duxut_staglatz
- employment where you trade liberty (i.e. subordination) against protection (can't be fired at will, minimum wage, guaranteed income set in the contract...) from a company
- being an independent worker where you keep your liberty and do not get protection
If there is a third category like what Uber is currently doing, you trade your liberty (subordination) against no protection. It is not a new category, it is lowering the protection of employment. Which may or may not be a good thing, that's not my point, but I fail to see where's the new category of work.
The driver does not quote anything, Uber does and both the driver and the customer accept or not.
They have a very limited way to choose the ride they take: they have to make the decision in a couple of seconds, they may not know the destination and they are punished for declining too many rides by Uber. Does not scream free choice of what ride to take.
It is possible to bypass Uber and exchange numbers, yes. But the Uber platform itself does not let you build your own clientele, such as letting you look for the clients you want or the other way around. The question is not whether drivers can build their clientele outside of Uber but inside of Uber.
They do indeed have flexible hours, something that is apparently - reading the comments of this thread - impossible as an employee in the US and thus a feature of being an independent worker, but in France you can be an employee and have flexible hours, so that does not make Uber drivers independent.
> On ne peut déroger, par des conventions particulières, aux lois qui intéressent l'ordre public et les bonnes moeurs.
> Le contrat ne peut déroger à l'ordre public ni par ses stipulations, ni par son but, que ce dernier ait été connu ou non par toutes les parties.
> Chacun est libre de contracter ou de ne pas contracter, de choisir son cocontractant et de déterminer le contenu et la forme du contrat dans les limites fixées par la loi.
The court merely implements "French labour laws", as it should.
> The fact that the driver is not obliged to connect to the platform and that this absence of connection, irrespective of its duration, does not expose the driver to any penalty, are not taken into consideration when characterising the relationship of subordination.
> The criteria for self-employment include the possibility of building up one's own clientele, the freedom to set one's own rates, and the freedom to set the terms and conditions for providing one's services.
- your employer will pay a large part of your public health contributions ; unless your gross wage is much lower as an employee than your income as an independent worker, this results in higher after-tax after-social-contributions income.
- you have access to a mutuelle, and the employer must pay at least 50% of its cost by law
In the end, the difference in health coverage between being an employee vs an independent worker is not life-or-death like in the US, but it's quite stark still.
[0] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutuelle_de_sant%C3%A9_en_Fran...
[1] Technically, the "social security", which include pensions, healthcare, work injuries, most family and child benefits, is not part of the government and has its own budget.
For reference, the average world GDP is about US$17,300.
At the OECD tax-to-GDP average rate, about $6000 would be spent through public institutions (i.e. taxes and public services). So that leaves about $11500 for both consumption and maintaining the capital stock.
The consumption of fixed capital is about 15% of GDP per year, so that leaves about $9775 a year, or $815 per month to consume stuff.
You are making a different point, which is that more stuff does not equal happiness, so we should not care about it.
Let's say I want to have both an all-terrain car for the weekend and my regular car on the weekdays. I now consume two new cars very ten years instead of one. The same number of car has been produced in those ten years (no growth). Where does my extra car come from?
>Light infantry is a designation applied to certain types of foot soldiers (infantry) throughout history, typically having lighter equipment or armament or a more mobile or fluid function than other types of infantry, such as heavy infantry or line infantry. Historically, light infantry often fought as scouts, raiders and skirmishers—soldiers who fight in a loose formation ahead of the main army to harass, delay, disrupt supply lines, and generally "soften up" an enemy before the main battle. After World War II, the term "light infantry" evolved, and now generally refers to rapid-deployment units (including commandos and airborne units) that specifically emphasize speed and mobility over armor and firepower. Some units or battalions that historically held a skirmishing role have kept their designation "light infantry" for the sake of tradition.
Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_infantry
- ethics. Example: is democracy good for economic growth? Of course one could randomly engineer coups in some countries but that's probably not appropriate.
- cost. Example: how much do people change their labor force participation when taxes change by 1%? where a RCT would be "let's give a _lot_ of money to people" and see what happens.
- situation where it is not appropriate. Example: why did Europe rise to prominence (aka the great divergence)? There is not much to randomize here.
Note that RCTs have shortcomings anyway (see for instance [0]).
In the end, this loopholes and others lead to a very complex tax (thus high administrative costs) as well as a much lower tax base.
But your first link does cite evidence that _if_ utility is CRRA, we are not far from the case where utility is logarithmic