I don't agree with it. Poor people tend to be very risk-averse (they teach their kids to get "stable jobs" above everything else), and this puts them in a self-reciprocating loop of poverty. Many rich people who i know became so by repeatedly getting involved into "bold" things looked totally bullshit, and usually indeed was - apart from 1-2 in their lives that wasn't, and made them millions.
The mathematical models you find in the works of many highly regarded economists are even more simplistic, more vulnerable to criticism.
"When you have such hubris and make such simple mistakes..." that pronoun "you" should be the economists!
That's why econometrics is a thing, that's why most economists nowadays are taught statistics, computer programming, advanced maths, etc... It's why there's a different process used to describe why things happen in a paper vs. predicting real world numbers.
As a percentage, sure, but in real terms the poorer person doesn't have 'much' to lose (to be regained) over someone extremely rich risking the same percentage. The potential rewards are also likely to be immensely larger in percentage for the poor person too.
But this is also relative risk against wealth in context. Comparing poor against poor there will still be comparable poor people with completely different risk profiles (basic example is one with children vs one without).
The model I imagine must primarily establish reasonable/full context before determining any value factors.
This is questionable. The assumption that a poor person can more easily regain their stake is shaky---a poor person who loses their money may become homeless, which could in turn make it harder for them to be employed, or if they are a trades person maybe they lose their tools or can no longer afford to rent them. By contrast, a rich person has access to credit lines and investors in their social network. For the poor who aren't wiped out below a critical threshold, then, it may be true, but you're not taking into account the significant number who drop below that threshold and may never recover.
I would rephrase the original statement, "the poorer a person the larger percentage they are willing to risk" as "the poorer the person, the larger percentage they are forced to risk if they want to achieve comparable returns on a percentage basis."
I see it most often attributed to George Box, a statistician, but it's not completely clear he was the originator. In physics you have a luxury of verifying models at many empiric touchpoints via data collected in controlled or precisely measurable conditions. Comparatively in economics it's difficult to establish you have a useful model because the empiric data is difficult, and with unmeasurable aspects around human choices.
It is true that calories = calories-in - calories-out.
It cannot not be true.
It just isn't helpful.
tl;dr: The only time CI-CO is truly accurate is when CI=0.
For instance, in a study of obese women, a reduction of (4.3 +-(4.6) kcal/kg) was observed in a calorie restriction diet of 20kcal/kg
Similarly, in a different study, a 30% calorie intake reduction was linked to only about a 5% reduction in total energy expenditure.
CI-CO is not a perfect model, in that it doesn't perfectly estimate weight loss rates, but the general concept holds true.
I didn't mean to imply that it was 1:1, just that the model doesn't hold entirely.
> CI-CO is not a perfect model, in that it doesn't perfectly estimate weight loss rates, but the general concept holds true.
In general, I suppose, however most people aren't trying to lose weight but rather fat. Consuming sugar causes a spike in insulin, and insulin triggers the uptake of sugar in the blood by adipose tissue as fat, and actively prevents the release of fats stored therein. [1]
So in the most literal sense, CI-CO works, in that (net of the 16% reduction in TEE relative to your reduction in CI per your data) you're going to need to get the calories from somewhere. However, if you eat 30% less calories than your BMR entirely as sugar, you're much more likely to be burning alcohol, glycogen and protein than fat, certainly in the near term.
If you combine that with the "eat 6 meals per day" fad and you're in for a seriously tough time losing fat. On the other hand if you at 30% less calories than your BMR entirely as sugar in one sitting over 20 minutes and fasted the remaining 23h30 you may actually lose fat, since that'll give your body time with low insulin levels.
Let me re-state: CI-CO is a very inadequate model for losing fat.
[1] https://www.diabetes.co.uk/news/2018/jan/drop-in-both-insuli...
CI-CO is accurate if CI<CO. There is absolutely no way it cannot be. This doesn't depend on any kind of reasoning about biology or insulin or hormones at all. It's the law of conservation of energy.
That's the beauty of it. It always works. If CO<CI, you will lose weight. There has never been an exception to this in the history of life, and there never will be.
Even fasting, which you mentioned, only works as a means to an end. And that end is CI<CO. Research shows that the actual timing of fasts is irrelevant; the same calories eaten in 6 hours per day have the same effect if eaten over 16 hours of the day. But when people fast they tend to eat less overall; it's all that matters.
So many people try to follow your path, and figure out a way to manipulate complex metabolic systems they don't understand to try to wheedle the body into dropping pounds. It works only rarity, and 98% of people on this path are just deluding themselves to avoid facing the fact that they need to get CI down under CO. So they take refuge in complexity, endlessly finding ways to rationalize away the need to do the actual work.
How does calories in vs calories out work regarding the energy left in food that is not extracted (i.e. the caloric value of poop basically).
Is digestion / energy extraction pretty consistent throughout the population or do the specifics of people's digestive systems play a role in how many calories are actually available to the body?
Basically, would a constipated person's digestive tract pull more energy out of the food since it is in the intestines longer?
And even if the numbers were accurate, they're still rule-of-thumbish, because human metabolism doesn't simply ingest all energy available in a food. For instance you'd absorb roughly 40% more calories from peanut butter than from actual peanuts (of the same calorical value).
There are more reasons why counting calories isn't nearly as accurate a method as people tend to assume, but these two are really sufficient.
- GK Chesterton
I am no Einstein, to be sure, but I do particularly recognize the experience he had as a teen, learning the math and engineering of his father from his father. His father and uncle, it's worth noting, built electric power generators. Mentally building an effective model of fields was surely something Einstein had to learn early, and perhaps without the math first.
Note that he too did most of his work in isolation, and he too was extremely proud.
(1-3): I honestly forget which of these it was, but the key term I search for is "mind-breakingly"
https://www.deirdremccloskey.com/docs/paradigm.pdf
Utility function is logaritmic.
The need for money saturates slowly. Think about winning 1000 dollars (nice dinner pehaps), 10 000 (better car), 100 000 (larger appartment), .... , 10 000 000.
At some point it doesn't matter if its 200 000 000 or 300 000 000.
On the other hand a lotter ticket is 1$. What is the utility of 1$ - a can of coke pehaps. But the perspective of winning $1 000 000 - thats a nice idea to hold for a few days... So many people do despite the slim chances.
[] https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/23952/is-the-u...
[] https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2013/08/05/how-the-mar...
But your first link does cite evidence that _if_ utility is CRRA, we are not far from the case where utility is logarithmic
-------
I will add that I still am a physicist who likes to think about things like this. One addition I would make to the model is that the poorer a person is the larger a percentage they are willing to risk. It still doesn't get around the fact that this whole model is based around the fallacy of object value but I like playing with models.