News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by SiVal on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:48PM (#21467795)
There is a popular political perspective that rules on campus these days that treats wealth as something that just magically exists and is simply "redistributed" by one means or another like, say, a phase change in physics where no magnetism/charge/energy/etc. is ever created or consumed. I waited for a point in their model where people actually produced wealth and consumed it, made something or ate it, in addition to redistributing it. Not part of the model.

And the idea that things have a "true" value, the one put on them by enlightened campus philosophers, so a transaction not controlled by the wise and just will have a winner and a loser. I waited for the idea that I, shoeless but with ten loaves of bread, and you, hungry but with ten pairs of shoes, might reasonably value bread and shoes differently and BOTH win from the "redistribution" of bread and shoes, but it was not part of the model.

But their model (which they claim "reproduces inequality with unprecedented accuracy") could also (they claim) be fitted to a variety of different observed power law distributions when its parameters were adjusted, and the more parameters, the better the fit became. Yes, and they could probably get their model to describe the frequency distribution of English vocabulary (also a power law), with remarkable accuracy which probably does say something about economics but maybe not as much as they seem to think.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:52PM (#21470251)
It's not part of the model because, if you're studying how wealth gets distributed rather than how it is produced, it doesn't matter.

I'm guessing that your disquiet at this notion comes from the possibility that everyone is creating their own wealth, and to some extent that is no doubt true. But if you start with the simplifying assumption that everyone's wealth creation ability is equal, and you just look at distribution, and you find that your model pretty accurately reproduces the real-world distribution of wealth, it's at least some evidence that wealth-creation ability is not that different from person to person, and what's driving inequality is the distribution mechanism.

Since virtually all human traits follow a Gaussian distribution, it seems like whatever the wealth-building factor is, it would also follow a Gaussian distribution. But wealth follows more of a power law distribution. You never encounter anyone 1000 times taller than average, but there are many people 1000 times wealthier than average. This casts some doubt that wealth accumulation is down to individual human ability.

Couple that with the micro-economic observation that someone with 1 million dollars is astronomically more likely to make another million dollars than someone with 100 dollars, even if the two people are otherwise identical, and it seems pretty unlikely that wealth creation has much to do with the distribution we see.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by username90 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:09AM (#21471898)
> Since virtually all human traits follow a Gaussian distribution, it seems like whatever the wealth-building factor is, it would also follow a Gaussian distribution. But wealth follows more of a power law distribution. You never encounter anyone 1000 times taller than average, but there are many people 1000 times wealthier than average.

This is nonsense. Lets take an easy example, books, people don't want to waste their time reading bad books so only the most palatable books gets a good amount of sales. This means that a small difference in skill leads to a large difference in sales, which would recreate the power-law of wealth creation. Similar arguments can be made about engineering skills, management skills etc.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pytester on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:43AM (#21472056)
If you look at the actual richest people in the world though, they largely make their wealth off the hard work of others (walmart family), through some kind of gamble (finance), some kind of parasitism (unearned income like interest) or by monopolizing that "magically existing wealth the OP doesn't believe in" (e.g. saudi arabian oil).

For every JK Rowling or Steve Jobs there's maybe 100 who either fully or mostly extracted their wealth while going to great efforts to pretend that they're really just another JK Rowling or Steve Jobs.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by qnsi on Friday November 08, 2019 @03:37PM (#21486465)
More than half billionaires are self-made.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by joeblow9999 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @10:12PM (#21496161)
so?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by bildung on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:06AM (#21472166)
And yet the reality does not reflect your model at all: Most wealth in the US is inherited. https://www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2019/02/06/people-l...
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by anovikov on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:17AM (#21471932)
Very true. And my opinion of why distribution becomes even more skewed in both the income and wealth, is that it becomes easier to exploit this small difference in skill thanks to computer and the Internet (and books are the best example: it costs nothing to "publish" the book in millions copies online, so the feedback loop moving slightly better authors on top works a lot better than in times of printed books).
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by amalcon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:14AM (#21472472)
This is itself nonsense. It presumes several obviously false things:

- That people who are bad at writing books are either equally bad at everything, or derive most of their income from writing books. "Don't quit your day job" is a meme for a reason.

- That writing quality (by some metric), as opposed to marketing, is the primary driver of book sales. Sales of Twilight demonstrate otherwise. It's even more clear in music: see any one-hit wonder from a past decade. In many cases, people who liked it then now wonder why.

- That the economic model of book sales is representative of the economy as a whole. Books are almost pure intellectual property. Intellectual property is typically characterized by high development costs recouped through high margins. Services and commodity physical goods are typically characterized by low development costs and low margins, with non-commodity physical goods lying somewhere in between. The latter categories make up most of the global economy, so most of the economy doesn't meaningfully compare to books.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:15AM (#21473329)
The first two of your three points only mean GP needs to replace "authors" with "marketers". Also worth noting that it's not the authors (or musicians) that get rich, but primarily the people facilitating the marketing and distribution.

I feel marketing itself could be enough to recreate power law - ceteris paribus, even a little edge in marketing lets you get more money quicker, which you can then reinvest in marketing; rinse, repeat.

And marketing is not the only way you can reinvest money to make more money. All those ways turn making money into a form of: dmoney/dt ~ money, to which solution is an exponent.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by amalcon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @10:07AM (#21473804)
> The first two of your three points only mean GP needs to replace "authors" with "marketers".

Granted, but if you do that, it's no longer making the point that GGP seems to be trying to make.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tremon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:28AM (#21472245)
This means that a small difference in skill leads to a large difference in sales

That does not follow at all from your initial observation. You could just as easily state that a small difference in exposure leads to a large difference in sales, thereby taking skill out of the equation again, and thus supporting the GP's initial argument.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by username90 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:50AM (#21472327)
But exposure in the form of publishers costs money. Therefore publishers try to find authors whose work will sell, meaning that skill also makes exposure easier. And once your books sell your skills are validated, so you will have even more opportunities. But if the books doesn't sell enough then you are thrown away, and the publisher lost money. If you used your own money then you lost money betting on yourself, money didn't help you earn money here it just gave you more leverage to lose/earn more.

This is why people say "The first million was the hardest", because after you have used their skills to make a million others will trust your skills and thus give you more exposure and opportunities. So winning a million on the lottery wouldn't help much, it gives you capital but it doesn't validate your skills which was the most important part.

Of course I am not saying that luck doesn't play a part, just that earning power doesn't follow a Gaussian distribution.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:48PM (#21475406)
This is why people say "The first million was the hardest", because after you have used their skills to make a million others will trust your skills and thus give you more exposure and opportunities.

It is precisely advantages like this that drive the "trickle up" effect. To use your original example, let's say one author legitimately wrote a book that was 10% 'better' than the next best effort. As a result, many more people bought her book (let's leave aside for now the notion of winner-take-all markets, which is another factor in the skewed distribution), and now she (and her publisher) are enriched. On her next book, they can afford a lot more promotion, and with her name recognition, her next book is a huge success, even though it is 10% worse than her nearest competitor. Now they've both written two books, and they're both 1-1 in terms of quality. But the one with the first good book has two best-sellers, and the second is a failure who will probably drop out.

No one is saying that the first author is morally wrong, they're simply saying that if we, as a society, want to reward people according to their skill and effort, the current system fails in numerous cases because it is heavily biased in favor of existing wealth over talent.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by username90 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:03AM (#21471877)
> someone with 1 million dollars is astronomically more likely to make another million dollars than someone with 100 dollars, even if the two people are otherwise identical

I'm not sure this is correct, at least not on average. Take two average persons, give one of them a million dollar, then watch what their net income is the next 10 years. I'd bet that the one you gave a million dollars will have used up a large part of it thus having a huge net loss while the one you didn't give anything will still be roughly at zero.

