News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bjz_ on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:42PM (#18595121)
Been really enjoying Firefox, especially after Quantum. More devs should support and use it, lest we be beholden to Chrome for the rest of time.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by fl0wenol on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:46AM (#18596660)
I donated to the Mozilla Foundation today when I heard about this trend coupled with the rumor of Edge's sunsetting.

Even if the money is simply spent on marketing, I think that could be a good thing.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by unixhero on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:53AM (#18597614)
Marketing should not be underestimated.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by mehrdadn on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:14AM (#18598342)
I actually tried switching. I found Firefox to be still slower than Chrome. At least on Google sites it may not be their fault but knowing where to put the blame doesn't help me on my end. Marketing doesn't seem like the likely fix.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sametmax on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:24AM (#18598755)
Are you on Mac? If yes, it's not a feeling, it's a real problem Mozilla is trying to address but have yet to crack. Firefox is an order of magnitude more performant on windows and linux.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by pluc on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:33AM (#18599674)
Hasn't Firefox been around for longer than Chrome...? It's a bit off-putting when they can't seem to solve popular platform issues.

I've been on Chrome for a long time, tried to switch to FF when Quantum came out and couldn't hear myself think over the sound of my laptop winding up.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sametmax on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:36AM (#18599701)
Yes it is. Given that their team is top notch and their intent has been great so far, I will go with "it's a freaking hard problem and google could afford spending millions of dollars to solve it" kind of explanation.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by reitanqild on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @04:08AM (#18606738)
Another reason could be that Google optimizes both sides of the Chrome/Google webapp interaction but doesn't care very much about optimizing for any other browser than Chrome.

Once you realize that not being evil isn't a priority at Google anymore this explanation actually makes some sense.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by fbender on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:42AM (#18599762)
I've never had any issues on my Mac. Then again, I'm using an MBA 2012 sans Retina. If you are using displays with "non-standard" resolution (including Retina), even external ones, then you can refer to my other post[1] for background.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18599707

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by mehrdadn on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:33AM (#18598812)
Nope, Windows. Google.com itself spends at least 1 second switching its logo placeholder to its image on Firefox. See here for more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18055952
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by willtim on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:21PM (#18604412)
Google Chrome is probably talking HTTP3 to its own sites, so not sure that's a fair test.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by mehrdadn on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:25PM (#18604439)
This isn't because of that. Although even if it was, my entire point was that at the end of the day if Firefox is slower, even if it's Google playing dirty, that's going to make users like me not want to use it over Chrome.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bad_user on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:13AM (#18599531)
For personal email I'm on FastMail, but my work email is still Gmail (not my choice). I found Gmail to behave like shit in Firefox.

Then I tried it in Chrome and found that Gmail behaves like shit in Chrome too.

The solution however was to drop Gmail's web interface. Switched to a desktop client. If you're on MacOS I think MailMate is the best.

Couldn't be happier. And this advice is independent of your browser choice.

PS: the fact that Google's online properties are optimized for Chrome should make you realize that Chrome is the new IExplorer and it's our fault for allowing it to happen ;-)

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Klonoar on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:18PM (#18595433)
I'd support it if it felt like a first-class citizen on macOS. It's ironic that everyone decries Electron for not being native, then says you should use Firefox when it violates so much about the platform that it's not even funny.

A bug about overflow scrolling (the default bouncing when you scroll over in macOS) has been open for years. It doesn't fit in.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vvillena on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:09AM (#18598046)
Does Apple provide a correct specification for implementing overflow scrolling on custom window controls? Or is a default behavior that only Apple-blessed graphic components have? Failing to follow the Apple guidelines would be bad for Firefox. If the issue is not having a spec, we'd be talking about Apple actively sabotaging apps like Firefox.

I'm a Firefox user on macOS and I don't remember issues with scrolling. I don't use a trackpad, maybe that's the issue?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by kiwijamo on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:50AM (#18597239)
My main machines (both personal and work) runs macOS and I find Firefox to fit in fine. Certaintly does what I expect 99.9% of the time. Scrolling for instance seems to work as expected (and on par with Safari which I occassionally use). Can you share more examples?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by masklinn on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:29AM (#18597824)
> Can you share more examples?

Keychain does not work, FF57 killed KSE.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by arendtio on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:17AM (#18598083)
Sadly, that problem is not specific to MacOS :-/

On Linux with KDE that web-extension change killed the kwallet integration too. But you are right when you are saying that it degrades the user experience of MacOS users :-(

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by rangibaby on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:48PM (#18595648)
There used to be a proper Mac fork of FF (Camino), maybe it’s time to revive that
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Klonoar on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:26PM (#18595893)
Camino was fantastic, used it back in the day. :)

I'm not sure what Mozilla's deal is these days, to be honest, but Firefox really just doesn't feel like it fits in on Mac. It's frustrating, because I want to support it... but I just end up back in Safari because it feels far more smooth and integrated.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by giancarlostoro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:26AM (#18596557)
I got into using macOS later on but after 10 years of Firefox I had no issue with it on the Mac. I guess I possibly did not even notice the bugs mentioned. Ironically I couldnt use Chrome after beta cause I was too used to how Firefox works.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by qmarchi on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:38AM (#18596905)
I was originally using chrome for pretty much everything, but I started getting annoyed with the performance hiccups and I wasn't switching over to Safari because of the failure of the extension ecosystem ($99 to publish an extension?). Firefox being the best choice out there has been positive to the point where I don't have Chrome installed on anything other than my phone.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by baldfat on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:14AM (#18599108)
I really would like to say that I find it ridiculous that mac users consistently bash Firefox due to feeling it doesn't belong while they use Google Chrome.

