Unfortunately these days the browser would be better referred to as the advertiser's agent," or perhaps just Google's agent.* Owing to Google's control over both web standards and the advertising market, cookie management features have received little attention.
Google's monopoly power has prevented a competitive market of privacy-focused, user-first browsers from flourishing.
It's also probably unlawful, the irony is that not too many years ago we punished Microsoft for unlawfully leveraging its monopoly to control the browser, and when we stopped them we paved the way for Google to do the same thing!
Well, from a antitrust perspective, having TWO giants in the space is better than having only ONE giant.
Ideally we'd now apply to Google the same pressure and further split the field. Alas, politics are complicated.
Many games wouldn't work well in a VM, of course, there's no getting around that.
Only if you ignore the giant market of adtech tracking bullshit that that has been ruining the web since about 2000.
Every website that shows you a "cookie" banner (aka we-track-the-fuck-out-of-you banner), is part of this problem. The law is just bringing it to light. Don't be annoyed by the law, be annoyed by the websites, they are choosing to be annoying.
Look at those websites, they are the problem, not the law telling them they can't do it secretly behind your back any more.
The biggest problem was that this law didn't tell them to be fucking honest in the banners. "This website needs cookies to function" (when it's only about their mishandling of data to 3rd parties) is a straight up lie by omission. If they had to honestly tell in the banners what they were up to "we track your every breath on this site and then sell it to third parties, who sell it to other parties, and god knows what", people would be looking at these sites differently.
"We're forced by law to inform you that we crap on your privacy and are actively ruining the web by delivering the fundamental data that runs the adtech industry"
And obviously Chrome would never do this kind of thing, since it hurts Google.
TBH, I wouldn't blame GDPR for this. Here's a good analogy of what's tracking companies are doing:
- Companies dump used batteries into the sea.
- Dumping batteries into the sea is banned.
- Companies start dumping batteries into lakes.
This basically shit on the law, and just though of another way to keep disrespecting consumer's privacy.Cookie control/policy in browsers needs to become more sophisticated than what we have today.
I agree. The EU cookie laws were well-meaning, but have had the unintended consequence of making the web more annoying, more difficult to use, and more fragmented.
The solution? Cookie consent should be a built-in feature of browsers and http, not something that is reimplemented in a slightly different way by every single website.
Your browser should pop up a standardised cookie consent request when you browse a new site, and enforce your selection as part of its security policy. If you choose to block all cookies (ie: private browsing mode) then the cookie consent request wouldn’t need to appear at all.