Edit: This study shows that people significantly reduce their income after winning the lottery, suggesting that there is a negative correlation between wealth and earnings given that everything else is the same.

https://www.nber.org/papers/w21762.pdf

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by sokoloff on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:08AM (#21472174)
That suggests to me only a negative correlation between wealth and income among people who achieve wealth via the lottery.

I don’t see any reason to think this same linkage holds for those with a propensity to make money from entrepreneurial or investing activity.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:05PM (#21475599)
I'm not sure this is correct, at least not on average.

I assure you it is true. It is not true only if there is a negative value to capital (ie, capital essentially destroys itself). That's what you seem to be saying with your link, but that link looks at only a narrow segment of people (lottery winners) and even then, appears to merely be observing that winners subsequently have less labor income, not less overall income. Which intuitively seems reasonable---winners would be more likely to take early retirement. The idea that, all else being equal, having money means your income will go down is absurd on its face.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by bumby on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:13AM (#21472466)
The book "The Meritocracy Trap" points out that inter-generationally this isn't true.

More money helps fund better training which leads to elite networking/training (elite colleges, for example) which leads to well-paying, high status jobs and the cycle continues. Granted, it's not just money alone, but the major theme of the book is that high income from labor (rather than inherited wealth) is a positive feedback loop passed along generational lines and concentrated among the upper quintile of incomes

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by username90 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:26AM (#21472543)
I'm from Sweden were the things you are talking about doesn't apply, getting into our best colleges isn't particularly hard and private schools you have to pay for are almost non-existent. Yet there are still a significant gap in how much people earn, and kids from rich families still do much better in school and college than kids from poor families.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by bumby on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:42AM (#21472656)
Fair enough. At least here in the States, Scandinavian countries are often portrayed as more equitable on relative terms. Do you know how Sweden's inequality compares to the U.S. quantitatively?

The training for schooling outlined in the book is often independent of the school structure (e.g., tutoring, test prep etc.). The upper echelons didn't think it was uncommon to spend $100k per student on this extra training. The authors point was that training works and that the rich have more advantages to educating and training their kids

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by xyzzyz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:32PM (#21477527)
> Do you know how Sweden's inequality compares to the U.S. quantitatively?

By the Gini coefficient, the inequality is much lower, but the social mobility rate is about the same.

http://faculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/gclark/The%20Son%20A...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pflenker on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:25AM (#21472539)
I think you might be missing the point a bit. This is not about two people being otherwise equal, and one being given a million dollars.

The point is that someone who has a million dollars is in a position where it will be easier for him to make another million dollars, or at least it's more likely for him to be in that kind of position than for someone who does not have a million dollars.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:31AM (#21471194)
Why would you assume something as silly as everyone having similar wealth production capabilities? Wealth is not an oil secreted by a wealth gland.

It’s a really complex process of getting the right market fit for your product (i.e. your time in the laborer case). Someone who can produce a lot of wealth in one society can completely fail in another. Or they can just fail in a different market environment. Wealth production comes from giving the market what it wants at a higher price than it costs you.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by nomel on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:24PM (#21470370)
> if you're studying how wealth gets distributed rather than how it is produced, it doesn't matter.

I know nothing of this, but how can distribution be understood without the forces that drive it?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:38PM (#21475272)
We're using distribution here in two different senses. One is statistical distribution, like power law or gaussian distribution. The other is distribution in the sense of a distribution network. You can test your understanding of the distribution network without understanding how the wealth being distributed was created in the first place.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by duxut_staglatz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:35AM (#21472020)
It's called curve fitting (or machine learning if the techniques used are fancy enough).
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by duxut_staglatz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:14AM (#21471919)
Many things in the economy follow a power law, see [0] for instance

[0] https://www.nber.org/papers/w14299

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by koro9n on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:06PM (#21477822)
Then when you read James Madison defined the Senate as protector of the rich, a legacy fed to our Senators since childhood, you realize wealth accumulation has nothing to do with organic economic trade, and everything to do with political power brokering.

That it’s somehow dictated by physics is another example of people with emotional minds filled by godheaded supervisors that social hierarchy is preordained, not the uglier truth: the elite and their sycophants get violent when it’s pointed out they aren’t gods owed political deference

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by dv_dt on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:16AM (#21470885)
I think if you're studying the propagation of wealth distribution, how the wealth is produced matters, because there are threshholds below which it's more difficult for individual actors to start or expand productive economic activity. You see a hint of that in economic data where high-inequality economies show lower growth than more equal economies.

I think of it as something like a phase change, with insufficient energy applied equally enough across enough atoms you can't make it from solid to liquid and have a much lower mix rate in the economy.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by piokoch on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:27AM (#21471706)
I am not sure we can ignore wealth creators, surely they want to have an impact on wealth distribution, I can't imagine sane model that would just ignore this factor.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tremon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:33AM (#21472267)
But then, what is a "wealth creator"? Is a teacher a wealth creator? Were the parents of Bill Gates wealth creators? Were Elon Musk in need of a heart transplant, would the surgeon performing it be a wealth creator? Would the heart donor be? Would the director of said hospital be one?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by speleding on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:06AM (#21472794)
>it seems like whatever the wealth-building factor is, it would also follow a Gaussian distribution... >You never encounter anyone 1000 times taller than average

If I compare myself to Shakespeare / Einstein / Elon Musk I do feel that their abilities outstrip mine by an order of magnitude more than one would expect with a Gaussian distribution.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kamaal on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:08AM (#21471096)
>>someone with 1 million dollars is astronomically more likely to make another million dollars than someone with 100 dollars, even if the two people are otherwise identical, and it seems pretty unlikely that wealth creation has much to do with the distribution we see.

Someone who scores 85 marks in an exam is more likely to score 95 with a little more effort than some one who scores 35 is likely to score 85 with a lot of effort. This is for a very simple reason that to get to 85 requires a lot of effort, which builds a whole range of human qualities along the way.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:21AM (#21480137)
Note that the statement is that the two people are identical other than their wealth, so that in this case the difference in probability is independent of how the original million was acquired. That's the point.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kamaal on Friday November 08, 2019 @10:43AM (#21483221)
>>Note that the statement is that the two people are identical other than their wealth

That kind of thing exists in my example too. The real problem is people are similar but not the same.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:26AM (#21483730)
Of course they're not the same. The point of the experiment was to show that the differences don't need to be taken into account to replicate in a model the inequality we see in reality. The implication is that, while differences between people clearly exist, they aren't necessary to explain inequality.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by friendlybus on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:30PM (#21470395)
The power law you are describing happens in nature too. Size of trees in forest, mass of stars, ect. You can't go deep enough to dig up it's source, so you get carte blanch freedom to make the distribution arguments however you want. But until you dig up the cause for why the system produces a power law output for wealth distribution that has happened pretty much throughout history, under monarchies or capitalism or whatever, then you're just shuffling deck chairs on a titanic argument.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by wuliwong on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:24PM (#21468218)
I received a Ph.D. in physics in 2010, throughout my training, my anecdotal experience was that of an echo chamber. I didn't fully realize it until I left academia. Although, it was slowly becoming apparent as the years passed. My experience was of a relatively small and closed group of physicists who reaffirmed each other's assumption that they were at the absolute peak of intellectual thought. Most of the professors imparted this mindset onto their graduate students and post docs. It fits pretty well with my experience that physicists would ignore the history of economic thought and believe that they could create a simple model that would accomplish what economists and philosophers have been hitherto unable to in the prior thousand years. But economics (or praxeology to be more general) is not physics. And a simple model of coin flips with random pairings and one risk limiting function isn't economics. When you have such hubris and make such simple mistakes as to assume that value is objective, it should be embarrassing.