How is Google Chrome more AppleOS then Firefox? Granted I can't stand AppleOS and find the UI to be totally frustrating still in 2018 and how old it feels. How is Firefox any different then Google Chrome?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by classichasclass on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:42AM (#18600382)
The reason was Mozilla killed embedding. Making everything an XULRunner app was supposed to be the future solution, but precluded native apps like Camino and K-Meleon from doing their thing, and while Mozilla had "reasons" I thought and continue to think it was incredibly shortsighted. Look at all the Chromium and WebKit shells. You just can't do that with Gecko on desktop (this may be changing on Android, though).
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by isostatic on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:25AM (#18598114)
It's odd that firefox doesn't use the osx certificate store
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by alex_duf on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:10AM (#18598318)
It's a matter of opinion at this stage. I trust Mozilla more than say... Lenovo or Dell that both shipped rogue certificates
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vetinari on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:31AM (#18598145)
Firefox doesn't use certificate store on any OS. Only the ESR for Windows has an option, off by default, for respecting the cert store.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sametmax on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:26AM (#18598772)
It's sad, but necessary. The OS certificate stores have been a circus for so long now that nowbody take it seriously anymore.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lightwords on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:56AM (#18598953)
Pinch to zoom is also non-existent so Firefox becomes useless for a many adults/elderly with poor eye-sight or even just many other users who like to browse and zoom on text/pictures etc. It's so frustrating that this feature is not available in Firefox when you are promoting it. The absence of this feature in my small survey is the main reason people quit using Firefox.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Vindicis on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:32AM (#18599234)
I'm honestly a bit confused. This is the second comment I've seen regarding the lack of this feature. It's not one I ever use purposefully, so maybe I just don't understand what's missing. But, with Firefox on my Samsung Galaxy, I can zoom in and out of text and photos by pinching, with no issues at all. Was it a long time ago when you last tried it perhaps?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lightwords on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:57AM (#18599419)
Latest version on MacOS It's one of the primary gestures of MacOS, and is in heavy use with casual users. It's f.x the primary method of reading material on websites that my parents use.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Klonoar on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:39AM (#18599733)
(The trackpad gesture, is what you're getting at)
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by NoGravitas on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:53AM (#18599388)
I think they mean desktop Firefox on a touchscreen laptop, rather than mobile Firefox. Personally, I can't imagine trying to pinch-zoom on a desktop, but maybe I'm just old.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ghostly_s on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:13PM (#18602023)
They're talking about a gesture that's specific to the Macbook trackpad; namely, the implementation you see in Safari, which is not the typical browser 'zoom' function that increases the size of elements and reflows the page, but rather zooms in to show you a subset of the DOM canvas as rendered, like mobile browsers do. It is definitely a handy feature but to characterize it as a missing 'standard' functionality I don't think is fair. No desktop browser had this functionality until Safari ported it over from the mobile version a few releases back as I recall, though Chrome has since copied it.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ShinTakuya on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:53PM (#18603911)
On Microsoft Surface in tablet mode I often want to pinch zoom. It works but it's limited to the discrete zoom levels that you see with Ctrl+ and Ctrl- so you don't get the smooth zoom you get on Chrome. I still prefer FF for a variety of other reasons so to me it's just a nitpick.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by dak1 on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:58PM (#18595258)
I would love to use Firefox more for dev, but until it has a first class way to disable CORS, I can't. "CORS Everywhere" is not sufficient (it alters responses, but does not actually disable CORS, which doesn't cover all needs).

Chrome I can at least disable CORS via the command line, and Safari does it best by putting it in a Developer menu that I can easily toggle.

Firefox's dev tools also seem to still be behind — I haven't seen a good way to inspect WebSocket frames, for instance.

I would really prefer to use Firefox due to Mozzila's stances on privacy, especially in contrast to Google; however, I have to use the tool that lets me actually get work done.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sombremesa on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:14PM (#18595397)
I love using Firefox as my daily driver, and I can always pop open chrome if I really have to. What kind of life do you lead where your browser needs to have CORS constantly disabled?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:36PM (#18595567)
This can be helpful in development scenarios. I’m supporting a team that uses localstack to support local development against some AWS services. Unfortunately, the CORS settings for localstack break the development environment. With Chrome allowing them to disable from the command-line, I can provide a shortcut to launch with degraded security, no plugins, no user settings, etc. My only wish is that Chrome would make it more obvious that it’s running with these protections disabled.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vorticalbox on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:27AM (#18597109)
You should be setting your server to set cors to allow all not disabling it in your browser.

This is what we do while running docker for local development with node.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by oelmekki on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:10AM (#18597350)
At the very least, CORS should be disabled for localhost. I build interfaces using create-react-app, which launches a dev server on localhost:3000 (useful for things like live reload), making requests on a go api on localhost:5000. On production, both are on :80 and the backend serves frontend production files. This is annoying to alter the application code just to handle dev environment (although, this already happen in many other places, so it's not critical).
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by giancarlostoro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:22AM (#18596536)
Not sure if it might have this but have you tried using Firefox Developer Edition? I would suggest if disabling CORS is missing to request it for Firefox Developer Edition. Its Firefox bleeding edge with some developer focused plugins out of the box.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by kevin_thibedeau on Monday December 03, 2018 @11:38PM (#18596325)
Why not just configure your server or a proxy to add the necessary headers that unlock CORS restrictions.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:19AM (#18606513)
The web server is configuring CORS policy properly, but the browser is making client-side calls to localstack. As far as I can tell, localstack has hardcoded a CORS policy that is a mismatch for the requests being sent.

The cleanest solution is to extend the dev pipeline with a proxy for localstack. It won't take me long to knock that out, but it's not something I can prioritize at the moment.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by oelmekki on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:25AM (#18597454)
Because having code that behaves differently on development and production is never a solution, it's a workaround. Having bugs that can't be reproduced locally is the worst thing that can happen to a developer. So yeah, you can _just_ put environment settings if you have no other possible way, but you should really avoid it if there is any other one (like using chrome with CORS disabled, here).
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by minitech on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:06AM (#18598293)
Disabling CORS in your browser is not representative of production. Serving CORS headers is.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:32AM (#18606572)
Mentioned this in another response. In this case, that requires the addition of another component. The app itself is serving a valid CORS policy. The stub we're using to support S3 development offline (LocalStack) ignores the configuration it's passed.

I agree with you that fixing the headers (via a proxy in this case) is the right solution. I'm just not able to prioritize right now.

Beyond that, there are always going to be occasions where developers, security analysts, and testers need to bypass default security enforcement. I'd like to see every browser provide a way to make these adjustments for a one-off session (e.g., via a command-line switch). It's an efficient solution that I can offer when I come across a nasty hack living permanently in a developer's web configuration.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by majewsky on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:20AM (#18598722)
By that same argument, using Chrome with CORS disabled is just as bad, if not worse. If you only test in Chrome with CORS disabled, how do you know that CORS works at all?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by reaperducer on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:24AM (#18596546)
Because in real companies the IT department needs a real good reason, or a large number of devs that need it, to reconfigure a server that way.

