News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:40PM (#21468823)
The Earth has finite resources: finite land, finite minerals, finite water, finite energy. When people accumulate vast amounts of wealth, they place a large portion of these finite resources under their own control.

If we allow people and families to accumulate wealth indefinitely, it’s not hard to imagine a future whereby a very small elite control a vast majority of the resources. In this future, people can still create wealth by mixing their labour with raw resources... as long as they can afford to pay the rent to the rentier class.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by BurningFrog on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:23PM (#21469531)
Economic growth is the art of producing more value using the same amount of finite resources.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:33PM (#21470166)
...by extracting more and more of those resources until they're gone.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by BurningFrog on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:41PM (#21470442)
A popular idea among misanthropes.

Here are some facts showing the opposite:

https://reason.com/2019/10/09/the-economy-keeps-growing-but-...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:00AM (#21470547)
We're "dematerializing" by externalizing our costs.

This topic has been litigated on HN before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21020682

Key quote: Finally, and speaking of stepping in to fill the void: ctrl-F - "China" - 1 match. The single mention is to refer to it as a developing country, not to acknowledge it as the present-day location of much of the USA's manufacturing.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by reilly3000 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:47PM (#21470231)
more like until they are no longer profitable to exploit, which of course is a function of global state. That is what underlies the fallacy of peak oil, which I was personally susceptible to. Resources don't vanish, they become incrementally more expensive to extract until the marginal benefit of doing so becomes negative.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by akiselev on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:09AM (#21470594)
In any reasonable discussion about economics, I would assume that "until they're gone" means "no longer profitable to exploit" as we're all aware that short of extinct species that are beyond our technological capability to recover, nothing is truly "gone" as long as there is someone capable of expending gargantuan amounts of money and tangible resources flying to another solar system (or galaxy or galactic supercluster) where those elements are still easily available. Really, then, it's a function of universal state.

Regardless, here on Earth, eventually we will either reach a point where growth in energy production is practically infinite or we will be faced with the rather herculean task of converting all of our waste back into usable material, ad inifintum, with less energy available than was put into the system to create that usable material to begin with. At that point entropy comes knocking on the door.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:24PM (#21470374)
Peak oil is not about cash profits, it's about EROEI [1]. At some point all of the oil still in the ground will become useless because it'll take more energy to extract than you get out of it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_returned_on_energy_inve...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:44AM (#21471260)
That stupidly assumes all energy sources are equal. Oil has an extremely high energy density that makes it useful for travel where battery isn’t even close (heavy industry, air travel, long distance trucking/travel).

There is an article on the front page about solar companies in Australia shutting down every other day because of negative energy prices. Burning 100MW for 10MW of oil makes perfect sense under these conditions.

Here’s a thought experiment for you: why do you think we have batteries given they take more energy to create than they will produce?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:07AM (#21472804)
Looks like you didn’t read the link. Quote:

When the EROEI of a source of energy is less than or equal to one, that energy source becomes a net "energy sink", and can no longer be used as a source of energy, but depending on the system might be useful for energy storage (for example a battery).

If oil is made to compete against batteries then it will lose. It may have higher energy density but it’s also non-rechargeable, requires a heavy and complicated and high maintenance (compared to a very simple electric motor) internal combustion engine, and produces large amounts of greenhouse gases.

About the only thing it would still be cost effective for with a negative EROEI is aviation fuel, but even that application is facing competition from batteries [1].

[1] https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/electric-aircraft/index.h...

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:39PM (#21479313)
Aviation fuel is facing absolutely no competition from batteries. Neither is gas for long-haul trucking, bunker fuel for container ships, etc, etc, etc.

EROEI will come and go with nary a shit given. The entire value prop of oil at this point already is it’s portability, density, and refuel time.

Electric cars are already cheaper per mile when it comes to fuel, yet tons of people don’t bother because of charging logistics.

Energy into extraction is just part of the cost like anything else. There is nothing magic or even meaningful about it. That whole theory is based on the stupid notion that energy is fungible.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by shanhaiguan on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:11PM (#21470323)
I was under the impression that this is exactly what peak oil is: the end of our current levels of oil production, not (necessarily) the disappearance of the oil itself.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pasquinelli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:26PM (#21469172)
That's a fair description of the past too.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:43PM (#21469284)
At no time in the past were we in danger of reaching the limits of our planetary resources. There was always somewhere else to go, some other resources untapped. In the future that will no longer be the case, unless we manage to settle among the stars.

Past performance does not guarantee future results. The story of our society was not written with a fairytale ending. Whether we succeed and create a better future for all or destroy ourselves or create a hellish dystopia, there are no guarantees.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by jlawson on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:10PM (#21469761)
Medieval and previous people were always at the limits of the resources they had the technology to access. The past was a Malthusian world. No economic growth and no population growth for thousands of years, in a world without birth control. The difference was paid by death. This is life when you're at ecological carrying capacity.

We managed to find new ways to tap resources better, more efficiently, deeper, and so on, so we revealed new carrying capacity which we haven't reached yet.

If we don't advance again the way we did before, a return the Malthusianism is possible. That should be your null hypothesis. However, spreading past Earth or transcending to entirely new ways of existing (e.g. computational life) are also possible. The future resists past-based analysis because the rules are always changing.

But there's no reason in principle that we can't tap extraplanetary resources, any more than a Roman-era tribe in Britain couldn't pump for oil in Texas. It just took a lot of steps to get there.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by chongli on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:53PM (#21469970)
However, spreading past Earth or transcending to entirely new ways of existing (e.g. computational life) are also possible

The leap to another planet is far, far greater than to a new continent. It is an open question whether or not we could achieve it at all before a crisis destroys our civilization to an extent we may never recover from. There can be no second fossil fuel revolution, that was a onetime event in Earth’s history.

But setting aside the challenge, with new possibilities come new opportunities for inequality. In the case of the former, it’s not difficult to imagine a wealthy person owning an entire planet. In the case of the latter, might I suggest the short story Incarnation Day [1] by Walter Jon Williams. In a world of finite resources and computational life, perhaps only the wealthy and privileged can afford to be incarnated.

[1] http://www.sfsfss.com/stories/incarnation-day.html

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:24AM (#21472920)
Space travel requires energy. On earth we obtain most of our energy from the sun. During interstellar travel there is no sun that we can depend on. Therefore space travel is impossible without creating our own sun with fusion power.