-------

I will add that I still am a physicist who likes to think about things like this. One addition I would make to the model is that the poorer a person is the larger a percentage they are willing to risk. It still doesn't get around the fact that this whole model is based around the fallacy of object value but I like playing with models.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by anovikov on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:20AM (#21471948)
>he poorer a person is the larger a percentage they are willing to risk

I don't agree with it. Poor people tend to be very risk-averse (they teach their kids to get "stable jobs" above everything else), and this puts them in a self-reciprocating loop of poverty. Many rich people who i know became so by repeatedly getting involved into "bold" things looked totally bullshit, and usually indeed was - apart from 1-2 in their lives that wasn't, and made them millions.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by deehouie on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:40PM (#21469259)
I think you're a bit burnt out from physics, thus this rather cynical view of physicists' approach to an important economic problem.

The mathematical models you find in the works of many highly regarded economists are even more simplistic, more vulnerable to criticism.

"When you have such hubris and make such simple mistakes..." that pronoun "you" should be the economists!

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by zamfi on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:50PM (#21469956)
That economists make mistakes, and that even well-regarded economists espouse simplistic models, is not evidence that physicists might be any better at it.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by Mikeb85 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:53PM (#21470515)
Economic models are simplified in such a way to describe causality and relationships between variables but aren't actually expected to work 1:1 with real world numbers.

That's why econometrics is a thing, that's why most economists nowadays are taught statistics, computer programming, advanced maths, etc... It's why there's a different process used to describe why things happen in a paper vs. predicting real world numbers.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by headsoup on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:44PM (#21468858)
> the poorer a person is the larger a percentage they are willing to risk

As a percentage, sure, but in real terms the poorer person doesn't have 'much' to lose (to be regained) over someone extremely rich risking the same percentage. The potential rewards are also likely to be immensely larger in percentage for the poor person too.

But this is also relative risk against wealth in context. Comparing poor against poor there will still be comparable poor people with completely different risk profiles (basic example is one with children vs one without).

The model I imagine must primarily establish reasonable/full context before determining any value factors.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:08PM (#21470310)
As a percentage, sure, but in real terms the poorer person doesn't have 'much' to lose (to be regained) over someone extremely rich risking the same percentage.

This is questionable. The assumption that a poor person can more easily regain their stake is shaky---a poor person who loses their money may become homeless, which could in turn make it harder for them to be employed, or if they are a trades person maybe they lose their tools or can no longer afford to rent them. By contrast, a rich person has access to credit lines and investors in their social network. For the poor who aren't wiped out below a critical threshold, then, it may be true, but you're not taking into account the significant number who drop below that threshold and may never recover.

I would rephrase the original statement, "the poorer a person the larger percentage they are willing to risk" as "the poorer the person, the larger percentage they are forced to risk if they want to achieve comparable returns on a percentage basis."

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:33AM (#21471205)
Rich people do not have access to credit lines if they don’t have assets to back the loans. And their rich friends certainly aren’t going to invest in someone who just lost a ton of money.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by vannevar on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:22PM (#21475119)
That's better than a poor person, who does not have access to reasonably priced credit even in the unlikely event they have the collateral. And in reality, the rich often do have access to unsecured credit. They have that credit because they've made money in the past, and even if their current fortunes have turned, creditors and investors will often continue to invest in them.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by dv_dt on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:19AM (#21470903)
One of may favorite quotes about models is (paraphrased): All models are wrong, but some models are useful.

I see it most often attributed to George Box, a statistician, but it's not completely clear he was the originator. In physics you have a luxury of verifying models at many empiric touchpoints via data collected in controlled or precisely measurable conditions. Comparatively in economics it's difficult to establish you have a useful model because the empiric data is difficult, and with unmeasurable aspects around human choices.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by emmelaich on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:55PM (#21468929)
It's analogous to weight-loss arguments.

It is true that calories = calories-in - calories-out.

It cannot not be true.

It just isn't helpful.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jlawson on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:05PM (#21469737)
I found it helpful. In a world where a million distracting influences are promising cheats, shortcuts, and easy ways to get to the goal, a single true statement to focus attention and wipe away the bullshit is incredibly useful.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by arcticbull on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:19PM (#21470105)
Sugar and insulin response are critical to weight loss. The more overweight, the more you're insulin resistant, the harder it is to actually lose weight. Once you hit metabolic syndrome you've got a big problem on your hands. The CI-CO model is not sufficient to model weight loss effectively. Especially since with caloric restriction your BMR slows down to match your reduced intake (which doesn't happen with fasting, FWIW).

tl;dr: The only time CI-CO is truly accurate is when CI=0.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by esyir on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:43AM (#21470753)
That's an extreme overgeneralization that's wrong in just the right places to be misleading. While there is a reduction in energy expenditure associated with the reduction of caloric intake, it is not equivalent to the reduction in caloric intake.

For instance, in a study of obese women, a reduction of (4.3 +-(4.6) kcal/kg) was observed in a calorie restriction diet of 20kcal/kg

Similarly, in a different study, a 30% calorie intake reduction was linked to only about a 5% reduction in total energy expenditure.

CI-CO is not a perfect model, in that it doesn't perfectly estimate weight loss rates, but the general concept holds true.

https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/85/1/73/4649429

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by arcticbull on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:54AM (#21470793)
> That's an extreme overgeneralization that's wrong in just the right places to be misleading. While there is a reduction in energy expenditure associated with the reduction of caloric intake, it is not equivalent to the reduction in caloric intake.

I didn't mean to imply that it was 1:1, just that the model doesn't hold entirely.

> CI-CO is not a perfect model, in that it doesn't perfectly estimate weight loss rates, but the general concept holds true.

In general, I suppose, however most people aren't trying to lose weight but rather fat. Consuming sugar causes a spike in insulin, and insulin triggers the uptake of sugar in the blood by adipose tissue as fat, and actively prevents the release of fats stored therein. [1]

So in the most literal sense, CI-CO works, in that (net of the 16% reduction in TEE relative to your reduction in CI per your data) you're going to need to get the calories from somewhere. However, if you eat 30% less calories than your BMR entirely as sugar, you're much more likely to be burning alcohol, glycogen and protein than fat, certainly in the near term.

If you combine that with the "eat 6 meals per day" fad and you're in for a seriously tough time losing fat. On the other hand if you at 30% less calories than your BMR entirely as sugar in one sitting over 20 minutes and fasted the remaining 23h30 you may actually lose fat, since that'll give your body time with low insulin levels.

Let me re-state: CI-CO is a very inadequate model for losing fat.

[1] https://www.diabetes.co.uk/news/2018/jan/drop-in-both-insuli...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jlawson on Friday November 08, 2019 @08:22AM (#21481922)
CI doesn't have to be 0. That's total nonsense. You think if you eat one grape per day suddenly you won't lose weight, or something? Who said anything about 0?

CI-CO is accurate if CI<CO. There is absolutely no way it cannot be. This doesn't depend on any kind of reasoning about biology or insulin or hormones at all. It's the law of conservation of energy.

That's the beauty of it. It always works. If CO<CI, you will lose weight. There has never been an exception to this in the history of life, and there never will be.

Even fasting, which you mentioned, only works as a means to an end. And that end is CI<CO. Research shows that the actual timing of fasts is irrelevant; the same calories eaten in 6 hours per day have the same effect if eaten over 16 hours of the day. But when people fast they tend to eat less overall; it's all that matters.