If you're not a lone wolf, or working in the SV bubble, the IT and security departments are going to tell you to go pound sand.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by AzMoo_ on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:44AM (#18596655)
Not really. In lots of relatively large companies there is a good relationship between infrastructure, development and security teams and they will work to find a solution that works for everybody.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vorticalbox on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:09AM (#18597343)
This is how it works at my work.

CORS is allowed while running locally and then set while running in development and finally production.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sametmax on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:34AM (#18598820)
It's 2 lines of code with most modern web frameworks with junior level knowledge required. Actually, any people with decent dev skills (any people that receives money for code should...) add a conf switch for that since the begining of the project.

I don't buy your comment at all.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by chipperyman573 on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:05PM (#18595742)
>My only wish is that Chrome would make it more obvious that it’s running with these protections disabled.

I know this is beginning to become off-topic, but why? Presumably, if you're using a flag that has to be run from the command-line, you're either doing it on purpose or using hardware you don't own (and a keylogger is a much greater risk than anything else at that point)

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Stratoscope on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:14PM (#18595807)
I can't speak for OP, but for me the problem is that I likely already have normal Chrome windows open when I start a "special" Chrome instance with a private profile and other settings. So now when I see a Chrome window I would like to be sure whether it's my normal user profile or the special profile.

In practice, it's not a problem for me, because the presence or absence of my usual row of extension icons and profile photo is enough of a clue.

But I could see where someone who doesn't normally sign into Chrome, or who doesn't have very many extensions in their normal Chrome profile, could have trouble distinguishing it from their a profile. The windows will tend to look pretty similar.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:49AM (#18606643)
Exactly. If I need to run a browser in a special configuration, I want to take every precaution to avoid using it for anything but the intended purpose. Since I disable my profile and extensions, I get similar cues.

The problem I see is that not everyone takes the same precautions. And plenty of developers accumulate these sort of tweaks and hacks in their daily driver without realizing or remembering that they've crippled their own security posture.

From a UX perspective, my preference is to make it clear when normal security mechanisms are disabled.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by rendaw on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:41AM (#18597557)
I set up a separate profile for debugging stuff - you may want to do this anyway since you'll be free to install development extensions willy nilly.

Then you can change the theme for that profile which makes it obvious which instance you're using.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:51AM (#18606652)
I do the same for myself, including an obnoxious theme. Not all developers are this cautious.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by coffeeaddicted on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:19AM (#18598374)
Chromium pops up some yellow bar with a warning when you use those flags. Isn't Chrome doing the same?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:49AM (#18606647)
There's a temporary warning.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sk5t on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:55PM (#18595679)
Most folks set up a little proxy--or configure CORS if the other end of the pipe is owned or cooperative--rather than throw out the baby with the bathwater due to inability to disable an important security measure.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by joking on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:35AM (#18597524)
angular dev environment already comes with that proxy incorporated.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by paraditedc on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:17PM (#18595417)
Curious what use cases you have for disabling CORS?

Is it for 3rd party domains and APIs or response that you control? Either way, controlling it in browser doesn't sound like the right way.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by reitzensteinm on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:33PM (#18595551)
For testing a client side app in development locally against a remote API, disabling cors is really handy.

I have localhost.com in my hosts file and a local web server to run around it, but it's still really frustrating not being able to turn it off entirely.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by paraditedc on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:20PM (#18595862)
Obviously I don't have context on your work, but in general, do you have control over remote API?

If yes, you can setup different environments (dev, staging, production) and set CORS accordingly for each of them.

If no, how is it working in production?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by reitzensteinm on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:59PM (#18596094)
I develop browser based video games that talk to a central API that I control.

I mostly have the setup you describe, and most development happens against a CORS-free staging server. But it's often necessary to build a local prod version that is identical to the live version for debugging or analysis, that plays against real players and reads/writes to the same data store.

It's an edge case, and in the past when I've done web development simply turning off CORS on staging has trivially solved any issues. But it does feel a bit like the developers of the browsers have chosen not to include the feature in a "we're smarter than you, trust us, you don't want this" kind of way. For the most part, they're probably right.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by paraditedc on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:21AM (#18596531)
I see.

Just a wild idea that I haven't tried yet:

Would it work if you configure your etc/hosts to point production domain to localhost and open the production domain in the browser?

I'm gonna try this when I get free time.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:31PM (#18595528)
This is one of my gotchas (and I prefer to do so from the commandline). I also need a good extension manager and a session/tab manager. The extension manager makes it easy to disable extensions that are only used occasionally. The session manage makes it easier for me to keep tab count down.

I have found a few session manager options on Firefox but most suffer from permission bloat and poor UI.

Last I checked, there was nothing to make it easier to manage add-ons.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by eikenberry on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:33PM (#18595936)
I just switched to FF and had a similar requirement. I found "Session Sync" to be a good replacement for what I used in chrome (FreshStart).
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cjcampbell on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:52AM (#18606656)
Thanks. I haven't checked in a few months, so I'll give it a look.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by xg15 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:30AM (#18596868)
Out of couriosity, wouldn't it be an option to implement CORS? From my understanding, it's just a few static headers.

Agreed with the missing WebSocket inspection.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by eksemplar on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:20AM (#18596830)
I use Firefox for development, but I use safari (privately) and edge (professionally) for browsing, and see no real advantages to using either Firefox or Chrome for that.

I think modern Firefox is a much better browser than Chrome though, but Mozilla certainly lost the PR war and to no fault but their own, because Firefox sure sucked for a long while.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by feanaro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:37AM (#18597168)
> I think modern Firefox is a much better browser than Chrome though, but Mozilla certainly lost the PR war and to no fault but their own, because Firefox sure sucked for a long while.

This gets said often, but I've been using Firefox continually since 2003 and I've never noticed it sucking.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cm2187 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:43AM (#18597563)
I switched from Chrome to Firefox after the google login controversy, and have been happy with the transition too.

The only only thing that really annoys me is that when you snap a tab out of a window into a new window, the gesture is similar with snapping a tab into the favorite bar, and I end up with lots of "New Tab" or other unwanted favorites.

