News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:16PM (#21468127)
> I waited for a point in their model where people actually produced wealth and consumed it, made something or ate it, in addition to redistributing it. Not part of the model.

That’s because the people making the models don’t create wealth and don’t really understand where it comes from.

It’s like the way you see Marxists saying “seize the means of production” but never “build the means of production”.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by WilliamEdward on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:05PM (#21469004)
Not so sure you understand what means of production are. You cannot build more means of production without having access to means of production in the first place, hence the 'seizing' part.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:45PM (#21469297)
But all humans of sufficient ability (except those with extreme mental handicap) have innate means of production. Even those who have lost use of their limbs have an innate means of production via their minds in the form of intellectual property. Honestly, even many with mental disability but physically capable are capable of producing value from relatively little.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by Klinky on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:57PM (#21469706)
Your bar is too low if you think that things are okay because "you can always become a starving artist".
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:02AM (#21480081)
No need to starve. Just make something people want. You can do ghostwriting or content writing with few materials. You can become a personal assistant if you can answer a phone. You can, with labor, and ready materials(garbage for example) make a lot of things people want
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:11PM (#21470057)
More like “you can get a job and use the money you earn to buy tools.”
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by Klinky on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:34AM (#21470718)
Unless the job you get doesn't provide enough money to buy these tools, or there is a general lack of labor opportunities. This is a reality for a large portion of the current population.

So it's not an innate ability to create value really that matters, it's the ability to navigate a system with many gatekeepers who have entrenched interests, and where not everyone is starting from the same spot, but we should pretend they are, and pretend that all wealth accumulated is justified. Let's not question the means to that wealth or its ramifications on society as a whole.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:47AM (#21470763)
No, you can always start from scratch and make your own tools, invent your own techniques and products, etc. What you're seeing is that it's much much easier to get things if you work as part of the economy than if you go it alone. This is because the economy is already bootstrapped, through the work of countless millions of people who came before you. Nothing's stopping you from doing it yourself except for the fact that you don't want to because it's much harder to make things yourself than to get a job and then buy things.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tathougies on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:03AM (#21480087)
There's tons of labor opportunities. Most people want someone else to find some for them rather than searching themselves. And then they want to complain about how they're being exploited.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by sdfin on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:55PM (#21469375)
How did the first means of production appear?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by hollerith on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:58PM (#21469392)
The first capitalists stole it from the poor people :)
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:27PM (#21469179)
Yet all of the modern means of production stemmed from no means of production... hmmm.

People create all of the time with extremely limited resources. Especially ones that haven’t been seized.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @08:01PM (#21469408)
How would you go about building your own means of production for creating modern computers?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:12PM (#21470067)
It took a large part of modern industry working cooperatively for decades to build the tooling to make ICs. If your commune wants to make a similar effort then there’s nothing stopping you. If you don’t then you’re not entitled to own a chip fab.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:21AM (#21470912)
Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab? Why is some rich daughter entitled to own a chip fab? Because she is in the current system, while anyone else would have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by taneq on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:04AM (#21471084)
Ok so they do that, they organise people and get everyone working together (which, while it’s not generally acknowledged in this kind of conversation, IS work and DOES count as creating value) and by the time they’re old, they own a chip fab. That’s ok, right? It’s fair? If they build it, or pay other people to build it in a fair trade of money for services, then they own it?

So if they own it, they can do what they like with it.

Including give it to their daughter.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:22AM (#21472223)
No. They can't give it to their daughter, because it's not their factory: it's in the ownership of everyone who participated, since we were assuming no capital to start with.

If you aren't born with capital, and don't win the lottery, you can't pay people to build something for you.

You can work very hard, together with other people, and build something as a community. This is difficult and almost never happens in practice, as it requires extreme dedication and some alternate revenue stream to be able to live until the thing being built is done and can be used to produce ongoing value.

But when this does happen, the end result is in the ownership of the community, it is not any one member's to give away or sell.

Alternatively, if you are born with wealth, you can dispense with all that effort, and simply invest several fractions of your wealth in things until you hit on one thing that you can collect rent from. Sure, you'll do some work, but the money accumulated by your ancestors, often built on slave labor, monopolies, theft and other nice things, will do most of the work for you.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:06PM (#21477835)
If by "organize people," you mean induce people to work for them then, no, that is not work. That is using the coercive nature of capitalism (work or starve/be homeless/die) against workers.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by kortilla on Thursday November 07, 2019 @02:54AM (#21471305)
> Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab?

Why is anyone entitled to own food? If someone invests their resources to have something built (or help make it themselves), why wouldn’t they be entitled to own it?

The rich daughter gets to own it because that’s what the owner wanted and the thing about owning something generally is deciding its fate.