So many people try to follow your path, and figure out a way to manipulate complex metabolic systems they don't understand to try to wheedle the body into dropping pounds. It works only rarity, and 98% of people on this path are just deluding themselves to avoid facing the fact that they need to get CI down under CO. So they take refuge in complexity, endlessly finding ways to rationalize away the need to do the actual work.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jimktrains2 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:35PM (#21469592)
That phrase is usually used to remind people that eating less is as if not more important than exercising to lose weight. It takes a lot of effort to burn a Calorie and next to no effort to consume one.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by sokoloff on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:14AM (#21472195)
Aka “you can’t outrun the fork.”
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by viridian on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:23PM (#21475131)
A common joke on weightlifting and bodybuilding forums when someone asks how to get shredded abs to to tell them to add 'fork-putdowns x F' to their routine. x F is the format used to mean "repeat until failure", and it's funny because it really is the best way to get all of the fat off your midsection so your abs are visible.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by hector_vasquez on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:00PM (#21468967)
How are you defining a "calorie"? The number printed on the package? Because that number is basically meaningless.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by solveit on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:52PM (#21469680)
That number happens to be remarkably accurate. More accurate than required by law in fact. It also happens to accurately predict changes in a person's weight if you know everything they're eating.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by war1025 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:00AM (#21470548)
A question I've had that I never really looked into or found an answer to:

How does calories in vs calories out work regarding the energy left in food that is not extracted (i.e. the caloric value of poop basically).

Is digestion / energy extraction pretty consistent throughout the population or do the specifics of people's digestive systems play a role in how many calories are actually available to the body?

Basically, would a constipated person's digestive tract pull more energy out of the food since it is in the intestines longer?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by V-2 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:54AM (#21473143)
While it certainly differs from country to country, FDA allows a discrepancy of 20%. That's significant. There have been studies that showed the labels to be off by 25%.

And even if the numbers were accurate, they're still rule-of-thumbish, because human metabolism doesn't simply ingest all energy available in a food. For instance you'd absorb roughly 40% more calories from peanut butter than from actual peanuts (of the same calorical value).

There are more reasons why counting calories isn't nearly as accurate a method as people tend to assume, but these two are really sufficient.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by was8309 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:22PM (#21470117)
Isn't the low carb argument that for proteins more is passed and don't need to be burnt off, but for carbs almost all calories must be burnt off? How many calories do I take in and therefore must burn off thru exercise if I swallow a penny?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by solveit on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:01PM (#21470277)
I think the low carb argument is that processed carbs mess with your blood sugar levels, making you hungrier, but the discourse around nutrition is messed up enough that there are many low carb arguments, some of them mutually contradictory. As for your penny, zero, unless I'm greatly mistaken, which is why pennies don't come with nutritional labels.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by narag on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:52AM (#21470785)
THE low carb argument is ketosis. That's not even controversial. If you look it up on Wikipedia, it's described in a very aseptic way, it just a basic fact of metabolism. If you look at low carbs diets articles instead, a cloud of disinformation appears.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by trentnix on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:36PM (#21469239)
Thinking in isolation and with pride ends in being an idiot.

- GK Chesterton

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by deehouie on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:41PM (#21469266)
Albert Einstein did much of his greatest work in isolation, and he was quite proud, too.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by killjoywashere on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:59PM (#21469715)
If you read Isaacson's biography, it's hard to come away without feeling like Einstein's insights were a product of his time, that he was in some sense no more a vessel than each of us, and that vessel was continuously exchanging contents with others: his father, the family's weekly dinner guest (a local student), the classmates he cribbed notes from, the professors who found him frustrating, the playboy he tutored (and learned to smoke cigars from), his wife, the patent applications on time-keeping devices he read as a Swiss patent clerk (and his train-time-keeping metaphor), his many collaborators (Lorenz perhaps most of all), the early conferences in Paris, etc.

I am no Einstein, to be sure, but I do particularly recognize the experience he had as a teen, learning the math and engineering of his father from his father. His father and uncle, it's worth noting, built electric power generators. Mentally building an effective model of fields was surely something Einstein had to learn early, and perhaps without the math first.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by dcow on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:38PM (#21469891)
And, yet, in 200 years he may well be regarded as an idiot.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by username90 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:40AM (#21472036)
Why? Newton is still regarded as one of the greatest scientists ever.

Note that he too did most of his work in isolation, and he too was extremely proud.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kamaal on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:11AM (#21471108)
Exceptions only prove the rule.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by killjoywashere on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:50PM (#21469671)
My first exposure to really opportunity to contemplate economics, in even a qualitative sense, came with Dierdre McClosky's essay in the early days of "post-autistic" economics (1-3). Her observations about the flimsiness of economic modeling, verging on simply serving as a veil naked capitalism, struck me as the sort of informed cynicism I could hold onto. 17 years later, it's her disdain for economic models in comparison to physical models that sticks with me.

(1-3): I honestly forget which of these it was, but the key term I search for is "mind-breakingly"

https://www.deirdremccloskey.com/docs/paradigm.pdf

http://www.deirdremccloskey.com/docs/pdf/Article_320.pdf

https://www.deirdremccloskey.com/articles/stats/stats.php

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by d0mine on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:22AM (#21471678)
There is a crucial difference between physics and economic theories. Physics is a hard science. Physics works.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chewz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @03:24AM (#21471446)
> the poorer a person is the larger a percentage they are willing to risk

Utility function is logaritmic.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by duxut_staglatz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:15AM (#21471924)
Is there any evidence that it is?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chewz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:35AM (#21472608)
Pretty common assumption. [1]

The need for money saturates slowly. Think about winning 1000 dollars (nice dinner pehaps), 10 000 (better car), 100 000 (larger appartment), .... , 10 000 000.

At some point it doesn't matter if its 200 000 000 or 300 000 000.

On the other hand a lotter ticket is 1$. What is the utility of 1$ - a can of coke pehaps. But the perspective of winning $1 000 000 - thats a nice idea to hold for a few days... So many people do despite the slim chances.

[] https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/23952/is-the-u...

[] https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2013/08/05/how-the-mar...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by duxut_staglatz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:36AM (#21473012)
That's evidence for a concave utility function wrt income, not logarithmic per se.

But your first link does cite evidence that _if_ utility is CRRA, we are not far from the case where utility is logarithmic

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:40PM (#21468823)
The Earth has finite resources: finite land, finite minerals, finite water, finite energy. When people accumulate vast amounts of wealth, they place a large portion of these finite resources under their own control.

If we allow people and families to accumulate wealth indefinitely, it’s not hard to imagine a future whereby a very small elite control a vast majority of the resources. In this future, people can still create wealth by mixing their labour with raw resources... as long as they can afford to pay the rent to the rentier class.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by BurningFrog on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:23PM (#21469531)
Economic growth is the art of producing more value using the same amount of finite resources.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:33PM (#21470166)
...by extracting more and more of those resources until they're gone.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by BurningFrog on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:41PM (#21470442)
A popular idea among misanthropes.

Here are some facts showing the opposite:

https://reason.com/2019/10/09/the-economy-keeps-growing-but-...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:00AM (#21470547)
We're "dematerializing" by externalizing our costs.

This topic has been litigated on HN before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21020682

Key quote: Finally, and speaking of stepping in to fill the void: ctrl-F - "China" - 1 match. The single mention is to refer to it as a developing country, not to acknowledge it as the present-day location of much of the USA's manufacturing.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by reilly3000 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:47PM (#21470231)
more like until they are no longer profitable to exploit, which of course is a function of global state. That is what underlies the fallacy of peak oil, which I was personally susceptible to. Resources don't vanish, they become incrementally more expensive to extract until the marginal benefit of doing so becomes negative.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:09AM (#21470594)
In any reasonable discussion about economics, I would assume that "until they're gone" means "no longer profitable to exploit" as we're all aware that short of extinct species that are beyond our technological capability to recover, nothing is truly "gone" as long as there is someone capable of expending gargantuan amounts of money and tangible resources flying to another solar system (or galaxy or galactic supercluster) where those elements are still easily available. Really, then, it's a function of universal state.