Also a small personal annoyance. I got into the habit of always launching the browser by clicking the shift key on the windows task bar icon, so that I always get a new window, irrespective of whether some session is already running or not. But in firefox, when no session is running, launching with the shift key pressed results in the "safe mode" prompt. I wish there was a way to disable that.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by randkyp on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:59AM (#18597659)
You can middle-click on the taskbar icon to do that -- and it works for other apps, too.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by totfz on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:22AM (#18597799)
If you haven't used Chrome, no wonder you haven't noticed Firefox sucking. But a side-to-side speed and responsiveness comparison of Chrome and Firefox is unfair even today.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by downer56 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:59AM (#18597989)
I have used Chrome and Firefox side-by-side, consistently since Chrome's original release. I have used Netscape and Internet Explorer since before both existed. I have performance gaming rigs of all generations, and I develop software. I have multiple generations of Apple machines as well. I run Windows and Linux.

Firefox doesn't suck, and matches Chrome. But there's no accounting for user behavior. I have seen user behavior that is mind-blowingly stupid, and subcultures of user activity and tendencies trace well with product loyalty trends.

Some user subcultures are retardedly dependent on browser extensions, never clear their cache, retain cookies for the lifetime of their laptop battery, and seemingly need hundreds of tabs open. And none of this shit makes sense to me.

These are likely the same people who carry around phones on the brink of overheating while locked, and in their pocket, because they have to have a thousand apps installed, in order to feel like they're getting the $1,000 phone they paid for, I guess. Their emails are constantly peppered with "sent from [app|device|service]" signatures, and they claim microphone permissions are why ads target them.

Honestly, if you've been blaming the browser, it's more likely that you're the one being your own worst enemy.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ksec on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:41AM (#18599301)
All the users I forced to use Firefox, decided that Chrome was faster, and they were more than 100s of them.

( And as a user I knew that too. I just wanted to support Firefox. )

So saying Firefox Doesn't suck may be partially right. As we will have to define "suck" first. But saying it is as fast as Chrome during Firefox 4 and early Chrome era is just the same as saying earth is flat.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by HappyFapMachine on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:05AM (#18598292)
So...what are you trying to say here? That if you don't feel comfortable with a browser, you are the issue? That if you have different use-cases and behavior, you are the issue? Each browser has different look and feel and is unique in its own way, even if some differences are tiny.

And, yeah, if Mozzila likes dropping numbers, nothing has to change.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by wj on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:15AM (#18598691)
Chrome handles PDF and printing (with the preview) better than Firefox in my opinion. I probably like Chrome a bit more for dev work as well but as a user they're pretty similar with the exception of the PDFs that I mentioned.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by PuffinBlue on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:36AM (#18598833)
"Chrome handles..." can be said for a lot of things really.

Just this last month I've had Firefox crash tabs daily that Chrome handled perfectly fine, I've seen it crash the entire browser when Chrome did just fine. Underlying both those issues was a janky Windows install that was partially broken. But still, Chrome carried on like a trooper.

I've even just switched back to Linux and immediately saw Firefox stumble over scrolling frame rates. That was caused by using an Nvidia graphics card and the proprietary drivers on Kubuntu which was a bit janky again to say the least. But Chrome carried on through again with no problem.

Just today I've switch to an AMD graphics card and the opensource drivers on Fedora and only now is Firefox seemingly playing nice.

It's a great browser (though Dev Tools don't seem as good to me) and I love the containers but it does seem it needs a bit more of a particular environment to operate just right whereas Chrome 'just works' more of the time. That is possibly why lots of people say 'fine for me' (it is for me now, yey!) but others say "it's broken" or 'slow' or whatever.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vvillena on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:18AM (#18598086)
When I notice a difference in responsiveness between Chrome and Firefox, it's usually due to the webpage being Chrome-optimized. I don't know why: maybe it was developed and tested under Chrome, maybe it uses features that work better on Chrome because they were developed and pushed by Google, or maybe the differences between the rendering engines favor Chrome.

Google's own websites are some of the major culprits. The funny thing is that similar webs don't have this issue, and I don't notice any slowdowns that push me to do side-by-side tests.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by woolvalley on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:33AM (#18598151)
I've noticed worse performance of firefox on macos compared to windows, to the point where firefox is unusable on many websites on a 2 core macbook pro. Even fucking facebook is slow on firefox, even with recent improvements.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by feanaro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:21AM (#18598388)
Then this is likely an edge case/bug you are encountering because it is definitely not something I experienced.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bayindirh on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:16AM (#18598353)
I use Firefox daily, alongside Chrome for a very long time. Firefox manages system resources much better, works way more stable, and behaves the way I want, without any exceptions.

Chrome feels like an untamed animal which does stuff without telling you, and I don't like it.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by gronne on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:34AM (#18597859)
I use both and could never feel the speed difference. On the contrary the lack of control over browser behavior in chrome is a constant annoyance.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ionised on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:48AM (#18598206)
I mean, I use both daily and this just isn't true.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by feanaro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:18AM (#18598369)
It's not that I haven't used Chrome from time to time. I just meant that I use Firefox as my primary browser.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by criddell on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:34AM (#18600287)
Neither browser sucks. They are both quite good.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Silhouette on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:36AM (#18597868)
This gets said often, but I've been using Firefox continually since 2003 and I've never noticed it sucking.

To this day, my browsing experience is still worse with Firefox than it was before 57, because so many useful little add-ons have never been replaced or have been replaced only with inferior versions. In some of those cases, that useful functionality can't be provided in the new environment, because the APIs to support it aren't there. I was unpleasantly reminded of this just a few days ago, when the same problem infected the latest Thunderbird update.

More seriously, I am running into increasing numbers of sites that simply don't work properly with Firefox. Sometimes this is because of the privacy/blocker extensions I use, but often the problem persists even if I disable those. Whether it's due to bad web developers doing Chrome-only things or bugs in recent versions of Firefox, the unfortunate result is still the same from the user's point of view.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by feanaro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:26AM (#18598423)
This I can relate with, but I would like to note that Firefox seems to be continually expanding its APIs and regaining functionality that was lost. In particular, [Tridactyl](https://github.com/tridactyl/tridactyl) (which tries to reimplement Pentadactyl, a kitchen-sink extension API consumer) works rather well. There are still some pain points, like the keyboard shortcut API which still hasn't been merged, but I am hopeful they eventually will be.

I too experience privacy extensions breaking websites frequently, since I'm a heavy user of those, but so far I have never encountered a case of a website that was truly broken under Firefox. It was always one of my settings and worked under a clean profile.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cf498 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:10AM (#18598659)
They rushed it and I find it hard to not see it as a giant "screw you".

