Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by goto11 on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @03:52PM
(#23095531)
Logging into an account requires some kind of persistent identifier. And it is not just for shopping carts - you also have a login and cookie here on Hacker News.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by takeda on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @07:47PM
(#23097890)
Cookies were introduced as a hack to allow sessions. When HTTP/2 was being proposed phk raised this issue and asked why they didn't use this as an opportunity to make real fixes to http warts like this and eliminate cookies[1]. But given that it was pushed by Google, which didn't mind them, this of course was ignored.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @05:33PM
(#23096567)
And such a cookie one that is necessary for the site to function, and as such not covered by cookie laws.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by Kiro on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:24PM
(#23097092)
Yes, but elric is arguing that even those kind of cookies are unnecessary. Meaning I would have to log in every time I visited Hacker News.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:28PM
(#23097139)
I think they said it was unnecessary until you logged in, which was the thing that the Hacker News cookies were being used for?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by goto11 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @07:38AM
(#23101861)
Yeah agreed. I was just replying to elric who argued we shouldn't need cookies at all.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by hk__2 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @05:20AM
(#23101171)
> Of course it's not visitors who want persistent shopping baskets. It's sellers.
That’s not so simple. Persistent shopping baskets create problems for sellers e.g. stock changes; price changes; products may become obsolete. Some of them let the cart expire at some point, even down to a couple hours for some (ASOS). As a visitor I do want a persistent cart accross sessions because I may need some time to make (nor not) my purchase. And no, I won’t give you my email just for that.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by Kiro on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:23PM
(#23097084)
I run a game where you can play without creating an account, and going back to the game later will take you back to your previous state. How would I manage this without cookies? A lot of people don't want to create an account.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by saagarjha on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @06:29PM
(#23097149)
Can you ask them if they'd like to save their progress?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by recursive on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @10:36PM
(#23099084)
Save it where? What if there's no budget for server infrastructre? Say... a hobby project.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by kd5bjo on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:26AM
(#23099995)
A query argument inside a URL that they can bookmark is one option.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by saagarjha on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:07PM
(#23105354)
Local storage?
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by recursive on Thursday May 07, 2020 @01:12PM
(#23105417)
I assume that whatever fate befalls cookies will happen to localStorage as well. But maybe not. localStorage is kind of better for this purpose in any case.
Re:No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU...
by 0-O-0 on Thursday May 07, 2020 @09:02AM
(#23102463)
Shouldn't you be using localStorage for that?
Of course it's not visitors who want persistent shopping baskets. It's sellers. And I don't really care about what they want. On ~100% of the websites I visit, I'm the visitor, not the seller. And given that webshops were a thing before persistent shopping baskets were a thing, I'll wager they can do without.