Regardless, here on Earth, eventually we will either reach a point where growth in energy production is practically infinite or we will be faced with the rather herculean task of converting all of our waste back into usable material, ad inifintum, with less energy available than was put into the system to create that usable material to begin with. At that point entropy comes knocking on the door.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:24PM (#21470374)
Peak oil is not about cash profits, it's about EROEI [1]. At some point all of the oil still in the ground will become useless because it'll take more energy to extract than you get out of it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_returned_on_energy_inve...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:44AM (#21471260)
That stupidly assumes all energy sources are equal. Oil has an extremely high energy density that makes it useful for travel where battery isn’t even close (heavy industry, air travel, long distance trucking/travel).

There is an article on the front page about solar companies in Australia shutting down every other day because of negative energy prices. Burning 100MW for 10MW of oil makes perfect sense under these conditions.

Here’s a thought experiment for you: why do you think we have batteries given they take more energy to create than they will produce?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:07AM (#21472804)
Looks like you didn’t read the link. Quote:

When the EROEI of a source of energy is less than or equal to one, that energy source becomes a net "energy sink", and can no longer be used as a source of energy, but depending on the system might be useful for energy storage (for example a battery).

If oil is made to compete against batteries then it will lose. It may have higher energy density but it’s also non-rechargeable, requires a heavy and complicated and high maintenance (compared to a very simple electric motor) internal combustion engine, and produces large amounts of greenhouse gases.

About the only thing it would still be cost effective for with a negative EROEI is aviation fuel, but even that application is facing competition from batteries [1].

[1] https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/electric-aircraft/index.h...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:39PM (#21479313)
Aviation fuel is facing absolutely no competition from batteries. Neither is gas for long-haul trucking, bunker fuel for container ships, etc, etc, etc.

EROEI will come and go with nary a shit given. The entire value prop of oil at this point already is it’s portability, density, and refuel time.

Electric cars are already cheaper per mile when it comes to fuel, yet tons of people don’t bother because of charging logistics.

Energy into extraction is just part of the cost like anything else. There is nothing magic or even meaningful about it. That whole theory is based on the stupid notion that energy is fungible.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by shanhaiguan on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:11PM (#21470323)
I was under the impression that this is exactly what peak oil is: the end of our current levels of oil production, not (necessarily) the disappearance of the oil itself.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pasquinelli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:26PM (#21469172)
That's a fair description of the past too.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:43PM (#21469284)
At no time in the past were we in danger of reaching the limits of our planetary resources. There was always somewhere else to go, some other resources untapped. In the future that will no longer be the case, unless we manage to settle among the stars.

Past performance does not guarantee future results. The story of our society was not written with a fairytale ending. Whether we succeed and create a better future for all or destroy ourselves or create a hellish dystopia, there are no guarantees.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jlawson on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:10PM (#21469761)
Medieval and previous people were always at the limits of the resources they had the technology to access. The past was a Malthusian world. No economic growth and no population growth for thousands of years, in a world without birth control. The difference was paid by death. This is life when you're at ecological carrying capacity.

We managed to find new ways to tap resources better, more efficiently, deeper, and so on, so we revealed new carrying capacity which we haven't reached yet.

If we don't advance again the way we did before, a return the Malthusianism is possible. That should be your null hypothesis. However, spreading past Earth or transcending to entirely new ways of existing (e.g. computational life) are also possible. The future resists past-based analysis because the rules are always changing.

But there's no reason in principle that we can't tap extraplanetary resources, any more than a Roman-era tribe in Britain couldn't pump for oil in Texas. It just took a lot of steps to get there.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:53PM (#21469970)
However, spreading past Earth or transcending to entirely new ways of existing (e.g. computational life) are also possible

The leap to another planet is far, far greater than to a new continent. It is an open question whether or not we could achieve it at all before a crisis destroys our civilization to an extent we may never recover from. There can be no second fossil fuel revolution, that was a onetime event in Earth’s history.

But setting aside the challenge, with new possibilities come new opportunities for inequality. In the case of the former, it’s not difficult to imagine a wealthy person owning an entire planet. In the case of the latter, might I suggest the short story Incarnation Day [1] by Walter Jon Williams. In a world of finite resources and computational life, perhaps only the wealthy and privileged can afford to be incarnated.

[1] http://www.sfsfss.com/stories/incarnation-day.html

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:24AM (#21472920)
Space travel requires energy. On earth we obtain most of our energy from the sun. During interstellar travel there is no sun that we can depend on. Therefore space travel is impossible without creating our own sun with fusion power.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by notJim on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:28PM (#21469562)
It seems like a huge distraction to claim that this study is somehow an exemplar of problems on "campuses." There are apparently 1.6 million faculty on campuses and 76 million students [hastily-googled statistics], so to claim that they have uniform beliefs about the nature of the economy seems like an extraordinary claim to make, which I'd like to see substantiated more than this.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by nine_k on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:04PM (#21469734)
I suspect that beliefs are also distributed non-uniformly, and 1-2 beliefs dominate the discourse, while the widely varied rest is seen as minority / fringe.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by bhupy on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:02PM (#21470024)
You could argue that the distribution of beliefs is so uneven as to be almost oligarchic. :)
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by WalterBright on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:34PM (#21470170)
> I, shoeless but with ten loaves of bread, and you, hungry but with ten pairs of shoes

Even if I and you were equally skilled at making both bread and shoes, by economies of scale we can produce more bread and shoes if we specialize. Thereby, the use of trading makes us both better off.

The invention of trade, and inventions that facilitate trade (money, banking, stock markets, contracts, property rights), have greatly benefited humanity.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by 0-_-0 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:11PM (#21468602)
As John von Neumann said: "With four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk."
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by deehouie on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:18PM (#21469504)
You probably misunderstood what they're doing. They are not fitting data with a model; that's what economists and statisticians do.

They show that a simple mechanism, with very few assumptions about real world behavior could reproduce a remarkably realistic phenomenon.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by duxut_staglatz on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:17AM (#21471935)
It is very similar to what economists do, I am not sure where you find a difference.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by murftown on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:59PM (#21475531)
Totally agree that wealth creation is a thing distinct from distribution, and that it matters.

However, I'm not aware of any metrics or markers for wealth creation - other than revenue / profit. So in other words, most of our attempts to study economics ignore this, just like the model in TFA. They look at successful businesses and growing GDP and infer that wealth must have been created.

Another related concept - similarly murky and unaccounted for - is wealth destruction. If wealth is defined, say, as the capacity for people to live a good life, then how often is this capacity destroyed in the pursuit of growing business? We similarly have no markers for this factor in most of our economic models that I'm aware of.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:16PM (#21468127)
> I waited for a point in their model where people actually produced wealth and consumed it, made something or ate it, in addition to redistributing it. Not part of the model.

That’s because the people making the models don’t create wealth and don’t really understand where it comes from.

It’s like the way you see Marxists saying “seize the means of production” but never “build the means of production”.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by WilliamEdward on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:05PM (#21469004)
Not so sure you understand what means of production are. You cannot build more means of production without having access to means of production in the first place, hence the 'seizing' part.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:45PM (#21469297)
But all humans of sufficient ability (except those with extreme mental handicap) have innate means of production. Even those who have lost use of their limbs have an innate means of production via their minds in the form of intellectual property. Honestly, even many with mental disability but physically capable are capable of producing value from relatively little.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by Klinky on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:57PM (#21469706)
Your bar is too low if you think that things are okay because "you can always become a starving artist".
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:02AM (#21480081)
No need to starve. Just make something people want. You can do ghostwriting or content writing with few materials. You can become a personal assistant if you can answer a phone. You can, with labor, and ready materials(garbage for example) make a lot of things people want
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:11PM (#21470057)
More like “you can get a job and use the money you earn to buy tools.”
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by Klinky on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:34AM (#21470718)
Unless the job you get doesn't provide enough money to buy these tools, or there is a general lack of labor opportunities. This is a reality for a large portion of the current population.