They didnt release the specifications early enough for people to rewrite their addons and at the end of ESR52 there where still multiple bugs open which prevented people from porting their addons. We didnt even get a normal 1 year ESR support frame for gods sake. All that ignoring the fact that there was no warning for the end users that all their security addons were disabled after the automatic update.

I am still furious about the absolute arrogance and carelessness Mozilla showed here.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by feanaro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:13AM (#18600066)
I was very pissed at them for exactly this reason and I still am to some degree. I would love to find an acceptable alternative that goes back to the roots, so to speak. For instance, I've been looking at qutebrowser, but it's still too limited (and might remain so for some time).

But Chrome as an alternative? That's not even on the table. Firefox is definitely the lesser of two evils.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Karunamon on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:44AM (#18598876)
This. Ever since the plugin fiasco, it’s really hard for me to see Firefox as anything other than a worse Chrome. Extensibility was Firefox’s main selling point; and they pissed that away.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by SilasX on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:58AM (#18601197)
I'm just amazed that you can't even manually remap keyboard commands. Seriously Mozilla? $500 million/year in funding and you can't support that customization?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by cf498 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:44PM (#18603423)
An even better example is "Other Bookmarks". https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/default-bookm...

They simply changed the default bookmark location with no option to change it back.

I need an addon to change the default bookmark location to keep my earlier filing approach.

I mean really?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by SilasX on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:44AM (#18600386)
Thanks for the heads-up! I locally maintained Pentadactyl for my own browser until Mozilla banned unsigned addons (which ticked me off enough to write a Hiter parody[1]). That extension was also what got me into vim.

I'm still upset that they broke custom keyboard shortcuts for ... two years now? All the replacements will only remap keys after a tab's JS has loaded. I used to be able to just zoom through the tabs with shift-j and shift-k, but now it will randomly stop on pages that need to reload, which breaks the whole experience.

I've had Super NES games that offered key customizations, and had much less memory and money to work with. That's really disappointing.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=taGARf8K5J8

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Bartweiss on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:16AM (#18600730)
For several years, Firefox was punishingly slow and had awful tab control compared to Chrome. It may not have 'sucked', in the sense that I still vastly preferred it to IE or even Safari, but switching was an immediate and dramatic improvement.

There have been major speedups since, and container tabs help fix the other issue. At this point, I still find Firefox worse than Chrome in a large number of ways, but they're small and often preference-based - but lots of people seem to agree that were a lot of users lost (or not gained) during a stretch where Firefox was pretty much objectively behind.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:11AM (#18597361)
I use FF too, and I notice it sucking periodically, often after a big update - as things will - there have been periods of a month maybe two times in the last 10 years where I had to switch to another browser because it sucked too bad.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by baldfat on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:18AM (#18599144)
Sadly this is my story also. I use Vivaldi as my main browser now, which is Chromium based. Firefox does work awesome and is normally what I program my scripts through headlessly but in personal use FF just gets bad periodically.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by mda on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:07AM (#18598037)
I used Chrome since its early alpha versions on Linux, and I have to disagree. Even in its first days Chrome was a far superior browser speed, responsiveness and security wise. Firefo caught on some of these nowadays, but not nearly e ough for me to switch back.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by xte on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:35AM (#18598468)
The same for me until few time ago when Chrome weight and features start to be more nice for Alphabet then me.

I ditch all Alphabet services, I do not like to waste my system and network resources for it's sake.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by watt on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:01AM (#18597296)
When you log out, Firefox will block it and warn you that you are about to close number of tabs. When you select "OK", your tabs are gone.

But Chrome will quietly exit, and when you start it next time, will offer to restore the tabs that were open last time. Chrome approach wins, hands down.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sveme on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:05AM (#18597320)
That's a setting in both browsers. Default is "Start with Startpage or empty page" in both browsers as well. You can always select "Restore last session" in both browsers.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by veidr on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:09AM (#18597724)
Defaults really matter. Probably 1% of users would ever think to look for a way to change that behavior.

I think Firefox for a long time tried to optimize for those users who do want to tweak their software, and doing that can even be a way to make superior software (instead of aiming for the lowest common denominator), but it is certainly not the right approach to maximizing _web browser market share._

I didn't use Firefox for many years (because I thought it sucked; slow, bad defaults, always apologizing in this anoying way for having crashed the last time I used it) but I now use it every day again (though not as my default browser; I tend to keep all the major ones open) and I'm glad to see Mozilla recently seems to have changed their priorities and focused on usability and performance. I hope it's not too late.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sveme on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:28AM (#18598133)
When I last installed Chrome in a fresh installation of Windows (so no saved settings from previous installations), it defaulted to an empty startpage. Might just have been me, mind.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by watt on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:15AM (#18597390)
The problem is that if Firefox is getting this default wrong, what else are they getting wrong? And it should realize user state is sacred, I would even expect if I quit browser with something written in the address bar (or search bar, etc), when it starts up again, it should be able to preserve this half-entered user input!
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by askmike on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:27AM (#18597473)
I'm very happy that when I close my browser it kills all my tabs. If I really want something back I just view it from the history.

> I would even expect if I quit browser with something written in the address bar (or search bar, etc), when it starts up again, it should be able to preserve this half-entered user input!

I'm pretty sure no one expects nor wants this. You're definitely in a minority here. The problem you describe isn't very technical, it's simply that you want something else than most people else and you don't want to take the time to configure your browser to how you want it to behave.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vvillena on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:26AM (#18598119)
Lots of people actually expect that. It's how phone apps work. There's no concept of "closing an app" in the iOS and Android guidelines. You just get the app out of the way.

I think the lack of improvements in desktop UX in the last 10 years is making every desktop OS to slowly adopt mobile UX conventions. Some of those new conventions are a step back.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by QasimK on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:40AM (#18597551)
I’m pretty sure watt is right...
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Silhouette on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:43AM (#18597900)
But this isn't wrong, it's just your entirely subjective personal preference being different to someone else's.

Personally, I don't like it when browsers implicitly keep tracking things when I close the application and then fire up some half-baked version of the same stuff when I come back later. If I want to remember where I am, I can easily bookmark some or all of my tabs.

Firefox has had a particular problem in recent versions where it seems to think it crashed on the previous shutdown, even though there was no user-visible evidence of this, and then tries to restore the previous session even when it otherwise wouldn't. That's not helpful if your previous session involved shopping for surprise Christmas presents for the SO who is now standing behind you as you open the browser again several hours later for some entirely unrelated purpose, in a totally hypothetical example.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by LandR on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:45AM (#18597918)
> when it starts up again, it should be able to preserve this half-entered user input!

