Re:Is Inequality Inevitable?
by roenxi on Thursday November 07, 2019 @01:07AM
(#21470848)
We seem to be in furious agreement on most points, but since you asked...
> I'd be interested in where one hears that printing money increases the GDP
That one is self evident. I'm talking about nominal GDP not real GDP.
> inequality is undetectable
Nobody in my building could order the people in my building by wealth or income. You can't order the commentators on this article by wealth or income. It is unlikely anyone you know could tell you how much wealthier the wealthiest person in your city is than they are. I'm much more clued in to the wealth & income statistics than most people, and I have no idea what the wealth gap is between me and the people in my social circle where the range is large.
The only way to detect wealth inequality is for someone to specifically go and survey it, using a somewhat artificial and abstract construct like GINI. Inequality doesn't have a measurable impact on anyone's daily life and cannot be detected without putting in a large and special effort. Compare that to crime, poverty or homelessness which are extremely easy to detect and potentially have a real everyday impact.
> and ending anti-trust enforcement et al makes a market healthier.
> I'd be interested in where one hears that printing money increases the GDP
That one is self evident. I'm talking about nominal GDP not real GDP.
> inequality is undetectable
Nobody in my building could order the people in my building by wealth or income. You can't order the commentators on this article by wealth or income. It is unlikely anyone you know could tell you how much wealthier the wealthiest person in your city is than they are. I'm much more clued in to the wealth & income statistics than most people, and I have no idea what the wealth gap is between me and the people in my social circle where the range is large.
The only way to detect wealth inequality is for someone to specifically go and survey it, using a somewhat artificial and abstract construct like GINI. Inequality doesn't have a measurable impact on anyone's daily life and cannot be detected without putting in a large and special effort. Compare that to crime, poverty or homelessness which are extremely easy to detect and potentially have a real everyday impact.
> and ending anti-trust enforcement et al makes a market healthier.
I'm pretty sure I didn't say that.