So it's not an innate ability to create value really that matters, it's the ability to navigate a system with many gatekeepers who have entrenched interests, and where not everyone is starting from the same spot, but we should pretend they are, and pretend that all wealth accumulated is justified. Let's not question the means to that wealth or its ramifications on society as a whole.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:47AM (#21470763)
No, you can always start from scratch and make your own tools, invent your own techniques and products, etc. What you're seeing is that it's much much easier to get things if you work as part of the economy than if you go it alone. This is because the economy is already bootstrapped, through the work of countless millions of people who came before you. Nothing's stopping you from doing it yourself except for the fact that you don't want to because it's much harder to make things yourself than to get a job and then buy things.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:03AM (#21480087)
There's tons of labor opportunities. Most people want someone else to find some for them rather than searching themselves. And then they want to complain about how they're being exploited.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by sdfin on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:55PM (#21469375)
How did the first means of production appear?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by hollerith on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:58PM (#21469392)
The first capitalists stole it from the poor people :)
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:27PM (#21469179)
Yet all of the modern means of production stemmed from no means of production... hmmm.

People create all of the time with extremely limited resources. Especially ones that haven’t been seized.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:01PM (#21469408)
How would you go about building your own means of production for creating modern computers?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:12PM (#21470067)
It took a large part of modern industry working cooperatively for decades to build the tooling to make ICs. If your commune wants to make a similar effort then there’s nothing stopping you. If you don’t then you’re not entitled to own a chip fab.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:21AM (#21470912)
Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab? Why is some rich daughter entitled to own a chip fab? Because she is in the current system, while anyone else would have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:04AM (#21471084)
Ok so they do that, they organise people and get everyone working together (which, while it’s not generally acknowledged in this kind of conversation, IS work and DOES count as creating value) and by the time they’re old, they own a chip fab. That’s ok, right? It’s fair? If they build it, or pay other people to build it in a fair trade of money for services, then they own it?

So if they own it, they can do what they like with it.

Including give it to their daughter.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:22AM (#21472223)
No. They can't give it to their daughter, because it's not their factory: it's in the ownership of everyone who participated, since we were assuming no capital to start with.

If you aren't born with capital, and don't win the lottery, you can't pay people to build something for you.

You can work very hard, together with other people, and build something as a community. This is difficult and almost never happens in practice, as it requires extreme dedication and some alternate revenue stream to be able to live until the thing being built is done and can be used to produce ongoing value.

But when this does happen, the end result is in the ownership of the community, it is not any one member's to give away or sell.

Alternatively, if you are born with wealth, you can dispense with all that effort, and simply invest several fractions of your wealth in things until you hit on one thing that you can collect rent from. Sure, you'll do some work, but the money accumulated by your ancestors, often built on slave labor, monopolies, theft and other nice things, will do most of the work for you.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:06PM (#21477835)
If by "organize people," you mean induce people to work for them then, no, that is not work. That is using the coercive nature of capitalism (work or starve/be homeless/die) against workers.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:54AM (#21471305)
> Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab?

Why is anyone entitled to own food? If someone invests their resources to have something built (or help make it themselves), why wouldn’t they be entitled to own it?

The rich daughter gets to own it because that’s what the owner wanted and the thing about owning something generally is deciding its fate.

If someone builds themselves a house out of wood they chop from trees they grew, do they get to keep it? What if they exchanged goods and services for the wood instead? What if they also exchanged goods and services to have someone else build it who needs the goods and services.

> have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.

So? That’s how many of the successful chip fabs existed.

What’s your proposed alternative when 10,000 people want chip fabs and there are only 200 for you to steal? The government seizing them certainly doesn’t make more and it completely discouraged anybody from wanting to invest their time/labor/money into building new ones.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:33AM (#21472266)
My proposal is that no one person is entitled to own vastly expensive items that required the work of countless people to create. Those items should generally be collectively owned by the people who designed and built them. The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them (which includes marketing and sales people and whatever else is needed), in some democratically chosen percentage.

I said nothing about the state in this. I am still talking exclusively about private property.

And as for food, I believe people are entitled to life, and by implication to anything required to sustain it, such as food, medication, water, air etc. The exact means for realizing this entitlement (free food? UBI? I don't know) are not clear, but the fact that you can starve to death in a country with enough food to feed the whole medieval world is a travesty.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:50AM (#21473116)
>The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them

Well, economic theory says that the profits should approach zero as more and more competitors join the market and the provided goods or services become commodities. This effectively is a redistribution mechanism. The reality is a bit uglier.

By the way, prevention of wealth accumulation doesn't require repossession of existing property. A simple redistribution policy could dictate that a single person is not allowed to inherit more than 50% of the wealth of their parents. This forces parents to have two children and split the wealth. After a few generations the children will have 25%, 12%, 6% of the original wealth and so on.

There are still ways to exploit this if the siblings are colluding but let's be serious. If your family is rich and owns 50 billion dollars. Would you prefer $25 billion or $0 billion for the sake of higher generational wealth?

My point is that you need to create policies that even rich people would agree with.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:01PM (#21477787)
Agreed, and I never mentioned repossession. I was taking about ideal notions of entitlement, not practical measures for realizing that entitlement.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:57PM (#21475497)
Not yours to “not allow”.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:08PM (#21477846)
Please provide your reasoning.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:28PM (#21478474)
Define “theft”.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:21PM (#21494438)
So, you have no reasoning?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:21PM (#21509516)
My reasoning will mean little to you if we do not agree on core terms.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:54PM (#21475464)
As one who is not involved in creation or operation of “vastly expensive” items, you have no say in the matter. Those involved do have a say, that being accepting or rejecting contracted providence of goods or services, which may or may not involve co-ownership. Distribution of profits occurs by contracting. Democracy doesn’t apply because those not involved have no say.

You are entitled to life insofar as nobody may actively take it from you. There is plenty opportunity in this country to earn; $1 per meal is enough for healthy comfort (thanks to capitalism, food is plentiful, varietal, and cheap).

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:00PM (#21477771)
In an ideal world, they should have more of a say than 'take it or leave it'. And in fact, for most of human history, people who produced things did have more say than that.

I was also talking about democratic governance among the worker-owners: this is how cooperatives work in general. The strict top-to-bottom autocracy of regular corporations is not the only possible system of governance for a successful market actor.

As for food, it's not so much capitalism as enormous state subsidies that affect the price of food in America. And living on 2-3$ worth of food a day will not lead you to a long life. Also, how is someone refusing you the right to take food when you are starving not actively taking your life from you?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:04PM (#21479428)
It is an ideal world. People may negotiate for whatever they see fit. It takes two to come to an agreement. It only one agrees to terms offered, how is it fair to compel the other?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:20AM (#21480135)
A 'negotiated agreement' between a company or state and a person that would starve if they don't accept the agreement is nothing more than coercion with a nice layer of paint.

Remember that we actually depend on some people literally not having a chance to eat unless they agree to collect our garbage, clean our floors etc.

Do you think that a cleaning person in a contract with Google or with the city of LA had any kind of real negotiation power?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:12AM (#21483568)
Minimum wage is ~$7.25/hr. All one need do is work 25 minutes mundane labor a day to afford 3 square meals per day (see Twitter's @ABuckAPlate). (Corollary: min wage law prohibits anyone earning anything if they can't produce at least $7.25 value per hour.)

Collecting garbage, cleaning floors, etc has value - that's why we pay people to do it. Is it really worth more than ~$7.25/hr? would you pay someone $20/hr to do it?

A thing is worth what another will give for it. People are willing to trade $7.25 for an hour of mundane labor.

And yes, there is real negotiation power. Businesses are having to pay more, or find alternatives, for services because not enough people are willing to do those jobs. That's negotiation, in context of large numbers of people being willing to do a job.