I wouldn't expect this at all!

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by mathw on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:45AM (#18597577)
I'm sure I remember Chrome not preserving session state as its default setting either. It's been so long since I configured either of them though...
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:13AM (#18597369)
Isn't this google applications will track what you do all the time, and even after you close the application and restart it knows who you are and what you did?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by distant_hat on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:32AM (#18598456)
Except for tabs in incognito mode. I wish there was an 'OK' for Chrome too. Especially since it is so easy to hit Cmd-Q instead of Cmd-W.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by blauditore on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:06AM (#18597328)
Both browsers have this configurable in settings. So they just use different defaults, which depends on personal preference.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sdenton4 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:12AM (#18597362)
But which is the natural default? The one where you lose a lot of state seems like a far worse choice.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by blauditore on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:07AM (#18597712)
It warns you. And there are people who do browsing in a one-off fashion: Open many thing, then close everything and forget.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by donatzsky on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:57AM (#18599904)
Unless they removed it recently, Firefox will also let you restore the last session. You may have to use the default startpage, though.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sametmax on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:29AM (#18598792)
> but Mozilla certainly lost the PR war and to no fault but their own, because Firefox sure sucked for a long while.

The last part is true, it did suck for a while. But I can't say "no fault but their own". Even if they rocked, they would have taken a big hit: chrome was advertised for a long time, and at no cost, using solicitating prompts directly on the most consultated and trusted web page in the world.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by kajecounterhack on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:02AM (#18597004)
The advantage of Firefox / Chrome in general is that if you develop habits / shortcuts you can use them in any OS. Safari only works on macOS and edge on Windows.

Both their plugin ecosystems are significantly less robust as well e.g if you want to use any popular tools e.g shodan, google data saver, edit this cookie, etc

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by arkh on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:08AM (#18597336)
I think it's more like a new generation of people started using Mac OS on which I heard Firefox suck. So being already in a walled garden environment they did not care about entering Google's.

Firefox was always good on other OS. And you got noscript there with full access to block everything Chrome does not want you to block.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by sakisv on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:15AM (#18597759)
FWIW, I use Firefox on High Sierra and I don't think it sucks at all.

About noscript:

Recently I was playing with it, in an attempt to curate which site is allowed to make connections to which domain but I discovered that I cannot do it on a per domain basis and every whitelisted entry was applied everywhere. Apparently that was something that could be configured at noscript's ABE panel which doesn't exist in the latest versions.

If you want per domain rules I would suggest trying umatrix instead.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by GrayShade on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:43AM (#18598522)
uBlock Origin can also do that.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by 11235813213455 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:03AM (#18597009)
What I like in chrome is search shortcuts, example I start typing "thes" then press TAB, then I'm brought directly to https://www.thesaurus.com/browse/hello (possibly with little configuration). I don't think Firefox has similar things, last time I checked we have to use bookmarks or something
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Dunedan on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:16AM (#18597066)
In Firefox you can add a bookmark and set a keyword for that bookmark. If the URL of the bookmark contains "%s", it'll get replaced by everything you type in the URL bar after the keyword. For example I have a bookmark for Wikipedia with the keyword "wp". So when I type "wp Y Combinator" I end up on the Wikipedia page about Y Combinator.

I really enjoy this feature and even catch myself regularly trying to use it on other computers, which obviously don't have such keywords defined.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lorenzhs on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:36AM (#18597159)
Yeah, but the indicator that you’re using such a bookmark when typing “wp Foo” in the address bar is really poor. When you use the OpenSearch search engine integration you can also set a keyword but it’s highlighted properly. Downside is that you need to enable the separate search bar to get the option to add a site’s OpenSearch provider when visiting it because the small looking glass gets a tiny plus you need to click.

I recently switched from chrome to Firefox but the search engine situation is something I’m not really happy about.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by yorwba on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:04AM (#18597314)
> Downside is that you need to enable the separate search bar to get the option to add a site’s OpenSearch provider when visiting it because the small looking glass gets a tiny plus you need to click.

Nope, you can just right-click the site's own search bar, which is how I've been doing it forever.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by QasimK on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:44AM (#18597568)
I think that adds it as a bookmark which is not the same thing as an OpenSearch provider because it doesn’t give you the blue highlight when searching with it.

Actually this is exactly what lorenzhs said, and it is my experience too. I know this because I spent half an hour trying to get a “blue search” for BBFC.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lorenzhs on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:45AM (#18599333)
Yup that’s what I meant. The right click -> add as search engine creates a bookmark which doesn’t get the blue highlight when using it. That distinction just doesn’t make sense to me.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by veddox on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:58AM (#18597284)
DuckDuckGo: `!w Y combinator` ?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by chrishynes on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:50AM (#18599841)
Didn't know about this either. Awesome and helps alleviate a pain point... but a) how the hell would any normal user know to do this? And b) how long until it is yet another undocumented feature dropped by Firefox?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jlelse on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:08AM (#18597335)
Thanks for mentioning this feature, I didn't know about it before. Really like it!
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by depressedpanda on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:52AM (#18597243)
You could just set duckduckgo as your default search provider. Then you can use their bangs[1] to quickly search on specific sites. "!thes test" will find synonyms for you.

It works flawlessly in all browsers I use.

[1]: https://duckduckgo.com/bang

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by __d on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:29AM (#18597825)
I switched to DDG for the privacy, and a general desire to ensure that competitors to Google survive. But I've found I use the "bang" commands all the time.

Typing "w! foo" beats "wikipedia foo" every time.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vvillena on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:31AM (#18598144)
Firefox/Chrome: You can right-click any search field on any web you visit and add it as a search engine, with the keyword of your choosing. I've been using "w foo" to directly search on English Wikipedia. It's half the characters! :)
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Freak_NL on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:15AM (#18599113)
The advantage of Duck's bangs is that you don't have to install or configure anything beyond searching with DuckDuckGo. I've managed to guess the correct bang-abbreviation plenty of times (Urban Dictionary? ud, OpenStreetMap? osm, Hacker News? Guess!).
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Cyphase on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:11AM (#18600683)
I've also had 'w foo' as a keyword for years and years, along with many others for varying lengths of time. So convenient.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by vatueil on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:33AM (#18597142)
As others have mentioned and I believe you were referring to, Firefox does let you create bookmarks with keywords to accomplish the same thing.