If someone builds themselves a house out of wood they chop from trees they grew, do they get to keep it? What if they exchanged goods and services for the wood instead? What if they also exchanged goods and services to have someone else build it who needs the goods and services.

> have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.

So? That’s how many of the successful chip fabs existed.

What’s your proposed alternative when 10,000 people want chip fabs and there are only 200 for you to steal? The government seizing them certainly doesn’t make more and it completely discouraged anybody from wanting to invest their time/labor/money into building new ones.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:33AM (#21472266)
My proposal is that no one person is entitled to own vastly expensive items that required the work of countless people to create. Those items should generally be collectively owned by the people who designed and built them. The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them (which includes marketing and sales people and whatever else is needed), in some democratically chosen percentage.

I said nothing about the state in this. I am still talking exclusively about private property.

And as for food, I believe people are entitled to life, and by implication to anything required to sustain it, such as food, medication, water, air etc. The exact means for realizing this entitlement (free food? UBI? I don't know) are not clear, but the fact that you can starve to death in a country with enough food to feed the whole medieval world is a travesty.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:50AM (#21473116)
>The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them

Well, economic theory says that the profits should approach zero as more and more competitors join the market and the provided goods or services become commodities. This effectively is a redistribution mechanism. The reality is a bit uglier.

By the way, prevention of wealth accumulation doesn't require repossession of existing property. A simple redistribution policy could dictate that a single person is not allowed to inherit more than 50% of the wealth of their parents. This forces parents to have two children and split the wealth. After a few generations the children will have 25%, 12%, 6% of the original wealth and so on.

There are still ways to exploit this if the siblings are colluding but let's be serious. If your family is rich and owns 50 billion dollars. Would you prefer $25 billion or $0 billion for the sake of higher generational wealth?

My point is that you need to create policies that even rich people would agree with.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:01PM (#21477787)
Agreed, and I never mentioned repossession. I was taking about ideal notions of entitlement, not practical measures for realizing that entitlement.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:57PM (#21475497)
Not yours to “not allow”.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:08PM (#21477846)
Please provide your reasoning.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @06:28PM (#21478474)
Define “theft”.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by pmiller2 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:21PM (#21494438)
So, you have no reasoning?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:21PM (#21509516)
My reasoning will mean little to you if we do not agree on core terms.
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:54PM (#21475464)
As one who is not involved in creation or operation of “vastly expensive” items, you have no say in the matter. Those involved do have a say, that being accepting or rejecting contracted providence of goods or services, which may or may not involve co-ownership. Distribution of profits occurs by contracting. Democracy doesn’t apply because those not involved have no say.

You are entitled to life insofar as nobody may actively take it from you. There is plenty opportunity in this country to earn; $1 per meal is enough for healthy comfort (thanks to capitalism, food is plentiful, varietal, and cheap).

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:00PM (#21477771)
In an ideal world, they should have more of a say than 'take it or leave it'. And in fact, for most of human history, people who produced things did have more say than that.

I was also talking about democratic governance among the worker-owners: this is how cooperatives work in general. The strict top-to-bottom autocracy of regular corporations is not the only possible system of governance for a successful market actor.

As for food, it's not so much capitalism as enormous state subsidies that affect the price of food in America. And living on 2-3$ worth of food a day will not lead you to a long life. Also, how is someone refusing you the right to take food when you are starving not actively taking your life from you?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @09:04PM (#21479428)
It is an ideal world. People may negotiate for whatever they see fit. It takes two to come to an agreement. It only one agrees to terms offered, how is it fair to compel the other?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:20AM (#21480135)
A 'negotiated agreement' between a company or state and a person that would starve if they don't accept the agreement is nothing more than coercion with a nice layer of paint.

Remember that we actually depend on some people literally not having a chance to eat unless they agree to collect our garbage, clean our floors etc.

Do you think that a cleaning person in a contract with Google or with the city of LA had any kind of real negotiation power?

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:12AM (#21483568)
Minimum wage is ~$7.25/hr. All one need do is work 25 minutes mundane labor a day to afford 3 square meals per day (see Twitter's @ABuckAPlate). (Corollary: min wage law prohibits anyone earning anything if they can't produce at least $7.25 value per hour.)

Collecting garbage, cleaning floors, etc has value - that's why we pay people to do it. Is it really worth more than ~$7.25/hr? would you pay someone $20/hr to do it?

A thing is worth what another will give for it. People are willing to trade $7.25 for an hour of mundane labor.

And yes, there is real negotiation power. Businesses are having to pay more, or find alternatives, for services because not enough people are willing to do those jobs. That's negotiation, in context of large numbers of people being willing to do a job.