BTW: if you're working where Google is, or in LA or the like in general, you MUST provide above-min-wage value because the carrying capacity of those areas has been reached - there are people making >$37/hr wanting to live in the same place, and $MinWage/hr can't compete with $37/hr productivity. I threw my stuff in a truck and permanently moved 1000 miles on short notice - so can others who likewise seek economically viable conditions.

I've lived off the land. Most of humanity did. If you don't want to plant seeds and build cabins (always a viable option), get busy doing something others will pay enough for.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @05:42PM (#21487693)
> If you don't want to plant seeds and build cabins (always a viable option), get busy doing something others will pay enough for.

How will you buy the land to build your cabin and plant your seeds on? We live in a system where all of the land is already owned.

> All one need do is work 25 minutes mundane labor a day to afford 3 square meals per day

This is just so wrong... Again, you can't have a healthy diet with 3 dollars a day. You also can't keep a job if all you earn is food money - you also have to have a place to live and shower, you have to have clean, non-raggedy clothes, a car, gasoline, maintenance for the car and maybe washing machine, health insurance so your life doesn't crumble at the smallest sign of disease, and possibly others. These are all necessary in order to even have that job which you claim lets you eat for 25 minutes of work a day.

> Collecting garbage, cleaning floors, etc has value - that's why we pay people to do it. Is it really worth more than ~$7.25/hr? would you pay someone $20/hr to do it?

Your thinking about this the wrong way around. Nobody would be willing to collect garbage for 7.25 if they had some alternative. It is essentially a job of desperation. So, it is vital for us as a society that there are always enough people desperate enough that they are even willing to collect garbage to make some money.

And in a worker driven job market (by which I mean, a job market where employers compete for workers, instead of the current economy, where mostly workers compete to find employment), garbage collection would be a high-paying job, precisely because it is absolutely vital for any community, and no one really wants to do it.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:57PM (#21509829)
If you don't want a solution, then you will fail.

I frequently make healthy meals for $1/plate; don't tell me I can't when I do. Covering meals in 25 minutes or less means time earn for other needs. Give me specifics, and a willingness to make money work, and I'll give you good inexpensive solutions to all needs.

The notion of a "worker driven job market", where menial tasks make enormous salaries, or "there should be some alternative", is pure fantasy. Of course everyone has alternatives: anyone can pick a preferred job, find an open position for it, and apply. Supply-and-demand is an economic law: garbage collection is not a high-paying job, because there's always someone willing to do it for less. You think GC should be high-paying, but you're not willing to pay someone high to do it; concocting (and forcing on others) a society inclined as you indicate would quickly devolve back to what we have now, precisely because easy & widely-available jobs are not worth high pay.

Bottom line: it takes a certain amount of effort to live off the land (go watch Primitive Technology on YouTube); everything else is an alternative because we contract for better options, and wishing for better doesn't work.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:59PM (#21479406)
You would refuse a starving person your food? You have enough, why the compulsion to steal from others to “redistribute”?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:26AM (#21480158)
I didn't talk about redistribution. I'm describing how a system could work from the ground up with a market economy but without any capitalists. How to get there is another discussion that is far more thorny.

I wouldn't deny a starving person my food, though the reality is that I rarely come into contact with someone who is starving.

On the other hand, a lot of restaurants and super markets do regularly deny starving people food - they ask for money in place of common human decency.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Friday November 08, 2019 @08:27AM (#21481949)
They give away lots of excess food. Every week I take bushels of gourmet bread to food charities. I go out of my way to do so, maybe you should to rather than agitating to compel strangers out of ignorance.

The well off do far more for the poor than you think - without gov't compulsion.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:39AM (#21473039)
>Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab?

If I make a coffee why should I be entitled to drink it? Well it's obvious. I bought the ingredients, heated water, etc... I consumed my own resources to make the coffee. If I don't own the end result then by making coffee I am just harming myself.

>while anyone else would have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.

So would the rich daughter. A chip fab requires external funding. This means the rich daughter has to obtain credit from a bank. In an ideal world the bank is itself funded by the depositors which have agreed to let their bank lend the money out. (in reality the central bank offers low % credit to encourage this)

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:04PM (#21477814)
There are people rich enough in this world that they could probably buy a chip fab 'money down' from their own finances. If that is somehow exaggerated, there are certainly people rich enough that they could buy, say, a shoe factory, or a brewery. The point still stands.

Also, even if you involve a bank: the rich daughter can get credit to buy a factory, while the worker in the factory certainly could not.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ihm on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:22PM (#21468201)
I don't think your comment is a good faith engagement with leftist understandings of value. This is the starting point of Marx's whole theory of capitalism (it's in the first few chapters of Capital) which is the labor theory of value.

Namely, his starting point is that labor is identified with value. Wealth is created when raw materials and the means of production are combined with labor. In the capitalist theory of value in contrast, one's legal right (inherited or otherwise) is one of the things which is identified with value.

It's not a claim that this value is something metaphysical, just a political assertion that this is what we ought to think of as "value". It's all about what you want to consider as the primary "cost" in production.

This has been refined over the years. I'm not an expert so I may not be able to respond to any and all criticisms but I will try my best.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by noonespecial on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:43PM (#21468851)
A funny thing happened on the way to the worker's paradise. It turns out that technology allows for capital to be substituted directly for labor. Its starting to look like so much so that labor may become altogether unnecessary (and so without any value at all). That leaves us in a pretty tight spot under the current orthodoxy.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by clairity on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:23PM (#21469148)
in such cases, labor is being leveraged, not obviated. the labor shifts to those who build, monitor, and maintain the machines doing the work that used to be done directly by laborers. capital is the accumulation of the fruits of our (leveraged) labor. that we privilege capital is why we’re in a tight spot, rather than labor not being the basis of value.

the miracle is that we can build more while doing less, but nothing gets built if we do nothing at all (e.g., wealth concentration).

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jancsika on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:01AM (#21470821)
> It turns out that technology allows for capital to be substituted directly for labor.

And which Capitalist Paradise Cruise ship do you picture yourself manning for this critique? Elsevier?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by notJim on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:12PM (#21469464)
Who created the technology, though?

If people really think Marxism can be dismissed with a simplistic argument like this, I'd encourage them to actually read the first few chapters of Capital. Agree with his world view or not, Marx was not an idiot.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by WalterBright on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:23PM (#21470119)
> his starting point is that labor is identified with value

This is a large mistake. For example, spending an hour on an exercise bike is certainly a lot of labor input, but nothing of value, since nobody will pay you to cycle on an exercise bike.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tremon on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:20AM (#21472504)
You're making a large mistake too. For example, that nobody will pay you to cycle on an exercise bike does not mean your labor has no value -- after all, if you're in better health, you will be more productive in the hours you're not on that bike.

(to make my point more explicit: in Marx' definition of labor he implies labor of enterprise, not just spending calories. Just like your definition of value implies financial value, not just any positive outcome. I'm purposefully misrepresenting your definition of value just like you're purposefully misrepresenting Marx' definition of labor.)

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by WalterBright on Thursday November 07, 2019 @04:45PM (#21477639)
> Just like your definition of value implies financial value

When the discussion is about economics, that's what matters. There is no intrinsic value to labor.

> Marx' definition of labor he implies labor of enterprise

The economic value of labor has no necessary relationship at all to the effort or time supplied by the laborer. If Bob works inefficiently, his labor is worth less than Bill who works efficiently, even if they both work exactly the same length and effort.