Funnily enough, I've often seen Firefox users unaware that they can do the same with custom search keywords in Chrome, so the problem runs both ways.

As someone who uses these features in both Firefox and Chrome, I do think it would be nice if Firefox copied how Chrome automatically adds these search actions, and perhaps a bit of the UI polish too (like how Chrome's omnibox will recognize you're performing a keyword search and adapt accordingly). It doesn't make much of a difference for existing power users, but it could help new users discover and use the feature.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by pseudalopex on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:56AM (#18597265)
Firefox now highlights the search keyword and limits history matches to just that site.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lisper on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:06AM (#18597032)
Seriously? You would sell your soul to the devil to save typing four extra characters?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Kiro on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:27AM (#18597111)
If you think using Chrome is selling your soul to the devil I wonder what you think about me who is fully integrated in the Google ecosystem with Google Home and everything.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by lisper on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:34AM (#18597148)
At least in that case I can see what you might think you're getting out of the deal. But typing "thes" instead of "thesaurus"? Seriously?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by nindalf on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:44AM (#18597570)
In Firefox it requires a space instead of a tab. I search wikipedia and google like "w foo" and "g bar" respectively.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Vinnl on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:37AM (#18597538)
To add to the comments that show you how to configure something similar yourself, Firefox recently started including search shortcuts by default. This means you can now type `@google <query>` in a recent Firefox installation to search Google. More info here: https://blog.mozilla.org/futurereleases/2018/10/17/searching...

It's still not as smooth and doesn't support as many OpenSearch providers as Chrome's, but might already help a bit.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by d4l3k on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:14AM (#18597059)
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:48AM (#18598551)
As someone who switched from Chrome to Firefox not that long ago this is the only feature I miss. Searching e.g. YouTube involves typing the query and then using the mouse to click the YouTube icon in the address bar dropdown. It's not nearly as effortless.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Freak_NL on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:17AM (#18599134)
Set the default search engine to DuckDuckGo, and just type !yt query in the address bar. No mouse necessary.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by kristerv on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:28AM (#18597112)
Yeah this is the worst in firefox. I'm desperately trying to stick to firefox out of principle, but Chrome is just sooo much more comfy beacuse of like 3 features.

Firefox actually has 2 domain specific search-shortcut features, but both take time to set up and then is not intuitive at all. Chrome just blows it out of the water.

Also wtf - if I type "hello" and press enter in the search bar in FF, it puts a "www." in front and ".com" at the end.. like holy hell, if I knew the domain I'll write .com myself, it really is no problem. I even went ahead and googled for 15 minutes and disabled this in some deep settings somewhere, but it still does it when I press enter too fast... damnit, it frustrates me every single day.

I hope they see this and fix this very-frustratingly-obvious anti-UX behaviour..

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by michaelmrose on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:38AM (#18597172)
Typing a word or words that don't look like a url or file has so far as I can recall always searched the default search engine for the word or query. This so far as I can recall has always been the case. Can you replicate this in a fresh profile to ensure this isn't just something you have set?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by snlnspc on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @11:41AM (#18601013)
I run into the same thing somewhat frequently. it's the only real issue that I have with firefox. it's definitely not related to the profile, and it only seems to happen with fast enough input+enter.

it's really jarring to be sent to a random domain when looking up something in a hurry.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Abishek_Muthian on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:50AM (#18596948)
Do you use Safari for private browsing because each private window is sandboxed between each other unlike Chrome?

I find it intriguing that each incognito window in Chrome is not sandboxed between each other. Am I missing anything here?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by AlmaElma on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:25AM (#18597098)
I'd love to use Safari privately but uBlock Origin is a mess right now (lots of UI bugs) and won't work at all soon, so FF it is for me.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by skgoa on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:23AM (#18597441)
Firefox sucking wasn't their own fault? I would say it was. I would also say that their continued bloating of firefox and ancilliary projects/services shows that they still haven't return to their original mission.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by eksemplar on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @06:17AM (#18598361)
Yes, that’s why I said it was to no fault but their own.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by keithnz on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:03PM (#18595729)
I like firefox, and use it a lot at work as generally my main browser with DDG as the , but I end up going back to chrome quite a bit

Things that bug me - For some reason often when I have quite a few tabs, open link in new tab stops working, the tab appears then disappears instantly, oddly if I use Vimium to open the tab in a new link it works. Mostly I use Vimium so this is not too much of a problem

- Copy pasting of formatted html is worse than Chrome.

- Confluence runs like a pig on Firefox for some reason, completely unusable on some pages, not strictly a FF problem, but is problematic.

- Just something about the aesthetics that is somehow "off"

On the positive

- I like the developer tools

- "Column select" out of the box just works

- scrolling tab bar instead of teeny tiny tabs where you can't see anything is good

- I feel better that I'm hopefully leaking less data, not that I can really verify that, but I generally believe I should be better protected than if I was using chrome

Overall, while there is cool things about FF, I feel I'm using it not because its the better browser, but some vauge idea I'm helping browser diversity.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by chalst on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:54AM (#18597626)
Firefox Containers really do allow you to limit the amount that data leaks.

https://medium.com/firefox-test-pilot/firefox-containers-are...

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by executesorder66 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:30AM (#18598799)
I have at least 30 tabs open at a time on some confluence page. None of them ever gave me any issues. So I think that's specific to you.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by TheArcane on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @08:52AM (#18599381)
Don't forget the absolutely terrible translation add-ons on Firefox
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by morpheuskafka on Monday December 03, 2018 @11:42PM (#18596339)
This. And their dark theme is way better than any Chrome extension. The big deal is that Chrom(ium) has taken over the rapidly growing desktop webapp market with ElectronJS, and AFAIK there is no Electron competitor that uses the modern, Quantum FF stack.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by segmondy on Monday December 03, 2018 @11:45PM (#18596355)
Yup, not only that, but we must evangelize and install it every where. I installed it on every phone, tablet & computer in my house hold.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by chmln on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:06PM (#18595334)
Sorry but the devtools can't even inspect my websocket API frames.

The websocket inspector was a feature request filed 6 years ago. [1]

Maybe Firefox devs didn't have time for it. But somehow they got all the time in the world to add clickbait Pocket articles on my new tab page.

[1] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=885508

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by judge2020 on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:56PM (#18595689)
As well as the time to code in product placements https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15956325
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ripdog on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:23AM (#18596538)
Financially, Mozilla is currently entirely dependent on a search contract with Google, their mortal enemy.

