... I think so at least, maybe you need wildcards or something...

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TapamN on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:19PM (#23095801)
This used to be a feature of Firefox. You could get a pop-up asking if you wanted to allow, allow for session, or disallow cookies from a domain the first time it tried to create a cookie. This was removed for some reason.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jdlshore on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:22PM (#23092835)
The Cookie Autodelete extension does this.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by noisem4ker on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @02:58PM (#23094915)
uMatrix lets you whitelist cookies on a domain and subdomain basis, either per-site or for the whole web.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by lilyball on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:19PM (#23096441)
If this was a browser thing and not mandated by law, sites would just intentionally make their sites break if your browser didn't accept cookies and then tell you that you have to accept the cookie to make the site work.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by elric on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:43AM (#23100055)
Had this been implemented 15 years ago, people's awareness might have grown and they might have decided to not visit sites that are obviously broken. Many sites only worked properly in IE for ages. Other browsers reaching critical mass forced the issue, and the web became better for it.

You're probably right that it won't be happening now..the cat's out of the bag.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ukyrgf on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:26PM (#23096504)
The only difference between this and the web ~15 years ago is that they didn't even tell you it was a cookie issue. If you couldn't access the site, then "uhh try using Internet Explorer?"
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:24PM (#23096485)
…and this is exactly what they used to do, so this isn't even a hypothetical.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ornornor on Thursday May 07, 2020 @03:24AM (#23100593)
There is a nifty Firefox extension (maybe it exists for chrome too, haven’t checked) called “I don’t care about cookies”

It discards most of these popups. Coupled with unlock origin and decentraleyes, I think you’re pretty well covered against tracking without too much hassle.

Of course temporary containers is the cherry on top (although amazon seems to have a way to recognize you anyway because it almost always only asks me for my email before logging me in)

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by jahewson on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:36PM (#23093076)
This is what Chrome has announced they are doing with “privacy sandbox” which is going to replace 3rd party cookies in 2 years time.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by kohtatsu on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:49PM (#23094095)
I'll put money on Google bringing some of their own toys into that sandbox.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22245101

https://source.chromium.org/chromium/chromium/src/+/master:c...

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by om2 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @09:29PM (#23098645)
Safari takes this seriously and now blocks all third party cookies by default.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by x3blah on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:10PM (#23099288)
"If more browsers were still User Agents in the literal sense, maybe we wouldn't have needed this legislation."

s/browsers/popular &/

There are browsers and other clients that are still User-Agents in the literal sense but they are not the popular ones.

The popular browsers measure their success by market share, not qualitative measures.

That is why Firefox tries to stay more or less in lock step with the leading browser on features.

This is not done out of fear of being inferior by some qualitative measure but out of fear of losing market share.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by dannyw on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:57PM (#23099200)
How can you reconcile this with the unfortunate situation that the world’s most popular browser is made by the world’s biggest tracking (aka spyware and adware with consent) company?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by WhyNotHugo on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:29AM (#23114045)
I do think this needs to be rethough from scratch.

When a website sends cookies, prompt the user "this website wants to track you, allow it? y/n".

The same way microphone/camera access it prompted. So it should be fine to reject this for news sites, a random museum, etc, but okay to accept for, eg: webmail, sites where you log in, etc.

We've simplified browsers UI so much, a SINGLE toggle button for this would be lovely!

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by Nursie on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:38PM (#23093945)
It doesn't requite banners.

No tracking-by-default, no need for a banner.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ezoe on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:04PM (#23099245)
Why don't you just disable the cookie in the browser you are running in the computer you own? If you can't, that means you have no control over the computer and software you own.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by ChuckMcM on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:20PM (#23093713)
Except that many modern web modalities only "work" if there is a cookie to tell them the state of your session with respect to the current display. (Think displaying page 7 of 10 pages of results for example)

Too many people were using this as a way to get a blanket acceptance of cookies, which not only included specific state to make the web site work, but other tracking cookies. What I see when I read this ruling is that you can't bundle the two. You have to allow the user to say "No, I don't consent to any cookies that provide PII." and then stop using them.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by toast0 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:31PM (#23093849)
> (Think displaying page 7 of 10 pages of results for example)

You don't need cookies for that. But, if you insist that you do, that can easily be a session cookie, not a stored cookie. And there's no need to obtain consent for a cookie like this, if it's not used to identify or track a (EU) person.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vertex-four on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:06PM (#23092632)
The legislation also covers things like sharing that Joe Bloggs living in Summerstone Drive, or the user with email address [email protected], is looking for a new car, even without advertising cookies. The GDPR would be necessary even if advertising cookies were not a thing.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by elric on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:26PM (#23092909)
I agree. The GDPR would be necessary. And it's a useful instrument (if still somewhat underused). The "cookie law" is what drove people to add cookie banners before GDPR was a thing. GDPR admittedly made them worse and more prevalent.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by vertex-four on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:39PM (#23093120)
I'll also point out that vast swathes of cookies do not require a cookie popup, according to the European Commission's internal guidance; specifically, for their own websites, they believe that "cookies used for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication" and "cookies that are strictly necessary in order for the provider of an information society service explicitly required by the user to provide that service" do not require a cookie popup. So, for example, CSRF cookies, login cookies, and so on and so forth do not require a cookie popup.

That is - if you're building a website and using the bare minimum cookies you need to make the website function, you don't need a cookie popup. The default here is that you don't need a cookie popup, and when you start tracking users and/or selling their data, you need to comply with ePrivacy and the GDPR.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by wlll on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:19PM (#23095149)
No, GDPR just forced website owners to air their dirty laundry. You don't need a cookie popup. See Basecamp.com, github.com etc. You only need one if you're asking the user for more data than is necessary to provide the service.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by monadic2 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:33PM (#23095293)
What's the meaningful difference to people who don't write their own HTTP agents?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:31PM (#23099417)
GDPR is about the collection of people's personal data, regardless of the mechanism you use to do it.

There are plenty of ways to collect data about people without using cookies to do it, so GDPR would still be needed no matter what measures browsers took to block tracking cookies.

Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU... by gpderetta on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @04:13PM (#23095734)
FWIW, GDPR has very little to do with cookies.