[dead]
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by dang on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:30AM (#21480169)
Please don't use HN for ideological battle, regardless of which ideology you favor or disfavor.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tasubotadas on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:33AM (#21472006)
This will go in my "Hacker News Wisdom" folder for the future quoting :)
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by TomMckenny on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:26PM (#21468711)
There is no philosopher involved, in this case there is the wealth expended to produce an item. In your idealized example both parties are better off but the one that traded the item and took less effort to make it is comparatively better off. He will have advantages in future trades which will further increase. Not to mention a bigger voice in societal structure. (which is a tldr; of the article)

Anecdotally you met some college kids whom you perceived as not understanding economics. But the knowledge of increasing wealth inequality and the current deficiency of private investment is uncontroversial. Regardless of what the impression those kids gave, there number of techniques to address it and _increase_ GDP through the stimulus.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by roenxi on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:39PM (#21469251)
Increasing the GDP is really easy, the government can pass a law adding a zero to all measures of money (so $10 becomes $100). Reducing inequality is also easy, confiscate people's wealth.

The real problem is "people are not secure in their lifestyle" which is not addressed by the first solution and is probably exacerbated by the second. People getting antsy about inequality as a final problem instead of a symptom of another issue are not going to find their way to solutions that increase prosperity.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by mr_toad on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:58PM (#21470270)
> adding a zero to all measures of money

Do you really think that nobody has ever thought of measuring inflation adjusted GDP?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by roenxi on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:52AM (#21472113)
Add a 0 to all the financial numbers and introduce price controls. No inflation then. Problem solved. As solutions go this is just as stupid and yet this is also a strategy that still gets tried (!) from time to time.

The point I'm making is that the problem is living standards and prosperity. If we try to improve arbitrary single measures, like GDP or Gini, then the easy solution is pick something stupid that games the numbers then work it back towards the Overton window of ideas until it is mainstream enough that people don't understand why it is failing.

The metrics to focus on are real outcomes like living standards which are - and this is the central part of my point today - not negatively affected by someone else in the city being filthy rich.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by TomMckenny on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:03PM (#21469729)
How would printing money improve the GDP anymore than just lying about the figures? And since no one is suggesting that, I think it's kind of a straw-man.

But surely these can't seriously be the best rebuttals to the paper: that straw-man, anecdotal opinion about college campuses and physics professors and a statistics joke about, but certainly not refuting, the elephant curve. I really can't tell if these arguments are genuinely considered valid or is this just a semi-polite troll technique to shout down unpleasant information.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by roenxi on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:03PM (#21470025)
The GDP would be 10 times higher. It wouldn't be a lie. If the government wasn't completely blatant about it maybe store owners would only raise their prices by 9.95x and there might be a real GDP boost as well.

Is it stupid? Yes. Is it a straw man? Not so much compared to what is done in practice. When people seriously say that the policy is to "stimulate the economy" they mean incentivising people to consume rather than save. This has a positive effect on the economic figures but it is madness to believe it is setting up a better future; because setting up for a better future generally involves saving in the present.

> And since no one is suggesting that...

I haven't seen anyone propose a plan to tackle wealth inequality that doesn't involve confiscation and redistribution of some form or another. The argument is over whether that is appropriate or not.

As for GDP it is generally accepted that setting up a free market and leaving it alone maximises the GDP. There is lively debate about whether than is the best outcome. There is a serious argument that lower-than-maximum GDP with resource redistribution to the poor is better - which is what happens in practice.

> certainly not refuting, the elephant curve

There is nothing to refute. Inequality is not a problem - people can't even detect inequality! Nobody has a gut feel for it and the average level of mathematical intuition isn't high enough to understand the charts. Certainly people can't suffer because someone else has it really easy.

People suffer when their lifestyles deteriorate and we should be focused on preventing that. That is a completely different problem and one that actually deserves attention. The living standards of poor and middle class people is a real and ongoing issue that should be focused on. It does not matter if dealing with that makes the rich ricer. And in that context, the elephant curve can reasonably be interpreted as a massive success story that we can all be proud of as millions are lifted up to a better standard of living.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by TomMckenny on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:46PM (#21470471)
>The GDP would be 10 times higher. It wouldn't be a lie.

That would mean Venezuela, top in the world for printing money, has the highest GDP growth. Zimbawe and Argentina would be next.[1] In the event one might claim they are, here[2] is the actuall GDP growth rate by country.

>As for GDP it is generally accepted that setting up a free market and leaving it alone maximises the GDP.

The highest per-capita GDPs are in exactly those countries which monitor and adjust the market, for example the Scandaniavn countries. And in the US, the period 1945-1980 saw vastly more regulation and taxation than 1980-today yet vastly greater growth. So evidentilly, modest regulation and taxition and zealous anti-trust enforcemnt are actually good for an economy. Far from generally accepted, very few economist disregard all evidence and assert zero regulation means maximum growth.

> Inequality is not a problem - people can't even detect inequality!

The existence of inequality is not remotely controversial and is trivial to measure, for example with the GINI and even the absurdly blunt Elephant Curve. And indeed, vast swathes of the population very much feel the decline in their quality of life and say so loudly and are electing lunatic politicians as a consequence.

Actually, if you happen to have a reference, I'd be interested in where one hears that printing money increases the GDP, inequality is undetectable and ending anti-trust enforcement et al makes a market healthier.

>doesn't involve confiscation and redistribution of some form or another

One could call gasoline tax "confiscation" bridges toll "redistribution" and, on the other side, call rent "theft". Calling stimulus spending "confiscation" is as extreme as saying that wealth was "stolen from the proletariat in the first place". I humbly suggest it is not helpful. At any rate, as further proven by this paper, the solution to both QoL declines created by inequality as well as a stagant GDP is a wealth tax used to increase consumer spending power.

> the elephant curve can reasonably be interpreted as a massive success story that we can all be proud of as millions are lifted up to a better standard of living.

Then how is ridiculing its reality a refutation of this paper? And the rise of devolping countires is not in dispute. The problem at hand is the preciptous decline for those who lost out and who are still loosing. And who, as it turns out, are the middle and lowerclass members of the richest countries which also contain the people that benefited by far the most.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inflation...

[2]https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ny.gdp.mktp.kd.zg

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by roenxi on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:07AM (#21470848)
We seem to be in furious agreement on most points, but since you asked...

> I'd be interested in where one hears that printing money increases the GDP

That one is self evident. I'm talking about nominal GDP not real GDP.

> inequality is undetectable

Nobody in my building could order the people in my building by wealth or income. You can't order the commentators on this article by wealth or income. It is unlikely anyone you know could tell you how much wealthier the wealthiest person in your city is than they are. I'm much more clued in to the wealth & income statistics than most people, and I have no idea what the wealth gap is between me and the people in my social circle where the range is large.

The only way to detect wealth inequality is for someone to specifically go and survey it, using a somewhat artificial and abstract construct like GINI. Inequality doesn't have a measurable impact on anyone's daily life and cannot be detected without putting in a large and special effort. Compare that to crime, poverty or homelessness which are extremely easy to detect and potentially have a real everyday impact.

> and ending anti-trust enforcement et al makes a market healthier.

I'm pretty sure I didn't say that.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @03:01AM (#21471335)
Why do you assume that inequality somehow is responsible for a decline in quality of life?

The existence of the top 0.1% essentially has zero impact on grocery prices, healthcare, housing, etc.

> One could call gasoline tax "confiscation" bridges toll "redistribution" and, on the other side, call rent "theft".

Rent is voluntary, taxation is not. A bridge toll charges for use, so it’s actually fair. You don’t get charged $3000 to cross the Golden Gate Bridge because you do it in a Porsche.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ajross on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:25PM (#21469164)
That seems like a giant strawman to me. What "enlightened campus philosphers" (or "the wise", if those people are different) specifically are you arguing with? Does it include any actual academic economists? I mean, you're talking about stuff that sounds specific, but for the life of me I can't see exactly what opinions you're arguing against.

Inequality isn't magic. It goes up and down in response to both economic cycles and public policy. It's been set all all sorts of levels over history, and right now is at a post-industrial zenith and getting higher rapidly. And some of us think that's bad, for reasons of simple fairness.

And lots of actual academics agree with this, and have pretty solid numerate arguments that might convince you if you were willing to read them.