They obviously see that this relationship is extremely risky, especially as Firefox becomes less popular and thus their userbase less valuable to Google. As such, they're trying to diversify their revenue stream.

Do you have any better solutions? Browsers are absurdly expensive to develop, by the way.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jhasse on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:21AM (#18597083)
Become more popular by improving the product?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by ripdog on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:13AM (#18597748)
Firefox is improving by leaps and bounds every day.

But the market is not a meritocracy, as much as some people like to pretend it is. Success in the market is much more to do with things like marketing, momentum, inertia, and general opinions. All of these things are favoring Chrome right now, and Mozilla is not in a position to turn this around.

And you may not have noticed, but being popular doesn't actually give you money when your product is free and features no ads or tracking. All you are saying is that "google should give mozilla more money". How do you suggest they diversify their revenue stream?

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jhasse on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:46AM (#18598200)
I disagree. IMHO Chrome is a better browser than Firefox. A few examples from the top of my head why Firefox is worse than Chrome (on Linux):

1. Hardware acceleration is still disabled by default on Linux

2. Pocket

3. Unwanted notifications about wanting to update / being updated / having updated

3. Ugly spacing left and right of the adress bar

4. Takes longer to start

5. No integration with GNOME keychain.

6. Ctrl+Q quits the browser.

7. Laggy UI

> How do you suggest they diversify their revenue stream?

I would suggest that they don't need to diversify their revenue stream. As long as they are a major player, Google (or any other search engine) will continue to fund them.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by dblohm7 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:10PM (#18601989)
3. Ugly spacing left and right of the adress bar

Those spacers are easily removed via customize mode.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jhasse on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:16PM (#18602054)
Sure, you can also fix a lot of other annoyances. But those add up until the point where someone just installs Chrome in the first place where the defaults are sane.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by rb666 on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:08AM (#18597337)
Funded by? you?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jhasse on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:19AM (#18597413)
All the money they shouldn't spend on Pocket for example.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by rb666 on Thursday December 06, 2018 @10:52PM (#18624991)
Pocket is not a cost center, it earns them money to develop the browser in the first place!
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by bitsnbytes on Monday December 03, 2018 @11:11PM (#18596166)
I agree more option other chrome is a positive. Started to use duck duck go browser on mobile and so far so good.

Firefox has always been a resource hog and crash prone for me on just about any system. Although I use it primarily for some of its features and prefer it over chrome.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by justusthane on Monday December 03, 2018 @11:37PM (#18596318)
In my experience that's not the case since Quantum.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by boudin on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:49AM (#18597226)
It's been a really long time I experienced any crash from Firefox. Last time I had instabilities, it was due to my profile. Deleting it solved the issues.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by EpicEng on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:13PM (#18595387)
DevTools are lacking and they broke a ton of add ons with the API update (with no simple way to side load.) I can't use it. I tried again about five months ago and, one two machines, pages would stutter as I scrolled. Not worth my time to mess around with.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by viswaprasath on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @12:59AM (#18596739)
Would love to know your favorite add-ons that are broken and not available in AMO for FF57+ some of the contributors during their free time working on to bring extensions. can you share link or about the addon ( https://github.com/firefox-addons/ideas )
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by jholman on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:23AM (#18596844)
As one of the FF faithful, I almost quit when downthemall stopped working.

https://www.downthemall.net/

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Karunamon on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @07:50AM (#18598913)
DTA is one of the reasons I’m still pissed at Mozilla to this day.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by PetahNZ on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:52AM (#18598228)
This addon used to be the only reason I opened Firefox.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Kliment on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:51AM (#18597604)
Session managers no longer work reliably since the apis for reading and writing tab and window state are not exposed. This is the biggest one for me. Also vertical tabs addons have been fighting an uphill battle.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by plopz on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @09:18AM (#18599564)
Classic Theme Restorer
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by baq on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @04:22AM (#18597794)
i've been on firefox for the last six months or so. very happy overall.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by protomyth on Monday December 03, 2018 @08:59PM (#18595265)
More devs should support and use it, lest we be beholden to Chrome for the rest of time.

Why support what already broke your work once without an actual transition plan? They didn't have a full replacement ready to go when they got rid of XUL, and seemed that they didn't really care.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by michaelmrose on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @02:57AM (#18597271)
They announced web extensions in summer of 2015.

https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2015/08/21/the-future-of-dev...

At the end of August of 2018 they stopped supporting 52 ESR which is the last extended support release that supports the old addons.

During the 3 years between a and b mozilla worked to provide support for flexible interesting addons which is why all the notable interesting addons I'm aware of have new versions.

I'm sure that the will to port every useful addon in existence just isn't there but it seems challenging for firefox to move forward without ditching the old addons.

Did you realize the new addon system was released over 3 years ago? It kind of seems as if perhaps as a user you were only peripherally aware of matters and derived an erroneous interpretation of events.

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by larrik on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:03PM (#18595305)
I'm pretty sure he meant web devs, not plugin devs.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by protomyth on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:09PM (#18595356)
Anyone who ignores prior treatment of folks is foolish.

Why would a web developer support one browser over others? They keep everyone honest by sticking to the middle road and not having a badge like "Works Best In FireFox".

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by Jorge1o1 on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:22PM (#18595456)
And yet there’s scores of websites that barely work on anything except Chrome because it’s obvious that’s what the devs are using.
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by microcolonel on Monday December 03, 2018 @09:17PM (#18595420)
Well, it would help if they would resolve the serious quality issues. I wrote a webpage the other day, fully standards compliant (at least as I read it), and Firefox got it completely wrong (one of the bugs, three days old and not triaged[0]) in a way Ed.

I still have open bugs in Firefox from 2012. Firefox is riddled with layout and scripting bugs. I don't understand how they can afford all of this experimental development and "outreach" stuff, when the core product is basically just accumulating bugs which they will never address. Their tracker is full of untriaged bugs from as far back as a decade.

[0]: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1511514

Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by michaelmrose on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @03:00AM (#18597290)
Do you not work around the way chrome does things in any way shape or form?
Re:Firefox desktop market share now below 9% by microcolonel on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @10:05AM (#18599990)
It is virtually never required. Even Chrome's interpretation of undefined behaviours is convenient (i.e. margin: auto on elements with only a max-height; this doesn't work in EdgeHTML or Gecko)