BTW: if you're working where Google is, or in LA or the like in general, you MUST provide above-min-wage value because the carrying capacity of those areas has been reached - there are people making >$37/hr wanting to live in the same place, and $MinWage/hr can't compete with $37/hr productivity. I threw my stuff in a truck and permanently moved 1000 miles on short notice - so can others who likewise seek economically viable conditions.

I've lived off the land. Most of humanity did. If you don't want to plant seeds and build cabins (always a viable option), get busy doing something others will pay enough for.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @05:42PM (#21487693)
> If you don't want to plant seeds and build cabins (always a viable option), get busy doing something others will pay enough for.

How will you buy the land to build your cabin and plant your seeds on? We live in a system where all of the land is already owned.

> All one need do is work 25 minutes mundane labor a day to afford 3 square meals per day

This is just so wrong... Again, you can't have a healthy diet with 3 dollars a day. You also can't keep a job if all you earn is food money - you also have to have a place to live and shower, you have to have clean, non-raggedy clothes, a car, gasoline, maintenance for the car and maybe washing machine, health insurance so your life doesn't crumble at the smallest sign of disease, and possibly others. These are all necessary in order to even have that job which you claim lets you eat for 25 minutes of work a day.

> Collecting garbage, cleaning floors, etc has value - that's why we pay people to do it. Is it really worth more than ~$7.25/hr? would you pay someone $20/hr to do it?

Your thinking about this the wrong way around. Nobody would be willing to collect garbage for 7.25 if they had some alternative. It is essentially a job of desperation. So, it is vital for us as a society that there are always enough people desperate enough that they are even willing to collect garbage to make some money.

And in a worker driven job market (by which I mean, a job market where employers compete for workers, instead of the current economy, where mostly workers compete to find employment), garbage collection would be a high-paying job, precisely because it is absolutely vital for any community, and no one really wants to do it.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:57PM (#21509829)
If you don't want a solution, then you will fail.

I frequently make healthy meals for $1/plate; don't tell me I can't when I do. Covering meals in 25 minutes or less means time earn for other needs. Give me specifics, and a willingness to make money work, and I'll give you good inexpensive solutions to all needs.

The notion of a "worker driven job market", where menial tasks make enormous salaries, or "there should be some alternative", is pure fantasy. Of course everyone has alternatives: anyone can pick a preferred job, find an open position for it, and apply. Supply-and-demand is an economic law: garbage collection is not a high-paying job, because there's always someone willing to do it for less. You think GC should be high-paying, but you're not willing to pay someone high to do it; concocting (and forcing on others) a society inclined as you indicate would quickly devolve back to what we have now, precisely because easy & widely-available jobs are not worth high pay.

Bottom line: it takes a certain amount of effort to live off the land (go watch Primitive Technology on YouTube); everything else is an alternative because we contract for better options, and wishing for better doesn't work.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:59PM (#21479406)
You would refuse a starving person your food? You have enough, why the compulsion to steal from others to “redistribute”?
Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:26AM (#21480158)
I didn't talk about redistribution. I'm describing how a system could work from the ground up with a market economy but without any capitalists. How to get there is another discussion that is far more thorny.

I wouldn't deny a starving person my food, though the reality is that I rarely come into contact with someone who is starving.

On the other hand, a lot of restaurants and super markets do regularly deny starving people food - they ask for money in place of common human decency.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by ctdonath on Friday November 08, 2019 @08:27AM (#21481949)
They give away lots of excess food. Every week I take bushels of gourmet bread to food charities. I go out of my way to do so, maybe you should to rather than agitating to compel strangers out of ignorance.

The well off do far more for the poor than you think - without gov't compulsion.

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by imtringued on Thursday November 07, 2019 @08:39AM (#21473039)
>Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab?

If I make a coffee why should I be entitled to drink it? Well it's obvious. I bought the ingredients, heated water, etc... I consumed my own resources to make the coffee. If I don't own the end result then by making coffee I am just harming myself.

>while anyone else would have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.

So would the rich daughter. A chip fab requires external funding. This means the rich daughter has to obtain credit from a bank. In an ideal world the bank is itself funded by the depositors which have agreed to let their bank lend the money out. (in reality the central bank offers low % credit to encourage this)

Re:Is Inequality Inevitable? by tsimionescu on Thursday November 07, 2019 @05:04PM (#21477814)
There are people rich enough in this world that they could probably buy a chip fab 'money down' from their own finances. If that is somehow exaggerated, there are certainly people rich enough that they could buy, say, a shoe factory, or a brewery. The point still stands.

Also, even if you involve a bank: the rich daughter can get credit to buy a factory, while the worker in the factory certainly could not.